29 ms·
Tim Berners-Lee says tech giants may have to be split up
- zackkatz 8y agoI suggest the title be changed to remove “Father of Web”. “Tim Berners-Lee says…” is better.
- dccoolgai 8y agoYeah. Honestly after his advocacy for the EME/DRM stuff it's hard for me not to be skeptical out-of-hand to any of his suggestions.
- throwaway2048 8y agoIt's sad he didn't see that EME/DRM is ultimately a tool that massively benefits incumbents to the determent of literally everybody else.
- contravariant 8y agoMake that "Sir Tim Berners-Lee" and I agree.
- craftyguy 8y ago"Tim 'supporter of DRM and now mostly trying to just stay relevant' Berners-Lee"
- gist 8y agoI actually have a big issue when the news runs stories like this to begin with. They would do the same btw if Woz said it or any other well known person. Sure the fact they can tag on 'father of the web' gives a strong pull but that is part of the problem. His thoughts on this aren't any more important than thousands of others that nobody has ever heard of. This is a total 'news as entertainment' story. And this has nothing to do with whether I agree or disagree with what he is saying. I just don't like prominence given solely based on some prior achievement which quite frankly has no bearing on what he is saying today.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoI agree that his opinion should have no bearing on the way that the modern WWW is run - but considering he invented the platform I think his opinion is interesting and well worth hearing when it didn't turn out the way he originally envisaged.
- gist 8y ago> I think his opinion is interesting Hence 'entertainment', right? > when it didn't turn out the way he originally envisaged Sure but who cares if that is the case? And he didn't imagine and invent the modern web nor did he even popularize it or put much effort into making it what is is today. By his statements I take it that he is jealous that he feels that he has not played a bigger role in what happened after his 'invention' (which was based on a great deal of work prior to his involvement). Many of us used the arpanet in the 70's not to mention the US Government's involvement. Honestly (and nobody will agree I am sure) if there was no conflict with Russia the Internet would not exist (most likely). And I am not seeing what he had a vision for any more than solving some simple issue he saw which was: > Instead, it was hard work, the experience of working in computer science and an attempt to overcome the frustrations of trying to share information with colleagues and students That is not the web today or even close to it and for that matter it wasn't the web even in 2000 or 1998.
- asaph 8y ago> “If you put a drop of love into Twitter it seems to decay but if you put in a drop of hatred you feel it actually propagates much more strongly. And you wonder: ‘Well is that because of the way that Twitter as a medium has been built?’” How exactly is breaking up the tech giants going to solve this problem?
- supercanuck 8y agolower the barriers of entry for competition.
- themagician 8y agoThere is no barrier. There are OSS alternatives that are just as good as the real thing which you can spin up on an AWS instance in like 15 minutes. The cost to entry is $10 for a domain and a $1 credit card authorization to get started with AWS.
- maxxxxx 8y agoThere is no barrier to entry. But there is a huge barrier to grow and establish something new. Whatever a smaller competitor comes up with Facebook can quickly copy and dominate the market just by sheer size. There is a reason why so many startups get acquihired by one of the big companies and shut down their product instead of establishing themselves on the market.
- enitihas 8y agoAren't there already some competing social media platforms out there? Twitter, facebook(Whatsapp and Instagram too), Snapchat, G+ used to be a thing. You may say they do not compete head on to each other, but which one of them was immune to this problem? The fact that any internet based social platform will have a very large connectivity and will provide people a very easy way to communicate to an exponential amount of other people, that fact won't change by lowering barriers. The fact that all the people reading something online neither have the time nor the patience to research everything is not going to change.
- 8y ago
- noetic_techy 8y agoI agree. Having trillion dollar valuation companies dominate the internet is akin to letting Standard Oil dominate a resource, or monopolies dominate the emergence of railroads. You have to recognize these technological emergence's when they occur, because typically they will be unlike anything we've seen before. I would argue Social Media is one of those emergence's. Smartphones arguably another. Ideally, I would like to see tech giants split into 3 companies, with 2/3 residing outside of SV so as not to be subject to the group-think of that region. This coming from someone who grew up in the heart of SV, got into tech, and eventually left.
