26 ms·
Microsoft threatens to stop hosting Gab unless posts are removed
- zajd 8y agoGood
- amyjess 8y agoThis is society's natural immune system at work.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sadris 8y agoIn which the left now suddenly no longer supports network neutrality.
- zajd 8y agoAhh yes, multinational corporations worth hundreds of billions, also known as the left. Insightful.
- eli 8y agoThis is not relevant to net neutrality as the phrase is traditionally defined.
- amyjess 8y agoNobody on "the left" has ever argued that companies can't have a terms of service that prohibits bad behavior. Net neutrality has always been about preventing the companies that control the last mile for consumers from extorting additional money from server operators that are already paying their own ISP for bandwidth.
- drak0n1c 8y agoNot quite nobody. There were arguments that without Net Neutrality ISPs may develop TOS that target certain data/content services with paywalls, throttles, or blocks - to the point where politically motivated censorship would be a big concern. This censorship argument played a core part in the Net Neutrality campaign. Note the specific reference to censorship being the biggest problem in the headlines and leading paragraphs of the following popular articles: 1) https://www.nbcnews.com/think/opinion/ending-net-neutrality-will-destroy-everything-makes-internet-great-ncna823301 https://www.nbcnews.com/think/opinion/ending-net-neutrality-... 2) https://qz.com/1158328/what-will-happen-now-that-net-neutrality-is-gone-we-asked-the-experts/ https://qz.com/1158328/what-will-happen-now-that-net-neutral... 3) https://www.vox.com/2017/12/14/16774148/net-neutrality-repeal-explained https://www.vox.com/2017/12/14/16774148/net-neutrality-repea... 4) https://futurism.com/ny-attorney-general-fcc-net-neutrality/ https://futurism.com/ny-attorney-general-fcc-net-neutrality/
- SteveNuts 8y agonet neutrality has nothing to do with freedom or neutrality of speech online, especially in regards to a private company's terms of service.
- smt88 8y agoNeutrality is about the pipes, which are a natural monopoly. It has nothing to do with the users of the pipes. Microsoft has a right to choose not to participate in broadcasting speech that it disagrees with, and the reason that's OK is because there are many other platforms for Gab to move to. For many (most?) people, switching to a different ISP is impossible or comes with severe drawbacks.
- wnevets 8y agoinsert picard facepalm here.
- dragonwriter 8y agoMicrosoft is an edge provider, not an ISP; net neutrality is about stopping ISPs from controlling edge providers to consumer contact, largely. It's not about regulating edge providers.
- sctb 8y agoThis a great example of a comment from which we learn little but are agitated much. > Eschew flamebait. Don't introduce flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- makomk 8y agoThe posts in question are frankly pretty awful, but this does kind of put the lie to the idea that if you don't like FaceGoogleBook's censorship you can just set up your own website.
- smt88 8y agoThere are literally thousands of hosts other than Azure. Worst-case scenario, they could run their own servers or use a colocation service.
- zokier 8y ago"Worst-case scenario" for them would be datacenters and colo providers refusing them service. They have ToS too, as does their network providers.
- lainga 8y agoWell, they kind of shot themselves in the foot by leaving big social media platforms... for a big server hosting platform. If they wanted to go Henry David Thoreau on the corporate internet, why didn't they buy physical equipment?
- SteveNuts 8y agoNo matter where they end up hosting they'll most likely be breaking some ToS of either their colo or ISP.
- Someguywhatever 8y agoIt's ToS violations all the way down
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- awakeasleep 8y agoIn your scenario, are the datacenters and ISPs immune to political pressure?
- hartator 8y agoLittle's posts on Gab are awful, and Microsoft is in his rights to refuse service to anyone. However they don't have the capacity to do a fair manual triage of all the services they are hosting, and they should avoid doing it until legally constrained.
- Someguywhatever 8y agoToo lazy to actually look it up but I think that MS are getting ahead of the lawsuit from Europe. Europe will fine you X dollars for every second / minute / hour or something that a bad post is left online. So even if GAB does not comply with EU regs then Azure surely will and EU will go after the weakest link. MS knows this, and they don't care about GAB or Free Speech or whatever so they're going to shut them down if they don't comply. IMO Europes rules are designed this way on purpose, they are sort of exporting their rules, and eventually if that's allowed to continue the internet will devolve to the lowest common denominator. Whomever has the biggest most enforceable fines rules the internet.
