19 ms·
Stacking concrete blocks is a surprisingly efficient way to store energy
- jaggederest 8y agoThere is a similar idea using metal pellets fired from electromagnetic accelerators in a "space fountain". The energy would be stored there in the form of kinetic and potential energy, and it is relatively effortless to tap into that stored energy to even out something like the energy grid. Has the nice side effect of being able to launch things to space on it. http://www.orbitalvector.com/Orbital%20Travel/Space%20Fountains/Space%20Fountains.htm http://www.orbitalvector.com/Orbital%20Travel/Space%20Founta...
- vidanay 8y agoThat page made my eyes bleed.
- anonymous5133 8y agowhen geeks try to do design....
- NullPrefix 8y agoLooks like something hosted on Geocities. Just like with old paintings, when judging, you have to take into account the period it was produced in. >Article added 2005
- gitgud 8y agoChrome Mobile recognises this and suggests "simplified view" white background, black text.
- personjerry 8y agoI would assume the water pump is more efficient than the motor moving the concrete though.
- anonymous5133 8y agoIMO, that is not an important factor because the water pump option would not even be available in a desert area. This is assuming you are thinking of traditional pumped-hydro. You could probably make some sort of closed off pumped-storage where water can't escape but that would probably be very expensive.
- waynecochran 8y agoIf you have driven thru the Columbia Gorge where the highest capacity hydroelectric dams are you’ll notice that these dams are much lower than the surrounding top of the gorge. I always wonder why not pump water to the top of the gorge?
- mmt 8y agoI would expect a signficant limiting factor to be the cost of dam construction (which is going to go up at least geometrically with height, assuming a V-shaped opening), not the height of the already-constructed-by-nature surrounding walls.
- URSpider94 8y agoMany of our biggest hydro facilities in the USA are smack in the middle of the desert.
- URSpider94 8y agoNope. Pumped storage is between 70 and 80 percent efficient, this is 85 percent efficient. Remember, with pumped storage, the pumps/turbines are usually centrifugal vanes, not displacement pumps. So, there’s quite a bit of inefficiency caused by fluid drag and leakage/backflow, like in an automatic car transmission without a torque converter. With a crane, the motor is directly geared to the weight.
- jefurii 8y agoThe Ares Project (https://www.aresnorthamerica.com/ https://www.aresnorthamerica.com/) did something like this with robot trains shuttling concrete blocks up and down a slope. No news on that project in awhile tho. I hope this idea is more successful.
- theunamedguy 8y agoQuick question: how does the electricity get from the train (in motion) to the grid? Using the rails as conductors could work, but I'm not sure how efficient that would be.
- roywiggins 8y agoIt looks like overhead wires? https://www.aresnorthamerica.com/about-ares-north-america https://www.aresnorthamerica.com/about-ares-north-america
- ebikelaw 8y agoThird-rail electric distribution is an established technology.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 8y agoOne way would be using a funicular: The "train" is just the weight, pulled up/lowered on a cable that's connected to a motor-generator at the top. Would also make it cheaper to build extra wagons, with a storage yard at the top and bottom.
- anonymous5133 8y agoI think this idea is excellent and really opens up the idea of thinking of non-traditional grid energy storage. Let's go back to the basics of what we can do to store energy and retrieve it at the basic level.
- cagenut 8y agoI wonder why just barrels, maybe to limit the scope for an academic project? I'd love to see what could be done with the cranes that load/unload container ships, daisy chained up a hillside like canal locks.
- gonesilent 8y agomost dockside cranes recapture power on the way down as is.
- progfix 8y agoA few thoughts: - Someone needs to watch the stacking process. If there is a single error the whole tower can collaps and do a lot of damage. - You need a big (and expensive) foundation for a tower like this. - Is the low-cost-concrete a strong enough building material? - The generator needs cooling (in hydro pump it is cooled by the water flowing through)
- ebikelaw 8y agoEverybody seems fixated on the stacking, but it's clearly not central to the system, merely an artifact of the demonstration-scale (and presumably demonstration-budget) implementation. They could just as easily be lifting a tremendously massive object a small distance and then letting it back down again with fixed hoists, which eliminates all of the structural problems this stack of barrels faces. Also, that would allow a single unit to sink and source power continuously instead of intermittently like this crane.
- gitgud 8y agoYes, you could have 1 massive block, but the stresses and risks on the system would be much higher. Probably not achievable with current common tower cranes. The beauty of this idea is that these tower cranes are standardised and ubiquitous. So it could be implemented immediately in almost any city in the world.
- foota 8y agoI think the engineering there is more difficult because you need very strong cabling and pulleys that can deal with huge load.
- pas 8y agoJust use multiple attachment points. I think the problem with the one big weight is that it'd require an extra structure (a gantry) to hold it, whereas this is really simple logistically. Easy to transport and assemble.
- adrianmonk 8y ago
- hasperdi 8y agoThis is gravity lamp all over again.
- CydeWeys 8y agoIt's not, because the gravity lamp math didn't check out, whereas the math on this does.
- carapace 8y ago(ya got me) Don't pump water up. Convert to steam/vapor. Run a hyper-insulated pipe up the side of a mountain with repeater heaters if necessary. Condense at the top, recovering the heat, and send them both (the water and the heat) back to the bottom separately. For added points make up your losses from solar inputs.
- meesterdude 8y agoon netflix is a show called "islands of the future" and in one of the episodes they did in fact pump excess water back up the mountain. I think their location was already hot enough that they didn't consider converting to steam.
- yodon 8y agoMoving ambient temperature water through an appropriately sized pipe is nearly lossless from an energetics perspective. Moving steam through a pipe of any length is far more lossy even with significant amounts of insulation.
- edent 8y agoAnd if there are no mountains nearby?
- sebazzz 8y agoExactly. The point of this idea is that it is supposed to be doable when you lack geographical features, like in the Netherlands.
- zethraeus 8y agoDoes anyone have a sense of what maintenance for a system like this would look like relative to maintenance for a dam? It seems expensive as hell.
- 0xfeba 8y agoAre you serious? A crane vs corrosive water?
