47 ms·
Facebook announces Clear History feature
- znpy 9y agoThe title should really be "Facebook promises 'clear history' feature" as it has been promised but not yet delivered.
- tripzilch 9y ago"Facebook vaguely but condescendingly hints at caring about EU citizens' privacy while threatening to worsen their experience [JUMP SCARE WARNING]"
- tripzilch 9y agoCan we add a little warning about the jump scare if you're not logged in to Facebook? It's even timed to pop in your face after a few seconds as you're just focusing on the first paragraph, BAM! Gigantic crazy-looking Zuckerberg in your face.
- stevensonbaines 9y agoQ U A D H A C K E D @ G M A I L . C O M. I went on google in search of other means to take care of eviction report and late payments record from my credit report records and most people on different blogs kept talking about a professional . and how fast, affordable and reliable he is…I summoned courage to reach out to him, and told him my issues with my records. His response to my mails made me calm and optimistic about the whole thing. I made a down payment for the job and he cleaned my negative remarks in just a week and was approved by credit union in 3 weeks. that singlehandedly brought so much relief to me and its so amazing. Fix your credit report by contacting his email { Q U A D H A C K E D @ G M A I L . CO M } and by the time he’s done with your job . and when you get pleased with your job, you'll b willing to recommend just the way i am
- alex_young 9y agoMoney quote: "Your Facebook won't be as good while it relearns your preferences." I bet that depends on how you define "good".
- tripzilch 9y agoIt's a veiled threat, just like when they told you that if you disable facial recognition you're worsening the experience of blind users, and that nefarious people will take your photos and impersonate you.
- chrischen 9y agoThey probably intentionally selected things to delete to cripple the experience. It's a way of forcing people bad-mouthing facebook to put their money where their mouth is. If critics don't use this feature, they can put the blame solely on them.
- tripzilch 9y agoWhy is this downvoted? The article itself is a demonstration that they really do this. Case in point: If you're not logged in to the FB tracking network, after 5 seconds of reading, you get surprised by this "funny" jump scare: https://i.imgur.com/PCQOo8N.png https://i.imgur.com/PCQOo8N.png That is deliberately worsening the experience. If you click the close-button (helpfully labelled "Not now"), it is replaced with a sticky footer that takes 33% of your screen (depending on your window size and zoom setting).
- Lionsion 9y ago> If critics don't use this feature, they can put the blame solely on them. Once this rolls out, I'm going to be posting instructions to my feed. One of the only reasons I still keep Facebook around is to publicize articles critical of social media and stuff like this.
- ceejayoz 9y agoIndeed. I've discovered it can make major mistakes on who's "important" to me - I'd thought they'd stopped Facebooking, but it turned out their algorithm had for some reason deemed them not to be a "close" friend and de-emphasized them from my feed.
- giarc 9y agoI agree this probably won't make Facebook as good. I relate this to the time before spam filters were good and 50% of my email was penis enlargement pills and money wire fraud. You dump all this data and we go back to a time where I'm not known, and Facebook shows me my active "friends" and it's just my aunt sharing her latest Bejeweled score. I'm all for better control of my data, but there needs to be some balance so the ads I see are still relevant and not acai berries super juices and Hot Local Singles In My Area.
- jonshariat 9y agoQuestion is does Facebook remove it from their data?
- C14L 9y agoWe will see. Here in Europe, its possible to find out after 2018-05-25. My guess is that they will retain as much data on you as they can legally get away with.
- netsharc 9y agoAh... now I'm speculating that this tool is their answer to GPDR's right to delete. "We have a tool, we're compliant!". Insert "Beware of the Leopard" quote here...
- ericrav 9y agoEven if they did keep some part of the data, would they be able to use it for anything without inevitably getting caught and facing another scandal?
- loceng 9y agoIt might be difficult to catch depending on the how macro attributions they could make on you, depending on the time scale - say over 20 years, if you cleared the history every year, it might give them insights that might be hard to correlate to earlier history. If there were strong whistle-blower laws and pre-set rewards however, then might get a whistle-blower who could earn themselves say $1B+ (based on size/revenues of Facebook) for outing the deceit - which then Facebook would be fined for.
- Rjevski 9y agoIs a scandal a huge issue? Despite the recent #DeleteFacebook and everything, Facebook wasn't really impacted all that much and is still making tons of profit even without the 1% of users who did delete it. A future hypothetical scandal where another 1% deletes it would be worth it considering all the data and revenue they made from abusing people's data before the scandal.
