15 ms·
Ten years left to redesign lithium-ion batteries?
- asah 8y agoWorth reading: https://www.fool.com/investing/2018/02/21/cobalt-stocks-what-investors-need-to-know.aspx https://www.fool.com/investing/2018/02/21/cobalt-stocks-what...
- another-one-off 8y agoThe Broken Hill Proprietary Company, BHP, comes from Broken Hill, Australia. It is one of the largest mining companies in the world. Now what is interesting about Broken Hill is I have it on reasonable authority that the area as a whole has had "20 years of remaining reserves" for the last 60 years, because the explorers only bother to go out and 'discover' new parts of the deposit when they get below 15-20 years of reserves. This is an interesting anecdote to my main point - the cobalt price seems to have jumped like a salmon about 12 months ago, but bringing a new mine online can take about 5 years. Even assuming we don't make this 10 year time frame, who really knows what deposits might have become profitable to mine with even a doubling of the price. High prices isn't a signal that we have run out, it is a signal that more mines are needed. It is likely the market will heed the signal.
- pyre 8y ago> High prices isn't a signal that we have run out, it is a signal that more mines are needed. It is likely the market will heed the signal. It is a signal that there is a high demand, and not enough supply (whether naturally or artificially -- e.g. diamonds) to meet that demand. That's it. Building more mines can only happen if the resources exist to mine. This idea that "the market" is a magic wand to wave at problems really needs to stop. As far as "the market" is concerned, the electric car industry could collapse because it failed to innovate past resource shortages.
- xigma 8y ago>> Building more mines can only happen if the resources exist to mine. The resources do exist to mine. Only a tiny fraction of rare earth minerals are actually being mined, because it's not economical in most places.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- skybrian 8y agoThe article is not about rare earth metals.
- pjc50 8y agoIt's worth recalling the distinction between "reserves" and "resources": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineral_resource_classification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineral_resource_classificatio... In a very real sense, we don't know how many undiscovered resources are out there, we can only estimate them. And the estimates move over time with technological improvement.
- jeffreyrogers 8y agoThis happens in pretty much every mining and extraction industry. Oil reserves have been enough for about 50 years for the last 50 years iirc. There's no point in trying to find all the reserves ahead of time since your technology will change and things that were previously unviable become viable.
- vinceguidry 8y agoOne of the more interesting aspects of modern global warfare is the fact that, should the world decide to stage another world war, pretty much everyone is going to run out of a lot of these strategic resources within a few months to years. This, plus the fact that nuclear warfare is going to be extremely limited due to lack of available weapons, and the virtual impossibility of invading a country you don't share a land border with, puts a very hard limit on the amount of aggression any one nation can muster up. Even the mighty US military is a paper tiger after a few steady months of all-out combat.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoThe USA has plenty of rare elements to mind as long as the military doesn’t mind paying more. The USA is already a resource powerhouse, but China has undercut it severely in refining because they hadn’t been caring much about their environment. The USA military also really really excels at strategic logistics, I’m pretty sure they have more than just a few months stockpiled.
- vinceguidry 8y agoThe military has to compete for these resources with the private sector, you might be surprised at just how much the current logistics toolchain simply buys from private companies off the shelf.
- detaro 8y agoAssuming a world war scenario, there likely is no competition with the private sector, which will have a choice between producing what the government wants it to produce or being put under government control and then producing what the government wants.
- jcranmer 8y agoThe government can, and will in any WWII-level war, choose to ration industrial metals that are in short supply. The US government in WWII effectively allocated who was allowed steel, copper, tin, cobalt, etc. to ensure that sufficient material was diverted to military needs.
- joking 8y agoThis is supposing that we want big cars with big batteries, In the cities the mobility is moving toward small personal vehicles, and if you have bigger commuter needs, I hope that in the future the highways can be electrified and the cars would only need the battery to get from the highway to your home. There are not enough minerals to make batteries to replace all the current cars with their current autonomy, but a change of transport paradigm could be feasible.
- Reason077 8y ago”There are not enough minerals to make batteries to replace all the current cars” More than enough reserves exist, in the ground. Particularly as new cell chemistries are using much less cobalt. It’s just there may not be enough production at current rates.
- majewsky 8y ago> I hope that in the future the highways can be electrified Obligatory remark: Let's also put the cars on metal rails instead of on asphalt to reduce rolling friction. And maybe instead of small cars, we could use large wagons or chains of those that could transport a lot of people at the same time.