- FrojoS 8y agoSimilar concept using trains: https://www.aresnorthamerica.com/grid-scale-energy-storage https://www.aresnorthamerica.com/grid-scale-energy-storage I wonder though, the density of concrete is only about 2.5 higher than that of water. So, a concrete tower, comparable to a pumped-storage hydroelectricity plant would be gigantic. Seems infeasible to me.
- Someone 8y agoBuild one inside Fort Knox :-) I also think it might be easier to do away with the crane and just put the weight on a huge moving platform. Where available, you could sink that into a disused mine shaft.
- roywiggins 8y agoThis method uses rails and a hill: https://www.aresnorthamerica.com/about-ares-north-america https://www.aresnorthamerica.com/about-ares-north-america
- st26 8y agoMight come down to things like, how efficient are cranes & conveyors & so forth, vs water pumps & hydro generators. The nature of each material leads to different techniques which could have very different efficiencies.
- hinkley 8y agoUpfront costs can sink a project, but so can ongoing maintenance. Materials that don't foul as easily have a long term advantage. And when there's a drought people won't be too happy about all that fresh water you're taking to make electricity ('course, how much water does it take to make a cubic foot of concrete, cradle to grave?).
- mmt 8y ago> how much water does it take to make a cubic foot of concrete The article does mention that they expect to use 1/6th the cement of construction concrete. This paper https://www.nature.com/articles/s41893-017-0009-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41893-017-0009-5 gives an idea: 2 Gt of water per 21.3 Gt of not-water. Assuming perfectly dry concrete (and none of the water converting to not-water mass, both of which I believe are counter-factual), that means a 2130 kg block of concrete would have needed 200 kg of water. Pumped hydro, assuming identical efficiency, would need all 2130 kg of water.
- joshuaheard 8y agoI would think storing energy using compressed air would be more practical. Excess electricity pumps air into a compressed air tank. When electricity supply is low, the compressed air is released turning a turbine to generate electricity. It's basically the same principle as the pumped hydro mentioned in the article but using compressed air. The advantages are size, cost, and availability. You can put it anywhere and scale when necessary.
- JohnJamesRambo 8y agoThe disadvantage is that you have made a huge compressed air bomb in the event of failure. The concrete blocks would fail in a more local way by just falling down.
- crispyambulance 8y agoThe compressed air would be located in deep inside abandoned mines. The volume and thus energy storage potential of such places is vast. The idea has been around for decades, but no one has been able to really do it yet.
- cgdcraig 8y agoRock isn't necessarily airtight more so in mines. A fractured host material for the ore is very desirable as it means less explosives and higher ore production numbers.
- cgdcraig 8y agoThe compressed air systems anger the thermo gods though
- giomasce 8y agoI do not know much about engineering this sort of things, but it seems to me that working against gravity is easier than working against elastic force (as you propose), because the force of gravity is independent of the amount of energy stored, while the elastic force depends on the amount on energy stored (when the air is already pressurized it is much harder to push in some new one). And in general I believe that it is more difficult to build a motor or a generator that are efficient independently of the force they have to work against/with. Just random thoughts, though...
- maxxxxx 8y ago"The round-trip efficiency of the system, which is the amount of energy recovered for every unit of energy used to lift the blocks, is about 85%—comparable to lithium-ion batteries which offer upto 90%." That's quite efficient. Maybe they can get creative and build something different every day. One day you get a big pyramid, the next day you get a big elephant. That would be quite entertaining.
- raverbashing 8y agoPyramids are probably the most effective to prevent it falling down because of wind gusts You still have to build a base, which stores no energy, and then plan for different storage amounts in different layers.
- RandomInteger4 8y agoWould wind gusts impart enough force to affect barrels / blocks of concrete?
- foota 8y agoIt'd basically be a skyscraper, and those certainly move in wind.
- dagss 8y agoSkyscrapers are hollow...
- Synaesthesia 8y agoThey’re also a lot stronger because of steel construction, often incorporating a solid core. I don’t think we can attain skyscraper heights with blocks of concrete but I may be wrong on that.
- csours 8y agoI think you've actually hit on the real selling point here - ADVERTISING! Think of it as a VERY slow, VERY large TV screen. With red, green, and blue blocks, they could advertise almost anything! The value generation from the ad would almost certainly outpace the value generation from energy storage! Also, you could encase your bitcoin wallet in a block, creating the ultimate block-chain block-chain! By god and the scientists, you're a genius maxxxxx!
- mrfusion 8y agoNow why couldn’t we build something like this right into a wind turbine? They’re already pretty high up. Just have it lift one giant concrete block up and down.
- kordlessagain 8y ago> Let's spin some numbers to further illustrate the poor energy density of gravity-based storage systems. Assume that you have a 100 kilogram lead weight that you can lower into a 10 meter deep hole in your yard. > Now, how much energy can it store? This is given by potential energy formula E=mgh, thus E=100kg⋅9.8m/s2⋅10m=9.8kJ≈2.7Wh. > For comparison, a single AA-sized battery stores about 2Wh of energy. https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/305563/why-dont-we-use-weights-to-store-energy https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/305563/why-dont-... Wind turbine height: 99 meters. 100 kilogram lead weight == about a large person. So, a normal turbine maybe can hold about 100 people's worth of additional weight (elephant or two) * 10 (height multiplier) = ~1,000 AA batteries worth of stored power.
- aeleos 8y agoWow, I never really realized how good our current chemical battery technology is at being extremely dense.
- dwaltrip 8y agoOur battery tech is pretty impressive. However, this is also a clear example of how weak of a force gravity is, comparatively. One simple demonstration is to look at how a small magnet can combat the gravity of the entire planet when it holds an metal object in place above the ground.
- noir_lord 8y agoDecades of incremental small percentage gains really adds up in overall terms.
- deleted 8y ago
- nielsbjerg 8y agoWhy not use a single mega block, and hydrolics? Seems to me there would be less mechanical wear, and the system would be simpler?
- andbberger 8y agoHigher structural costs presumably. In the idea presented here you only need to move a small amount of mass at a time, so you don't need an especially strong crane.
