43 ms·
A note to our employees
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoLooks like Google has tried to dodge directly acquiescing to most of the walkout's demands. The chief diversity officer will "continue" to report to the leadership team, rather than being promoted. No mention of the employee representative on the board, either. Pichai states they'll add detail to their sexual harassment report, but doesn't commit to release it publicly, as demanded. Google also didn't address pay inequality, likely because doing so would require admitting they've been lying to the Department of Labor by claiming there is none. But there's an end to forced arbitration, we'll see if that's enough for the walkout crowd. I kinda doubt it.
- evrydayhustling 8y agoThe nice thing about ending forced arbitration is that it opens the lever to fix the other problems you mentioned. If they're smart they really will get ahead of the other core issues, instead of working them out in (real) courts!
- rifung 8y ago> No mention of the employee representative on the board, either. Can someone who knows better than me explain whether this is actually a reasonable request? It sounded ridiculous to me but I admit I am not knowledgeable in these matters.
- tapoxi 8y agoElisabeth Warren is working on a bill to make this a requirement. Personally I think its sensible to have some accountability to your employees, not just your shareholders.
- vkou 8y agoIt's a reasonable request, if you consider it from this perspective: > Why do shareholders get board seats? Because they don't trust company leadership to do the right thing, without any oversight. Leadership is currently asking employees to trust that leadership will do the right thing, without any oversight. This is, obviously, an unreasonable expectation. Even if employees trust current leadership, what assurances do they have that Sundar's successor will do the right thing? An employee representative on the board is the only way to ensure that leadership will do the right thing. Corporate America has figured out this accountability thing over a century ago.
- lawnchair_larry 8y agoThat's pretty backwards entitled thinking. Shareholders elect a board because they own the company and have rights to manage their assets. Employees are a resource. They have no such rights.
- zkomp 8y agoNot necessary. It is narrow minded to only see employees as a resource to exploit. Actually giving people a voice and representation is good and won't hurt
- lawnchair_larry 8y agoA voice is fine. But a board seat is not a voice, it’s extraordinary power. You are not entitled to that.
- vkou 8y agoWithout employees, there would be no company, and all conversation about what shareholders want would be moot. Employees have extraordinary power - especially if they work together to use it.
- devilmoon 8y agoI believe it would be quite ridiculous as well, any elected employee representative would probably be somehow bought out by the company/board and become useless. That's what Union Reps in my country do at least - they are basically friends with upper management/board and just strike deals that benefit them rather than the workers
- nrook 8y agoThis is required in some European countries. For example, in Germany, workers have a right to 50% of the board for companies with more than 2,000 employees. (Ties break for shareholders, due to the way the chair position works.) https://www.worker-participation.eu/National-Industrial-Relations/Countries/Germany/Board-level-Representation https://www.worker-participation.eu/National-Industrial-Rela... Obviously, this hasn't destroyed Germany's economy, so it's doubtful it would hurt Google's profits much either.
- lozaning 8y ago50% of the board with votes breaking for shareholders sounds a lot like the workers don't actually have any control at all. What prevents the shareholders from just consistently railroading the workers, forcing everything to a tie, and then having the decision break their way?
- enitihas 8y agoI was reading about employee-employer relationship in Japan(in the context of Sony) and it seemed like most people used to work at a place for life. It might be similar for Germany in a lot of industries(Automobile, heavy manufacturing). However, wouldn't this pose a new set of problems when applied to companies where the average employee tenure is very short? I think the average tech worker tenure is very very short compared to other industries. While representing employees on the board is a good idea in general, it might need some modifications before being applied to companies with high employee churn rate.
- travellingbuyer 8y agoSounds like half-communism to me. It's messing with the reward/punishment mechanism of profits/losses. They have 50% of control, but no skin in the game. If their policies hurt dividends, it doesn't matter, because they didn't invest their own money in the first place and the salary is stable. If the company goes broke, they can just find another job. > Obviously, this hasn't destroyed Germany's economy, so it's doubtful it would hurt Google's profits much either. You can't say the Germany economy wouldn't be better off without this regulation.
