9 ms·
>The University of Pennsylvania’s Hans-Peter Kohler, who studies fertility and birthrates, said the data indicated that many shifts affecting fertility are occu
by dragontamer 8y ago
>The University of Pennsylvania’s Hans-Peter Kohler, who studies fertility and birthrates, said the data indicated that many shifts affecting fertility are occurring “in the transition to adulthood.” The biggest recent drops in birthrate have been among teenagers as well as people in their 20s. In 2016, the teen birthrate hit at an all-time low after peaking in 1991.
This... doesn't sound like bad news to me?
It seems like the #1 "issue" is that teenagers have stopped having kids. That's a good thing, is it not?
Young 20-year-olds not having kids could be easily explained with the higher amount of people going to college, and starting life later.
If the 25+ age group has stopped having kids, that'd be a bad thing for sure. I guess its important to keep the overall fertility rate in mind for future economic reasons, but a severe decrease in teenage pregnancy seems like a good thing overall... even if it may cause an economic issue in the future.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoDepends on your culture of course. Teens get pregnant so readily because they're designed that way. The US obsession with avoiding teen pregnancy causes problems of its own I'm sure.
- manfredo 8y agoI'm not sure I follow. A piece of plastic, or a pill is all it takes for teens to explore their sexuality without getting pregnant.
- rocketpastsix 8y agoAre you American? If not, its easy to see why it seems like common sense like this would work. But in America, especially the Southeast, those are taboo things.
- Thiez 8y agoThe shape of the human penis is 'designed' to scoop out the sperm that competing males may have recently left, but I rarely hear arguments that monogamy is unnatural and 'going to cause problems of its own'. I don't find the appeal to biology and 'design' particularly convincing. Perhaps you could give some examples of the problems you foresee, while keeping in mind than avoiding teen pregnancy is not the same as delaying having children until the age of 45?
- liftbigweights 8y ago> The shape of the human penis is 'designed' to scoop out the sperm that competing males may have recently left That's myth ( or we don't know for absolute certainty ). If that was true, it would scoop your own semen out better than your competitors. The shape has more to do with arousing females and making it easier for your sperm to reach the eggs than anything else. > but I rarely hear arguments that monogamy is unnatural and 'going to cause problems of its own'. Monogamy or polygamy is a far better male competitive "design" than the shape of the human penis. The best way to ensure you impregnate a woman is through monogamy or polygamy rather than semen displacement. Most male sex competition is geared towards preventing other males to mate with a female rather than scooping it out after your competitor mates with a female. > Perhaps you could give some examples of the problems you foresee, while keeping in mind than avoiding teen pregnancy is not the same as delaying having children until the age of 45? The best time for a female to procreate is 19 to 26. It's their peak biological fertility years. When they're most fertile and when their children are least likely to suffer from defects. Starting from 30s, it gets harder for women to get pregnant, it's more dangerous for the mother and it's when poorer quality of offspring are born. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-112136/The-female-fertility-clock-starts-ticking-27.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-112136/The-female... A woman waiting til their 30s to have offspring is like an nba player waiting til they are 40 to join the NBA.
- Thiez 8y ago> That's myth ( or we don't know for absolute certainty ). I think there's a rather big difference between myths and things we don't know with absolute certainty. If you're open to the possibility that something is true, while knowing there isn't absolute certainty, calling it a myth seems misleading at best. > If that was true, it would scoop your own semen out better than your competitors. I haven't done a poll, but I suspect many males stop thrusting after orgasm. Assuming that is true then there isn't really any downside to scooping out your own old semen if you only do it in situations where you're just going to make a fresh deposit 30 seconds later. > The shape has more to do with arousing females and making it easier for your sperm to reach the eggs than anything else. I'd be interested in seeing the research supporting this idea. I'm not saying I think it's false, but I've heard the 'sperm-scooping' theory before, but never the 'arousing females' one. > Monogamy or polygamy is a far better male competitive "design" than the shape of the human penis. The best way to ensure you impregnate a woman is through monogamy or polygamy rather than semen displacement. By polygamy I think you specifically mean polygyny? Because polyandry sounds like the kind of situation where the sperm scooping would be pretty effective. And just because one mechanism to achieve something exists does not mean that other mechanisms are useful. The best way not to die of poison is simply not to consume poison, but I'm pretty happy the body is able to vomit if you (accidentally) consume poison anyway. > The best time for a female to procreate is 19 to 26. It's their peak biological fertility years. When