14 ms·
Why it’s so hard to fix banking: An interview with Simple’s exiting CEO
- ikeboy 9y agoSo how hard is it now to open a bank with $20 million?
- watersb 9y agoI am glad they came along when they did. Works great for me.
- eklavya 9y agoHey, so you are using all these expensive AND inadequate techs, could we at least use something sane for this non critical stuff? I mean you don't have to worry about this thing and you save a lot and you are using a much better stack overall. What say you? No.
- dnomad 9y agoEh. This is not a mystery. Banks have tremendous lock-in and inertia working for them. The only way to fix the industry is complete account portability. Anybody should be able to wander into any competitor to their existing bank and initiate a transfer of their account to that competitor. The transfer should freeze the account and take no more than 48 hours. Do this and let the free market work its magic. Just like American celluar providers used to suck until number portability kicked in, American bank providers will suck until account portability is a thing. P.S. Banks should also be required by law to provide minimal services to every American citizen. It is absolutely beyond stupid that there are 10 million American households that don't have access to a bank account [1]. These households are then forced into dealing with the Check Cashing/Payday Loan businesses who are pure, unmitigated fucking evil. These firms charge outrageous fees that trap many people in poverty. [1] https://www.fdic.gov/householdsurvey/ https://www.fdic.gov/householdsurvey/
- simias 9y agoI completely agree, I've been using the same bank for about 15 years now and I'm sure if I looked around I could find better deals but I simply can't be bothered to go through with it. It's not an American issue though, as far as I can tell the situation is nearly identical in Europe.
- stevekemp 9y agoIn the UK, at least, there are switching-services which aim to make it painless to change your bank. Your direct-debits, and bills get switched to the new provider, etc. I've never used such a service myself, but I have heard from friends that the process was pretty painless.
- simias 9y agoInteresting, I've never heard of a similar service in France but then again it's not like I've been searching.
- hocuspocus 9y agoThere is. The banking portability law is even called after your president :) Most banks offer it, or at least claim to. However there's still no penalty for banks that don't do their job properly. But it shouldn't stop you, transferring all your SEPA direct payments isn't that hard even if you do it yourself.
- simias 9y agoThank you for the tip, I'll be sure to look into that the next time my bank annoys me, which statistically shouldn't take too long.
- hocuspocus 9y agoGet a referral or wait for a promotional offer, the big players (Boursorama, Fortuneo, ...) regularly offer 130~150€ sign-up bonuses, which is a decent compensation for the time you'll invest switching banks.
- azeotropic 9y agoWhat exactly prevents people from cashing checks at the issuing bank, or walking into a bank or credit union with their paycheck and opening an account? Or cashing it at a Wal-mart or a 7-11, which have low fees? These people may trapped in poverty, but ultimately not by the check cashing/payday loan business.
- Retric 9y agoMany banks have a tiny number of branches so good luck finding one to cash a check. Low fees are rarely low when you're talking a minimum wage income. Walmart's 3$ fee for anything under 1000$ works out to 1/2 an hour of work. Picture spending 1/2 an hour of your salary every 2 weeks simply to get paid. Now make that worse by having 3 jobs...
- watmough 9y agoI had no idea this was the case. That's shocking. If I need cash, I walk into a Chase branch [Not my bank, but conveniently near a Thai Restaurant I like to visit] and just ask for cash advance against my VISA card. Done by a teller, there's no ATM fees.
- cslarson 9y agoAccount portability works exactly like this in the UK. I can't say that banks here provide a much better service than I received in the US.
- hocuspocus 9y agoI never lived in the UK but I've heard good things about Monzo and Starling. If you look into the fintech space, there's a stark difference between Europe and the North American market. We have several players entering retail banking every year in Europe, and that's partly thanks to regulations.
- jamiegreen 9y ago+1 for Monzo. Used it since it was in beta and now as my main account. Not quite ready to shut my other account yet...but maybe in a year or two
- pnutjam 9y agoYeah, and when did cell providers stop sucking...?
