6 ms·
It's not about privacy, its about poorly written regulation that leaves too much vagueness because its based on principles rather than hard rules. Good intentio
by manigandham 8y ago
It's not about privacy, its about poorly written regulation that leaves too much vagueness because its based on principles rather than hard rules. Good intentions are not enough, there must be clear paths to implementation and verification. Perhaps that should've been fixed instead of wondering why so many companies don't really want to deal with it.
It will also do just about nothing in regards to the major companies that everyone had such a big privacy issue with in the first place, so not only is the regulation vague but it's also ultimately very ineffective.
- mrweasel 8y ago>because its based on principles rather than hard rules They tried hard rules, rather than principles with the cookie laws and the companies around the world turned a good idea into a shit-show of popups while continuing to behave like nothing happened. Honestly the more I read and the more I see how different business react I start to view the GDPR as EU finally showing that will not accept businesses viewing it as a second rate legislator. The GDPR and reactions to Trumps policies an EU that is finally starting to behave like it's representing the best interest of 500 million people.
- Matticus_Rex 8y ago95% of my GDPR work has done nothing for actual privacy. If this is how the EU "represents the best interest of 500 million people," then no thank you.
- globuous 8y agoCan you elaborate please ? And what about the other 5% ? I mean, if companies cared about privacy in the first place, there probably wouldn't be the need for such a regulation. At the very least, GDPR will get the general population be conscious about what the hell is going on under most websites.
- Matticus_Rex 8y agoMost of the costs of this (so far -- we'll see how it goes with subject rights; I spent several hours already working on a right to erasure request that was so confusing it will take a number of additional hours just to entangle and document) are learning the regulation (not privacy, but the regulation itself -- very different), doing documentation (the largest cost by far), and holding customers' hands. The last 5% wasn't all that meaningful; a few assorted things, like one of our S3 buckets that was storing encrypted backups of non-sensitive data with no expiration, and it got noticed during GDPR prep. It would have been noticed anyway (probably even before now). We've also lost customers (including a contract that would have been our second-biggest) because our competitor is either lying or doesn't know anything about the GDPR, and has convinced customers they're compliant. Their story sounds easier than ours; "We're in the EU, so we're compliant" as opposed to "Hey, you need to sign this DPA with us to be compliant." And no, many companies already did care about privacy. Companies are not faceless villains -- they're made up of people like you, assuming you have a job, and even aside from not wanting the bad publicity of breach or misuse most people want to use data correctly.
- seszett 8y agoA lot of "GDPR work" I have witnessed recently has been totally useless and frankly I'm still not sure why I understand the tortuous paths some have chosen to follow. I think a lot of that is down to decisions taken by US-based management that is simply clueless about how law works outside the US. And probably also only got their information from US-based lawyers that were either as clueless as themselves, or had incentives to make everything look very complicated. On the other hand, most of the companies around me that have no links with the US were not particularily worried, and either consider that they are already compliant, conducted minimal work to be acting in good faith, or at worst are waiting for the regulatory body (CNIL here) to tell them what they are doing wrong, if that is the case. However, I don't know any company that does shady things with their users' data, and things might be very different for those.
- kerng 8y agoI think you are mistaken - the amount of effort big companies are putting into this certainly already has improved privacy significantly- and its just the beginning!
- zajd 8y agoAnd yet, multiple companies that do all kinds of crazy things with your data (https://www.google.com/search?q=gdpr+shutdown https://www.google.com/search?q=gdpr+shutdown) have shut down already as a result of GDPR. You could argue that wasn't the goal but I'm pretty sure it was part of it and seems to be effective in that way at least.
- Matticus_Rex 8y agoYeah, what a win for humanity that EU users can't play Ragnarok Online anymore.
- manigandham 8y agoLike what exactly? The vast majority of them don't do anything that crazy other than storing an email or running some ads on the site, which is completely insignificant compared to the detailed profiles that Facebook and Google have and will continue to maintain. And it doesn't even touch the ISPs, credit unions, medical companies or other deep databanks. Right now there are billions of people around the world clicking "yes" on all the privacy and consent popups while grumbling about the annoying notices and just wanting to get back to what they were doing. Meanwhile there are also plenty of people creating havoc by filing lawsuits against every company they can, adding up to billions demanded on just the first day.