they're most fertile and when their children are least likely to suffer from defects. Starting from 30s, it gets harder for women to get pregnant, it's more dangerous for the mother and it's when poorer quality of offspring are born. To quote your own article: > Team member Dr David Dunson explained: 'Though we noted a decline in fertility in the late 20s, what we found was a decrease in the probability of becoming pregnant per menstrual cycle, not in the probability of eventually achieving a pregnancy. So it sounds to me that although women in their late twenties are slightly less likely to get pregnant on any given menstrual cycle than women in their early twenties, the effect does not seem to significantly affect their odds of procreating. > Starting from 30s, it gets harder for women to get pregnant, it's more dangerous for the mother and it's when poorer quality of offspring are born. But since we're linking studies, I would like to refer to some research by the CDC [1] that shows that infant mortality is lowest for mothers between the ages of 30 and 34 (inclusive), and the infant mortality for mothers younger than 20 is the highest of all, significantly surpassing that of women over 40. Based on a report from Australia [2] which includes some information about the risk of mortality for the mother it also looks like having children before the age of 20 is inadvisable at best. Risk of death for the mother is lowest in the 20-24 range, but mysteriously the 25-29 range is at a higher risk of death than women in the 30-34 range. Regardless, based on the data I don't think it's self-evident that the best time for women to procreate is between the ages of 19 and 26. I'll admit I haven't included numbers about birth defects. Another thing we haven't examined is the ability of the parents to raise and support their children. I suspect a 30 year old women may have the advantage over one 10 years her junior in that particular department. It is short-sighted to consider only biology when discussing the 'best' age to have children. > A woman waiting til their 30s to have offspring is like an nba player waiting til they are 40 to join the NBA. I don't think the numbers support that conclusion at all. [1]: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr58/nvsr58_17.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr58/nvsr58_17.pdf (table 1, page 14) [2]: https://www.aihw.gov.au/getmedia/a8ff4563-b8f6-43b4-826e-a861522d825a/aihw-per-92.pdf.aspx https://www.aihw.gov.au/getmedia/a8ff4563-b8f6-43b4-826e-a86... (figure 3.1, page 22)
- manfredo 8y agoIs a shrinking population actually bad in the long term? I'm taking on the order of centuries here. While it does introduce the dilemma of reducing spending on the elderly or increasibg taxes to care for the latter aging population, a shrinking population seems like it'd reduce environmental impact and global resource consumption in the long run.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoWhile this may be true, it's not that much of an exaggeration to say that capitalism is a Ponzi scheme. At the very least our current economic system is dependent on continuous growth, including population growth, and when that ends there will be a world of hurt.
- manfredo 8y ago> and when that ends there will be a world of hurt. First world countries' with shrinking populations aren't falling apart. Sure places like Japan, Italy, and Spain have economic troubles associated with a growing retirement population, and shrinking workforce. But they're still pretty good places to live in. While global growth would decline, I'm dubious of the claim that per-capita wealth would go down. With the same pool of resources spread across fewer people, the opposite seems likely. The labor force would reduce in size, too, so manufactured goods and services may not see their prices go down. But things that are zero-sum like natural resources, real-estate, etc. should drop in cost as fewer people are competing for them.
- Gibbon1 8y agoI take the argument that from an economists view point negative population growth is a very bad thing indeed. But from an individuals point of view actually not. Because the economist only cares about total 'GDP' and is absolutely uninterested in quality of life. Because quality of life can't be monetized. From an individuals point of view lower population means fix resources are spread less thinly. There is less competition for jobs so you can command a large share of the pie.
- 21 8y agoBiologically the best age (for a woman) to have a baby is around 19 years old. Sociologically is probably 35+. So there is an unsolvable problem here, you have to compromise one way or the other. https://www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/cusp/201211/whats-the-best-age-have-baby https://www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/cusp/201211/whats-th...
- perl4ever 8y agoOnce I read otherwise, that highest chance of a healthy baby is more like 30ish. Men are biased towards younger women because they don't bear the risks of pregnancy.
- Lordarminius 8y agoAccording to the article you link to : (biologically the best age to have a baby is 19 because the...) "oocytes are fresh and the body’s reproductive and other systems are at a youthful peak" I stopped reading after that. There's no such thing as 'fresh' oocytes. The author is just making stuff for his purpose as he goes along. The ideal age for having kids lies somewhere in the range of late 20's to early 30's. Here both biological and sociological advantages convene.
