28 ms·
Nancy Pearl’s Rule of 50 for dropping a bad book
- Munksgaard 8y agoI suffer under the same affliction Nancy is describing: I cannot bear the idea of putting down a book that I've started. Currently I'm struggling to get through Gödel, Escher, Bach. I like the ideas presented, especially the parallels between music and art (which I know little about) on one hand, and mathematics and computer science (which I know more about) on the other hand. But I think that it lacks focus and a clear thread. Additionally, I already know most of the mathematical concepts presented in the book, so I don't feel like I benefit much from the long chapters detailing various proofs and formal systems. To make matters worse, Hofstadter avoids using conventional notation and terminology, so I'll be reading through page upon page of detailed descriptions of his own little formal system only to finally realize "Oh, he's just describing propositional logic in a roundabout way". Meanwhile, I've got a bunch of other interesting books sitting on my shelf that I'd like to read. Alas, there are only about 300 pages left...
- mattmanser 8y agoI've never struggled stopping with non-fiction, I think because at Uni when studying philosophy they often recommended a lot of books with "read chapter 10 + 14" of a book. Often the rest of the book was a boring, pointless drudgery that rehashed arguments I'd already read and that really opened my eyes. I remember more than once deciding to read the whole book instead of the recommended chapters. Descarte's Meditations springs to mind, the first half of the book is great (think therefore I am), the 2nd half is bad (trying to prove the existence of god, having just disproved him). Also, I read Immanuel Kant and he is probably one of the worst famous writers in history. He was awful at expressing himself, and if you've had to endure that, you learn to skip chapters at a time looking for the crux of a book. Hegel was similarly bad I seem to remember.
- computator 8y agoOne great thing about Gödel, Escher, Bach is that you can enjoy it by flipping it open to a random place and reading a few pages, or if you don't like it or get it, flip to a different section. It's neither a novel nor a textbook. You don't have to understand A, B, C, & D, before you can understand (or at least appreciate) E. I treated like a coffee table book, reading 2/3 of it but randomly.
- n4r9 8y agoI was in almost exactly your position two or three years ago. I appreciated reading about Bach's self-referential patterns and had some fun playing with the toy formal systems, but as someone with a background in pure mathematics I found much of it long-winded and tedious. I carried on trying to slog through it because a friend (who's sister had bought it for him) shoved it into my hands on the proviso that I explain to him what it was all about. Eventually - about halfway through - I simply surrendered in the face of mounting gratuitous discourse. I just wanted it to cut to the chase.
- madhadron 8y agoI give you permission to put down GEB. If you already know some logic and music, there's no point in reading it.
- kthejoker2 8y agoI disgree, but only the stories of Tortoise and Achilles. They're the most original bits in the book and they make great repeat reading, reading aloud to others, etc.
- shadowsun7 8y agoWhat has worked really well for me has been to follow Peter Bregman's reading technique, which he got from history professor Michael Jimenez (story and full article here: https://hbr.org/2016/02/how-to-read-a-book-a-week https://hbr.org/2016/02/how-to-read-a-book-a-week): 1. Check out the author’s bio online to get a sense of the person’s bias and perspective. 2. Read the title, subtitle, front flap, table of contents. Figure out the big-picture argument of the book, and how that argument is laid out. 3. Read the introduction and conclusion word for word to figure out where the author starts from and where he eventually gets to. 4. Read/skim each chapter: Read the title, the first few paragraphs or the first few pages of the chapter to figure out how the author is using the chapter and where it fits into the argument of the whole book. Then skim through headings and subheadings to get an idea of the flow. Read the first sentence and last sentence of each paragraph. Once you get an argument, feel free to move on to the next argument, skipping over the many repeated case studies or examples. 5. End with the table of contents again, looking through, and summarising each. I've found that this has worked wonders for my reading. A year or so later, I refined this technique further, as I found that it didn't work for all books (it works for 'single-idea' books, which I call 'branch books'; it doesn't work as well for 'map of ideas' books, which I call 'tree books'.) For example, The Long Tail is the an example of a branch book, and Thinking: Fast and Slow is an example of a tree book. (I've written a longer post about the categories here: https://commoncog.com/blog/the-3-kinds-of-non-fiction-book/ https://commoncog.com/blog/the-3-kinds-of-non-fiction-book/) Edited for formatting
- computator 8y agoOpening a book at a random places and reading a couple paragraphs was easy in physical bookstores but now so difficult online. In particular, Amazon insists on showing only the very beginning of a book (preface, table of contents, intro) and the end of a book (the index). You can no longer browse random pages out of the middle of the book.