- Taylor_OD 8y agoDo you believe they are lying to the Department of Labor? Do you have any evidence for that claim? I'd love to see it.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoGoogle claims they have "no pay gap". And have resisted turning over their HR data as much as possible to avoid allowing the Department of Labor to investigate it, including claiming it was to protect employee privacy, and hilariously, that it was too hard/costly for Google to gather the data. Meanwhile, the Department of Labor says there is "systemic compensation disparities against women pretty much across the entire workforce" and that "received compelling evidence of very significant discrimination against women in the most common positions at Google headquarters". A fifth of Google's entire workforce (20,000 people!) walked out, in part, because of that systemic mistreatment of women, and demanded Google fix the pay gap. The Department of Labor and 20,000 employees who say there's a pay gap. I believe them. Google says there isn't one. I do not believe Google is run by people too incompetent to notice a "systemic" pay gap. Therefore, yes, I believe they are lying. Source: https://www.theverge.com/2017/4/8/15229688/department-of-labor-google-gender-pay-gap https://www.theverge.com/2017/4/8/15229688/department-of-lab...
- thoughtexplorer 8y agoSerious question: Does the Chief Diversity Officer include diversity of ideas and experience? Or is it just skin deep like it sounds? Edit: Lots of up and down votes. Why is this question so controversial? I'd like to see an argument as to why it's an invalid or flawed question.
- cryoshon 8y agoi would say that at google there's a chance they're including diversity of ideas and experience. at most companies, we all know that the skin-deep diversity is the only thing the HR department cares about because it's all they're terrified about getting sued over. however, given google's unique corporate culture, i think that they might be forward thinking enough to seek out different perspectives, but probably not in a quota-driven fashion.
- georgeburdell 8y agoYou’re getting downvoted because Google and many other well known tech companies are known not to be comfortable places to work if you’re a conservative. Political ideology, like skin color, should not itself be a diversity goal, but the former often reflects differences in mindsets that may be better suited for certain projects or job roles.
- cryoshon 8y agothere's a lot more to a person's perspective than their political ideology. i imagine at google it'd be advantageous to have people who approached problems with a plethora of cognitive approaches, however. it's difficult to measure such things, of course. political ideology can't be a meaningful diversity goal anyway, nor should it be. there may not be a "best" ideology but promoting political ideology alone would be a terrible idea because in the current way that diversity is practiced it would require treating ideologies like nazism as on the same table as others.
- tracker1 8y ago
- cryoshon 8y agostatements like >Going forward, we will provide more transparency on how we handle concerns. We’ll give better support and care to the people who raise them and >We’re overhauling our reporting channels by bringing them together on one dedicated site and including live support. We will enhance the processes we use to handle concerns—including the ability for Googlers to be accompanied by a support person. And we will offer extra care and resources for Googlers during and after the process. immediately set off my BS detector. whenever someone talks about meta-issues surrounding another issue without ever directly touching on the main issue itself, they're being evasive. the arbitration clause change is a good one. but the entire statement lacks any genuine taking of responsibility regarding the prior anti-employee practices. nor is there any "we're gonna try to stamp out sexual harassment". notably, there is also no acknowledgement of other recent internal concerns, namely aiding governments in the oppression of their people (china and arguably others) and aiding governments in warfare (the US). while googlers have been shamefully complacent about getting their employers to drop these collaborations, the fact that it isn't even mentioned by pichai in a "please shut up and go back to work" letter is a bit sad. in conclusion: googlers need to step on the gas WRT sexual harassment changes if they want anything beyond the modest changes announced in this letter and other social issues regarding the company must also be brought to the point of conflict internally.
- SpikeDad 8y agoThat really said nothing. They actually previously had a policy that if you were required to take sexual harassment training and didn't you got docked 1 point? Wouldn't getting fired be a more appropriate penalty? However they take this "seriously" so I'm sure everything will be fine for Google employees.
- jahlove 8y ago> Wouldn't getting fired be a more appropriate penalty? no.
- craftyguy 8y agoCare to explain why you think not?
- mxstbr 8y agoThe linked PDF contains a lot more substance than this PR-ey blogpost: https://services.google.com/fh/files/blogs/november_announcement.pdf https://services.google.com/fh/files/blogs/november_announce...
- abalone 8y agoHow does this compare with the protesters' demands? Anything missing?
- wffurr 8y agoNo employee rep on the board. Chief Diversity Officer still reports to C-team not the board.
- shmel 8y agoMandatory sexual harassment training sounds quite disturbing. Anybody can comment in detail how it is conducted? Is it really mandatory for everyone or only for men?
- bobbytherobot 8y agoWhy does that sound disturbing?
- shmel 8y agoMainly because to me it sounds a lot like horror stories about those college classes to teach men how to not rape (I dunno, what happens there? instructor keeps telling "rape is bad"?)
