16 ms·
Why I’m Worried About Google
- orf 8y agoFirefox.
- demxzy 8y agoFirefox is looking more like a very good insurance policy going forward privacy-wise. I would like to see more open source browsers though. It feels like we are getting nearer and nearer to browser mono cultures with all the chromium clones. Maybe Ms can release edge as an opensource app with it being far behind in adoption.
- Klathmon 8y agoI believe the Edge team is actively working on open sourcing the whole browser. They have already open-sourced the JS engine behind it [0], and they worked on some integrations with other things (IIRC there was an experiment with node using the chakra engine instead of V8). I'm with you though, I really hope this opens back up into an all out competition between 3 or more big players. And I think firefox is in a great position to take up the "top" spot in terms of security, performance, and resource usage. They have been "paying their dues" for a while now working on that stuff, and it's starting to pay off. And if they gambled right, they might just have an architecture that is overall better than Chrome's, who will be stuck with the cruft they've slowly built up over the years. [0] https://github.com/Microsoft/ChakraCore https://github.com/Microsoft/ChakraCore
- stochastic_monk 8y agoI’m seeing more webpages entirely break on Firefox recently. I tend to reach for Vivaldi when I need to try a different browser, as it’s Chromium without all the tracking.
- mattnumbers 8y agoYes, on newer versions, this can happen when Tracking Protection is enabled. This feature causes things like CAPTCHA and other third-party scripts to break. When this occurs, look for a shield icon in the URL bar to the left of the green TLS padlock. Click it and disable Tracking Protection. This has fixed every site issue I've seen so far.
- GnwbZHiU 8y agoThere's also Brave browser by Brendan Eich. It's still very young and have issues, but it's getting better over time.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rolandog 8y agoI've enjoyed using the Brave browser so far (less than a week). I'm excited to try out the BAT payments feature! For those out of the loop, like I was a week ago, it's a way to pay what you want per month, divided proportionally by the time spent per site between the sites you visited, as a way of trying to compensate the publishers and creators for your ad blocking. You use a crypto currency called Basic Attention Token (BAT). If anyone has any questions about the setup process, I'd be happy to help. As a side note: I live in Mexico, but I was happy to be able to fund a wallet and not be region-blocked for once.
- tannhaeuser 8y agoBefore using Brave, you should consider if you value their business model as ethical (I don't). What they do is filter-out ads and replace them with ads of their customers.
- user812 8y agoNo they filter out ads. Then they give everyone the opportunity to use a Patreon-Style support or view Ads, optionally. Why isn't it ethical to target big Ad-Tech middle men like Google and Facebook and increase efficiency and privacy at the same time?
- lern_too_spel 8y agoThe publishers didn't agree to it. Brave is not allowed to unilaterally dictate terms. If I'm going to steal from publishers, nobody should benefit, especially not some smarmy browser vendor. Similarly, if I'm going to pirate, I'm not going to pay some piracy middleman who makes up some cryptocurrency to send to the content creators. Of Firefox, Chrome, and Brave; Brave is by far the worst browser of the bunch. It's not even pretending not to be evil, let alone trying and failing like the others.
- sinaz 8y agoWhich has a few privacy scandals of its own. Marginally better than Chrome, not a silver bullet.
- matthewmacleod 8y agoMarginally better than Chrome That's a gross misrepresentation.
- sinaz 8y agoWell... regarding what Mozilla did with Cliqz, I'm sure Google won't be sending my user data to third parties, which Mozilla did. So maybe Chrome is better than Firefox in that regard.
- icebraining 8y agoGoogle does send your user data to third-parties, for "external processing" (it's in their privacy policy).
- lallysingh 8y agoDo you mean this https://www.zdnet.com/article/firefox-tests-cliqz-engine-which-slurps-user-browsing-data/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/firefox-tests-cliqz-engine-whi... ? Mozilla was an investor in Cliqz, so it's not precisely a full-on third party. And the data was (at least, according to the article) well anonymized. I can see why Moz would want to try and keep up with the user advantages of collecting this information -- catching malicious URLs, etc -- but even if it's just appearance-wise, they've lost a bit of trust here. Frankly I think they should have two distributions of Firefox, one that's bells-and-whistles for the best user experience, and another that takes a more aggressive pro-privacy stance. This can be little more than the set of preinstalled extensions + default config.