- spraak 8y agoAt the end do you still read the book straight through? Even so, it seems equal in effort to just read the book. Though to be fair I haven't tried your method, I just feel skeptical.
- toolslive 8y ago50 is a bit low. Personally, I use 20%.
- spraak 8y agoSounds like you often read books with 250+ pages :)
- peteretep 8y ago> And if, at the bottom of Page 50, all you're really interested in is who marries whom, or who the murderer is, then turn to the last page and find out. Thank God for Wikipedia's plot summaries of books and films. > there's no way that anyone there will be able to tell (even if they were interested) whether you've really read every page of the book you just returned. Unless it was a Kindle book, right? :-P
- DEADBEEFC0FFEE 8y agoI definitely used to be a hardcore finisher. It's a really difficult habit to break, as it feels like personal failure, and violation if principle. My wife was also, and independently a book finisher. I don't recall the realisation that life is short and there is so much to do. Neither of us are finishers now. But I do have a special shelf for unfinished books. They stare at me.
- shoo 8y agoone thing i started doing in recent years is just borrowing heaps of books from the library. trawl the catalogue, see what's ready for borrowing, borrow half a dozen ones that look interesting or are on the reading backlog. then start reading a few of them in parallel. if some of them don't hold your attention, stop reading and focus on the ones that are interesting. take them all back to the library when they're due, read or not. edit: okay, so now for the obvious question, what's the correct way of framing the which-books-should-be-finished problem, and what's the optimal strategy? is this a bandit algorithm thing? at each interval t, sample a page from a book according to gittins indices to minimise lifetime regret? does it need monte carlo tree search?
- rusk 8y agoMassively Parallel Speculative Evaluation. I like it!
- noelwelsh 8y agoNot a classical bandit because the arms have a finite lifetime (the arm is no longer active once you read the whole book) and you know this lifetime. Definitely can be viewed as some form of RL problem. For me the challenge is how you define rewards and hence what information reading part of a book gives you about the total reward for completing the book. Maybe assume some smoothness criteria, so that the reward for reading part n of a book is highly informative of reading part n+1, but less informative of part n+2, and so on. More formally, each book gives some total reward on completion and that reward is distributed according to some stochastic process. Greedy strategies probably work reasonably well.
- 8y ago
- barking 8y agoProbably a fair rule to go by overall But if I'd followed her rule I might not have read 'Fathers and Sons' through. The first fair chunk of the book I found extremely boring but at some point I became engrossed and to this day remember it as one of the books I've enjoyed the most.
- spraak 8y agoHm, maybe the algorithm could be refined to define a threshold of boredom; should this be met before 50 pages, use the remaining pages (50 minus pages so far) to randomly select pages to explore for more something exciting ahead.
- zaidf 8y agoAnd if, at the bottom of Page 50, all you're really interested in is who marries whom, or who the murderer is, then turn to the last page and find out. Ironically, I simply wanted to know what the actual rule was. It takes some effort to find it hidden in the middle of the article.
- shanghaiaway 8y agoYou don't need a rule to stop reading a book and there's no reason to feel bad about it
- ramblerman 8y agoThis is such a simple counterargument to OP, It's funny to see you down-voted. I guess we all need a system these days to validate our actions, even how we should spend our free time.
- wavefunction 8y agoI read quickly so 15 minutes is enough time to make this sort of call. The more you read the easier it is to determine if a book is good or not, as well.
- pjc50 8y agoDefinitely a "journey" vs "destination" thing going on here. If you're interested in finding how a novel ends, of course you can skip to the back; but hardly anyone does that, because it's the process of reaching there that's the important (and supposed to be enjoyable) part. So if it's not an enjoyable process, it's worth questioning what social ideas of "worthiness" are leading you to press on with it. Doubly so with "classic" books, where you might need to read a whole other chunk of canon to have the proper context for understanding why this book is supposed to be good in the first place. Or you need to skip some bits that have aged badly. For non-fiction, it's worth separating books which sincerely have a thesis and supporting arguments from books which are trying to sell you an idea, even (especially) if it's an idea you really want to hear. There is no longer a "canon" that you can expect everyone to have read; the world is far too big and contains too many people, books, cultures and ideas. (For youtube videos, when I'm trying to get information on something, I employ a "rule of third": just drop the slider a third of the way in and skip all the personal introduction and setup, to see if this video might actually get to the point.)