- middleclick 9y agoI am still not sure if saying and doing is the same thing, specifically in this case when more data means more money for Facebook. And this is not just about Facebook, but to any service that claims they won't log or store my data. At the end of the day, it's just a claim and I try to minimize harm by giving as less data as possible because once they have it, I am not sure what happens to it and for how long it is retained.
- chrischen 9y agoThe issue isn't that they aren't honoring requests to delete data. The issue is that they've tied their success and the usefulness of their product strictly to the weakening of user privacy and the necessity to provide them as much such data as possible.
- Xeoncross 9y ago> Once we roll out this update, you'll be able to see information about the apps and websites you've interacted with, and you'll be able to clear this information from your account. So it's really just a way to de-authorize all apps/sites at once?
- chrischen 9y ago> To be clear, when you clear your cookies in your browser, it can make parts of your experience worse. You may have to sign back in to every website, and you may have to reconfigure things. The same will be true here. Your Facebook won't be as good while it relearns your preferences. Sounds like they designed this feature explicitly to show people why they need to provide facebook data. Instead of designing facebook features so that they can enjoyed while preserving privacy, Facebook is making moves to explicitly show how on Facebook privacy is at odds with utilitarianism of their product.
- loceng 9y agoI wonder if and how this impacts their ad targeting abilities?
- chrischen 9y agoIf people use it en-masse, probably negatively, but most likely they're betting few people will use it, just like how few people (almost no one I know) 100% go through with account deletion. The reality is there is no compromise for privacy. They build tools that help you either lose all value from facebook and retain your privacy, or relinquish your privacy to continue using facebook. It's not so much privacy forward tooling as it is a constant reminder they have a gun to your head.
- loceng 9y agoThanks for the reply. Instapainting looks like a great service btw.
- BlackFly 9y agoWell, GDPR makes forces them to make the tracking features opt in, so they have to collectively convince EU users to turn on the tracking as opposed to hoping the people won't disable it. They do this through a few devious practices, such as the spin doctoring discussed here. One other thing that they do is instead of the option being a check box, it is a selection between two radio buttons and you explicitly have to choose one of them. I suppose this is actually a violation of the GDPR, since it should be disabled by default. You don't lose value from facebook at all by not opting in. "Show ads that are relevant to me," is an arrogant statement. The actual statement is "Track my browsing to show ads that Facebook believes are relevant to me." I don't use Facebook for the targeted ads, I use it to infrequently receive news about people I know spread out across the globe.
- jabgrabdthrow 9y agoIs this official confirmation that everything is safely secretly backed up?
- giarc 9y agoYou thought they didn't have backups of their data?
- jabgrabdthrow 9y agoI thought it was possible they didn't have "safe, secret" backups (the implication here hopefully being obvious from context clues. A general principle of good discourse is to assume the interpretation that makes the most sense instead of picking apart targets you yourself would know how to respond to if you were in the adversarial position) Another way to put it, "You thought I thought they didn't have backups of their data? your face"
- gbrown 9y agoHow about a way to delete past activity? The fact that there's no option for "delete all my old posts, comments, likes, and photos" is infuriating. I don't need a record of my inane crap from high school on the same platform as work friends.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- smrtinsert 9y agoI have my doubts about this feature. In the case of Russian bots, having access to their data is critical.
- oliveshell 9y agoThat’s assuming “delete“ actually removes the data from Facebook‘s servers rather than just hiding it from you and ignoring it for ad targeting.
- gbrown 9y agoStuff can still be deleted, it just has to happen one item at a time (which is stupid and user hostile).
- envy2 9y agoLike it or not, the right to proper, permanent deletion is enshrined in GDPR.
- djsumdog 9y agoI think that's one reason people stopped using LiveJournal/Blogger and other platforms back in the early 2000s. I had countless friends delete or restrict those accounts because there was too much up there; too personal. All modern social media platforms encourage constant posting to quickly bury anything embarrassing. It's a weird change in dynamic when you think about it, because people were too afraid of the "real" so to say. I wrote a post about this years ago. I'm not sure if I entirely still stand behind it, but I'll leave it here anyway: https://khanism.org/society/how-social-media-destroyed-my-generation/ https://khanism.org/society/how-social-media-destroyed-my-ge...
