28 ms·
Stack Overflow Isn’t Very Welcoming – It’s Time for That to Change
- Antonella247 9y agoHey everyone! Ive read a lot about users complaining about the cultural change in Stack Overflow. Maybe you're even also annoyed by that change? Help me find the causes for this change as part of my Master Thesis by sharing your opinion on this matter. Lets work to together on this to keep the unique community spirit of SO alive!:) I would appreciate your help! https://erasmusuniversity.eu.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_9YvdQcryXcdIXkN https://erasmusuniversity.eu.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_9YvdQ...
- lza 9y agoI enjoy reading the problems and solutions but every time I am trying to answer a question I get the "You don't have enough karma" lol. I just smile and move on :)
- homero 9y agoI didn't feel welcome the few times I tried answering questions
- nurettin 9y agoLike you currently can't vote on HN?
- dang 9y ago(The GP comment has been edited in a way that makes some of the replies, like this one, make less sense.)
- ceejayoz 9y agoI'm kinda baffled by this complaint. [edit: OP has completely changed their post.] I'd think most new SO users are looking for help or a solution to a problem. Why was not being able to vote yet so upsetting you abandoned the resource?
- homero 9y agoI tried being part of the community
- ceejayoz 9y agoA user with zero rep can both ask and answer questions. Letting them vote seems like it'd quickly result in voting rings via a bunch of zero rep bot accounts.
- ceejayoz 9y agoPlease don't edit your posts to say something totally different without at least a note. It makes the people who reply to you look like lunatics.
- wvenable 9y agoI got a stackoverflow account once they stopped requiring you to link to a Facebook or Google account but I've never done anything with it. It's seems somewhat difficult to contribute if you're an expert. The site seems to be geared more towards newbies in design and the community is hostile to them. I suspect a lot of people who use Stackoverflow have now used it enough (grown up with it) that they don't have these kinds of problems anymore.
- kardos 9y agoI read OP's point as a new user might want to hit the vote in the "thanks, this solved my problem" sense, but gets a rather surly "your vote is denied until you demonstrate that you are worthy" response. Entirely a relevant criticism given that we're discussing SO hostility here. Edit: OP changed comment while I was writing this; leaving it anyway
- rudedogg 9y agoAlso, comments are prohibited for new users. I ran into this, and wanted to comment on answers I found (noting changes required for new versions of the language), etc., but couldn't. It basically caused me to not help other people for quite awhile until I could finally comment on other posts.
- protonimitate 9y agoGlad to see an active approach is being taken. SO is a great resource and contains some of the best information on the web IRT programming. If there was only one thing I could change it would be this: If someone marks a question as duplicate, and closes, make them provide a link to the 'original' question and a brief summary as to why it is a duplicate. Closing something as duplicate and then forcing the user who submitted the question to do more digging comes off as hostile, lazy, and even condescending. Sometimes the original question is lazy and un-researched, but in most cases it is hard to find the right search term for the problem you have.
- amingilani 9y agoActually, if you browse up to the top, it tells you what question it's a duplicate of. But even I was thrown off a few days ago, when I couldn't find that link after a question I answered was marked as duplicate. It's just bad UX, I suppose.
- Izkata 9y agoAnd even before that, when people are still voting, it automatically adds a comment on the question with the same link.
- abainbridge 9y agoSimilarly I've had my questions being down-voted with no explanation. Or worse closed as "not a valid question" for no good reason. The article suggests that the problem is that SO is too cruel to new clueless users. This isn't how it seems to me. Perfectly valid content gets down voted or closed.
- Operyl 9y agoThat feels like it happens everywhere on the internet. Even here on HN, where you need a significant amount of "points" to downvote comments, you can still just get randomly down voted to oblivion based on a group of people just not agreeing with your content. Sometimes there just isn't rhyme or reason.
- benjojo12 9y agoPersonally, My primary frustration with Stack(Exchange|Overflow) sites is that I _can_ help people there, but I would need to confirm with them with a comment... and I can't because I don't have the points (???) to comment ,but I can answer. I end up closing the tab, If the site won't give me the basic tools to help someone, then what is the point of letting me sign up.
- ygra 9y agoThem accepting your answer is your confirmation. Just answer and they usually will tell you whether it's correct or helpful. Comments should not be necessary in many cases.
- ceejayoz 9y agoI think "confirmation" here means "additional information that confirms my theory so I can write it up".
- metalliqaz 9y agoYeah comments are probably meant to talk about the actual post, while answers are meant for the problem.
- minimaxir 9y agoAs relevant context, the impetus for this post was likely this Medium article + initial tweet, which received replies from SO leadership: https://medium.com/@Aprilw/suffering-on-stack-overflow-c46414a34a52 https://medium.com/@Aprilw/suffering-on-stack-overflow-c4641... As an aside, if anyone has a good heuristic to identify bad behavior on Stack Overflow, I'd be interested in looking into it since SO data is public. (please do not suggest "build an AI to identify toxic comments")
- nanis 9y agoHere's something she complains about (she posted a screenshot of a comment): "If the error says line 49, it tells you exactly where the problem lies. If you post 7 lines of code here, we clearly cannot tell you what the problem is in line 49." [1] I see nothing wrong with that. As luck would have it, today some random stranger recognized me from my Stackoverflow profile at a Panera and asked me to help him debug his Django app. It was straightforward to fix because the error message described the problem exactly, but, for whatever reason, it wasn't apparent to him. I pointed this out, explained the problem, and showed him how to look for additional information based on the error message. Maybe this sounds softer in person, but there is nothing wrong with reminding people to pay attention to error messages, and the importance of giving people adequate amounts of information when you ask for their help. Now, as a person who's answered many a question on Stackoverflow, I've had people threatening physical harm to me and my loved ones, as well as setting up Twitter accounts to harass me. To their credit, Stackoverflow admins always take swift action when actual harassment occurs. However, Twitter and Facebook seemed rather uninterested. [1]: https://twitter.com/aprilwensel/status/974859164747931650 https://twitter.com/aprilwensel/status/974859164747931650
- Karunamon 9y agoThis also struck me - as far as some of the treatment I've seen and read about on SO, this is downright courteous. She didn't provide enough information to actually answer the question, so literally what the fuck did she want?
- 9y ago
- jaghaj662 9y ago>Too many people experience Stack Overflow¹ as a hostile or elitist place, especially newer coders, women, people of color, and others in marginalized groups. Women consider SO an elitist place? People of colour? What colour? Black? White? Marginalised groups? Which groups are those? Are people in SO hostile to Palestinians? Amputees? Such an accusation, where's the data to back it? I'm white and male and completely normal and let me tell you: everybody in SO behaves like a stuck-up twat to me. This has nothing to do with "diversity". Too many people are there sitting in a throne of points and medals and rubbish, closing comments and questions and editing whatever they see fit. The truth of the matter is that you've had a code on conduct for a long time and everybody ignored it so this post is not going to change that. Why don't you just change the braindead voting system?
- damagednoob 9y agoYeah, I mean seriously. SO is hostile to everyone. Seems like needlessly jumping on the diversity bandwagon. I used to participate in SO but also stopped because people were answering questions faster with better quality. That's a strength not a weakness.
- lopmotr 9y agoHow does anyone even know what color or sex someone is on SO? Seems like those people are either imagining it or they're generally intimidated by programmers and their typical arrogant or blunt attitudes everywhere.
- ceejayoz 9y agoI saw an example a while back of an SO question about "how should I store gender (sex) in a database". Conflating the two may alienate or upset a transgender individual, without the participants in the Q&A ever being aware of that person. Maybe they're a new user with no ability to comment to point it out, and they just head elsewhere from then on. Similarly, if minority groups are more prone to imposter syndrome, it may be that aggressive and blunt answers impact them disproportionately. In both of these cases, it needn't be intentional or directed at any particular individual to have a disproportionate impact on a group of people. Just as a group can get a reputation of being a "boys club" without explicit "no girls" rules.