- juancampa 8y agoI was thinking the same but with chains or some heavy contiguous body. The problem is that you need something that can lift one super heavy load, as opposed to many lighter weight ones. I guess that's what you mean by hydraulics but then you need hydraulics
- eeZah7Ux 8y ago*hydraulics
- gitgud 8y agoIf the giant block was literally just suspended and a crane would hoist it up and lower it to recover energy. Then this would put continuous stress on the crane structure. Much higher than a series of smaller blocks being lifted intermittently.
- aeleos 8y agoI like the idea, but I am wondering how big these will need to be. If one of their prototype towers can store 20 MwH, at each one requires a circle 300 feet in diameter, than it will require a lot of land to do this. I wonder how this compares to lithium on a power store per square foot metric.
- oihoaihsfoiahsf 8y agoThey can store (not generate) 20 MWh at, according to the article, a cost of $2M. The article does not discuss how much power they can produce using one unit. That means it would cost roughly a trillion dollars to build enough storage to power the entire US for a day [1]. That's a lot, but you wouldn't need nearly that much, since daily consumption is still roughly balanced to production. You could think of that as an upper bound on the cost of backing the entire grid with this tech, assuming their numbers scale perfectly and are entirely accurate. Almost everywhere has a lot of unused land, even in densely packed countries like Japan. If it's not good for farming, forestry, or leisure, it would be suitable for this sort of use. [1] - 3.8e12 kWh/y electrical use in the US. - 1e10 kWh/d - 1e10kWh / 2e4 kWh/unit = 5e5 units - $2e6 / unit * 5e5 units = $1e12
- aeleos 8y agoThanks, yea I meant store. Fixed.
- adrianmonk 8y agoThey spent $2M on the demonstration plant, which is ~1/10th the size. It doesn't store the full 20 MWh. (Or is that 35 MWh? The article seems inconsistent on that.) The bad news is, the capacity is lower, but the good news is the $2M is the cost to build the first prototype, and prototypes can be extremely expensive compared to the real manufacturing costs. It seems like the only information available about the price is their estimate that they can hit $150/kWh.
- saulrh 8y agoHuh, I'm less doubtful of this than I thought I'd be. Tower cranes are apparently surprisingly low-maintenance. I assume this is because they have to actively participate in their own disassembly [1] and major breakages are super difficult to deal with because they're at altitude, so they need to operate reliably enough that they can always take themselves down at the end of a job or if they need a major repair (cracks found in main pivot ring, etc). Concretely (pun not intended), I found a document [2] saying that 10 tradesmen and $35k/month in parts (together a bit more than $1m/year) can keep a fleet of 70 tower cranes (15 metric ton lift capacity each) at ~80% utilization over a one-year period. So, yeah, I'd definitely believe that you could run these things at the quoted price. 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nww6MN_Lxeo&t=24s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nww6MN_Lxeo&t=24s 2: Annex 9, "Example of the Use of Key Performance Indicators for Maintenance", in this PDF: https://www.mantiscranes.ie/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/CPA-TCIG-0801-Maintenance-Inspection-and-Thorough-Examination-of-Tower-Cranes.pdf https://www.mantiscranes.ie/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/CPA-T...
- nabla9 8y agoThe selling point of this is low relatively low capital cost and well tested technology. Power density is not that good, but if you have land that's not a problem. The use of space to store energy is maybe double of what typical damn reservoir uses to store the same amount of energy.
- acidburnNSA 8y agoReservoirs have a tendency to emit biogenic methane though so they're not great at scale for climate change mitigation.
- your-nanny 8y agoI'm assuming this is because of growth and decay between fill and release cycles. But in the long run wouldn't that be carbon neutral?
- 8y ago
- quotemstr 8y agoWhy would you use a large number of small blocks to build a tower instead of one extremely large block on vertical rails, with appropriate devices to create sufficient mechanical advantage to move the block?
- bufferoverflow 8y agoBecause the crane has a limit of how much it can lift. If you're suggesting a custom system, it's addressed in the article, using off-the-shelf hardware is much cheaper.
- tomp 8y agoBecause a block on the top of a tower of blocks is way more stable than a hanging block 100x heavier.
- quotemstr 8y agoThat's why you mount the heavy block on rails. I don't see a practical problem with very heavy monolithic blocks. Over a century ago, people built perfectly stable hydraulically-powered draw bridges that have opened and closed several times per day, every day, up to the present. Sounds like a solved problem to me.
- mmt 8y agoAre you sure those bridges aren't counter-weighted? I don't believe I've ever seen a drawbridge that wasn't. Moving a counter-weighted something-heavy up and down is a distinctly different physics problem (that closely resembles moving it back and forth horizontally) than moving an unattached something-heavy up and down.
- CydeWeys 8y agoYou're orders of magnitude off on the scale involved. A single one of these concrete blocks is 35 tonnes. To get useful stored energy levels you need thousands of blocks. So you're looking at something like 100 kilotonnes of total mass. That's way, way, way more than any movable bridge weighs. Bagger 288, the largest mobile machine ever built, only weighs 13.5 kilotonnes, and all of that weight is supported by the ground on massive treads. To be able to lift many times the weight of Bagger 288 over 100 m in the air defies imagination as to what would be required. It would require billions of dollars to achieve, most likely. Contrast with an off-the-shelf tower crane that costs a few million.
- sagebird 8y agoThey may as well make the concrete blocks in the shape of cups. Open a drain hole when the cups are on the ground. When the cups are on top of the towers, let them fill with rain.
- gunn 8y agoThat would make it partially, an indirect hydro dam.
- grenoire 8y agoIt's about concrete's density. Denser means more energy.
- dmurray 8y agoRainfall is 50 cm/month in the absolute wettest parts of the US, and less than half that in most of it. This wouldn't really move the needle.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- IshKebab 8y agoThis is why there are so many harebrained energy ideas - because people suggest ideas like this that sound vaguely plausible but when you spend a few seconds thinking about how much energy you'd get you realise it is pointless or just an idiotic version of an existing idea (hydro in your case). Same for all the energy from pedestrians/cars ideas, solar roadways, etc.