- alkonaut 8y agoI don’t think there is a pan-European set of free speech laws. These are per country.
- eli 8y agoI don't follow your reasoning. Why is it wrong to refuse service to "bad" customers as they come to your attention, but it's ok to do it if you review everyone at once?
- hartator 8y agoDMCA process is far from perfect, but is a good example. Everyone can fill a DMCA, but if DMCA are abused, you can sue back. Banning Gab for what one of their user did seems outside of any process.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> However they don't have the capacity to do a fair manual triage of all the services they are hosting Perhaps, but that's not really an argument against complaint-based ToS enforcement. The US (or any other) government may lack the ability for a complete and fair manual triage of all behavior subject to their jurisdiction, but few people argue that complaint-based enforcement of criminal law is therefore unacceptable.
- Nadya 8y agoA common argument in philosophy is that bad ideas should occur in the open - where everyone may ridicule them. When they are cast to the shadows they can grow, under everyone's noses, in private where only there are they allowed to exist. In private, these bad ideas cannot be challenged by others and people will be convinced to believe in them, with nobody challenging the idea as a genuinely terrible idea. It gives bad ideas a breeding ground to foster and you'd never even know about it. By publicly prohibiting speech all that happens is it is brushed under a rug and people pretend it doesn't exist. That doesn't make the problem go away, it's the same as shutting your eyes and covering your ears and pretending the monster in front of you no longer exists. If you get to define certain speech as unspeakable you justify the censorship of any speech determined to be unspeakable when you lose power and someone else steps up to the plate. As history has shown - it's a matter of "when" not "if". Actions like this serve to placate the public. The general public won't be angry at Microsoft for censoring platforms "known for" or "complacent of" hate speech (or worse). It's always a slippery slope though. Once you open up the can of worms that is censorship you justify future censorship. I wait to see what will be next on the chopping block. Edit: A few too many responses to respond to everyone, but if anyone would like to speak with me on it more in depth feel free to email me - information on how to contact me can be found on my profile.
- BryantD 8y agoThat common argument rests on norms established by millennia of relatively difficult communication. Best not to assume that the same people would come to the same conclusions today. For example, QAnon believers have not had their speech restricted. That conspiracy theory is as open as anything you could name. People have challenged it. It's still going. If you believe that challenging terrible ideas makes those who hold them think twice... why hasn't the exact argument you're using gotten rid of the terrible idea that we should restrict speech? Answer: because logical refutation doesn't work. I am not arguing against the slippery slope. This is a very, very hard and risky problem. I am refuting the misconception that shedding light on bad ideas makes them go away.
- mrguyorama 8y ago
- chvid 8y agoWho are the organisations pushing for these bans? Are they completely anonymous?
- pandasun 8y agoIt's the same people who are downvoting you, it's anonymous people that can't handle different political views. Yesterday it was Alex Jones, now it's Gab, Voat will be next, then The_Donald etc. Sticks and stones is a foreign concept to people reporting these sites. They want everyone to agree with them. And since most of the major hosting companies have that liberal culture going on, they will happily ban them. Now watch my post get downvoted and flagged :)
- charonn0 8y agoJust to be clear, his "political views" are a call for violence.
- pandasun 8y agoInteresting, you see I see calls of violence on Twitter all the time but their hosting company isn't threatening to ban them. And if you mean "me" by "his": I don't call for violence.
- sctb 8y agoWe just asked you to please go read the guidelines and follow them. Could you do that now? We don't need any more flamebait here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- inevitable2 8y ago"The Net interprets censorship as damage and routes around it." -John Gilmore Lately this is getting absurd. I believe this quote is still true, but the amount of 'I don't like what is being said so therefore you should be silenced' is going too far. I don't agree with what this guy said (or even know who he is aside from what was said in the article), but I'm alarmed that Microsoft would go after Gab for a user on Gab's platform.
- bitwize 8y agoLately we're sort of learning that absolute freedom to express any opinion you like is kind of a bad idea, especially at web scale. The example of Germany, which is freer and more democratic than the USA despite having strict laws forbidding expressing any sort of Nazi-like opinion, supports this.
