13 ms·
As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and blame follow
- sunstone 8y agoChildren are becoming a luxury good in a lot of cities.
- Pulcinella 8y agoSeriously. I wouldnt use the term “luxury good” to describe a child, but having kids is far too expensive. My wife and I want to have more, but we can barely afford one. The hospital bills even with insurance are ridiculous, paid parental leave in this country is practically non-existent, and daycare is expensive (to the point where it is often cheaper to have one parent work and one stay home with the kids than to have both parents work and place the children in daycare). Housing for families is also incredibly expensive and can be hard to find. My city is building apartments like crazy but the vast majority are one and two bedroom luxury apartments, not three or four bedroom units than can accommodate families. Our housing market has also completely rebounded so houses are too expensive.
- prolikewh0a 8y agoThis is the real reason fertility rates are dropping. Children are unaffordable in many places in the country and as work requires more out of all of us with stagnated wages, we don't have the time, money, or required health insurance to participate in raising a child. I'm late 20's and I want a child, but I just can't see myself ever being able to afford one. It's certainly a luxury to responsibly have a child.
- jdhn 8y ago>We don't have the time, money, or required health insurance to participate in raising a child. What would happen if 2 out of 3 of these issues were solved, or at least greatly reduced? In Europe they have much more generous maternal/paternal benefits, as well as universal healthcare. Yet despite this, their birthrates are even lower than ours.
- Pulcinella 8y agoI can’t speak for anyone but ourselves, but we would have more children if we have paid parental leave and universal healthcare (also free college tuition). Financial reasons are why we can’t have more kids.
- burfog 8y agoIt's a value choice you are making, and "financial reasons" probably have little to do with it. The money issue is an excuse. Europe generally has the paid parental leave and universal healthcare. Some parts even have the free college tuition. Where are the kids? People who focus on families don't need paid parental leave. There is a full-time parent permanently at home. Not that everybody needs to go to college, but that is often cheap if you start with a community college AA degree and then transfer to a state school. Most people don't have much of a healthcare problem.
- toasterlovin 8y ago> that is often cheap if you start with a community college AA degree and then transfer to a state school And, you know, make your kids get a fucking job and pay for their own education.
- masklinn 8y ago> This is the real reason fertility rates are dropping. One of them at least, children are also fairly disruptive and a huge responsibility if you assume you're actually becoming responsible for the education and upbringing of a human being. Generally speaking mainland europe has low hospital bills, paid parental leave, subsidised daycare and education, but the fertility rates are still extremely low, and children are still horrendously expensive.
- freeopinion 8y agoYour opinion is almost certainly clouded by your particular circumstances. I will counter it with my own clouded opinion shaped by my particular circumstances. Children are not unaffordable. They require sacrifice. In my culture (within the U.S.) it is common to have 4+ children, often in single-income, middle-class homes. Raising 4-6 children on an income of $60K doesn't attract any attention at all. To read posts like the gp that claim they can't afford a single child seems ridiculous from my perspective. I grant that my perspective is ignorant of their specific circumstances. But my wife and I welcomed our first two children while we were starving college students making < $20K/year. I don't own a Tesla. My children have worked to pay for their college debt free (as did I). I don't have a home in the Hamptons. I don't live in California. I've never been to Europe. My kids haven't gone to Stanford. But I have the most amazing children in the world. I wouldn't trade any of them for a Tesla. Or a MBP. Or equity in whatever startup you are slaving away at. I am glad there is Tesla in the world, and people with MBPs. I don't think my choices are necessarily better than your choices. I don't regret my choices, and I flatly reject most claims by people that they don't have a choice.
- Ancalagon 8y agoYoure mentioning a lot of real luxury goods but these arent the costs OP is referring to I believe. Its more about the necessities in that regard for ensuring their children have a good future: healthcare, private schooling, a college tuition fund, etc. I agree a lot of people in this country spend too much on things they shouldnt, then complain they dont have enough for more of the essentials, but I think in this case the original point is valid: raising children in a metropolitan area is pretty expensive JUST for their necessities.