- sciurus 8y agoTo an extent Mozilla has that now on mobile with Firefox vs Firefox Focus. https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/mobile/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/mobile/
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- navidfarhadi 8y agoI’m a fan of Firefox and I use it when I am docked at home or near a power outlet but the battery life hit is enormous on Mac OS compared to Chrome and Safari. The performance is fine, I just wish I had better battery life when using Firefox on the go.
- ealhad 8y agoYeah, last time I tried Firefox on Mac OS it was terrible. On my laptop, running GNU/Linux (with lower specs), it's way faster.
- minitech 8y agoExactly! I was confused for a long time about the slowness people kept talking about with Firefox, and then work switched to MacBooks. Firefox is faster and more capable on my cheap Linux device than any browser on the Mac, but on the Mac, Firefox is slowest. So strange.
- driverdan 8y agoWhen was the last time you tried it? It's still not as fast as on Windows or Linux but it's much better than it used to be.
- ealhad 8y agoThe point is, performance-wise, it's not the best choice on Mac OS. Not that I care much, I rarely dwell on Apple computers.
- FerretFred 8y agoI used to run Lynx, but now I've upgraded to xlinks2 and can see images on pages too! ;-) edit: except when they're in a sprite :/
- phakding 8y agoWhat is Google's end goal here? More accurate targetted advertising?
- tyingq 8y agoAnything that maintains the double digit year-over-year percentage gains in revenue that they've enjoyed for years. Their revenue growth has outpaced user/activity growth for some time.
- ataturk 8y agoMy guess? An unholy alliance between government and private industry which allows each to get away with things the other can't. For example, squelching free speech can be done by a private company with practically no impediments. Meanwhile, governments want to eavesdrop on everyone and develop dossiers on everyone because that's how you control people. Corporations are doing that for marketing purposes, but the intelligence agencies are right there in that data now, too. Google always had a CIA connection. You do the math on how this works and what it means now that you can see it all unfolding like everyone else can. They want total control over your mind and barring that, they want total control over your behavior one way or another. What can't corporations do? They can't force people to buy their products or pay their bills. Governments can, though. It's actually the only tool in the box. Corporations would love to gather and coalesce the information and then have the jackboots do the violent stuff to suppress and subjugate. The very definition of fascism.
- lallysingh 8y agoWhat CIA connection?
- 908087 8y agohttps://medium.com/insurge-intelligence/how-the-cia-made-google-e836451a959e https://medium.com/insurge-intelligence/how-the-cia-made-goo... https://pando.com/2015/07/01/cia-foia-google-keyhole/ https://pando.com/2015/07/01/cia-foia-google-keyhole/ Search "In-Q-Tel Google" for more.
- robin_reala 8y agoIt’s the closing paragraph that’s the important bit: In the end, this is why I’m moving away from the Google ecosystem. If nothing else works, then at least I can vote with my feet—or my fingertips. Google have set their path, so it will take effort for them to deviate from it. The best way to show them that the effort is worthwhile is to affect their bottom line by reducing your use of their services. And maybe you’ll find that the competitors are still there and pretty good.
- CaptainZapp 8y agoFirefox is fine and DuckDuckGo is good enough by now. Firefox has the added bonus that it doesn't implement a two tier cookie system. Of which one tier cannot be deleted. This, in combination with the new and improved "sign-in-convenience" convinced me that Google is exactly as dirty as any other tech company and should be avoided like the plague, wherever possible.
- bla2 8y agoDuckDuckGo is mostly a skin on Bing search results. By using it, you're saying you trust Microsoft more than Google. If that's your intent, cool, but you're not really getting away from the big tech companies by doing this.
- stephengillie 8y agoWhere is the open source internet search platform?