- glangdale 8y agoThe point is that if you're not enjoying the journey, you skip to the end and take out the "I need to get to the destination" motivation for finishing. I do this all the time: if the book is getting tedious, I prevent myself from compulsively finishing it by "giving away the end" to myself.
- pavel_lishin 8y agoI do the opposite. If I'm finding the novel a slog, I'll read the Wikipedia synopsis. If the payoff seems worth it, I'll keep going - I think that most novels where a "twist" isn't the only selling point are worth reading even if you know the plot. (And if the payoff doesn't, I drop the book. That's what I did with Mieville's Embassytown at the 50% mark.)
- kbutler 8y agoRather than skip to the end, googling plot summaries (for popular books) and or other summaries like Cliff's Notes (for classics) are also really useful. If you don't care about spoilers (and if you're considering just dropping the book, why would you care?), you can get a good idea of "what happens" and see if you are interested enough in the "journey" to bother with the "destination."
- rusk 8y agoI remember the first book I intentionally didn't finish. It was a fictional work that I'd gotten about 85% the way through and I felt the narrative start to deterioriate. It was one of those books that makes bold promises at the outset but then kind of just strung you along with increasingly vapid plot twists and I was at a point in my life where I was learning to be impatient and I just said fuckit. Never felt guilty about not finishing a book again. Life's too short to be giving due diligence to poor authors.
- paulpauper 8y agoI usually just read the beginnings of books and then selected chapters for non-fiction. That's often the best part.
- sjclemmy 8y agoI totally agree with the author. I’m a ‘finisher’ (so tend not to start things! ;)) Like the author it’s taken me a while to get to the point where I can ditch a book part way through. But when it comes to books, if you don’t want to read it, don’t. Forget 50 pages. If it’s boring or annoying simply stop reading and use your time more wisely.
- weavie 8y agoI have the opposite problem, there are so many good books out there that I will often be reading several at any one time. The ones that just don't grab me tend to fall to the bottom of the pile and stay there until I realise its just not going to happen. Then it goes back in the shelf.
- m0nty 8y agoI had the interesting experience of returning to two of Iain M Banks's novels, both of which I had read in my late 20s (20 years ago). Feersum Endjinn was fun but not at all profound: I had found it to be very thought-provoking the first time around. In fact, it was the first Banks book I read and it had me hooked. Consider Phlebas I had read and enjoyed, but it seemed flat, uninspired and uninteresting on second reading. I abandoned it after several chapters. I hardly ever abandon books but have done so more often recently - encroaching age does lead to impatience in some things. I'm not sure how I would feel returning to Use of Weapons and The Wasp Factory, both of which I found shocking and profound the first time around. So the point of this is, your opinion of something might change, or maybe it's just that storytelling is like a magic trick which requires the wholehearted participation of writer and reader to be successful. If you're not interested, you should quit and find something else to do. I'm the same with television - cannot watch The Wire too many times, cannot watch most other things even once.
- monochromatic 8y agoI actually gave up on Banks’s The Player of Games a couple of days ago. Maybe I didn’t give it enough of a chance, but I just couldn’t get interested.
- AndrewStephens 8y agoThe Player of Games is sort of Banks-lite. If you didn't like that then you are not going to get into his other stuff. Personally I like his novel but I can understand why others don't - he has a certain style and way of constructing plots that either grabs you of leaves you bored. There are certainly many books that I struggled through and wished I didn't, but there are others that I thought I was going to hate long past the 50 page mark that brought me around in the end. But 50 pages is enough to know that a book is _terrible_.
- sulam 8y agoPlayer of Games is the book I recommend to people to know if they'll like all of his books. It's kind of a set piece for all of them. So I can say with some confidence that you probably won't like many of his books.
- ilamont 8y agoGive a book 50 pages. When you get to the bottom of Page 50, ask yourself if you're really liking the book. I can usually tell within 10-20 pages. I also have the "five minute rule" with TV shows, movies (on streaming services), and other activities. Only so much time left on this planet.
- wonderbear 8y agoSimilar. If I'm not excited about a tv show by the time the first set of credits is shown, then I'll only watch the rest of the pilot if my friends have assured me it's really good. And even then I won't watch more than the pilot if it doesn't speak to me. Maybe it will get better in the second season or whatever, but life is short and a tv series is a lot of time. Books, I'm a bit more dogged about. It has to be pretty bad before I won't at least skim it before giving up. Partly this is because I'm a very fast reader and most books I can finish in a sitting or two.