- sagebird 8y agoThe amount of energy depends on how long the average cup would sit. A better critism might be complications in climates where water freezes. In any case, there is nothing so wrong with my comment that necessitates a negative attitude. I would not be surprised if it is an ‘idiotic’ form of hydro, or if it is not an idiotic form. But it’s clear that nobody has shown it to be one or the other as of yet, so your comment is negative with little justification.
- csours 8y agoQ: A big stack of concrete blocks seems to be almost purpose built for the wind (or a gigantic mutant toddler/cat) to push over. Cranes are also extremely susceptible to wind. I suppose the blocks could be engineered to interlock, but the pictures show cylinders. How do they plan to counteract the wind?
- sandebert 8y agoBy putting it indoors?
- csours 8y agoThat would almost certainly price it well out of the range of even lithium ion storage.
- jvandonsel 8y agoAs far as the crane goes, the article indicates that "Wind could cause the block to move like a pendulum, but the crane’s trolley is programmed to counter the movement." That actually seems like the most interesting part of this system.
- csours 8y agoI'm sure they've accounted for winds they expect to encounter on a yearly basis, but "century" storms do happen, just ask Houston TX. "Houston is experiencing its third ‘500-year’ flood in 3 years. How is that possible?" - https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/08/29/houston-is-experiencing-its-third-500-year-flood-in-3-years-how-is-that-possible/?utm_term=.09e98bacffa8 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/08/29/houst...
- lenzm 8y agoThey aren't worried about the wind's effect on the stacked blocks, just the ones suspended. If a century storm comes, just shut it all down for a day, everything is stable.
- 8y ago
- Kagerjay 8y agoNot related but the first thing I thought of was flywheel regenerative braking in cars, except that is storage in kinetic energy not potential energy
- romdev 8y agoAlso (mostly) unrelated to the story, but the first thing I thought of when hearing about kinetic energy storage was a story I heard several years ago about a data center that protected itself from catastrophic power surges by using a massive spinning flywheel to store energy from the grid and harvest its rotation to run a generator that powered the servers.
- tpurves 8y agoWhy not stack or lift heavy lead-acid batteries? 2 for 1 deal on energy storage.
- 7952 8y agoOr make a fly wheel out of batteries and lift that
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoStacking flywheels reminds me of that NES robot attachment. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/R.O.B https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/R.O.B.
- dmurray 8y agoWith a mirrored surface, so it could contribute to a concentrated solar farm.
- adrianmonk 8y agoThe flywheels would make it more stable as you lift it, too!
- Faaak 8y agoSeems quite useless to me as the earth's gravitational field is not very strong. Supposing that you could store the concrete blocks at a height of 50m (which is already a lot), you would need roughly 8000 tons to store 1 MWh. Taking account concrete density (2400kg/m^3), that's 19000 barrels !
- monk_e_boy 8y agoI wonder why they dont put the blocks / dirt into train wagons and drive them up hill. Then generate electricity through retroactive breaking as it descends. Maybe the efficiency isn't 85%... but it sounds cheaper and simpler to make.
- andruby 8y agoSee https://www.aresnorthamerica.com/grid-scale-energy-storage https://www.aresnorthamerica.com/grid-scale-energy-storage
- icebraining 8y agoHills aren't available everywhere (see e.g. the Netherlands).
- PhasmaFelis 8y ago> Seems quite useless to me as the earth's gravitational field is not very strong. Citation needed. The vast majority of current energy storage uses pumped hydro. > Supposing that you could store the concrete blocks at a height of 50m (which is already a lot), you would need roughly 8000 tons to store 1 MWh. Taking account concrete density (2400kg/m^3), that's 19000 barrels ! Both the video and the article make it clear that the thing with the barrels is a 1/10th-scale prototype. The full-size version is slated to stand 120 meters tall and use 35-ton concrete blocks.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- barbegal 8y agoIt's not significantly more efficient than pumped hydroelectric storage which is 70 to 80% efficient. And whilst it might be able to store quite a lot of energy, it can't release it particularly quickly I'd estimate the 6 crane motors can maybe generate a combined 1MW which is a paltry amount of power compared to even a tiny pumped storage facility.
- proto-n 8y agoOk but the whole premise was that hydroelectric storage is infeasible in most places.
- dredmorbius 8y agoPumped-hydro needs few high-powered turbine-pumps, of 100 - 400 MW capacity. Solid material gravity storage requires vastly more low-capacity motors, of under 1 MW each, as you note. Raw efficiency isn't everything.
- imhoguy 8y agoThat is true. However such gravity storage can be multiplied and distributed on flatland at any nearby solar or wind source.
- montalbano 8y agoThis is absolutely fascinating. Interestingly, the cement industry produces ~5% of global c02 emissions [0]. (Cement is an important binding element in concrete [1].) As this technology is presumably most useful for storing surplus energy from unpredictable renewable sources (e.g. wind, solar) I wonder if there is a conflict of interest? I'd love to know more about the carbon economics involved, perhaps they could use reclaimed (i.e. recycled) cement. [0] https://blogs.ei.columbia.edu/2012/05/09/emissions-from-the-cement-industry/ https://blogs.ei.columbia.edu/2012/05/09/emissions-from-the-... [1] https://www.thespruce.com/difference-between-cement-concrete-and-mortar-2130884 https://www.thespruce.com/difference-between-cement-concrete...
- JudasGoat 8y agoWould it matter if it was containers filled with water, soil, trash instead?
- monochromatic 8y agoWay less dense than concrete. So less energy stored.
- yummybear 8y agoSand and water?
- LeifCarrotson 8y agoRock.
- MauranKilom 8y agoAside from mass density, the problem here would be structural integrity. How high can you stack buckets of water before the tower collapses? Probably not 120 meters. It comes as no surprise to me that this would use the same kind of material as a 120 m tall "normal" building.
- VBprogrammer 8y agoIm surprised no one had mentioned the CO2 cost of producing concrete.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- imhoguy 8y agoBut it is one time cost for 30 years. Everything has an initial cost like creating traditional plant, building water reservoir (concrete too and ground formation work), photovoltaic panel grid. Benefit here is abundance of material - existing concrete waste.
