11 ms·
After 48 hours we haven't seen any sign people are using Waymo's service
- blhack 8y agoJust an anecdote here, but I live in Phoenix, near their service area, and I see these cars all over the place. I'd say I probably see at least one on each journey I take in my own car.
- cachvico 8y agoAre there any US municipalities that already allow fully driverless cars at all?
- wtf42 8y agoIt seems they have some 'safety level' constant they can control during their training process, so about half a year ago when they were preparing for public release they decided to change safety level constant from 0.99 to 0.999 and something went wrong, like it's completely unable to do some unsafe actions (unprotected left turns, merges, and other tricky situations). And because of that they need additional training with safety drivers for this kind of situations.
- orangecat 8y agoso about half a year ago when they were preparing for public release they decided to change safety level constant from 0.99 to 0.999 That's my theory as well. Remember, Uber killed a pedestrian earlier this year. Fortunately that didn't result in self-driving cars being banned or regulated out of existence, but they may not a get a third chance, so it makes sense to be even more cautious after that.
- lolc 8y agoThey're just stuck solving the remaining hard cognitive tasks where even humans struggle. They're just not good enough at predicting other cars' trajectory. And nobody really knows at what point they will be. I'd say we will find the machines to refuse to drive like humans. And we'll have to adapt.
- sophistication 8y agoRelated question: Is the AI bubble smaller or larger than the dot-com bubble? https://i.imgur.com/q7whaio.png https://i.imgur.com/q7whaio.png
- avinium 8y agoAs far as I know, there are no "AI" companies listed on the NASDAQ. Of course, there are listed companies with significant AI investments. But I'd argue their valuations are driven by their existing/conventional/ad-driven scale, not their AI arms. Whether or not they're overvalued remains to be seen. The era of cheap money seems (?) to be coming to an end, so it will be an interesting few years.
- sophistication 8y agoWere "dot-com" companies listed on the NASDAQ back then, or only companies with significant dot-com investments?
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoWow, this makes me feel old. Tons of .com companies (very common to actually have .com in the company name) were listed on the NASDAQ back then.
- avinium 8y agoThe poster children of the dotcom boom certainly were - pets.com, webvan, etoys.com (though I can't say with 100% certainty they were all specifically listed on NASDAQ). It was the IPOs that drove the boom (and subsequent bust). Public investors falling over themselves wanting to get in on the "next big thing". Older generation companies were never going to deliver the kind of quick return multiples that characterized the boom (though as we saw, the enthusiasm certainly jacked up their share prices too, but by and large they managed to ride out the storm).
- bsaul 8y agoWhen i think about the rumours i’ve heard that waymo chief made a 500 millions $ bonus last year... at the time i thought this was because he was the only guy in the world truely capable of transforming the whole industry...
- paganel 8y ago> In late September, a Waymo spokeswoman told Ars by email that the Phoenix service would be fully driverless and open to members of the public—claims I reported in this article. > We now know that Waymo One won't be fully driverless; there will be a driver in the driver's seat. This reminds me of this famous Radio Yerevan joke: > Q: Is it true that Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov from Moscow won a car in a lottery? > A: In principle yes, but: > it wasn't Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov but Aleksander Aleksandrovich Aleksandrov; > he is not from Moscow but from Odessa; > it was not a car but a bicycle; > he didn't win it, but it was stolen from him. Because smart people have invested billions of dollars into this technology and because even smarter people work on this technology the general public must pretend that it's all going according to plan, that everything is damn serious and that the emperor still has his clothes on.
- pmoriarty 8y agoThe chairman of a local chamber of commerce had to introduce the speaker at the organization's annual black-tie dinner... "The man who I am about to introduce," he said, "is someone I know you'll enjoy listening to. He is the most gifted businessman in the country. He has made one hundred million dollars in California oil." The speaker, embarrassed, came to the podium. "Thank you for your kind introduction, Mr. Chairman," he said. "However, the facts need some clarification. It wasn't oil; it was coal. It wasn't California; it was Pennsylvania. It wasn't one hundred million; it was one hundred thousand. It wasn't me; it was my brother. And he didn't make it; he lost it."