- bluesroo 8y agoI completely agree. I've run into a lot of people who say something like the following: > But dude, you just have to get through the first 3 seasons and the show gets so good. No, I'm really fine not wasting 15-30 hours of my life when there's hundreds of other incredible shows, movies, books, and video games.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoRight! When somebody says "You should watch this great new series!" its like they're saying "You should knit this great afghan!" Man-weeks of work. No thanks.
- nothis 8y agoI would have dropped every Stephen King book by that measure. Actually, maybe I should have.
- logfromblammo 8y agoI was gifted two of them recently, and it seems like maybe he might have chosen to sacrifice quality for quantity two or three hundred books ago. I'm glad I decided to avoid him as an author when I was much younger. He'd have been better off just writing them as screenplays or teleplays to begin with. Someone recently compared my Twitter posts to Stephen King, and I winced physically. I'm almost certain they meant it as a compliment, though. And maybe that's good if I wanted to write for the mass market instead of the sci-fi/fantasy nerds?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cafard 8y agoI suspect that I would never have finished The Man Who Loved Children by Christina Stead if I had followed that rule. As a matter of fact, page 120 might not have sufficed. It stopped me once, in my 20s, but when I picked it up in my 50s and pushed on, I was very glad I did. I agree that life is too short to read crummy books through. I do now and then for a neighborhood book club, with gritted teeth.
- Amorymeltzer 8y agoWhile I think this is good, my impression is that it works better for fiction than non-fiction. Most of my reading the past few years has been non-fiction, and the hardest thing is finding a book on a good subject and with interesting information, but poorly written or just generally unenjoyable. I know that continuing will be painful, but I also know that continuing will allow me to learn about the subject. Not sure 50 pages (or some other metric) works in this scenario, only real option is to find a better book on the subject! As for fiction, what really did it for me was listening to the New York Times Book Review podcast[1], specifically the reviewers and Editor Pamela Paul. Many of them, especially PP, frequently mention not finishing a book, and hearing that from them felt liberating. It's still hard, but I figure if they can put a book down, so can I. 1: https://www.nytimes.com/column/book-review-podcast https://www.nytimes.com/column/book-review-podcast
- segmondy 8y agoI rarely read fiction these days so this is a non issue. If I pickup a fiction, if I'm not into it by the 2nd chapter. I'm tossing it. I don't care how great the world says it is. If non fiction, I can always jump around to relevant parts that I care about.
- chris_wot 8y agoI remember looking at the Wikipedia history of the Nancy Pearl history and discovered, to my amusement, that a librarian at the State Library of NSW had carefully started editing her page, and a bunch of other library related pages.
- menacingly 8y agoDoes anyone else find it unsatisfying that it's not computed from the outset but switches to it later after a trigger?
- pitt1980 8y agoMore generally than just books, when to quit, is a really hard problem I'm reminded of the Hacker New link from a month or so ago about 'The emotional journey of creating anything great' https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17164822 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17164822 where most of the time invested in doing something, looks like all the time you invested, will end up having a poor ROI pretty much every point there except the end looks like a case study for calling it a sunk cost and quitting to do something else. Its a hard thing to know when your sample size of data is big enough to make conclusions that have consequences on (I guess all in all that's the point, you need to use some heuristic, and the link is arguing for a heuristic of 50 pgs when reading a book, which seems like a rule of thumb that I have no particular objection to)
- andreofthecape 8y agoWhen to quit... great question! Seth Godin wrote a wonderful little book on this called 'The Dip: A Little Book That Teaches You When to Quit (and when to stick)'
- pitt1980 8y agoThanks for the recommendation!
- XorNot 8y agoFor me it would've been 1 year into my (ultimately failed) Ph. D project. I would be a lot wealthier now if I'd launched into the tech world then and been working all that time.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoI recently read the book Deep Work by Cal Newport, and I wish I had employed this 50-page rejection rule instead of pushing through the whole thing. I’m a big proponent of deep work habits, avoiding open-plan offices, etc., ... most of the stuff the book talks about. But it is just so poorly and shallowly written, mixing in little factoids or sound bytes that have no real evidentiary weight behind them and as a result just go in one ear and out the other. Most of the advice is entirely subjective, supported by anecdotes about unrealistically successful people who can use their positions of luck-driven-success to be sounding boards for whatever grandiose selection bias and retrospective plaudits they want. I was very disappointed after seeing the book praised often here on HN. But boy, it was a total stinker and there are many better books on the topic (Peopleware, for one). The whole book of Deep Work could have (and should have) been summarized with about 5 pages of bullet points, and published just as some blog post. It is absolutely dreadful as a long form book.