- growtofill 8y agoWhat's wrong with smartphones?
- Balero 8y agoI think the problem is not with smart phones, but with the ecosystem around them. Eg, Apple, and iTunes. Android, and google docs
- neaden 8y agoI think a good example is cars. Imagine having a Ford car that you could only get repaired at Ford dealerships, that only took Ford bumper stickers or other accessories, and only could get filled up with Ford gas at Ford gas stations. I think most people would agree that would be a problem, and we are getting dangerously close to that with smart phones.
- edejong 8y agoTim, you made the web fundamentally client-server. Servers have urls, can be indexed, have centralising power. Clients do all the work: run the code, render the page, be subservient. Clients do not have urls, cannot be indexed and cannot communicate among each other (gRPC excepted). Don't you agree this design has massive centralisation as a side-effect, and how can we fix the design?
- exhaze 8y agoHe's actually been working on solving that exact problem: https://www.fastcompany.com/90243936/exclusive-tim-berners-lee-tells-us-his-radical-new-plan-to-upend-the-world-wide-web https://www.fastcompany.com/90243936/exclusive-tim-berners-l...
- choko 8y agoIt's interesting that he is pushing the decentralization concept while at the same time decrying hate speech on the web. Wouldn't a non-centralized version of the web make it harder to police said speech? As a disclaimer, I am not advocating the policing of speech in any way and am against that concept.
- megous 8y agoYou wouldn't be able to control what people publish on their own devices, but for those people to be able to spread their (unwanted) content would be presumably harder.
- macintux 8y agoIt's not clear that he's decrying hate speech so much as decrying the amplification effect on it that the current state of the tech world enables.
- hobofan 8y ago> Wouldn't a non-centralized version of the web make it harder to police said speech? It might make it easier, by not connecting to those parts of the decentralized web where hate-speech is prevalent. Of course, this might then amplify echo-chambers.
- themagician 8y agoThey really don’t. They don’t have monopolies on anything and there is no high barrier to entry to compete, they are just really popular. Facebook is far more akin to Kim Kardashian than Ma Bell or Standard Oil. You don’t need Facebook or Instagram or Twitter or any of that other crap. In fact, it turns out if you stop using them nothing bad happens to you at all. I’m many cases your life is better and you actually end up more connected to your friends and family. Comcast, AT&T, and Verizon however… now those are some real problem companies that pose real dangers.
- stochastic_monk 8y agoAT&T is a tech giant in precisely the same sense that Google is.
- themagician 8y agoAT&T controls infrastructure and has a monopoly in certain geographic areas. Google does not. Google has a monopoly on search, but that’s about it. There are alternatives though, some of which are as good or better in many ways.
- ghostly_s 8y agoIn any meaningful sense, search is infrastructure now. So is email, etc.
- basilgohar 8y agoGoogle dominates search, but also dominates e-mail, mobile devices (less so, but still a major player), and is heavily involved in many other tech verticals. That they dominate isn't the problem. That they are leveraging their hegemony across all of these verticals to drive their main source of revenue, advertising, is where the concern comes. The fact is it is nearly impossible for a non-entrenched player to enter into the market without either being drowned our or bought-up by one of the big players is where the monopolistic concerns arise.
- lotsofpulp 8y ago
- choko 8y ago"But social media, Berners-Lee said, was still being used to propagate hate." This is one of the side effects of an open web, and one I feel we should live with in the interests of freedom. The only alternative of which I am aware is to police speech through some kind of authority. I'm not sure that there is an authority in existence that I would trust with that level of power. In a perfect world, we would be able to de-platform those that incite violence against others (for any reason), but we can't even come to an agreement on what that means. Some people argue that criticizing a marginalized group is hate speech and further argue that hate speech is violence. Should some people be shielded from valid criticism because they identify as a certain group? It sounds like a simple concept, but the more you explore it, the less simple it becomes.