- lukev 9y ago> Feelings have no “technically correct.” They’re just what the feeler is telling you. When someone tells you how they feel, you can pack up your magnifying glass and clue kit, cuz that’s the answer. You’re done. This is such an important point and missed so often by technical types. Impressed to hear it stated so clearly here.
- fortythirteen 9y agoI'm sure no fan of dismissive, know-it-all programmers, but to play devil's advocate, who's injecting their feelings into a site with the explicit purpose of solely answering programming questions?
- favorited 9y agoI think any tool which facilitates communication between 2 or more humans will involve emotions. I'd guess it's certainly likely to be the case on a forum for technical Q&A, for multiple potential reasons: - the questioner and the answerer might have vastly different levels of experience & therefore struggle to exchange ideas in terms they both understand - people might already be frustrated when they ask a question, since they may have already invested a lot of time trying (and failing) to solve a problem - multiple answerers are competing to be the endorsed answer, and there are rewards associated with it
- s73v3r_ 9y agoFeeling get injected into everything, because we're all humans with feelings, not robots.
- freeflight 9y agoBut that doesn't mean they should dominate everything we do. Feelings shouldn't control us, they can guide us sure enough, but the moment they control us we might just as well climb back up the trees and go back to angrily flinging poo at each other.
- 9y ago
- dionian 9y agohas anyone here ever seen women or people of color treated poorly on SO? I haven't but maybe I'm not paying enough attention
- asdsa5325 9y agoI have not.
- bdcravens 9y agoI have not, but I think the point they're trying to make (but don't really agree with) is that of cultural norms, or more specifically, the cultural norm of overly-assertive, insensitive nerds (most of which who are younger white males), so that it's an unwelcoming environment to outsiders.
- commandlinefan 9y agoBut most actual programmers are Indian, not young white males...
- bdcravens 9y agoProbably true, but even shifting the demographic mix (with a large % of interactions on SO still being white male) is male Indian culture and communication style inclusive towards females and other groups? I may be off-base, but my experience is that Indian males are very point-blank and strongly assertive in their communication style, so the underlying assertion about inclusiveness would still ring true I think.
- nagVenkat 9y agoSome personal thoughts: I got downvoted for answering some simple questions at stackoverflow.com for encouraging low quality questions. This was discussed in the article. I can see why some people can get hostile as some questions are framed as please solve this for me. Usually people ask the posters to tell them what they had done but the tone of that request can be harsh. I think the elitism is most prevalent in stackoverlow. The other stack websites seem less hostile.
- Pamar 9y agoAbout your last comment: I respectfully disagree. I dabble in a handful of other stack sites, but the only one I have some real experience with (apart from SO itself) is the one devoted to tabletop roleplay gaming. (I have a score of ~3500 on SO and ~2800 on RPG - i.e. respectively top 7% and top 13% just to give you an idea). On the RPG site, especially in the last couple of years at least, there seems to be a certain fanatism among moderators in sticking to the most literal interpretation of the "rules" (e.g.: if a question is about "what system you would use simulate movie X?" it is strictly verboten to answer unless you describe having extensive experience with the system you suggest). Rules and "quality" are fine, except that while I can understand that SO is used almost exclusively for job-related questions, so the quality of a question can potentially cost you much... I doubt that anyone will have their career ruined if they pick the wrong edition of D&D to replay Game of Thrones or - perish the though - miss some important errata on elvish footgear when creating their next character. (I also dabble in a few more, like japanese language and martial arts but they are either less strict in general, better mannered or maybe there is so little traffic that moderators have no reason to obsess about "quality").
- pugworthy 9y agoHave been down voted as well for the "easy ones", I sympathize. Not all stacks are elitist, but some definitely are. I like the slow pace of some of the little ones like Arduino, etc.
- gavanwoolery 9y agoI think "being nice on the internet" is typically a learned skill, unfortunately. That said, sometimes comments that appear scathing are actually warranted criticism - perpetuating "bad" knowledge can be very harmful to the person using it and to those that use their products or code.
- ceejayoz 9y agoSome of the active users in the PHP tag (where I spend some time) have pre-made snippets for common issues, like SQL injection, deprecated function use, etc. On really problematic code, this can lead to a stampede of comments, each mentioning a different issue with grim wording, which can be really unwelcoming even if they're completely correct.
- dang 9y ago> I think "being nice on the internet" is typically a learned skill That's really true, not repeated enough, and much deeper than it appears.
- metalliqaz 9y agoFrom the linked article: > Too many people experience Stack Overflow as a hostile or elitist place, especially newer coders, women, people of color, and others in marginalized groups Breaking that down... "...people experience Stack Overflow as a hostile or elitist place..." This is obvious just by looking at the discussions that happen here, or, even by observing the SO-related memes that bubble up to the top of Reddit programming subs. I have commented on it myself. "...especially newer coders, women, people of color, and others in marginalized groups." lol what? Like most programmers, I use SO practically every day. I don't post much because that's usually a waste of time, but I land on SO from searching for errors all the time. I cannot recall ever, even once, seeing someone's race, sex, or orientation being mocked or even mentioned. As far as I can tell most users don't have full names or photos on their profiles. So it isn't even possible to know such things unless it was volunteered, and that never happens when asking questions about APIs and whatnot. So what in the heck are they even talking about? I'm glad the issue is getting attention, but justifying like this strikes me as pointless virtue signaling. Perhaps they are trying to stem criticism from their power users who like SO the way it is.
- sremani 9y agoIt is standard silicon valley virtue signaling, by now we should get used to them. In the entire blog, I still did not find what they have actually done to make it welcoming, other than shoving a CoC (pun-intended).
- vikiomega9 9y agoJust to paraphrase, you're asking for more data right?
- kadenshep 9y agoIt's almost like this was directly addressed in the article: >especially the idea that women and people of color felt particularly unwelcome. There’s a weird paradox with bias. Those of us who have privilege, but care deeply about reducing bias should be uniquely positioned to help, but we struggle the hardest to recognize that we are (unintentionally) biased ourselves And this line in your post: >pointless virtue signaling. Really nice recycled talking point. It also strikes at the heart of the above quote.
- WA 9y agoI hate if I help people, provide the correct answer but they never accept it. SO should encourage people to accept the correct answer somehow. Maybe force them to review answers to their questions before posting new questions.
- Ajedi32 9y agoIt's already incentivised: accepting an answer gives you +2 reputation.
- asdsa5325 9y agoI've never seen minorities being mistreated on stack overflow. Does anyone have any examples?
- legostormtroopr 9y agoI don’t believe SO has a field for race, so unless you put it in your profile or username I doubt anyone is even aware what colour you are or country you’re from.
- throwawayrt 9y agoIt was few years ago, I asked a question and posted the code that I had written on a dynamic programming question. I used to keep a public profile had around 2k or so. Dude(with a higher score than I had), left a comment. "You should consider another profession, you don't have aptitude for programming".
- sergiotapia 9y ago
- taw-an 9y agoI'll believe they changed when I see it. Pretty sure it's not going to any time soon.
- crispinb 9y agoWhen I was active on SO I did often see unwelcoming behaviour. Closing questions as being dupes or offtopic, with no explanatory comments, was the most common thing. Infuriating too (and not only to new users) was the proliferation of bad edits, clearly undertaken by clueless people to try and amass points. More of an irritant to me was the generally noisy and poor-quality content. I will only follow links to SO now in areas where I know enough to be able to filter for quality myself (usually it's wanting). From my perspective, the gamification schtick is a failure.
- Randgalt 9y agoI've always felt the problem was the moderators have too much control. A bad or dictatorial moderator can ruin an SO board. Hanlon seems to imply moderator changes but doesn't say anything specifically. So, I'm dubious until this is directly addressed.
- corobo 9y agoChange closed due to being offtopic Honestly I just want them to noindex the questions that are closed so that they stop turning up in Google searches
- ldiracdelta 9y agoI still find great results from questions that the Most Holy Keepers Of Stackoverflow Purity deem "off topic".