- netsharc 9y agoI can imagine this spectacularly backfiring... "Facebook tracked all those sites I visited?!?" (What was the joke about porn videos having "Like" buttons?). I look forward to the even more damage control... The Guardian coverage (https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/may/01/facebook-mark-zuckerberg-unveils-privacy-tool-clear-history https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/may/01/facebook-...) has this quote like a parent explaining to a 5 year old why they shouldn't delete cookies: > Zuckerberg also cautioned users against clearing cookies in their browser, saying “it can make parts of your experience worse”, and adding, “Your Facebook won’t be as good while it relearns your preferences.” I wonder why he's so afraid of people clearing his tracking pixels.
- djsumdog 9y ago> What was the joke about porn videos having "Like" buttons? "I don't understand why porn websites have a +1 under the videos? Why would I want anyone to know I use Google+?"
- Fenrisulfr 9y agoSomewhat relevant: A friend took my phone (playfully) and posted this as a status on my profile a while ago. I left it up because I found it funny. Now that it's easier to delete I may actually just do that.
- craftyguy 9y ago"Delete"
- bigiain 9y agoHe says: " … you'll be able to clear this information from your account. You'll even be able to turn off having this information stored with your account." "your account". What do you reckon is the chance of them removing this from their ad targeting data set "account"??? They're just going to give you a tool that shows some of it to you, then hides it from you when you click the [fuck me over more] button (and they'll record _that_ interaction too, and sell you to the "tinfoil" and "headwear" segments.
- koolba 9y ago> To be clear, when you clear your cookies in your browser, it can make parts of your experience worse. You may have to sign back in to every website, and you may have to reconfigure things. The same will be true here. Your Facebook won't be as good while it relearns your preferences. That's not a bug, it's a feature! I've had my browser set up to nuke everything on shutdown as far as I can remember. Yes you have to log back for sites you want to interact non-anonymously but I consider it the sane default. Tracking and privacy aside, you'll likely save some money too as not being logged into shopping sites raises the barrier to ordering pointless crap.
- tripzilch 9y ago> I've had my browser set up to nuke everything on shutdown as far as I can remember. I have this and only log into GMail in a private window (I would do the same for FB if I used it). It's a bit of a hassle, especially since I've enabled 2FA, but it's become a habit and not that much of a hassle (I leave the private window open).
- koolba 9y agoI use entirely separate browsers for that. Gmail logged into my primary account gets its own dedicated browser. Nothing else ever gets opened in that browser and it's never used for "regular" browsing. It's a failsafe against bugs in the private browser implementation and provides a further separation of authenticated vs anonymous.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoWas any timeline mentioned for this feature?
- BinaryIdiot 9y agoWhat I _really_ want is an option that allows me to prune my Facebook posts. Like if I had a button, or at least some sort of bulk deletion with overview, so I could delete all of my political posts and memes then it would be really handy. This clear history is handy I guess. Seems kinda shitty to need it, though.
- m-localhost 9y agoI used this. It works ok. https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/social-book-post-manager/ljfidlkcmdmmibngdfikhffffdmphjae https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/social-book-post-m...
- barryduffman 9y agoDid you uninstall that after using it? Otherwise that extension still has the ability to "read and change your data on all facebook.com sites." For all you know, it may have uploaded a copy of all your Facebook data to its servers already.
- m-localhost 9y agoI deactivate the extension after usage. I also looked at the console/source code and the only external urls the extension is calling are google services (Analytics and Chrome Store) I have analytics blocked in the HOSTS file anyway.
- dcbadacd 9y agoWhat I really want is purging all messages sent to other people, selectively.
- kevin_b_er 9y agoThis just means facebook will no longer show you or your friends what was in the history. Facebook will still sell advertising based on your private data. It won't be cleared, just hidden from your view.
- latenightcoding 9y agoIs Facebook ever going to let us unsend messages? I think that is what most people wanted. Delete posts, messages and other things from the past.
- saagarjha 9y agoWeren't they going to roll this out for Messenger at some point? They did it for Zuckerberg, and then mentioned that they were just "testing" it and were going to roll it out generally some time in the future.
- giarc 9y ago>Is Facebook ever going to let us unsend messages? Does any service actually allow this? I can't unsend an email (except with Outlooks recall feature I guess). I can't unsend a text.
- mynameisvlad 9y agoYou can't unsend an email or text because generally speaking you can't control the other end. SMS was never built with the ability to "recall" a text, so once it's been delivered, it's off the carrier's hands. Email is similar, although with modern mail clients (outside of POP3), you would be able to remotely delete emails in most cases. Exchange recall works exactly like this; if the e-mail hasn't been read yet, then there's a chance for the recall to happen silently. Otherwise, you get a separate "X would like to recall" message instead. With Facebook Messenger, you're entirely within their platform. You read messages on the Facebook site, or Messenger, and they control it fully. It'd very much be possible to add this functionality.