- krallja 8y agoPresumably because the CO2 cost of cement is thoroughly discussed in the article.
- Hello71 8y ago> He’s developed a machine that can mix substances that cities often pay to get rid off, such as gravel or building waste, along with cement to create low-cost concrete blocks. The cost saving comes from having to use only a sixth of the amount of cement that would otherwise have been needed if the concrete were used for building construction. Notwithstanding the misspelling of "of", it seems like if this becomes popular, such "waste" materials will increase in price, making the plan unviable at scale.
- svachalek 8y agoIf they're so successful they've cleared the market for construction junk, I think they're well past the viable stage.
- chx 8y agoThere's the horizontal version, so to speak, at https://www.aresnorthamerica.com/grid-scale-energy-storage https://www.aresnorthamerica.com/grid-scale-energy-storage -- it's running heavy weights up a hill on a closed rail loop to store and use them coming down to generate energy. 78% efficiency is claimed (in the press kit, the web page says "approaching 80%"). It claims to be able to store tens of gigawatt hours of energy.
- CydeWeys 8y agoThe crane idea appeals to me more because the infrastructure appears simpler. Rather than having to build a lot of rail and a whole switching infrastructure, you just install the one crane and a shitload of heavy concrete blocks for it to lift. Seems like it would be cheaper.
- chx 8y agoSomeone would need to run the costs per GWh stored and generated. To me it looks like once you built your rail loop you could run a lot of cars on it. Still, building instead quite a lot of cranes might be cheaper.
- CydeWeys 8y agoRolling stock isn't cheap either, though. Not even remotely close to how cheap a concrete block is. Rolling stock typically costs in the millions per car. The rail might not even be the most expensive part. The nice thing about the crane idea is you don't even need a lot of cranes, you just need a lot of stackable mass. The rail idea needs a lot of movable mass on wheels, and a lot of siding to store it on. It seems like the rail idea would need more land as well, plus it only works on hillsides.
- rtkwe 8y agoYou need enough cranes to smooth the dips in power generation as each crane finishes dropping one weight and has to go fetch another. The number needed would be proportional to the desired power output of the system (holding the size of the weights constant).
- anon1253 8y agoVery nice. Seems a bit finicky with all the cranes though, but what do I know. If the cost of concrete is a problem, why not put a huge sheet-like structure below a landfill and very slowly rise it up or down ... same principle, but now you're just moving waste and there's no shortage of that!
- CydeWeys 8y agoThe difference is that tower cranes capable of carrying 35 tonne blocks can be bought off the shelf. As for lifting an entire landfill, how the hell would you accomplish that? No such machine exists, and the support columns required to do so would be utterly massive. Also, I don't think a strong enough material exists to make that sheet out of.
- dredds 8y agoHaving an even number of opposing cranes might save tad of energy by hoisting the hooks and cable up by counterweight than by motor, but speed seems a more likely reason.
- tomelders 8y agoHonest question. Is there a reason to use a crane rarther than digging a hole? It seems all that needs to happen is for a weight to be lifted and then allowed to fall. If that was done below ground, that would cut out the weather issues and I feel like the structure itself would be a lot more robust.
- pharrington 8y agoThe general principle is converting kinetic energy -> potential energy (storage) and vice versa (consumption). My intuition is that using existing technology to lift a weight through lower atmosphere by >= X required meters is waaaaay more efficient than displacing ((X required meters of height) * required storage surface area) volume of Earth crust.
- tomelders 8y agoCheers. I must be missing something, but once the hole is dug, it’s dug, and i’d have thought it was pretty low maintenance and more structuraly sound than a crane. So over time, would the costs of maintenance provide a benefit?
- Qwertystop 8y agoYou still need a crane to move the blocks from the bottom to the top and back. It might be a different type of crane, but I don't know that it would be any cheaper to maintain.
- tantalor 8y agoHoles are expensive
- adiusmus 8y agoNot all of them. Sometimes they are waste products of some other industry. Eg old mines / quarries.
- fizx 8y agoI wonder what religious purpose future archeologists will think this served :)
- ENOTTY 8y agoWho knew Tetris could be used to solve climate change
- radarsat1 8y agoIdea: Stick a heavy load onto a rotating screw. Actively power it to rotate, moving the weight up; let the weight drop forcing the screw to rotate on the way down. Sounds pretty simple, I guess a lot of energy would be lost to friction.. teflon? Bearings?
- CydeWeys 8y agoSounds less efficient than just using a high efficiency electric motor to power a crane as in this proposal.
- baron816 8y agoIf this became a real thing, can the employees who operate the cranes be called "Sisypheceans?"
- ktzar 8y ago9.8m/s2 * 120m * 35000kg = 41160000 J = 11.4 kWh Not convinced. Am I missing how they get to store 20 MWh of energy using gravity?
- Redoubts 8y agoIs it not feasible to have a couple thousand of these blocks?
- CydeWeys 8y agoThe idea involves lifting thousands or tens of thousands of blocks, not just one. Of course it's ridiculous to have an entire tower crane dedicated to lifting a single block, but that's not what they're proposing. The linked article has a rendering showing how many blocks are involved.
- ktzar 8y agoNo way one a single block weights 35 tons. A concrete cubic meter weights 2.4 tons.
- samatman 8y agoright so, 4 square meters base, 4 meters high, 16 cubic meters, 16 * 2.4 = = 38.4 tonnes. That's not an implausible object.
- CydeWeys 8y agoThen they're clearly bigger than a cubic meter. You want to use blocks that are as big as possible so you get more energy out of each trip. 2.4 tons isn't very much at all compared to the carrying capacity of a crane -- you want as heavy as possible while still being comfortably within the lifting capabilities of the crane. Their design says 35 tonnes and that does indeed make more sense. Where is your doubt coming from?
- skookumchuck 8y agoThe blocks don't have to be concrete all the way through. Just need a shell, and fill it with rubble.
- amelius 8y agoWhat will happen to Earth's rotation if we start lifting objects on the side where the Sun shines, and dropping them on the other side?
