18 ms·
YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers
- tombert 8y agoI noticed with MetroPCS, when I download a Youtube video offline, it's very slow. However, if I turn on my Private Internet Access VPN, it's fast. This has been going on for at least two years; well before net neutrality was destroyed. I'm no expert in this, but I feel that that's a relatively definitive proof that they're throttling it.
- slededit 8y agoWireless carriers had exemptions from Net Neutrality. The basis was that bandwidth was much more limited and they needed more flexibility to manage it.
- phobosdeimos 8y agoNot where I live, net neutrality applies to T-mobile too. Throttling on purpose is illegal.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoIt is very hard to tell the difference between throttling and congestion with that kind of example.
- null0pointer 8y agoWhy is it hard to tell between throttling and congestion? Maybe my understanding is wrong but they are still sending the same amount of data. But when it's encrypted traffic from the VPN the ISP can't sniff and throttle.
- jerkstate 8y agothrottling and congestion both drop packets in a TCP stream, which signals the sender to slow down it's sending rate. congestion means that the packets are lost because they can't be pushed through a networking device (because the output port is busy and there isn't enough buffer, for example if the peering link between an ISP and a busy content provider is at maximum capacity); throttling means there is enough buffer, but the networking device is programmed with a policy to drop packets from certain streams (for example, those with an IP address originating from a content provider) A VPN circumvents congestion or throttling not by virtue of being encrypted but by having a different source IP or traversing a different route & different network ports/links from other packets going to the high bandwidth use content provider(s)
- anoifeh 8y agoData transmitted using a VPN goes through a different route that might not be congested.
- astura 8y agoThe same amount of data, but not by the same route.
- michaelt 8y agoIf at the peering point my ISP has two 1000mbps connections to Youtube and limits them both to 50% speed, that's "throttling". If they set one to full speed and unplug the other, that's "congestion". From a customer's perspective, the symptoms - slow Youtube videos - are indistinguishable.
- kbuck 8y agoMetroPCS is T-Mobile under different branding. T-Mobile is fairly open about their throttling practices (you have to purchase their "ONE Plus" plan to have un-throttled video), but MetroPCS puts it in their rather long "Network Disclosure"[0]: "All current MetroPCS plans include video optimization features that are always enabled, which, when connected to the cellular network, deliver a DVD quality (typically 480p) video experience at up to 1.5 Mbps with minimal buffering while streaming ("Data Maximizer"). Customers may, for an additional charge, add on a native resolution video feature, disabling optimization for their device. Some qualifying video providers may choose to self-optimize their video content or opt-out of the Data Maximizer program." [0]: https://www.metropcs.com/terms-conditions/network-disclosure.html https://www.metropcs.com/terms-conditions/network-disclosure...
- Drakim 8y ago> Customers may, for an additional charge, add on a native resolution video feature, disabling optimization That's such beautiful double think. We have this amazing feature for you, and for just a small charge you may turn it off.
- null0pointer 8y agoIn Australia I noticed my downloads from some sources were much slower than others. I have two examples: 1. YouTube vs Netflix. When I would try to watch YouTube in the evenings it would not buffer fast enough for continuous playback. While Netflix would. I assumed that my ISP was prioritising Netflix traffic. When I turn on my VPN YouTube plays much smoother in full quality. 2. Steam downloads. When I would download a game off the automatic download server is would start at full speed (Blistering 100mbps on NBN...) and after a few seconds drop down to single digit kbps. When I switched the download server to the Singapore one I would get constant full speed downloads. Could either be throttling that specific server, or there is something wrong with that server. I switched ISP and now both of those issues are gone. From my understanding that points pretty strongly towards throttling. Though admittedly my knowledge may be lacking. Note: This is for a wired connection. But I thought it was relevant anyway.