- antidesitter 8y agoThere’s an open source P2P-based distributed search engine called YaCy.
- clear_dg 8y agoCheck searx https://asciimoo.github.io/searx/ https://asciimoo.github.io/searx/
- janpot 8y agoThis bothers me a little bit > By clicking “Agree,” you consent to Slate’s Terms of Service and Privacy Policy and the use of technologies such as cookies by Slate and our partners to deliver relevant advertising on our site, in emails and across the Internet, to personalize content and perform site analytics. Please see our Privacy Policy for more information about our use of data, your rights, and how to withdraw consent. I need to consent to have your website show me "relevant advertising across the Internet". If you can't take my privacy seriously, how should I take your concerns about Google and privacy seriously?
- simion314 8y agoSame here, so I always close the tab.
- Flow 8y agoProbably it's too late. Or do they really load the scripts from Google et al after you click "Accept"?
- davb 8y agoSurprisingly, before you click Agree they make no third party requests and only set one cookie (AB=1, presumably because I'm using an ad blocker) and one Session Storage value (slateFontsLoaded=true). Unlike Samsonite, who I recently discovered set large number of cookies and make a bunch of third party requests before you click on Agree.
- tyingq 8y agoIt is funny that they load Google Analytics and Doubleclick. There's also trackers for Comscore and Amazon on the page.
- ericintheloft2 8y agoSame here. I just spend 3 minutes trying to figure out how to opt out, but couldn't find it in the walls of texts and links down the rabbit hole. Closed the tab.
- mxuribe 8y agoI have already begun to vote (against Google) with my feet/fingertips. I realize that even if I use non-Google products/services - much like the Kevin Bacon game - I'm only so many degrees away. But still, I feel i have at least a little more agency over my data. If I do this (move away from google), and then another person does this, and then another...eventually if many more do this, there could be a dent; which would hopefully more positively influence google (AND others like google); in essence manually move Adam smith's supposed invisible hand.
- decasteve 8y agoI wonder if, in a couple of generations from now, we’ll be browsing private messages, emails, browsing history, etc—all the “private” details that Google et al, have amassed—much in the same way the Stasi files are available now.
- GreeniFi 8y agoI think it’s probably possible to model credit-worthiness according to search history and site use patterns. Google’s partnership with Mastercard could be something to do with that. What would be particularly irritating is if Google start showing credit offers next to product ads. Eg you look at an advert for a new iPhone and google then lets you know Mastercard will give you an immediate credit line for an impulse purchase. Marketing strategy is obviously focused on overcoming your will power to buy things you want but don’t need. One of our last lines of defence is: I can’t afford that right now...Mastercard and by axiom Google profit when you don’t think like that.
- lallysingh 8y agoIt'd probably be a massive overfit to race and age. In comparison, everything else would be unbiased noise.
- GreeniFi 8y agoMy guess is that Google, like Facebook, have a good impression of your CANOE/Big 5 personality type: Conscientiousness, Agreeableness, Neuroticism, Openness, Extroversion. And in that they have an extremely good assessment of your likelihood to repay loans.
- lallysingh 8y agoHow does browsing/purchasing history tell you about those?
- GreeniFi 8y agoI understand that this has been at the heart of the Cambridge Analytica political manipulation scandal. The basic methodology is take a large sample of people whose big 5 traits you know, and look at their browsing history. Through this you create a model: people visiting x websites are statistically more likely to be y personality. Then when they look at your patterns of web use, they are able to assign you a personality type. Or more specifically group you with others likely to be of that personality type. Of course this assignment may be incorrect, but of course over a large number of people using this methodology, they are more likely to be right than wrong across most people. And although I’m not a statistician, this is the power of big data.
- bnt 8y agoTo me it sounds like we need a Libre Office of Google Docs (web based). Everyone is worried about tracking and privacy, but what about the productivity tools? If you quit Google, you also abandon the GSuite - which is quite nice.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoI use Sandstorm.io which has most of the features of Google Docs/Sheets and then some. But there are plenty of other open source alternatives as well. Look at Nextcloud and Cloudron as other options.
