12 ms·
Americans are changing their relationship with Facebook
- 0x4f3759df 8y agoMaybe Americans figured out it's not that much fun to post when you have to consider that your mom, your aunt, your employer, your future employers, law enforcement, the TSA, the NSA and foreign governments are going to read it. Long live pseudonyms.
- notacoward 8y agoIs it really about what they write, or about what they read? People were putting out information that all of the parties you mention could read long before Facebook existed. I still remember "NSA food" on Usenet. Those privacy concerns, while valid, have never become foremost in most people's thoughts, even among technorati. Out there among the Great Unwashed, I suspect the issue is more about the value they get from reading. People read a lot more than they write, after all. People were already getting tired of watching all their friends' highlight reels. Then since the last election there have been far more fights in comments, and the feeling of being manipulated, and people pretty naturally start to wonder whether this is time well spent. I'm not dismissing your concern, but I don't think it's particularly relevant to the OP. Barely makes a dent, really.
- feocco 8y agoAgreed. I'm far more concerned about how I behave at the local pub.
- monetus 8y agoI suspect for most people you are right, but it isn't like we can measure and quantify either disincentive. I know the chilling effect of the widened pool of viewers is real. I also know the quality of the feed is generally terrible. What keeps me there is the quality of the groups (mostly people I don't know) and the somewhat reliable means of contact. I don't know anyone who keeps a phone number for more than a few years, but very few change social networks frequently.
- beat 8y agoI love Facebook - or perhaps, I'm addicted to it - and have been for many years. I recently quit using it temporarily for a variety of reasons, and realized a few ugly things. First, it amplifies my own tendency to be argumentative. "Someone is wrong on the Internet!" seems more true on FB than anywhere else. Second, when I did go back, I realized I was just endlessly scrolling - a behavior the UI encourages - looking for anything interesting in the sea of memes, selfies, and nonsense. Now, I allow myself back on only from a computer at home. I've removed it from my phone. It's still bad, but it's less bad. It saddens me, because I do like keeping up with old friends and new (it's especially great to see people that I lost contact with decades ago, and to keep up with the lives of my sisters and nieces and nephews some). In the place of all that FB time, I've developed a love affair with my Kindle. I carry a paperwhite with me, and also the Kindle app on my phone, so I have two books going at once. It's so much better for my mind! Today's two books: Strange Stars: How Science Fiction and Fantasy Transformed Popular Music, by Jason Heller, and The Better Angels of Our Nature, by Steven Pinker. So yeah, the "value they get from reading" matters a lot. And Facebook has poor value relative to the addictive qualities and bad social habits they design into it. When I came back after my hiatus, FB put me through a quiz, and in an open answer section, I said flat out that the addictive nature was a serious problem. A little hook is good, but not too much! I think I said they should be selling candy, not heroin.
- gaius 8y agoSecond, when I did go back, I realized I was just endlessly scrolling - a behavior the UI encourages - looking for anything interesting in the sea of memes, selfies, and nonsense. You pull down... something spins... sometimes you get a reward. Can it really be pure coincidence that Facebook and one-armed bandits have exactly the same UI?
- notacoward 8y agoThere's a model/theory out there about many of the problems in modern society coming down to our all being trapped in low-energy low-reward activities like watching TV or surfing the internet. They're just rewarding enough that we keep doing them, but also just taxing enough that they sap the energy we need to do or explore etc. I think there's some truth to it, though I wouldn't oversell the idea. Facebook is clearly in the low-effort category. It's designed to be. That doesn't mean it should be shunned entirely - we all need to relax somehow - but it does mean it should be managed. For some people that means limiting time. For others it means increasing the reward side of the equation, which might paradoxically mean more engagement. I have a friend who's a moderator for a very large and active group there. She has made lots of friends that way, and it makes her happy. Good for her. For still others, a complete separation might indeed be the right answer. The important thing is that no size fits all. Kids need to be taught how to make these decisions for themselves, and in the better school systems they often are. Given the newness of technology, I think a lot of adults also need such education, and sadly won't get it.
- cryptozeus 8y agoI think this is the core point. Surely drove me away from Facebook
- johns 8y agoDon’t forget advertisers!