- xigma 8y agoYeah... but that's kinda missing something. Can't we put it into a vacuum tube instead, preferably underground?
- magduf 8y agoNo, those are called trains, and while they're great for shuttling a large number of people between two distant points, or along a line of points, they really suck for moving a large number of people between countless arbitrary points that are arranged in 2-dimensional space like a grid (or a metro area that's spread out in all directions). What you really want, to replace private cars, is SkyTran: tiny cars for 1-2 people, suspended from metal rails (which have a maglev effect to eliminate friction altogether), that are completely autonomous and take riders directly to their destination within a metro area. Each one operates independently, so you don't have to worry about what other users are doing or waste time going to stations that aren't your destination. IMO, it's shameful that we haven't done more to explore PRT (personal rapid transit). It could really revolutionize city and suburban life and eliminate the need for so many people to own cars, while also saving people so much time with commuting (since such a system, fully built-out, would have far higher capacity than our current road system).
- xigma 8y agoThe headline is made to sound like: "Oh no, we are running out of cobalt!" Yeah, not really. Just like with "oil reserves", there's a common misconception that we'll "run out" when they are depleted. However, "reserves" are just those resources that can be extracted economically at today's prices. When demand increases, prices rise and reserves "magically" increase. That's exactly what will happen here. "Rare-earth materials" aren't actually rare in the sense that precious metals are rare. They're just uncommon compared to other minerals. If prices rise, eventually China will decide to increase exports and other countries that aren't literally warzones (like the DRC) will chime in. So, we have ten years until those batteries will become somewhat more expensive, making research into alternatives more promising. There is no urgency here. Then of course there's the questionable idea that electric motors will replace combustion engines because we're "running out of oil", which is why we supposedly need all these batteries in the first place. My bet is that synthetic fuels will become profitable far earlier.
- Reason077 8y ago> "there's the questionable idea that electric motors will replace combustion engines because we're "running out of oil"" Right. Electric motors will replace combustion engines because they're cheaper to operate, offer better performance, require less maintenance, don't emit toxic pollutants, contribute less CO2 emissions, they're much quieter, and they offer a better driving experience. Sooner or later they'll be cheaper to manufacture, too, due to reduced labour required, component commonality, fewer moving parts, etc.
- xigma 8y agoSome questionable assumptions there: - cheaper to operate An enormous amount of electricity would be required to actually replace all combustion engines in just regular cars, plus a lot of investment into infrastructure to charge all these cars. Higher demand, higher prices. - offer better performance Are the best-selling cars today those with the best performance? No, they're the ones offering acceptable performance at the best price. - require less maintenance That's assuming that maintenance cost is a big deciding factor in a car. Cars are assumed to be depreciating assets, when maintenance becomes too expensive they are replaced. There's some argument to be made here for certain vehicles like Taxis with a lot of usage, but the general consumer will not highly value or even accurately estimate maintenance. - don't emit toxic pollutants Most consumers don't put a premium on this. Modern combustion engines don't emit a lot of pollutants anymore, but even then it would take government intervention to force people away from them. - contribute less CO2 emissions Again, most consumers don't put a premium on this, but government intervention could change that. Synthetic fuels of the future may well be carbon neutral though. - they offer a better driving experience ...assuming you're not running out of battery.
- ggm 8y agoOh god, another Erlich/Simons bet is needed: what's low is the level of rare earth exploration and exploitation not absolute supply. Is there a supply chain problem? Yes. Are we approaching a mad-max hell war for the last vestiges of humanities wonder mineral? Alas.. no. The ten years meme is based in a false premise. The article even says Australian known sources are only utilised at 14% and yet predicts a long term supply problem without asking what other sources might be discovered. From the article A lithium-ion car battery with a 100 kg cathode requires 6–12 kg of cobalt and 36–48 kg of nickel so work on 10kg without improvements and same article says at current economic models only 10 exp 8 tonnes economically extractable. So 10 exp 10 batteries. (1000 kg per tonne) 10,000,000,000 batteries. One car for everyone alive... And that's before normal levels of production efficiency, scavenging nice cobalt rich sources like old batteries or even the intent of the article: new sources and new technologies.
- tompccs 8y agoAnother point the article missed: although batteries have a lifetime of 15-20 years (which they claim makes recycling infeasible), most people currently replace their cars far more frequently than that. Which means that either the cars will be scrapped and the battery materials recycled (if they really are all that valuable), or the global production of cars per capita will slow as people keep their cars for the lifetime of the batteries.