- detaro 8y agoThere is an online office suite based on Libre Office. https://www.collaboraoffice.com/collabora-online/ https://www.collaboraoffice.com/collabora-online/
- bryanlarsen 8y agoGoogle always knew that trust was very important to their long term growth and viability. It's why "Don't be evil" was their motto for so long and it actually appeared to be more than lip service. That motto is gone, and now they're actively monetizing that accumulated goodwill.
- Hikikomori 8y agoIt's still in their code of conduct.
- ckastner 8y agoAs a non-native speaker, I would have expected the title to be "Why Google Worries Me". "Worried About" sounds like it's Google who's being negatively affected by this, but that doesn't seem to be the main point of the story. Is this a common pattern?
- Stratoscope 8y agoYour wording is certainly better than the ambiguous article title. I would write it your way too. "I'm worried about X" usually means that I'm concerned for X's welfare, but not always. It takes some context to disambiguate the phrase. A couple of examples: "I'm worried about that stray kitten." "I'm worried about the lion perched in that tree." They are both felines, but clearly in one case I'm concerned about the cat's safety, in the other case what the cat might do to me.
- lovich 8y agoCommonish I guess, it's not something I havent seen before. I dont know how often I see the pattern but it is ambiguous as both interpretations of meaning are valid
- woodrowbarlow 8y agoyes, it's a common pattern in colloquial american english. "worried about" can mean either "concerned by" (as the article uses it) or "concerned about" (as you interpreted it).
- humanrebar 8y agoBoth are fine. Try reading it this way: [Why] [I'm worried] [about Google].
- Dirlewanger 8y agoYours is the more succinct way of saying it. Remember that all these modern blogs usually aren't written by (or edited by for that matter) professionals of any kind, so the grammar/sentence structure will suffer at the expense of pumping out articles fast and getting clicks.
- bla2 8y ago> But it brings users within an accidental click of sharing their bookmarks and browsing history with Google. It's two clicks, you need to be really explicit about it. The first click opens a huge "You're about to turn on sync" dialog, where you have to click "Yes, I'm in" again. I don't disagree with the general sentiment, but the article isn't factually correct. It's also by the same person who misunderstood the recent chrome changes and wrote a long blog post triggered by them misunderstanding what was going on (https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/gyny83/google-chrome-sync-privacy https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/gyny83/google-chr...).
- matthewdgreen 8y agoCould you tell me what claims in my post were incorrect? So far nobody at Google has disputed them, just pointed out that they don’t activate sync (which my blog post already stipulates.)
- bla2 8y ago"Google developers claim this will not actually start synchronizing your data to Google — yet" It sounds like you got up in arms because you thought that chrome now auto-syncs when you sign in to gmail, and wrote the blog post draft. Then you learned that this isn't the case but you kept your arms up anyway, added that unsubstantiated "- yet" and hit "publish" anyway, despite nothing really having changed. (Disclaimer 1: I used to work for google, so I'm likely biased to give them more benefit of doubt. Disclaimer 2: This is a shared HN account (the password isn't exactly hard to guess), so not all of its comments or posts are written by me.)
- matthewdgreen 8y agoIf you look up my Twitter account, you’ll see that I had a long discussion with multiple Chrome engineers days prior to writing the post, and there they explained the sync distinction to me. The post clearly explains the situation (mandatory login, but not sync) and articulates several reasons why I think it’s still an issue even if Google doesn’t auto-synchronize — a guarantee I don’t feel confident relying on in the future. In those various Twitter threads I also identified several problems with the Chrome privacy policy, which Google had to quickly update on a Sunday as a result. https://twitter.com/matthew_d_green/status/1043331229326749697?s=20 https://twitter.com/matthew_d_green/status/10433312293267496...
- Spartan-S63 8y agoWith all of these emerging privacy concerns, it reinforces my choice to move away from the Android and Google ecosystem insofar as I can. It reinforces my choice to embrace the Apple ecosystem. While their products aren't perfect, they do take your privacy seriously and you do pay for it. But to me, that seems like a fair trade. Additionally, they have second to none customer support, so it's going to take a company providing the same level of support (3-5 business day repairs on laptops) for me to move away from Apple.