- shrimp_emoji 8y agoThere was this old and ostensibly authoritative page that was describing hacker culture. The author said that true hackers don't hide behind pseudonyms because they should be proud enough of what they do that they can put their real names behind it. It lost me there. Not only am I not proud of my social track record through the ages, but the idea of "privacy is dead" online identification is quaint, naive, and/or intolerable to me. For better or worse, there's a sharp, strategic/emotional partitioning of how I interact with or present myself to strangers, friends, family, employers, and law enforcement, and the chilling effect applied to my behavior from all angles is very limiting. LONG live pseudonyms. : D
- beenBoutIT 8y agoThere's no shortage of ways of looking past pseudonyms and identifying authors.
- sandworm101 8y agoIf that were true, a great many more people would be locked up, or disappeared, across the world. Pseudonyms have been essential long before the internet, long before electricity. They should not be looked down upon. Nor should they be a privilege. It is cute when a celeb adopts a "stage name". We don't really consider that hiding, but politicians use stage names too. When you want to actually research a person, say to find out if they have a criminal background, cute "stage names" become barriers to legitimate research. If the wealthy and powerful get to use pseudonyms, everyone gets to use pseudonyms.
- noobermin 8y agoAny devoted individual with sufficient will and power can track you down. Even with a little less power, will can do it. We rely on the fatigue of adversaries and limits on their time and resources. Any sufficiently motivated entity can find out who you are.
- sandworm101 8y ago
- throwaway5250 8y agoIndeed, but not just pseudonyms, as over a surprisingly short time, you'll almost certainly uniquely identify yourself. You really need to be using and rotating "burner" usernames on a quite regular basis. Unfortunately, some sites forbid this to varying degrees. HN perma-banned my primary IP address because I was rotating several times per year. As is their right. But savvy people will generally stay in lurk mode as a result. Maybe that's the future: Most posts by bots, most humans reading only.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gnicholas 8y ago> Around four-in-ten (42%) say they have taken a break from checking the platform for a period of several weeks or more, while around a quarter (26%) say they have deleted the Facebook app from their cellphone. 44% of younger users (those ages 18 to 29) say they have deleted the Facebook app from their phone in the past year, nearly four times the share of users ages 65 and older (12%) who have done so.
- stephengillie 8y agoWhen people "delete their Facebook", most only ever delete the app. Many still use it on other devices, or maybe even their phone browser.
- Spooky23 8y agoDepends on the group. My wife’s friend list has many of the grey ghost profiles of deactivated users.
- janitor61 8y agoSure wish I didn't have to root my phone to delete the Facebook app. Is this a T-Mobile thing, or do most carriers bundle Facebook now?
- lozaning 8y agoIt can be either a carrier thing, or a phone manufacturer thing. Of all the phone I deal with at work (3 models each from all the major manufacturers) I loath the HTC ones most because of the amount of shitware you cant uninstall.
- tomrod 8y agoOne of my conditions to go with a cell provider is whether I can bring my own phone. I've found BLU phones to be highly serviceable, and works great with an MVNO (I use one on T-mobile's network). I am not associated with BLU, just a satisfied customer. The sub $200 price point is nice and the hardware tradeoff hasn't been too bad. I do worry about their phone-home issues though.
- redefineminimal 8y agoFacebook offers the promise of socializing and having easier access to your friends and gatherings. The reality is that socializing on Facebook consists of posting memes and arguments. No one is closer together for it. Facebook doesn't meet it's promise (to the user, advertisers expectations I'm sure are met).
- notacoward 8y agoBingo. My impression is that only a few leave Facebook because of principle. A hundred times more leave because it's not fun any more. I could argue that how much fun you have has a lot to do with how you curate your feed - mine's good for lots of laughs and only rarely much aggravation - but most people would rather just leave than make the effort to improve their own experience. Same as it is everywhere else, and has been since the dawn of time.
- themodelplumber 8y agoI find a lot of the groups really fun. Unfortunately far too many of them are cluelessly set up as public groups, meaning that your friends or coworkers or worst enemies can really easily keep tabs and even get notified about your activities within the groups. This makes them much less fun. Everybody needs a part of their life that is shut off from their work friends or even their blood relatives. So the otherwise really engaging Facebook group concept is heavily encumbered by yet again the old privacy issue, aka the "you saw me post that!?" issue. It blows my mind that this is still such a stumbling block.