- bluGill 8y agoMost cars today are scraped because the body wears out, not because the engine fails. Of course if you are reading this you probably trade in your car much sooner, and send it on down the line to poorer and poorer people, eventually the car ends up in Mexico/Central America (US/Canada), or Africa (Europe), where they keep it running until it is ~20 years old and the body fails. You probably are more ware of engine failures because you don't have any experience with a car that actually wears out, only cars where there is either premature engine failure, or is in an accident. The only reason 15 year batteries are not recyclable are it will be 15 years before current cars get old enough to need that infrastructure. There is plenty of money to be made if you want to invest in recycling them, but you need to invest at the right time. You probably should be thinking about recycling in Central America or Africa (consider political issues before investing!), and make sure you don't over invest, lead acid batteries fundamentally need twice as much infrastructure because they are replaced twice as often.
- endymi0n 8y agoAs one of my favorite comedians once put it: „Analysts are people who tell you what the world will look like in 15 years if nothing changes. Now do you REALLY want to know how long your toenails get if you don‘t cut them?!“ Movement here will come from a number of factors: - Demand increases, which will: - open up more mines (nicely summarized in the long commentary in this thread) - incentivize better extraction technology - Supply will decrease, which will make Cobalt more expensive, which in turn leads to: - battery chemistry with way less cobalt needed (already happening) - better recycling - technology accessing hidden reserves (oil shale and tar sands anyone?) - research into complete alternatives like pressured air, hydrogen, redux flow batteries etc. We‘ll be fine and renewables will win in any case by now.
- crunchlibrarian 8y agoOne of the first things we learned in civics class when I was all of 11 was that you should be very suspicious any time you see a line extrapolated out into the far future. Things never stay the same, especially rates of change. Now half the media seems to be in the business of extrapolating lines out and trying to stir enough panic to get that click. Maybe we need more civics classes.
- agumonkey 8y agoI don't like over confidence in any resource access, that's probably what oil digger thought 100 years ago.
- simias 8y agoDoesn't this example go against your point? I've been hearing that we were nearing the end of the oil supply since I've been a kid but the date keeps being pushed back. As the demand for oil grows the price goes up and new methods to extract more oil from the ground become profitable. Now current projections seem to target the 2050s at the earliest.
- heavenlyblue 8y agoYeah. I mean if you started digging oil 100 years ago - you would probably be rich enough for another century today. Even if you don’t dig it anymore.
- Reason077 8y agoThe NCM cells most commonly used in electric vehicles have already significantly reduced their cobalt content in recent years. Moving from NCM 333 (33% cobalt cathode), to 622 (20%), to 811 (10%). Tesla claims to use even less cobalt in their 2170 NCA cells than the best NCM811 chemistry. As for nickel, a billion tonnes of known commercially-viable reserves ought to be enough for all the world’s vehicles to be electrified several times over. And all these minerals can be recovered and reused from recycled batteries.
- ptero 8y agoTL;DR: Battery demand grows. Best current tech uses nickel and cobalt. Their prices grow and at the current growth trends demand outstrips supply within 20 years. We should fund research (in the author's area) to find better alternatives (e.g., using iron and silicon). This is valid but not surprising and hardly catastrophic. This is not "10 years left to find an alternative". But what turned me off is scaremongering and naive justifications. For example, "In Africa, some mine owners exploit child workers and skimp on protective equipment" (this is true, is a problem, but has no relation to the article; they do not even claim that children mine Ni or Co), etc. My 2c -- the title is clickbait-y and the content is lacking for nature-caliber writeup (I only read it because it referenced nature.com).
- xigma 8y agoTo the point, the prices are so damn low that only by the worst production methods is extraction even economically feasible. Higher prices will lead to production in less reckless environments, which is a good thing.
- Kagerjay 8y agoI thought nickel-colbalt has a significantly lower specific energy / energy density than other lithium-polymer batteries. They might be cheaper to make (or maybe not so much anymore), but they have a large space form factor. I don't know of any laptop today that's using a nickel cobalt battery. Those ones usually allowed you to remove the battery pack from the laptop. Now there all based on lithium-polymer now. Same with smartphones. I did some research in lithium polymer batteries a few years back. I distinctly remember there being almost 10 or so variations of lithium polymer mixes being used in battery production.