- corobo 9y agoOh yeah I more mean the ones where someone doesn't manage to sneak in an answer before the question police get there
- Ajedi32 9y agoThose get automatically deleted after a few months. https://stackoverflow.com/help/roomba https://stackoverflow.com/help/roomba
- corobo 9y agoThat works for site maintenance and garbage collection but it doesn't stop them appearing in search results which is where my problem lies If I see a StackOverflow result in my search I'd wager there's a more than 50% chance it's a closed question without an answer. Sometimes I'll grant if it was marked dupe I may end up finding the answer, but honestly the only visits I really remember are those that are marked dupe and link to something sounding similar but completely unrelated
- politician 9y agoThere seems to be a recent tendency where web-based business that wish to make changes to their platforms cite lack of inclusiveness for the main reason for the change. SO is a trash fire. For everyone, not "women", not "people of color", not "people without color", not "groups". Everyone. It's an openly hostile place where mods close questions unrelated to their expertise based on the whims of those in private chat rooms while belittling the questioner with those "your question was closed because X" explainer boxes. It would be refreshing if they just said something like "We've realized that SO is a hostile place, and it's not better if you just happen to be a white man." If you read their change list, nothing there has anything to do with "identity". It's just a list of very small tweaks.
- weberc2 9y agoI agree that SO has an arrogance problem and the diversity appeal is pandering, but the "trash fire" characterization is too hyperbolic. The site is still immensely useful if suboptimal.
- Karunamon 9y agoSO is a trash fire that has some really great content down in the basement, [beware of leopard metaphor elided]. But the problem is the people on the ground floor that the average new user will run into are, to put not too fine a point on it, a buncha jerks. Great place for finding answers to older common questions, really awful place for asking new ones.
- Someone1234 9y ago> Great place for finding answers to older common questions, really awful place for asking new ones. It might just be me, but I've found it substantially harder to find good Q/As on SO for newer topics and frameworks. You ask about a technology which existed in 2014 and there are high quality detailed posts all about it, with different viewpoints, upsides/downsides, etc. But you do the same with a technology popularized in 2017 (and I'm talking highly popular stuff) and yet slim pickings from SO.
- StaticRedux 9y agoI always thought Stack Overflow/Exchange should have a way to filter questions from users with less than a certain amount of karma and any of those questions/ansers/comments should not be able to be down voted or closed as duplicate or low quality or off-topic (the most annoying close reason). Anybody that gets annoyed by those questions can opt to not see them and focus on higher quality. Anyone that wants to help newbies can. Those people can also be marked as unfriendly or hostile and won't be able to answer newbie questions if they get a certain number of reports. This seems like it would solve two problems: oft-repeated low quality questions annoying users who want more complex help, and encouraging newbies bc they won't be afraid of retribution.
- herogreen 9y agoInteresting idea, but what if not enough people are going to the "low quality corner" ? Also it would be nice to know the current percentage of questions closed because they were classified as duplicate because these would still have to be closed (unless you want the database to explode).
- cpburns2009 9y agoThat, or a spin off as Stack Overflow for Dummies. If I ask a question, frequently it's either too specific to be of much use, or it's too "simple" because I don't have a clue what I'm doing.
- warent 9y agoI've experienced a form of hostility in StackOverflow just recently--as in a couple of days ago. On a whim, I visited the website and answered a couple questions, something I'd never done before. I realized it was actually a lot of fun, so I started rapidly answering the all JavaScript questions I could as they were asked. Suddenly a "higher ranking" individual started leaving comments on my answers that I needed to stop answering certain questions, and only address "well asked" questions. After reading the guidelines, I noted that neither I or the asker had broken any rules, so I commented that I felt I was being treated unfairly, and I asked where I could discuss further since the comments on my questions seemed inappropriate. Suddenly another, even higher scoring person, deleted all the comments and locked my answer, noting that the discussion had stopped being productive. After that, my answers were left alone with no more meta criticism. In my limited experience, it's a bizarre community.
- jamesb93 9y agoThey also outright get rid of questions that people provide good and helpful answers to. I once asked a question about a specific ML technique in regards to implementing in a specific c++ API. Higher ups said that the question was far too broad and against the guidelines, despite receiving at least 5 good answers to my questions before they got to it. They effectively shut up good conversation for the sake of a rule book they probably didn't write.
- lainga 9y agoSame situation as Wikipedia: Absolute power corrupts absolutely - but so does a small, petty amount.
- notatoad 9y agoI think it's significant though that both wikipedia and stack overflow, despite being ruled by petty assholes weilding the smallest amount of power in seemingly the stupidest way possible, have become two of the most valuable references in existence. Do toxic communities produce better content?
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- amelius 9y agoPerhaps they can learn from Wikipedia?
- singularity2001 9y agoAs someone said Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, Stack Overflow is that AND a forum, so needs other tools.
- mmd45 9y agoMy issue with the site is the opposite. Asking a specific nuanced question results in a response of a) tell me what you are really trying to accomplish and i'll answer that question or b) don't do what you are doing. Don't presume I don't know what I'm doing or know the right question to ask. This happens so often and is such a time waster I hesitate to use the site. Their culture even invites it by giving it a fancy name of the "xy problem". Please provide a way to flag a question as "Don't respond with an XY question" or alternatively "I know what I am doing and still have a question".
- the8472 9y ago> Please provide a way to flag a question You can do those with prose. Explain that you know what you're doing. Give an underlying reason that shows that your X is an X. Answerers can only act on a) the information you provide b) heuristics they have based on seeing many other questions. If you do not provide a) then they'll have to fall back on b)
- mmd45 9y agothat invites a debate about the premise. i shouldn't need to justify my constraints. i should be able to pose a problem and STATE the constraints. if you don't believe that my constraints are real then you can feel free to not answer my question but the SO regulars always feel the need to interact even when they have nothing to add.
- the8472 9y ago> if you don't believe that my constraints are real then you can feel free to not answer my question But XY-problems exist and are not uncommon. Overconstrained questions also exist. How are people supposed to know that yours is not one of those without additional information?
- zbentley 9y ago> i shouldn't need to justify my constraints. If you're asking people for free help and to spend their time understanding how their relevant but not identical experiences may adapt to your different-but-related problem, then yeah, you might. If someone, even someone I respect, know personally, and work alongside, comes up to me and says "I need to install a nearly-20-year-old version of MySQL next to a modern software stack; help!" [0], I'm going to ask "why?" and maybe "are you sure there's no other way to approach your goal?" first. Not presumptuously or because I'm sure I know better, but because a) the answer will help me better understand the problem and goal, and b) because sometimes extremely competent, rational people really do overlook the obvious solutions, sometimes for days/weeks spent beating their head against the wrong problem. Sometimes the justification is as simple as "it's a business constraint imposed from above". Sometimes it's a more complex story. Either way, wanting to know that isn't asking too much. [0]: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/47350382 https://stackoverflow.com/questions/47350382
- ewar-woowar 9y agoFirst time I asked question on SO I got a very curt response "this isn't a code writing service" and pretty much told to gtfo, but my question was very much asking for advice about _how to proceed as a beginner_ and I was clear about that. I was explicit in framing a coding a problem and asking for direction, not a solution to my homework. Maybe it was the wrong site for that, but the elitist response, I think the question even got deleted by a mod along with the scathing comment, made me leave and only use SO as a reading resource. Never contributed and probably never will even though 8ish years later I have learned enough to be able to contribute.
- hd4 9y agoReading an ever-increasing number of similar articles I begin to wonder if we have a tech-industry-version of the Overton Window...
