11 ms·
China is making electric buses cheap, just like it did for solar panels
- melling 8y agoChina is adding a lot of electric buses. I remember seeing this story a few months ago that gives it perspective: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/04/china-is-adding-a-london-sized-electric-bus-fleet-every-five-weeks/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/04/china-is-adding-a-lon...
- adrianN 8y agoMeanwhile in Europe we're still in the prototyping phase. I feel like the electric car market will belong to China and established European car companies will become irrelevant over the coming decade. Right now they seemingly spend more effort lobbying against change than keeping up with innovation.
- lnsru 8y agoDiesel cars are what German car makers want to sell. I doubt they can go all electric. It would make 2/3 current staff obsolete since electric car does not need complex internal combustion engine. What to do with these people? Basic income isn’t there yet. Edit: I wanted to buy BMW i3, because it has about right range I need for my travels. Guess what: there is no way to charge it! No single charger closer than half mile. Electric cars are useless without infrastructure.
- blacksmith_tb 8y agoIf emissions weren't gamed, diesel-electric hybrids would have some potential (most trains and many ships use this combination).
- KozmoNau7 8y agoPrototyping? Companies such as Linkker in Finland have been producing BEV buses for years: http://www.linkkerbus.com/ http://www.linkkerbus.com/ We've had a couple of them running normal bus lines in Copenhagen for some years, to assess the feasibility and TCO compared to diesel, CNG and hybrid buses. So far they seem to be doing rather well. They're quiet and comfortable (no vibration) -- as a passenger, I really like them.
- Symbiote 8y agoVolvo make electric buses, they're in use in Sweden and other places have ordered them. https://www.volvobuses.com/en-en/our-offering/electromobility.html https://www.volvobuses.com/en-en/our-offering/electromobilit...
- PuffinBlue 8y agoVolvo is Chinese though, so not sure if you're supporting the OP point or just weren't aware they'd been bought out by the Chinese.
- Symbiote 8y agoThere are two Volvos, the one that makes trucks, buses and construction equipment is still Swedish.
- kaybe 8y agoThe Deutsche Post (German Post) was so frustrated with the market offers they started to develop their own electric vans.. (you can buy them now!) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deutsche_Post#Electric_van_manufacturing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deutsche_Post#Electric_van_man...
- netsharc 8y agoAnd Mercedes took a peek at their van by pretending to be a different company and taking 1 for a test drive, but got caught because since it's German Post, when the worker entered the address of this fake company, the system warned them that it's an unknown company, could it be a shell corporation?
- nimos 8y agoI wish they would make self attaching electric/battery trolley busses. The main lines on the streets in Vancouver aren't bad but the intersections are such a mess with the trolley lines. You could min-max a system that combined trolley lines with batteries and use much less of both. Put the starts above bus stops so they don't have to attach at speed and you get to cover the initial expensive acceleration too. Back of the envelop guess from supercharger times is you would only need 10-20% of the routes actually covered in lines to maintain battery charge. It'd also be nice if more of the self driving companies would go after busses first. Fixed routes seems like a significantly easier problem and you can amortise all your sensor/electronic cost over a more expensive vehicle. Both combined would pretty radically alter the environmental and economic cost of public transportation.
- Tyrek 8y agoAre trolleys more efficient than buses, pound for pound? Especially after you factor in the capital expenditure needed to build out the trolley lines? I find it hard to believe that a niche technology (trolleys) would be more efficient overall (impact * quantity) than buses, which are everywhere. Buses are probably an 'easier' problem, but it's much easier to pitch selling self-driving cars to individual consumers rather than to government procurement budgets. Also, I suspect the bus problem space introduces additional issues such as <what to do when some asshole is parked in the bus bay>.
- TomMarius 8y agoBut the trolleys are already in place in many places around the world...?
- hencq 8y agoYou seem to be thinking of trams, while nimos is talking about trolleybuses, which are buses that draw their power from overhead wires [0]. Specifically they're suggesting that a hybrid option with batteries would reduce the need for wires everywhere (just run on battery power), but would still allow the buses to charge while connected to the overhead wire. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolleybus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolleybus
- maym86 8y agoThis is great. Countries and governments have the power to make the future they want happen. Often we see that power used to stifel innovation and subsidize failing incumbents to protect jobs. Investing in technology research that'll be better for the planet (and China's smog problem) in a way that actually brings prices down long term and not just subsidize purchasing the technology in the short term is a good thing. I hope this continues.
- avar 8y agoFrom the article: Economists are inclined to frown on the strategy of dumping giant piles of government money onto budding technologies that are in need of scaling up. They prefer market mechanisms, tech-neutral incentives, and nudges that maximize the free choices of market participants. In any economic model, such policies will perform better. And that’s well and good. But sometimes problems are big and urgent, you need scaled-up solutions quickly, and you just don’t have time to mess around. I think the author is fighting a strawman here and not giving those economists enough credit. What China's with solar panels and electric buses has been narrow and centrally planned, they wanted to solve those problems in particular. Whereas the argument on the other side is that you should be equally aggressive with something like a carbon or pollution tax, because then you start solving the same problem in parallel across the entire economy instead of just in some specific sectors. What China's been doing right is having the political will do actually spend money on the problem, as opposed to most of the west. But that doesn't mean their method of doing so is optimal, if we were similarly willing to turn the screws on via carbon or pollution tax I think we could make more gains than they're making.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoWhatever method brings about action is optimal, as the largest developed countries don’t have the will to enact carbon or pollution taxes.