- randcraw 8y agoI recently read "Deep Work" too. I found it unenlightening but generally well written. Newport's main failing was his laser focus on how to schedule your waking hours to spend more time doing deep work. At least half of the book addressed only this. Personally, I'd have preferred to hear more about what deep work is, what ends it serves, and how to do it better. But I guess we were supposed to read Csikszentmihalyi's "Flow" for that. Mostly I came away from the book with deep insights into how Newport manages his daily routine for maximum productivity. Useful info perhaps, but not what I sought. However, as a self-help book, Deep Work shines. And seen in this light, its many 5 star reviews start to make more sense.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoI would disagree in the strongest terms. The book is essentially the opposite of what you described. It’s strong points are the general discussions of what deep work is and the differences with shallow work. As a self-help book, it’s beyond pitiful. The advice given is often totally impractical for most people and is extremely hard to read because of the meandering inclusion of useless anecdotes about what this or that CEO does or the throw-away sound byte statistics cherry picked from old research studies and quoted out of context. The closest thing to a self-help guideline that the book gives is to just state, unqualified, that you should make a ritual out of dedicating certain hours to deep work that cannot be interrupted by shallow work (unless you’re a journalist, in which case he advises some totally fictitious concept of just grabbing deep work time in an ad hoc way, whenever you can). Really, I was interested in reading it primarily as a self-help guide for how to effectively enforce deep work time in my schedule despite meeting-oriented company culture and open plan offices. In terms of self-help, not only does the book fail to deliver anything useful, but it could even be considered harmful to the extent that people buy into the anecdotes and sound bytes in the book.
- DanielBMarkham 8y agoHaving just published a book, and going through a couple of alpha and beta reader groups, I look at my experiences, the stack of books by my nightstand, and realize: most people do not buy books to read them They buy books for the promised experience they'll have owning them. I think most of us heavy readers are not honest enough with ourselves to admit it, but we're not enamored with the ideas in books as much as the experience. An unread book is the promise of a good time yet to come. I don't know about the Rule of 50. I know that some of the best reads I've had were a struggle for a good, long while until I could finally get into the mind of the author. I also know that some really awful books were a struggle too -- and they didn't get better. The problem here is that everybody has authors they are easily able to follow. The text just sort of flows. For me, Dean Koontz was like that for a while. It got to the point I started believing a machine was writing these things. They were enjoyable, easy-to-read, action-packed, and completely forgettable. I loved them. Used to call them my "airplane books". Pick one up the morning of travel, finish reading it that day. Compare that to my current read, "The Brothers Karamazov". I'm struggling, and it's not the author. It's my mind getting aligned with the author that's causing the problem. Sometimes it takes a lot more than 50 pages for that to happen. A little faith is required. If I had to come up with a rule, I'd go with Pearl's Rule, except for classics. And I'd add a fallback position: try the audiobook. Many times it's easier to listen to an audiobook half-way and get the general gist of it.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoI don't know about 'most people'. I start reading a book immediately after buying it.
- DanielBMarkham 8y agoIt's not unusual for me to get three or four book recommendations in a week. I try to resist the urge to buy them all, but my ability to purchase books far exceeds my ability to read them.
- logfromblammo 8y ago
- byproxy 8y agoI'm a finisher. But I tend to do my diligence before I start, so even if I am not particularly thrilled about the book at the end, I find there is usually something to glean from it. A few nice passages in the context of a book I'm otherwise not enjoying much is a nice experience, I find. Plus, reading other styles of writing in general is good for comprehension, I think. The more you read, the more of what you read starts making sense.
- jimbokun 8y agoHa, she really does have an action figure! https://mcphee.com/products/librarian-action-figure https://mcphee.com/products/librarian-action-figure
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Koshkin 8y agoWhen deciding whether to buy a book at a book store, I do not usually have a luxury of reading the first fifty pages; at least, I seem to be able to discern whether I would not like the book by simply opening the book on a random page and giving it a quick look. If, for example, the book consists mostly of conversations, I see it as a "talking heads" book and lose interest; there may also be other things that could immediately put me off, like "hither and thither".