- Someone1234 9y ago> I can't say that banks here provide a much better service than I received in the US. Really? "ATM" withdraws are free in the UK, money transfers are instant, checks are dead, and account data easily downloadable as e.g. CSV. I've had US and UK accounts and it is night and day. Who were you banking with in the US who gave you as good of an experience as a UK bank because I'd love to move to them?
- lykr0n 9y agoAlly is Good. Schwab is another one. The problem is that you will be hard pressed to find a excellent bank that has a large physical presence. Get a local credit union and you should be more than happy.
- deleted 9y ago
- hndamien 9y agoThe crypto dream is that you leave banks all together. It is happening slowly.
- distances 9y agoI've had bank accounts in three different EU countries. No bad experiences. Never paid any fees if salary went to the account. Free money transfers to anywhere within EU. Free credit card with no interest if paid back next month. True 2-factor authentication with physical one-time TAN list. Account insured against bank's bankruptcy up to 100k. I have zero interest in seeing blockchains enter any financial services I'm part of.
- hndamien 9y agoYou have a very narrow world view if you are your entire sample.
- distances 9y agoI was trying to imply that blockchain is not the only way of fixing the broken US banking system, and moving to blockchain could perhaps limit your options of interoperating with other parts of the world that have managed to build a user-friendly banking system. It's possible that blockchain could form a basis of a financial system for a limited group of people, but hoping it to be a foundation for a widely accepted system is from my perspective a misguided attempt to apply a technical solution to something that doesn't need one.
- hndamien 8y agoI was making the point that bad experiences are commonplace throughout the world. I have worked with people that can't afford bank accounts in the Phillipines and I have had my own bank accounts frozen and had assets stolen by my banking institution, and I live in a first world country and am a law abiding citizen. This is not even to speak of central banks and the encroachment of surveillance and impingement of economic liberties that I believe to be self evident. I stand by my statement that you should widen your view point since you have not experienced the things that make Bitcoin valuable.
- repolfx 9y agoThat'd make US law contradictory. The reason the number of unbanked keeps going up is that post-9/11 the USA kept tightening anti-money laundering requirements. These require banks to refuse to bank with clients who they suspect might be criminals, on pain of the banker becoming a criminal themselves. That means once people fall out of the banking system for whatever reason and have to live in the cash economy for a while, they cannot prove where their income came from and are thus presumed guilty by default. To fix that you'd need to make US AML laws much less punitive. No political appetite exists to do that.
- nradov 9y agoYou can prove where your income comes from by just showing a couple months worth of pay stubs. The actual reason that people are most commonly denied new bank accounts is due to bouncing multiple checks on a previous account. https://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/banking/blacklisted-by-chexsystems-what-to-know/ https://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/banking/blacklisted-by-chexs...
- gonzo41 9y agoGod cheques are an anachronism. I can't believe they persist in this day.
- linsomniac 9y agoIt feels like checks are barely hanging on. I started using Simple 4 years ago when I switched jobs, partly because it seemed like more and more places were posting signs that they didn't take checks. Since Simple doesn't really have checks, except ones you have them send by using the website, that seemed ok. In the 4 years since, I've had a few instances where I needed checks. I have a plumber I like, but he isn't really a businessman, and so he wants cash or a check when he's done with work. The only tradesman I've dealt with that wasn't happy with me sending a check from Simple. He does good work though. I have some bills I pay via check, like the yearly pool membership, that I can just use Simple to send out. I've been pretty happy to not have a check book. Especially after I had a $45 check I sent someone that got stolen from their mailbox and cashed for around $2,000 each, twice at different branches of my bank. Thankfully, I noticed within a day or two, and it was only a big hassle.
- dsr_ 9y agoMinimal banking services to every American? Postal banking. http://www.campaignforpostalbanking.org/know-the-facts/ http://www.campaignforpostalbanking.org/know-the-facts/
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Nursie 9y agoThis is how it works in Europe, or at least the EU. Very few people ever switch an account anyway. Something loke 0.4% of the market have evere done it. PSD2 is supposed to make it even easier but I guess we'll see.