- rosege 8y agoCan you name the guilty for your fellow Aussies? Also Netflix might be better / not throttled due to their OpenConnect program which would be saving the ISP traffic https://openconnect.netflix.com/en/ https://openconnect.netflix.com/en/
- mcpherrinm 8y agoThe first example is more likely congestion than throttling, but that's only really a difference in the manner that your ISP is being cheap (and not having enough bandwidth upstream). Using a VPN in this case is probably causing your traffic to take a different route than everyone else's youtube traffic, thus avoiding the congestion bottleneck. Netflix may have a local cache nearer to you, so you don't hit the congestion (and the amount of content in a Netflix cache is probably a lot less than Youtube). Example 2 could be a packet-lossy network which causes your TCP connection to ramp back. If it's constant packet loss, your TCP connection will probably get slower and slower: TCP uses packet loss as a signal it's going too fast, but if that's not the cause of the loss, your connection will just keep getting slower.
- criddell 8y ago
- pmx 8y agoI used to experience this in the UK with Virgin Media. Youtube would be unwatchable and any downloads from the Google Play Store would timeout 80% of the time. Switched my devices over to a VPN and the issue went away immediately. They deny it but thats pretty damning evidence af far as I'm concerned.
- calv 8y agoHmm, I never experienced that. I just experience their crappy wifi.
- 7952 8y agoWhich could be an issue with the router, device hardware, or even ChromeCast. Anecdotally Youtube seems to interact weirdly sometimes and trigger bugs in other devices.
- martinald 8y agoUnlikely, could also just mean congested upstream routes/bad routing somewhere. Your VPN means traffic takes a different route that isn't affected. I'm 99% sure VM don't do any throttling (on downstream at least).
- throwaway77384 8y agoI had the same problem for quite a while and was told it was a peering issue. So while they were not throttling, they somehow messed something up elsewhere and for months my VPN was significantly faster than an un-VPN'ed connection for some bizarre reason. Proof: https://imgur.com/a/JflXR https://imgur.com/a/JflXR
- throwaway77384 8y agoSame thing. Connection speed using VPN suddenly doubled and tripled, depending on the time of day. The problem went away after a few months. Very bizarre though, and of course no transparency from Virgin on this.
- TorKlingberg 8y ago
- gnicholas 8y agoMight be useful to add "mobile" before "carriers" in the title. It's still bad, but not as bad as if wired ISPs were doing it, since mobile carriers (usually) tell the customers that they throttle, and under what circumstances.
- vezycash 8y agoHaving neutralized net neutrality, throttling a.k.a network decongestion, would become common. And as predicted, these two companies have the financial power to make deals and the smaller guys would get screwed. Imagine Skype / whatsapp startups - telecom income threats being introduced today.
- dingaling 8y agoThrottling has existed long before net neutrality. Just about any public wifi service, for example, will throttle video streaming to unusable levels. And why would YouTube and Netflix pay ISPs for better treatment? That would create an escalating fee scenario that would become unaffordable.
- jachee 8y ago> That would create an escalating fee scenario that would become unaffordable. Never underestimate the power of capitalist greed. See also: education and healthcare costs.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoNet neutrality was not stopping this behavior, which has been happening for years * . How quickly do we forget things like the widely publicized NetFlix + Comcast arrangement... Anyhow, in that monstrosity of a net neutrality bill every single rule was qualified with a "Thou shall not [...] except for reasonable network management." ISPs were completely free to throttle so long as they could do so under the pretext of reasonable network management. You'll note that even lacking clear rules, they're still using the same sort of language: “We do not automatically throttle any customers,” said Rich Young, a Verizon spokesman. “To manage traffic on our network, we implement network management, which is significantly different than blanket throttling.” --- * = granted, in the past years we only had a legally sustained net neutrality for an extremely small window of time, but most people do not realize this and think that we've had net neutrality for years and things only recently changed.
- amelius 8y agoCan't the FCC make some objective measurements and penalize the offending ISPs?
- rb666 8y agoUntil Americans start voting with their brain instead of some other unknown body part, your government will keep screwing you. This is just one of the many faces of this drama.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- anoifeh 8y agoI assume Americans vote with their brain, but they don't place "Netflix being throttled" at the top of their list of priorities (and rightly so).
- jakamau 8y agoAs an American, I've come to the cynical view that most vote based on their identity, or their perceived identity, instead of specific issue priorities. After someone has firmly established their "identity", active debate on a specific plank of their party/identity's platform is received as a personal attack. When the party/identity diverges from the person's personal ethics, they won't seek out a new identity/party (too much sunk cost) but instead rationalize why their current identity/party is still coherent with their individual stance. It doesn't matter if "Netflix being throttled" is at the top of their list of priorities, it matters if the identity/party they align with makes it a messaging priority.