- setr 8y agoIts the natural cycle of AI; this is what, its third or fourth iteration? My game leg has been acting up — we’re in for a bitter winter..
- aaaaaaaaaab 8y agoThis is now a Radio Yerevan thread! Q: Is it true that the great poet Vladimir Mayakovsky committed suicide? A: Correct, and his last words were “comrades, don’t shoot!”
- ilaksh 8y agoTo me it sounded like they basically just gave people the option of getting out of the NDA if they wanted to start paying for rides. I assume to most of the early riders, it's just not worth it when they can continue just getting free rides.
- ChrisSD 8y agoIs the problem with driverless cars that humans are, on average, absolutely terrible drivers?
- JasonFruit 8y agoIt's not a problem with humans on the average; that's an easy problem. It's humans in specific that are difficult.
- dsr_ 8y agoPartially. The three problems: 1. The cost of screwing up is very high. 2. There are important events in the real world environment that are not very recognizable or predictable. 3. Humans accept a level of danger from other human drivers that they absolutely will not accept from robocars.
- gpm 8y agoI doubt that it's human drivers that are the issue. Cars are nice big easy to identify predictable things, and even if you screw up and hit one the cost is relatively low. The challenging cases are probably things like children playing on the side of the road, pedestrians, bicyclists, construction workers, cops standing in the street, people working in manholes, and so on. Relatively small, easily obscured, unpredictable, hard for computers to figure out how they are moving, and very high cost to hit.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoWhy not just start with freeways/ring roads?
- jzwinck 8y agoPeople don't want to be picked up and dropped off at freeway exit ramps or Cracker Barrels.
- IshKebab 8y agoNo. The problem is that road systems (even really easy ones like in America) are designed for humans, and humans are requires some human abilities that AI isn't even close to, like anticipating what people are going to do. Also I think the actual hardware is not good enough yet. LIDAR is great but humans can see really far in really good detail and can work out what is happening even in really bad conditions (rain, looking into the sun, etc). Non-motorway driving is just too varied. I still think the first real application of autonomous vehicles will be driverless lorries that drive between depots that are connected by motorways. It's way way easier because the environment is so restricted, there's a clear commercial need, and people would be a lot more comfortable about the safety aspect - who hasn't seen a lorry drift into the hard shoulder? Plus lorries are super expensive so it wouldn't increase the cost too much, and they're huge so there is plenty of space for hardware.
- gniv 8y agoI'm not as pessimistic. I think Google is taking its time since a bad accident would be a PR disaster. Given how big a deal this is, it makes sense for them to take it slowly, and I don't think we can read much into this in regards to the state of their self-driving tech.
- mactrey 8y agoI think I agree with this take. Do we really think Waymo cars would be so cautious with merging if a Waymo crash were received with the same level of fanfare and financial repercussions as an ordinary commuter crash? I.e. a $1,000 financial hit and literally nobody cares. Most of the "mistakes" in the video looked to me more like a hyper-cautious grandmother than an A.I. that fundamentally doesn't know how to drive.
- woah 8y ago> "Lane changes appear to be a problem for the cars," Randazzo says in the video. When trying to move into a crowded lane, a Waymo car seemed to lack a human driver's ability to anticipate other drivers' actions and squeeze into an open spot. Instead, the vehicle would turn on its turn signal and wait for a few seconds for an opening to appear. If one didn't appear, it would turn the turn signal off and wait for a while before trying again. This makes sense, because a lot of times merging into a lane is a game of chicken. You've got to make the drivers in that lane believe that you're going to merge anyway and that they'll need to slow down to avoid hitting you.
- Swizec 8y agoIt's also about accelerating into the lane when half an opening appears so the drivers behind you don't have to slow down as much. A lot of city driving, especially rush hour city driving, is about creating an opening. Not about waiting for one. But yeah if your turn signal is on and you're not moving into my lane within 1 second, I'm assuming you forgot to turn it off.
- jnbiche 8y ago> A lot of city driving, especially rush hour city driving, is about creating an opening. Not about waiting for one. Exactly, which is why non-city drivers struggle to drive in big cities. They're used to just waiting for an opening.
