17 ms·
The EU Copyright Directive: What Redditors in Europe Need to Know
- esotericn 8y agoCould someone clarify the impact of this legislation on decentralized platforms? It seems to me that all of the problems here stem from the fact that there's a centralized entity that is profiting from the re-use of links. If you have a peer-to-peer protocol with no-one to "go after" so to speak, what happens then? On the face of it this legislation looks bad, but could it be seen as a good thing if it sows the seeds for decentralized platforms to outcompete centralized ones (because they have a competitive advantage due to lower cost)? The users themselves don't seem to be committing any crime by posting the links - it seems like the website, owned by a company or individual, ends up being chased after. So what if they don't exist?
- barney54 8y agoAre you saying “so what if Reddit does not exist?” Is that your argument?
- jstanley 8y agoI don't think it's "a good thing" that they're making it harder to run online services. I agree that the likely outcome is that decentralised systems get better, and I agree that that outcome would be a good thing. I still don't think the end justifies the means, and would rather see politicians just leave the internet alone: https://www.eff.org/cyberspace-independence https://www.eff.org/cyberspace-independence
- esotericn 8y agoI agree. Perhaps I'm just jaded; it seems obvious to me that the political view on copyright is radically out of touch with constituents, and copyright law is morphing from something that's a bit weird, to probably OTT, to evil, and eventually into complete absurdity as a result. The entire system benefits a tiny number of elite players whilst the man on the street ignores copyright completely - unless their choice is restricted (e.g. DRM) they won't even think about violating it, it's "not a thing" to them. If I thought that the legal system accurately represented the desires of the population, centralized entities wouldn't be anywhere near as much of a problem. It blatantly obviously doesn't, though.
- criddell 8y agoWe don't really know what the outcome will be yet. I think it's worth trying to see what happens and if it's bad, lets update the legislation and try again. I don't know a whole lot about it, but from what I have read so far it doesn't seem that bad. It doesn't help that it's Reddit complaining. It's hard to feel any sympathy for them.
- kodablah 8y ago> would rather see politicians just leave the internet alone Unfortunately this can't happen because too many can't take the bad with the good. As a global platform, those who prefer their governments take control will affect everyone, often killing liberty with thunderous applause. GDPR wasn't enough, people gave givernments a mandate, implicitly promoted anti-web news blitzes, and generally helped build an enemy out of the internet as a projection of disagreements with elections and society in general.
- k__ 8y agoOn Wikipedia I read: "The proposal makes explicit that this does not include private cloud storage services, non-profit encyclopedias (such as Wikipedia), non-profit educational or scientific repositories, nor a variety of other cases." The directive says: "The definition of an online content sharing service provider under this Directive targets only online services which play an important role on the online content market by competing with other online content services, such as online audio and video streaming services, for the same audiences. The services covered by this intervention are those the main or one of the main purposes of which is to provide access to a large amount of copyright -protected content uploaded by their users with the purpose of obtaining profit therefrom, either directly or indirectly, by organising it and promoting it in order to attract more audiences. Organising and promoting content involves for example indexing the content, presenting it in a certain manner and categorising it, as well as using targeted promotion on it. The definition does not include services whose main purpose is not to provide access to copyright protected content with the purpose of obtaining profit from this activity. These include, for instance, electronic communication services within the meaning of Regulation 2015/2120/EU, including internet access providers, as well as providers of cloud services which allow users, to upload content for their own use, such as cyberlockers, or online marketplaces whose main activity is online retail and not giving access to copyright protected content. Nor does this definition cover websites which store and provide access to content for non-for-profit purposes, such as online encyclopaedias, scientific or educational repositories or open source software developing platforms which do not store and give access to content for profit making purposes. In order to ensure the high level of copyright protection and to avoid the possible application of the liability exemption mechanism provided for in this Directive, this Directive should not apply to services the main purpose of which is to engage in or to facilitate copyright piracy."
- kauffj 8y agoI'm the CEO of a company (LBRY) that deals directly with these issues. I'm approaching six figures in legal bills and have spent hundreds of hours on this issue. Here's the truth: no one knows. Not a single person. No one knows how even existing laws like the DMCA and CDA in the US apply to decentralized platforms. E.g. The DMCA and CDA both Utilize the term "service provider" - who is a service provider in a decentralized network? Under existing law, a service provider is supposed to at least be running a server. This doesn't cover the European issues, but here's a ten page memo on this topic prepared pro bono by Cardozo Law on how the CDA/DMCA apply to my company: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B2oudj04lCTJOFZ5V1g5dG9tR2NrWGlYWU1ldVFpZ3EyZlNj/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B2oudj04lCTJOFZ5V1g5dG9tR2N... It is substantially similar to memos I've spent far more money on.
