9 ms·
A Major Industry-Funded Alcohol Study Was Compromised
- Trump2020MAGA 8y agoAm I the only one who thinks it's strange that the NIH can receive money directly from a company? I have trouble believing that will ever go well.
- maccard 8y agoI can't speak directly for the NIH being funded by the companies, but in the UK and Ireland, there are Drinkaware foundations which are almost entirely funded by alcohol companies. It works quite well here
- metafunctor 8y agoWorking well for whom? I was under the impression that alcohol consumption in the UK hasn’t really taken a turn for the better in the past 20 years.
- maccard 8y agoI don't have a huge amount of time to dig into this right now but the impression I get from the ONS is that the numbers are trending in the right direction - sort of. Will explore more later https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthandsocialcare/drugusealcoholandsmoking/bulletins/opinionsandlifestylesurveyadultdrinkinghabitsingreatbritain/2017 https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthan...
- orf 8y agoDrink driving offenses have gone down hugely, as have drink related crime.
- Trump2020MAGA 8y agoInteresting, thanks for sharing. Why was my comment downvoted to hell and flagged?
- Dylan16807 8y agoProbably having a brand new account with that username, honestly.
- Trump2020MAGA 8y agoWhat's wrong with my username?
- maccard 8y agoI don't know - I didn't down-vote you though! (I reserve that for off-topic discussions).
- fnord123 8y agoOoh, an exception to Betteridge's Law of Headlines!
- btilly 8y agoThe original headline was "How many others are out there?" Which makes it not a yes/no question, and therefore Betteridge's Law of Headlines does not apply.
- Swenrekcah 8y agoBetteridges ‘law’ is a rule of thumb. A rule of thumb needs to give you approximately the right answer more than 50% of the time without spending any effort to examine the particular problem in order to be useful. So it really does not need to be pointed out every time this ‘law’ is broken.
- vfc1 8y agoOf course there are, this is pervasive. This has been done for decades by the tobacco industry, by the meat, dairy and eggs industry and others that try to buy scientific studies that favor their product.
- raverbashing 8y agoAnd also by the sugar (possibly the HFCS) industry to shift blame to fats
- bad_user 8y agoThe whole nutrition field is an absolute disgrace, giving a bad name to the medicine and science. We basically resort to having beliefs instead of depending on science, with the parent confirming husband own biases in only a couple of words. When something like 80% of studies on nutrition are either compromised or never confirmed by independent sources, it’s no wonder that people turn to the alternative medicine promoted by Fake News media outlets, no wonder that anti-vaxers are a thing in the 21st century.
- cageface 8y agoNot really. Most studies support the consensus findings of nutrition studies for the last several decades. Unfortunately the meat and dairy industries have managed to muddy the waters enough to get most people to just throw up their hands and eat what they want. Processed foods are bad for you. Refined carbs and sugars are bad for you. Saturated fat and cholesterol are bad for you. A diet centered around whole fruits, vegetables, legumes and grains will do more to extend your healthy lifespan than any other.
- megaman22 8y agoThis is no less ideological than what you purport to oppose, which is the problem in a nutshell. In the absence of religion, most of us have become religious about little, largely inconsequential lifestyle choices, with food being the most common hill to die upon, and producing some of the most strident adherents. Beware anyone telling you what you should or should not eat, because they're invariably a charlatan pushing some agenda. Ideally, you'd make some experiments and see what your body tolerated the best, but it's far easier to just cargo cult onto the trendy or virtue-signalling diet trend. As long as you're not trying to live on pixie sticks and cheetos, you're going to be okay.
- exhilaration 8y agoThis article from 2017 appears to be the New York Times reporting (mentioned in the article but not linked directly) that brought down this trial: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/03/well/eat/alcohol-national-institutes-of-health-clinical-trial.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/03/well/eat/alcohol-national...
- oldgradstudent 8y agoStudy 329 anyone? https://study329.org https://study329.org
- sorokod 8y agoHow about a requirement that all participating researchers provide the relevant financial disclosures as part of the published research?
- godelmachine 8y agoWe are all told that red wine if consumed in limited amounts every day is very beneficial for health in the long term. Of late, I heard that this scientific marketing was also sponsored by the alcohol industry and high chances that this notion is fake and preposterous.
- DanBC 8y agoA very small amount of red wine is beneficial to women over 60. No-one else gets the benefits. We've known this for a few years now.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- therealjumbo 8y agoNah, I feel great after two bottles of wine and I'm not 60 or a woman.
- godelmachine 8y agoDon’t wanna pun but maybe you feeling great must be inebriation. We are talking about long term health benefits here :)
- nasredin 8y agoWrong. The woman's husband always benefits.