- 1ste 9y agoWhere could I find more information about that stat?
- Nursie 9y agoI think it was 0.42%... If you look into why the EU came up with PSD2 you should find out some more about it. Honestly can't find it now. It may just have been something I heard around the office (I am currently consulting with Open Banking in the UK but do not speak for them here or anywhere else)
- 1ste 9y agoCool, I'll try find it. I'm looking into PSD2-related things for my company at the moment.
- marcosdumay 9y agoThe inter-banking transfer systems are a major source of oligopolization. And the barriers to entry imposed by the government are huge. You won't get a competitive market if you don't solve those two. But it's not even clear if it would be benefic to lower the barriers to entry.
- neffy 9y agoWell, they have had that in the UK for sometime now. The system there was already far more efficient than the US one when this was introduced - which is not surprising, it´s mainly a technology issue. The only thing it really changed was that deposit accounts received a slightly higher interest rate up to a certain limit, provided that you pay your salary into them. So based on that, Account portability is not whatever it is that is stopping the US banks providing a service to the entire population.
- fjsolwmv 9y agoThere's no need to switch "accounts". All you need is account number portability, so you can switch over your direct deposit and autobillpay. If you have a low balance, you need a way to fallback, so the number can draw from both accounts, that's the hard part. There's no need to do it in 2 days -- take as long as needed for securr setup, then use both accounts for a month.
- bobwaycott 9y agoWouldn’t that be relatively difficult to accomplish when routing numbers are tied to account numbers, as well? My admittedly naive understanding tells me account number portability would require routing + account numbers to smoothly change things. I’ve never setup an EFT/ACH transfer without being required to provide both.
- sakopov 9y agoI've been using Simple for close to 5 years now and have been incredibly happy with my experience. The customer service is hands down the best I've ever come across and all updates to the app made the experience much better. Simple being a partner bank instead of a stand-alone bank has definitely held them back. I'd wager they lost quite a few customers when switching from Bancorp to BBVA. Even I considered leaving due to lengthy switch process and generally thinking that such a hard change is not acceptable, but I stuck around and the entire process was exceptionally smooth. I'm still somewhat surprised they haven't made strides to become an actual bank entity, but having experienced regulations working at a banking SAAS company myself I can imagine the monstrous effort required here. Either way, it's sad to see the original founders leave. I really hope this doesn't change the vision and direction.
- udfalkso 9y agoI’ve had a similar experience. Would never go back to The nickel and dining nightmare that was Citibank.
- abiox 9y ago> dining nightmare bad food? :)
- dcosson 9y agoHuh. I had exactly the opposite experience, simple was mostly fine when I used it but the web experience of chase these days is also fine. A clear, simple UI for seeing statements and setting up credit card auto-pay, deposit checks in the app. Plus, having branches if you absolutely need to use them is nice, and finding atms in most us cities for a big bank is much more straightforward than finding the partner atm brands that work with simple, or whatever you have to do there. When simple goes wrong though, the leaky abstraction of being a thin wrapper around another bank makes it much more painful. I forget the details now, but some fairly straightforward things broke for me a couple of times. And as friendly as their support might be, they were completely useless for fixing the problem because it was due to the underlying bank they built on top of. Canceling my account was also somewhat opaque. So I can’t really relate to this article or most of these comments at all. The underlying money transfer infrastructure in the US (between banks and merchants or banks and other banks) on the other hand really needs an upgrade from the arcane ACH system, that’s the last thing that sucks about consumer banking as far as I can see.
- erikb 9y ago"Why it's so hard to fix <X>?" Very easy question. There are people who profit from how <X> fails. The reason it bothers you is because you are not one of the people who are profiting. You might not be profiting from <X> but you are likely profiting from some <Y>. And when it comes to <Y> you are probably not recognizing how it fails on the cost of others and are not really bothered by it. So good luck convincing the people who profit from <X> to change it.
