19 ms·
The 20-Hour Flight Is Coming, and It May Have a Gym and Bunks
- maxxxxx 8y agoI like the idea of bunk beds. Instead of 3 people sitting next to each other let them lie above each other. Being able to sleep during long flights would make my life much better.
- CodeCube 8y agoBunks, combined with being able to get up for brief visits to the head, and perhaps a small bar (for food, drinks, and coffee), would be a dream long distance commute for me.
- alxhill 8y agoI like this idea too. Sadly I doubt regulators would go for it without substantial modification - all lie-flat beds have to be in the upright position for take-off and landing at the moment, for example.
- sandworm101 8y agoWho gets top bunk? Seriously. How do all the old or disabled people climb up and down? How are people belted in? What does an evacuation look like. Lots of people have thought about this concept. It just isnt practical.
- jandrese 8y agoIn my mental image of this layout the plane has 1/2 seats and 1/2 bunks. People who want to sit take a seat. People who want to lay down take a bunk. I always imagined it as open ended boxes so you have to climb in kind of awkwardly, but you don't have all of the seatbelt issues. I also imagined a little curtain you could close to block out the light if you want. Evacuation would be a problem though, especially for people crawling out of the bottom bunk. I've always assumed the evacuation problems were the reason this has never happened.
- kalleboo 8y agoI've always imagined basically a flying capsule hotel https://www.google.com/search?q=capsule+hotel&client=safari&rls=en&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjng_LVq5bdAhXKbrwKHVuZDVUQ_AUICygC https://www.google.com/search?q=capsule+hotel&client=safari&...
- jakobegger 8y agoI've travelled on night trains in Europe a bunch of times in a 6 bed compartment, and the solution is pretty simple. When you book a ticket, you can choose your preferred bed (top / middle / bottom), and there's a checkbox you can tick if you absolutely need the bottom bed. Somehow it all works out. It's really neat, because if you're travelling in a group and don't want to go to bed right away you can fold the top beds up and use the bottom beds as comfy benches. The problem with putting the same thing on an airplane is that it needs a lot of space. Seats offer way more density than bunk beds.
- sandworm101 8y agoTrains generally dont deal with turbulance. We cant have a situation where a 10000' drop sees people flying around the cabin. And doors/bars on each bunk would be a safety nightmare.
- TylerE 8y agoActually, bunks with some sort of safety netting, and all the other surfaces padded may well be safer. My understand is that most injuries during turbulence are due to flying objects, not the actual motion.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoSounds like a Chinese hard sleeper train ticket. The top bunk is kind of claustrophobic, however, and everyone hangs out on the bottom bunk during the day.
- SteveCoast 8y agoI spent some time on this a while ago and it's not quite as simple as I'd hoped. People typically need to be facing/laying along the axis of flight for the seatbelt to work. If you're laying at 90 degrees and there's a big (de/a)cceleration and you have a belt across your waist, you get folded in half hanging off the bed. If you stack three people on top of each other then the you need egress (space one one or both sides of the beds) which takes up a bunch of space to get back/forward. Most seats have the aisle as egress but you need more mini-aisles for bunkbeds. You might want to divide it and say some people have egress forward and some backward to save the space... but if there's some kind of emergency you want people to be able to go whatever way they want. If you think about roughly the volume of 3x3 seats (9 pax) then roughly speaking you could have three sets of three bunkbeds. But the curvature of the airframe means you don't have the same height near the window you do in the middle of the plane, and you may take away cabin baggage space. One way to get around this is to make the lowest bunk very low, like an inch off the deck, but that would mean a smaller market as you have to have pax who can get down low or climb up to the top. All of this is assuming you're trying to go for the same kind of density of pax as a plane has today. If you just want two bunks and charge more, or you want to have a seat and a bunk (so you sleep only half the flight or something then someone else gets the bunk...) then the space requirements all change. You can also just have some bunks or just in the middle rows on a widebody and on the outside have seats. Lastly, my memory is the flight computers will try to direct smaller aircraft movements in the vertical axis / pitch angle. Again from memory, but people get really sick if they have a bunch of movement side to side or at some other funny angle their vestibular system isn't used to. And with bunkbeds you might not have a window to look out of for a frame of reference to help. This is another constraint on how you lay people out on the plane. It's all fixable kind-of but not just "put in a bunch of bunkbeds and make the same amount of money / same price per seat-mile". Someone with more knowledge can probably list all the reasons the FAA wouldn't allow it. I still want bunkbeds though.