- Osmose 8y agoWhat are you talking about? Mandatory sexual harassment training is standard for managers; California requires it for companies with 50 employees or more: https://www.dfeh.ca.gov/sexualharassmentpreventiontraining/ https://www.dfeh.ca.gov/sexualharassmentpreventiontraining/
- XCabbage 8y agoI'm not sure whether your confusion is genuine or feigned. If it's the former, then allow me to blow your mind by informing you that non-Californians exist and use the internet.
- HarryHirsch 8y agoLook at the overspecific promises going forward! - We will make arbitration optional for individual sexual harassment and sexual assault claims Ordinary harassment and assault is still covered by forced arbitration, as is systemic sexual harassment. Good to know. - We will update and expand our mandatory sexual harassment training Everyone knows already that mandatory XY training serves to deflect liability from the company. If the previous instance wasn't good enough for its purpose, the new one will certainly be. Why not just follow policy in the employee handbook? They usually have a section on harassment and appropiate conduct, and form part of the employment contract.
- jey 8y agoJust putting it in the employee handbook is more of a liability deflecting move than actively training people and explicitly creating common knowledge.
- snowwrestler 8y agoSexual harassment prevention training is an area where HR and employee incentives are well-aligned today, because the risk of a sexual harassment incident has a large reputational component. Gone are the days when a company just needed a box to tell a court that they checked. The public doesn't care about those boxes. The only way to manage the reputational risk of sexual harassment is to really try to prevent incidents. Good training can do that. Good training does not just tell you what you cannot do, it explores hypotheticals and addresses headline topics that people are thinking about. It is educational not just proscriptive.
- grandmczeb 8y agoIs there any research on the effect of training on sexual assault in the workplace?
- HarryHirsch 8y agoMany universities offer scientific ethics training for incoming research students. (The NSF actually demands it for projects they sponsor.) The purpose isn't to make them walk the narrow path of goodness, it's to enable them to spot temptation when it comes, as it inevitably will. With sexual harassment the line is much sharper drawn. If someone hasn't learned how to behave civilly and not to exploit a power differential in their early 20s, no amount of training is going to help.
- duxup 8y agoThis reminds me of a company I worked at where they deiced people were spending too much on travel. So they came out with new rules about travel expenses every 6 months until large swaths of people simply couldn't travel (me included). But the problem wasn't solved at all because the bulk of the absurd spending was caused by people who the rules didn't apply to....
- crunchlibrarian 8y agoThere will be more stories coming out about Google in the coming months, they are notorious for having a whole different set of standards for their super special elite executives. I don't know any specifics of an event or anything, but I have heard a lot about how none of the rules apply anymore once you get to the inner circles.
- habosa 8y ago[Googler] This is how I feel when I see an increased emphasis on training. Making a bunch of leaf-node employees like me sit through more simple online training is not going to fix the problem we have (although it can't hurt). It doesn't address the harassment that comes from extreme differences in power and a lack of accountability. Still, I am cautiously optimistic about today's announced changes.
- noobermin 8y agoIt's the neoliberal response to everything. Make cosmetic, progressive changes but don't address underlying structural inequalities between groups.
- duxup 8y agoI would say it is the response by any group in power, corporate, politics, whatever. They want to makes some news they're doing something, but regardless of organization or politics, the rules often don't apply to those in power.
- ericabiz 8y agoOne of the more interesting pieces is buried in the linked PDF: "Excessive alcohol: Harassment is never acceptable and alcohol is never an excuse. But one of the most common factors among the harassment complaints made today at Google is that the perpetrator had been drinking (~20% of cases). Our policy is clear: Excessive consumption of alcohol is not permitted when you are at work, performing Google business, or attending a Google-related event, whether onsite or offsite. Going forward, all leaders at the company - Directors, VPs and SVPs - will be expected to create teams, events, offsites and environments in which excessive alcohol consumption is strongly discouraged. For example, many teams have already put two-drink limits in place for events. Others use drink ticket systems. The onus will be on leaders to take appropriate steps to restrict any excessive consumption among their teams, and we will impose more onerous actions if problems persist." As someone who's been exposed to heavy drinking culture in Silicon Valley, this is a huge step in the right direction. I hope more companies and tech events adopt this.
- philip1209 8y agoWhy not just ban alcohol at work? Why can't work be work, and social stuff can happen outside of it? I know it sounds a bit extreme. But, after reading "It doesn't have to be crazy it work," I feel like companies use alcohol to bribe employees to stay at the office after-hours. A midground would be drinking only with sit-down food. Nobody is doing shots while having dinner. Another idea could be making company social functions a lunch activity, rather than a dinner one.
