30 ms·
The Case Against Patents (2013)
- andrewla 8y agoThe authors summarize as: > ... there is no empirical evidence that [patents] serve to increase innovation and productivity ... This seems to be a fundamental misunderstanding as to what purpose patents serve. The public benefit of a patent is that the information is public -- inventions which might previously have been kept secret are instead put into the light where others may use them. The cost to the public of patents are that such use must be deferred out of respect for the temporary monopoly granted to the patent holder. That is, patents don't increase innovation or productivity -- that is by design. They are just a means of harnessing the innovation and productivity of individuals and encouraging them to make their work public instead of keeping it a secret. So it seems to me that the paper is arguing a strawman rather than making a useful point.
- beefield 8y ago> The public benefit of a patent is that the information is public -- inventions which might previously have been kept secret are instead put into the light where others may use them Can you come up with siginificant patented innovations that are not easy to reverse-engineer? I have thought that the raison d'etre of patents is to foster innovation.
- jordigh 8y agoI always mention the Michael Jackson smooth criminal patent. Is it easy to reverse-engineer? I don't know, it seems obvious once you see what it is, but it seems awfully clever if you don't know about it. A lot of people seem to believe that it would involve electromagnets, but the actual invention is more low-tech.
- rbultje 8y ago> The public benefit of a patent is that the information is public [..] > The cost to the public of patents are that such use must be deferred But who does this benefit? The author points out that it benefits big/old ("stagnant") corporations rather than innovators. And that still holds, no? Here's a thought experiment: if you're a small innovator and you invent something new (let's be evil: a software algorithm), what benefit does disclosure bring you? It's better to keep it secret, because big/old ("stagnant") companies will find legal loopholes in your patent application to work around it. Or, they will run it in the cloud and not tell you at all that they're running your exact algorithm. The innovator would never know. Big/old ("stagnant") companies, on the other hand, have enough legal manpower to sue you out of existence regardless of whether their patent is valid or not. It's not the patent, it's the legal process that will bankrupt the small innovator. Can patents be molded to protect the small innovator? Because isn't that the intent? Regardless of whether that protection results in monopoly, disclosure or both.
- ChrisLomont 8y ago>Can patents be molded to protect the small innovator? There's plenty of cases of a small or lone inventor making big companies pay for infringing a patent. I think patents are about the only protection for a small innovator to get enough leverage to enter a market. As a small innovator myself, at probably every pitch I've ever made to investors, I've been asked immediately if I have patents. When I've looked at Chinese manufacturing for products, the first thing they ask is about patents (un-patented means they can copy and sell in a lot of markets, patented makes it harder for them to sell in markets where I have a patent). There's also plenty of people that are skilled at invention, that don't work for a big mega-corp, and they make their living by being able to stop big corporations from simply stealing their product ideas and crushing them via bigger and better distribution networks. Patenting a key aspect of a new item gets small players a seat at the negotiating table where a big player has to buy the product. Without patents this would rarely happen.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cwmma 8y ago> The public benefit of a patent is that the information is public They cover that in the paper. More generally 'productivity' is being used slightly more abstractly here more in terms of general welfare, e.g. do patents serve to increase the productivity of the economy overall.
- learc83 8y ago“To promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries.” >That is, patents don't increase innovation or productivity -- that is by design. Yes one part is to prevent trade secrets, but the idea is that by making trade secrets public, other people will have the ability to improve on the idea and make innovations that wouldn't have otherwise been possible had the knowledge been kept secret--not just that society gets to use that one invention. The other purpose has nothing to do with trade secrets. There are many inventions that wouldn't be possible to protect with trade secrets. Patents are designed to make this kind of invention profitable to create--encouraging people to invent them. Btw I'm not arguing that patents necessarily fulfill their purpose.
- enriquto 8y agolink to the abstract (not a pdf): https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/jep.27.1.3 https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/jep.27.1.3
- kwjenfo 8y agoAnyone who supports the opinion that they should own all the benefits of an idea just because they got it a minute before others is fucking demented
- drewlander 8y agowow at first I thought it said "Against Parents." I think I need glasses....
- _bxg1 8y agoI saw "Against Patients", for some reason
- _bxg1 8y agoNeeds a [PDF] tag
- kevin_b_er 8y agoMeanwhile the Intellectual "Property" wants patents treated as real estate and the party of corporate interests is in power.
