15 ms·
I use privacy.com and Lastpass to help with this problem. Any time there is a service I have to have a business relationship with that I don't trust to keep my
by jedberg 8y ago
I use privacy.com and Lastpass to help with this problem. Any time there is a service I have to have a business relationship with that I don't trust to keep my info secure, I use a unique password and a unique credit card number with a tight limit. What's nice is that they tie the card to a single vendor too.
For example, the water company. I know the water bill is usually $50 or less, so I set the limit to $60/mo. As it turns out, they did get breached. I got an alert about someone who isn't the water company trying to hit the card for 80 cents. Most card runners use amounts under $1 because most credit card spending alerts have a $1 minimum. But privacy.com warned me, so I warned the water company, who was very thankful. Turns out their 3rd party provider had been breached and they were grateful for the alert too. Ended up saving a few thousand of my neighbors a lot of headache.
- shittyadmin 8y agoI wish privacy.com or something similar was available in my country, Entropay seems to be the only thing but it's not allowing new signups.
- mehrdadn 8y agoYou could just use a normal Citi or BoA or any other card that generates virtual card numbers and that'll also lock it to that vendor after the first charge. So that they couldn't even hit it for $0.80 if they wanted to.
- jedberg 8y agoThe 80 cents didn’t go through. I got a warning instead. And my regular cards don’t offer the level of control privacy.com Does.
- kccqzy 8y agoLast time I checked, both Citi and BofA give me virtual card numbers via a Flash plugin. I really have no desire to run Flash any more. Has that changed?
- koolba 8y agoNope it hasn’t changed. It’s the same FIA Card Services Flash app from 2005.
- 10bass 8y agoIt hasn't changed for either one, sadly. [1] [2] [1]: https://www.bankofamerica.com/privacy/accounts-cards/shopsafe.go https://www.bankofamerica.com/privacy/accounts-cards/shopsaf... [2]: http://www.citibank.com/transactionservices/home/card_solutions/commercial_cards/global_corp_sol/products/vca_demo/virtual_card.htm http://www.citibank.com/transactionservices/home/card_soluti...
- gowld 8y agovirtual card #s is a great system, why did it rot? I assume it's because the whole industry prefers data-brokering your purchase history, joined on credit-card # to establish identity.
- Karunamon 8y agoThat's one good reason, another is probably pushback from merchants. Having these virtual cards completely shuts down the "free-trial-we-hope-you'll-forget-and-let-us-ding-you-for-a-month-or-two" business model that's so popular for online services.
- kiriakasis 8y agoAlso usability, most people just don't care enough. (which is reasonable often)
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoNot sure you need merchant pushback there - if it leads to unexpected charges then it's more likely to lead to inability to pay, or short payment, which gives the credit card companies their chance to feed off the client.
- mook 8y ago
- jiveturkey 8y agothe real feature of privacy.com is the ability to use any address. who cares if your CC is compromised? get one just for recurring balances and another for everything else.
- ryacko 8y agoOutside of the top ten SFW subscription services, they are all prone to being hacked.
- jiveturkey 8y agoI don't follow your argument. Yes, any merchant is going to get hacked. My argument is, I don't care a whit about my CC being stolen. My liability is zero and I can just get a new card. The only thing I care about is the hassle of setting up a new card for recurring balances. Hence, why I need at least 2 cards. OTOH I do care about my name, address, and other PII being stolen. That is where privacy.com is a help. But not because it protects me from CC loss.
- jjoonathan 8y agoLastpass has been going downhill with every acquisition and had gotten to the point where autofill failed on the majority of sites and the "copy password" menu item disappeared, bringing clicks-to-login from 1 to ~10. A few weeks ago I saw bitwarden finish their third party security audit and took the opportunity to jump. Couldn't be happier. Autofill fails less, the "copy password" menu works, the mobile experience isn't intentionally broken to sell an app, and export->import went without a hitch. Better, actually: it is the first time I have done an export/import and had the resulting data immediately work better in the second app. There's also the hope-springs-eternal factor of bitwarden giving me the option to host the sensitive stuff myself once I get off my butt and set up that server I've been meaning to for a while now. If you're thinking about lastpass, save yourself the trouble and try bitwarden first. Or something else, but bitwarden has been good to me and lastpass, well, hasn't, to put it politely :)
- driverdan 8y agoI second this. I was a long term LP user that switched to Bitwarden this year and haven't looked back.