- hwillis 8y agoNo, LiPo (which really means li-ion with gel or polymer electrolyte) has a lower specific energy (kWh/kg) but higher specific power (kW/kg). > I don't know of any laptop today that's using a nickel cobalt battery. Those ones usually allowed you to remove the battery pack from the laptop. Now there all based on lithium-polymer now. Same with smartphones. They all use NMC (nickel manganese cobalt) cathodes. LiPo batteries have the exact same cathodes and anodes as normal li-ion, just a different electrolyte. > I did some research in lithium polymer batteries a few years back. I distinctly remember there being almost 10 or so variations of lithium polymer mixes being used in battery production. There are ~10 main chemistry families, but hundreds of mixes.
- Sir_Cmpwn 8y agoWe should invest in space mining as well, there's no practical limit to the natural resources of the solar system at humanity's current scale.
- Retric 8y agoThere is over a cubic km of earths crust that can be mined per person on the planet using current technology. There is zero need for space mining as actually rare materials we care about like Oil don't exist in space.
- Sir_Cmpwn 8y agoThe problem with the Earth's crust is all the stuff on top of it. We can't extract 100% of the earth's crust's value, or anywhere near it, without disrupting huge swaths of wild and human habitats. We're already causing a mass extinction at our current rate of consumption, do you really want to increase that? We need to move away from oil so that we don't kill ourselves with climate change regardless.
- Retric 8y agoThat's just cost / benefit. We can keep the top ~5 meters of earth and extract what's beneath it without disrupting ecosystems. However, the current approach of massive mines is cheaper and frankly we have such a vast abundance of resources that's working fine it's not like every person on the planet has any need for 20+ lb of gold. Further, we can always just mine old garbage dumps as elements are not destroyed just shifting chemical bonds.
- Sir_Cmpwn 8y agoBut this very article is talking about the possibility of running out. Do you disagree with the premise of the article? Nature is a respected publication, if you think they're wrong you should work on a properly sourced and peer reviewed rebuttal.
- baybal2 8y ago3-4 new polymetalic mines can easily double the global cobalt supply. The story with cobalt is the same as with REEs and Lithium - they are everywhere, but few big companies dare to mine them expecting the business to go bust the moment China or Congo resort to further dumping For Nickel, global supply is being dominated by a price cartel, doing the same thing.
- baybal2 8y agoIronically, in Nickel, the only company that somehow manages to lives outside the cartel scheme is Chinese.
- nutjob2 8y agoIt's peak cobalt! Just like peak oil.
- 3pt14159 8y agoI remember trying to explain basic Econ 101 to a classmate while in third year engineering. Peak Oil was a religion back then. The same isn't true for the environment. Unlike Peak Oil where economic incentives simultaneously would encourage smaller cars with more efficient engines while also directing research into more advanced oil retrieval (or at the very worst biofuels) the environment is not something the market will automatically solve. Quite the opposite. It will push up against it until there is sufficient political resistance to overcome market resources attempting to maintain the status quo. We have a real problem, but it isn't oil or cobalt.
- xigma 8y agoPolluting the environment is damaging someone's property (private or state), for which they will eventually demand restitution. It's part of market forces. Conversely, a certain amount of pollution/environmental destruction is a price people are willing to pay.
- mikeash 8y agoWhat market forces allow them to convert their demands into action?
- merpnderp 8y agoAren't all market forces in the end the result of private property and contract law? Without those, people would quickly stop being able to trust any deals they made, and would have to resort to cash, and even then only in cases where they have a high level of social trust in the person they're trading with.
- mikeash 8y ago
- grecy 8y ago> We use less than 3% cobalt in our batteries & will use none in next gen - Elon Musk https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1006968985760366592 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1006968985760366592
- xigma 8y agoDon't put your money on that.
- Robotbeat 8y agoThe current 3% battery cobalt level already confirmed by 3rd party tear down analysis. "Next gen" could be years away, sure. But there are PLENTY of existing lithium battery chemistries which use no cobalt whatsoever.
- xigma 8y agoThere's a big difference between 3% cobalt and no cobalt. Cobalt is important for safety, skimping on it to save some money is a big risk. I'm not saying it won't happen, just that I wouldn't put money on it.
- Robotbeat 8y agoLiFEPo batteries, which are notable for their safety, use zero cobalt. There are other ways to accomplish these goals.