- gambler 8y ago>This is one of the side effects of an open web, and one I feel we should live with in the interests of freedom. The only alternative of which I am aware is to police speech through some kind of authority. I strongly believe this is nor correct. You can mitigate a lot of this stuff through better design, without censorship. Most important point: Open Web is the idea that people can find info they're looking for, not that anyone on the web can bombard everyone else with information. Modern social media is optimized for the latter. Algorithms chose for you, and they chose badly, and you have no control over it. Jaron Lanier has a lot of talks about incentives and why current social media is bad for you. His hypotheses seem plausible.
- choko 8y agoThat just means the person writing the algorithm becomes the authority. As we recently saw with Amazon's hiring practices, algorithms have bias as well. Granted, a better designed system might not have made this mistake, but since humans designed it, can it ever be perfectly unbiased? Without actual censorship (which I'm against) the offending material still exists, but would only be found by those who seek it. I do like that approach personally, but I don't think it would be enough to satisfy many people who prefer to eradicate offensive speech through authoritarian measures.
- 8y ago
- davidwparker 8y agoHe also said: “Before breaking them up, we should see whether they are not just disrupted by a small player beating them out of the market, but by the market shifting, by the interest going somewhere else,” edit: formatting
- arendtio 8y agoI am not sure, but sometimes I think splitting the companies is not even what we need. Instead, companies with > $1 billion annual revenue should be bound by law to built federated platforms and provide the software to participate in such a network. I mean, you could split up Google into Search, Youtube, and Mail. But in the end, Youtube would still use Analytics and provide Search with all the data they need for their Ad business and Mail would use the Ad tech from Search. With Facebook, it is mostly the same story. Federated Systems, on the other hand, let you build a distributed network of providers where no provider has all the data in one place, and you can choose which provider you want to trust (or if you want to be provider yourself).
- WC3w6pXxgGd 8y agoWhy do you trust governments so much?
- bilbo0s 8y agoTo be fair, all sides trust the government. We're trusting the government to go in and properly split up a company. Or you're trusting the government to properly regulate a company. The people who don't trust the government, don't want the government to take ANY action. They believe the market will solve the problem.
- vlunkr 8y agoSo all sides trust the government except for the ones that don't
- bilbo0s 8y agoAnd the ones that don't, have not stated their position in this discussion. So all sides presenting in this discussion, trust the government.
- paulddraper 8y ago> To be fair, all sides trust the government. > The people who don't trust the government, don't want the government to take ANY action Which is it?
- mattlondon 8y ago> "Before breaking them up, we should see whether they are not just disrupted by a small player beating them out of the market" How long do you wait to see if this happens? E.g. MySpace was the social network back in the day. When was the last time you even heard/thought about MySpace let alone even visited the site? Did we wait long enough for MySpce to die on its own, or should we have acted sooner? Does it matter either way? We've had a couple of recent examples too, like Snap that looked like the unasailable Neu-Facebook a year or two ago, but now is crumbling and losing users rapidly - should we have broken up Facebook before that happened to Snap? Does it matter either way? Facebook is now losing users in western countries too - should we act now to break it up, or wait to see if it is "doing a snap" and will die on its own? The point I am trying to make is that competitors come and go on the incredibly open and incredibly egalitarian internet that Berners-Lee helped to popularise with WWW. Making arbitrary decisions about when to break up a company without relying on anything apart from hand-wringing "think of the children!"-ism seems unlikely. What would the metric be? Revenue? DAUs? I cant think of a meaningful way to measure when a company is too big and is not going to be disrupted apart from hand-waving and sensationalism-based approaches. Facebook has no control of the internet as such. Sure they are pervasive but if people stop visiting Facebook, the money dries up. They can profile as much as they like but if there are no eye balls viewing those perfectly targetted ads then there is no money coming in - Facebook cant use their "control" of the intenet to force you to go view their ads no more than Google can use its "control" of the internet to force you to view their ads. You have choices on what to visit. Just like no one chooses to go to MySpace any more. The solution - as always - has been an ad blocker, rejecting 3rd party cookies, signing out of facebook & google, switching from Google/Facebook services to alternatives (e.g. DuckDuckGo is a good and viable replacement to Google Search; Firefox is a good and viable replacement to Google Chrome, talking to people is a good and viable replacement to Facebook).