- freeopinion 8y agoPlease re-read my comment. My children have earned 3+1/2+1/4 college degrees, debt-free. I did not pay for that. They did. I expect at least 2+1/2+3/4 college degrees to follow. They went to public schools (+ 1 private college). They play violin and cello and bass and guitar and percussion and brass. They are insured. They played youth soccer, and high school sports. They have learned foreign languages. They've worked as janitors and at supermarkets and as research assistants. I'm not sure what "necessity" they have not enjoyed. Raising children in metropolitan areas includes raising children in Memphis and Dallas and Boise. It doesn't have to mean San Francisco. And for that matter, who says you have to raise children in a metropolitan area? That is not a necessity. As I wrote before, it doesn't bother me if you choose not to have children, or if you choose to live in San Francisco, or if you choose to raise children in San Francisco. It just bothers me to see the claim that it is impossible to provide the necessities to children today. Children are expensive. No doubt. That is true in NYC or the Himalayas. I believe that to raise a child properly will require sacrifices. That is true for a parent who makes $16K or $16MM. But I reject the claim for the vast majority of people that raising children properly is out of financial reach. When I read that claim from 20-somethings making twice my current salary, I shake my head. I translate that claim to, "I am not willing to give up my current lifestyle to have children." That is a much different statement.
- eaandkw 8y agoI think that this is a false argument. Just look at the poorer nations or even poorer populations. They tend to have plenty of children. Kids are expensive, that is true, but I think that most people arguing that it is too expensive to have children actually mean that they are not willing to change their lifestyle or standard of living to have kids.
- thrav 8y agoI agree. Everyone wants to live a certain kind of lifestyle, and kids aren’t worth the sacrifice for many. Without fail, the people I see having kids are all people who grew up with an economic head start, and further distanced themselves with extremely high paying jobs (private equity, hedge fund, commercial real estate, VC, big tech). I don’t know anyone with kids where the husband is not killing it financially, and they all still complain about having limited money. This is true in the Bay Area, where I live now, and back in Texas (Dallas, Austin, San Antonio), where I’m from.
- sorenn111 8y agoYour story is so anecdotal and influenced by the people you know that it is practically irrelevant. Not trying to jump down your throat, but "people I see" and "I don't know anyone" renders your statement useless.
- kitsunesoba 8y agoWhat if it’s not an unwillingness to sacrifice, but an unwillingness to take on risk and uncertainty that increases with financial success? We now have an entire generation that has been saddled with crippling debt and has been given little to nothing in the way of tools to escape. Many of them saw something similar happen to their own parents, watching them struggle to keep the boat floating as they grew up. Is it really so strange that this group would approach having children with great caution and only commit once they acquire some level of assurance of reliable and reasonably strain-free access to resources? This is especially true for those who’ve “made it” to some extent and have managed to procure freedom from debt — they’re going to do everything in their power to avoid winding up in those circumstances a second time. I don’t know, to me the attitude reads as more calculated and responsible than anything else.
- EduardoBautista 8y agoThen why are children far more common in families with lower incomes?
- prolikewh0a 8y agoThere are plenty of safety nets when you're low income if you take advantage of the available benefits. Your children will be taken care of with medicaid/medicare, you'll receive food stamps, housing assistance. If you're not low income, you're on your own, which can be really tough for people in a middle income range slightly above being able to get those safety nets.
- manfredo 8y agoI think it's because the proportional cost of children actually increases as you move up the income ladder. Probably only starts to reverse once you hit the mid-high hundreds of thousands of dollars. Kids are cheaper for poorer families, because they dedicate less resources towards kids. If someone lives in a place where housing is cheap and don't expect anything beyond public primary and secondary school then another kid only really costs some extra groceries and clothes. By comparison if someone expects to give their kid a private education, subsidize their college education, and afford to house them comfortably in an expensive neighborhood, then kids can be incredibly expensive. Lower income people often trend towards the former, higher income people towards the latter. Of course there are exceptions - some lower income people dedicate great resources towards their kids, some wealthier families don't.
- masklinn 8y ago> I think it's because the proportional cost of children actually increases as you move up the income ladder. The opportunity cost as well. Having and raising a child means there are things you can't do because you have to raise/take care of the child. > If someone lives in a place where housing is cheap and don't expect anything beyond public primary and secondary school then another kid only really costs some extra groceries and clothes. At the end of the day, even for people with low COL raising a child to adulthood is still on the order of tens of thousands of dollars. Planning might also be a factor there, it's likely more present higher up the income ladder, meaning the wealthier segments see the kind of costs associated middle/long term and go "maybe not yet".