- giarc 9y agoYes possible, but is it really "what most people wanted." as OP said? I've never heard this from anyone.
- mynameisvlad 9y ago
- merinowool 9y agoSo someone is going to commit a crime, then clears history, asks FB to delete account. Police knocks at FB doors - FB is like "We don't have any information". How is that going to work with GDPR?
- alex_young 9y agoGDPR gives them 3 months to delete anything, so you better plan your coverup well in advance of a knock on the door [1]. [1] https://gdpr-info.eu/art-12-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-12-gdpr/
- Disillusioned9 9y agoSurely there is going to be plenty of other leads they can look to for evidence? Don't see how this edge case is worth permanent surveillance of everyone.
- p1itopre 9y agoIf I do not have a facebook account, does this change anything? There are facebook pixels all over the web. Do I need to continue deleting cookies to stop the tracking?
- PunchTornado 9y agoyou need to create an account on facebook, give them more information about you and then you can delete the data.
- saagarjha 9y ago> One thing I learned from my experience testifying in Congress is that I didn't have clear enough answers to some of the questions about data You bet you didn't, Zuckerberg. And those questions weren't even challenging. Imagine if they had grilled you about tracking pixels and cookies and the Facebook login JavaScript snippets that you encourage everyone to put on their website.
- rhizome 9y ago"It was hard to pretend I'd never heard of community moderation."
- danra 9y agoGreat feature, but not major in the big picture. This (or any other Facebook feature/change) wouldn’t be such a big deal if Facebook weren’t a monopoly which actively takes steps to remain one. Namely, - being a closed platform with no easy way to migrate your data to another platform - buying out the competition As long as the above is true I consider Facebook as acting against its users’ interests, regardless of any specific feature.
- superflyguy 9y agoIf this is GDPR related then it's to do with privacy, not competition. Suppose you did download a bunch of liked pages, friends comments. What would you do with them? Learn python and import it into, I don't know, Twitter or something? Most people aren't actively looking for a way to do exactly whatever it is on Facebook.com using a different URL.
- tripzilch 9y ago> If this is GDPR related then it's to do with privacy, not competition. Yeah but they're very obviously refraining from outright stating "we only do this because GDPR forces us to". > What would you do with them? Federate it in a privacy-respecting way among different services, obviously. And you won't need to learn python, because cool tools to do cool stuff with your facebook data will be popular enough to download as apps.
- pimmen 9y agoI hope clearing this history would give me back the chronological feed, would maybe make me use Facebook more than once every month. I completely missed that one of my old friends graduated, another friend moving to a different country for a new job and I missed one of my childhood friends mourning his lost mother. All three of them had posted updates about it on Facebook but since I didn't interact much with their updates Facebook drew the conclusion that I couldn't give less of a shit.
- MilnerRoute 9y agoI hate how Facebook announces that they're going to release a privacy feature before they actually have. It's like they're trying to trick the press into covering it before anyone can actually test it -- while reducing the actual amount of coverage it gets when it's finally available to real users.
- ddebernardy 9y agoIt's frustrating to distracted readers too. I read the headline and logged into FB on the spot, for the first time in years, with the intent to flush all of that data. But no amount of searching allowed me to locate the button.
- fishmeat 9y ago>It's like they're trying to trick the press into covering it before anyone can actually test it Yep, when big guys like the NSA claimed to delete all data collected without releasing any details, I'm sure at best they drag and drop a few files into Recycle_Bin.
- esbafb8 9y agoSpot on. In marketing, it's called "teasing". Definitely generates more hype and makes them look like heroes...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- foolfoolz 9y agoyou should always delete all cookies on browser close, there’s a setting to do this automatically. also never accept 3rd party cookies. if you want convenience of easy logins save the passwords into your browser
- ng-user 9y agoBetter yet, don't store any passwords in your browser - use a proper password manager.
- cjhopman 9y agoChrome's password manager has a much, much better security record than any "proper password manager".
- 45h34jh53k4j 9y agoWhat? Noo... When you consider the chrome password manager you must consider the chrome binary as a whole. Chrome has had significantly more security issues than 100% of password managers. Of course -- its a more complex set of code. Its about surface area. A password manager that has no browser integration is by its nature less likely to be compromised, as there are far less vectors of exploitation. Don't store your passwords in the browser. Use a proper password manager. How its gets from PM to B is up to your risk appetite.