- schoen 8y ago> People typically need to be facing/laying along the axis of flight for the seatbelt to work. If you're laying at 90 degrees and there's a big (de/a)cceleration and you have a belt across your waist, you get folded in half hanging off the bed. I thought airplane seatbelts during cruise were more about controlling vertical movement than horizontal movement. At least, the strongest sudden accelerations that I've experienced under those conditions, and the strongest ones that I've heard about, were vertical.
- tim333 8y agoI wonder why no one has tried that. I'm guessing there's some safety reg about being seated for landing which a bunk wouldn't satisfy?
- Someone1234 8y agoOn Virgin Atlantic's flights they have a class called "Upper Class." It is essentially business class with some first class perks (like airport lounge access). Anyway, they have these unique seats that let you lay literally flat[0]. It is the only time I've ever slept on a flight, even most business class don't go flat they just tip back. So sign me on for bunk beds. [0] https://c8.alamy.com/comp/E87ARA/upper-class-on-a-virgin-atlantic-flight-seats-become-beds-or-can-be-E87ARA.jpg https://c8.alamy.com/comp/E87ARA/upper-class-on-a-virgin-atl...
- maxxxxx 8y agoI have looked at these longingly....
- Someone1234 8y agoThey're everything you imagine they are. Some other business class might give you more room or perks, but lay flat beds are extremely rare (only other example off the top of my head is the A380's private rooms).
- bolasanibk 8y agoThey are becoming more common. Check the table on this page for a list. https://www.seatguru.com/charts/longhaul_business_class.php https://www.seatguru.com/charts/longhaul_business_class.php
- SteveCoast 8y agoLay flat seems pretty common internationally, United Polaris for example...
- eyd68 8y agoLie flat beds in international, long-haul business class are common enough that I consider anything else Premium Eco. For example, Norwegian Premium is sold as Business Class (J), but I've been just as comfortable in British Premium Economy. They are priced about the same.
- sunstone 8y agoBack in the early 90's the Chinese railway system had some cars set up exactly like this. They were called "hard sleepers" and they had a vinyl cover over a bit of padding with a narrowish (i'm guessing) plywood base. They looked not promising but they were surprisingly comfortable for even two or three day rides. You could either sit or lie down on them. A modern airliner probably wouldn't go for plywood but if the safety aspects could be worked out the general design would be a big improvement for long haul flights.
- kart23 8y agoI don't think the FAA would allow it. Imagine turbulence and suddenly 20 people get thrown a few inches into the air and come crashing back down. Not safe at all, plus that would feel scary to passengers. You'd also need to find a way to secure them into their bunks to not get thrown to the sides.
- Jazz4241 8y agoYeah, I agree with you!! I have trouble with 6 hours long flight where you can't sleep properly on those chairs depriving me of the sleep and thus making me feel sick!
- arnon 8y agoWe've been seeing this since the 60s. DC-10 promised it. L-1011 promised it (https://www.psa-history.org/about_psa/aircraft/lockheed-l-1011/the-lower-lounge-of-the-l-1011-lockheed-promotional-picture/ https://www.psa-history.org/about_psa/aircraft/lockheed-l-10...). 747 promised it (https://vinepair.com/wine-blog/the-glamorous-airline-lounges-in-the-sky-from-the-1970s/ https://vinepair.com/wine-blog/the-glamorous-airline-lounges...). A380 promised it. It's not going to happen, because airlines want to cram as many seats as possible, even in business class.