- feocco 8y agoValue of the content is what drove me away. I tried with much effort to weed out memes and garbage content via the share feature. I'm interested in personal photos and status updates(not twitter-esque complaints). But I had little to no success. Give me a "disable memes & politics" button and I'd probably be back that day.
- iamdave 8y ago
- Damogran6 8y agoI've poisoned my profile. Chopped the friends list by 75%, quit using them for Single Sign On, will automatically halt video playback the second an AD hits, Report a significant percentage of ADs I see in the timeline as 'offensive to me'. If they can abuse my profile, I can significantly lower it's value to them.
- samschooler 8y agoIn addition to this, whenever I log on, I like to change my home city, political preferences and other "about me" info. This makes my profile next to useless.
- paulie_a 8y agoI've been banned from reporting ads more times than I can count. every third post is an ad or some low quality suggested post. Ive definitely lowered my Facebook usage. For all the data they collect they do a terrible job at utilizing it.
- zahrc 8y agoTheir useless, annoying and most importantly toxic ads are one of the main reasons I stopped using it. At least advertise me something I am really interested in and not stupid ripped of play store apps. Reddit is now doing the same thing. Yea no thanks
- imgabe 8y agoHa, I do that with the ads too. Report them all as spam.
- superkuh 8y agoI have not ever changed my relationship with Facebook. I never even started because it was obvious that a proprietary centralized platform would have perverse incentives for censorship and spying. It's nice that other people are finally waking up to it, but unfortunately their motivation seems to be primarily driven by partisan politics rather than the root problem.
- philwelch 8y agohttps://www.theonion.com/area-man-constantly-mentioning-he-doesnt-own-a-televisi-1819565469 https://www.theonion.com/area-man-constantly-mentioning-he-d...
- irrational 8y agoHeh. I don't own a TV. The only time it comes up is when cable sales people come to my door or stop me in a store. When I ask them if their service comes with a TV they always get this aghast look on their face. I don't know if it is because they can't imagine life without a TV or because I've totally thrown them off of their sales script so they don't know what to say next, but I've got to admit I do enjoy it.
- kasey_junk 8y agoI’m surprised no one has offered one yet. They are super cheap these days.
- irrational 8y agoIt's probably just not a part of their script. After all, who doesn't have a TV? It probably didn't occur to the sales script writers to include that path.
- reaperducer 8y agoNot that long ago I worked with a bunch of Millennials who all claimed they don't watch TV. When asked why, they said they watch Hulu and HBO Go and Fox's apps. They simply couldn't wrap their brains around the notion that all that stuff was on a television. They also didn't know that there was such a thing as free over-the-air TV. They acted like it was some kind of black magic to get TV without a cable or internet connection.
- cryptozeus 8y agoDo you think its possible that the fb socializing was fun when it started but after few years we all realize that its just not the right way to socialize. You can only post so many updates and likes have no meaning anymore.
- btgeekboy 8y agoIt was great when it was friends showing off pictures and potentially pointless status updates, not unlike twitter. Now it’s mostly overrun with political vomit and filler content/spam. Once everyone starting friending parents, colleagues, and acquaintances, the more intimate stuff moved to more private platforms.