- narrator 8y agoYouTube makes the argument that they can ban unpopular, but legal speech because they're a private company, so why can't carriers throttle them because they are private companies? The carriers are regulated monopolies, but Youtube is an unregulated monopoly. One is under the jurisdiction of the government, the other is free to ban whomever they want whenever they want.
- ric2b 8y agoYouTube isn't a monopoly, their competition is one click away. ISP's are often regional monopolies or even if they're not, the switching costs are large and usually involve breaking a 2-year exclusivity agreement. I do think that YouTube shouldn't be censoring content based on political views, but it's also not at all comparable to an ISP.
- xienze 8y ago> YouTube isn't a monopoly, their competition is one click away. The mere existence of competitors does not preclude one from having a monopoly.
- mrep 8y agoBy definition, it does "A monopoly exists when a specific person or enterprise is the only supplier of a particular commodity" [0]. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly
- EduardoBautista 8y agoCall them a de facto monopoly then.
- izacus 8y agoDefending one anti-consumer shitty practice with another will not improve either of the situations. The end result is that you now live in a shitty situation where your company isn't providing you the service performance you bought. Why on earth would you defend that?
- AndyMcConachie 8y agoDoes anyone have a link to the actual research? I've looked around a bit for it, but all I can find are these general news stories. I want more technically detailed information.
- black6 8y agoThis reflects the sad state of modern journalism. It costs nothing to link to the original study, which is online somewhere, in some format. Nothing, that is, besides lost advert views and potential clicks.
- andrewbinstock 8y ago>It costs nothing to link to the original study, which is online somewhere, in some format a) You have no way of knowing whether the data beyond what is linked to in the article is available online. b) Finding it is not free if it requires the reporter's time. c) Bloomberg is hardly an example of the "sad state of modern journalism."
- amanaplanacanal 8y agoOn b) if the reporter doesn't have the link, how the F is he writing the story? Is he just copying from somebody else's reporting?
- droopybuns 8y agohttps://dd.meddle.mobi/td_details.html https://dd.meddle.mobi/td_details.html http://david.choffnes.com/pubs/imc095-molavi-kakhkiA.pdf http://david.choffnes.com/pubs/imc095-molavi-kakhkiA.pdf They need to publish their source code for me to believe their app.
- kmfrk 8y agoImagine being a Twitch streamer whose livelihood is streaming to the website, and out of the blue, your ISP just starts throttling you. What a nightmare; I've already seen streamers who had to consider moving because of continuous internet issues.
- tantalor 8y agoThen upgrade your residential internet service to a business plan, & deduct from taxes as business expense.
- vuln 8y agoThank you!!! It drives me insane that residential customers expect business grade service, service support, and uptime. Yet they want to pay a fraction of the price.
- guelo 8y agoThen the ISPs will start requiring *Enterprise Premium", then they'll make you get "Enterprise Premium with Streaming package", then you'll have to get "Xfinity Triple Play Enterprise Premium with the Extended Streaming Bundle, up to 500 Subscribers Package". It's all bullshit for then to keep charging you more. Thanks Net Neutrality.
- jessaustin 8y agoPerhaps you meant, "thanks government-enforced monopoly"?
- Spivak 8y agoI think more realistically I think you mean, "thanks natural market effect where even among competing entities there's strong pressure to charge very close to customer's willingness to pay since undercutting your competition risks a race to the bottom where all competitors suffer."
- close04 8y ago> we implement network management, which is significantly different than blanket throttling [Verizon spokesperson] Correct. It's selective throttling.
- scarface74 8y agoAnd I’m perfectly okay with that for wireless carriers. Unlike wired based data transport, you can’t just throw money at infrastructure and get more bandwidth. There is a known limit to how much data you can carry over a certain frequency and only certain frequencies are good for data.
- ehnto 8y agoBad news for Australia, where people switch to their phone data when they need serious bandwidth because it's faster than our wired infrastructure.