- redsymbol 8y agoActually, and I didn't read the article, but responding to your last sentence... Apparently the primary oocytes in a female human body are all created before she is born, and available evidence says it's likely no more are produced after that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oogenesis#Oogenesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oogenesis#Oogenesis
- 21 8y agoWell, you are wrong about that. > Mitochondria in oocyte aging: current understanding > The oocyte is the largest cell found in multicellular organisms. Mitochondria, as the energy factories for cells, are found in high numbers in oocytes, as they provide the energy for oocyte maturation, fertilization, and embryo formation via oxidative phosphorylation. Failure of assisted reproduction is mainly attributed to oocyte aging and increased aneuploidy. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5506767/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5506767/
- pesmhey 8y agoIs it a truly a bad thing for teenagers to have children and then remain within their extended families and communities for support? Not forever, of course, but for a handful of years. I'd say that the claim 'teen pregnancy is bad (or not good)' requires a lot of evidence to back it up, rather than taken as a given. This issue probably has very little to do with sperm quality or the availability of abortion, but with our culture in general. The assumption that teen pregnancy = bad, the stigma around it, etc. In your comment, the mentality that life starts later. Like, life starts at birth. I'd imagine that same mentality is responsible for the loneliness epidemic written about in the same places. This idea that life is some achievement to be gained after doing things like going to college. Like, you can't live your life until you've completed some rites of passage, except they get increasingly more detached from reality every decade. And as we read about in the WaPo and other sources, has the college rite of passage really served the amount of people who have gone through it? Student loan debt, bad job prospects, starting life later... Another interesting fact, younger couples have healthier children. Not like, 13 young, but late teens early 20s young. As couples age, the risk of genetic faults and things like autism rise. tldr, it's not sperm count or abortion. Our rites of passage into adulthood suck.
- jurassic 8y agoThere is abundant evidence that teen pregnancy has a severe negative impact on the economic prospects of young women. Many of these women will drop out of high school and almost none will complete college degrees.
- pesmhey 8y agoAnd yet, we’re having a discussion about a fertility crisis. A discussion that is happening in parallel with a discussion about whether or not the benefits of a college education are worth the costs, for either gender. And a political climate where a demagogue rose to power on a promise to return to a time when these weren’t discussions. A general lack of respect for tradesmen and blue collar workers - despite the many benefits they provide to the economy. An epidemic of loneliness, the destruction of communities all across the country. For a great number of people in the US, there’s a longing for a return to traditional values. The answer is somewhere in between both extremes. Not every man or woman need to start life later. Economic outcomes would be a lot better for a lot of people (and the US in aggregate) if that wasn’t the narrative being sold to them. Of course, for a lot of other people, college, and starting life later is absolutely the right answer, economically, socially, etc. I’m not saying that everyone needs to strive for the traditional nuclear family and forego college, I’m saying that there’s an incredible lack of respect for the people that do, much to everyone’s detriment. Does a woman who enjoys the idea of being a mother and a homemaker really need to go to college? Is it ok for women to want to be president, or to bake cookies for their family. It seems like we’ve really told them ‘no, if your goal is to bake cookies and make a warm home, then you’re pretty much a garbage proletarian.’ Disclaimer, I’m a man, talking about what women can or can’t do, so take it with a grain of salt, hopefully a woman can provide a perspective based on experience.
- wycs 8y agoChildren are public goods with massive positive externalities. I think it would be a shame if the population declined. My favourite policy to increase birth rates is to give parents a percentage of their children's income tax revenue. Standard econ says we just need to internalize some of these positive externalities. This has the advantage of scaling with the wealth of the parents, as economic productivity has a significant heritable component. Though this policy triggers an intense moral disgust response in everyone I've proposed it to, so likely not possible unless things get very desperate. But I think it has a chance of working, which is more than I can say of most natalist policies I have seen.
- elektor 8y agoI'm not sure I understand. How would the state calculate a child's future income tax revenue?
- wycs 8y agoYou don't. You wait until they grow up and then you give the parents a commission on their income tax.
- elektor 8y agoThat's certainly an interesting proposal. I voluntarily do this with my parents by helping them out with their living expenses. I imagine this would be difficult to implement with people who have strained relationships with their parents/ step-parents.
- wycs 8y agoI'm not sure if it would be stable or not. After a couple generations I sort of feel it would be, as even if you hate your parents if you have kids you would still benefit from the policy. In fact, if economic growth continues you would benefit more than your parents did. And most people do love their parents.
- toasterlovin 8y ago