- jbob2000 8y agoIt's not airlines that want to do this, it's the customers who want to fly around the world for as cheap as possible. Nobody values the time they spend travelling, they just want it to be as quick and cheap as possible. It'd cost you $10,000+ to take a 20 hour flight with a gym and bunk beds. Fuck that, I can stay in Aruba at a 5 star resort for a week at that price.
- rm_-rf_slash 8y agoAt a certain level of income/wealth, the time spent traveling is valued higher than the dollar amount. That’s why premium airlines include first class suites with beds. If those offerings weren’t profitable they wouldn’t exist.
- nostrademons 8y agoThe problem is that the market segments such that these travelers are no longer served by commercial aviation. If you are the sort of person whose time is worth $10K/hour, you fly private. You get your bed, and gym, and first-class suite and attendants who wait on your every move, and you also don't have to go through security or wait in the terminal or deal with other passengers. The lie-flat business class seats aren't actually for those sorts of people, they are for ordinary corporate mid-level employees who fly for business. I have some Googler friends in Australia who will regularly take the bed-seats on the Sydney => SFO run. The company pays for it - when you're going to be paying the employee $10K anyway for the two weeks they're away, and they're generating well over that in value by having the next 3 months of work synced up with what the home office is doing, why would you not?
- crooked-v 8y agoI feel like a capsule hotel-style bunk would be way more comfortable than current airline seats for single travelers.
- GFischer 8y agoThat's basically business class :)
- crooked-v 8y agoBut if you stack them, you have a higher passenger density than economy while still making each person more comfortable.
- GFischer 8y agoYes, that's what they were discussing somewhere else in the thread. I think there are some FAA regulation issues preventing it. The workaround seems to be this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17880748 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17880748 but it loses cargo money.
- heeen2 8y agoAre there issues with safety and evacuation or why has it not happened yet?
- olliej 8y agoMoney. Space for a “gym” means space with no one it for take off and landing: so that’s an immediate drop in passengers. Similar issues for “bunks”. For it to work they would have to be bunks for the entire flight. That means you probably can’t use them for short haul flights (so your plane is less useful in general), you gain accessibility issues (people who can use seats may not be able to climb into upper level bunks. This is ignoring whether a bunk would be comfortable - you’re going to be constrained for movement (basically to retain passenger count there has to still be 1:1 bed->seat conversion, so beds would be as wide as a chair, and you’d need 3-4 levels of beds). Then there’s safety - how quickly can you get out of your bed in an emergency is one thing, but how do you also ensure that no one stands on anyone while getting out, etc
- rjsw 8y agoBunks may not take up more space, there are long-distance buses with seats that convert into bunks for the same number of passengers.
- jandrese 8y agoThose seats are huge compared to airline seats. If you had that much space in the airline seat this wouldn't be nearly as necessary.
- olliej 8y agoIgnoring other issues, that means you're making the seats movable in significant ways, so they have to be engineered to take the loads of landing repeatedly for decades without breaking - that will probably increase the weight a lot (compare the construction of plastic bench seats in most buses, to the construction of long haul passenger buses.
- digi_owl 8y ago
- veritas3241 8y agoHaving just done a close to 20 hour flight (sort of - 6 hours CPT to ADD, just enough time to go to another plane, 14 hours ADD to IAD via a technical stop in Dublin), I've got to say just how absolutely miserable it is to fly for a long period of time on a full flight. Particularly if you're taller than 6'2" (~1.9m) and you have broader shoulders, you're going to be massively uncomfortable. Yeah, I want a cheap flight, but if there was a small perk where I could physically lie flat for ~15 minutes at some point during the flight, I would pay for that. I haven't been able to really deload my spine for pushing 48 hours (aside from some psuedo-yoga stretching while standing) due to further connections and layovers and it sucks. International flight is an amazing, painful miracle of science and technology. Maybe SpaceX's BFR will make it better :-) But I highly doubt we'll ever see a reasonably priced long-haul flight with a gym available to us peasants.