- CM30 9y ago> Too many people experience Stack Overflow¹ as a hostile or elitist place True. There's definitely an elitist undertone at Stack Overflow, and the voting system has a huge effect on that... > especially newer coders, women, people of color, and others in marginalized groups. But this isn't true. No one knows anything about a user on Stack Overflow unless they explicitly announce it, and generally my perception seems to be a disdain towards newer members in general, not ones from any particular group. Trying to make this about minorities feels like a desperate attempt to fit in with the 'social justice' sphere, and to virtue signal to people on sites like Twitter. Still, the rest of the article seems fairly sane, and I guess this point stands out above all: > Let’s reject the false dichotomy between quality and kindness Because at the end of the day, we need to kill the 'brilliant jerk' archtype already. No, most intelligent people are not Dr House or Rick from Rick and Morty, and we shouldn't make the assumption that a community has to tolerate that sort of behaviour in order for it to be good. Moderate the community well, stop tolerating jerks because they're 'smart' and fix your voting systems, and Stack Overflow can easily become a great community to be part of again.
- icc97 9y ago> > especially newer coders, women, people of color, and others in marginalized groups. > But this isn't true. No one knows anything about a user on Stack Overflow unless they explicitly announce it, They don't say it out in the open, they contact the SO admins directly or through surveys.
- rossdavidh 9y agoI think the point was that the people being mean don't know the gender, color, etc. of who they're being mean to.
- saint_fiasco 9y agoLook at it from the other side. The person who is getting mean comments tells someone at SO about it (maybe via a survey). Then the SO admins notice that in the surveys women are overrepresented in the population of "people who complain about hostility". Perhaps minorities already get enough abuse and hostility every day on meatspace, so they are less tolerant of even minor hostility over the Internet. Since they have a limited amount of fucks to give, so to speak, they are more likely to leave the site for good after an unpleasant interaction. Think of minorities as the canary in the coal mine. They are more sensitive, so they start leaving the moment the environment starts to become toxic. Left unchecked, the toxicity will grow and push away everyone else too, so you can't just ignore them for being "snowflakes" or whatever.
- ggregoire 9y agoI've been an active user for 7 years… and I lived my very first case of moderator abuse last week. A moderator closed a 1.5 year old question[1] with 20 upvotes, 25 stars, 9000 views and an answer at 28 upvotes without any vote or consultation, because it was too broad for him. StackOverflow has all the tools to allow the users to moderate the platform by themselves, kinda democratically. From my experience, it works and the decisions are most of the time justified. Then it's mind blowing that someone can skip all the closing process/votes and close a well-rated question with a useful answer in his sole opinion. And there is no way to report/flag/discuss a moderator actions on Stack Overflow. You can at least do that on Wikipedia. [1]: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/41250087/how-to-deploy-a-react-nodejs-express-application-to-aws https://stackoverflow.com/questions/41250087/how-to-deploy-a... Edit: the question has received 5 votes to reopen, thanks HN!
- m_myers 9y agoYou can either flag for another moderator to take a look, or (better) bring it up publicly on https://meta.stackoverflow.com https://meta.stackoverflow.com. Most times you'll get an answer from the moderator in question. (Also, that's a... very broad definition of "moderator abuse". The question is still there and no one can post an answer to compete with yours if it's closed.)
- nanis 9y ago> And there is no way to report/flag/discuss a moderator actions on Stack Overflow. Yes there is. See Meta. E.g., see https://meta.stackoverflow.com/search?q=why+was+my+question+closed https://meta.stackoverflow.com/search?q=why+was+my+question+... You can also flag your own question/answer.
- cpburns2009 9y agoThis will be the downfall of Stack Overflow eventually. The rules for question and answers try to be objective and specific, but they end up being too strict and are making the site less useful over time. What they should do is allow broad, general, subjective questions. That would allow for answers with general guidance instead of directly answering a broad question. It would also allow a clueless person to get some direction. When you're working with an unfamiliar technology, you frequently don't even know what to ask. BTW: You can ask a question about it on meta, but based on your question I think the "too broad" closure is technically correct based upon the rules and how they're enforced.
- rhapsodic 9y ago> It was hard to accept some of the (valid) criticism, > especially the idea that women and people of color felt > particularly unwelcome. The article fails to offer any examples women or POC were treated more shabbily because of their gender or color. Does anyone know where this is coming from?
- commandlinefan 9y agoMore than once, I've googled a question, had the top hit be SO, clicked through it to see my exact question asked... with the top answer "haven't you ever heard of Google, n00b?"
- herogreen 9y agoI would be genuinely interested in seeing such a question. That could be a problem due to the search engines giving to much credits to SO whatever the content of the post (It is astonishing to see that if you post a question or an answer it pops up on the first page of Google within 2 minutes !).
- yaur 9y agoAnswering those questions is probably the best way to rack up SO karma.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoThe weird thing about SO is that it's not for answering questions asked by users. It's for pre-emptively answering questions that people might search for later. I know that sounds like a meaningless distinction, but questions can be (and often are) closed for being too specific. Like, "this question is well-researched and well-presented, but you're not allowed to ask it here because it's unlikely to come up for anyone else." That's such a bafflingly bizarre attitude that I really don't know what else to say.
- Pulcinella 9y agoYes there definitely seems to be a very bizarre criteria for questions that I have never been able to parse. I often see questions closed as duplicates of another, when they are definitely not. As you said, I have come across exact questions that I have had, but they were closed three years ago as being too specific. Questions will be marked closed as being “too opinion based” when it’s a question like “why are singletons considered something that should be avoided? Can someone provide me an example of a situation in which using one would be bad?” I feel like the main goal of SO is to close questions without answering them unless someone sneaks in a good answer before it’s closed.
- jpalomaki 9y agoShould they limit the amount of ”moderation” like activities one person can perform? It’s probably not good for the community if there are users who are mainly contributing by performing housekeeping tasks.
- legostormtroopr 9y agoThey do. You only get a certain number of review or close actions per day.
- wwweston 9y agoFor everybody who's questioning the premise that there is some kind of special hostility to newbies, women, PoCs and others, consider this: * How would you know whether there's a difference between the experience of these groups and the baseline level of friction lots of people outside those groups experience? * For the sake of argument, assume for a moment that there is no difference, and what those who feel singled out are experiencing is the baseline friction that they've mistakenly correlated with some aspect of their identity. Then the only way to address the issue is to address that baseline. If StackOverflow does this, it will mean the experience improves for everyone. (If there is a difference, then the experience improves for everyone and the world is a bit fairer.) * Is there anything in the specific list of areas SO has identified for improvement that really seems like a bad idea? - Let’s shift from “don’t be an asshole” to “be welcoming.” ... “I wasn’t just tolerated; I was made to feel like the community was actually better because I was there.” - let’s start by working with the community and our community managers to start flagging and deleting unkind comments now. - Let’s make it easier for new users to succeed. - Let’s stop judging users for not knowing things. - Let’s reject the false dichotomy between quality and kindness.
- commandlinefan 9y agoIt just seems strange to say that a universal hostility is somehow worse on, say, women, than it is on everybody, given that they're admitting it's universal.
- wwweston 9y agoFWIW, it's possible both for hostility to be universal and for it to be harder on some subgroup if either (a) that subgroup tends to be socialized in such a way that they're less equipped to deal with/push back on hostility or (b) that subgroup tends to be more agreeable or threatened by hostility by natural temperament. But overall... it doesn't matter much to me. Reducing universal hostility seems like a positive goal no matter what. Even reducing localized hostility that I'm not subject to means that the potential pool of contributors who might be able to help me or others with problems on SO is larger.
- 9y ago
- viggity 9y agoStack Overflow is naturally full of nerds. Nerds are pedants by nature. Are some answers bereft of friendliness? Of course. Are some answers rude and/or insulting? Sure, there are millions of them, its bound to happen. But how in the hell that specifically impacts women or poc more than a random white male is frankly beyond me. I will say that being curt in some contexts has its advantages for the community. Linus is kind of notorious for being a bit ruthless in responding to various requests/suggestions. You have to be to some regard in order to set a high bar and drive success. I've been on SO since the very beginning and have had my own feathers a bit ruffled by responses I got when I was being sloppy. It drives quality. After a minor rebuke or two, I really try to put as much thought and effort into my questions as possible. I'm asking a group of strangers to solve my problem, I have certain responsibility to make it as easy on them as possible. TL;DR - This exists but effects everybody not just women or poc. It could be more polite, but a bit of harshness drives quality.