- infogulch 8y agoGood point. We know that large shifts in mass, like huge landslides caused by earthquakes, can measurably affect earth's rotation. What happens when we start using multi-gigaton masses for energy storage -- that are within a couple orders of magnitude of those landslides -- in a cyclic pattern? I wonder if we could even get resonant effects.
- samatman 8y agoy'all remember we got tides right
- slyall 8y agoMaybe the tech industry will pay them billions to adjust earth's rotation to eliminate leap seconds.
- DonHopkins 8y agoGlobal Wobbling
- hmexx 8y agoYou made me smile
- IshKebab 8y agoNothing
- pirocks 8y agoWhy not do this in the ocean? Lifting and raising blocks from the sea floor provides far more potential energy, since the ocean is deeper, than any crane is tall.
- mrtnmcc 8y agoWater resistance?
- joe-collins 8y agoTransmission costs and greater wear and tear from saltwater, off the top of my head.
- Const-me 8y agoThe majority of the world’s economy is at or near the seaside. I find this approach more practical, similarly low tech (which is a good thing, simple and reliable) but uses hydrostatic pressure instead of gravity. http://theliquidgrid.com/2016/12/27/marine-energy-storage/ http://theliquidgrid.com/2016/12/27/marine-energy-storage/ Sea floor is underutilized, but you can do a lot of things on a piece of land. Below certain small depth the sea is always calm, atmosphere is not, I anticipate catastrophic consequences with these tall cranes when hurricanes, tornados or lightnings.
- CydeWeys 8y agoThat seems harder to me. Anything done deep underwater costs at least an order of magnitude more, plus they still have all the same concrete requirements because they need ballast to keep the air balloons from rising to the surface. Seems easier to just use that same mass on land with a crane.
- Const-me 8y ago> Anything done deep underwater costs at least an order of magnitude more They don’t need to do much underwater, only install. But I agree capital costs might be higher because of this. > all the same concrete requirements because they need ballast Depends on the geology of the sea bed. Where I live, the sea bottom is mostly solid rock, it’s possible to attach stuff to the bottom without putting much ballast. > use that same mass on land with a crane. The idea’s nice I just worry about disasters. I read in local news about falling construction cranes every couple of years, because stormy weather for a few months each year. It’s possible to make cranes strong enough even for bad weather (like bridges), but such weather proof cranes will become more expensive than regular ones.
- CydeWeys 8y agoThe installation process dominates overall effort, so if that's a lot harder then it ends up being a lot more expensive and thus a lot less cost competitive. It is absolutely insane how expensive an underwater oil well costs to tap compared to one on land, for example. > Depends on the geology of the sea bed. Where I live, the sea bottom is mostly solid rock, it’s possible to attach stuff to the bottom without putting much ballast. It's likely to be more expensive to attempt to attach to the sea floor than it is to just sink large weights. In fact, I'm not aware of any large structures that are anchored to the sea floor in a way that resists an upward force rather than a downwards one. It might be a wholly unsolved problem. > The idea’s nice I just worry about disasters. Falling construction cranes are dangerous because they tend to happen in inhabited areas, adjacent to other buildings. The energy storage cranes, on the other hand, would likely be in the middle of nowhere where land is cheap, so even if they do fall there's nothing to damage beyond the energy storage installation.
- kwelstr 8y ago"On a hot July morning, I traveled to Biasca, Switzerland, about two hours north of Milan, Italy" Ok, sorry for the off topic, but this annoys me to no end. Two hours by plane is about 1400 miles, by car about 120 miles, by bicycle about 25 miles, by foot maybe 6 miles, so why not give distance by miles or km? Even if we are talking by car, then how do you know there are no traffic jams on the way, or bad weather? </please ignore rant>
- Naga 8y agoNot sure about where you are from, but in Canada distances are routinely given in hours or minutes, and it always means by car unless it is specified. As in, "Toronto to Ottawa is around five hours, or an hour by plane."
- kwelstr 8y agoAnd that's the problem, tell me 10 miles and it will always be 10 miles. Where I live, in a rapidly growing city, 15 years ago it would take 15 minutes to downtown from my house, now it takes 25 or 30. It's the same distance but traffic has increased significantly in a short number of years.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoIn my experience, hours of distance always means "by car under typical traffic/weather conditions" unless otherwise specified.
- post_break 8y agoThis is so cool! Could you replace the crane with mine shafts and lead elevators?
- CydeWeys 8y agoNot at even remotely the same cost, no.
- ada1981 8y agoThis is neat. We are also facing a global sand shortage crisis due to increased demand for concrete. https://theconversation.com/the-world-is-facing-a-global-sand-crisis-83557 https://theconversation.com/the-world-is-facing-a-global-san...
- legohead 8y agoIndia's sand mafia: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ugT-zyXGNIY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ugT-zyXGNIY
- thewizardofaus 8y agoThat was interesting to watch. Thanks for sharing :-)
- ada1981 8y agoGreat film. I wanted to get a sense of the economics of the entire thing. They said mining for sand could be more profitable than mining for gold. I presume that means extracting a truckload of sand will yield more profit than a truck of ore containing rock? I’m also now curious about sand alternatives.
- ada1981 8y agoApparently using desert sand, which is abundant, isn’t feasible and beach / river sand has been the only solution. A team has recently created a concrete alternative from desert sand, however, that has half the carbon footprint and is made from abundant materials. https://www.dezeen.com/2018/03/24/desert-sand-could-offer-low-carbon-concrete-alternative/ https://www.dezeen.com/2018/03/24/desert-sand-could-offer-lo...
- billsmithaustin 8y agoIf there isn’t a steampunk novel featuring this technology, there should be.
- npunt 8y agoIf they don't call themselves Sisyphus Energy they're missing out on a great poetic opportunity. > In Greek mythology Sisyphus was the king of Ephyra (now known as Corinth). He was punished for his self-aggrandizing craftiness and deceitfulness by being forced to roll an immense boulder up a hill only for it to roll down when it nears the top, repeating this action for eternity. Its quite an ingenious idea. Could even hollow out a mountain to do this, avoiding the co2 cost of concrete.
- asdfman123 8y agoI can imagine living next to one of these facilities and thinking "What the hell are they trying to build?"