- henrikschroder 8y ago> Meanwhile there are also plenty of people creating havoc by filing lawsuits against every company they can, adding up to billions demanded on just the first day. No, the EU is not the US, no lawsuits have been filed. Some individuals have reported some companies to their local data protection agencies, just like the GDPR says you should. No money has been "added up to billions", because the DPAs don't sue for damages, the levy fines to ensure compliance. Huge difference. If you're going to critique the GDPR, please understand how the legal and regulatory systems of Europe work first.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- acatton 8y agoAs a French guy, these type of comments make me smile. The GDPR is basically just the implementation of the French law "Informatique et Liberté" into the European Level. (You can read on HN many Germans saying that it's actually the implementation of the Datenschutzgesetzt. The truth is: these two laws are extremely similar.) This law has been in application since 1978 [1]. And in 2018, we have adtech companies like Criteo. [2] I have one of my best friend who started his adtech startup in France. Everything is good. There's is a lot of implicit contracts (you filled up our sign up form? Well, then you chose to give us your data. ...) The only things you have to do: know which data you collect and give the ability to people to update/delete their data. That's all. I don't understand the fear. I don't understand what is "vague" about it. It's so simple and low barrier that Microsoft decided to make it the rule for all of their users. But thanks to the hysteria, they made a PR stunt out of it. -- [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Data_ownership&oldid=833932895#France https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Data_ownership&ol... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criteo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criteo
- manigandham 8y agoYou mean Criteo the company that has lost over 50% of their valuation since last year because of cookie and consent issues? Yea it's going really well for them. https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/CRTO/chart?p=CRTO https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/CRTO/chart?p=CRTO The difference is that France is insignificant in the adtech market. The real money is in the US and spread out across Europe, with Asia soon to overtake. The existing rules you point to weren't affecting global operations where Criteo and others made their money.
- dnomad 8y agoThe entire adtech business is due for correction. It's strange that you think the business models are going to fly in Asia. China and many Asian countries are laying out privacy regimes that are even more strict than the GDPR. Take a look at China [1] or Thailand [2]. Pretty soon it will be the case only in America that adtech companies can collect and sell endless personal information without consequence. [2] https://www.bangkokpost.com/business/news/1455534/new-data-law-aimed-at-ensuring-privacy https://www.bangkokpost.com/business/news/1455534/new-data-l...
- kadenshep 8y ago>its about poorly written regulation What is poorly written about it? > there must be clear paths to implementation and verification. There are. >Perhaps that should've been fixed instead of wondering why so many companies don't really want to deal with it. There's nothing to fix, and I'm going to assume you can't even name 3 things since your post is just an extremely vague talking point.
- toweringgoat 8y agoWhat you have described is _exactly_ how regulation works. It's still a hundred times better than what most countries in the world produce, since it's designed around the average human and not a megaco.
- manigandham 8y agoThis isn't about how it works, it's about whether it works or not. That companies need to follow the law isn't exactly confusing, and nobody is saying they shouldn't, but when the law cant even clearly answer basic questions of who it applies to and when, that's a problem. There are examples of regulation that does work, but GDPR is not really in that category.
- Tomte 8y ago> but when the law cant even clearly answer basic questions of who it applies to and when I haven't seen many grey areas or difficult corner cases in the discussions here, so far. Only people claiming that everything is unclear, because they don't want to accept the truth: that they clearly fall under the GDPR.
- manigandham 8y ago> that they clearly fall under the GDPR ...Ok, because you say so? Are you a lawyer? Do you realize that this whole discussion exists precisely because it's unclear? There are already billions in lawsuits against facebook, google and others so companies are rightfully being careful. And even if you fall under GDPR, there is plenty of vagueness about the data and processes itself. This is not as simple as you make it out to be.
- Tomte 8y ago> Do you realize that this whole discussion exists precisely because it's unclear? I realize that this statement is untrue. Some people are dredging up all kinds of "but what if" and "I really, truly don't understand how my collecting data could be considered GDPR-triggering". I find that dishonest. Protest as much as you want. Oh, and surprisingly, just by some bizarre happenstance, you are "Currently working on Instinctive, a B2B marketing technology company." I can tell you immediately that whatever you're doing falls under the GDPR.