- Ma8ee 8y agoIt’s about time that we learn that there’s no free lunch. We either pay with our privacy, our attention, or with money. I prefer to pay with money.
- tango12 8y agoTrue. Unfortunately, the rest of the world that cannot afford products from the apple ecosystem will continue to suffer and they are probably highest at risk of being exploited in ways they can't fathom. Not sure if/how there's a way for privacy ethics to win over economics/convenience.
- pjmlp 8y agoUnfortunately security seems to be a problem only solvable with first world salaries it seems. I really doubt most people earning 500 euros or less would think on the benefit of Apple's privacy when looking at their price ranges, many times just mapped directly from dollars into local currencies.
- qubax 8y agoEvery post about google, facebook or privacy, there is a PR comment about Apple. Apple doesn't care about privacy any more than google believed in "do no evil". They collect data on you just like google does. They buy data from other vendors like google does. They sell data on you. The idea that a company who gives data to the chinese government cares about privacy is laughable. http://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-apple-china-20160226-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-apple-china... You shouldn't confine yourself to an "ecosystem" controlled by one company. Be that google or apple.
- ekzy 8y agoI've switched to Safari and DuckDuckGo last week. I can still search on google with the DuckDuckGo shortcut !g when the duck doesn't quack. I tried Firefox but it became too slow. Safari is actually pretty good, for me the main problem is that it reduced my productivity for web development (I need to get used to the safari devtools) and the lack of some browser extensions (redux devtools etc). For now, I keep switching back to chrome for web development.
- kvz 8y agoDid you try FF recently? It feels as fast as Chrome for me these days! devtools are good and transition was surprisingly frictionless. Bonus: I’m trying Linux and it works/syncs my stuff across Mac/iOS/Ubuntu.
- ekzy 8y agoI am on mac, I used FF when they announced their performance improvement last year [1], and it felt fast at the beginning but then it started to get slower. I can't explain why as it was a while ago and I did not look much into it [1] https://hacks.mozilla.org/2017/11/entering-the-quantum-era-how-firefox-got-fast-again-and-where-its-going-to-get-faster/ https://hacks.mozilla.org/2017/11/entering-the-quantum-era-h...
- isoskeles 8y agoSame here. The way I noticed the slowness was that I am used to opening up a new tab and immediately typing in my url or search. Whatever speed comes naturally to me, Chrome can handle it. Firefox would lag in ways that resulted in half of what I typed being cut off and other odd behavior. I am positive that Firefox is (or was, when I tried it last year) slower than Chrome in this regard, which was incredibly frustrating and caused me to switch back to Chrome within a week.
- kbrosnan 8y agoThere are a couple fixes in 63 beta specifically about OS X performance. https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/63.0beta/releasenotes/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/63.0beta/releasenotes/ > On macOS, WebGL power preferences allow non-performance-critical applications and applets to request the low-power GPU instead of the high-power GPU in multi-GPU systems - https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1349799 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1349799 > Faster tab switching in the majority of cases for our macOS users - https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1481519 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1481519 > Improved the reactivity of Firefox on macOS - https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1265824 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1265824
- pm90 8y agoThe default on is a favorite ad-tech strategy; its how a lot of websites gather customer data, since most users couldn't care less that they're always signed in, always sending browsing/tracking data to other parties. There is little regulation in online advertising; GDPR helped a lot but most ad revenues are still generated in the US. I have a feeling that some regulation would go a long way in improving the online browsing experience and prevent incidents like this, which can get tiring: every time a trusted internet company makes a privacy "error", everyone is outraged, we shame the company to getting better yadda yadda.
- fluidcruft 8y agoI don't think anything's actually changed in terms of how you can be tracked, it's just being made obvious to you. If you don't want your browsing linked to your gmail, use different profiles or use a private browsing window.