- galfarragem 9y agoI read somewhere, probably Nietzche, the following statement (paraphrasing): There are only 3 types of people: the poor that wants to be rich, the rich that wants to continue to be rich and the idealist, that using his ideals, wants to be rich. edit: I always read it figuratively. Getting rich meaning to improve position in whatever hierarchy the person cares about.
- Angostura 9y agoAnd do you think that’s true? Why category do you think - say- Tim Berners-Lee falls into?
- talltimtom 9y agoThe last one obviusly.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jeremyjh 9y agoHe's worth tens of millions. Is it really hard to understand?
- Angostura 9y agoI chose a poor example. Do you really believe there’s no such thing as altruism?
- Cbasedlifeform 9y agoI was with Simple from the start and generally liked the app and the customer support (based in Portland IIRC) was very helpful and friendly. My problem was that I had a large check to deposit and before they cleared it they insist I not only specify the source of the funds but also what I was going to use the monies for! I understand they need to ask the former (per IRS regulations and "Suspicious Activity Reporting") but the latter is frankly NOTFB and no other bank has asked me that question. I told them as such and closed the account.
- ellius 9y agoThey're supposed to ask both actually per AML laws. Which may be completely overbearing but are not within their control.
- savrajsingh 9y agoWhat’s the future of simple, though? With all the founders leaving, does it have a future?
- WJW 9y agoSurely, a company that requires the presence of its founders to function has way less of a future than a company that doesn't? A great company should not be dependent on any one person.
- agsamek 9y agoI'm going to write a few words I always do this in the bank topics. In Poland (post-soviet EU member, 36M people) we have many banks. Inter-bank transfers are free for personal accounts. $0.50 for businesses in my case. We have free transfer for phone number of up to $1000. Instant. We use mostly debit cards tied to accounts without any fee with wireless payments. Our goverment reduced transaction fees so you can pay as low as $.10 bill without complain. Of course this moves us closer to cash-less full-control mode but who cares ;)
- fwdpropaganda 9y agoCzesc!
- cbnotfromthere 9y ago"post-soviet EU member" Poland was never part of the Soviet Union.
- exegete 8y agoPoland was a Soviet satellite state, so I'm guessing "post-Soviet" here means "post-Soviet controlled" vs. being an official member of the Soviet Union.
- comnetxr 9y agoI wanted to like Simple. But the budgeting and money tracking features were never really that useful, I needed checks, and my card number was stolen and used to purchase groceries in another state even though I had only used it for a couple of transactions. Their customer service handled the transaction but it really seemed like the card leak was probably on their end. I pulled my money out then.
- freddie_mercury 9y agoThey picked the worst possible time in 80 years to start a new bank. It meant they couldn't actually get a banking certificate. This constrained every technical choice & feature they wanted to offer. I mean....I'm not sure there's a lot to learn from the Simple story beyond that.
- fwdpropaganda 9y agoWhy do you say it's the worst possible time in 80 years to start a bank?
- venantius 9y agoHe's referring to the time Simple started - in 2009, in the peak of the financial crisis and right after the Office of the Controller of the Currency initiated what is now nearly a 10-year moratorium on the granting of new national bank charters.
- wffurr 9y agoThere's already a solution for what is wrong with banks: credit unions. They just don't waste money on advertising so they get less visibility than they should.
- christophilus 9y agoI'll second this. I used to do a good bit of work for credit unions. Every one of our clients were great folks who genuinely were trying to do the best thing for their customers. I'm a happy customer of USAA and Simple. If they didn't exist, I'd use a credit union. Without question.
- wffurr 9y agoUSAA is the next best thing, an employee-owned cooperative.
- kasey_junk 9y agoUsaa is the single best “bank” in the USA. Unfortunately their charter prevents lots of places from using them. I’ll note they are much different than a “small” credit union in terms of reach & technology.
- leetcrew 9y agoi have a zero fee, zero minimum account with schwab that also gives me access to their ETFs with no trade commissions or monthly limits, and the ETFs themselves have extremely low expense ratios. also they reimburse any ATM fees in full every month. what advantages does Usaa have over this setup?