- savanaly 8y ago>Why not just ban alcohol at work? Why can't work be work, and social stuff can happen outside of it? I see this sentiment a lot (especially on HN!) and I share it. I usually skip team dinners when I can. But there's no accounting for taste, and humans in general seem to have a taste for mixing work and "social stuff", so why shouldn't companies encourage it in that capacity?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- knl 8y agoI'm not a native speaker, but doesn't "We will update and expand our mandatory sexual harassment training" mean that trainings teach how to do sexual harassment, not prevent it? Shouldn't it be "prevention of sexual harassment"?
- GaryNumanVevo 8y agoI'm a native speaker and it probably should be "sexual harassment prevention training" but I know a lot of companies shorten it to "sexual harassment training" the "prevention" part is obviously implied
- rjknight 8y agoA few years ago I had to do "financial crime training", and although I had heard all kinds of rumours about what working in financial services is like, I was surprised that they were so up-front about it! More seriously, I think this is what happens when certain words or phrases become jargon terms - they're used to invoke a concept, and lose their literal meaning. Something similar is happening with "mental health", as in "we should be concerned about mental health", where "mental illness" would seem to be a more accurate term. The jarring effect comes when people who use these terms frequently and for whom they have become jargon have to talk to everyone else, for whom the term carries its literal meaning. "Sexual harassment" and "financial crime" stand out because their literal meaning also carries a strong emotional charge for most people, whereas their jargon invocation doesn't.
- scrollaway 8y ago> Something similar is happening with "mental health", as in "we should be concerned about mental health", where "mental illness" would seem to be a more accurate term. I don't think it's happening to the term "mental health". Maybe it is being used as a superset of "mental illness" sometimes when talking about eg. homelessness, but most of the time it talks about the general psychological health of people. Eg "People in tech need to manage their mental health".
- SilasX 8y ago>Something similar is happening with "mental health", as in "we should be concerned about mental health", where "mental illness" would seem to be a more accurate term. Wait, what? That's like saying "You're not concerned with employee health, you're concerned with whether employees are sick".
- kyberias 8y agoIt looks to me like US is like an alien planet. What does arbitration even mean in this context? It's crazy that employees need to know these things.
- xyzzyz 8y agoArbitration means that you don't get to sue in real court, but instead you are forced to go through "arbitration", which is a private company hired by your employer that's supposed to make fair decisions in disputes between the party that brings them continued business, and the random person that will never talk to them if they weren't forced to.
- dagasgasgasg 8y agoThis is not correct. You are not obligated to agree to the arbitrator your company selects. More on this: http://help.legalnature.com/arbitration-agreement-faqs/how-are-arbitrators-chosen-and-who-chooses-them http://help.legalnature.com/arbitration-agreement-faqs/how-a...
- slededit 8y agoThe Federal Arbitration act was specifically setup to provide a lower cost avenue to settle disputes as it is widely agreed that the current court system is too expensive for the average person. There is valid criticism that it prevents class action suits, but aside from that arbitration is better for everyone involved. Most people won't even bother to litigate a lawsuit due to the costs exceeding the relief sought, but arbitration is far more approachable.
- albertgoeswoof 8y agoIsn’t sexual assault / harassment a criminal offence though? Surely the state should be prosecuting the moment a law is broken? Or does the US justice system work differently?
- xyzzyz 8y agoThere are plenty of fireable offenses of sexual harrasment type that don’t meet the relevant criminal standard of sexual assault. Sexual harrasment is not a crime, though often it is very close to the crime of sexual assault (e.g. unwanted touching is a crime).
- ummonk 8y ago>We will recommit to our company-wide OKR around diversity, equity and inclusion again in 2019, focused on improving representation—through hiring, progression and retention—and creating a more inclusive culture for everyone. What meaningful difference is there between representation OKRs and quotas?
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoA quota would be a documented mandate to engage in illegal behavior, while the OKRs will just encourage lower-level employees into doing illegal behavior without the documentation and the corporate liability. Remember Wells Fargo and how their sales mandates lead to retail bankers opening up fraudulent accounts? Same concept. Don't demand anything specific, just demand that something be done and apply rewards and punishments appropriately.
- politician 8y agoI thought this would be about facilitating Chinese surveillance initiatives, but on reflection, I suppose that was naive.