- reaperducer 8y agoDo you think its possible that the fb socializing was fun when it started but after few years we all realize that its just not the right way to socialize Pretty much. It's all so pointless now. My feed today: Important service alert from a transit agency in some other city. Obviously fake friend request from someone who thinks a Sharpie is an eyebrow pencil. Promoted post from some company I've never heard of pushing something I don't care about. People You May Know who are all people I don't know. Someone else's shared memory of an event 5 years ago I wasn't at and don't care about. Post from a "neighborhood" group on the other side of town. Suggested Post about something I don't care about. Post in a language that I don't speak, but that's OK because I did intentionally follow the Yomiuri Giants. Post from the state parks people about a state park 400 miles away. Image caption repost of a repost of a repost of a repost from someone who thinks that life's problems can be solved by re-posting other people's refrigerator magnet thoughts. Ad for a coffee chain in another city with no locations within 700 miles. "Breaking News" weather alert about a dust storm last week. News item that a local TV station posted three months ago. Photograph of someone I don't know who is friends with someone who is friends with someone I might know. Photo from an actual Facebook friend, but it's of his tween daughter in a leotard. Ummm... Ad for a coffee chain in another country. One of those "URGENT! URGENT!!! !! Please help us find out dog!" re-posts from someone 2,500 miles away. A re-post of an image caption that's been around since the 1990's. Photograph of a friend not wearing enough clothing with a bunch of other quite hairy people not wearing enough clothing in what I really really hope is a sauna. Good job, Facebook. Glad to see the $70 billion spent on "user engagement AI" is working out for you.
- naochan 8y agoJust quit already. Plenty of meaningful relationships in the real world!
- em0ney 8y agoI quit a while back. One of the best things I have done
- amha 8y agoThis study doesn't show that "Americans are changing their relationship with Facebook": >Just over half of Facebook users ages 18 and older (54%) say they have adjusted their privacy settings in the past 12 months, according to a new Pew Research Center survey. Around four-in-ten (42%) say they have taken a break from checking the platform for a period of several weeks or more, while around a quarter (26%) say they have deleted the Facebook app from their cellphone. All told, some 74% of Facebook users say they have taken at least one of these three actions in the past year. Is this different from what these people have done in the past? I've changed my Facebook privacy settings in the past year––but I've also changed them on a regular basis since getting on Facebook. Likewise, I've always taken regular Facebook breaks in the 13 years I've been on it. This study is interesting, but it doesn't prove the claim in the headline.
- artemisyna 8y agoI also don't quite understand why "adjusting their privacy settings "is a metric for people changing how they use FB. FB threw an interstitial in front of people for GDPR. It'd be weird if people didn't change their privacy settings then?
- itry2develop 8y agoI stopped using it when it became nothing but new moms sharing every page they read on the internet. I honestly think the share button everywhere killed the quality of the feeds. No longer was it about what people where actually doing themselves.
- irrational 8y agoI was at an event recently where an older teenager was giving a speech. He mentioned Snapchat or Instagram (or some other social media platform) and then said "that's like Facebook for you old people". Ouch. But, I wasn't surprised. I have children in their late teens and early 20s and they and their friends openly mock people who still use Facebook.
- yesenadam 8y ago..all those billions of them? Meanwhile in the rest of the world...everyone's on there. Tell them not to be so embarrassingly naïve and provincial, if they can.
- lkrubner 8y agoAround 2004, when tech writers were trying to explain why Friendster failed, and why MySpace was becoming such a power, there was a lot of writing about Metcalfe's law -- the more people who joined, the more valuable the network was. Then around 2009, when MySpace was dying, there were several articles that pointed out that the opposite was also true: the more that people withdraw from a network, the more that network loses value. Perhaps we will see similar articles soon, making the point about Facebook. But I'm not expecting to see people abandon Facebook suddenly, the way people suddenly abandoned MySpace. Rather, the process this time seems a bit more subtle -- people realize that everyone they know (plus future employers) is watching, therefore they have to censor themselves, therefore they have to limit their engagement. The effect is the same, Metcalfe's Law in reverse, the network loses value. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metcalfe%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metcalfe%27s_law
- abraham_lincoln 8y agoFriendster should have licensed their patents to the other networks.
- rm_-rf_slash 8y agoThe hundred billion dollar question is where will people alternately socialize online? Lots of people I know spurn Facebook but use Instagram. Nearly everybody I meet on Fortnite communicates off-game via Snapchat. I personally get my internet dopamine fix through Reddit and Hacker News, and if I want to stay in touch with friends, I call/text/email, like the good old days of like 10 years ago. I don’t see a general global social network around the corner gearing up to dethrone Facebook, but at the same time I am noticing social media usage splintering across a myriad of sites and apps, instead of being dominated by one giant social network.
- burlesona 8y agoThat seems like a good and natural thing to me.