- ajvs 8y agoYour solutions are not enough because Facebook owns Instagram and WhatsApp - they buy out new social media so they're always in control. In Europe at least everyone uses WhatsApp and no-one texts anymore - they're too pervasive to avoid.
- hirseypie 8y agoWhy does one man claim the Right to force other men to break up their businesses? digusting. This is communism and totalitarianism.
- wowamit 8y agoI strongly believe we need to tread extra cautiously while observing what these companies do with the internet. They would like to have their own walled sections of the internet where they define the rules and govern the policies. It started with URLs first (facebook.com was the internet for many). It is shifting to whole top level domains - Google’s usage of “.new” for example. I agree that the best solution will be to reduce the concentration of power. However, it is extremely complex to implement. There are too many parameters in play, both technological and political. It would be important to not let these walled premises build until we have the solution.
- majani 8y agoI think the main issue that has allowed the likes of Google and Facebook to grow to a dangerous size is the ability to scale globally with minimal resistance from other countries. As time goes by, I start to realize that China's great firewall may have had some visionary thinking behind it, and other countries may follow suit in future to enable their citizens to take part in the digital revolution.
- obenn 8y agoThe issue is that the firewall protects the interests of a political regime instead of a capitalist one. It is a complicated topic but I see decentralized technologies as a more viable way of preserving digital freedom.
- WC3w6pXxgGd 8y agoDid you seriously just praise the authoritarian control of information in China?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jshowa3 8y agoAs someone who has been to China. This is the worst part about going there. Try finding or enjoying anything online where half the sites are blocked.
- dasil003 8y agoI don’t think anyone would argue the GFW is not visionary, the question is what kind of vision?
- balozi 8y agoI'm sorry, but yours is supremely paternalistic analysis borne of a believe that your fellow citizens are too stupid to have agency or act in their own interests. And there is nothing visionary about China's great firewall since aristocrats have been trying to control the surfs since time immemorial by controlling communication. There is a reason antebellum slave owners did not want their slaves to learn how to read.
- sharemywin 8y ago* You need to un-bundle features. identity from social feed from storage * require data, interaction and reputation portability. - be able to search for a user on twitter by their facebook username(if the user agrees). - be able to request a transaction or feedback is transferable to other platforms if both users agree. - look up john smiths reputation on amazon is 5 stars. * Transparency around security, transparency around pricing and income from your data and an ability to pay to opt out. - get an invoice we made $30 this month display ads to you. - $4 from Statefarm, $2 from viagra etc. * ability to delete data from a service.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoIn general, the current trend of value accumulating in companies with more revenue than the GDP of most countries, is something that is killing diversity. Capitalism with one monopolist is not that much better than communist style centrally run planned economies. Both are inefficient and ultimately self serving. However, instead of breaking up companies, maybe it is better to constrain their ability to accumulate this much power and wealth. Big companies are treated way too nicely by governments. They get to dodge taxes, ignore regulations, lean on smaller players in the market, lean on politicians to look the other way or legislate in their favor, hoard patents, kill off competitors with unfair behavior, etc. Just level the playing field and restore competition.
- __initbrian__ 8y agothe article mentions wait for them to be disrupted. but how can that happen when they seem to acquire any threat?
- quadcore 8y agoHave we ever broke up a software company?
- maxxxxx 8y agoMicrosoft's growth got restricted successfully around 2000. all it took was to make their life a bit more difficult.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nakedrobot2 8y agoThey don't have to be broken up, they need to stop being morally bankrupt. Nothing about Facebook's size dictates that they needed to: - Allow their platform to be abused by misinformation campaigns, because it pays well (thereby allowing Trump to win) - Allow hate groups to flourish - Allow anti-vax groups to grow and flourish - Allow nutty conspiracy groups to flourish - Help dictatorships with their genocide It's simply because they are morally bankrupt by design and by culture.