- theltrj 8y agowants? this is the way it has been done for a long long time in the US (the first US patent grant was from George Washington in 1790), there is Property category where there is at least Real Property & Intellectual Property, patents which are in the Intellectual Property 'bucket' so to speak There are multiple of forms of intellectual property beyond patents: copyright, trademarks, etc This is the way the legal system has always worked, not an invention of a modern corporate interests, the ancient Greeks recognizes some forms of patent, the modern version is based around the implementations of Italy's patent system in the 1400s: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_patent_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_patent_law no conspiracy here....but yes corporations do like to see a return on their significant research and development investments
- kevin_b_er 8y agoThere is no intellectual "property", merely a temporary exclusive grant made by the public to encourage the arts and sciences. To call it "property" is, as I warned, the goal of the "IP" industry in equating a patent as no different from a house and land. Then it magically becomes some sort of right, but one is fundamental a restriction of your own fundamental human rights because a patent can be accidentally infringed. A patent can be accidentally issued, but it can be hell to accidentally UN-issue it. Meanwhile the patent constraints your actions and speech through its power. And we want to treat it like a house? The house limits what you may do upon that land, a patent limits what you may do anywhere any everywhere. And you don't even need to know the patent "property" upon your actions even exists.
- pnw_hazor 8y agoIntellectual property is real. Try stealing some IP from Apple and see what happens -- something real will happen. IP is as real as any other legal construct, such as, contract rights. The term intellectual property is a term of art that just happens to model some of the analogues that exist between intellectual property, real property, and personal property.
- monochromatic 8y ago[2013]
- jordigh 8y agoI never thought that the case for patents was to increase productivity. I always thought that their purpose was to eliminate trade secrets: people are going to invent stuff whether you want to or not, but without patents, they'll take the secrets to the grave. My favourite patent of all time is Michael Jackson's smooth criminal patent: https://mashable.com/2015/03/28/michael-jackson-shoe-patent/#AdzmmRRZPmqY https://mashable.com/2015/03/28/michael-jackson-shoe-patent/... This is the patent system working as intended. A magician revealing his tricks. Tell us how you did it, and in exchange we promise to not compete with you for a while. The patent system could work if patent clerks had the time to be a lot more discerning and reject any patent that is obvious or already known. But it takes a lot of work to do that and the deluge of patents makes it impossible to give each application sufficient consideration. I think the general idea of patents is good, but perhaps it's impossible to execute it correctly. Edit: Should have read the damn article. They address concern further below and also argue that patents are not revealing any secrets because pattent attorneys are not qualified to judge the merit of patents and because the way patents are written makes it almost impossible to reproduce their results, and sometimes patents are granted for utter nonsense, such as moving "through the fifth dimension".
- enriquto 8y ago> I think the general idea of patents is good Also, there may be a fundamental difference between physical inventions, where patents seem to make sense, and mathematical theorems (and computer algorithms), where patents do not make sense at all.
- api 8y agoThe difference is between a specific invention vs. a law of mathematics or nature. The latter absolutely should not be patentable. The negative opinion of patents around here comes from the fact that most people here are programmers and the vast majority of software patents are trash. I've seen very few patents on software that are not "obvious to anyone skilled in the art," patents on abstract mathematical concepts, or patents for which there is ample prior art in the literature or open source code repositories. Telling the difference requires a great deal of conceptual thinking. Patent examining is "strong AI hard." I think it is possible to expand on these ideas to some useful extent. Obviousness for example could be explained as first-order connectedness is the evolutionary/learning state-space graph. Something is obvious if getting from current art to the new idea requires only one "hop" through state space or traversal of a densely connected region of state space. Non-obvious means some kind of great leap across state space or long journey through many indirections was required. It's basically a measure of creative labor. The RSA patent is often cited as an example of a decent software patent: original, a specific well-bounded invention for a specific purpose, and non-obvious in the extreme. Another example would be if whomever Satoshi is had patented proof of work block chains since that would also meet those criteria. Of course patents on cryptographic systems tend to result in them not being used, but that's a separate issue.
- js8 8y agoI am against (all) patents on the following grounds: The article talks about first-mover advantage.. it seems to me that the case for or against patents depends on how you model it. If you model it as a single-shot prisoner's dilemma, then without patents, there is no incentive to make result of research public. This is a classical argument in favor of patents. On the other hand, if you model it as a many-rounds prisoner's dilemma, then even without patents, it makes sense for companies to have a strategy which makes some results of research public, then hopefully piggyback on the research that was done by others and also published (that is, mutually cooperate). It seems to me that the second strategy can only be viable if the results of the research are "infinitely divisible", that is, companies can make arbitrarily small steps in opening up their research. However, I don't see any evidence that the research is NOT infinitely divisible, thus it seems to me that patents are not really needed for the latter to happen. In addition, interestingly, economists generally approve patents as needed for someone to make the first move, but they don't feel the same about similar issues that happen in the market. For example, somebody needs to explore new market first or make a capital investment in a new field - economists do not call for government support in that. This convinces me that the rationale for patents is somewhat hypocritical defense of status quo (caused by rather arbitrary choice in the game theoretical model).