- blattimwind 8y agoAlways curious how traffic is viewed as an antagonistic activity by many. I usually have the opposite impression. Someone wants to switch lanes in dense traffic, so I slow down slightly and let them slip into my lane. Others do the same for me. That's working with each other not against each other for me.
- rootusrootus 8y agoThat sounds so polite. And unlike anything I have ever experienced. Especially in the truly dense traffic, cooperation means giving up just enough space to let the other guy take it, as long as he's assertive. Definitely not a place for the timid, I've found that people who are accustomed to driving in extremely dense traffic tend not to have much patience for lollygagging. It screws up the rhythm.
- popotamonga 8y agoHonestly looks to me like the AI translation problem, always 5 years away from being perfect, still mostly crappy, only good enough to have a rough idea of what is being said and with glaring mistakes.
- nostrademons 8y agoAI translation has gotten massively better in the last 10 years. I can read a foreign news site in Chrome, pop "translate this page", and get a reasonable sense of what the article is about and the factual content it contains. The grammar will be off and some sentences will be non-sequitors, but getting to this point is a massive leap forward compared to 15 years ago.
- mikeash 8y agoI feel like a lot of AI problems move directly from “this is so terrible that it’s completely useless” to “this capability is a fact of life that I no longer think about” without ever passing through a conscious “this doesn’t suck so much anymore” stage. Speech recognition and translation both did this. They’re far from perfect but they’re good enough to get a lot of real-world use, but somehow they still have a reputation for being worthless junk.
- arbie 8y agoBiometric authentication and banking fraud detection are two more areas where there has been a step-function improvement in accuracy with little pomp.
- buboard 8y agofor some people, waymo-like cars are not an optional luxury/curiosity but a necessity (elderly people, disabled). It would be nice if they focused on those groups early, instead of leaving it as an afterthought. The oddities of the cars are not going to be a show-stopper, as long as the cars are safe. Human drivers will learn to adapt their way around the "roomba cars" over time.
- rootusrootus 8y agoHadn't really considered that. Where I live, the transit company runs a van service door-to-door for elderly and people with disabilities that cannot reach a normal bus stop. The cost of the tickets are the same as for the normal city bus. What do disabled folks do now in places that don't have such a service?
- oldgradstudent 8y agoTaxi, Uber, Lyft. The only advantage of a self-driving cars is that it might be somewhat cheaper.
- datguacdoh 8y agoThey did focus on these early though. Literally their first fully autonomous drive on public roads was with a blind individual, explaining how the technology was going to be transformative. Video: https://youtu.be/ArYTxDZzQOM https://youtu.be/ArYTxDZzQOM
- buboard 8y agothat was a promo video, but i have not seen anything specific to disabled people since then
- jonas21 8y agoThey've been working with the guy in the video for over 6 years [1], and he's the former CEO of the Santa Clara Valley Blind Center, which has aims for "a future where awareness, legislation and technology meet at a crossroads to provide individuals who are blind and visually impaired the same opportunities as their sighted peers" [2]. It sounds like they're taking this seriously. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cdgQpa1pUUE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cdgQpa1pUUE [2] http://www.visionbeyondsight.org/About-MissionVision.htm http://www.visionbeyondsight.org/About-MissionVision.htm
- djsumdog 8y agoAutonomous cars are a very difficult problem, more than I think most people anticipate. There's been a lot of tax breaks/money that goes into these programs too, and that's the tragic thing, since that funding should be going to known solutions: public transportation (trains, trams and express buses). Even if you had a full-autonomous only Interstate where each car could be fully loaded and ride bumper-bumper at over 100kph, it wouldn't even begin reach the carrying capacity of currently existing fully autonomous subways systems like those in Singapore. https://penguindreams.org/blog/self-driving-cars-will-not-solve-the-transportation-problem/ https://penguindreams.org/blog/self-driving-cars-will-not-so... These driverless cars would be great in Europe where they can solve the last leg problems in countries that already have strong public transport infrastructure. In places like America, the existing infrastructure has a long way to go before autonomous cars won't lead to the same gridlock as normal cars .. and an even longer way to go before they're ready for mass consumption.