- drawnablank 8y agoI don't think that enforcing the arbitrary restriction of views and opinions is the correct path to the morality you accuse them of being without. Once upon a time, Copernicus and Galileo would have been viewed as "nutty conspiracy" theorists, the latter of whom the church tried combat, purely for having different views. 'First they came' and all that...
- mattmaroon 8y agoI don't think you could break them up in any meaningful way. What would you break Apple up into? The company that makes iPhones and the company that makes iPads? Or Facebook? Two social networks that get half of the population each? Breakups only make sense for vertically integrated companies. I guess you could break up Google (it's already done so itself to some extent with the Alphabet reorg) but not in a way that's meaningful, other than maybe requiring advertising to be its own company. Also it neglects the fact that their biggest asset is their domain name. Google.com might be worth literally trillions of dollars. How do you break that up? If anything, I'd argue the government could regulate Facebook since it's basically a natural monopoly, much the way it does the NFL or basic utilities.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> What would you break Apple up into? Apple the device manufacturer and iTunes (or whatever) the streaming content service provider. > Or Facebook? Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp. > I guess you could break up Google Alphabet makes this easy. YouTube, Cloud Compute and the other things. > it's basically a natural monopoly Natural monopolies don’t have to acquire potential competitors to protect their flanks. Facebook minus Instagram would be very different today.
- uxhack 8y agoWhy not break them up with identical tech stack to start off with. So you could have 10 Google Search engines. Then let them inovate from there. With Apple it would be the same. You would have several platforms competing with IOS. Eventually they will start to doffer on thier offerings.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Why not break them up with identical tech stack to start off with Now we’re arbitrarily drawing lines. Platform-service separation, on the other hand, has precedent. (As does gobbling up up-and-coming competitors, as Facebook did with Instagram and WhatsApp.)
- 8y ago
- throwaway487548 8y agoIt it could be essentially the same procedure as splitting of Standard Oil, then, obviously it is good idea. Why should an ordinary joe like you and me care about FAANG shareholders?
- pinewurst 8y agoIn 1940, Lee de Forest, (semi-self-proclaimed) Father of Radio, sent an open letter to the National Association of Broadcasters in which he demanded: "What have you done with my child, the radio broadcast? You have debased this child, dressed him in rags of ragtime, tatters of jive and boogie-woogie."
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoWhen he talks about maybe waiting to see if things change and another company comes along to disrupt the big boys, I feel this has pretty much already been proven impossible. The big boys will just buy you. YouTube, Android, Instagram, WhatsApp, etc. all represented serious potential challenges to Google and FB, and they were just acquired.
- rezeroed 8y agoNo buying companies once you're above a certain size.
- partycoder 8y agoIf they split up then Tencent and Alibaba would take their place.
- Rafuino 8y agoIf Vint Cerf had said this as a Google guy, it would be a bit more news worthy.
- arminiusreturns 8y agoThey shouldn't have been allowed to get as big as they are in the first place. Where has the DoJ been on anti-trust/anti-monopoly laws? I'm guessing going through the revolving door. That's why those laws are there, because busting up a monopoly after the fact is much harder than preventing it from merger and acquisitioning it's way to that monopoly in the first place.
- avaika 8y agoHow do you imagine companies shouldn't be allowed to grow? "Oh, you already have X customers, you can't get X+1. That would be a monopoly"?
- arminiusreturns 8y agoThat's not what I said. Antitrust/anti-monopoly laws have a strong basis, and it's certainly not "you can't grow". You are attacking a strawman.
- john37386 8y agoMaybe these social networks could be manage by the community. A bit like HN. Here if you post crap, people can downvote your crap to the bottom so that no one can see it. If you want to be seen and red, you need to post quality and gain reputation. People with bad reputation will slowly lose visibility. It might not work, but clearly it seems that quality is a prime factor on HN and it's one of the reason why I trust more HN than any other social network.