- epicide 8y agoThis dovetails with the case for enterprise open source quite nicely. We continually make more and more complicated things. The time in which we iterate also decreases. I can see the argument that patents were useful at a time where an iteration could take decades or more. However, I'm sure we're well past the point of usefulness for any patent system. A lot of decision makers in companies are stuck in the mindset of trade secrets because that made sense at one point. Your company made a widget. Your goal was to make that widget better than the other widget makers. You (at least believed that you) had some breakthrough that made your widgets better and continued to make widgets in that style for years without much change. In that time, you protected how you achieved the breakthrough. Patents helped with this. Today, a lot of the money is not really in creating widgets. It's in creating digital recreations of widgets (e-widget) that accomplish the same task [0]. You don't pay much overhead per copy of e-widgets, so prototyping and "mass production" is fast and cheap. You can iterate at increasingly faster paces. It is not worth it to you to protect how you differentiate your e-widgets once it comes out [1]. You're already working on the next version. If you spend a lot of resources on protecting how you achieved your previous iteration(s), you are doomed to fall behind [1]. Once a company falls so far behind, it makes more sense (but only in the short term) to double down on your protection efforts. This is how we end up with the cable company ISP situation in the US. It is easier [2] to fight in the legal system than it is to a) spend on the R&D to improve your networks and b) actually roll out those changes. These are just my observations. I have some ideas on solutions but obviously don't really know what would work. I doubt any one thing would work for every company, but I know (long term) a lot more are either going to need to adapt to a more open mindset or continue to spend more and more to protect their closed mindset. The latter is probably more likely for the foreseeable future. [0]: Realistically, the real money is in trading investments in potential value of creating digital recreations of widgets, but that's a different conversation. At some point, you usually have to create the widget / digital recreation, so we'll continue to talk about that. [1]: Unless you're a patent troll. [2]: Cheaper.
- hammock 8y agoDrug patents are ten years. It's common to say without patents no drug company would spend the billions it takes to bring one drug to market. But I remember doing the back of the envelope math in college on the socially optimal length of a drug patent based on the cost, profit motive and public benefit, and it worked out to only about three years.
- _Wintermute 8y agoIs that assuming the patent only comes into effect when the drug reaches market?
- hammock 8y agoYes
- notlob 8y agoPost-AIA, US utility patents (including APIs, biologics, methods of manufacture/use, etc.) are 20 years with possible adjustments to term length.
- hammock 8y agoI was in college a while ago :) Appreciate the correction
- SiliconAlley 8y agoI think it could be argued that the entire mechanics of drug development (and costs) would be fundamentally different in an environment without patents. Without the incentive of monopoly, there might be a lot more evolution (think of forking/branching of open source software projects) of meds, which I imagine would significantly alter the costs/incentives in drug development. These are kind of just my thoughts as a layman, though.
- twoheadedboy 8y ago> doing the back of the envelope math in college Sounds rigorous
- kajumix 8y agoThe case against patents has a moral dimension as well as a utilitarian one. This article is about the latter. Stephan Kinsella makes a good argument for both [1]. Ideas are free and can't owned. In a way, enforcement of intellectual property rights infringes on physical property rights. If you come up with a process P to assemble certain kinds of physical widgets together, your claim on the patent for P prevents others to use those kinds of widgets in a certain way, even when they own those widgets fully. [1]: https://mises.org/library/against-intellectual-property-0 https://mises.org/library/against-intellectual-property-0
- kauffj 8y agoThis seems like as good a thread as any to mention one of my favorite unrealized enterprises: Patent Trolling for Good (PTG) The idea is simple: take the traditional model of a patent troll, but alter the settlement terms to create a cascade that ultimately ends or significantly reduces the exclusive ownership of facts (aka IP). Patent Trolling for Good acts like a traditional Patent Troll in that it takes any IP it has and aggressively uses it to make claims against other firms/entities. However, instead of just seeking cash, PTG offers two options: - Pay us a lot of cash - Join PTG. By joining: 1) all of your IP can be used by PTG to sue others and 2) everyone in PTG has automatic rights to any IP held by others in PTG And of course, anyone is welcome to join PTG at any time. You don't have to wait to be sued to join :) I've brought this idea up with VCs and lawyers a few times across the years but I've never gotten any bites. If anyone was ever seriously and credibly interested in pursuing it, I would give such an entity any and all IP owned/claimable by LBRY (https://lbry.io https://lbry.io) and potentially a small amount of initial funding as well.