- amelius 8y ago> If you don't want your browsing linked to your gmail, use different profiles or use a private browsing window. It still requires a mental effort to make sure your information is not linked. One small mistake (e.g. visit site in wrong browser window) and all your previous effort is wasted. Therefore, we need not only technical solutions. We need companies to change. Perhaps by an update of the law (GDPR for US), and if this doesn't work then perhaps we should even consider a ban on personalized advertising to make sure that these companies have no incentive to trick the user into disclosing personal information.
- post_break 8y agoI'm trying so hard to move my email away from Gmail. I have a paid proton account by the syncing for desktop and the mobile app is terrible. Are there any other options out there? I switched to Firefox and I love it so far.
- corobo 8y agoIt gets thrown around a lot and in my opinion for good reason - I've switched to Fastmail[1] myself. I've got the $5/mo account because I wanted to bring my own domains. Had it for a while just forwarding everything to my gmail but have now cut the forwarding and switched fully. If you're in the Apple ecosystem the app I attribute to finally moving was Spark[2], which I discovered after Google announced it was killing off Inbox [1] https://www.fastmail.com/ https://www.fastmail.com/ [2] https://sparkmailapp.com/ https://sparkmailapp.com/
- post_break 8y agoThank you I will check it out.
- jtmarl1n 8y agoDoesn't spark scan your email box like GMail used to? I haven't found anything recent stating they have stopped that practice.
- ascagnel_ 8y agoThey do (it's why I've stopped using it). If you're in the iOS/macOS ecosystem, Airmail is a good option.
- corobo 8y agoWhat does that mean? I imagine it has to scan my email if it's to provide the search functionality. If you're hinting at something more untoward could you spell it out for me, I can't find anything that painted it with an ugly brush
- observr9 8y agoFirefox doesn't highlight find-in-page search results on the scroll bar. Chrome does. Am I the only person who relies on that feature daily for their work?
- taeric 8y agoWhat is the daily use case? Sounds useful, but daily?
- observr9 8y agoBrowsing a large code repository. The scrollbar highlights allow me to "eyeball" the page and go to the general locations quickly rather than hitting Next a thousand times (which feels primitive as hell anyway), especially when a block of code has the same keyword used many times and I need to move on to the next block. I tried Firefox for a while but I rely on that feature around once or twice a day and I preferred using Chrome for those browsing sessions. So I dumped Firefox and switched back.
- taeric 8y agoAh, I think I just avoid using a browser to browse a code repository. Swiper/helm in emacs are far superior for searching a repository. Unless I am looking at more than what I can checkout locally... which, I typically don't need to do.
- ktosobcy 8y agoFor me, highlighting all occurrences and ctrl/cmd+g (next) is enough. Jetbrains idea does the highlight in scrollbar but I don't find it useful.
- observr9 8y agoIf a method is used several times at the top of the page, and you want to find out if it's used elsewhere, without the highlights, you don't know that. You have to hit Next until you make sure it's nowhere else. With the highlights, you immediately see that the block you're looking at is it, and you can move on to a different file.
- ngngngng 8y agoI really want to get away from using a pixel (or Android) phone, but an equivalent iPhone costs literally twice as much. Is it worth it for privacy alone?
- bromuro 8y agoit is worth for all the rest :)
- TrueGeek 8y agoJust buy used. My iPhone 7S Plus is great and a third the price of an iPhone X. I switched from Android after the Nexus 5X and have really enjoyed it. SOOO many iPhone users buy the latest phone every single year that eBay is flooded with used phones in perfect condition.
- rhexs 8y agoI suppose that depends on how much 400-500$ is worth to you. I'd pay 500$ to not have a mobile tracking device developed by an advertising company on me at all times, but I have that luxury from working in tech.
- oh_hello 8y agoI don't think this cost comparison is true if you look at the older generation iPhones still for sale. Yes, a Xs is extremely expensive, but choosing a 7 or 8 drops the price significantly and these older models still hold up well.