- wffurr 9y agoAmong others, USAA doesn't require a brokerage account to bank with them. I don't think it's really a comparable situation. In their competitor comparison[1], you'll note they don't list USAA or any credit unions, because it would look basically the same as the Schwab account. Low or no fees, low or no minimum balance, decent interest rates, etc. There's no reason for you to switch, either, but not everyone needs or wants a Schwab brokerage account too. [1]: https://www.schwab.com/public/schwab/banking_lending/checking_account#account-basics https://www.schwab.com/public/schwab/banking_lending/checkin...
- venantius 9y agoWe came to many of the same conclusions. This is why my co-founder and I decided to relocate to the UK in order to set up our bank. The friendlier regulatory ecosystem here is just a huge advantage compared to the US. Plus, there's still a pretty clear path to getting a national US banking license - it just requires you to expand in from abroad, rather than trying to build it within the US.
- purple-again 9y agoThe number of FDIC banks in the United States. Anyone working near this space can attest to the flurry of mergers and acquisitions. 2002 7,870 2003 7,750 2004 7,612 2005 7,507 2006 7,380 2007 7,262 2008 7,061 2009 6,813 2010 6,506 2011 6,263 2012 6,061 2013 5,836 2014 5,596 2015 5,330 2016 5,102
- purple-again 9y agoIt’s a long hard reality that anyone who wants to operate in this space has to deal with. You think it’s unfair you can’t cash your check for free and have to pay a $10 fee? Take a look at what the bank is required by the BSA and later KYC laws to do after accepting that check and understand it’s not the bank that’s the problem. It’s the onerous regulations that have literally almost halved the number of institutions able to survive.
- cesarb 9y ago> 2016 5,102 In my country (Brazil), the bank identifier used by several banking protocols is three digits. It's hard to imagine over a thousand separate banks in a single country. (For the curious, the full list of identifiers: http://www.bb.com.br/docs/pub/siteEsp/compe/dwn/IFPCNC.pdf http://www.bb.com.br/docs/pub/siteEsp/compe/dwn/IFPCNC.pdf and http://www.bb.com.br/docs/pub/siteEsp/compe/dwn/IFPECNC.pdf http://www.bb.com.br/docs/pub/siteEsp/compe/dwn/IFPECNC.pdf)
- linsomniac 9y agoI've been using Simple for around 4 years now, and one thing I really hoped to have was a very good system for tracking and managing my money. They had a good start 4 years ago with their "envelope savings system" and goals and their web interface. It had a few warts, and was only ok, and really didn't do a very good job of categorizing the transactions. But, they were new and surely it would improve, right? 4 years later I can say it is basically unchanged. It really isn't very usable. I do still like how it implements the envelope savings towards your goals, but for managing and tracking money it really isn't useful. Mint is better for tracking. I like Simple, but I wouldn't say I love Simple.
- tc08 9y agoAgreed, I tried them for a while but now I've switched to Capital One 360. Excellent app and web, savings account with 1.6% interest, free ATM worldwide, no foreign transaction fees, etc. I tried Schwab as well but IMHO Capital One is above and beyond the others when you look at everything offered.
- jcrawfordor 9y ago> but the reality is that most millennials, like most Americans, bank at the top four banks. I suppose I'm willing to believe this claim, but I find it pretty surprising. In my social group, the commercial banks are viewed negatively almost to the point of stigma against using them. Everyone uses credit unions for their checking, and several credit unions in this area (Nusenda, Rio Grande, USEagle) are at least as convenient as the major national banks. I think a large part of the perception of convenience comes down to the Credit Union strategy of federating services. An ATM network jointly operated by many of the credit unions in the region (CU Anytime) has a large fleet and has focused on placing ATMs in high-convenience locations like offices of major employers and college campuses. Co-Op Shared Branching means that you can walk into a branch of almost any credit union and they can access your accounts at your own credit union. And as for avoiding ATMs and branches at all - the online and mobile services offered by most credit unions are perhaps a bit behind aesthetically, but they work just fine, and the credit unions seem to have been offering free and easy person-to-person transfers for longer than the commercial banks have. So what's limiting adoption of credit unions? I'm skeptical that it's awareness because the branches are everywhere and some of the larger ones around here purchase billboards and TV advertising regularly. Is there a feeling that they're more limited in their service offerings?