- acjacobson 8y agoReddit has had mixed results with this - it entirely depends on the community and moderators. Some subreddits are much better managed than others.
- ar-nelson 8y agoThis is the result of manual moderation, not community voting. Reddit relies on voting, and it doesn't have the same level of quality. With the exception of subreddits with well-thought-out rules and moderators who consistently enforce those rules.
- TimJYoung 8y agoI think the solution may lie with changes to, or removal of, Section 230 of the CDA: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_230_of_the_Communications_Decency_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_230_of_the_Communicati... I suspect that forcing those that host 3rd party content/discussion to actually moderate and control the discussion will keep the size of such online communities smaller, which is good. Or, they will simply need increase revenue so that they can properly moderate them. Either way, the toxic nature of a lot of the internet goes away pretty quickly, and companies will be forced to clean up their act.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I think the solution may lie with changes to, or removal of, Section 230 of the CDA [...] > I suspect that forcing those that host 3rd party content/discussion to actually moderate and control the discussion [...] CDA Section 230 was largely adopted to encourage active moderation, since without it active moderation made a host a “publisher” rather than a mere “distributor”, which triggers strict liability for a number of violations for which a distributor would only have knowledge-based liability.
- TimJYoung 8y agoYes, but is it being used that way ? Everything that I've seen has indicated that service providers use this law to play it both ways: they actively control what users see through algorithms, but then claim that they are (largely) not responsible for the moderation of questionable content. IOW, they are not just a passive distribution point for information, and, in many cases, actively control the flow of information. Doesn't that intrinsically make them a publisher ?
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Yes, but is it being used that way ? Yes, most hosts have and enforce (though imperfectly) content rules as they would be disincentivized from doing without CDA 230. > Everything that I've seen has indicated that service providers use this law to play it both ways: they actively control what users see through algorithms, but then claim that they are (largely) not responsible for the moderation of questionable content. That's not playing it both ways. > IOW, they are not just a passive distribution point for information, and, in many cases, actively control the flow of information. Yes, the entire point of CDA 230 is to allow them to actively moderate without becoming strictly liable for all content, since without that allowance they would be disincentivized from moderation. Removing CDA 230 would not encourage active moderation, it would make active moderation a gateway to unmanageable liability. > Doesn't that intrinsically make them a publisher ? Yes, without CDA 230 it would, restoring the “if you moderate content at all, you must succeed in capturing every bit of user-submitted illegal content or be fully liable as if you had deliberately originated it yourself” rule that was in place before CDA 230 (with the added challenge that there are more content regulations now than before the CDA was adopted), which is not something that promotes moderation, it promotes either no moderation or no user content hosting at all, leaving moderated hosting for operators outside of US jurisdiction.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dreamdu5t 8y agoSounds like Tim Berners-Lee needs to take a break from Twitter and Facebook.
- brookhaven_dude 8y agoHow about we deal with ISPs and the telecom cartel first?
- _cs2017_ 8y agoI'm hoping he provided some rationale about why Microsoft, Google, and Apple should be split up. The way the interview is quoting just a couple sentences, it's hard to tell. If there's nothing besides the quote below, I'd consider this an extremely weird and weak argument: > What naturally happens is you end up with one company dominating the field so through history there is no alternative to really coming in and breaking things up. There is a danger of concentration.
- bostonpete 8y agoRight -- he makes this "one company" comment and then follows it up with a list of 5 companies that are dominating...
- perseusprime11 8y agoIf we fundamentally think big tech is bad, splitting them up will make the go much faster and it can get worse. Big companies move slower than smaller more nimble companies. The answer is not splitting up but just make them accountable for KPIs that are good for society.
- kyledrake 8y agoLet's start with the companies that voted for EME DMCA first. I'm sure TBL would be happy to release the list from the secret vote they had for it at the W3C. Seriously, it's bad optics going around and criticizing everybody else for not holding power accountable when you don't have your own house in order. When it came time to stand up to this power, Tim actively defended their interests. I suppose most people have already forgotten about it, but I never will, and neither will my friends that could go to jail for trying to research the security of binary crap in people's browsers.