- jewelthief91 8y agoHow is Germany more free and Democratic? Aren't they purposefully less free because of anti-Nazi laws?
- bitwize 8y agoGermany consistently places higher than the USA on international press freedom indices. The press, in general, is a protected institution there, whereas here, blowhards like Trump do their damnedest to intimidate journalists out of doing their job, which is to expose the dealings of government to the public. And you don't have to read Hackernews for long to see how terminally fucked and anti-freedom the U.S. justice system is. Things like plea bargaining, money bail, and systemic racism in law enforcement and criminal proceedings make U.S. "freedom" illusory unless you're white and wealthy. As for democracy, it's well known that votes in Congress can be easily bought in the US, far more easily than in Germany's parliament.
- jewelthief91 8y agoHow is this freedom attributable in any direct way to restrictions on "hate speech"?
- driverdan 8y ago> Neo-Nazi deletes anti-Semitic posts from 'alt-right' Twitter Who writes these terrible headlines? Why do these blogspam sites refuse to put the actual topic in the subject? This makes it sound like Twitter is alt-right. It's not even accurate since Gab isn't political or "alt-right," Nazis use it because they refuse to censor.
- slater 8y ago> Gab isn't political or "alt-right" haha, good one!
- devmunchies 8y agoits the last recourse for the alt-right because other platforms censor them. I'm sure if you posted far-left stuff on there it wouldn't be censored either, but there is no point because most social media platforms don't censor far-left thoughts anyway.
- int_19h 8y ago> most social media platforms don't censor far-left thoughts anyway. They do, though. https://www.counterpunch.org/2017/08/09/google-censors-block-access-to-counterpunch-and-other-progressive-sites/ https://www.counterpunch.org/2017/08/09/google-censors-block...
- devmunchies 8y agogoogle results are a social media platform? And i said "most".
- ubernostrum 8y agoWell, there are all the people who point out that Twitter will take ages to respond to a report of a conservative-leaning account making threats and will usually end up saying "that doesn't violate our guidelines". But somehow quickly suspends left-leaning accounts which say similar things. Especially if you say them in the direction of a blue-checkmark conservative-leaning account.
- MoveConstructor 8y agoIt's disconcerting to see how many tech and free speech people are clamoring for the censorship of dissenting opinion and are jubilant when it happens. Free speech has always been a very counter-intuitive process. Opinions that directly oppose yours or even your very person will rub you the wrong way, and to be intent on defending the right of your opponent to voice his opinion seems paradoxical, but we nevertheless conceded that this serves the greater good. The recent Alex Jones incident was legitimized on the basis of dissemination of dangerous ideas. With Gab, the argument is that it is hate speech. The most compelling argument for free speech is that it removes the subjective and variable limits of speech and by extension, slippery slopes. If you must know, while I do consider myself a political conservative, I cannot bear to listen to Alex Jones and I've never used Gab. I'm radically free speech which means I enjoy living in a world where literally everyone can say quite literally everything. Whether there is a slippery slope angle to all this is not even relevant for me. I want to hear the ideas of everyone who is broadcasting. The very arguments I am expounding on are already controversial, but they weren't very long ago. Makes you think.
- kevinmchugh 8y agoThe free speech absolutists would have been more convincing had they been as up-in-arms about the banning of ISIS or ISIS-affiliated accounts over the last several years. This happened by the hundreds-of-thousands.
- jewelthief91 8y agoFor better or worse foreign and domestic terrorist speech is treated separately. If ISIS was a domestic terrorist organization afaik they would have 1A rights.
- kevinmchugh 8y agoWhat's the connection to the first amendment? Did the government dictate bans? I saw very little concern from the "free speech" crowd about the government's ability to censor US publishers from publishing content by foreign authors.