- newsoundwave 8y agoMaybe not relevant to you, but my Pixel 2 XL was already $900-ish, so switching this year to the iPhone XS wasn't a big deal. I will say a brand new iPhone 8 is also currently $599 (and the 7s is even cheaper) and will likely get updates for the next 4 years or so. I've used Android since the original Android phone (T-Mobile G1/HTC Dream). It felt hypocritical, however, to have switched away from most of Google in my personal life and still give them access to me through my phone. I dislike Apple for many reasons, but I'd much rather deal with those issues than continue to use Google.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoDo you think we’ll ever move away from search engines entirely? What’s stopping us from using alternative means of searching and what would these look like?
- ThirdFoundation 8y agoI don't have an answer, but I have trouble picturing a better option that's both egalitarian and actually gives the best search results. The closest thing I can think of almost feels regressive -- sites like HackerNews and Reddit. What I mean is asking a question there or searching for threads where other users have asked a similar question. Often the links provided in those threads are less likely to be provided by advertisers and actually just promoted by users. That's often where I find the best answers for things. But to access those threads I still use Google or DDG because the Reddit search function is terrible. Other options, like AOL Keywords (if you remember those) basically just directly link to paid providers. I guess it's possible that there is a fair and balanced web crawler, but to give true freedom and not guide the user to specific the best option still seems to be a search engine. Maybe the answer isn't alternative forms of searching but rather alternative ways to show the results? Right now they look like a ranking list. Maybe they could be displayed in a map or another form?
- MusaTheRedGuard 8y agoThis honestly makes me sad. I really did think google was different
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- olivermarks 8y agoChrome turns on the fans on my old macbook air which is an audio reminder to only use it occasionally for specific tasks. My paranoid side makes me wonder if all the fan activity is because it's so busy phoning home all the time 'sharing data'?
- olivermarks 8y agoMy comment was tongue in cheek. I do feel Chrome is v bloated these days though. Opera and Brave seem to run much more cleanly and faster
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- CosmicBagel 8y agoFor some reason this was also a breaking point for me. I've switched to Firefox and Duck Duck Go. It's a small thing, but boy do you start to feel like a second rate citizen fast. The state of extensions on Firefox is a mess. I can get the usual privacy extensions easily enough, but things like using media keys to control videos playing in the back ground. Or how in the phone app of Firefox you need to pull up the side menu to refresh instead of just pulling the page down. It's all small stuff, but it adds up. But despite this, and the lower quality search results of DDG, I'm still going to push forward with degooglifying my stuff. But I'm in deep. Drive, keep, Gmail, photos, hell I'm even typing this on a pixel 2. It's gonna take a while. It's been surprisingly difficult finding a good replacement for keep. If anyone has suggestions I'm open. I'll probably make the shift to protonmail to replace Gmail. Not sure what do to about drive at this time. The issue is that Google's stuff has always been very reliable and performance (well performant enough). For example I'll often ping Google.com for a network test. Google.com is never down, it's always my hardware, or my ISP, never Google. Im just rambling at this point, but I think somewhere in there is a point about reliability, ease of use, and security that makes Google's products so compelling. Hence why they'll be able to get away with privacy issues like this.
- fokinsean 8y agoI'm in fairly deep too, ~3 years of photos in their service. As convenient it is to do search and essentially having a "free" backup, I really need to move off. I'm not worried about moving mail since it's more of an iterative process, but moving photos is going to be a pita.
- thinkmassive 8y agohttps://takeout.google.com/settings/takeout https://takeout.google.com/settings/takeout
- colecut 8y agoNextcloud made it pretty easy to get away from Google Drive and Keep. I really like using QOwnNotes to manage my markdown files which are synced to nextcloud.
- nicodjimenez 8y agoGoogle is a brilliant company but ad based business models have weird incentive structures. When your primary customer isn't actually using your product it makes product decisions harder. I don't think Google means harm but it does seem like they are making some questionable decisions. Zuck was smart to remove ads on FB even though it cost FB lots of ad revenue. Their web browser change had no obvious benefit for users compare to how creepy it is to have gmail forced on you by the web browser. they might have some hidden strategy that will eventually benefit chrome users but it's not clear what that is
- kangus 8y agoI still see advertisements on Facebook. Even more so, in fact. They now have ads that will cut in while you're watching a video.