- poster123 9y ago"Too many people experience Stack Overflow as a hostile or elitist place, especially newer coders, women, people of color, and others in marginalized groups." Must everything be about race or sex? Yeah, I am a little annoyed that so many of my questions get shot down on Stack Overflow, but other members cannot infer my sex or race from my SO handle. I am a guy from a racial group not under-represented in tech.
- greenhouse_gas 9y agoIt's for several reasons (and why I personally find reddit (of all places!) a much more welcoming and useful community): 1. Points. They're very visible, giving you power. If you want power, you mine for points, and once you earn them, well you worked for your power, you use your power. You are expected by the powers-that-be to close questions for being bad, or for being duplicates, or whatever. In contrast, reddit doesn't focus on points. You focus on the name/flair. So the focus is hanging around and answering questions - in other words, it's more of a community than a way to show off your knowledge. 2. The communities are kept separate. For example, /r/Rust has a different community culture than, say, /r/golang. So they have different mods with different policies. 3. The lack of community moderation means that I don't have to be scared that 5 guys out of 5000 decide that my question "wasn't good enough" or "subjective", closing it. And yes, there are hard-code reddit communities. /r/askhistorians put's history.stackexchange.com to shame in rigor. To write an answer there, you're writing a term paper based of primary sources. So how do they do it? They have a team of moderators. Really, stackoverflow could be broken up into rust.stackoverflow.com and go.stackoverflow.com and python.stackoverflow.com, where each community elects[1] their knowledgeable moderators who know their community and respects them. 3. Unlike reddit, they're not trying to solve my problem. They're trying to be a large database of answers[2]. A wikipedia of programming or something (which is why duplicates are not just pointed out, but actively closed, and why "open ended discussion questions" are closed). The problem is that I'm not interested in that. I'm interested in getting my question answered. Now if you don't want to answer my question, that's fine. But it's up to the asker. [1]. Another point - community elections means that there's politics involved. reddit allows one to easily fork a community, so if a significant group of users don't get along with /r/linux, they can fork and make /r/linuxos or something.
- porker 9y agoPoints are damaging, especially the way they've done them on StackOverflow. It's fine for anyone who got in on it in the early days, or cares about collecting them. But to make a better community the points need to decay (exponential decay preferably) so there isn't such a power imbalance. This would incentivize everyone to gain points by being helpful, rather than enjoying being an 'authority'.
- koala_man 9y agoI think there's a strong selection bias that makes newbie questions generally sub-par. If you know enough to do research and make MCVEs, you'll likely rubber duck your way into a solution instead of posting a clear and well formulated question. This is why you get a pile of "Unable to checksum downloaded file" type questions with a 30 line code dump and vague "doesn't work" comment: All the users who instead narrowed it down to their `if (sum="foo")` or `if [[ $sum=="foo" ]]` or whatever pitfall their language has will already have googled "how do I compare two strings" and discarded their draft. I don't have a good solution, but I'm happy about the article's "new “beginner” ask page that breaks the question box into multiple fields". It'll help ensure all questions have actual/expected results, and the code section will hopefully clear a path for applying static analysis.
- j45 9y agoStackOverflow initially was very, extremely warm and welcoming. It's mission to replace the dodgy EE was noble. Through natural daily interaction with the site (more than HN), built up a karma at 5K+. Why I found myself using it less? The community aspect remained undefined and once the post police got a hold of the site, they interpreted the site to be only a technical reference, where technical discussion is allowed, instead of also a reference for soft skills and decision making that also were very popular. Although asking such a question today will get the post closed, some of the insightful questions about how to approach software architecture, or a specific problem, continue to ironically generate me karma there.
- tqi 9y ago"...serves a valuable purpose by keeping signal high, but also suggests that we just might be Zuckerbots who aren’t even trying very hard to pass as actual humans" A snarky dig at someone in a post about how SO wants to be less mean and snarky is an interesting editorial choice.
- wool_gather 9y agoYes, this VP's disdain for Stack's core users is long-running, deep-seated, and intensely hypocritical.
- smsm42 9y agoIt's a frustratingly common thing. People think that talking about tolerance and inclusion and being more welcoming gives them personal permission to be rude, mean, intolerant and unwelcoming - maybe because they thought they already earned enough "credits" so they can afford this behavior? Or that they are "on the right side" of whatever, so it's OK to do what they just were publicly decrying doing - to the people "on the wrong side"? Scott Alexander wrote an excellent blog post about it: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anything-except-the-outgroup/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anything...
- hguhghuff 9y agoSo much could be fixed simply by removing downvoting, which is no different to a virtual slap in the face or shout of abuse. SO already has a variety of mechanisms for identifying issues with questions, why does it also allow people to yell random abuse without explanation via downvotes? The most disheartening, but completely expected, result of posting a question is that it will be very rapidly downvoted...not welcoming at all. AND everyone gets this face slap upon posting a question, but I can see how minorities might feel that are being singled out by the sites typical negative response to pretty much all questions. Sadly, even here on HN you can almost feel the joyful glee with which people can anonymously knock something down with downvotes and no need to explain. Downvotes on SO should either be removed entirely, or it should cost 2 SO points to make 1 downvote. Downvotes are nothing but pure negative, so hey, wanna remove some of the negative from SO? It’s obvious what to do.
- ldiracdelta 9y agoSneering comments from neckbeards are worse than downvotes to me. Some days are just Monday and you're not on your game, but that doesn't stop the neckbeards from trying to light you on fire, despite the fact that you spent 30 minutes massaging the question or half a day agonizing about asking the question. You know the neckbeards are lurking in their basements.
- grzm 9y ago> "Sneering comments from neckbeards" Condescension, like any other dismissal, can be rough and is definitely detrimental to communication. That said, I encourage you to be the change you want to see. Name calling as you've done here, and snark, as you've done elsewhere in this thread, similarly degrade conversation and communication.
- ldiracdelta 9y agoI'm not directing this at anyone in particular and so I will use "bad", yet colorful, words for people behaving bad. No one is going to read these comments and think they are the neckbeards, but most people who have participated in Stack Overflow have interacted with a preening, sneering neckbeard and neckbeards are indeed a problem on Stack Overflow.
- Slippery_John 9y agoIt's hard. I used to answer regularly, but it's draining to have to sort through a flood of bad questions. Rather than turning into a jerk, I just gave up answering. I feel like the cross-section of people with lots of domain knowledge and people who have the personality to let them gracefully triage questions for extended periods is tiny.
- Someone1234 9y ago> We set them up for failure, and our power users have been asking us to help them for ages. Your Power Users are the ones making SO toxic. They don't need better tools, they need to have their privileges pulled until they learn to use them responsibly. The whole "SO is an encyclopedia not a help site" thing started this, and it encouraged a lot of "content curators" to the site, who view their role as squishing every question unless it meets their personal editorial standard (Wikipedia has this too but IS an encyclopedia!). This post feels hollow. It is nice they're taking blame, but SO is still rotten at the core, the site needs something akin to a constitution setting out what the purpose of the site is. Everything else should flow down from the site's core purpose, not up from rules and "more <3!!!" Is SO a "help site for newbies" or a "encyclopedia of programming knowledge?"
- deviationblue 9y agoThe problem is that there is already such a wealth of information that exists on SO, that some of the beginner questions I had starting out never needed posting. So I can imagine a similar scenario for someone else, and hope that they do a little searching around before posting. Sometimes you need to use 2 or 3 tangentially related posts together to see the bigger picture of how the question you were going to ask relates to the problem you wanted to solve. I mean, learning has always been that kind of tortuous process. Maybe there needs to be a separate place on the site that's primarily help for newbies.