- CM30 8y agoThis sort of thing illustrates the biggest issue with web hosting, domain registrars and the internet's infrastructure in general; everything is privately owned by companies who get unlimited rights to decide who and what they want to host. The solution is to require all hosting and domain companies to act as utilities, and require neutrality in regards to any content that's legal. They're not private forums or homes, they're the internet equivalent to the electricity company or the water company. They're the internet equivalent to a phone service provider or ISP. Why do/did ISPs have to deal with net neutrality while large hosting companies and registrars get free reign? The power company can't cut off your service because you offended someone online or what not. If you want to argue the internet is a place for free speech, then it needs places you can host content/register domains/whatever that act like a public square, not a shopping centre.
- 394549 8y ago> The solution is to require all hosting and domain companies to act as utilities, and require neutrality in regards to any content that's legal. They're not private forums or homes, they're the internet equivalent to the electricity company or the water company. They're the internet equivalent to a phone service provider or ISP. Exactly this. When the First Amendment was authored, I don't think it was even conceivable that any organization besides a government or state church could effectively censor speech at scale. Now that we have "private" organizations that effectively have that power, it's perhaps time that the law be updated to reflect that change in facts and preserve people's right to free expression. The internet shouldn't be another Zuccotti Park.
- CM30 8y agoWhen the First Amendment was authored, I suspect people thought public property was going to be where the largest audience was, with the town hall and park and square and what not being the main platform for discussion. Reaching the crowd meant going out with a handbell or standing on a box passing out pamphlets. Stopping the government from arresting someone advertising in the town square was more important than stopping a shop from kicking out a customer they didn't like. But that's not the case now. The platforms hosting your work are privately owned, the large community websites/social networks/whatever with millions or billions of users are privately owned, and a larger portion of real life locations people frequent are privately owned too. The way society is going seems to be making the amendment less and less relevant as time goes on.
- h4b4n3r0 8y agoSlippery slope, if I've ever seen one. This can and will be used against legitimate dissidents and protesters at some point, that I can pretty much guarantee. Bottom line: I'd be much more comfortable if takedowns could only be done in response to illegal activity on the account, and only after a court order. Otherwise some techno-bureaucrat serves as a judge, jury, and executioner, and I'm categorically not OK with that.
- gammateam 8y ago'alt-right' Twitter just sounds like a subculture on Twitter, not a separate network called Gab. take note journalists... or take note devs that happen to work in open office plans next to the writers. lets not refer to things off of twitter as analogous to subcultures of twitter.
- gammateam 8y agoWho can make better tools for IPFS and other services that are more difficult to take down? The tooling is the main thing stopping people from using more autonomous decentralized services.
- DanAndersen 8y agoOne thing that hasn't yet been remarked on here is that the 48-hour-warning message said that the linked posts were flagged for having phishing links. Notice that the statements made afterward by MS were not on the grounds of the original "phishing links" report, but focusing on the content. However, if you look at the posts, you'll see a fair amount of unsavory content but no phishing links. I feel like this was purposeful on the part of whatever political group made these reports. Most likely, these hosting companies have automated anti-spam/phishing systems whereby, if a large number of reports come in, they will automatically send out an alert to the suspected offending party. If Outraged Group X goes to the company saying "this site you're hosting has vile speech and so you should take it down," it probably has to go through an internal company process, which might have a slightly higher bar for acting on it. However, if Outraged Group X falsely claims that "this site is hosting phishing links", something which might trigger an algorithmic response, then the company cannot easily reverse course -- because then the story becomes "Company ABC actively reverses course on allowing hate speech." The PR fallout locks them in.
- tptacek 8y agoHaving read the article but not knowing anything about the posts themselves, I think most of this thread misses the point. Clearly Microsoft knew it was hosting Gab and what Gab was. There's a troll argument that suggests Gab is just "free speech twitter", but of course that's not the case: I've been screenshotting the front page for months, from a random anonymous account, and every time I've done it the front page was full of horrible Islamophobic, racist, and anti-Semitic crap. That and bot content. My point here is: everybody knows that's what Gab is. Microsoft isn't pushing back on Gab's anti-Semitism --- without anti-Semitism, there is no Gab. They had specific harm reduction problems with a pair of posts, one of which, according to this article, was a call for violence directed towards Jewish people.
- minimaxir 8y ago> I've been screenshotting the front page for months Out of curiosity, why?
- tptacek 8y agoI honestly don't know why. Something just made me think I was going to want data about it someday.
- lainga 8y agoIs this something you do manually...?
