12 ms·
Wi-Fi Gets More Secure: What You Need to Know About WPA3
- caust1c 8y agoI look forward to using this in 20 years.
- mcny 8y agoI see current generation wi-fi routers being discounted already. It could be a co-incidence but I am sure vendors would LOVE to sell you newer routers and will implement it within years, not decades. As for devices on the other end, apparently it is possible to skimp out and have 1x1 instead of 2x2 https://superuser.com/a/323778 https://superuser.com/a/323778 I don't even know why 1x1 is an option at this point. Don't make me think! In any case, mobile SoC manufacturers should incorporate this new technology much faster so I would assume the new WiFi will be readily available in mobile hardware not more than three years after the standard is final.
- zamadatix 8y ago1x1 is still an option for the same reason your laptop will be 2x2 even though 802.11ax supports up to 8x8 - it's cheaper to put fewer radios in and someone always wants to buy the cheapest PoS. Technically less power as well but I doubt anyone who cares that much about power is using 802.11.
- philjohn 8y agoOr, get a router that supports OpenWRT (which a lot do, Netgear are pretty good about third party firmware) and you can have WPA3 now, for free.
- rauar 8y agocurious if existing hardware can be upgraded later. i guess technically it might be feasable but vendors will try to make money and sell new hardware anyway. hoping for open router firmwares...
- yjftsjthsd-h 8y agoThat would probably be radio firmwares; open router firmware isn't rare (openwrt, dd-wrt, tomato, etc.). And yes, it would be nice to get open radio firmware, though I'm not sure how that would play with FCC certification? I suppose if enough stuff is regulated in hardware it could work.
- djrogers 8y agoYou don’t need new radio firmware - this isn’t that low in the stack.
- zamadatix 8y agoIt requires stronger encryption but assuming your hardware is up to the task it'll work. If you're using OpenWRT recent builds with an up to date hostapd support it.
- Someone1234 8y agoI'm most excited about "Enhanced Open." The reason Open WiFi never had encryption is essentially because people argued that if a connection cannot be perfectly secure then it shouldn't try to be secure at all. Or the exact opposite of defense in depth. Enhanced Open does what we should have been doing since WPA1, Opportunistic Wireless Encryption. It is imperfect, but a substantial improvement over current Open WiFI. To quote Voltaire "Perfect is the enemy of good."
- wpietri 8y agoSame. I run an open guest network, and have always thought it deserved more security. Nice to see that's coming.
- stephengillie 8y agoIf we make perfect the enemy of good, there's no end to what we can filibuster to committee.
- zamadatix 8y agoIt's more than imperfect it's practically useless in its current state. It provides exactly 0 proof of identity or trust. It's basically "oh, you're advertising an SSID with <name>? I'll connect to you and we can make up a trust after that".
- DuskStar 8y agoIt means that someone else in the area can't listen to your traffic and decrypt it, among other things. That might not be perfect, but it's far better than nothing.
- jake_the_third 8y agoAs long as it's not presented as secure to users, I think it's a good thing.
- DuskStar 8y ago
- mangix 8y agoEverything you wish or need to know?
- reaperducer 8y agoAgreed. Every time some headline tell me a "need" something, I keep going. Obvious clickbait. And insulting. You don't know what I "need."
- baby 8y agoDidn't they use the backdoored PAKE algorithm from the NSA? https://www.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/cfrg/current/msg03554.html https://www.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/cfrg/current/msg03554.... Looks like no one was supporting this algorithm and it still got adopted for wpa3. What can we do about this? Are vendors this corrupt?
- yuhong 8y agoI think this is probably a misinterpretation.
- yjftsjthsd-h 8y agoWhy? Is there good support for it that we're missing?
- yuhong 8y agoWPA3 Personal seems to be another name for SAE that was defined in 802.11s.
- acct1771 8y agoWaiting to hear how.
- nickthemagicman 8y agoWow! Looks like Kevin Igoe is trying to sneak NSA backdoors into these encryption protocols! People like that are why we can't have nice things.
- amoshi 8y agoJust looked into NSA agent Kevin Igoe, somehow the vote to boot him off the group failed a few years ago. The millions and billions from the NSA's black budget[0] have to end up somewhere after all... [0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/black-budget-summary-details-us-spy-networks-successes-failures-and-objectives/2013/08/29/7e57bb78-10ab-11e3-8cdd-bcdc09410972_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/black...
- smiley1437 8y agoI looked desperately in the press release for some version of Aerohive's Private PSK (PPSK) where you can have multiple PSKs for the same SSID (Ruckus and Cisco have their own versions too) but couldn't find anything. The ability to have multiple PSKs and revoking\changing one of them but not the others would be really convenient for small and even medium-sized wifi deployments...