- scarface74 8y agoIn the grand scheme of things, neither is our wired infrastructure in the US. Upload speeds are usually abysmal. Comcast’s gigabit plan costs over $100 has 35Mbps upload speed and still I believe has a data cap. But I don’t even bother getting on WiFi when I go somewhere. My cellular data is usually more reliable.
- Ajedi32 8y ago> you can’t just throw money at infrastructure and get more bandwidth Can't you? You can always just keep decreasing the size of the individual cells in the network, right? Surely we aren't hitting any strict limitations in that respect yet, are we?
- crankylinuxuser 8y agoOf course you can do that. But each individual cell in an area raises the noise floor of that chunk of spectrum. And Shannon Information theory then has some pretty harsh things to say about that.
- mbreese 8y agoTo me, the real question isn’t if the mobile carriers throttle video, it’s if they equally throttle video. Video throttling has been happening for a long time. But what I’d really like to know is if a carrier (say ATT) was throttling Netflix, but not their own DirecTV app. DirecTV is already zero rated on ATT, but I’m not sure if it is also throttled.
- mrweasel 8y agoPrecisely. It's fair to opt to throttle large downloads and video streaming, if that's what they need to do to ensure that other users have fast access to other services like maps, search, emails and so on. That's completely reasonable, no one user should be allowed to saturate the connection to a cell tower with a video stream or torrent download. I can understand that it's easier to just select the biggest sources of traffic and throttle them, but that doesn't make it okay. The least they could do to show good faith is throttle their own service.
- paulie_a 8y agoNo it is not fair or reasonable. If I get a certain plan I should be able to utilize it to the full extent. If a company is incapable of providing the service they should not sell that service plan.
- mrweasel 8y agoI sort of see your point, but what you're arguing is that they should just change the wording of the contracts. You're not going to get what you want anyway. We ran into that issue with the marketing department and upper management when I work at a telco. We where starting to sell 3G USB modems, and "plan" was that we'd start to push internet via 3G, because it was 7Mbit at the time and that would be plenty fast. There would be no need to sell ADSL connections anymore. The issue, which the people responsible for the network pointed out is that the 7Mbit was SHARED. It assumed that the user was alone on that tower. Also there's a limit on the connection to the tower it self, these are fiber now, so not a major issue, but a limiting factor at some point. Internet via 4G is certainly faster than 7Mbit now, but it's still a shared capacity. If you surf the net, check your emails and such, it's in burst so it's fine to share. Streaming is you using a constant amount of traffic for a sustained period of time and that's not what the cell network is designed to do.
- JustSomeNobody 8y ago> If you want high-definition video, you can pay more, the carriers say. Yep. This is what people warned about. https://i.huffpost.com/gen/1567010/original.jpg https://i.huffpost.com/gen/1567010/original.jpg
- overcast 8y agoWith the amount of actual non "Original" content disappearing from streaming services, I've ramped up my BluRay plan to 3 Discs out at a time. It's the only way to watch 99% of movies anymore. This bullshit throttling makes an already poor streaming audio / video quality experience even worse.
- kaustyap 8y agoOne of the organization which I know had developed network monitoring tool to determine quality of experience for youtube videos by analyzing packets flowing over the network. The customers of the product were mostly carriers. So obviously they are watching and interested to know bandwidth usage for youtube.
- yAnonymous 8y ago1. Display warning to the user that their ISP is throttling the traffic or doesn't provide enough bandwidth 2. Show them local alternative ISPs who don't have these problems 3. Take a signing bonus when users who had the warning displayed change ISPs Just one idea of many, but content providers and users could put a lot more pressure on ISPs to prevent this, at least in areas where alternatives are available.
- dboreham 8y agoBecause there are so many alternative ISPs to choose from and because there's so much money to be made by starting a new ISP.
- yAnonymous 8y agoSpeak for yourself. There are plenty of alternatives where I am from (Europe) and running small, local ISPs works just fine. The situation in the 'country of the free and awesome'© is supposedly different, but that doesn't invalidate my statement in any way.