- nickik 8y agoThe problem with Rare Earth is that the West collectively acts like 3 year old who are to dumb to solve incredibly simple problems. Rare earth contained lots of Thorium and that has to be handled as nuclear waste and that means you have 1000s of tons of nuclear waste on your hands. This is of course completely idiotic because Thorium not really a big problem as it is not radioactive. The few Rare Earth mines that do exist only extract the lower group so you can avoid the Thorium. Because the US drives policy for the whole West, there is basically no Rare Earth mining in the West. China on the other hand understands that the more expensive rare earths are outside of China the more likely people will manufacture in China. While I am 100% with Simons (one of the best economists ever) the unlimited stupidly of government is stopping a real market solution. There was quite a bit of effort to change this and it got traction in congress because many people are really concerned that all US military equipment depends on rare earths from China. See: - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O7QNZ56j-HM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O7QNZ56j-HM - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lxwF93wnRQo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lxwF93wnRQo
- pjc50 8y agoThorium is radioactive, just not very much. It's toxic in the way a lot of heavy metals are. https://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/toxprofiles/tp147.pdf https://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/toxprofiles/tp147.pdf
- nickik 8y agoYeah is radioactive but you can build a bed out of it and sleep on it so its not radioactive in any practical sense. And of course Toxic is not a problem because most of the metals a rare earth mine would deal with would be toxic. You can actually find heavily concentrated earth in the US that would basically count as nuclear waste because nuclear policy is so insane.
- woah 8y agoWhere is this earth located?
- ed_balls 8y agoWhen I was in school - 15 years ago - I remember reading that we will run of oil in 2030. Seems like a similar wrong estimate.
- Jweb_Guru 8y agoThe fact that we haven't run out of oil yet doesn't really change anything about the fact that oil-based industry is not sustainable. I don't see why this isn't a similar situation.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoIs anything truly sustainable when we live on a planet of finite resources?
- jcadam 8y agoIn the long run, nothing is sustainable.
- francisofascii 8y agoThe sun is our best bet. We will have it for another 5 billion years give or take.
- basicplus2 8y agoYeh so not sustainable.. it will run out.. and... it will run out even if we don't use it!
- hn2017 8y agoThis is what people don't get. It's simply not sustainable and of course we need to invest in battery research. And the sooner the better.
- bloomthrowaway 8y ago> Recycling cannot replenish supplies. Lithium-ion batteries last for 15–20 years, 3 times longer than the 5–7 years for lead-acid batteries Over 90% of car batteries are already recycled. Assuming this stays constant when batteries get bigger(why wouldn't it), we'll hit steady-state on materials about a decade after electric cars become dominant. Due to recycling, this whole article is baseless. Eventually we'll only need to mine enough to make up for a the few percent of batteries that aren't recycled. Car batteries are already recycled at extremely high rates, and there's no reason to believe this will change.
- nickik 8y agoThe problem with Rare Earth is that the West collectively acts like 3 year old who are to dumb to solve incredibly simple problems. Rare earth contained lots of Thorium and that has to be handled as nuclear waste and that means you have 1000s of tons of nuclear waste on your hands. This is of course completely idiotic because Thorium not really a big problem as it is not radioactive. The few Rare Earth mines that do exist only extract the lower group so you can avoid the Thorium. Because the US drives policy for the whole West, there is basically no Rare Earth mining in the West. China on the other hand understands that the more expensive rare earths are outside of China the more likely people will manufacture in China. There was quite a bit of effort to change this and it got traction in congress because many people are really concerned that all US military equipment depends on rare earths from China. See: - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O7QNZ56j-HM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O7QNZ56j-HM - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lxwF93wnRQo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lxwF93wnRQo
- gok 8y agoREs are an interesting situation but not what's being talked about in this article. China has no production of cobalt and a tiny fraction of nickel.
- w-m 8y agoThe inclusion of the metal price graph[1] is very strange. What are they trying to tell with that? To me it demonstrates that nickel and cobalt prices are currently right where they should be in the market (considering the concentration), compared to the other metals. So if cobalt prices quadrupled from 22$ to 81$ recently, doesn't it mean that cobalt was highly undervalued before and is now correctly priced? [1] https://media.nature.com/w800/magazine-assets/d41586-018-05752-3/d41586-018-05752-3_15963452.png https://media.nature.com/w800/magazine-assets/d41586-018-057...
- syncsynchalt 8y agoI believe the graph was to support their argument that it's better to [fund their research in electrodes that] use Cu and Fe rather than Ni and Co, since their abundance will always make those materials cheaper.