- Marsymars 8y agoI've been looking into password managers for my team/department, and bitwarden has some good looking stuff, but they seem to only invoice in USD, which creates constant friction for recurring IT bills at my company.
- arvinsim 8y agoHmmm, I have been using the Keepass + Dropbox combo. Wanted to change to a more streamlined experience. The current choices of 1Password, LastPass and Dashlane didn't seem to attract me. I will give Bitwarden a try.
- Lievelingsduif 8y agoI personally use keeanywhere to streamline my experience. It allows me to just log in and select my db
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tokyodude 8y agoLastPass is not helping you with privacy here. From their tos tos: > You may use our Services only as permitted in these Terms, and you consent to our Privacy Policy at https://www.logmeininc.com/legal/privacy https://www.logmeininc.com/legal/privacy, which is incorporated by reference. pp: > When you use our Services, we receive information generated through the use of the Service, either entered by you or others who use the Services with you (for example, schedules, attendee info, etc.), or from the Service infrastructure itself, (for example, duration of session, use of webcams, connection information, etc.) We may also collect usage and log data about how the services are accessed and used, including information about the device you are using the Services on, IP addresses, location information, language settings, what operating system you are using, unique device identifiers and other diagnostic data to help us support the Services. > Third Party Data: We may receive information about you from other sources, including publicly available databases or third parties from whom we have purchased data, and combine this data with information we already have about you. We may also receive information from other affiliated companies that are a part of our corporate group. This helps us to update, expand and analyze our records, identify new prospects for marketing, and provide products and services that may be of interest to you. > Location Information: We collect your location-based information for the purpose of providing and supporting the service and for fraud prevention and security monitoring. If you wish to opt-out of the collection and use of your collection information, you may do so by turning it off on your device settings. > Device Information: When you use our Services, we automatically collect information on the type of device you use, operating system version, and the device identifier (or "UDID"). and > Some specific examples of how we use the information: > * Conduct research and analysis > * Display content based upon your interests > * Market services of our third-party business partners and > 4. Information Sharing > ... We may share your personal information with (a) third party service providers; (b) business partners; (c) affiliated companies within our corporate structure and (d) as needed for legal purposes. and > Examples of how we may share information with service providers include: > * Sending marketing communications etc...
- Karunamon 8y agoYow, that is precisely the last thing you want from a company whose job it is to store passwords. Thanks for the heads up.
- gowld 8y agoWas the water company thankful enough to compensate you for the $X,000 consulting services you provided because they didn't set up their own security monitoring?
- jedberg 8y agoGiven their lack of security, I’m guessing they have no idea of the value that I provided. It’s all good though. Knowing I helped thousands of my neighbors is compensation enough. Besides, if they gave me a credit, they’d have to hike everyone’s bill to compensate!
- barking 8y agoOr give a smaller bonus to their head of security. I know I'm a cynic, but it takes all sorts of people.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoI guess the money diesn't matter to you personally at all, but they could pay a bonus from profits, or by cutting executives wages (if they're a non-profit). It's not like the only means of paying is gouging customers.
- draw_down 8y agoRight, it’s a nice story and all, but... why is the customer the one informing these companies of the problem? That’s backwards.
- nawtacawp 8y agoI’m happy with privacy.com I’m using two personal domains fo host my own email. One domain is purely for registration/junk purposes and it forwards *@junkemail.com —> junk@myemail.com. The same server uses nextcloud for calendar/contacts/webdav I use the password manager Enpass which can sync via webdav across my devices. Everything selfhosted and emails/credit cards disposable
- O1111OOO 8y agoI looked over privacy.com - specifically their security page[0] which reads impressively. As I looked at my "dashboard" I couldn't help but notice (according to uBlock Origin) that privacy.com, ironically, connects to facebook (.net) and google (fonts, apis, gstatic). I'm certain none of those 3rd-party connections are necessary and yet... like muscle-memory... devs continue to thoughtlessly invite tracking. [0] https://privacy.com/security https://privacy.com/security
- jacquesm 8y agoI've seen people include such tags on the logged in areas for cancer patients in medical websites without batting an eye and wondering why that's a bad thing.