- redsymbol 8y agoThanks so much for publicly sharing this.
- tcd 8y agoI think they ought to tread very carefully and very lightly. Imagine if there was an internet where you can't just remove something. Sure, you can see the IP address of the people hosting/distributing the material, but there are numerous ways to disguise that. Suddenly, via P2P everyone becomes their own client _and_ server, and the _only_ way to remove content is to ensure everyone in the pool no longer has it. Good luck with that.
- danShumway 8y ago> Imagine if there was an internet where you can't just remove something. Isn't that exactly the point of distributed services? There's no difference between the horror scenario you're describing and the ideal that other people are striving for. If you removed your opening and closing sentence, I'd have no way to tell whether this was an advertisement or a criticism. Distributed services really are an area where one person's meat is another person's poison.
- esotericn 8y agoWhat of it? That's already how the world works (it's not limited to the Internet). Public information is public. Someone has already saved it.
- buboard 8y agoDecentralized will then be the target of the next regulation. They are too small to matter atm.
- dahfizz 8y agoWhat is the end game for Reddit if this does pass? Will it just block European users?
- deno 8y agoUpload filters ala Google’s ContentId. The impact will be similar to Youtube in the short term. Since Reddit is GIFs not audio it will be topical things like FIFA replays etc. The ultimate goal is to lay ground work for filtering/shadow banning political content. But that will happen slowly, not overnight.
- nerdponx 8y agoWhich of course is where the truth comes out. This helps big tech players at the little guys' expense. Big companies can build their own content filters. Small companies can't, and are forced to buy content filtering software or services from the big companies.
- ffwd 8y agoAs far as I can tell it doesn't even help the big players, Google has said it is economically impossible to be compliant with article 11 https://news.slashdot.org/story/18/11/12/2045240/youtube-ceo-says-eus-proposed-copyright-regulation-financially-impossible https://news.slashdot.org/story/18/11/12/2045240/youtube-ceo... There's a big difference between a DMCA system where the content host has the responsibility to take down copyrighted content in a reasonable time frame, while having safe harbor protection in cases where content gets through, versus a "non-safe harbor" law where you literally cannot allow any copyrighted content _on upload_, or you can be held liable. It would be impossible to decide who owns what, even for Google, and so they would need to have some other system that is not user generated content (who knows what). User-generated content is the life blood of the web, it's why everyone can communicate and we have this new world, we simply need it I think. I really disagree with others who try to frame this as if Google and Reddit are simply another company trying to defend their turf. This is a real blunder for the EU and completely misinformed IMO
- 8y ago
- IanCal 8y ago> like sharing links to news articles Aren't there repeated statements in the text that links are not covered? > the use of existing content for creative new purposes (r/photoshopbattles, anyone?) would suddenly become questionable under the law What's actually changed about the law here? AFAIK the rights for fair use aren't changed, and using copyrighted content otherwise is already legally questionable.
- vorticalbox 8y agoThe problem is the liability will now fall on the host rather than the uploader.
- Semaphor 8y agoAnd even with less extreme rules we already had YT ContentID which errs on the side of the possible rights holder even if they aren't actually holding the rights.
- IanCal 8y agoA13 seems to require that users can dispute things (and that rightsholders have to justify the takedown), requirements of proportionality and I think also requires an independent body setup by member states to raise these issues up to if not properly solved.
- Semaphor 8y agoYeah, but it still leads to overbroad takedown through filters first, maybe corrections after. Because everything else is simply too much risk for the platform.
- yifanl 8y agoAnd it should as long as the host profits from the uploader's work.
- 8y ago
- xhruso00 8y agoreddit makes money when a user shares a link. EU just disrupts their business model and they are defending.
- mimsee 8y agoLink target also (almost always) make money when visiting the site. They want the publicity from all sources. Nobody small lives on direct traffic.
- buboard 8y agoCool i guess, Reddit will lose money, doesn't affect me or anything. What is the point of this disruption though? Nobody gains from it, it's like "if i can't have it, nobody can have it".
- eksemplar 8y agoIt's perfectly fine to share links, the EU directive specifically states so. What you can't do, is take content, and host it as your own without getting authorization to do so by the content creator. You can probably imagine why that would be a problem from Reddit. I don't personally care if companies like reddit get to face the harshest possible fines from the EU, they are morally bankrupt after all. I mean, almost every image posed on reddit is a form of piracy, and very rarely does the original content creators actually benefit from having their works shared or altered on reddit, and that's not even touching their shady political and commercial manipulation. On the other hand, I really doubt that EU legislation will ever be successful in stopping people from sharing dank memes. Also, I'm guessing this only applies to the desktop version of reddit, because would be impossible to see anything on the mobile version anyway since everything is blocked by all those "USE OUR APP" banners.