- onetimemanytime 8y agoor after 18000 years, after they reboot the civilization and only a few structures remain. Give a +- few years :)
- 105e9 8y agohttp://sisyphusenergy.com/ http://sisyphusenergy.com/
- dudeonthenet 8y agoYeah, imagine passing by a field with about a hundred of those while they're dropping the blocks.
- rumcajz 8y agoDigging holes and filling them in again may be yet another way to go.
- JonasJSchreiber 8y agoDoes anyone see the downside that a little bug gets introduced, the concrete chips, the barrel dents, a cyber attack takes place, and suddenly your 120 meter tall stack of 35 ton blocks becomes a Jenga tower raining death into the Swiss countryside?
- dojomouse 8y agoIf the promoters themselves are only claiming $150/kwh as a goal this doesn't have a chance of success given its other limitations.
- dojomouse 8y agoI should qualify that a bit... - The promoters are likely to present at least a realistic (if not optimistic) estimate of mid term cost, the technologies involved are all mature (so the potential for further reduction I'd low), and the estimated cost is not materially better than battery energy storage (worse, in fact, than near term forecasts, and much worse than midterm potential battery energy storage cost). - The siting flexibility is poor, which means grid connection will be slow/expensive. - The power density will be pretty bad (which wouldn't matter for bulk energy storage... but it's too expensive to compete in that market). Maybe it could become more attractive with much taller cranes?
- ryeguy_24 8y agoEarthquake = Big Waste of Energy
- giomasce 8y agoThat is true for other plant types as well: see for example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vajont_Dam https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vajont_Dam and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_nuclear_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_nuclear_disa....
- calebm 8y agoI remember a mechanical engineer friend of mine who worked in a power plant telling me that large flywheels are still used for energy storage. Funny how basic the energy storage solutions often are.
- keypusher 8y agoThey say the proposed version could store 20 megawatt-hours, but I wonder what the maximum output is? That is, how long does it take to produce that energy? If the maximum output is ~1-2 MW, it can support 1k or 2k homes, but it's also important to put in context that peak load of an average sized US city peak load is ~1000 MW. A med-sized wind turbine can produce ~2 MW, for comparison.
- ShinTakuya 8y agoThe cost is key here though, at $2m or potentially lower you're paying just $1-2k per home and maybe $100 a year maintenance thereafter. Not a bad price overall for what you get. In Australia at least, electricity costs $1-2k per year per household. Some napkin maths tells me that at 15MWH consumption per year this sort of storage could make solar (at $50 per MWH) pretty viable. As in, potentially below $1k per year even if you build enough storage to cover 80% of the day.
- Liron 8y agoHow can a falling block generate electricity? Is it like a turbine that spins very slowly as the block falls?
- robjan 8y agoPresumably there is some kind of gearing system that causes the turbine to rotate at the optimal speed. They are probably just using the motor that they use to lift the mass in the first place.
- dagss 8y agoAll/most electric motors are also electric generators. Similar to how electric cars convert braking energy back to electricity.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- FrozenVoid 8y agoIt would be much cheaper to use sand in reservoir.
- pas 8y agoSand is very abrasive, hard to pump, you need to build a reservoir, etc.
- tomxor 8y agoFinally a useful application of block and chain based storage... Hides
- hayksaakian 8y agoHow does it actually generate power from the stacked blocks?
- pas 8y agoWhen it lets the down, they pull on the generator.
- phy6 8y agoHow about huge helium balloons attached to a hose that lets a compressor suck the helium back down to ground level. The hose/tether would be on a spool attached to a generator. You could even do this from the ocean floor using regular surface air.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 8y agoThe "huge" is the problem here. In order to store any useful amount of energy, you'd need way too much. We use water because it's readily available, cheap, easy to transport, and relatively easy to store. Concrete is already harder to transport (you need to correctly grasp, stack and release the blocks).
- camtarn 8y agoAs somebody linked further up - there are companies already working on the air-on-the-seafloor idea: http://theliquidgrid.com/2016/12/27/marine-energy-storage/ http://theliquidgrid.com/2016/12/27/marine-energy-storage/
- anderspitman 8y agoReally cool. I wonder how efficiently (and safely) you could operate a small-scale version in your back yard for personal solar panels.
- Gravityloss 8y agoI guess with a harbor crane type of system where the crane is on rails, you could scale to a higher energy storage with similar power. Don't know what the sweet spots of capacity vs power are on different markets. This could be good for long term storage.
- 8bitsrule 8y agoI'd like to see a comparison of this electric-crane-block system with a system already being tested, 'rail storage', which uses electric locomotives to pull heavily loaded cars uphill. I'd guess the cranes would be cheaper than locomotives and laying track.... and works on flat terrain (EG the midwest). https://vimeo.com/124312632 https://vimeo.com/124312632 (ARES, Bakersfield) https://www.snl.com/InteractiveX/Article.aspx?cdid=A-26542351-12594 https://www.snl.com/InteractiveX/Article.aspx?cdid=A-2654235... https://www.vox.com/2016/4/28/11524958/energy-storage-rail https://www.vox.com/2016/4/28/11524958/energy-storage-rail
- bacon_waffle 8y agoI like that this scheme doesn't put the local food/water supply at odds with the local energy supply, like hydro schemes can do.
- v-yadli 8y agoCan we attach such things to the high buildings? Thus we can build low cost distributed systems across a city.
- nashashmi 8y agoThey are better off using metal products in place of concrete blocks because they have higher weight densities. About 3 times more. Water permeability also has an impact. Imagime lifting the products when it's wet and dropping them when it's dry.
- jondubois 8y agoWhy doesn't it just lift a single extremely large block when electricity surges and then very slowly drops it back down to generate electricity (no need for complex hook-and-release)? The maximum capacity would be determined by the maximum height of the tower along which the block is lifted. Or why doesn't it just have many medium motors; each permanently attached to a single medium-sized block? Why should the relationships between motors and blocks be one-to-many? Lots of small concrete blocks, a camera and a hook to latch onto them one at a time sounds overly complicated and error-prone - Not to mention how much precious time would be wasted getting the hook through the holes and then coordinating the lifting so that each block ends up stacked nicely.