- zamadatix 8y agoIt has use in large environments as well, there are plenty of old/shit vendor devices in many businesses that aren't getting replaced any time soon just so they support 802.1x in a working manner.
- yjftsjthsd-h 8y agoI'm confused. I run my home wireless off a Debian box using hostapd, and there's specifically an option where you can have multiple passwords on the same SSID, either per-client (by MAC) or for anyone. Is that what you mean? Is this a rare feature?
- zamadatix 8y agoHostapd is probably how Cisco, Aerohive, and Ruckus are doing it. It's not that it's exceedingly rare it's just not everywhere as it's not part of wireless standards.
- EvangelicalPig 8y agoI thought there were patents in this area, preventing implementation without licensing/getting sued?
- zamadatix 8y agoI'm only aware of patents related to certain systems which implement more than just the base idea of using more than one security key for a given SSID e.g. the Ruckus patent on how Dynamic PSK automatically creates and assigns multiple PSKs from a controller portal.
- reaperducer 8y agoEverything You Need to Know About WPA3 Things I know about WPA3: - None of my routers support it, and I'm not gonna buy all new routers. - My printer doesn't support it. Heck, it doesn't support WPA2. - None of my IOT doohickies support it. Not gonna buy all new devices. In this instance, I feel I'm more aligned with Joe Lunchbucket than Zap McTechburg. I still use my PSP. It's 14-years-old and not going to work with WPA3. My wireless printer is 15-years-old, and doesn't even do 5GHz. By the time the average person upgrades all their gear to WPA3 stuff, it'll be cracked and we'll be on WPA5.
- bcaa7f3a8bbc 8y agoThings I know about WPA3... - I can install/upgrade some packages on my OpenWrt router/computers to enable it. - I can leave a WPA2 SSID for my old gadgets. > By the time the average person upgrades all their gear to WPA3 stuff, it'll be cracked and we'll be on WPA5. Perhaps vendors can implement a WPA3/WPA2 mixed mode? Or just use the dual SSID hack...
- jandrese 8y agoI have a modern router for WPA3 and an older router that does WPA1 but is firewalled from the rest of the network and only allows access to a small range of IPs.
- txcwpalpha 8y agoIf you're on a network that has both WPA2 and WPA3 enabled, are you really even benefiting from all of the WPA3 security improvements? Any attacker can just fall back to your WPA2 SSID and crack your network that way. And once they have access to your network, unless you're doing some advanced network segmentation, does it matter which version of WPA you're using?
- sieabahlpark 8y agoCongrats, you have realized that most people don't understand this. I guess you could section off a guest SSID which is a dmz or something like that.
- jiveturkey 8y agoshit. all i need to know about it is that my airport is soon to be obsolete.
- tyc85 8y agoHas anyone ever consider bringing up a private LTE network (over unlicensed or shared spectrum), either at home, enterprise, or even MDU? Density and security are less of a concern on LTE, and the peak throughput is catching up. The question I have has always been: are we seeing a world moving towards a more controlled wireless network architecture or a evolved version of Wi-Fi type of ad-hoc architecture.
- lucb1e 8y agoAre there LTE routers you can buy at reasonable prices? Would I then need a custom SIM card in my phone that only works at home? Does my device even look for mobile carriers on unlicensed spectrum? Basically, is this a real, consumer-grade thing or something you can only do with sdr and osmocom?
- tyc85 8y agoI think the short answer is no, currently there isn't a reasonably priced LTE routers that you can deployed by yourself. There are products available though. That's why the question can be interesting to be figured out to a certain extent. Whether device look for carrier in unlicensed spectrum: the answer is yes, Licensed Assisted Access is happening, though slowly, as with any things related to carrier. See this link: https://support.t-mobile.com/thread/144981 https://support.t-mobile.com/thread/144981 Finally, it's certainly not something you can only do with SDR, but then doing it with SDR could be what makes it appealing though, it the price can be somewhat brought down. Good Wi-Fi routers nowadays cost a lot anyways, and some even wants you to pay monthly fee, no?
- IshKebab 8y agoThere are various attempts at that sort of thing, but generally they are still tied to an existing LTE connection. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LTE_in_unlicensed_spectrum https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LTE_in_unlicensed_spectrum
- gok 8y agoVery few modems support LTE in unlicensed spectrum (aka LTE-U)
- combatentropy 8y agoSociety has hit a new low when the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers succumbs to clickbait headlines. Compare: Everything You Need to Know About WPA3 and: WPA3 What is the difference, besides a creepy parental claim of knowing what I need to know? It's empty filler and often a lie. It should be struck from every title. - "Everything You Need to Know About the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies", by Albert Einstein - "Everything You Need to Know About My Early Life", by Winston Churchill - "Everything You Need to Know About Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows", by J. K. Rowling
- Jonnax 8y agoIt's pointing out that the article is a summary. It's a common phrase in ending.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoThat's not what clickbait means.