- minor3rd 8y ago> The hundred billion dollar question is where will people alternately socialize online? It's a good question. Personally, I got rid of Facebook and didn't feel like I needed a replacement. I do use Instagram and Snapchat, but mostly to communicate with family.
- mikeleeorg 8y agoWhen I first joined Facebook, I used it like a typical social network back in the day (added as many friends, acquaintances, coworkers, etc as I could), with very surface-level interactions (pokes, shared cows and sheep with contacts, etc). I would post interesting articles I read and make really lame quips about life or what I was doing. Later, after I got married and had kids, I consciously experimented with posting photos of my kids. Engagement on my posts shot up. This led me to gradually phase out article sharing and life quipping in favor of kids' photos. I still consumed interesting articles shared by contacts though. And the curated news that Facebook offered, even though I realized it had a risk of being an echo chamber. Eventually, I started weeding out people who fell below the level of a real-life friend, because I didn't want to share family photos with them. Facebook became a place to share kids' photos and see kids' photos from friends and family. Now, I mostly read reddit for interesting articles and discussions. Some Facebook groups are decent for that, but they never quite match the reach and range of discussion that reddit does. Facebook is now my family-photo-sharing service. And even then, I've begun to slow down my usage in favor of other mechanisms for sharing kids' photos. Some of my actions were motivated by privacy concerns. Some by conscious experiments in engagement. And some by the utility, or lack thereof, of Facebook in general. I wouldn't consider myself a typical Facebook user, but anecdotally, a decent number of friends have told me their interactions with Facebook have matched mine.
- jjrh 8y agoI really liked the /idea/ behind google plus where you could put people into circles and selectively post to them. - Family photos go to everyone in the family circle. - Articles about politics go to people in that circle (who might also be in my family circle) - Articles about technical topics go to people in that circle. We all have different interests and contexts in our lives - like I might want everyone (close friends and acquaintances alike) to know I got married but only my very close family to know I got the flu last weekend. The part (well last I used google plus which was a while ago) that was missing was sorting that the other way - so when my sister posts family photos it shouldn't show up in the 'news' group that I also have her in. The interface for google plus sucked, but they got the right idea.
- Ws32ok 8y agoThe penny dropped for me about 5 years ago. I cleared my account out. Didn’t bother deleting the account though.
- benatkin 8y ago44% of people 18-29 deleting the app from their phones sounds bad, but it's important to take into account that Facebook does all sorts of things to increase engagement in their apps that cause some people to be annoyed. Facebook could make their app less distracting or make it easy to turn off annoying features, and fewer would uninstall it. It also doesn't take into account people reinstalling it. I've deleted and reinstalled it in the last year, and it is currently installed.
- JumpCrisscross 8y agoDeleting the Facebook apps (Facebook and Messenger) has been a huge boost to my productivity and happiness. Could not recommend a single thing more to the average person.
- spaceflunky 8y agoLots of people are moving to Instagram because it's new and quicker/easier to digest. But I see Instagram going the same way as Facebook. Eventually it will not be "fun to share when mom, your aunt, your employer, your future employers, law enforcement, the TSA, the NSA and foreign governments are going to read it." As another has said. I abandoned Facebook because the connections I have that are active only use it to post baby photos or political content. To me political content is the worst because it is mostly whining and people feel like if they whine on social media they are being heard and therefore validated. Not to mention the postings of 20 pages op-ed pieces they clearly didn't read. And then one of their random acquaintances decides to disagree and then someone else feels compelled to "set them straight" and then its like 100 comments of bickering. Dude fuck that... I especially despise the people who use "Instagram Stories" for political content because they basically trick you into giving your entire phone to them for 1-2 seconds for their political message. Yea no thanks. Unfriend...
- erickhill 8y agoNot only that, but what's with all of the Followers you get on Instagram that appear to be fake accounts made to sell porn? I used to get all of these weird "You're now being followed by..." notices. I'd tap on the profile pic (if it looked safe) only to be greeted with porn pics. And they'd have a ton of followers! It got to where I was nervous to even use the Instagram app around my kids for fear of what might show up there. It was bad.
- 1337biz 8y agoHad the issue only 2-3 times. Flagged the accounts and moved on. I think I even got a message once by the Insta team thanking me and that the account got deleted.