- always_good 9y agoNot really. For one, anybody that can use your computer can see a plaintext list of your Chrome passwords directly from the Chrome options menu. It's an incredibly primitive system.
- foolfoolz 9y agothis part though we usually have good defense against. how many people are using your computer? do you have a login with a password? do you have FDE? when was the last time you handed your laptop over for someone to use without you being right there? the browser password managers are good enough for most uses
- DannyB2 9y agoDear Facebook: Please clarify. By "Clear History", which do you mean: 1. Delete History 2. Make All history available for everyone to see.
- DesiLurker 9y agoI can almost guarantee that this will end up in FB recording my entire browsing history every-time I use it. I wonder how would the congressional apology for being 'careless' with this feature would go.
- blklivesmatter 9y agoMy privacy protection seems to not clear. Avoid abort leave simply this platform
- danbruc 9y agoI don't get it, how does sporadically deleting cookies help? Sites don't, I assume, store significant amounts of data in them that would get irrecoverably lost. And even for cookies identifying you it should not be too hard to stitch two histories connected to two different cookies back together on the server based on your IP or browser fingerprint. And if they were actually worried about negatively impacting the user experience, why would you not selectively destroy the cookies? Just keep my preferences and give me a new authentication token so that I remain logged in and don't loose my preferences, the browser already has a feature to delete everything. So what am I missing, how is this a useful privacy feature?
- dobs_bob 9y agoToo little, too late
- downandout 9y agoIf a significant percentage of users actually exercise this option, that will be the end of Facebook as a significant channel for ad spend. It will decimate revenue. Most people likely don’t remember this, but Facebook ads were a joke among the marketing community when they were first introduced. I’d have to find it, but one study produced before the Facebook pixel was introduced showed that less than 6% of Facebook advertisers had any kind of ROI from their Facebook ad spend. The pixel is one of a handful of things they created that turned this around - all of a sudden, people saw ads for things they were already interested in. If the pixel is effectively gone, much of Facebook’s revenue will go with it. The recent upheaval over privacy didn’t make me worry about Facebook’s future or the stock price. Revenue was still coming in, and as Eric Schmidt says, “revenue solves all known problems” [1]. But this marks the beginning of Facebook’s end as a cash cow. What does a post-revenue Facebook look like? I would short the stock - now. [1] https://twitter.com/ericschmidt/status/507219358246903809?s=21 https://twitter.com/ericschmidt/status/507219358246903809?s=...
- tripzilch 9y ago> If a significant percentage of users actually exercise this option, that will be the end of Facebook as a significant channel for ad spend. It will decimate revenue. That's what he meant when he said it will worsen your experience right? :-)
- ttul 9y agoWhat choice did they have? Either do this or be regulated and forced to do this.
- ttul 9y agoSaid another way: when you become successful enough, the government becomes a stakeholder in your business.
- oblio 9y agoLooking at the 2008 crisis debacle and “too big too fail”, maybe it wouldn’t be that bad. If your company has an impact on the level of a public utility, maybe it should be regulated like one. And God knows that Zuckerberg’s lifestyle wouldn’t change much if he was only a “simple” billionaire instead of a multi-billionaire ;)
- skocznymroczny 9y agoLooks to me like they only mean the kind of websites, where you allow the application to use your Facebook profile, like Tinder or some minigames so that they can post "XYZ has clicked 1000 times in FooClicker!" on your timeline. This kind of history you'll be able to clear. I doubt they mean the tracking cookies that are everywhere in those "Like" buttons.
- gnicholas 9y ago> Your Facebook won’t be as good while it relearns your preferences. But if I already ignore all ads and promoted posts, then it doesn't matter to me if the ads/promos are "good".
- d4l3k 9y agoI assume this also relates to which organic posts show up too. They use similar machine learning models for both ads and user/page posts.
- gnicholas 9y agoYou’re right — they’re probably going to sweep in all news feed algorithms so it has a profound binary effect. If it just affected advertising and third-party tracking, it would be a no-brainer for people to activate.
- pleasecalllater 9y agoAnd you just believe that the data will really be deleted?
- outside2344 9y agoThis is great. That said, I am trying to figure out how I'm being tricked here.
- DesiLurker 9y agojust give us all your browsing history and we'll delete it for you, nothing to see here, move along.