- tptacek 8y agoYes.
- microcolonel 8y agoDo you have a (Twitter? ;-) feed with these screenshots?
- pvg 8y ago
- hkon 8y agoI don't know, somehow along the way, videos of beheadings and other cruel content became ok and simple text/opinions can now put entire sites at risk. I am not familiar with the content of the messages, but from now on it's enough to get certain ideas labeled same as these, then it will have to be deleted. The number of labels will increase, and so will the reporting and the deleting.
- fareesh 8y agoThe content here is quite disgusting, and I certainly do not defend it, but I really take issue with what is happening here in principle. Overall this is similar to a runaway effect that negligence of the environment can have. At a certain point it will be too late to solve the problem i.e. control emissions or oppose this kind of authoritarianism under different circumstances. The very means to do so will either be impotent or impossible. By then you are reliant on some new magical invention to resolve the problem, or a large death toll in the millions, which changes the entire landscape. Corporations certainly have the right to do this, but they are only choosing to do so because there are strong winds blowing in this direction. It's important that they are opposed, before this paves the way for big mistakes to be made. It's important that these kinds of ideas see sunlight. Ideas that promote tolerance, peace and common sense will win in the end, provided we keep talking. If talking comes to an end, we know what comes next. These ideas will only find more room to grow, and see greater validation when they are opposed in this kind of authoritarian manner. Rather than advocating a strategy where we are relying on governments and corporations to solve these problems, we should be the ones fixing our societies and arguing against disgusting ideas such as this, with well reasoned arguments, or even humor, both of which have historically been great at winning ideological battles. I am sure this crowd knows their Aaron Satie. "With the first link, the chain is forged. The first speech censured, the first thought forbidden, the first freedom denied, chains us all irrevocably."
- genericid 8y agoI hope this crowd knows their Joseph Goebbels. "When our enemies say: But we used to grant you freedom of opinion -- yes, you granted it to us, that is no proof that we should do the same for you! That you gave us that just proves how stupid you are!" (source: https://de.wikiquote.org/wiki/Joseph_Goebbels https://de.wikiquote.org/wiki/Joseph_Goebbels and https://www.sr-mediathek.de/index.php?seite=7&id=37143 https://www.sr-mediathek.de/index.php?seite=7&id=37143 ; translation by me)
- fareesh 8y agoSo take Goebbels' advice? Not sure what you are getting at. Our enemies are fascists who will take away our rights, therefore anyone suspected of eventually becoming a fascist will have their rights preemptively taken away so that it does not come to that?
- samlevine 8y agoThreats of violence already violate Gab's ToS: "Users are prohibited from calling for the acts of violence against others, promoting or engaging in self-harm, and/or acts of cruelty, threatening language or behaviour that clearly, directly and incontrovertibly infringes on the safety of another user or individual(s)." https://gab.ai/about/guidelines https://gab.ai/about/guidelines
- Scooty 8y agoI wonder what this says about Gab's reaction. Why would they give Little the option to delete his posts instead of banning him and removing the posts themselves? If I was in their position, it wouldn't even be a question of free speech considering he was breaching the ToS.
- Endy 8y agoI have an alternate solution especially for Gab and Voat. Rather than allowing them to become known cesspits, advertise them to people and say, "see how others' opinions exist" - people will sign up for curiosity, they'll sign up to argue, etc. But most importantly, they'll be there on that platform and perhaps some people will actually learn to communicate openly with people they disagree with or whose views they despise.
- DanAndersen 8y agoThat would honestly be a pretty good pivot. The trouble with Gab and Voat is that if you only bill yourself as a "free speech alternative," you get almost-exclusively populated with the sorts of people who have to worry about that (i.e. fringe characters). The community becomes strongly influenced by the "founder effect" of the digital refugees that made up its founding stock. It would be interesting to have a sort of two-column format, where one column is who you normally follow, and the other column is an auto-generated list of people in the most opposite social-graph cluster. The lifeblood of places like Twitter is the ability for people to get into loud arguments that people feel matter more than they actually do. If Twitter ever actually did a full purge of one side of the ideological spectrum they'd find a massive decrease in interest. People want to fight deep down and so need the other around.