- nerdponx 8y agoSo linking to an image in-place is fine, but reuploading to Imgur is not?
- agumonkey 8y agoImage hosters, before comments and likes, were useful mirror too
- eksemplar 8y agoIf I'm a photographer and you see my images and like them, then you can't download them and then upload them as your own on reddit, and reddit certainly can't make money from the clicks generated by my photos that you uploaded to their site. Unless you have my permission. Thats the clear case, it gets difficult with stuff like Star Wars memes. Disney probably doesn't mind someone using Darth Vader to tell a joke, they probably don't care if you stole the image and uploaded it as your own either, and they probably don't care if your joke is distributed on reddit either or whether they make money from it. Because at the end of the day, thet's sort of a free commercial. Under the law though, you have to ask permission. It's annoying to be honest. I give a lot of presentations, and not having every image on the internet available to me, is just annoying. But I work for a municipality, and it can potentially be held accountable if I use proprietary images without having permission to do so. It's been like that for a long while by the way, but internet companies like Reddit have somehow gotten away with doing what the rest of us cannot. In fact they've build a big part of their business model around it, and now the EU is telling them they aren't above the law, so of course they're unhappy.
- znhy 8y agoVery slightly related, but I'm concerned. Reddit has recently implemented the NetzDG law and has yet to say if posts that are censored under that law will disappear only for German users or worldwide.
- mabbo 8y agoIf Reddit and other similar sites want to make a point, a banner won't be enough. They need to do the unthinkable: Block all access from the EU. If the legislation as written is going to make it impossible to do business in the region, then that's what these companies are facing eventually anyways. This sucks for them, sucks for users, sucks for everyone. So let's have a taste of what that looks like. A preview. Reddit, YouTube, Facebook, Twitter, Wikipedia, Instagram, TwitchTV, etc. All the websites where the content is made by users. As a group, shut down for 24 hours within the EU, instead displaying a simple page explaining the problem and what can do done about it. Until they're willing to do that, the users don't know or care what they're talking about. Legislators are relying on a population who is too distracted to care what they're doing. Well, fine, let's take away the distractions.
- 0db532a0 8y agoI really don’t think we’d be missing much if these websites were shut down. In fact, it might be a good thing.
- Barrin92 8y agoIt might even spur new European based social media companies that aren't full of American politics 90% of the time. To make Reddit useable I essentially have to filter out most of the website. Also for a long time I've been frustrated with the content policing that American companies enforce on European users. As a German user I have always been confused by the fact that a topless woman is going to get her account closed while some guy with a burning cross in his backyard and a swastika on his forehead can post merrily. Maybe the result of this is social media in Europe more closely aligned with people's values over here. I've never been a fan of Zuckerberg's 'connect the world' mentality.
- jstanley 8y ago> They need to do the unthinkable: Block all access from the EU. This is not a solution. This is just allowing beauracrats the power to make us voluntarily erect borders in cyberspace where none are required. Blocking entire geographic regions is the worst possible response.
- gingerlime 8y ago> especially on small and medium-sized companies like Reddit slightly OT, but is Reddit really a small / medium-sized company? or are they seriously downplaying it to get sympathy?
- mcguire 8y agoDoes the directive affect HN?
- raverbashing 8y agoMost likely it won't as it only hosts text, and links + individual words is ok (the reason I'm less worried about Art 11 is two fold: first is that I do agree that content scraping like Google News should be under agreement and that it will be worse for the news orgs than they think it will be)
- mcguire 8y agoBut in much of the discussion, links are explicitly mentioned. On the other hand, HN doesn't have ads.
- akvadrako 8y agoHN doesn't fall under EU jurisdiction, so even if they did violate it, I'm doubt it would be enforced.
- djflutt3rshy 8y agoI've seen quite a few paywalled articles posted, where someone else posts a link to "theoutline.com" to bypass paywalls, or just straight out copy/paste the article text.
- SimeVidas 8y agoWho are the companies behind these directives? Who are we fighting against?
- jansan 8y agoProbably German media "giants" like Springer and Bertelsmann. They don't get their shit done and are losing mind share each year, so they are panicking. However their influence on politics is still strong, therefore they can pull off stuff like that.
- mrep 8y agoProbably since GDPR will decimate most targeted advertising based businesses, they need to find another way to make money. The natural solution are paywalls but those don't work since people end up just copying the content and pasting it elsewhere. Shit, even journalists themselves rip off each others stories, paraphrasing the whole thing and then linking back to the source website. It's so prevalent that hacker news even has a rule about posting the original link to a story.