- virmundi 8y agoSome might need to be split, but he’s looking at the wrong platforms. Gab is demonitized. The financial platforms won’t allow them to transact. The app stores won’t allow them to install. All this because a loon sent bombs. Twitter and FB have a history of allowing terrorists to communicate, but they are the darlings of the left so the are left alone. Break up the financial platforms if the government must break up someone.
- sfilargi 8y agoNo, we don't need the companies to split up. What we need is a truly distributed Web. Web X. Imagine a web where all the servers are just something like torrent nodes(or IPFS nodes). Ever user uses an Agent that just stores and retrieves encrypted chunk bytes to the servers. No central point of control => No dominance, no monopoly, no censorship.
- 0x262d 8y agoit's silly to try to split up tech companies. look at AT&T; it was tried, now it's basically un-split up. they exist in natural monopolies and their service benefits from monopoly anyway. it's also silly to try to regulate them. they have a fundamental incentive and nearly unlimited resources to do bad things, such as profiting from spreading hate via advertising, but also protecting their ability to do things like that by capturing regulatory agencies. look at attempts to regulate banking and how that has worked. services like web search, email, internet access, and social media are clearly valuable and important, arguably necessary. they also get massively distorted and damaged in private markets. these are not lemonade stands; capitalism is an extremely bad model for natural monopolies. they should be publicly owned, run, and developed, in the federated, open model suggested elsewhere. anything else is fooling yourself about what is possible or beneficial. as an addendum: yes this would require a massive renewal of democratic control over everything involved in this in order to make it work. unfortunately there aren't other good solutions.
- rchaud 8y agoI wish it could be made more apparent to people that Twitter and FB are not mediums for communication, but mediums for marketing broadcasts. Everyone with a significant following (let's say 100,000) is selling something. Software, home goods, consultants with online courses, meme pages angling for a TV deal, something. Yes, you can still use it to communicate with a core group of people whose tweets you enjoy. You can also do that on Slack, Discord, even phpBB forums, all of which grant the user more permissions to use the tool as they like.
- notacoward 8y ago> Twitter and FB are not mediums for communication, but mediums for marketing broadcasts. Why not both? There are plenty of people having legitimate, personally meaningful conversations on both. There are plenty that use both for marketing. The two aren't mutually exclusive. > You can also do that on Slack, Discord, even phpBB forums ...except that people mostly don't. They seem better able to discover and maintain their online friendships and communities on the bigger platforms, for whatever reason. They went into the market and they chose. Who are you to second-guess them?
- rchaud 8y ago> They went into the market and they chose. Who are you to second-guess them? The users are the ones second-guessing themselves. If all was fine and dandy on Twitter, there wouldn't be harassment mobs and people wouldn't be complaining. Decisions are not set in stone forever and aren't made with perfect information. What seemed like a good choice then may be sub-optimal now that users understand some of the design decisions that led Twitter to gravitate towards a marketing broadcast platform.
- marvelous 8y agoI wonder if a fix to many "too big to fail" and "winner takes all" market and public/private power imbalance issues, isn't simply this: mandatory split up beyond a certain size.
- ilovecaching 8y ago> “If you put a drop of love into Twitter it seems to decay but if you put in a drop of hatred you feel it actually propagates much more strongly. And you wonder: ‘Well is that because of the way that Twitter as a medium has been built?’” No, it's human nature. Stop blaming companies for the imperfections of the human race. If you put us into large groups, we will inevitably gossip, bicker, argue, and kill each other. We've been doing it literally since we were banging rocks and sticks together. The delusion that technology feeds us, and it is especially potent in America, is that there is some higher power leading us all to be terrible people online, and that technology should be able to fix the problem. But technology can't fix the problem. We are the problem. We also evolve incredibly slowly, and we're competing against technology that evolves in a matter of decades. We are too inflexible as a species to be compatible with the social effects of technology.