- fjsolwmv 9y agoI don't think other regions have as strong credit unions as your area. Certainly not in my area. I tried a credit union but the website was so bad I switched back to my big bank. I very rarely even use ATMs anymore; mostly cashless. So ATMs don't even matter.
- spyspy 9y agoAs a card-carrying millennial, I've found my friends to be woefully ignorant of how to bank, despite (or because of?) their often well-off upbringings. People often tend to follow the lead of their parents when it comes to banking decisions. They don't really explore the market for themselves or have strong opinions on what's efficient or ethical.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Justsignedup 9y agoUgh. Looking at their info: - I can get same deals from Ally bank. No fees. - Ally bank reimburses 100% of all ATM fees I pay. - Ally bank savings account is 1.60% at the moment. It is no investment account but better than any other bank period. - Ally's customer support is pretty darn good I don't see ally going crying around about how hard banking is. Simple was just sub-par.
- dogruck 9y agoIn the interview, he talks a lot about the difficulty of navigating the regulations. Perhaps his criticisms of those regulations are valid — but those regulations exist because of previous problems. In many cases, the same people who scream, “banking sucks” would also scream if their bank failed due to a reason that some existing regulation would have prevented.
- tokyodude 9y agoIf someone wants to fix banking they should figure out how to do it in Japan. For all of the supposed idea that Japan embraces the future Japan's banking system must be among the worst in the 1st world. A couple of examples No interest: A typical interest rate is 0.015%. No that is not a misprint. It's X * 0.00015 annual interest rate (https://www.boj.or.jp/en/statistics/dl/depo/tento/te180516.pdf https://www.boj.or.jp/en/statistics/dl/depo/tento/te180516.p...) No checks: Not sure about other countries but in the USA sending a check to someone usually costs nothing. In Japan checks really don't exist. Instead to send money you do a bank transfer which costs anywhere from $3 to $8 per transaction. For a regular person they might only have 1 payment like that (rent). But for a company that adds up quick. Electronic payment (sign in to your bank, send payment) uses the same $3 to $8 per transaction system. Byzantine hours: I recently got a business bank account and signed up for the online banking (costs extra). I'm only allowed to send payments from 8am to 3:30pm. ATMs are still not 24hrs. 7/11 (Shinsei Bank?) and a few others open 24hrs. Most ATMs still close at some point ever day. MUFG ATMs are currently 7am to midnight. Japan is still a very cash oriented society. They do have things like Felica (digital cash) but getting around with paper cash is not easy. Note, I don't mind the cash thing since cash = anonymous but I know lots of foreigners east and west that are surprised as they can generally get by cashless in their own countries but not here. I'm not even scratching the surface. I'm sure the people in power and regulations in place make it nearly impossible to fix the system but someone one out there must have a way.
- cepth 9y agoI’ve never lived in Japan, and judging from your username it seems you may have. But, I’d like to point out that on the low interest point you make, this isn’t necessarily a good thing: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/aug/26/japans-deflationary-spiral-worsens-as-abenomics-falters https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/aug/26/japans-deflati.... The interest rate available to consumers is directly related to the rate that banks can borrow from the central bank. The BOJ has had to operate at the ZLB for quite a while: https://www.boj.or.jp/en/announcements/press/koen_2016/data/ko160112a.pdf https://www.boj.or.jp/en/announcements/press/koen_2016/data/.... The low interest rates available to consumers are a function of macroeconomic factors and monetary policy, not anything that consumer lending banks themselves do.
- eweise 9y agoAn alternative to to Simple is VaroMoney. Unlike Simple, they are trying to get a bank charter which should give them more control over the bank experience.