- tombert 8y agoI know that the popsci media can overblow this, but wasn't there some optimistic results for super-capacitors that wouldn't rely on any of these rare-earth metals? I'm seriously asking, since looking this up tends to bring up links to crap-sites like IFLS and whatnot, so I don't know if the hype is warranted.
- hwillis 8y agoThere are also optimistic results for batteries, because li-ion batteries do not and never have used rare earth elements. Cobalt and nickel are not rare earth elements and as other people have pointed out the global resources of both are far higher than the article suggests. You probably have difficulty looking up alternatives to batteries with rare earth elements because the only sites that say they have rare earth elements have negative knowledge about the subject.
- tombert 8y agoI was specifically interested in the super capacitor part of my question, I apologize for some potentially ambiguous semantics.
- Theodores 8y agoGlad someone asked. Supercapacitors are the thing that halves the requirement for these lithium iron batteries that we are supposed to be running out of. The good news is that fantastic work is being done in this area, making those Tesla things rather quaint old technology. It is all going on in Estonia and you are well advised to watch this recent episode of Fully Charged to see what a wonderful place Estonia is and why it should be where you next go on holiday: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KQ2Eo6wl5r0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KQ2Eo6wl5r0 So, 'spoiler alert', a supercapacitor in a vehicle compliments the battery and stores the energy from re-gen and gets you away from the lights at super fast speed without having to have some huge Tesla-esque American sized battery providing the oomph. It is win win as the vehicle is lighter. The other benefit of supercapacitors is that they can also be used to provide smoothing of electricity supply, e.g. when the cup final is on and everyone goes to turn their kettle on at half time. As mentioned, watch the Fully Charged episode about Estonia and what lovely people there are there, including a few doing great things with supercapacitors.
- jdlyga 8y agoLet's just use D batteries. Good enough for a flashlight, good enough for a Macbook.
- gok 8y agoI know you're joking, but many D batteries (and effectively all the rechargeable ones) also contain nickel.
- gt565k 8y agoThe solution is investment in public transportation and a reduction in consumption. There's absolutely no reason for most people in industrialized countries to own a car, other than the fact that the public transportation infrastructure sucks. With the shift of gas to electrically powered vehicles, there's even less of a reason for people to own an electric vehicle with a massive battery. We need higher density public transportation. Where the kwh of transporting a person goes down on average, thus reducing the need for more batteries. As residential density increases, and road infrastructure can't keep up, we'll see a lot more bike paths, light and heavy rail, close proximity grocery stores, etc... Look at Atlanta right now. Traffic is a clusterfuck, suburbs are also expanding, prompting more people to own a vehicle so they can get to downtown where the jobs are. You sit on the highway, and every single person is in a 5 person vehicle, only for 1 seat to be occupied. What a colossal waste from a utilization perspective. Atlanta has decided to repurpose an old rail loop around the city and make a paved path around the entire city, which connects to other public infrastructure via auxiliary paths and existing trails. It is called The Beltline. It will take maybe another 10 years to complete the entire loop, but the city will be ready to handle the problems that will ensue decades from now.
- HillaryBriss 8y agoPeople want a consistent, reasonable commute time. Los Angeles's utilization rates for public transportation could probably be improved a great deal by giving buses priority over individual car traffic so that bus commute times were relatively short and predictably so. But what a huge political battle would have to be won to change street and freeway use regulations...
- andygreenwell 8y agoAnd then you have the mayors of North Fulton (for example Mayor Mike Bodker of Johns Creek) that are fundamentally opposed to expanding various forms of rapid transit into their supposedly low density housing suburban communities: https://www.johnscreekga.gov/NewsAndEvents/News-Archive/2018-News/View-the-Mayor-s-statement-on-proposed-MARTA-tax-i https://www.johnscreekga.gov/NewsAndEvents/News-Archive/2018... Having moved to Johns Creek from Boston last year, I think the Red Line should go all the way up 400 to Cumming and they should add more express lanes along 400. But there are two messages I hear consistently around town when I ask various people about this issue: 1. People like their low density housing, and you are never going to be able to put in enough rail access (like Boston's T or NYC's Subway) close enough to where people live or where they need to be on the other end to eliminate cars off the road through most of the area. 2. They don't want particular groups from other parts of Atlanta having easy access to where they live...essentially to keep possible criminal elements away. Point 1 is a legitimate concern, but commuter rail systems do exist in other areas of the country, and parking garages can be placed next to rail stations. Would definitely ease the nightmare that is rush hour on 400. Point 2 is just a terrible legacy of racism that still exists in the South (and I'm a Southern boy born and raised until living in Boston for 10 years). There is a terrible acronym for MARTA that I have heard multiple times since moving here that just needs to disappear.