- itry2develop 8y agoSoy...
- rabboRubble 8y agoI met super conservative friends of my parents the other day. They blamed the falling fertility rates on narcissism and social media. I'm like uh.... what about cost of living outpacing salaries? Cost of medical care? Education debt? All the young people I know aren't avoiding pregnancy because of their social media engagement, they are however wondering out loud in conversations with me if they can afford children.
- RodericDay 8y agoall of that + global warming and ecological devastation
- esoterica 8y agoAnd yet poor households have more kids than wealthy ones.
- rabboRubble 8y agoI bet the poor households are using Facebook just as much as the richer households. Whatever the root causes are, I seriously doubt social media the single most important cause.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- arenaninja 8y agoYep... medical care and child care are expensive. Not to mention my employer-provided insurance has ridiculous co-payment, co-insurance and deductible limits
- thrden 8y agoSocialized Medicine and Education are often discussed in this context. However, if we look at Europe where student debt is minimal, and medicine is provided by the state fertility rates are even lower.
- 0942v8653 8y agoAlthough social media might be the wrong thing to take aim at, I would argue that rising expectations for standard of living definitely have helped to reduce the amount of (relatively, but not ridiculously, wealthy) couples who wish to have kids. Narcissism tends to drive the expected standard of living, whether exploited through advertisements or broadcast through social media itself.
- techrich 8y agoPeople are getting dogs instead.
- eip 8y agoLooks like the vaccine for Human Population Virus is working.
- dang 8y agoWe've banned this account for posting unsubstantive comments and ignoring our requests to stop.
- dragontamer 8y ago>The University of Pennsylvania’s Hans-Peter Kohler, who studies fertility and birthrates, said the data indicated that many shifts affecting fertility are occurring “in the transition to adulthood.” The biggest recent drops in birthrate have been among teenagers as well as people in their 20s. In 2016, the teen birthrate hit at an all-time low after peaking in 1991. This... doesn't sound like bad news to me? It seems like the #1 "issue" is that teenagers have stopped having kids. That's a good thing, is it not? Young 20-year-olds not having kids could be easily explained with the higher amount of people going to college, and starting life later. If the 25+ age group has stopped having kids, that'd be a bad thing for sure. I guess its important to keep the overall fertility rate in mind for future economic reasons, but a severe decrease in teenage pregnancy seems like a good thing overall... even if it may cause an economic issue in the future.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoDepends on your culture of course. Teens get pregnant so readily because they're designed that way. The US obsession with avoiding teen pregnancy causes problems of its own I'm sure.
- manfredo 8y agoI'm not sure I follow. A piece of plastic, or a pill is all it takes for teens to explore their sexuality without getting pregnant.
- rocketpastsix 8y agoAre you American? If not, its easy to see why it seems like common sense like this would work. But in America, especially the Southeast, those are taboo things.
- Thiez 8y agoThe shape of the human penis is 'designed' to scoop out the sperm that competing males may have recently left, but I rarely hear arguments that monogamy is unnatural and 'going to cause problems of its own'. I don't find the appeal to biology and 'design' particularly convincing. Perhaps you could give some examples of the problems you foresee, while keeping in mind than avoiding teen pregnancy is not the same as delaying having children until the age of 45?
- TimJYoung 8y agoI'm not sure that this is such a bad thing, given that more and more people are working non-physical jobs and can continue to do so as they get older. Personally, I have no problem with anyone that worked physical labor their whole life retiring earlier with benefits while I continue to work. I like my work, and it's been a pretty easy life, comparatively.
- jmpman 8y agoI would have had more children if childcare was more heavily subsidized. Make it a tax deduction up to a fraction of the amount you pay in taxes to keep it from incentivizing those without financial means to have children.
- scottwernervt 8y agoIf there was a tax credit for day care wouldn't the day care companies just increase prices to make more profit?
- laaph 8y agoI found this article written oddly, as if it were a phenomena that is only affecting the US. Fertility rates have been collapsing world-wide, ever since the 90s if not longer. Yet this article doesn't mention that Europe has had below replacement rates since the 90s, and the rest of the world is having significantly less children per woman than it did back then too. For each of the specific things it suggests it might be, it would have to be something that is affecting the whole world, maybe at different rates around the world but the whole world nonetheless. Hans Rosling in one of his videos said we see the birth rate drop when women are educated and have economic opportunities outside the house.