- nsgi 8y agoSeems like this has some good security features, but with the move towards universal Https connecting to an unsecured WiFi network no longer carries the same level of risk it once did (other than exposing LAN shared resources). As good as prefect forward secrecy is, anything sensitive should already be being encrypted by the client (router passwords notwithstanding until that problem is solved). I'd rather move towards a world where you don't need a password to access a WiFi network and people share their internet access freely. This would improve not only access to the internet, but also increase privacy because you wouldn't be able to rely on an IP address indicating someone's identity.
- Avamander 8y agoThe only thing I like about the new standard is mandatory protected management frames, no longer can some sy enterprise access point determine mine should be killed with deauth.
- homero 8y agoThis will take a decade to even begin deploying. There's billions of chipsets right now that will never support it. Does wpa3 support leaving wpa2 on? Otherwise I can't turn it on for a decade.
- TulliusCicero 8y ago> My old stuff doesn't support this new standard, and it will take a long time to proliferate! I mean, yeah? How's that different from every other time there's a new standard?
- danmg 8y agoWe're about a decade further in the adoption of Wifi from when WPA2 was released. It's a completely different ballpark now that wifi is considered part of the basic infrastructure everywhere and baked in to exponentially more devices. It took several years for people to pitch their old dell laptops and nintendo consoles that couldn't support the then-new standards. People aren't going to replace their thermostats, baby-monitors, security systems, home entertainment systems, and juicers over night.
- homero 8y agoWpa2 was right before iot, smartphones, smartwatches, etc
- zamadatix 8y ago"Does wpa3 support leaving wpa2 on?" Yes, there are additional modes "WPA3 Personal Transitional" and "WPA3 Enterprise Transitional" which allow WPA2 on the same SSID and relax some of the WPA3 requirements like PMF.
- IshKebab 8y agoI'll be happy if it just has a proper "incorrect password" message rather than "couldn't connect for some reason, could be any reason really but maybe your password is wrong?" that we have to deal with now.
- mavhc 8y agoCan we see the details of this protocol? Not without paying. Good job they have a track record of not being the people who gave us WEP, we should totally trust that this time their open processes allowed for a secure system to be developed.
- AnaniasAnanas 8y agoNo chacha20 support.. Only 128-bit encryption in personal mode..
- bjoli 8y agoThe 128 bit encryption is probably going to be the last thing to break if there is an active attack against your network.
- lsh123 8y agoThe security of WiFi is much less of a concern for my home network today than it was during WEP time. Today everything I care to protect already runs over SSL and all the sensitive resources (documents file server, for example) are protected with authentication. This the only actual attack vector for me is WiFi or internet connection which I already share through public WiFi. Same applies to WiFi in the coffee shops (do you remember the time when FB didn’t use HTTPS?) and other places. Thus the WPA3 upgrade brings much smaller benefits compared to WPA2 upgrade.
- e12e 8y ago> Today everything I care to protect already runs over SSL Dns? Wins? Bonjour ? > and all the sensitive resources (documents file server, for example) are protected with authentication. But are the files streamed in plaintext? (samba, nfs3, nfs4 without encryption)?
- badrabbit 8y agoWifi is a layer2 standard. Always felt like security should be handled by upper layers. Layer2 secures one data-link segment at a time,layer3 secures a network connection at a time. There is a missing .5 protocol(.5== inter-layer,e.g.: arp,ndp,mpls and dhcp) that could use layer2 parameters to establish layer3 security. Or maybe all that is needed is a feature-stuffed version of dhcp that would configure a default gateway and a secure l3 tunnel to that default gateway as well as on-demand tunnel establishment parameters for intra-vlan endpoints. This would secure wired and non-wifi wireless IP networks as well.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 8y agoThe previous encryption methods didn't rely on asymmetric encryption, and VPN software nowadays often provides an option to use an additional symmetric-only key to protect the handshake. (This makes it quantum-resistant against attackers that don't have the symmetric key, while allowing to use DH to get forward secrecy against non-quantum attackers that later gain access to the key). Does WPA3 maintain this protection, or is it now open to quantum attacks? Also, is there a mode to allow connecting to open networks with authentication based on TLS certificates and domain names? For example, the SSID of the network could be a domain name, and the network would present a certificate for that domain (or some well-defined subdomain) to prove that it's indeed that network. This way, if you know the domain of the entity you're connecting to (e.g. a hotel), and see a WiFi with that name (and have a client that doesn't allow unicode for this mode), you could connect securely.