- flying_kangaroo 8y agoThe counterpoint to your potential Instagram downfall is that "kids these days" are making "Finsta" accounts, or fake accounts that they only add their close friends to, so they can post things they don't want the family seeing. Facebook tries very hard to enforce people using their real names, something that Instagram doesn't need to do.
- brlewis 8y agoI was temporarily excited when I saw they had a link to their methodology. I always want to know how questions were phrased in surveys like this, since phrasing can affect the answers. Unfortunately the 3-page methodology doc didn't cover that. Like many such surveys, there's selection bias here in that it's people who have a land line and will agree to answer a survey about Facebook. This is going to bias toward people for whom something interesting has happened recently in their relationship to Facebook. Additional bias comes from the fact that the only participants invited were ones who previously agreed to answer a political survey.
- wokawoka 8y agoFacebook - a place where you can share photos of your fugly children and comments of your low-meaning life.
- ageitgey 8y agoFacebook has been product-managed and algorithmed to death - two real sicknesses of short-term thinking common in SV companies. If you've used Facebook continuously for the last decade, you won't notice as much because the changes have been gradual. But if you came to Facebook now as a new user, it's all but incomprehensible. Combined with being "the place your parents hang out", it's no surprise that no one new wants to join Facebook or understands why they would want to be there. Here are three concrete examples of these diseases: 1. Comments on posts and groups are shown out of order using relevance ranking. You just see the fragments of conversation that are most likely to get you to click and write an enraged reply without any context. No sane designer would ever choose this design for a message posting system. It's clear that a PM ran an A/B test and is optimizing for short term "engagement numbers" and doesn't care at all if you can actually have a normal discussion with their product. Juicing engagement drives users away in the long term. 2. Since the visibility of nearly all content is algorithmic, the shittiest content rises to the top automatically. If you are friends with people who work on products like YouTube, they will tell you privately that the reason there are so many conspiracy videos suggested by YouTube is because crazy people click on ads at an absurdly high rate compared to the general public which makes that content very valuable to the algorithm and drives it to the top unless the penalize it artificially. The same thing happens all over Facebook. Human misery and lowest common denominator content rises to the top because it gets clicks. Again, you are juicing short-term engagement but driving away users in the long term when misery fatigue sets in. 3. Facebook has so many overlapping features and no clear product vision. PMs have slapped on feature after feature with little consideration for the overall product. You can literally feel the PMs fighting over screen space in the web page layout. For example on my default landing page, I have a live chat sidebar, a widget to post "Stores" and separate a widget to post "Posts", separate links to "Watch", "Live Video" and "Gaming Video", a link to "Marketplace" despite a totally separate link to something called "Buy and Sell Groups" and yet another one called "Offers", and all manner of bizarre and creepy sounding stuff like "Town Hall" and "Messenger Kids"(!). There's even some bullshit about a "Friendiversary" and a separate "Memories" tab. There must be 100+ separate "Products" on the screen that I can navigate into. Who is Facebook for?? If Facebook is going to survive as a viable place for people to hang out, someone with a clear product vision needs to be put in charge and the product needs to be severely stripped down and de-algorithmed. But of course that will never happen in a giant company, so instead Instagram will eventually overtake Facebook because it's actually still somewhat usable. But then Instagram itself will be PMed and algorithmed to death and replaced by something else. It's the corporate lifecycle.
- Cowicide 8y agoThe only thing that breaks my heart with Facebook going wayside is I know of many people with illnesses who use Facebook as one of their only outreaches for family and friends. Really is a shame that Facebook's greed and lack of integrity is driving people away from each other in this manner.
- jakeinspace 8y agoI use Facebook for 3 things: messenger, University/student groups, and marketplace/for sale pages. I live outside my home country, so messenger is the only way I can talk to many friends back home (or friends here in Canada when I'm home myself). Being in school(as well as some employers and organizations) means there are all sorts of groups for socializing, sports, clubs etc etc, and Facebook is certainly the main platform for organizing these sorts of things here. And just a few days ago I managed to find an apartment sublet through Facebook (1 day before classes started, yes I'm that dumb). Aside from those 3 activities, I'd estimate I spend about 30 minutes a week on Facebook max. It's just not fun, feels very lowest common denominator (despite analytics-driven content). I have the impression that a lot of people (my age or otherwise) are in a similar camp: depending on Facebook for a few key services but otherwise loath to use it.