- kleiba 8y agoBeen there, done that (6'2, Australia <-> Europe, multiple times). I couldn't agree more. The fact that there is no way to fully stretch my legs while seated is driving me nuts on such long flights. I get that they have to cramp in as many seats into a plane as they can in order to get the prices down to a point where normal people are willing to pay for a ticket. But it's really such a pain in the butt. Would I pay double the price for a ticket to get a bed? Probably not: long distance flights are already expensive. And knowing how everything on planes is smaller than in real-life, I'm sure whatever they'd sell me as "a bed" would not really be accommodating either. As a consequence, I now just avoid these long distance trips. A pity for one who loves to travel but on the upside, it's better for the environment anyway.
- fyfy18 8y agoIf you have a long trip with a connection, most airlines will charge you the same whether you get the earliest connection or get one a few days later. If you aren’t in a rush this is a good way to break it up, and travel to somewhere different. Yes it costs more booking a hotel for a couple of nights, but it’s still probably going to be cheaper than upgrading to business class. You usually have to book it directly through their website (look for “multi city”) rather than through an agent.
- myrandomcomment 8y agoUgh. I have 2 weeks, 8 flights lined up for work soon. Longest flight is 13 hours and average flight is 6. I do 100K miles a year. I do not want a direct 20 hour flight as all this stuff about bunks, bars, etc. will never come. They will just squeeze in more seats. Let's stop wasting money on this and work out faster planes. I want SFO to HND in 2 hours.
- mcgarnagle 8y agocorrect, the article and accompanied video is nonsense with regards to "everything being on the table" in terms of design.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoIf you are flying that much, you should have the miles to often get upgraded right? Many companies have a policy that their employees can go business class if they fly so much a month, with the idea that they won’t hate their lives.
- atourgates 8y agoYes. Unless op is spreading their flying all over the place, they should be at top-tier status on just about any airline/alliance they fly. Practically, that should mean first or business class upgrades on nearly all their domestic travel, and a fair amount of their international travel.
- myrandomcomment 8y agoYes for what it is worth I have god status on a single airline (and thus their alliance). I always put in for an upgrade, however most flights are getting quite full (full because the economy is doing well, so making money, but less seats). For the last year I have flown ~50 times and have been upgraded about 2/3 of the time. I work for a startup so business is out for everyone, CEO on down. We do pay for premium economy which on international is better with more room then economy. Of the 8 flights on this trip I have one confirmed upgrade and waitlisted for the others. My guess is I will maybe receive an upgrade on half. Now that being said I have used miles for family vacations (all in business) more then once so there is that. :)
- LinuxBender 8y agoSince we are fantasizing here, I would prefer large tubes underground and magnetic lift on coaster style rails that can get me around the world in minutes. Since we have those tubes, we can run fiber optic cables along side them. Until then, I will stick with video conferencing. I am too grumpy to sit in a plane more than two hours.
- contingencies 8y agoIn China, the largest high speed train network in the world, current technology's realistic speeds for realistic routes work out to around 200km/hr against an 'as the crow flies' distance (reference: recent 6 hour journey). This is actually very competitive with flying by the time you've done the 'get out of town' and 'security theater' parts, then the 'get back in to town' part for sort of 1000-2000km distances. After that, it's better to fly.
- LinuxBender 8y agoMakes sense. I shall wait for the 4th or 5th generation of teleporters then.
- kreeWall 8y agoI think it is worth noting that Singapore Airlines used to have a 19-hour flight from Singapore to NYC, which it flew for 9 years. Having been on this flight, the experience wasn't terrible and there was plenty of space to walk around and spread your legs, despite it being a non-A380 or anything fancy back in 2008. There were always spaces in the back of the plane with snacks and drinks where passengers could relax and look out the window and talk to the stewardesses. https://www.cnbc.com/2018/06/02/singapore-airlines-is-bringing-back-the-worlds-longest-flight.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/06/02/singapore-airlines-is-bringi...