- bmn__ 9y ago> the site needs something akin to a constitution setting out what the purpose of the site is I assert this already exists, laid out in the inaugural blogs posts and formally codified in the tour and help centre.
- TravelTechGuy 9y agoIt's funny reading this article after seeing one of my questions from 2011 edited today, to remove the word "Thanks!" from the bottom. I've been on SO since 2009. I can confirm the community is getting harsher, less patient, and more exact. HOWEVER, I can see the other side. I see tons of questions that are not fit to be on the site: one-liners, opinions, "help me with my homework", and utter spam. Not to mention people who clearly did not search the site, or even Google (many of Google's results come from SO), and ask a simple question asked a thousand times before. Bad questions and answers will stay online indefinitely, coming up in your future Google searches. There has to be a balance. Comments should be less hostile, but posters should vet their questions before asking. Perhaps the suggested structured form is the right way to go. If people will take some time to document their effort, and code, they'll gain appreciation for the time spent by someone reading their question and providing an answer. PS: +1 on using Zuckerbot in an article not about Facebook :)
- pishpash 9y agoRatings already take care of curating. Why do you need assholes to curate?
- Ajedi32 9y agoSame reason why HN has both up/down votes, and actual moderators.
- singularity2001 9y agoAnd the reason is ... ? What's wrong with comments just being grayed out, collapsed and moved to the bottom if they are downvoted for being (too) stupid / trolling / fascist etc? Moderators could just have more voting power.
- singularity2001 9y agoOK reading the Medium post [0] I see that toxic comments were the starting points here, not the rampant practice of closing questions for dubious reasons. [0] https://medium.com/@Aprilw/suffering-on-stack-overflow-c46414a34a52 https://medium.com/@Aprilw/suffering-on-stack-overflow-c4641...
- sli 9y agoA lot of people are not getting the diversity angle, so I want to call attention to a comment in this thread explaining it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16935683 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16935683
- edpichler 9y agoThis phenomenon (hostility for newcomers and down voting good and polite comments) also happens here on Hacker News. We (the human being) that must be fixed.
- ggg9990 9y agoWebsites that build knowledge-based status hierarchies naturally end up being dominated by insecure know-it-alls.
- JorgeGT 9y agoA site whose founder banned greetings isn't very welcoming, go figure. https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/93989 https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/93989
- deft 9y agoWill this stop the closure of questions that are legitimate and haven't been answered? Whoever is moderating and deciding which questions deserve legitimate answers is the problem. Everyone is snarky and bossy and can't just answer the damn question asked. I've noticed this on pretty much every developer help site, instead of answering what I asked they try giving advice... I know my issues better than they do, and the implementation details shouldn't matter. In some cases it's obvious someone is doing something wrong (let's say rewriting built-in string functions) but those cases are rare. This article addresses NONE of the complaints I've seen against SO. You're basically saying "we will be nicer and more inclusive!" Who told you that was the problem, because it isn't. The problem is the mods/power users/unwritten rules.
- bitL 9y agoNote to myself: Stack Overflow is done. When political overtone and insane mods dominate a platform, it's over. The amount of non-sensical bans/closings of sensible questions or answers etc. recently is getting out of hand; now using "privileged", "bias" etc. rhetorics from official top management means C players made it to the top, as that's the only way they can compete, by making everybody around feel guilty. If you complain about hostile environment in computing, go work in finance or retail for a few years.
- ajkjk 9y agoUgh. I find the use of `<3` in sentences so incredibly off-putting and fake, even in an otherwise well-intentioned point. I imagine that it's not just me. It's gross and corporate when Github does it in their "hosted with <3 at Github..." as well.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ryeguy_24 9y ago"You're driving our car wrong." This blog post is all about how the users need to alter the way they use the product. I've always been a firm believer than software should be intuitive and should influence the users to use the software in the way the developers want. If you want users to act more kindly and welcoming, incentivize that behavior. Some ideas for SO: - Create new reputational incentives for kindness - Offer the kindest users a vacation and write an article about them from time to time calling them out for acts of kindness - Allow newbies to report unkind behavior which would hurt reputation of the offender - Create workflow to assist the elite users in dealing with frustrating questions/answers/comments (a button to say, "It would help us if you clarified the question" would help eliminate a comment that says "You don't make sense idiot")
- wvenable 9y agoThat's interesting since Joel himself made the point about how software design influences community in 2003: https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2003/03/03/building-communities-with-software/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2003/03/03/building-communiti...
- pelasaco 9y agoEVP of Culture and Experience lol
- legostormtroopr 9y agoWhat the StackOverflow company fails to get is that their product is assholes and industrial level asshole production. Every question is moderated by volunteers, who have curated every high value question there. From an askers perspective, sure you may have asked 1 slightly off-topic question, but for a reviewer, that’s the 30th off-topic question today - and SO gamifies reviewing so you are encouraged to do so. I used to be on StackOverflow and had high enough rep to access nearly all of the moderation tools. The quantity of garbage that gets submitted daily is astounding. And when your contribution to the community of high quality content is keep quality up you get tired of saying “hey can you please add more code” for the 100th time and just hit dupe. Because if the asker isn’t trying, why should you? Ultimately, this leads every reviewer to become an asshole, because to keep up with the quantity of rash coming in you need to be.
- singularity2001 9y agoGood explanation, but what's the purpose of deleting duplicates and "off-topic" questions other than saving some SO storage space? Edit: IMO closing duplicates makes sense, IFF users are asked 'does the linked duplicate answer you question' and confirm. Deleting only makes sense in case of exact duplicates, otherwise they might be useful variants worth linking.
- Izkata 9y agoClosing duplicates has multiple uses: * Directs the asker to a place where their question has already been answered. * Trains the user to search for an answer instead of blindly asking. * Gets new answerers to put their answers all in one place so it's easier for others to find later. * Not deleting it acts as a signpost for people searching on more variations of the same question. Closing off-topic questions should be obvious: Prevent scope creep and limit the "broken windows" effect.
- wool_gather 9y agoThe general policy is exactly as you've described: duplicates are pointers; they are not deleted. That said, some queries reach a point where they become FAQs ("Why am I getting a NullPointerException?" being the canonical example) and at some point, there's diminishing returns from yet another search target for it.
- sharpercoder 9y agoOne thing with reputation systems which is not accounted for I feel in many websites, is that higher reputation must translate to higher responsibility. It's nothing other then the good ol' "With power comes responsibility" adagium, also known reversed as "Power always corrupts". In my humble opinion, there should be also a system that ensures increased power is applied correctly. SO does not have this, and that's a major problem.
- bitL 9y ago"Alright, I am a white male. I started programming when I was 10, winning programming competitions as a kid, after years of hard work, sleepless nights and study, heavily postponed pleasure and significant relationships, watched with disbelief what other teenagers do instead of working on their future, I am now suddenly privileged and biased, because I try to answer Stack Overflow/Reddit/etc. questions straight to the point, and somebody instead expects that I will provide them with complete answers including encouragement for free, instead of them working hard on acquiring the necessary skills. Then I get blamed that somebody felt bad about themselves, and suddenly I am the problem." Now why would anyone with this profile want to contribute to Stack Overflow ever again? What's the point? They should just shut up, keep their knowledge to themselves and instead offer $2000/month training courses to those "less privileged". Instead of getting beaten for their generosity and wasting time answering badly formulated questions. Specifically the solutions talked about will bring massive toxicity to the platform.
- golemiprague 9y agoIt is unbelievable the amount of garbage they throw at people who contributed so much to society. What other industry creates so much free stuff like the horrible programmers with their open source and free tutorials all over the place? I think this is actually the problem, the programming culture is too open and permissive, all you need is a laptop and an internet connection to make your mark on the world. But people don't want that, what they want is a certificate and status. That's why you see so many women doctors and lawyers, they would rather go through a system which whisk them from one point to another and protect them with certificates than doing something themselves.