- everdev 8y agoI was at a store in Reno that was giving out free gifts to people who weren't on Facebook or Twitter. The tide is turning on the public perception of utility and safety of large social media networks, even if extremely slowly.
- cm2012 8y agoExcept US daily usage of FB has been perfectly steady for 8 quarters.
- frizkie 8y agoI think you can be sure that Facebook is not happy with usage not increasing, especially over a period of 8 quarters.
- cm2012 8y agoOnce more than half of all Americans use FB every day of their lives, not a ton of room to grow! They are increasing US rev though and international growth.
- Yhippa 8y agoAs we learned from the last election what Americans say and what they do can be two totally different things. I'll believe any change in people's behavior when I see it. Right now Facebook and its companies seem to be making money hand-over-fist.
- erickhill 8y agoLast year I finally, after over a decade, 100% deleted my personal account omn Facebook. I just got so fed up with it all. The service had this sour yet addicting pull over my online experiences - a pull I grew to despise. I had found myself either hiding or unfriending folks I'd been friends or acquaintances with over 25 years ago. People I no longer had anything in common with, yet had re-connected on Facebook because we could. Seeing some of their posts, however, became a total pool of swirling toxicity. So I finally just deleted it. I used to "take breaks" and simply disconnect it for months at a time. But I'd never gone full nuclear option until last year. At first I had these weird feelings of - I assume - withdrawal. They lasted intensely for 2-3 days where I'd experience something with my kids and think, "Man, that would have been a photo I would have loved sharing." After about two weeks all of those thoughts drifted away. By week three, they were utterly gone. I don't miss it one bit. I'd relearned to experience life normally and not feel the need to put it out there. I still take a lot of pics; I just email them to my mom now. Now that being said, I did create an "anonymous" Facebook account for one single use: Groups. I'm deep into the retro-computing/gaming scene (especially Commodore) so I created a moniker that has nothing to do with me personally. This allows me to maintain my privacy and sanity while being able to stay "in the know" around these niche topics. I never post any personal articles, photos, etc. It's just for Groups. And at least from that standpoint, I've found it very useful. None of the content (for the most part) is ever objectionable nor even controversial. It's the new Forum, basically.
- tareqak 8y agoThe only value I found in Facebook around 2005 was something to keep track of people's birthday's so that I could wish them happy birthday, but the privacy implications seemed pretty obvious and pretty dire. In late 2010, I wanted to reconnect with people, and I decided to compromise on privacy. Sometime in 2016 or 2017, I saw the post on HN about how to delete my account and all the information. Given how Facebook made me feel as a user of their service and all the different accounts of how they use personal information that I read by that time, I was glad to have gotten rid off it then, but I wish I just stay off of it in the first place.
- Yhippa 8y agoI'll throw my hat in the ring for how my social media usage has changed. I've largely moved off of social media and onto chat networks. Discord seems to have nearly every type of interest group. I use Telegram for international sports and random tech groups. Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and Snapchat usage has gone down significantly for me. I was checking Reddit daily for a year but that has gone down significantly. I don't know if it's an Eternal September thing or what but that site has seemed to have regressed to memes and recycled content across all of the subreddits. I'm still learning about Mastodon but it seems like it utilizes the same concepts as Discord and other chat apps except it's federated which seems really cool to me.