- wolfgke 8y agoOr perhaps: let the PTG sue any company that sued any other company/indifidual for patent violations (rightfully or not; enforcing patents is always evil).
- dnautics 8y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/RPX_Corporation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/RPX_Corporation
- kauffj 8y agoThere are several (lots?) of defense patent networks. This is an offensive patent network with the intent of proactively obviating or severely reducing patent enforcement.
- tcoff91 8y agoIt seems to me that a potential flaw with this plan is that mounting patent litigation costs money, so if everyone just joins the PTG to avoid expensive patent litigation defense, then the PTG would not have any income to sustain itself. Its continued survival would require that a significant percentage of cases end up with cash winnings instead of the target joining the PTG. To be sustainable it can't be TOO effective.
- ajb 8y agoFYI, there was an article about a new patent bill on the front page yesterday, but it dropped off rather fast: "US Software Patents are back with HR 6264 section 7" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17492196 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17492196
- ibeckermayer 8y agohttps://reasonandliberty.com/articles/patents https://reasonandliberty.com/articles/patents
- ninjakeyboard 8y agoSleep deprived from go live, I misread this as "The Case Against Patents."
- choward 8y agoWhat?
- ninjakeyboard 8y agoPARENTS I mean parents. Ugh
- djhaskin987 8y agoNice name drop > We are grateful to the editors, the referees, and to Richard Stallman for a careful reading and comments.
- jimmydddd 8y agoQuestion for anti-patent folks. Do you like a system where Chinese companies just copy products listed on Amazon and sell them for less?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- throwaway37585 8y agoYes?
- jimmydddd 8y agoFair enough. I think it would promote copying instead of inventing. Not sure how that ends.
- anticensor 8y agoThat would prevent unnecessary "innovations" to refresh IP. You cannot keep everything secret.
- pnw_hazor 8y agoDragging out the old one-click patent I see. I guess I missed where the development of ecommerce was stymied by this patent. A patent can promote innovation in at least two ways: (1) rewarding the inventors for their toil and risk taking; and (2) by forcing competitors to try to solve the same problem with a different solution. People seem to forget about the second one.
- throwaway37585 8y ago(1) is addressed by the article. As for (2), well... do you have any evidence this outweighs all the downsides of the patent system?
- pnw_hazor 8y agoMost of the so-called downsides of IP are subjective or viewpoint based. Or, they are imaginary/hypothetical. But there is this, countries with the strongest IP protection are the most innovative and successful. So there must be something beneficial going on.
- zyxzevn 8y agoRestrictions hinder innovation, development and technology. And patents are such restrictions. The worst cases are the ones that grant monopolies on common or important technologies. They can completely block the progress in certain areas. Even companies with patents stop with innovation until the patent has run dry, if they do any innovation at all.
- kotharia 8y agoThe pharmaceutical industry is usually given as the prime example of an industry where patent protection is necessary; however, this is far from obvious. See Robin Feldman's book Drug Wars (there is an interview with her about it here: http//www.econtalk.org/robin-feldman-on-drug-patents-generics-and-drug-wars/)
- jernfrost 8y agoI would solve it with a combination of public funded research and prizes awarded to those solving important medical needs.
- aj7 8y agoA patent is, first and foremost, a fence. It creates property rights. Do fences increase productivity? Should they? It probably is more productive if your neighbor's dog shits on your lawn, or your clever invention is taken apart and immediately copied by a larger competitor. But is it right?
- jernfrost 8y agoI think patents should be replaced with prizes. People can propose problems which needs solving and then private individuals and/or government can pledge money to donate to whoever finds a solution to the problem first. However the winner doesn't own the idea. It must be made public.
- anticensor 8y agoDoes the proposer also get compensation after a solution is found, or only the solver?
- neilwilson 8y agoInteresting that many commenters use the 'make an idea public' argument for patents. However if reinvention and rediscovery of an idea doesn't happen that often then you why would you need patents anyway? Penn and Teller's Fool Us shows demonstrate that very few magic tricks are undiscoverable to other magicians. So just hire one to work it out. That increases the value of magicians and decreases the value of patent lawyers, patent reviewers, patent writers and the patent trade. Surely that is a good thing?