- mrep 8y agoExample copying and pasting paywalled article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18675496 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18675496
- repolfx 8y agoThat's where the EU link/Google taxes started but this copyright directive seems to have gone far beyond tackling news linking, which was what Axel Springer and friends cared about. Is there still provision in it for Google to have to pay for linking to news sites? I am reading contradictory things here - some are saying that links are perfectly fine now.
- variable11 8y agoOh no, someone is holding psychopathic Tech Bro culture accountable. Mah freedoms.
- ww520 8y agoWith GDPR and now this, EU is asking to be blocked off from the rest of the world. So be it.
- abc-xyz 8y agoI hope so. I'd love for evil companies who violate people's privacy (such as Reddit) to abandon EU, as it would allow for good and privacy-focused sites to gain a larger marketshare.
- PunchTornado 8y agoGDPR is good
- YetAnotherNick 8y agoCan you give me one example where it has helped(not the it would be helpful) the users. All I see now is everyone including FB and Google using the same privacy model, and just ask for big "consent", which is not much better than age old T and C, as I do it without reading it anyways.
- jeltz 8y agoMost European TLDs no longer publish sensitive information in the whois data. This mostly kills the whois protection companies which were just parasites, and also protects the privacy of domain name owners.
- YetAnotherNick 8y ago> Most European TLDs no longer publish sensitive information in the whois data. First of all, I don't think it is due to GDPR. Does GDPR mandate that you have to do it freely? Second, namecheap does it for free now, for every domain for users in every country.
- abc-xyz 8y agoAnyone who doesn't care about protecting people's privacy don't care because they don't understand how the data can and will be used. If they did understand and continued not to care (or god fodbid, continued to violate) then they're morally bankrupt. GDPR is amazing because it forces companies to think twice about the data they collect. Uneducated users tend to blame EU because some of their favorite websites (e.g. imgur) suddenly have a overlay that forces users to consent to them allowing themselves and a hundred random companies to violate users' privacy and force those who don't consent to manually click the opt out button a hundred different times. This should be a wakeup call for people to abandon these evil websites/companies rather than to blame EU.
- jokoon 8y agoEU citizen here. I keep using reddit but I have to admit the content quality has decreased. I keep going on it just like people like to go to facebook, just to entertain myself. If reddit was blocked, I guess I would just give up using it.
- buboard 8y agoi don't know a single other forum where you can converse with "EU citizens" other than /r/europe . I also follow other local reddits to find out the odd news that are not typically reported. And reddit is fun, entertaining, that's its value proposition and is based on the community, with posts being generally just a conversation starter. I would need an alternative to it. I also bet a lot of publications are going to miss the traffic it gives them.
- pas 8y agoThe content in general might have become less "deep", but the quality subreddits, posts, contributors are still there, just in total they make up a smaller percentage. At least this is my impression.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- MistahKoala 8y agoInitially I thought this was an appropriate and proportionate response. However, I eventually realised that doing so would be a tacit admission of acceptance of the extra-territorial ambition of the Directive and its application - which would be far worse, if we're truly concerned about global freedoms and rights. The morally correct response, as an organisation outside of the EU in terms of its presence and activities, would be to ignore the Directive, just as thousands of other bits of local legislation are by routine and convention. Unfortunately, Reddit is a subsidiary of Advance Publications, which I expect has physical operations in the EU and can therefore become subject to ransom locally. In which case, perhaps banning EU citizens in the EU from accessing Reddit is the most viable and proportionate moral response after all. It would mean I lose access, but I strongly believe that the European Commission monster must be tamed and cut down to size.
- dustycat 8y agoThe thing I can't understand is why on earth would anyone want to leave an organisation like the European Union?
- qwerty456127 8y agoEvery European reading this should call their local parlament representative and the EU authorities themselves and tell them their opinion on this subject (I know this kind of action can actually help in the EU).
- apexalpha 8y agoGuys this is meant for platforms that continuously allow users to upload fully copyrighted stuff, offer no good takedown and just point to the users when asked. "We're a platform so the user is responsible". Thousand, maybe millions, of Youtube videos by small channels are re-uploaded to FB everyday and essentially stolen. Watch this, for example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t7tA3NNKF0Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t7tA3NNKF0Q This law just says: ehm no Facebook, you ARE responsible for this, and you can't just say 'talk to the user / page who stole it'. The way Reddit and others interpret it is just because they don't want to be legally beholden to laws that protect people smaller than they are. And they're calling it a 'ban on memes' to get people online to protest it like useful idiots. No one read the texts but everyone is angry.
- pas 8y agoReddit allows image and video uploads nowadays by users. How is Reddit supposed to filter all of it?