- jadedhacker 8y agoCarbon taxes have to be astronomical to actually affect market behavior. Better to take direct control and titrate down carbon fuels while ramping other methods. The market can't do it except by perhaps a happy accident, an accident that would be resisted by the established players. Look for the big oil companies to buy up green startups and kneecap them to keep the oil money flowing. Consumables are much more profitable than capital purchases like solar panels, ask the printer makers about their ink.
- avar 8y ago
- zeristor 8y agoHow long before the Tesla bus?
- ForHackernews 8y agoElon Musk hates public transit, so Tesla will probably never make a bus. https://www.wired.com/story/elon-musk-awkward-dislike-mass-transit/ https://www.wired.com/story/elon-musk-awkward-dislike-mass-t...
- vinceguidry 8y agoThe article doesn't make it seem like his distaste was irrational, so I doubt he'd leave easy money on the table if an opportunity is spotted.
- maym86 8y ago> “It’s a pain in the ass,” he continued. “That’s why everyone doesn’t like it. And there’s like a bunch of random strangers, one of who might be a serial killer, OK, great. This just sounds incredibly entitled and out of touch. People are grateful for public transportation despite it's inperfections because it's much better than not having it at all.
- TomMarius 8y agoI don't think he ever said that it's worse than nothing.
- maym86 8y agoIf the alternative is the solution that he has, than yes he is saying it worse than nothing. Right now he has nothing implemented. He is comparing it to an imaginary system that doesn't exist (nothing) and saying it's worse. A billionaire saying systems that many people use and are happy with are bad while not actually using them himself and not actually having a viable afordable alternative is completly obnoxious. Come back and compain about buses Elon when you have actually built a reliable alternative people can use.
- maym86 8y agoMeanwhile in the USA we subsidize big oil and gas and bail out failing car manufacturers all while claiming market mechanisms and capitalism is the only way to go.
- paidleaf 8y agoDon't forget too-big-to-fail banks. They got bailed out and now they are even bigger than they were after gobbling up a bunch of mid-level banks the past few years.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoWe also have a lot more electric buses on the road in the USA than before, at least here in the Seattle area (well, we’ve always had them due to hills and cheap hydro, but now they have batteries).
- maym86 8y agoThe article isn't just about having some elecric busses in some cities. We also had some solar panels in USA but we weren't investing in them in the same way to increase their usage and ramp up their production. It's about the Chinese government investing in electric vehicles to make them cheaper long term and increase their viability and usage.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoYes, I know. But it isn’t like electric buses aren’t getting traction here in the states at all. Where public transportation is really a thing, this is happening. China has public transportation everywhere of course, though you’ll see these buses in shanghai and Beijing but not yet in tier 3’s (at least last time I checked a couple of years ago, it will change eventually).
- mtgx 8y ago> We also have a lot more electric buses on the road in the USA Is there a source for that?
- nopinsight 8y agoChina's goals for pushing electric vehicles very hard are multi-faceted and strongly aligned with their long-term national strategies: * Reducing their dependence on oil, one of few strategic resources which they do not possess in sufficient quantity and is subject, in large part, to the inclinations of foreign entities. Advanced electronics is another such resource on which they are also investing heavily to address the dependence. * Building up technical expertise by accumulating experience in designing and scaling up production of affordable electric vehicles for the masses. (Unlike ICE vehicles, this is an area where no one has a huge lead.) It is clear that EVs are the future. The size of global automative industry is in the trillions and can provide jobs for a huge number of people. * Improving urban air quality especially in tier 1 cities like Beijing and Shanghai to address the concern of talent who they try to attract (and attract back) from abroad as well as to address people’s demand and to reduce long-term public healthcare expenses. * Helping with global warming which may affect cities like Shanghai in the future. But this is possibly not a primary goal. As another commenter mentions, other approaches like carbon tax could be more effective. Governments in several developed nations should at least be concerned that, if they invest insufficiently in EVs, the issue of unemployment and underemployment in traditional manufacturing hubs could become more severe than it is now.
- dv_dt 8y agoYup, it's too bad that politicians in the US open purse strings when you say "national security depends on producing a leading fighter plane", vs "national security depends on an infrastructure for energy independence and ecological stability". China is basically investing in the second which yields nice secondary and tertiary economic benefits while the US builds a next-gen fighter with much weaker secondary economic benefits.
- eddieplan9 8y agoRight. How come we don't learn anything from the same policy that resulted in failures such as ARPANET and GPS.
- 8y ago
- nine_k 8y ago> So it decided to make electric buses a thing. How? By dumping a giant pile of money on the problem, subsidizing the purchase of more than 350,000 BEBs in the following four years. So, it's a typical state-financed infrastructure project. Good thing if it pans out. If not — :shrug.jpg: The problem with big governmental actions (especially of an authoritarian government) is that when they are good, they are mighty good; when they are bad, they are mighty bad. The same government that mass-buys electric buses also continues to build the Great Firewall and total surveillance. To my mind, they do both things for the same reason: for the good of the country, as they perceive it, and because they can.