- buboard 8y agoWhy don't they make all their employees remote? Having them in the office only seems to bring trouble. Or just separate men from women. It works in the middle east
- cphoover 8y agoSexual harassment training... what a joke
- scottlocklin 8y agoAnyone want to bet whether or not Andy Rubin has actually attended sexual harassment training?
- dionian 8y ago> We will recommit to our company-wide OKR around diversity, equity and inclusion again in 2019, focused on improving representation—through hiring, progression and retention—and creating a more inclusive culture for everyone. How does more diversity solve anything?
- travellingbuyer 8y agoIf anything, diversity potentially makes it worse, because you'd have people from more distinct cultures, some of which have customs diametrically opposed to the company's policies. Unless, of course, they are talking about superficial diversity: skin colour, sex, etc. Still, wouldn't solve anything.
- Joakal 8y agoThis whole PR looks like a CYA for the company because all if not most of these changes occur are mandatory [0] or gestures due to the power that the harassers have over their subordinates (report me and you're fired!). Am I wrong to assume that all the serial sex harassers have been managers to their targets? How about a subordinate relationship ban? This policy prohibiting relationships already occur for between doctor and patient, teacher and student. Even the recent police and detained people sex ban? [1] [0] https://hrdailyadvisor.blr.com/2018/10/04/new-california-law-requires-sexual-harassment-training-for-all-employees/ https://hrdailyadvisor.blr.com/2018/10/04/new-california-law... [1] http://m.amsterdamnews.com/news/2018/apr/05/bill-bans-cops-sex/ http://m.amsterdamnews.com/news/2018/apr/05/bill-bans-cops-s... If I was a protester, I would ask Google execs how these policies will tackle the abuse of power for sexual activity.
- x0x0 8y agoAm I the only one who reads a bunch of the stuff Sundar has done recently as (1) Sundar disagreeing very strongly with how Larry handled sexual harassment issues at google (see eg Andy), and (2) making it clear that he handles them differently? eg in his Oct memo Sundar carefully pointed out that people at google on his watch have been fired for sexual harassment, and none of them got a package [1]. [1] https://deadline.com/2018/10/google-ceo-sundar-pichai-fired-48-people-sexual-harassment-1202489812/ https://deadline.com/2018/10/google-ceo-sundar-pichai-fired-...
- walshemj 8y agoInteresting I sort of got the impression that it was mandatory company provided arbitration with NDA's was one of the key elements of the walkout.
- robut_98765 8y agoI wonder how long it will be until there is A note to our employees version 2.0
- rpvreviews 8y agoLike salesforce, let companies ban the drug, sorry alcohol.
- tptacek 8y agoI don't understand why the "mandatory" training has a penalty for skipping it. If it's mandatory, it's mandatory. This isn't rocket surgery; there are all sorts of mandatory training things big companies do, and they are often actually mandatory. For instance, we've worked with HIPAA-encumbered clients where you'll lose access to their network and applications if you don't complete annual security awareness training. The "docking people in Perf" thing just seems like needless drama. Just require people to do the damn training.
- schintan 8y agoand what if they still do not take the training, fire them ?
- mattmanser 8y agoYeah, why wouldn't you? Either you believe it necessary or you don't.
- tptacek 8y agoObviously, yes.
- erikpukinskis 8y agoThat is, in fact, what mandatory means.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I don't understand why the "mandatory" training has a penalty for skipping it. Because penalties for non-compliance are how mandates are enforced; otherwise, they aren't mandates. What you probably don't understand is really why is the penalty not immediate termination, or termination after a certain period of delinquency, not why there is a penalty, and I suspect it actually is the latter, and the downgrade in internal rating is the immediate and automatic consequence of delinquency (also, I don't know how Perf works, for all I know the stated downgrade may be enough to normally trigger being put on a PIP and terminated if the problem isn't cured quickly.)
- gchokov 8y ago“We will update and expand our mandatory sexual harassment training.“ That sounds as they will train how to do it properly and not get caught:)
- Pica_soO 8y agoI cant help but laugh a little at the sites layout- showing a message from the CEO of Google- and then, the site is going into full knights helmet mode, shoving a add-bar up, reducing the readability further. Whoever designed this, to silently mock his superior- i draw my hat.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lgleason 8y agoHow about banning all mandatory arbitration so that it is fair for everybody?
- travellingbuyer 8y agoThat would be unfair for people who want the arbitration.
- brynjolf 8y agoThe normal way to deal with corruption, make new rules for everyone except the people committing the corruption.