- grendelt 8y agoBut this is not a Net Neutrality issue. It's my understanding that NN only applies to wired carriers. Wireless was exempted from NN.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> But this is not a Net Neutrality issue. Yes, it is. > It's my understanding that NN only applies to wired carriers. Wireless was exempted from NN. Your understanding is wrong on several levels: (1) Net neutrality is a common name for a set of principles that predate (even as an official guiding philosophy at the FCC, though the FCC consistently used “Open Internet” instead of “net neutrality” as the name) the 2010 and 2015 Open Internet orders, and as such apply equally to all carriers. (2) The distinction made in the 2010 and 2015 orders was between mobile and fixed carriers, not wireline and wireless. (3) While much weaker rules were applied to mobile carriers in the 2010 order, that wasn't true in the 2015 order, and in any case both orders applied to both fixed and mobile carriers.
- anderber 8y agoAlthough Net Neutrality under the Obama admin only narrowly applied to wireless carries, one of the things that applied was discriminatory blocking/slowing downs of specific content (if I remember correctly).
- Kagerjay 8y agoI have a time warner cable subsidary as my ISP. I started noticing throttling from my carrier about 2-3 months ago. I blocked 2 common CDN access points and everything just went so much faster. https://www.drivereasy.com/knowledge/youtube-running-slow-on-my-computer/ https://www.drivereasy.com/knowledge/youtube-running-slow-on... I still had hit or miss issues every so often and get throttling, but I noticed it was substantially less over time. This might be purely ancedotal though. But the only issues I had were youtube throttling, I ran speedof.me tests during this time and its been fairly consistent
- SippinLean 8y agoTime Warner Cable the company no longer exists. It was acquired by Charter Communications. Time Warner Cable the internet brand also no longer exists. It was rebranded as Spectrum (Charter's existing brand).
- pq0ak2nnd 8y ago#4: Update the Flash I think Flash can be safely removed. I've been flash free for at least a year and all major content sites are supported.
- Spivak 8y agoI'm not exactly sure how to interpret your experience since it sounds far more like congestion than throttling. By blocking CDN endpoints you were inadvertently routing your traffic to somewhere uncommonly hit which had more available bandwidth.
- antpls 8y agoIsn't congestion and rerouting supposed to be automatically managed by TCP-over-IP (more or less) ?
- bogomipz 8y ago>'"John Donovan, head of AT&T’s satellite, phone and internet operations, said "unequivocally we are not selectively throttling by what property it is. We don’t look at any traffic differently than any other traffic." He compared AT&T throttling to an electricity grid where some customers sign up for rolling blackouts in return for cheaper service. That’s what Choffnes’s research is detecting, the AT&T executive said."' Except that nobody would ever sign up for a cheaper electrical service in exchange for rolling blackouts. It's also an interesting choice for a metaphor given that power companies are regulated utilities that would never be allowed to offer this as a result of that regulation. Lastly AT&T service is not cheap to to begin with. I think this statement really crystalizes the absurdity of these carriers and the buffoons running them. Remember the FCC's reasoning for rolling back Net Neutrality were "paving the way for better, faster and cheaper Internet access for consumers."[1] Exactly zero of those objectives are being achieved by throttling consumer's bandwidth. [1] https://www.fcc.gov/restoring-internet-freedom https://www.fcc.gov/restoring-internet-freedom
- ukyrgf 8y ago> Except that nobody would ever sign up for a cheaper electrical service in exchange for rolling blackouts. My power company does excatly that: https://www.fpl.com/save/programs/on-call.html https://www.fpl.com/save/programs/on-call.html
- rlucas 8y agoYes, the idea of ceding to the power company (in exchange for a credit / rate reduction) the ability to turn off your power in whole or part is well known and is called "Demand Response" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demand_response https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demand_response
- bogomipz 8y agoNo, that is not the same thing at all. Not even close. A rolling black out is an involuntary action. It is also an action that results in total loss of power, hence the term "blackout." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolling_blackout https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolling_blackout
- eurticket 8y agoSeems like it is time to separate the bundling of telecoms. No one that provides internet should be able to provide other services that would be a conflict of interest and promote an incentive of bad business practices such as throttling. What is the downside for Television companies to be restricted from expanding into separate services in the same space while providing internet and vice versa?