- mrtksn 8y agoMaybe the materials can't withstand such extreme forces? After all, the same logic would apply to any system that stores mechanical energy. Can you, for example, make a mechanical watch by compressing liquid instead of a spring?
- canam 8y agoOr maybe one block per house. Solar raises it though the day, generates electricity at night as it lowers. No grid required.
- jondubois 8y agoNice, that sounds even better.
- PeterisP 8y agoThe obvious answer is expense; the motor-generator part is the expensive part of the system (both in building and in maintenance) so you don't want a larger motor if a smaller will do, and you don't want more motors if fewer one will do. For such a system, time isn't precious, hardware is.
- xg15 8y agoWhat I don't get, why the complicated design to assemble the blocks into stacks? This seems to add a lot of non-essential complexity: Now you need cranes, a hooking/unhooking mechanism (that seems to even require cameras and image recognition!), the ability to move blocks horizontally and lots of computing power to coordinate the whole thing. Even more, the up-front cost to recover energy is higher because you need to lift the blocks from the stacks before you can drop them. Why not simply use a fixed hook/rope/motor/generator assembly per concrete block? Or, if there are too many blocks for that, use a hydraulic system? (But then again, what is the advantage of using many small blocks instead of a few large ones?) Nothing against the company - the idea is awesome - but it seems weird that almost all the advertised innovations are solutions to problems that wouldn't exist without the "put the blocks into stacks" design: >The innovation in Energy Vault’s plant is not the hardware. Cranes and motors have been around for decades, and companies like ABB and Siemens have optimized them for maximum efficiency. The round-trip efficiency of the system, which is the amount of energy recovered for every unit of energy used to lift the blocks, is about 85%—comparable to lithium-ion batteries which offer upto 90%. Pedretti’s main work as the chief technology officer has been figuring out how to design software to automate contextually relevant operations, like hooking and unhooking concrete blocks, and to counteract pendulum-like movements during the lifting and lowering of those blocks. (Not counting the described innovation of finding a new mixture that includes waste and reduces the amount of cement needed.)
- becasuretarded 8y agoBecause a single crane can move blocks in a r^2 * Pi area. (7.5m)^2 * 3.14 = 176.62m^2 Your little cuck lift per block idea doesn't work out. Let's say you have a giant 8m * 8m block per lift. You'd still only have 64m^2 capacity. The entire idea of a gravity battery is already infeasable from the start and this crane idea makes it a little more feasable but for some reason people like you just want to make it impossible again.
- ubercow13 8y agoThe tower in the video looks like it contains hundreds of these blocks. You would therefore need hundreds of assemblies to do it that way, and each one has to lift the same weight that the crane is lifting. All of this to save on the cost of making the crane complex enough to move about, and the cost of the software involved.
- matell 8y agoinstead of concrete blocks, they could be lifting LiPo blocks :)
- OliverJones 8y agoCool. I wonder if it makes sense to make a roller-coaster-like potential energy storage system? It sounds like the electric motor-generator problem is solved. Escalator technology has many decades of safety and efficiency track record. It also might make sense to use shipping containers full of heavy rubble rather than purpose-built concrete blocks. Container cranes already are designed to work fast and accurately. Containers are common and strong, and solving the saftey problem of weight integrity might be easier.
- dandare 8y agoThis doesn't make a sense to me. Why not instead of a crane use a rope into a deep well with a shaft with a conveyor belt?
- matt_the_bass 8y agoHow about putting one or two of these _inside_ a new construction sky scraper just like one long, heavy elevator? “Charge” it at night. Release it during the day. This may not be a general solution but might be helpful at a per building level.
- mhb 8y agoEnergy Storage Using a Rock-Filled Train on a Hill: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17794547 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17794547
- adamlett 8y agoI find it incredibly funny that a company in Switzerland has invented a way to store energy that basically uses the same mechanism as… a Swiss clock!
- MayeulC 8y agoGravitational potential-based energy storage is nothing new. There are lots and lots of ways this is harnessed; take a grandfather clock, for example. That said, there are a few points worth noting, if I spend a few minutes thinking about this: * You probably want to maximize "dumb mass", with relation to the lifting mechanism, to bring down your costs this has to be optimized vs density * You probably want to maximize the height difference in order to make the system more effective: --* Less losses due to the "fixed costs", both in time and energy, of positioning the mechanism for the next payload --* If you have lots of blocks to move, or are simply stacking them, it will take up a huge area when discharged, which will at least make the crane system more complicated So, simply stacking blocks does not seem like the perfect solution to me, unless you really want to max out the energy per unit of volume. This could make sense if you were stacking goods that would be useful elsewhere (think a warehouse that doubles as a batteries). Incidentally, batteries, fuel tanks or containers would be a rather good choice if you have to pick one of these. Following on the double-use idea, there is already one distributed, underused infrastructure that is designed for electrically lifting things (though probably not power generation). I can see a few ways that elevators could double as auxiliary power storage units. Of course, special care would be needed to make sure the extra weight doesn't compromises the buildings' structural integrity. The same could be said about virtually any other candidates, which includes existing bridges, dams, cliffs, etc. An interesting take on this would be to see whether it is possible to take it offshore. In theory, given perfect water-proofing (or just good pumps) and logistics, you could change the geometry of a concrete-built floating structure, and lower parts of it extremely deep. Of course, Archimedes doesn't help much with power density, but that wouldn't affect efficiency much (hydrodynamics would, if speed/geometry isn't optimized, though). As a preliminary approach, sea deeps near the coast could make it simpler. I suspect concrete composition would be the hardest part to solve, in that case.
- kragen 8y agoOne crane can store 20 megawatt hours. The wholesale price of a megawatt hour varies between US$-40 and US$120, normally being around US$60; if you manage to hit those peaks and valleys, which usually happen once a day, you make US$160. If you manage to do this 20 days a month, you make US$3200 a month or US$38400 a year. Given saulrh's comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17790442 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17790442 that each tower crane requires US$500 a month in parts to keep it running, it seems plausible that this could be economically viable.
- mark-r 8y agoWould it be possible to use shaped blocks of rock instead of concrete? Would that make it cheaper?