- Endy 8y agoBasically yes - then again what I'd like to see (and which I do see somewhat on Voat) is that you have fringe people on all sides - and yes, I mean all, not "both" - there's more than two sides to most human issues.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoYeah, no. People will see the vile toxicity right up front (it's not hidden at all there), and they'll leave in 5 minutes.
- markmark 8y agoSeriously. People have better things to do with their lives.
- reader5000 8y agoThe letter is encouraging in that it at least softly implies Microsoft applies a First Amendment analysis to take down issues. A First Amendment analysis is much superior and more just compared to the injustice applied to Alex Jones and any number of 10000s of removed youtube videos and so on. At the end of the day, tech companies need to realize they are just common carrier pipes and do not have authority to police the bits on their servers anymore than a city bus has the authority to police the politics of its passengers.
- rainbowmverse 8y agoThis thread is a good example of the "sunlight is the best disinfectant" fallacy. It is debunked by research. The thread has countless instances of it. In each, someone goes to the trouble of debunking it. The "exposing bad ideas reduces their power" camp is unmoved. The "the research says you're wrong" camp is unmoved. The false notion is firmly wedged into the public mind because the research came too late. I don't know a good way to prevent this while not shutting down good but unpopular ideas. Letting Nazis, goofballs, and fascists on to all the big social media platforms has obviously not reduced their numbers.
- Forge36 8y agoCan you source that? Otherwise I can't tell if I'm arguing with you, your source, or a straw man.
- rainbowmverse 8y agoNo one asked for a citation on the widespread claim that exposing bad ideas to the light makes them go away, or at least decline in popularity. It's stated and taken as truth, but no one provided proof that it's true. I matched the standard of evidence applied to the original claim. It might be wise to actually investigate that bit of "common sense" before betting the future of the world on people's ability to deal with a flood of misinformation. Maybe I'm wrong. No one bothered to back it up with evidence though. Start there, not with my response to the claim. You could wisely point out I claimed there's research, and I could at least provide it. The research I've seen tells me this won't help since people tend to discount research that goes against their beliefs, and use research that supports those beliefs as reinforcement. It won't do you any good if you start out with a strong belief in the unsupported original claim, as seems to be the case with most people I see here making it.
- Forge36 8y agoI didn't ask for sources on those because they looked believable. Worse, I hadn't seen support for banning until your post. You were the bastion for discussion supporting Microsoft's pressure on Gab. I want to believe your critique and take your side (it's a very popular one online). The article (unless I missed this) wasn't making either claim as superior, it was reporting the news. While many people discount evidence, I hoped to have a starting point for research and looked for support of banning from you. I thought you may be able to provide me sources to guide me towards your way of thinking. You didn't and self justified by fighting the straw man you built. I'd like to believe you, however your argument is self defeating. Instead it feels like you've belittled me for not already taking your side. You're withholding the research you have and I'm supposed to trust you based on this discussion? How? I tried to do research, What I found: 1) I don't know thy right search terms to find articles advocating banning users to solve the problem. 2) Articles discussing the problems of a lack of formal research: http://gwdspace.wrlc.org:8180/jspui/bitstream/1961/8566/4/A411_Transparency.pdf http://gwdspace.wrlc.org:8180/jspui/bitstream/1961/8566/4/A4... A defense of exposing behaviors as a means of change: https://heinonline.org/hol-cgi-bin/get_pdf.cgi?handle=hein.journals/wasbur51§ion=21 https://heinonline.org/hol-cgi-bin/get_pdf.cgi?handle=hein.j... What I've gleamed: 1) A policy of open communication is useful in groups 2) Exposing problems can lead to meaningful change 3) Open communication in a company can help build a powerful culture As this pertains to online forms: nothing it it's taking about discussion. Abd I failed to locate good articles on that subject. Researching Gab: the posts from Gab was immediately followed by a funding request. Users pointing out how it appears to be "Twitter for racists" add (cherry picked) posts highlighting the advocation of destruction if Jewish memorials (and enslavement of the Jewish people). To comment on the article: this appears to be shining the sun on what appears a racist bastion advocating violence. (I might be wrong. Gab didn't remove the posts, the user did) Or to rephrase Microsoft's threat as I'm seeing it: if [Gab] does not remove a post [advocating violence] , Gab must seek hosting on another platform. So which strategy worked? Ban or exposure? For Microsoft? For Gab? For the user? I don't know that the answer is the same for each group. I suspect given the article, exposure pushed Microsoft to push for a ban. A ban pressured the user, by thinking their platform. So where does Gab stand?