- erickj 8y ago"Carriers say they’re throttling to manage internet traffic. To deliver the videos people want to watch on their phones, sacrifices in speed are required, according to the three largest U.S. wireless companies" Moving from the US to Switzerland a few years ago really opened my eyes to how much US wireless carriers were fucking me as a customer. On Swisscom, my mobile provider, I get unlimited unthrottled data (with tethering!) for ~$99/month. With this I get speeds > 100Mbs on the "good side" of my apartment. And 60Mbs on the "slow side" of my apartment: I also get these speeds in the Alps. For another point of comparison Salt (rebranded Orange here), offers a home internet plan of 10 Gbps + 250 TV channels + a free Apple TV for $49 / month. https://fiber.salt.ch/en/?utm_campaign=saltfiberen&utm_medium=homepage&utm_source=banner#/ https://fiber.salt.ch/en/?utm_campaign=saltfiberen&utm_mediu...
- scarejunba 8y agoPart of the problem is that when you point out things like this, Americans on the Internet frequently react as if you are insulting their nation and invent nonsensical reasons for why their Internet must be slow.
- ectospheno 8y agoI'm an American and I understand why my internet is slow. So do all of my friends and coworkers. What do you propose we actually do about it?
- skh 8y agoVote and encourage others to vote. Also, it’s worth pointing out comparisons to Europe and Japan to help dispel the myth that we are a shining light to the rest of the world and that we are number 1.
- scarejunba 8y agoSupport things like this https://savecompetition.com https://savecompetition.com and similar initiatives that are constantly being brought up. Enable providers like Sonic to survive by telling your representatives.
- legohead 8y agoNo study needs to be done. The carriers are publicly admitting this on their websites, just go look at their plans. The more expensive plans have "HD-streaming" of video content. They even tell you X plan gets you 480p and Z plan gets you 720p. What else could this mean other than they are throttling videos?
- Itaxpica 8y agoUsually the fine print will say that these are expected video qualities based on the downstream bandwidth provided, not that they're literally charging you for each specific quality.
- dylan604 8y agoTo the point, I was offered via email a reduction in my monthly bill if I volunteered to have any and all videos streamed to my wireless device force delivered as an SD stream. There was also a separate email offer to lower my monthly fee for home internet connection if I agreed to allow them to inject their own advertising in my network traffic. The problem with all of that, is how do I know they are not doing it anyways? I don't trust these ISPs any further than I can throw them.
- vagab0nd 8y agoI'm curious, how can they inject their data if https is used?
- draw_down 8y agoDarn, if only there were some way the network providers had some kind of neutrality with respect to how they move traffic... hmm. Just a silly fantasy I had.
- anderspitman 8y agoI've thought it would be fun to try and sell a device with dual ethernet ports that people can plug in between their router and modem, which would constantly monitor their internet performance and give them a real time dashboard, in addition to reports. The goal being identifying how consistent your speed from your ISP is in general and detecting cases of throttling etc.
- jsgo 8y agoOn the T-Mobile side, were they leveraging the "Binge On Us" or similar setup? I have T-Mobile One w/ the international one plus or plus one (can't remember. The naming kind of stinks) add on and I've never noticed slow downs of any sort for video.
- shdh 8y agoMy Netflix seems like it gets randomly blurry almost every time I watch it now. (Using Google Fiber)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- benlorenzetti 8y agoNone of these articles ever talk about any concept of economic "distance". This one at least discusses the need for throttling if you read past the headline. End consumers pay an set price for generic data at their ISPs corporate node, but data that comes from further nodes fundamentally costs more, as do large sources at peak times. Personally, I would rather the ISPs sort this out between themselves and other corporations rather than graduate my bill based on which sites/times I browse. The best would be a patchwork of municipal, regional, and private owned wired ISPs, private wireless carriers, and an open standard for peering agreements with concepts of "distance" and "congestion". In response to the title of the article and ones like it: why is it surprising or "evil" that a company charging destinations a fixed price throttles at peak times or tries to be selective about data sources, even asking some over a certain threshold to reduce or foot part of the bill? It's OK to be suspicious of quasi public/private companies, but I need to see more evidence and more logic in news reporting to conclude people are acting immorally here. For example, outright blocking of content at the behest of politicians or differential throttling of data with equal "distance" outside of a common price structure.