- textmode 9y ago"Once we roll out this update, you'll be able to see information about the apps and websites you've interacted with, and you'll be able to clear this information from your account. You'll even be able to turn off having this information stored with your account." When the history is "cleared" is it erased from Facebook's storage or is it simply disassociated from the user's account? How forthright is Facebook in telling its users exactly what it is doing? "Citing sources close to the matter, The Washington Post reported that Mr Koum's decision to leave was the result of an irreconcilable clash over Facebook's desire to use users' data for the purpose of advertising, in part by weakening the end-to-end encryption that protects messages from being read by anyone other than the intended recipient." "Jan Koum [WhatsApp founder] leaves Facebook over data privacy issues " there have to be enough Facebook refugees by now out there to build the missile that terminates this experiment in surveillance capitalism - Tim Wu (@superwuster) 1 May 2018" https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/features/facebook-whatsapp-change-privacy-encryption-messaging-app-jan-koum-a8330626.html https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/fe... https://www.cnbc.com/2018/05/01/facebook-messaging-boss-david-marcus-whatsapp-more-open-to-ads.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/05/01/facebook-messaging-boss-davi...
- crashride 9y ago> Zuckerberg also cautioned users against clearing cookies in their browser, saying “it can make parts of your experience worse”, and adding, “Your Facebook won’t be as good while it relearns your preferences.” Sure...
- btilly 9y agoI believe that this feature is required by https://gdpr-info.eu/art-17-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-17-gdpr/. They have no reason to make it a good experience though.
- mgiannopoulos 9y agoI came here to say this. They are required by GDPR to have a way for users to edit and delete all personal data. They needed to built this anyway.
- mk89 9y agoThey are using the law for marketing purposes. I think that other websites too are doing the same.
- mgiannopoulos 9y agoI’m getting a new “we have updated terms of services” mail every day these days. Half of them don’t mention at all that they need to do this due to GDPR. It’s just because they want to give people more options and control /s
- tripzilch 9y agoDid you get the new Facebook one already? Did you enable facial recognition or do you hate blind people? /s (not sure if I should add the /s here; I'm being sarcastic but this is literally what the dialog said, twice. It also threatens you that you will be impersonated by people using your photos, twice).
- mgiannopoulos 9y agoI got the Instagram version of it. They feel they need to have agree for the facial recognition even though there is no related feature on the Instagram app.
- swalsh 9y agoI wish youtube had this feature. I watched a few videos a while ago, and now my "feed" is filled with similar videos. I keep clicking on them, almost instinctively, see what they're about.. then exit, but still. It's annoying.
- wjdp 9y agoYou can remove individual videos from your watch history and this does appear to affect your feed shortly after. On mobile this is under Library > History.
- kgbier 9y agoIt's certainly not very friendly if you want to remove categories en masse from your recommendations, but you can remove videos from your YouTube history list. There's even a search bar. I have found spending the time to purge a certain type of video from that history does improve my recommendations. Additionally, on the home page, you can click on the options overflow on each video and tell YouTube you don't want to watch it, and why.
- Kesty 9y agoYou can already do it on youtube, it's integrated on google activity. https://myactivity.google.com/myactivity https://myactivity.google.com/myactivity
- coherentpony 9y ago> One thing I learned from my experience testifying in Congress is that I didn't have clear enough answers to some of the questions about data. Mark, I can't believe this. Some of the questions you were asked were 'yes or no' questions and you couldn't even do that. While, yes, some of the answers (not the 'yes or no' ones) could have been clearer, there were some questions you just didn't answer at all.
- blhack 9y agoMark is suffering from a pretty classic engineer's problem. Somebody asks what they think is a simple yes or no question, but they either don't understand the complexities of the question, or won't be able to properly understand the implications of the yes or no. For instance: are whales fish? That's a simple yes or no question, right? http://inference-review.com/article/on-being-a-fish http://inference-review.com/article/on-being-a-fish
- coherentpony 9y ago> For instance: are whales fish? That's a simple yes or no question, right? You make a good point. While Mark was presented with a similar situation, the answer to the question, "Are whales fish?" could be, "That isn't a 'yes-or-no' question because [reason]," as opposed to, "I'll have my team follow up with you after my congressional hearing."
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThe latter is safer. I guess it's kind of the same thing as "don't talk to the police" meme in US - everything you say can, and will, be used against you. So correcting malformed/misinformed questions is dangerous, because you may trip up when explaining - or say something that will be misinterpreted.