- polaritron 8y agoMastodon really has the exact same feel as twitter. The difference being that CAP theorem produces really weird conversational effects. If you look at the myriad Mastodon domains, operating as single-instance hosted websites, on whatever infrastructure they deploy to, very, very few sites have more than 1,000 users, and any of the under 1,000 club are filled with mostly geeky accounts, and a fanout of a handful of lurker accounts per each identifiable personality. The one really, really huge Mastodon node is basically filled with sex workers (and their johns, presumably), and is operated out of Australia. That being said, consider what CAP theorem does to conversations as federated servers pop in and out of existence as they go offline. It's going to be link rot to all hell. You can figure that the prostitution Mastodon instance is probably going to experience some pressure, and eventually collapse. And not only that, any users on that trunk of the federation will disappear. So what happens to the followers, and the followed? Where do the conversations go? Does it matter? It's mostly the promotional efforts of ladies (and not-so-much-ladies), hawking their fare. Anywho, right now, suffice to say, Mastodon is in a weird place. The first people driven out of Twitter, were using Twitter as a bunker, after Backpage was dismantled. Then Twitter cracked down on those sorts of accounts, and now they're pioneering the largest Mastodon community in operation, because there are few open options. So, Mastodon is likely going to become associated with that sort of Craigslist vibe, but in the form of a Web 2.0, single page web app, right now. And where that will take things in the future is anybody's game, but we see what happens to these underground bunkers over and over again. Mastodon will unfold a little bit differently though, because of it's Twitter-style publicity angle.
- mikekij 8y agoI stopped using Facebook in December of 2015, but I desperately want to know if they count my “sign in with Facebook” SSO uses toward their DAU count. It would be really misleading if they do.
- em0ney 8y agoI don't think it's just Americans for what it's worth.
- alkonaut 8y agoI use facebook as a calendar and event planner. And I don't see another service overtaking theirs any time soon - for the simple reason that no other service can hope to get 99% of a persons social circle onto one single service again. I think the window for that kind of dominance has closed. The question is whether facebook can afford to pay the bills in 20 years when its only us 70's and 80's kids that still use it for only messenger and calendars/events.
- yAnonymous 8y agoFacebook confronts people with their own contradicting behavior from the past and people hate that.
- sytelus 8y agoThis is complete BS survey. None of these are reflected in Facebook DAU/MAU. If anything they have gone Ted bit up. Pew Research has been becoming a joke since past couple of years and mostly becoming just sensentionalist link bait grabbing headline generators. Just over half of Facebook users ages 18 and older (54%) say they have adjusted their privacy settings in the past 12 months, according to a new Pew Research Center survey. Around four-in-ten (42%) say they have taken a break from checking the platform for a period of several weeks or more, while around a quarter (26%) say they have deleted the Facebook app from their cellphone.
- stevenicr 8y agoas to where I think all surveys are tinged with multiple layers of BS for various reasons, I do think it's quite possible for 30% or so of people to change how much and in what ways they use fbook, and yet fbook could still show high numbers of DAU/MAU - certainly not everyone who deletes the app totally stops using it - they can access the portal in other ways. I can also imagine that older people could be lured into using it more while younger people abandon it nearly completely, which may show a steady MAU and that Americans relationship with Fbook is indeed changing - they can both be true I believe.
- IkmoIkmo 8y agoOne of the big failures I think is for FB to not push friends lists more. The default is that you have 500 people on FB that you sort of know, and that you don't reject people that add you but you barely meet. So you end up not feeling like you want to share anything because your supervisor is on there, which you're work-friends with, but not close enough to share just anything. For example, all my friends in their 20s will post pictures of them at various raves but none of them will post it on Facebook. Everyone knows half the people there are on ecstacy, which is fine for your friends to know, but perhaps not all of your colleagues. There's a great deal of limiting self-expression on FB, because it's become such a public place. You're left with people who keep very small facebook circles, which is a tiny minority of mostly inactive users, people with sizeable circles who keep quiet because things you're open about to your 20 closest people, you don't want to share with the other 480, and there's people with huge circles who are the most vocal and often extreme in opinions and things they share. Facebook has all the basic functionality to change this, moreso than instagram for example. You can put all your contacts in a limited-profile list, which reveals a profile picture, a handful of holiday pics and posts you explicitly set to public. And then you can put 20 friends in your close circle, which every picture and post is revealed to by default. This can be even more private and intimate than say instagram. But FB doesn't push it. So people end up having 1 privacy setting for everyone, accepting everyone on facebook, and rejecting most people on instagram. Most friends I know will rather accept 100 distant accounts (travel, food, lifestyle accounts of individuals abroad or companies) on instagram than accept a colleague that's 10 years older that you have lunch with everyday and are cool with, and have been facebook friends with since your first week at the company.