- tadasv 8y agoHaven't looked very closely, but how do you think they make money by offering virtual credit cards for free? I bet they will track all your purchases and resell them for marketing later. Fonts and other stuff from google and facebook is just a small piece of the puzzle.
- beatgammit 8y agoThey detail it on their website, but basically they keep part of the interchange fees for each transaction.
- gibolt 8y agoSame. All my passwords are 100+ characters via LastPass. Except the ones the have to be only 12 :(
- greentrust 8y agoNice. Hows that occasional instance where you need to type your 100 character password into Netflix on a Smart TV?
- mcbits 8y agoGiven the shady things people have found their smart TVs doing, I'd feel about as safe typing a password into a smart TV as I would changing the password to "hunter2". The TV should display (or maybe email) a link that I would visit with my primary web browser and grant it permissions - or ask for a password as a very last resort for users who have no computer/phone but somehow have Netflix.
- swish_bob 8y agoThe bbc iPlayer does essentially this now. It creates a short one time code and you type it into a logged in account to activate the smart device. Of course, when you only have one logged in device and it's tied to a different room, it's mildly irritating, but you only do it once.
- fuzzybeard 8y agoPlex and Roku do this. They give you a simple one time URL like plex.tv\U23SL That URL asks you to log in (on your computer) and once it's authorized, the Roku or Plex on your TV gets the signal and continues. Easier than typing on a TV device.
- gibolt 8y agoHaven't had to do that yet. My uh-oh case is VR. I just typed 5 chars at a time in the headset and then looked at my phone. The occasional cost is worth it though, only adding ~30 seconds
- 8y ago
- pmontra 8y agoI use keepassx, a local password manager. I don't trust centralized online password managers with browser extensions. Huge attack surface. I copy and paste usernames and passwords.
- mk89 8y agoSame here! Except I use Keychain (without icloud) from OSX, as it's built in. I can't trust a website to keep all my passwords.
- Angostura 8y agoI basically decided to trust Apple’s privacy and security teams so iCloud Keychain is the one service that I use it syncing.
- stef25 8y agoSame. Where do you keep the db file? Mine's in the cloud and I can't help but think it reduces security, but then I need access to this data from various locations.
- pmontra 8y agoOn my laptop. I synch to my phone and tablet using Syncthing. I write into the file only on the laptop.
- walton_simons 8y agoI worry about this too. I store the database itself in Dropbox, and I also use a keyfile alongside the password to open it. I can easily recreate the keyfile on any computer, but it never goes anywhere near the internet. In addition to that, for my really critical "gatekeeper" accounts, I don't put the full password in the database. Just a reminder that this is a "special" password, which needs to be combined with another bit of info in order to work. I just live with the fact that I can't use this system on my phone, and for my usage patterns, that's fine. There's nothing I need to do that's so urgent that it can't wait until I'm back in front of my computer.
- Moru 8y agoWhat bank/card allows you to create unique credit cards with separate limits? The one I was using (Swedbank/visa/mastercard) stopped providing this service last year.
- Naracion 8y agoPrivacy.com allows you to create virtual credit cards once you connect a source of payment to your account. Can be bank or debit card. I personally create one credit card for every paid subscription I have with the limit set on the amount that's supposed to be debited (eg. Monthly limit on Tidal charging $20). Privacy is a game changer for online transaction security imo. An additional benefit is the ability to subscribe to "try free for a month but oh wait we need your credit card info first so when you forget to cancel we'll keep charging you". Simply create a virtual card with single time spend limit $1 less than the monthly subscription charge, and you can rest assured that your one month trial is a one month trial.