- r00fus 8y agoIt has been working out. Please continue to ignore success until it's too late.
- amelius 8y agoAre (Chinese) solar panels environmentally neutral yet?
- Shivetya 8y agoIt isn't all roses however, Los Angeles has had serious issues with their BYD fleet [1]. I have posted many times the best place to put EVs is in the nations school bus fleet. they have fixed routes, obvious and accessible places to charge at, would introduce new generations to EV travel, and insulate school systems from fuel prices. The negatives are higher cost of entry, poor cold weather performance, and sheer number of buses to replace. http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-electric-buses-20180520-story.html http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-electric-buses-2018...
- gamblor956 8y agoMaybe in addition to making cheap electric buses, they could make EBs that don't break down every 20 miles? Several transit agencies in SoCal purchased Chinese-made EBs on a trial basis. None of them plans to continue to the trials due to the abysmal downtime record and maintenance costs. Instead, they're looking at the more expensive, but far more reliable American and Japanese EBs coming to market in the next year or two.
- jseliger 8y agoThis is a very interesting comment, but have you links to any articles or papers discussing the issue(s)?
- gamblor956 8y agoThere's the LA Times article about BYD already linked. The other big agency that's pulling back on Chinese EBs is the Foothill Transit Agency, where I have friends who are part of the team evaluating the EB trial. There are a few smaller transit agencies that cancelled their plans to acquire BYDs after the LA Metro's failed experiment. If they're not mentioned in the article you'll have to deep dive into the Metro archives to find the reference.
- greglindahl 8y agoStanford seems to have done OK with their BYD buses. I wonder why Proterra hasn't had more success with their US-made buses?
- gamblor956 8y agoThey've only recently begun actual sales of production vehicles. Up until a few months ago, all vehicles sold were test vehicles sold to transit agencies as proof of concept and for benchmarking cost efficiencies. Anecdotally, many of their customers are requesting additional buses, but I've been asked by my source not to say how I know that.
- tuxidomasx 8y agoThe fact that China's government moves so decisively in areas of technological advancement may have to do with the fact that many of their government officials have degrees in engineering, science, math, etc. With so many of the Chinese officials having technical degrees, I can't help but wonder if the United States government could benefit from technocrats in Washington.
- AFNobody 8y agoTechnocrats lack the skill set to win elections where everyone lies outrageously. If they had such skills, they would be common American politicians. One if the few benefits of China's collectivism is all the politicians have to share the same reality, even adjusted by party propaganda. It allows technocrats to operate effectively since they do not need to compete with outrageous liars.
- WhompingWindows 8y agoIs it about lying outrageously? I grant that occurs in high-profile and memorable cases, but is the average race for the house or a local seat corrupted by outrageous lies? It just seems sensible and historically continuous that those who study the law (lawyers) end up being the ones who most frequently write the law. I am 100% for more STEM and humanities-oriented law-makers, however I'm arguing technocrats lack specific knowledge of laws, not of lying.
- cheeko1234 8y agoThe best politician is the one who makes the most promises and keeps the least. Lying/exaggerating is the name of the game.
- AFNobody 8y agoDo you genuinely believe that when many laws are written by interest groups and past with little modification? And yes, the average race us corrupted by outrageous lies. I have literally never seen an election at any level that lacked outrageous lies by at least one of the candidates.
- grecy 8y agoCan anyone find details on the buses themselves? Battery size, range, time to charge, etc. ?
- nonamechicken 8y agoIn my state (Kerala, India), the government run bus company is trialling Chinese electric buses. These links have some info about the bus https://www.rushlane.com/kerala-state-transport-electric-bus-12271797.html https://www.rushlane.com/kerala-state-transport-electric-bus... http://www.newindianexpress.com/videos/videos-nation/2018/jun/28/kerala-launches-electric-bus-service-104600.html http://www.newindianexpress.com/videos/videos-nation/2018/ju... https://indianexpress.com/article/india/kerala-rolls-out-electric-a-c-buses-on-trial-basis-in-three-cities-5222436/ https://indianexpress.com/article/india/kerala-rolls-out-ele...
- nonamechicken 8y agoIn my state (Kerala, India), the government run bus company is currently trialing Chinese electric buses. I think some of the metro trains are also Chinese made. https://www.rushlane.com/kerala-state-transport-electric-bus-12271797.html https://www.rushlane.com/kerala-state-transport-electric-bus...
- AYBABTME 8y agoThis article has a graph showing ~200$/kWh on Li-ion. Is this anywhere close to reachable for hobbyist?
- mtw 8y agoCheap buses from China ? Wait until Trump puts tariffs into those!
- 8bitsrule 8y agoOnce again China is owning the future while the US twitters. Hopefully, in that future, we can talk them into selling us a few of those busses (with a BIG tariff piled on, of course). Which we -might- be able to use, if we can afford to -charge- them.