- z-tech 9y agoI think part of the problem is reputation points. People are so competitive for no reason about having the best answer that they're fine writing nasty notes about the next person's comment. I'm almost wary when I see an applicant with high SO reputation. It's like, you probably had to walk over a lot of people to get this.
- Kagerjay 9y agoI have 400ish reputation on stackoverflow Everytime I ask a question I automatically expect it to be downvoted to hell, get marked as duplicate, "dont post your homework", etc. Doesn't really matter how well I try to phrase the question either. You can't please everyone and some of the mods go on powertrips I treat SO simply as a potential place to get feedback and search for answers to issues I am facing. It sometimes comes at a cost of salty responses, downvotes and hostility but the pros outweigh the cons.
- alkonaut 9y agoI think the whole moderation thing is completely opaque. Last time I discussed this, and suggested some changes involving various "queues" and "waiting areas" for review etc - it turned out most of this already exists. There is a whole secret machinery behind the facade that somehow is hidden from users. I have been a user for years and never seen that. As far as I can see there are votes, close votes, and then questions just disappear. When I see a poorly worded question, I might comment with some suggestions for improving the question, then immediately start writing an answer. Before I'm done with the answer, it doesn't matter whether the asker had improved his question. It's probably already closed. That is to me one of the biggest issues, The "race" nature of Stackoverflow. Did you find an easily answerable but unanswered question? Don't write a good answer, write a quick one. Then maybe improve it. If your answer is the top one, you'll get upvotes forever. If it's the best one but stuck at the bottom - no upvotes. Same with questions. If your question was poor for 5 minutes, but is later fixed? Sorry. Closed. I just I don't get why the system wants to encourage someone to write the same question again, rather than improving one? Worse, it seems moderators fall in this trap: it seems to be a rush to find things to moderate. They have so successfully gamified the notion of moderation and cleanup that it's now also a race. A suggestion: if there is any kind of point system, statistics, badges or anything like that - hide it from the mods themselves. It just shouldn't be gamified.
- marzell 9y agoOne of the biggest problems, if not the biggest, for people in tech (especially new CS students, etc) is knowing how to ask the right questions. There's several 'layers' of tech-speak that people learn (or not) to adopt, and many ways of asking essentially the same question. These practices of gatekeeping, being opaque, and failing to practice patience and interactive dialogue on SO are extremely frustrating, and cause the system to fail to support some of the people that most stand to benefit from the community. It creates an attitude of elitism, and while I see how these attitudes can be self-serving for the karma elites, and help create a perception of the community being concise and clean. But it leaves many people falling through the cracks, and when questions aren't answered within 3-5 replies, the threads are often locked, deleted, and otherwise 'swept under the carpet'. For this reason, I don't contribute to SO at all anymore. If it comes up as a result in a Google search when I need help with something, I'll use the info made available, but otherwise I'm intentionally just a leech because I don't feel it's worth navigating all the negative aspects in order to contribute. Edit: I do hope that the changes and attitude they've outlined in the OP blog post do help resolve a lot of what I've just described, and I do intend to re-evaluate my opinion after enough time has passed for real changes to manifest.
- s2g 9y agoI had hopes based on the title, but... > Too many people experience Stack Overflow¹ as a hostile or elitist place, especially newer coders, women, people of color, and others in marginalized groups. Maybe that's a problem. I don't know. I'd rather see them address the problem of rampant question closures for dubious reasons and people who like to treat questions like a damn medium post. edit: Okay so reading further that is what it's about. What the hell does it have to do with minorities and women? oh they told them they feel less welcome. Did they say why, cause I don't see it here. This just feels like dressing up a very real, very broad problem as an issue for women and people of color so they can get extra bonus points by focusing on it.
- singularity2001 9y agoI agree that they should not focus too much on minorities when SO is hostile to everyone. > rampant question closures for dubious reasons That is the biggest problem
- abakus 9y agoI second that. They are avoiding the real problem by pretending to fight for social justices.
- s2g 9y agoI think they see the problem, they are just dressing it up. It's a tough problem, since community moderation of this sort seems to almost inevitably lead to some individuals who take it on themselves to obsessively shape the site to their own warped vision. Wikipedia has the same issue. Reddit avoids it by fracturing into small communities, and poor modding leads to death (or alt-right infiltration, ugh). If they want to say it is worse for women and minorities, which could be entirely true, then my worry is they just try to bring those groups up to the often shitty baseline where perfectly reasonable seeming questions get closed meanwhile others have people rushing to provide a lousy answer so they can later expand it into overwrought 1000 word answers.
- monksy 9y agoI actually wrote about this in 2012. It's still one of the most popular articles that I've written today: http://theexceptioncatcher.com/blog/2012/09/stackoverflow-is-a-difficult-community-to-participate-in/#.UEu2l1DNwcU.hackernews http://theexceptioncatcher.com/blog/2012/09/stackoverflow-is... Their issues aren't due to particular identity politics. It's been this way for a while. Original HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4494016 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4494016
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kapauldo 9y agoEveryone's a hall monitor on SO, reveling in their power to mark stuff as off topic. It's maddening.
- Gene5ive 9y agoThe support department for the software company I work for basically gave up having a dedicated team to answer SO questions because the endless bad attitudes we encountered made it not worth it anymore. Support means encouragement and we didn't want to encourage people to interact with us on SO if it meant bringing potential customers into a hostile environment.
- Keyframe 9y agoOne (maybe interesting) approach would be to reset points and power every so often. Once or twice a year? For past achievements have them as a badge inside a profile of a user, not visible on the comments/answers section. That way, users would have to keep working at maintaining their power status. Not like it's now, grind to the status and act like a roman senator.
- mike00632 9y agoThere seems to be a clear solution: sandbox all questions. Allow 'dumb' users to ask 'redundant' questions and be answered by helpful people who 'encourage such behavior'. Then let the zealous content curators search for sufficiently original or 'valuable' content to add to the archive. Also, if they're going to blame bad questions on bad searches then perhaps they should rework their search algorithm.
- Zamicol 9y agoI've had very negative experiences on Stack Overflow, especially when the "answers" are blatantly wrong. There's little one can do to correct it.
- iliketabac 9y agoYawn. Privilege. Women. People of colour....yawn. Getting a bit boring hearing this lame virtue signaling everywhere...
- Insanity 9y agoIt's one of the main reasons I stopped answering questions on SO. I got about 4.1k 'rep'/'points' or whatever they call it, mostly just from old answers getting upvoted. I tend to visit SO when google brings me there, but personally I prefer looking in the docs or asking in IRC (though it depends on the channel), rather than deal with asking a question on SO again. An interesting thing is that this does not seem to be network-wide, there are parts of the stackexchange network that seem much friendlier and more welcoming to new users.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- waydowntogo 9y agoI tried answer questions the best way I could and I had nice respond from asker mostly like it BUT there was almost everytime some smartass (with higher points than me and voted down my answer) who had some problem with that - bad words or word-order (i'm not kinding); too short answer etc. So I left. I wanted share my knowlidge but they didn't wanted them. Now admins/owners are crying. Just epic!
- LandR 9y agoI got an answer downvoted for helping someone and snarky comments about how I shouldn't have helped him because the person felt it wasn't a good enough question. There was enough info the question to allow me to solve his issue, ok it wasn't a great question, but it was good enough IMO. I think his entire question ended up getting deleted and with it my answer.
- ruirr 9y agoHave you considered using any point in time a spelling checker? With that atrocious grammar you won't get many people liking your posts.
- forapurpose 9y agoI hope you stick around HN, regardless of your command of English. High English proficiency isn't in the HN guidelines - most of the smart people in the world don't speak English at all! The one violating the guidelines is the other commenter who criticized you; please don't let them ruin things for the rest of us. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ruirr 9y agoI did not get out of my way to talk about his command of English, he is the one mentioning it about problems in other forums. I am not native, however if in an English forum, I will have to talk English. Otherwise, nothing prevents me from selecting forums in a language I am more proficient. Beware of the extremism in being politically correct. The truth will always be the truth.