- cncrnd 8y agoI always assumed that this had to do with antioxidants in grapes and nothing to do with alcohol itself. That's not so far fetched to me, but why not just drink grape juice?
- hrnnnnnn 8y agoOr go one better and eat the whole grapes.
- internetman55 8y agoMy grandpa is into his 80s without many health issues while drinking occasionally but not everyday or anything. His brothers all loved drinking more and died earlier in much worse condition. Hence I will just drink smaller amounts of alcohol and not obsess over such issues
- KozmoNau7 8y agoDon't drink every day/regularly, and only drink 2-3 units when you do drink, seems to be reasonable advice.
- vfc1 8y agoThere doesn't seem to be a safe lower limit for alcohol, its a well-known very potent carcinogen. Its not obsessive at all to completely avoid such a cancer inducing substance, especially if there is a family history of problems linked to it.
- KozmoNau7 8y ago"Very potent carcinogen" is scaremongering and alarmist. Don't drink if you don't want to, but tone down the retoric a bit. Generations upon generations of Germans have enjoyed beer in moderation, and they don't seem to have higher cancer rates than other western countries.
- vfc1 8y agoIts not a retoric, its according to the latest science. There is this social perception that drinking in moderation is ok for human health and even beneficial, when in reality alchool is a toxic substance with no known safe usage limit. Cancer in western countries are in general the highest compared to other cultures, so having an average rate among the highest in the world is not saying much.
- KozmoNau7 8y ago
- cbr 8y ago>patients are known to be highly inconsistent when reporting their own alcohol consumption. Answers patients provide depend on many factors, including the doctor-patient relationship. And patients’ spouses often disagree with their partners’ assessment of their drinking. The MACH15 trial had some sophistication built in to it, including the use of random smartphone-based check-ins for patients. But while some evidence suggests that smartphone-based self-reporting on alcohol consumption often contradicts patients hindsight reports, MACH15 had no ability to tease out which patients would adhere to the smartphone check-ins, and which were providing accurate accounts of their consumption. In essence, the NIH was making a $100 million gamble that volunteers would portray their alcohol consumption accurately. This doesn't seem like a problem with the study design to me. You're effectively assessing the effect of telling people to drink "zero" vs "moderate" alcohol as opposed to the the effect of actually drinking those quantities, but since one major use for a study like this is to figure out what doctors should be telling people this still seems valuable.
- Spooky23 8y agoThere’s too much judgement in the standards. If you admit to very moderate social alcohol consumption, you’ll get tagged as an abuser. Risky move these days.
- RandomInteger4 8y agoWhile I disagree and think your assessment is a bit hyperbolic, I do see that there may be some stigma in whether patients admit to their doctor that they drink. My dad apparently lied to his doctor quite a bit about his junk food consumption prior to his double bypass. Patients feel guilty about things they know or think to be unhealthy and for some reason think that lying will help them in any way. It's weird. Like, why are people more afraid of what some random person thinks than they are of seriously fucking up their doctor's ability to treat them?
- fisherjeff 8y agoI picked up the book Food Politics by Marion Nestle, mentioned in the article, on a whim several years ago and could not recommend it more highly for anyone interested in... well, the politics of food.
- mnm1 8y agoAn "industry-funded study" is an oxymoron. That's about as compelling as sports players also being the referee. All the studies that have shown that alcohol is not negative to health have been funded by the industry. To continue my analogy, the player/referee signaled for a touchdown when he wasn't even on the field. This is all propaganda bullshit pushed by alcohol companies to sell more shit. And really, anyone who stops to think about such ideas that a glass of wine a day--in other words a small addiction to alcohol, the most devastating commonly used drug in the world--could be beneficial, and doesn't question the validity by using his common sense is a fool who believes what he wants to believe. To sell addiction to the masses through manipulated studies is both genius on the part of alcohol companies and something that should be punished severely, as in disbanding the company. Except that nih and other federal departments are too dumb/corrupt themselves to not take the money. In the meantime, millions of people are and have died, gotten cancer, cirrhosis, and other problems because of their incompetence and willingness to sell the alcohol companies' take that a little alcohol addiction is not bad. Of course, for people that trust such government institutions, there is no hope and their trust, as we can see, has been the downfall of millions. But that's another issue altogether.
- AtlasBarfed 8y agoCould blockchains help detailed tracking in studies somehow? Maybe tie RFID in the products into a blockchain tracker. The blockchain could anonymize the data, but provide quantitative tracking. I'd also wish for some way to provide funding to studies but obscure the direct pay. So they pay into a funding that gets anonymously distributed to coinholders. Eh, these are all pretty far fetched.