- gadders 8y agoAs I heard an economist say once: "The best cure for high prices is high prices."
- cestith 8y agoAs a Houston resident who hears a lot of news about oil prices and demand for goods from the extraction support industries, there's evidence of this every day. Not everyone grasps self-limiting cycles and feedback signals at first. I like to point them to this old proverb about the Mullah Nasrudin. http://voetica.com/voetica.php?collection=4&poet=706&poem=3443 http://voetica.com/voetica.php?collection=4&poet=706&poem=34...
- aurizon 8y agoWe need to work on super-springs, so you can wind up your car... LOL Right now there is a lot of lithium in the earth, much is not economic, but as lithium prices rise, more mines will become economic. Cobalt, as well as lithium will become far more highly recycled. Battery innards will be improved to reduce Cobalt use. Lithium use can not be reduced very much per KW hour, as the chemical changes oxidation state in a charge/discharge cycle. Lithium is both light in weight and has nearly the highest possible voltage swing of ~~3.7 volts (versus 2 volts for lead and 1.2 volts for Nicads and NiMh which are many time heavier per KWHr in addition))
- magduf 8y ago>Lithium is both light in weight and has nearly the highest possible voltage swing of ~~3.7 volts (versus 2 volts for lead and 1.2 volts for Nicads and NiMh which are many time heavier per KWHr in addition) IANAchemist, but this makes me wonder if there's some other chemistry out there, either undiscovered or deemed uneconomic, that offers even better performance than lithium.
- aphextron 8y ago>IANAchemist, but this makes me wonder if there's some other chemistry out there, either undiscovered or deemed uneconomic, that offers even better performance than lithium. There are, but of course there's tradeoffs. Lithium is the best all around cathode choice for economical reasons, but Sodium and Potassium are being explored as well. The real gains can be found in new electrolyte chemistries, though. My money is that we will be using lithium for the foreseeable future, and that advances in electrolyte chemistry will get us to the $100/kWh point.
- magduf 8y agoI wonder what the problems with sodium and potassium are. Sodium, for one, is an extremely common element on Earth's surface, which I can't say for Lithium. Potassium is also very common. You can get all the sodium you could possibly want just by drying out seawater. By contrast, lithium supply seems to be limited to a few places such as Bolivia.
- ngrilly 8y agoWhat about graphene-based batteries?
- Lilienfeld 8y agoExactly, in ten years graphene batteries wil have obliterated current technologies.
- douglaswlance 8y agoWhen things get more scarce, they become more valuable. When things get more valuable, they become more expensive. When things get more expensive, people find new ways to sell them. FUD over supply and demand is so boring!
- mtgx 8y agoGood thing in 10 years solid state batteries should just about enter the mainstream.
- mchannon 8y agoIn ten years, I predict we'll have started transitioning to aluminum-ion batteries. Lithium has one valence electron. Aluminum has three. Aluminum-ion cells are not new, and they do have issues, but the same can be said of Lithium-ion 20 years ago. Energy densities are remarkably different, with aluminum the clear winner. Ironically, nickel and probably cobalt will be needed for mass-produced aluminum-ion batteries too.
- aphextron 8y agoAl-ion may be superior in energy density, but I doubt we'll be seeing it in EVs any time soon. The recharging issues may be able to be solved, but the vast majority of all funding for R&D and production is being focused on lithium right now. Lithium is "good enough" to hit the $100/kWh target which will make EVs affordable to the mass market.
- yazr 8y ago> Ironically, i see what u did there....
- exabrial 8y agoI don't think batteries are a long term solution without a materials science breakthrough. The charging rate and the charge density needs to be increased exponentially. I think we have a much better shot with hydrogen fuel cells, or other phase change system that can be refueled rapidly.
- TFlats 8y agoWhere's the investment in ultra-transformers nowadays? I joke, but surely there is potential...
- abakker 8y agoThe thing that I always thing about is that there are other uses for rare-earths. Vanadium, for example is used in structural steel as a alloying element that make steel MUCH stronger. Neodymium is used in magnets and lasers. Thorium is used in TIG welding. We can't just siphon off all the Rare Earths for batteries without impacting other industries.