- triviatise 8y agoself driving (they dont even need to be self driving just ride share algorithm powered) shuttles are the future of public transport The systems could be ride share type shuttles that can pick you up at your location and drop you off at your destination. You make the request in the app and the shuttle picks people up in a location. They can even drop you off for a transfer with other modes, other shuttles etc. The shuttle that picks you up doesnt have to be the shuttle that drops you off. Shuttles like these will greatly reduce traffic and can also handle spikes in demand unlike current mass transit.
- rootusrootus 8y agoEverywhere and everyone is different, obviously, but I would love to see autonomous electric vehicles become our future. I really don't care for public transportation, I find it uncomfortable in many ways, and I don't see any way that it will ever not be about half the speed of a private point-to-point transport. So a highway filled with self driving cars zipping along bumper to bumper may not technically be able to carry as much as a fully loaded subway train, but it's so much more useful. Take away the casualties and pollution, and it's as close to perfect as we are likely to get.
- ars 8y agoI've said it before, and I'll say it again: There will never be fully driverless cars until we have true AI. The only thing we might have are dedicated lanes on interstates for driverless cars, like railroad tracks. In city driving will never happen without AI. This is a strong claim, but I'm sticking to it.
- Lxr 8y agoWhat is “true AI” in your opinion?
- jon_richards 8y agoAny sufficiently misunderstood computer program is indistinguishable from AI.
- arbie 8y agoThen I've been writing true AI all my life!
- gameswithgo 8y agothat which powers the first fully driverless cars, apparently.
- ars 8y ago> What is “true AI” in your opinion? Able to teach itself anything from unstructured (unprepared) data.
- wongarsu 8y agoWhich would already make it superhuman. We are good at learning, but not that good.
- jimmy1 8y agoI have a variation of your claim since I think "true AI" is unfeasible: we will never have fully driverless cars until we build the infrastructure to support them, and in that case, we would have been 100 times better off building trains anyways.
- KaoruAoiShiho 8y agoThe problems that are reported in the article seems simpler than I imagined. Is google really only gathering data via real world tests? If so then something like NVIDIA simulator will completely crush waymo. https://blogs.nvidia.com/blog/2018/09/12/drive-constellation-open-simulation/ https://blogs.nvidia.com/blog/2018/09/12/drive-constellation...
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoYou'd think that simulation is useful for training machine learning algorithms, but in practice, the differences between our best simulations and the real world are such that training on simulations is next to useless. Google AI blog explains why: Simulating many years of robotic interaction is quite feasible with modern parallel computing, physics simulation, and rendering technology. Moreover, the resulting data comes with automatically-generated annotations, which is particularly important for tasks where success is hard to infer automatically. The challenge with simulated training is that even the best available simulators do not perfectly capture reality. Models trained purely on synthetic data fail to generalize to the real world, as there is a discrepancy between simulated and real environments, in terms of both visual and physical properties. In fact, the more we increase the fidelity of our simulations, the more effort we have to expend in order to build them, both in terms of implementing complex physical phenomena and in terms of creating the content (e.g., objects, backgrounds) to populate these simulations. This difficulty is compounded by the fact that powerful optimization methods based on deep learning are exceptionally proficient at exploiting simulator flaws: the more powerful the machine learning algorithm, the more likely it is to discover how to "cheat" the simulator to succeed in ways that are infeasible in the real world. The question then becomes: how can a robot utilize simulation to enable it to perform useful tasks in the real world? The difficulty of transferring simulated experience into the real world is often called the "reality gap." The reality gap is a subtle but important discrepancy between reality and simulation that prevents simulated robotic experience from directly enabling effective real-world performance. Visual perception often constitutes the widest part of the reality gap: while simulated images continue to improve in fidelity, the peculiar and pathological regularities of synthetic pictures, and the wide, unpredictable diversity of real-world images, makes bridging the reality gap particularly difficult when the robot must use vision to perceive the world, as is the case for example in many manipulation tasks. https://ai.googleblog.com/2017/10/closing-simulation-to-reality-gap-for.html https://ai.googleblog.com/2017/10/closing-simulation-to-real...
- sonnyblarney 8y agoNobody cares that much about the tech, they care about getting from a to b at a reasonable price, at a reasonable speed, in safety.