- tjoff 8y agoPrivacy.com is US only though.
- farrisbris 8y agoany decent international(EU) alternative?
- akvadrako 8y agoIs it only for US persons or does it just require a US bank account? Because then you can get one from transferwise.
- tjoff 8y agoThanks, unfortunately not enough. In order to use Payment Services, you must be at least 18 years old. You confirm that you are either a legal resident of the United States, a United States citizen or a business entity authorized to conduct business by the state(s) in which you operate and that you are an authorized signatory for the business you represent. https://privacy.com/terms https://privacy.com/terms
- dawnerd 8y agoI can’t trust privacy.com. I refuse to give some company direct access to pull money from my bank. Only a matter of time until they’re breached too.
- sytelus 8y agoWhat makes you trust LastPass that they won't sell/leak/expose your passwords from some backdoor or under the table deal? I'm asking because this is not a public company or an entity that can be held responsible in any way for such an act. It's just another startup obligated to make their investors 10X returns. I haven't read their agreements but I'm pretty sure any lawyers of such companies have enough clause to absolve them of any such acts.
- puszczyk 8y agoThey don’t have your passwords
- lmilcin 8y agoThey don't, officially. Nothing is stopping them from updating the client to siphon your passwords or the encryptuon key, though. This is a problem all password managers have. It would be nice to have some kind of communication protocol that could be provably restricted from passing whatever the company wants.
- sytelus 8y agoThey do store your "vault" on their server. It's encrypted though using key that doesn't leave your computer. However I can easily imagine deliberate as well as innocent "mistakes" in browser plugins and other weak links in architecture that would expose the master key and hence your vault.
- woolvalley 8y agoThat can pretty much happen to any software provider you download software from. You don't have the time to: - audit the source code - check every auto-update hash matches the main hash list "just in case" you get a special update just for you If you turn off auto-update, you will eventually get hacked because of bitrot
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Dolores12 8y agowhat will happen in case of privacy.com breach?
- crypt1d 8y agoIts unfortunate that privacy.com is only for US residents. Does anyone know of a similar service that's available for Europeans as well? Specifically the virtual card feature. Most of the services that I've seen to offer something like this are for EEA residents only. This seems to be a new restriction imposed by Visa/MasterCard.
- Ygor 8y agoNot sure about EEA only, but Revolut might work for you and it has virtual cards. Would be nice to have privacy.com more widely available.
- Mefis 8y agoAny one can suggest a good alternative to privacy.com for EU residents?
- Waterluvian 8y agoYou also hit on a very easy solution to for those who aren't going to go to those extremes: be sure your notifications are set up. Getting an email within minutes of every purchase or paid bill has been great.
- quadyeast 8y agoDoes the bank not hold the liability if a credit card is used fraudulently? (I'm sure the process is a pain.)
- SomeCallMeTim 8y agoI have a hard time trusting _any_ of the password services that host my passwords. Single point of failure. Even if they claim they're "encrypted so that even THEY can see them", it's so easy to mess up encryption, it makes it a single point of failure. I still share passwords between my devices though, but instead I use KeePass along with the Android app. For less critical passwords I let Chrome keep them; I _mostly_ trust Google, and non-critical passwords are exactly my level of trust of Google. And I also trust Google to share my (encrypted) KeePass file with my devices. But now it's two points of failure: Someone would have to break into a private Google Drive, get my KeePass file, and break the KeePass encryption. And I trust _both_ KeePass _and_ Google more than I trust Lasspass to get security right.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoCan you use this for one time purchases?
- jedberg 8y agoYep! You can create "burner" cards that become invalid after one use. I actually never use that feature, because sometimes vendors screw up and have to put the charge through a second time or whatever. Instead I set a lifetime spending limit $1 higher than the purchase I'm making.
- jiveturkey 8y agoInteresting. I literally don't care if my CC information is stolen from a merchant -- I have zero liability for fraudulent use on all of my cards. Why do I want the friction of privacy.com? The one thing that is cool, for items that don't have to ship in the mail, is the ability to use any name and address whatsoever with the merchant.