- 6ak74rfy 8y agoI was until recently one of those people who insisted on finishing any book (or movie or TV show, for that matter) they started. Otherwise, I wouldn't feel closure. I dropped a few books (Lolita, The Pragmatic Programmer, Kitchen Confidential etc.) but kept feeling guilty later on. I am glad to hear from so many people here that dropping in between isn't such a bad thing after all. Related question: do you guys have a similar system for research papers? I've tried reading them a lot but have successfully made it through only a few. At this point, I even question if the effort in getting through their drudgery is worth it.
- lallysingh 8y agoResearch papers deserve no mercy. Mine what you want out of them. Only reviewers have to read them whole.
- philwelch 8y agoYou might also want to at least skim the whole thing if you want to use a research paper to win an argument, if you suspect that your interlocutor will try and find something to nitpick.
- b_b 8y agoI personally barely ever read the meat of the research papers. Usually I am only interested in the actual results, some of their related data or figures, and the abstract of the paper. I suspect that I am not alone in this, but I wonder if this is partly to blame for so many false research findings based on bad procedures and methodologies still surviving. I think many people do take modern research papers for granted and assume that if it is published in a scientific journal, it must be true.
- wenc 8y agoYes. Research Papers: - Read the abstract - Read the conclusion. - If paper still interesting, read the introduction and skim the rest of the paper. This was how I got through tons of journal publications during my Ph.D. qualifiers.
- killjoywashere 8y agoNot a rule to apply in the first two years of undergraduate compulsory classes!
- ythn 8y agoSome really good books will get false negatives by this rule, however. For example: The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, by Agatha Christie. By the bottom of page 50 I was not enjoying it at all, seemed like a trite mystery novel. I was ready to put it down but the friend who recommended it urged me to slog through. And boy was I glad I did. As is common with Agatha Christie, there is often a huge payoff at the very end (last chapter).
- MBCook 8y agoI’m having that problem with The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo. It takes 120 pages or so to get to the real plot. An amazing amount of time. But I’m kind of enjoying it and get the feeling once it starts moving I may really like it. But at the same time it was so slow for a good portion of the start I’m not sure I want to continue.
- Uhhrrr 8y agoIt's a pretty fast read overall. But for me it fell into the category of "standard thriller fluff"
- MBCook 8y agoThat’s basically what I expect out of it, but if it’s well written that’s fine. I’ve mostly been reading Sci-Fi lately so I’m up for the change of pace. I’m not expecting it to be the next great literary work of the world.
- your-nanny 8y agoI think it's a fine rule; be master of your free time. But beware of the reasons you are setting it down. Profound books can be difficult reads, and older books especially were content to make you work for it.
- olfactory 8y agoI think it makes sense to give it 100 pages, but I read a fair bit faster than the average person. I think it is also a question of the other factors indicating that a book might be worth reading... is it a classic? Have others highly recommended it? Is it for a book club? While I'm well aware of sunk cost and realize that it often makes sense to cut and run, I have had the experience a few times with both books and movies where it all came into focus right at the end and make the whole thing worthwhile. If I'd stopped 90% of the way through I never would have had the moment of appreciation. Just as a hike through the mountains is often rugged and lacking in scenery, reaching the peak changes the entire experience and puts the grueling work needed to get there into proper context. Some albums are uninviting on the first, second, and even third listens, yet after a while something is unlocked and the music finally makes sense. I'd argue that some of the best things are good in spite of being inaccessible. It's asking a lot of any creator to give us a happy path and also give us something deep and significant. Sure it happens now and then, but I prefer the significance over the happy path just as I prefer a carefully prepared meal to a piece of candy. The world wants to give us candy... the endorphins of the clickbait headline are 90% of the endorphins one gets after reading the whole article... the endorphins from watching a porn scene are 90% of the endorphins of watching a romance with a plot... a few pop tarts will go down quickly and dampen our enthusiasm for any cuisine.
- hervature 8y agoWhen you are 100 years old, I guess you just look at the cover and decide. After that, people read to you?
- egypturnash 8y agoMy rule is that you can’t drop a book until you’ve read at least as much as the most you’ve told someone else to read before giving up on something you’ve loved. Saying “Oh, Wheel Of Time is GREAT once you’ve slogged through the first three shitty tomes!” means you are fucked by this rule. I am also pushing fifty and have read a lot, life’s too goddamn short to not give up a book the moment you stop giving any fucks about it.