- wlll 8y agoI can't read the article becaue their GDPR opt out is (perhaps deliberately) broken, is there a summary?
- foolzcrow 8y agoIt's much much worse than that. They are still tracking you even when you opt out. And there is increasing evidence their search product is filtered based on their political beliefs. So it's not showing you the actual internet anymore and it spies constantly.
- kbos87 8y agoThe fact that they added a setting means nothing. Settings in Chrome seem to randomly (but maybe not randomly?) get rolled back from time to time. Are you going to check the setting every day?
- known 8y agoI think Firefox should rollout its own search engine
- phmagic 8y agoGoogle is a for-profit enterprise. Currently the company has optimized its products for what users want: reliability, security, ease of use. The (sad) fact is that users tend to undervalue their own privacy and data because a single person's data is not very valuable. They don't see the power of aggregate data. The title is a little misleading because it's not Google who choosing this balance between privacy and convenience. We, the users, are making this choice. This is what concerns me. If users choose privacy over convenience, Google would happily oblige. I'm confident of this seeing the way that the "organic" movement has taken hold.
- casper345 8y agoI have an understanding on both sides. To keep our privacy is something we initially feel should be our decisions. However, besides companies buying Google services, most individuals do not pay for Google services. Chrome, Gmail, Google search, are monetarily free for us. We are paying with our information. If you use the service then you are saying yes to allow companies to enact these dark patterns, ethics aside. One could argue if the internet is a right, but that's another day Although it would be helpful for some if Google laid it out transparently to individuals who do not have the technical slop to understand what they are "losing"
- wlll 8y agoI've dumped Chrome over Firefox now. First time I've changed browser in about 10 years.
- ex3ndr 8y agoFor me breaking point was enabled by default google assistant on any Android phone. Not assistant itself, but one smaaaal feature. If you hold home button a little bit longer phone takes screenshot and uploads it to google to recognize it. That... just insane. I only wonder why no one is talking about this?
- MikeTV 8y agoToday Google popped up a little survey in the corner of my account page, with questions like "I trust Google to keep my data private", "It's easy to find out what data Google has on me", that sort. Answers were one-click response buttons: Strongly Agree, Agree, Neither Agree nor Disagree, Disagree, Strongly Disagree (top to bottom, in that order). The first time I clicked "Strongly Disagree", a few questions in, the next question had the order of the answers reversed so that Strongly Agree was on bottom. Submitted an opposite sentiment before realizing what happened. Strikes me as manipulative, like the survey really isn't so much for discovering my opinion as it is for collecting favorable ones. I wonder who will get the results, and to what end?
- Paul-ish 8y agoThat's common in surveys. It's to see if you are paying attention.
- MikeTV 8y agoI've noticed that with single-question responses such as Amazon's "why are you returning this" drop-down, and it makes total sense there. A consistently random arrangement means that users picking just the top answer will have no more influence on the overall report than random noise. Makes less sense when available answers are the same for each question, such that the user might have mentally cached them to avoid rereading. However, n=1. The timing might have been coincidental.
- allthecybers 8y agoI was done with Facebook several years ago even before I knew they were complicit in the subversion of our democracy. And recently I deleted my last Google account after moving domains, voice number and email to other providers. These are marketing companies and you are their product. This will only get worse. Opt out now.
- derReineke 8y agoAs soon as I can find a decent, stable job I'm going to start degoogling more of my life. Unfortunately, I have a Pixel 2 and a Pixelbook (unfortunately because Google, otherwise they're great), and I don't have the money to replace them right now. I do use Firefox and DDG on my desktop though. I really like them.
- LiterallyDoge 8y agoI just want a company that respects me and my data. Likewise, I want tools that behave in predictable and understandable ways. Google does not produce these kinds of products anymore. The small change in workflow with a different tool is minimal, the gain in quality from working with companies that treat me with respect is immeasurable.