- williesleg 8y agoAnd so the thought police is born.
- microcolonel 8y agoGL;HF Microsoft Azure, attempting to force your customers' content policy (in cases for which Azure is clearly not liable) is one more excellent reason not to buy Azure, right around only supporting IPv6 on load balancers (not directly on hosts). Though on the flip side, I think some of these posts could violate Gab's own ToS, so even if their OP didn't remove them voluntarily, they would likely not have survived long anyway.
- naaaaak 8y agoTwitter hosts renowned anti-white racist Sarah Jeong who is gainfully employed by the New York Times. Twitter is aware of her and even gave her a "blue" checkmark. How come Twitter's infrastructure providers don't threaten to pull service?
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoFrom Robert Bolt's A Man For All Seasons (substitute "principle of free speech" for "law"). William Roper: So, now you give the Devil the benefit of law! Sir Thomas More: Yes! What would you do? Cut a great road through the law to get after the Devil? William Roper: Yes, I'd cut down every law in England to do that! Sir Thomas More: Oh? And when the last law was down, and the Devil turned 'round on you, where would you hide, Roper, the laws all being flat? This country is planted thick with laws, from coast to coast, Man's laws, not God's! And if you cut them down, and you're just the man to do it, do you really think you could stand upright in the winds that would blow then? Yes, I'd give the Devil benefit of law, for my own safety's sake! ----------- People in positions of power generally assume that they will always be in power. Many of people during the Obama presidency, wished that the president was less susceptible to gridlock between the various branches of government. In January 2016, most people never even considered the possibility that in 1 year, Donald Trump would be sworn in as President. Right now, the progressive, center left is in a very strong position with regards to the tech industry. All the major players are sensitive to their causes, and against the alt-right. A lot of people are unhappy that the current norms of free speech are causing the social media companies to be slow in taking down alt-right, hate content. People forget, that things change. What if Zuckerberg decides that as a rich, white, male who is accused of indirectly helping Trump get elected, his future political prospects are better if he goes all in and casts his full support behind Trump? What if Twitter continues to have monetization problems and get bought out by a group of wealthy GOP donors? How easy would it be to call any discussion of European colonialism and imperialism or of slavery in the United States, hate speech against whites? How easy would it be to label any discussion of increasing taxes because the 0.1% are not paying their fare share as hate speech against the rich. How about labeling any post advocating protest against ICE as targeted harassment? If you knew that in 5 years, it would be the right that was running Facebook, Twitter, the ISPs, etc, what mores concerning free speech would you want to preserve, even when it involves a private entity. I think a successful democracy in a polarized country involves both sides realizing that there will come a time when they will be out of power and encouraging cultural mores and norms that make sure they are able to communicate freely and have employment even when the other side is in power - either in government or in the private sector.
- lesserroneous 8y agoI'm not convinced this is a true example of censorship. Historically, censorship relates to an institution's ability to prevent information before it becomes public, or to manipulate information to serve its own means. It assumes an almost complete control over the means of information production, whereby a populace barely even sees a glimpse of the censored information. Since Little's neo-nazi propaganda is public and is being openly discussed, he cannot truly be censored. It's more a publicity stunt by Microsoft. There is certainly censorship in the U.S., but this doesn't seem like a true example of it to me. I also think it's a slippery slope fallacy to say that removing a forum about torturing Jews (and other hate speech) will inevitably lead to totalitarian censorship of all provocative ideas. Please show me an example where a government or a private institution withdrew its support of speech like this, which then led to the wholesale censorship of free speech in a country.
- ironjunkie 8y agoWe are living in a new century of censorship. BigTech companies have become so big, that they are the one deciding what to allow or not allow based on some weird guidelines ("Hate speech" means everything and nothing). It became extremely difficult to put an opinion out there and not relying to at least one of them at some level. This weird censorship is perfectly legal since it's coming from private entities. What really annoys me is that it's always the same side that is "censored". All the FAANG//MAGA being extremely left leaning. There is going to be a backslash. It is mounting, and people start to realize.