- hwillis 8y agoGood news! None of those are used in batteries. In fact, there are no rare earth elements in batteries. Also, the article does not mention rare earths a single time. Even better: neodymium is unlike the other rare earths in that it is commonly found on its own. All the other rare earths almost always only occur together. Neodymium is quite easy to find an extract, and has always been of least/little concern. Back when fears about rare earth shortages were a thing, the element of concern was tellurium, as it was assumed that thin film cadmium-telluride solar panels were the next big thing. They are now virtually obsolete.
- GeekyBear 8y agoAn assistant professor at UCSD just announced a new method for recycling cobalt in lithium-ion batteries. http://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-lithium-ion-battery-recycling-20180316-story.html# http://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-lithium-ion...
- jackfoxy 8y agoI haven't studied this problem, but I suspect reserves of metals (and anything else that gets mined) is technically defined the same way oil reserves are defined, which renders this kind of headline nonsense. Even in the pessimistic case, we run out of money before we run out of reserves. In other words, price elasticity always brings more reserves online. Reserves are defined as what can be provably economically extracted given proven technology and current economics. And the proven technology is only what has been proven in a particular field (or mine, or battery recycling facility), not proven anywhere in the world.
- advertising 8y agoDespite the sentiment to this article here, has anyone invested in cobalt/copper/nickel futures or mining companies?
- squozzer 8y agoI would argue for a more holistic approach. Sure, optimize current resource consumption and even bring technically inferior but more practical batteries to market, but also do not assume the electric vehicle end-state = swap electric for internal combustion. For instance, would we have a possible resource crunch if US car ownership went from >1 car / person to 0.1 car / person or lower? That could happen in a few years now, with Uber / Lyft running on fossil fuels. What if self-driving, electric vehicles come to market not as personal transport, but instead as transportation-as-a-service?
- Proven 8y agoInvestors, $10 billion more for Tony Stark or the Earth gets it!
- KingPrad 8y agoMy first encounter with a "just 10 more years" projection was while writing a paper on zinc in middle school. My reference book about mining and metallurgy discussed declining reserves and that the world would be entirely out of zinc by 1985 without careful conservation. Except I was reading the book in 1995, and it was published in 1975. It became an interesting point in my paper. If this writer didn't work for a company that will make money off his ridiculous assertions, I would be baffled how an educated adult could write such an article.
- euyyn 8y ago> If this writer didn't work for a company that will make money off his ridiculous assertions You mean the authors of the Nature article? Only their affiliation to Georgia Tech is listed. Or the author of that book on zinc? Ooooh at the very bottom: > Competing Financial Interests > G.Y. is a co-founder, chief technology officer, a board member and a shareholder of Sila Nanotechnologies, the company commercializing silicon-based anode materials mentioned in this Comment article.
- dang 8y agoOk you guys, we've put a question mark above as a nod to the skepticism in this thread.
- erikpukinskis 8y agoWith respect to electric cars the actual energy density is only half the story. Efficiency can be gained with pack efficiency, aerodynamics, weight reduction of the vehicle, including smaller low occupancy vehicles enabled by the Mobility-As-A-Service model, and removing material with the help of better computer simulation and modeling, more efficient energy recapture systems, energy efficient accel/decel algorithms, denser destination charging network, skate systems like Boring Loop, all of which can decrease battery size which itself increases efficiency even further. Similar to density in chip design, as density hits fundamental limits, other axes of power can help keep improvement at least linear.
- acd 8y agoTo lessen global co2 emissions we should think about which wehicles gets batteries first. Is it a car commuting for example an hour a day or commercial wehicles which are out in the road constantly? Think of 100kw if battery power in a personal Wehicle versus commercial delivery trucks. Secondly you do not need to pack 100kw of batteries in a car who rarely commutes long distance. If the batteries are shared between cars then you swap in a 100kw pack for the long term commute but have a 10kw pack for every day use. That way batteries will last a lot longer.
- nanis 8y agoRequired reading for all you neo-Malthusian types: https://www.econlib.org/library/YPDBooks/Jevons/jvnCQ.html https://www.econlib.org/library/YPDBooks/Jevons/jvnCQ.html
- AtlasBarfed 8y agoAsteroid mining is just a space program away, and might be strategically valuable to the west if China does try to corner the supply market as it historically does.