- davemp 8y agoThis is incredibly fatalistic. Why can't technology be created with human nature in mind? Forms of democracy with checks and balances became so dominant because it acknowledged the deficiencies in human nature. We can certainly blame companies for producing bad/harmful technology just like we can blame forms of government for producing bad outcomes for its citizens. --- On a side note, based on influence and entrenchment, comparing FAANG companies to governments actually seems more appropriate that I initially thought.
- ilovecaching 8y ago> Forms of democracy with checks and balances became so dominant because it acknowledged the deficiencies in human nature. And those systems have tons of flaws as well. Have you seen the voter turn out in the U.S.? How many Americans are making informed voting decisions. You're shifting the blame back to the technology. I get it, as a technologist we'd like to think it must be a mistake in the product. But the reality is that our idealistic notions of how the world should be do not match the capabilities of human nature.
- davemp 8y ago
- twblalock 8y agoIf you break up the big platforms today, you'd need to do it again in 5 years. Big platforms exist because centralization is convenient for users. If they disappeared new ones would be created, for the same reason the original ones were created in the first place. I have yet to see a proposal for a federated platform that appeals to average people outside of the HN/open source community. And even if you could solve that problem for social media, how would you come up with a federated replacement for something like Google search or Amazon shopping that is anywhere near as good?
- flyGuyOnTheSly 8y ago>Before breaking them up, we should see whether they are not just disrupted by a small player beating them out of the market Like Youtube, Instagram, or WhatsApp perhaps? Jokes aside, I don't see how an internet giant who is flush with cash and data in 2018 would fail to see the next biggest thing and acquire it before it grew large enough to knock them off their pedestals.
- m_ke 8y agoYes, Google, Apple and Facebook know more about these startups than the companies themselves. Google has an insider look at all of your metrics, your market and your competitors through the combination of search, Gmail, Android, Google play, maps, YouTube, Google analytics, adwords and Google Ventures. Same goes for Facebook and Apple. On top of that they are the gatekeepers to the main platforms and can kill you if you refuse to play along.
- amdelamar 8y agoThey totally are gatekeepers. And don't forget Microsoft too. They own the horse-racing arena, and have a horse in every race too.
- baccheion 8y agoIn my opinion, 43 (1 CEO + 6 managers/executives + 6 * 6 individual contributors) is the optimal employee count. It becomes a still-reasonable 259 (1 CEO + 6 executives + 6 * 6 managers + 6 * 6 * 6 individual contributors) if reality is factored in. Any company larger inevitable becomes a stagnating drain. That is, one way to somewhat clip power and improve overall (intracompany and economic) efficiency may be to limit company size to a maximum of 259-585 employees.
- sas2000 8y agook this is the hottest take in here
- yuhong 8y agoI think I just posted an Ask HN about a similar topic.
- gaius 8y agoI would be pretty surprised if most of the MBA-bro management at any FAANG had even heard of TBL, let alone gives a stuff about what he might say.
- dreamcompiler 8y agoLet's be careful here. In 1984, AT&T was a monopoly and was forced to break up its local operations into seven regional companies (the "Baby Bells"). Guess what? Over time, the seven slowly merged back together, with one -- Southwestern Bell -- eventually subsuming all the rest. Southwestern Bell then bought what was left of AT&T corporate and renamed itself "AT&T" and here we are again. It would be a shame to break up the tech giants only to allow them to slowly merge back together again.
- krupan 8y agoI know I'm really late to this discussion, but what we really need[1] is the kind of control over our feeds (whether facebook, twitter, insta) that we have over our email inboxes. With email you can set up filters and labels and redirect your mail where ever you want. Or you can just hit the big SPAM button on stuff you never want to see. Why doesn't social media offer this? Especially with twitter, I'd love to follow some people for their tech tweets, as long as I could filter out their trump tweets. It should be super easy to do that, yet none of the social media platforms offer it. Have we been asking for it? 1. I'm not for regulation, but for us customers (yeah, yeah, we are the "product" not the customer, whatever) to demand this