- jnmd 8y agoI found one of the comments very thought provoking: "The declining total fertility rates are children not born in the moment, but the hope is that they are delayed, not forgone". I hadn't considered it before, but a gradual change in what age people choose to have children would show up as a temporary drop in fertility (for an easy example, think about everyone delaying their next child for five years). A quick google search show's a strong correlation between steeply increasing age of first child and low apparent birth rates. In particular, US fertility rates were even lower in the 1970's, another time when age of first child was increasing rapidly. Back of the napkin math shows that we'd see (very roughly) 80% of true fertility if not adjusted for, making the true fertility rate slightly above replacement levels (about 2.2)
- toasterlovin 8y agoYeah, but women can’t delay forever and previous generations have already pushed age of first child back way past where it once was. Anecdotally, I look at my Facebook and there are a lot of women on there who will really have to kick things into high gear ASAP to hit two children (since they’re all in their mid 30s and childless).
- dawhizkid 8y agoThe idea that you can have a kid in college in your mid 30s is pretty fascinating. Maybe sociologically it is not easy or ideal to have kids very young but being relatively young while your kids are grown is better than being old.
- anon4738383 8y agoStart paying people like Italy and elsewhere to have kids in order to boost taxes.
- fallingfrog 8y agoDaycare is 300 dollars a week, everybody's got a massive mortgage payment, not to mention the college loans.. why would you expect a lot of babies being born? Of course the fertility rate is falling. Society puts all its greatest costs squarely on young people of child rearing age. I mean, duh. Edit: originally said 160 not 300, was incorrect
- pcmoney 8y ago$160 a week?! ROFL. Try $450/wk for full time day care. This is in a non-coastal, non-major city for standard licensed day care, not Montessori or high end. Standard rate in the town I live in, could maybe save $50/month if I doubled my commute. Waitlist for daycare? 8months+. We enrolled shortly after we conceived.
- fallingfrog 8y agoI feel for you! Good luck! We do have it easy compared with many folks. We do have the same kind of waitlist though, in fact it's more than a year in many places. I always wonder, now if it takes 9 months to make a baby, and the waitlist is a year, then someone out there has way better planning skills than I'll ever have. Edit: just checked.. ha! We're paying 300 not 160.
- Tycho 8y agoThat's like 20k a year. So you'd need something like a 30k salary (before tax) just to break even. How much income would you be foregoing if one parent just stayed at home?
- christinamltn 8y agoI've known people who chose to work even though most of their income was going to daycare, commuting costs, etc. The argument was that in 3-5 years when the kids are in school they'd be another rank or 2 up the ladder and their net earnings over that decade would be higher overall. If they took the time off then they'd probably be returning to work a rank or two below where they left. It's also insurance that you'll be able to support yourself if something happens to your partner or you split up.
- esotericn 8y agoThe 'large metro area' drop is completely unsurprising to me as someone living in London. Working young people are looking at the "will I ever be able to afford to live in a house" problem. It is not at all uncommon for a 30 year old to be living with random individuals. Child rearing? You may as well ask a starving man his opinion on gluten free bread.
- wilde 8y agoMore people are renting. Rents are going up. When rents go up, fertility goes down. This is not a mystery. https://www.nber.org/papers/w17485 https://www.nber.org/papers/w17485
- csense 8y agoIf Congress wants people to have more kids, can't the government just pay people for each child they have, via a tax credit or direct payment?
- chriscappuccio 8y agothey....do??
- SwiftX 8y agoMaybe it's just all the Maga Hats causing women to be less interested in procreating?
- Justsignedup 8y agoI feel the answer might be simple actually. As contraceptives becomes well understood and taught kids are opting to have a better quality of life and not reproduce. They put it off so they can build a career. When they build a career they get used to a certain quality of life. And so by mid thirties they don't want to have 3 kids. Of course they delay having kids till they are financially stable enough to have kids and not worry about money and hardship. Because who wants to voluntarily go through extreme hardship. And so as cost goes up and pay goes down with available contraceptives people are just not having kids until they have the financial stability which many might not have.