6 ms·
It would no doubt be disruptive, temporarily. And it would also prompt a multi hundred billion dollar redirection of investment into moving those supply lines t
by adventured 8y ago
It would no doubt be disruptive, temporarily. And it would also prompt a multi hundred billion dollar redirection of investment into moving those supply lines to other countries. Vietnam would love to get some more of China's tech manufacturing action, as would a dozen other developing countries. Others would welcome gains to be had in apparel or autos by moves like that by China.
One of the biggest problems China has in this trade war: they're entirely replaceable. They offer nothing strictly unique that can't be replaced by another country, even though there may be a serious cost involved. The mistake of not being a large technology originator.
- justicezyx 8y ago> One of the biggest problems China has in this trade war: they're entirely replaceable. They offer nothing strictly unique that can't be replaced by another country, even though there may be a serious cost involved. I cannot see evidences that China is particularly more so than any other country.
- Retric 8y agoSaudi Oil is a commodity, but many country’s don’t have oil. Every country has low skilled workers.
- kasey_junk 8y agoLow skilled workers doesn’t accurately describe what China brings to the table currently. They effectively are the only place in the world you can source certain parts of the electronic supply chain at the volume currently necessary. They’ve been up the technical ladder for decades at the same time as other places have shed that capability. It would take a long time for Vietnam to come online. I’d guess Korea or Japan would be closest and that would have dramatic price impact.
- beamatronic 8y agoWhat is a dramatic price impact in the context of Apple products. 5%? 10%? Would that really stop you? They keep hiking the prices anyway.
- taobility 8y agofor iPhone, maybe it's just 10%, what about the other staff you need to buy daily? Do you count how many staff you using are Made In China right now?
- Retric 8y agoNationwide ~1/5th of US imports come directly from China, that’s bumped a little when countries manufacture with Chinease parts but stays well under 1/4th of US imports and ~1/37th the US GDP. Personally, I get very little directly or indirectly from China based on my shopping habits it’s mostly electronic gifts.
- justicezyx 8y agoThere is no absolute standard of low-tech and high-tech. The question is how replaceable. That is indirect relevant to iPhone or any small sample of particular items. The point is, overall, how replaceable is China? How is China ranked on the replaceable country list? I cannot see any evidences that China will be ranked below top3 (US China EU) in the world's least replaceable country when cutting from global trade.
- Retric 8y agoChina does a lot of different thinks all the way up to building jet engines. However, the percentage of people employed at mod to high skill manufacturing is not enough to keep things going in the event of a trade war.
- justicezyx 8y agoNah, if you see what technologies are used for extracting oil and the geopolitical structure, you'll see how western careful maintains the status such that Saudi is replaceable if needed. Given the oil's strategic value, sure, it's not as easily replaceable like cloth producers. But itself, as compared to any other country with similar strategic value, is certainly as replaceable as any other such country.
- enitihas 8y agoCorrect. Even if their large industrial integration of all sorts of parts in close proximity was easily replaceable(which is itself very difficult), for them to be easily replaceable, buyers would have to be more price indifferent, which doesn't seem to be happening.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tambourine_man 8y agoI’m not sure. Tim Cook seemed to suggest the iPhone couldn’t be manufactured anywhere else.
- hourislate 8y agoChina sources most of the components for Apple Products from different countries. Here is a list of countries that provide the parts. https://www.quora.com/Where-is-the-iPhone-originally-made https://www.quora.com/Where-is-the-iPhone-originally-made As you can see it would be fairly easy to for Apple/Foxconn to source these parts and build their products in the USA. I think the big motivator for them is they would rather outsource manufacturing to Foxconn and wash their hands of having to deal with it.
- mc32 8y agoAlso Foxconn could move ops back to Taiwan, albeit a bit expensive labor wise.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoBut still cheaper than the US. I don't see iPhones being made in the US anytime soon, there are many places in Asia other than China that would be higher up the list than the states.
- mc32 8y agoYeah. I don’t think it’s likely that production would come back —though not impossible. That said the main point is Foxconn could move production to other manufacturing centers, if need be, though it would need some transition period to avoid disruption.
- taobility 8y agoI don't think any other Asia countries has same scale of labor, supply chain and infrastructure to manufacture the goods with tremendous demand like iPhone. It's not just cheap labor, it involves a whole manufacture ecosystem.
- nkoren 8y agoThe manufacturing ecosystem in Shenzhen (for example) is unique. Any individual element of it is probably replaceable (at a considerable cost), but the presence of all those elements in the same place is not. The agglomeration benefits of this are HUGE, and losing them would introduce a thousand small frictions into the manufacturing process. Issues that can be sorted out in hours or days in Shenzhen (finding alternate suppliers, repairing specialized machinery, etc.) would take weeks or months anywhere else. That's for individual issues. A complex piece of equipment might have a dozen such issues while scaling and optimizing its manufacturing processes. In Shenzhen, this might cause a few weeks of delay. Anywhere else, the delay would be measured in years. There are several other such manufacturing ecosystems in China; Shenzhen is just the one I'm more familiar with. Yes, the individual parts may be replaceable -- but the whole is significantly greater than the sum of its parts. Building replacement ecosystems elsewhere would take decades. It took China roughly two decades to build this kind of ecosystem. Its primary resource for doing so was the ~4 million STEM graduates in produces every year. That's on par with the rest of the world put together. So don't underestimate the difficult of replicating this.
- doctorpangloss 8y agoThis is a commonly espoused narrative. I’m sure there were synergies in steel and auto production in US cities connected by rail between Pennsylvania and Michigan. I’d say the key misunderstanding is that you’re conflating China with “markets” in “it took China roughly two decades to build this kind of ecosystem.” If you read it as, “Markets took two decades to build this kind of ecosystem,” it should be clear that the relationship between prices, time, volume, supply and demand aren’t determined by political prerogatives, but by market ones. In other words, if your thesis is correct (that there’s something special about Shenzhen), the thing that’s special about it can be reproduced elsewhere. It will probably happen faster than two decades, because it’s proven to be a lucrative setup.
- mywittyname 8y agoThe Shenzhen special sauce is the high density of complimentary industries and specialized workforce. It's certainly possible to replicate, but history has shown that it can be difficult. It would be like trying to supplant Hollywood.