- why_only_15 8y agoWell without the tech they won't be able to get from a to b at a reasonable price, at a reasonable speed, in safety.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoYes, it's called 'drive yourself' or 'take a cab' or 'ride a bus' or 'ride a bike'.
- crazy_monkey 8y agoOn the bright side, their drivers haven't murdered anyone yet! >.> looking at you Uber and Didi...
- jfoster 8y agoOf course they're not going to unload hundreds of people onto it all at once. Would you? Of course safety drivers are going to be there for a while. Was the perception really that they would test a bunch and then just pull all of the drivers immediately after? Why would they take such a risk when they can afford to have the drivers monitoring for a while?
- arbie 8y agoExactly right. It's almost like the tech press wants Waymo to aggressively pursue a very public failure. Even one disengagement every 5000 miles without human backup will be perceived as apocalyptic when your fleet drives thousands of trips a day.
- oldgradstudent 8y agoThey've "launched" a "commercial" service, and claimed that their some of their early riders moved to the new service with no NDA. Where are those social media posts? Waymo's PR is getting more and more divorced from reality with every announcement.
- jfoster 8y agoTheir announcements do seem to be a certain amount of time ahead of reality. They announced the early rider programme having started at least a few weeks/months before the evidence of it started showing up, and it looks the same this time. My take on that is that it's okay. They're being cautious.
- Dylan16807 8y ago> Was the perception really that they would test a bunch and then just pull all of the drivers immediately after? If it's after an extended test period, it's not "immediately". But yes, the perception was that they would test a bunch and eventually pull the drivers out of the typical car. And that they would need to do this before it could be considered a proper launch.
- antibland 8y agoHey, I'm sorry about the penis thing. Just so you know, I first checked for signs showing a bare penis with a diagonal slash through it.
- cjmcqueen 8y agoI would think the general climate of fear in the country would make it frightening to launch an ambitious product like this. There's really no hope of a second right now when things go wrong. Disclosure, I work for Google, but have no connection to Waymo. I hope the team can keep pushing on; Waymo is one of the most important "moonshots" to the country. It really could save lives. But, one mistake and people won't trust it even though hundreds of automobile accidents happen every day.
- buboard 8y agoare other countries interested?
- zaroth 8y agoI’ll be happy when my TM3 can even recognize stoplights and stop signs on autopilot, and the adaptive cruise will stop at an intersection and continue on when it turns green. Next they can work on left and right turns. But in all seriousness, IMO the biggest challenge to AI driving is not object recognition or modeling instantaneous state, but the full hierarchy of “statefullness” which humans keep effortlessly, but which seems to be almost totally missing from the driving AI. Understanding the current state, the upcoming state, and the expected transitions in between... are crucial to how I am able to turn left with oncoming traffic, smoothly cruise through a 4-way intersection which happens to be on a curve, zipper merge with entering cars coming off an on ramp into my highway lane during rush hour, change lanes to avoid a bad driver, and not slam on the brakes when a stopped car is in the process of turning left up ahead. When driving on a two lane undivided road, and a left turn lane appears ahead, suddenly an AI finds itself driving in between two lanes and makes a random choice to veer left or right to try to stay in lane. Without the stateful understanding of how and why this new lane came into existence the AI is clueless. The AI can’t solve the problem just by identifying lanes at t=0, or trying to read signs or markings on the road. Us humans know intuitively (or from memory) which lane is for onward travel and which lane is for turning. Any AI driving system built in the next 5-10 years will need an annotated map which tells it which lane to choose. This all adds up, in my estimation, to a metric fuck-ton if metadata required per mile in order for an AI to operate. It cannot be done “statelessly” (like a human can do it) without an AI at least 5 orders of magnitude “smarter” than what we have today.
- ausbah 8y agoIt feels like many of these problems could be overcome if every car on the road was also autonomous, and every such car communicated with each other in a network of sources to coordinate traffic, signal important information, etc.
- gambiting 8y ago"In another incident, a Waymo car was part of a line of cars approaching an intersection where a car crash was blocking the right lane. The human drivers saw the issue far ahead and began shifting to the left lane. The Waymo car continued straight and only began trying to merge left when it was a few car lengths away from the traffic cones" So the car actually behaved correctly then? It's called a zipper merge.