- darpa_escapee 8y ago> What really annoys me is that it's always the same side that is "censored" Untrue. Religious extremist content has been silently taken down for years. People advocating for workers rights, anarchists and communists have all had a history of facing censorship online.
- Forge36 8y agoI spent done time digging through the posts (and researching the view points). My conclusion: This article and the Twitter posts feel like an advertisement for Gab. It's currently building a userbase, primarily from people banned from Twitter for expressing extreme views. In this case it's capitalizing on a very well known user, a stance supporting the user, and the user self censoring. Something feels off (see my quote). This is timed around Gab seeking funding (see Twitter: https://mobile.twitter.com/getongab/status/1027550072932851713 https://mobile.twitter.com/getongab/status/10275500729328517...) I suspect further exposure will push Gab to censor. However in the interim: it will grow based on the controversy to ban/remain open quoting my own reply >Researching Gab: the posts from Gab was immediately followed by a funding request. Users pointing out how it appears to be "Twitter for racists" add (cherry picked) posts highlighting the advocation of destruction if Jewish memorials (and enslavement of the Jewish people). >To comment on the article: this appears to be shining the sun on what appears a racist bastion advocating violence. (I might be wrong. Gab didn't remove the posts, the user did) Or to rephrase Microsoft's threat as I'm seeing it: if [Gab] does not remove a post [advocating violence] , Gab must seek hosting on another platform. >So which strategy worked? Ban or exposure? For Microsoft? For Gab? For the user? >I don't know that the answer is the same for each group. I suspect given the article, exposure pushed Microsoft to push for a ban. A ban pressured the user, by thinking their platform. So where does Gab stand?
- test001only 8y agoThis is a very clear example of hate speech and people in the comment section seems to unknowingly or deliberately conflating it with free speech. Free speech does not mean you call upon people to incite violence against a particular set of people.
- another-cuppa 8y agoYes it does, actually, whether you like it or not. But maybe you'd like to call into question whether such speech should still be protected as free speech. The difficulty is in establishing where you draw the line.
- jasonvorhe 8y agoMicrosoft should be able to decide who they do business with. That's typical contract law almost everywhere. If they decide get certain content is against their own values, culture and risks the safety of their own staff, even if that risk isn't an immediate one, they should always have the option of termination the contract. That's not censorship, that's business. A company doesn't owe anyone their service, unless they provide a public utility or because they're a monopoly. In terms of web hosting, neither is the case with Microsoft.
- stealthmodeclan 8y agoReligions? Do they've all scientifically verified ideas? People still believe in them. Not only that, religion is also given special place in the constitution and law of some countries. Religion is still going strong. Try to take away anyone's religion based on refutations then tell me that refuting bad idea really works. Till then many others will try to mix mash bad ideas into new religions.
- IanDrake 8y agoGood for Microsoft for drawing the correct line in the sand. Calls to violence are not protected speech. The Alex Jones censorship is another matter. His stuff is pretty crazy, but not worthy of being taken down. Louis Farrakhan says lots crazy stuff and I don’t believe he’s been censored at all. There is definitely a double standard at play.
- bovermyer 8y agoMicrosoft's comments are in keeping with a common misconception about the First Amendment. For clarity, the relevant part of the First Amendment is here: > Congress shall make no law ... abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press ... Nowhere does it say anything about private companies, other groups, or even other branches of government having to obey this rule. I don't have data on how many people actually believe the First Amendment lets them say whatever they want wherever they want. I'm guessing it's a pretty high number, though.
- jve 8y agoOr just use this secure key fob holder: https://youtu.be/-MILCnDczC0?t=9m17s https://youtu.be/-MILCnDczC0?t=9m17s
- inevitable2 8y ago"The Net interprets censorship as damage and routes around it." -John Gilmore Lately this is getting absurd. I believe this quote is still true, but the amount of 'I don't like what is being said so therefore you should be silenced' is going too far. I don't agree with what this guy said (or even know who he is aside from what was said in the article), but I'm alarmed that Microsoft would go after Gab for a user on Gab's platform.