- null0pointer 9y agoI felt the same. I've never been a fan of his but I have to say, after watching bits and pieces of the testimony, I felt sympathetic for his position. Senators pushing for yes/no answers to questions where there are many many variables and different situations to consider. Pretty much any question on the topic is too complex for a simple yes/no. And it's abundantly clear to me that 99% of the general public just do not understand that at all. Most people (senators included) were just looking for him to say something damning which they can endlessly bring up in the future. I don't believe Mark got into this position out of malice. Facebook just grew naturally over time and turned into the beast it is today. How many times have you been building an app and thought "If only I knew <x> about my users I could provide <really cool feature>"?. Each one of these little steps encroaching on user privacy is small and hard to notice for the users and even for the engineers. But over time they add up and at some point there is an "oh shit" moment where you realise what you have. Yes, some of us have been warning about this for _over a decade_. But the benefits clearly outweighed the costs in the eyes of the users. Only now are the general public starting to realise what the actual costs are.
- hacker27 9y agoGreat idea! Doubt he’ll do it.
- dbg31415 9y agoDoes anyone think Facebook will actually delete this data? Because if so, I've got a bridge to sell you.
- mbostleman 9y agoFor me there is a not a technical fix for the problem. The fact that my feed fills up with ads for something I Googled immediately prior to alt+tabbing to FB is creepy and annoying, but it's not the real problem. The real problem is that I know they have the data (and they still will after I "clear" it) and it can be used for a lot more than advertising. I don't trust them. That's the problem.
- jMyles 9y agoWell, you've described a problem for which this isn't a technical fix, but for which there is a technical fix: a decentralized open source social network on which you retain complete control over which of your data ever enters its ecosystem. And it will come. It will take years, but it will come.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- minor3rd 9y agoAnd then Facebook will buy it and change it.
- mbostleman 9y agoAbsolutely. A distributed system where each user controls their data is theoretically an architectural fix. But not one that is an option for FB since owning my data is the core of their business model.
- 9y ago
- DesiLurker 9y agojust a reminder that there exists an open source mozilla plugin that can put FB in a isolated container so it cant track you around. access here: https://blog.mozilla.org/firefox/facebook-container-extension/ https://blog.mozilla.org/firefox/facebook-container-extensio... Be safe & remember to use a separate browser for porn ;-)
- WindowsFon4life 9y agoSocial Media services are the new HA/RDBMS. No such thing as a Lossy Social Media Service(lsms)
- cal5k 9y agoI'm not really sure what people want from Facebook at this point - it's clear that Zuckerberg is genuinely trying to respond to critical feedback, but there's no pleasing anyone apparently.
- tripzilch 9y agoIt's reaaaaaaally hard to believe he is genuine when the response looks like this: https://i.imgur.com/PCQOo8N.png https://i.imgur.com/PCQOo8N.png
- ionised 9y agoI want them to piss off.
- jnky 9y agoPeople want Facebook to stop following people, especially those signed out or without an account to begin with, around the internet in a creepy way. How hard can it be really? Is it too much to ask that some company I don't have business with doesn't spy on my web surfing habits? The announcement also reads to me as if the "clearing" doesn't even do what people may expect it to do: > Once we roll out this update, you'll be able to see information about the apps and websites you've interacted with, and you'll be able to clear this information from your account. This sounds to me as if they still keep the information and just don't associate it with your account anymore.
- thunderplot 9y ago> Is it too much to ask that some company I don't have business with doesn't spy on my web surfing habits? But FB does not spy you (but itself), website owners do. FB and other trackers are tools, which all the media happily use, bashing FB at the same time. Wouldn't it be too much to ask THEM to stop spying on us? Just checked: theverge - 10 trackers, arstechnica - 9, wapo - 14 (including fb!), huffpost - 11 (including fb). It's not fixable by fixing Facebook.
- pavs 9y agoTheir hands were forced by law, which is why they implemented this. The law itself was created because of Facebook Actions (being one of the main reasons). You are making it sound like he is doing it because of the goodness of his heart, or to please his user. He literally didn't have any choice.
- jageen 9y agoDid or did not he mentioned about what happen to already analyzed data ? What I meant is facebook actually create a kind of DNA per user by analyzing behavior. If I choose to delete my history did it delete my DNA data too ? And what about data analyzed by third-party which installed by one of my friend and have access to my data. Did this feature(delete) will target above problem too ? My understanding is it will not going to be an easy task and if it actually delete all your data what happen to advertisement business ?
- trumped 9y agoDoes this clear all of FB's, NSA's and advertisers' servers? or only what is visible to Facebook users? Note: This is not really a question...
- sriram_iyengar 9y agoJoke of the day ! Thanks for making my day with the best joke I’ve heard in recent times !!!