- bena 8y agoYeah, entertainment's purpose is to entertain. If it fails to do that in the beginning, it's not for you. The whole you have to watch/read/listen to X amount before passing judgment is bullshit. If I surround a chocolate cake in three inches of shit, no one will fault you for not eating through the shit just to get to the cake. It might be a good cake. It might be the best cake. But I'm not chowing through three inches of shit just to get it. Maybe next time, don't cover your cake in shit and see how that goes.
- byproxy 8y agoIf you're reading purely for entertainment you're entering the act with a bunch of expectation baggage (and probably looking over some worthwhile literature in the process).
- bena 8y agoLike expecting to be entertained? He was talking about fiction. Mentally change the word to engagement if you find entertainment too trite. The point is that if the creator wants their work experienced, they must make the experience enjoyable in some fashion all the way through.
- sten 8y agoThis doesn't hold in all cases. One of my all time favorite books is Catch-22. That was an absolute slog to complete when I first read it in university and I considered abandoning it several times. However the ending surprised me and I went on to reevaluate the entire story with fresh eyes. Plenty of novels (and other media now that I think of it) require long setups for a sufficiently sophisticated punch.
- pressurefree 8y agoburning witches at the steak can be a good thing...
- pattisapu 8y ago"Don't try." -Bukowski
- edgarvaldes 8y agoFrom reading all the comments in this thread, it seems than nobody is a hardcore finisher anymore.
- pressurefree 8y agoeven if my triple bubbler was actually broke, i would not let this callous witch fix it
- tw04 8y agoIf I had followed this, I never would've finished the "A Song of Fire and Ice" series (game of thrones). I guess technically I may never FINISH since he hasn't written all the books yet. It is a VERY painful start. And if you read interviews with Martin, he admits he had no idea where hew as going with the story until about halfway through the first book.
- munificent 8y agoDevil's advocate: If you hadn't, perhaps you would have found other even better books to read during that time.
- sizzzzlerz 8y agoI eagerly read the first 3 books without ever considering abandoning any of them and I subscribe to the yank-the-bandage approach to dropping books if not interesting within 20 pages or, towards the end, abandoning if I find myself skimming or skipping pages. With these, it never happened. When I read the 4th book, however, A Dance with Dragons, I kept reading far longer than I would any other book, hoping that it would get better and start getting somewhere. It never did. It was a slow motion train wreck. Finally, I threw in the towel and dropped it with no desire to ever go back and finish it or the 5th book. It did strengthen my resolve to drop bad books early even if prior books by the author were great reads.
- cannam 8y agoSome years ago I had a conversation with a friend about Douglas Coupland's novel Microserfs. He said, "That book annoyed me so much I tore it up, on the Tube." I had never thought of stopping reading as such a decisive act.
- dredmorbius 8y agoIt's the book-halting problem...
- djtriptych 8y agoThis is funny because books are about the only thing I really feel compelled to finish whether I like it or not. I've abandoned countless side projects, instruments, sports, meals, friendships etc when they stopped holding value for me. But once I crack open a book I really feel like I have to finish it before I can get on with my life. I don't start a lot of books anymore but they tend to stay on my todo list until I've literally read every word..
- Nannooskeeska 8y agoI'm the same way. If I lose interest in a book partway through, I'll stop reading it and go on to other books for a period of time and finish it later. I currently have 6 books in my "Reading" list on Goodreads, 5 of which I started at some point in the last couple of years and haven't finished yet.
- cryoshon 8y agoi've used the rule of 40 for quite some time now for both fiction and nonfiction. it does allow for some edge cases where you figure out that the remaining pages of the book will be very similar and mostly mediocre and you end up finishing it anyway, but at least it's a known quantity at the outset.
- kazinator 8y agoCompletely stupid. Give it no more than two or three pages. (Of the real meat, not any front matter.) There are way too many books in the world, and too many bad ones, for any random book to deserve fifty pages of your attention.
- WalterBright 8y agoThese days, I find myself turning more towards non-fiction than fiction. History books about interesting events, for example.
- soperj 8y agoGotta say, Love in time of Cholera is terrible for the first 80 pages or so, but it one of my very favorite books, and doesn't work at all without those first 80 pages.
- vzaliva 8y agoHow do you apply it to Kindle books? What is the equivalent of 50 pages in Kindle "locations"?