- jpatokal 8y agoBut the flight was first premium economy/business only, then converted to business only, and then cancelled entirely because they couldn't make the economics work out.
- ajdlinux 8y agoThey're relaunching with an A350-900ULR this year: http://www.traveller.com.au/worlds-longest-flight-route-singapore-airlines-announces-launch-date-for-new-york-flights-h10qvl http://www.traveller.com.au/worlds-longest-flight-route-sing...
- jpatokal 8y agoYup, they figured the two-engine plane will be more efficient than the old quad-jet A340. But this time, too, there is no standard economy, only premium eco & business.
- nabla9 8y agoBut do they clean the toilets. The toilets are in horrible condition after 15-17 hour flights.
- Havoc 8y agoMeanwhile I'm dreading an upcoming 11 hr flight. Honestly at 20 hours I'd rather they split it into two legs with a pause in the middle. Really not in that much of a hurry that I can't spare the extra hour or two.
- Jaruzel 8y agoIIRC, a lot of fuel is burned during take off. By making the full trip non-stop without a lay-over, saves fuel as there's only one take-off. These sort of 'innovations' are never actually about passenger comfort.
- Havoc 8y agoTwo legs means you can run the average fuel level much lower (about half) meaning less weight thus more efficient. (or if you prefer you can load the plane with more cargo). Climbing to altitude is expensive yes but I'd imagine the costs of utilizing an extra airports facilities far outweigh this. (I suspect this plus the perceived advantage of "direct" flights is the reason they want this).
- MaxLeiter 8y agoThe first thought that came to me was the smell from the gym-goers... I highly doubt they’ll offer showers
- rustcharm 8y agoTaking people should get a break—-it’s not their fault they’re tall, but fat people should have to pay for two seats if they go over the seat boundary by even one centimeter. And charge fat people a weight penalty, just like we pay for extra baggage. The revenue from gay people can subsidize the legroom for tall people.
- digi_owl 8y agoGets a guy thinking about those old flying boat routes.
- callesgg 8y agoI would like folding chairs that could be made in to standing "beds" through a folding mechanism. Would not take up an inch of extra space and it would save my joints and back. The angle of airplane chairs is plenty. You could probably get in a 40 degre angle.
- jackpeterfletch 8y agoI've always wondered why long haul flights dont just have stacked bunks or highly reclined stack seats. It'd be more comfortable, AND you get as many/more people in.
- exhaze 8y agoHere's a review of a similar, 17-hour flight that Qantas has started doing from Perth to London that goes into much more detail about the flight as opposed to the hand-wavy article: https://thepointsguy.com/reviews/qantas-australia-london-inaugural/ https://thepointsguy.com/reviews/qantas-australia-london-ina... The things like sleeping areas and workout areas seem like a stretch - probably upgrades similar to "Economy Plus", so most people will still be stuck with just the bare minimum, which will be similar to what's described in the above review.
- glbrew 8y agoWhat about a psychologist?
- hyperpallium 8y agoReminds me of the hippy green tortoise buses https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Tortoise https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Tortoise with seats replaced by bunks. Long bus trips are awful, but lying down overnight helped. Bonus: copied in the Harry Potter books.
- mirimir 8y agoThere's something over-the-top obscene about this. These would be $10K-$20K tickets, for one thing. And damn, the CO2 emissions. Less than two hops, for sure, but still. Basically, if you're traveling that far, you ought to be staying at least a month. And if you're staying at least a month, it doesn't matter that there are three hops with layovers.
- gerbilly 8y agoUgh, we're celebrating the length of the flight? Why not try to make it faster? When they find a way to fly the route in 5 hours, now that would be news.
- TheCoelacanth 8y agoWhat makes you think that they aren't trying to make them faster? There was an article on here not that long ago about companies that are trying to make super-sonic commercial flights work[1]. [1] https://www.businessinsider.com/aviation-companies-are-plotting-the-return-of-supersonic-flight-2018-4 https://www.businessinsider.com/aviation-companies-are-plott...