- rocky1138 9y agoI've been holding off deleting my account until they've made some major changes which will let me clear out the history first. For all those people who quit too early, there's no obligation to delete anything.
- shogun21 9y agoDoes anyone trust Facebook to delete your data when they say they delete it?
- thogenhaven 9y agoThey dont say they delete it. They say they clear it. I dont think that wording is an accident
- yuhong 9y agoMy essay talks about ad tracking and Google: http://yuhongbao.blogspot.com/2018/04/google-doubleclick-mozilla-essay-final.html http://yuhongbao.blogspot.com/2018/04/google-doubleclick-moz...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- coatmatter 9y agoTo those who are still on Facebook: Is there an easy (script-free) way to hide all past posts from the Timeline from "Friends" yet? Before my deactivation, I tried one of the Greasemonkey scripts but it didn't seem to do anything (maybe I didn't wait long enough, etc).
- igivanov 9y agoThat's for those who have an account a.k.a. "dumb fucks". But what about those who have never had an account but are still constantly tracked, i.e. the rest of us? Not that I believe you would irretrievably delete anything from you surveillance archive anyway.
- garcianat698 9y agoThey want to make us feel that we are in control of our data but at the end, nope.. they're just playing us around.
- zapita 9y ago"Upload your entire browser history here and we will take care of securely deleting it for you".
- Aaargh20318 9y ago> after going through our systems, this is an example of the kind of control we think you should have. No. You didn't 'go through your systems' and you didn't think of this at all. The European GDPR requires you to offer this, at least to EU citizens. Don't pretend that isn't the only reason you even built this feature.
- tj-teej 9y ago"But after going through our systems, this is an example of the kind of control we think you should have. It's something privacy advocates have been asking for -- and we will work with them to make sure we get it right." He does admit it's been asked for in the next sentence.
- oldcynic 9y agoIt's something privacy advocates have been asking for, for years, and Facebook have been completely ignoring them. Generally they have responded with the exact opposite of what privacy advocates would wish.
- newscracker 9y agoRight. If FB really cared about another thing that privacy advocates asked for for several years, it wouldn't still stick to its harmful "authentic names" policy that affects vulnerable people more. This is just FB doing something because it has to, and is trying to use it to prop up its reputation a bit.
- Aaargh20318 9y agoFB isn’t doing this because people are asking nicely, but because it’s about to become a legal requirement subject to heavy fines if ignored. It’s not like they have a choice here. Or are you saying the timing is purely coincidental ?
- marricks 9y agoIt comes off as someone who thinks they’re above the law. “We’ll do what we’re told, but only because we want to” Companies know they’re above the law at this point and are getting more brazen about it.
- bprasanna 9y agoWe will still track you, but now we will give you a better control over what we have tracked! Without tracking and learning about user's preferences FB seem to feel like an empty store!
- lwansbrough 9y agoHmm, now the question is whether I sign back into my "definitely" deleted Facebook account to use this feature, or leave my account as-is under the assumption they actually have deleted my account...
- AiaMD13 9y agoI am so glad there's some damage control after the whole fuss. that means that they actually care and try to improve their mistakes. I see here a lot of negative comments, I don't really understand why though, isn't it what people where asking for, like, improvements?
- tomelders 9y agotoo little too late.
- Markusj1 9y agoIf there's not gonna be a feature where you are able to delete the whole history (and not one post, like, etc. at a time) then I don't see how it's gonna help the users.
- ancymon 9y agoWhat about letting website owners to have like buttons which won't track users?
- valeryB 9y agoI'm glad they are making changes, but I'm waiting for some more. Much more. This small post about the future changes in the face of all the recent events, like the data leak or face recognition feature, leaves me very sceptical.
- titzer 9y agoFTA: "To be clear, when you clear your cookies in your browser, it can make parts of your experience worse. You may have to sign back in to every website, and you may have to reconfigure things. The same will be true here. Your Facebook won't be as good while it relearns your preferences." I call BS. My experience definitely won't be worse, because I will do my best to block all your crap tracking and ads from the start. Also, please stop relearning my preferences, and no, I won't be using your crap to log into websites.
- amelius 9y agoI want a continuous clear-history feature, where every trace of what I do is deleted (including posts and messages) and only the last N days are kept.
- ape4 9y agoI wonder if it really clears 100% of your history. Will it delete all comments, posts, records of who you searched for. Probably not your friends.
- snvzz 9y agoWill they also clear the data for facebook non-users, such as myself?