- bcoughlan 9y agoI got downvoted to oblivion the first few times I asked questions on Stack Overflow. It made me review the FAQ and rules and do my utmost to make it easy for the people donating their time and expertise to help me. You know what I do when someone is mean to me on the internet? I roll my eyes, have a chuckle and get on with my day. Stack Overflow has a huge problem in the last couple of years with the amount of unhelpful comment spam by karma junkies who know very little about the problem area. There is a problem of declining quality in answers, as answerers have abandoned the site because of frustrations with the low quality of questions. SO was never designed for beginners. It was designed so that a good question can produce canonical, definitive answers that benefit thousands. Total beginners benefit more from a back-and-forth style to grasp concepts as traditional forums or chat communities cater for. If they blame their declining utility on the conduct of the users waiting for the admins to do something about the ongoing Eternal September it will be their downfall. Thankfully I am past the generation that has embraced the idea that having your ego bruised is the worst thing that can happen to you, so I'll just roll my eyes and move on.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ryanpcmcquen 9y agoStack Overflow is a reflection of most internet communities, which show that many people are assholes.
- cpeterso 9y agoGitHub solved their "thank you"/"me too" comment problem elegantly with the heart and thumbs-up emoji reactions for comments.
- flas9sd 9y agoI'm sure if the aggregation of all gathered points in user-profiles will be abandoned or "toned down", some of the powerplay will cede, because it will be about good answers only and helping each other out, not personalities. I benefit from that community alot, thank you to everybody who is contributing.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- singularity2001 9y agoIf SO is listening, do one thing: Stop closing questions! It is incredibly frustrating.
- janitor61 9y agoEven if it's a hostile environment, I do have to give credit to Stack Overflow for killing expertsexchange... that site was a plague
- throwaway613834 9y ago> I’d encourage you to take these implicit bias tests, specifically the Race IAT and the Gender-Career IAT. If you’re like me, they’re going to hurt. Hurt, and possibly needlessly so. I would also encourage reading about the flaws of said tests: https://qz.com/1144504/the-world-is-relying-on-a-flawed-psychological-test-to-fight-racism/ https://qz.com/1144504/the-world-is-relying-on-a-flawed-psyc...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- biocomputation 9y agoSuper useful community in some ways. Like many others in this thread, I was more or less scared off by super users. I know quite a lot about GLSL, shader programming, and GPU tech, but my experience was similar to what others describe. I answered questions that were 'poorly asked' or 'not constructive' and found that threads were locked pretty quick. But on the other hand, there's a ton of great stuff, and a lot of users have invested serious time providing extremely helpful answers. It's a really bizarre place.
- joeax 9y agoStack Overflow needs to be broken up into smaller, baby SO mini-sites (Bell telecom style) focused on separate lagnuages or stacks, like one for Node, one for .NET/C#, one for databases, etc. It seems they are headed this way for some disciplines like game dev and Unix/Linux, but they need to take it further and shut down the main SO site and migrate questions to these smaller sites. The site as it exists today is just one big monolithic mess with too many busybodies making it awkward for everyone else.
- simonblack 9y agoThe only time I use Stack Overflow these days is when Google takes me directly to a single question and answer. Way back when SO was new, I actually had quite a few karma points from my answers. I stopped going there/using it/answering questions when I was being denigrated for doing so by some elitist dickheads. I continue to deliberately stay away.
- dig247 9y agoIMO I don't think SO can bounce back in any real way. Years ago I even attempted to engage on Stack Exchange and it was the same uppity BS in a garden/home improvement setting. We are all often times simply trying to learn and share. There is no one single, authoritative source. Millions of people have probably felt the same way after posting or researching an answer. It is really sad. It could have been great. HN can get a little tight at times but all in all it is 100x better in terms of takeaway for the user. I guess my only gripe with HN is it has a touch of that "uppity, d*ck, unwelcoming vibe" due to calculation of points. I feel like if an individual has honestly tried to engage/add value and posts/comments 45 times and has a score of 12 they will give up with a bad taste in their mouth. Not everyone fairs well with that kind of thing. It is hard to navigate the world let alone coming into a space like this and getting crushed by a bunch of anonymous handles. All in all it has a similar impact on a user/readers reaction to their early engagement with the community. Obviously some of us have thicker skin and some truly believe they are snowflakes...Can't win 'em all.
- mesozoic 9y ago"especially newer coders, women, people of color, and others in marginalized groups." I can see how you can tell someone is a newer coder on the internet by their questions. But how can anyone possibly tell if someone is in a "marginalized" group unless they go about broadcasting seemingly because you want to claim some greater virtue. The internet was created by misfits (today called "marginalized" I guess) where everyone was accepted based on their ideas and no one knew if you were a man, woman, dog, or dolphin? It seems that it became popular and the real world just brought it's problems with it. on_the_internet_no_one_knows_you_are_a_dog.png PS If you're wondering if the implicit bias test is real. It isn't. It is fake science. https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-false-science-of-implicit-bias-1507590908 https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-false-science-of-implicit-b...
- tomkinson 9y agoMost accurate statement ever. 65% MOD problem, 10% newbs, 10% bad programmers that think they know and their way is the only way, and 15% policy. IMHO
- suavesav 9y ago>> (It serves a valuable purpose by keeping signal high, but also suggests that we just might be Zuckerbots who aren’t even trying very hard to pass as actual humans) Why randomly attack Zuck? That is such an unnecessary meanness in an article about being nice to people :(
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bsder 9y agoFor me, the bigger problem with Stack Overflow is simply that it is not aging well. There are a LOT of answers that have huge numbers of upvotes that are simply wrong--mostly because things change and evolve. SO is good for something which just came out in the last 6 months--anything older than 3 years needs to be treated with extreme skepticism.
- fahayekwasright 9y agoPeople are such thin skinned whiners nowadays.
- kizer 9y agoAs long as they get rid of “marked as not a real question”. Completely meaningless and the first instance of “hostility” that comes to my mind.
- bigger_cheese 9y agoI attempted to use Stack Overflow about a week ago. In regards to a Javascript problem I was having. I do not know this language very well (at all) When it comes to JS I am deinately a newbie. I kept on getting "undefined object" when I was trying use return value from an (external) library function. I could see in web browser debugger there was data but it wouldn't let me return. All the top results in google involving the libraries name + undefined object were from Stack Overflow and they did a decent job of explaining why I was experiencing the issue (in my case I was trying to mix synchronous and Asynchronous code). However pretty much all the suggested solutions were misleading - they all talked about using something called a callback. I found a blog post buried among the other google results that had better solution - to use something called a "Promise". After doing some more googling I found out the Promise syntax is very recent (added in 2017) and the answers I was looking at from Stack Overflow were all from 2011-ish so rather frustratingly Stack Overflow was full of outdated information. The old topics were locked and I could not edit them so no way of helping other new users like myself who might be running into same issue - especially given these answers appear so high in google it was a frustrating experience.
- jacobush 9y agoTrue but you could add your own answer.
- beevai142 9y agoThe problem with stackoverflow is that answering questions sucks in the long term, for most people. It's basically an user support job, and if you are not suited for that sort of job eventually you start to lose patience with fools, of which there is no shortage on the internet.
- 6t6t6t6 9y ago> Too many people experience Stack Overflow¹ as a hostile or elitist place Agree > especially newer coders Totally agree > women, people of color, and others in marginalized groups. What the actual F*?
- askvictor 9y agosee https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16935488 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16935488
- VikingCoder 9y agoFrom an old Reddit post of mine: Your reply has been Cursed to Hades for not being stack overflowy enough, even though it was the accepted answer, and has received hundreds of votes. Also the whole question has been Excommunicated for not being mumblemumblemumble enough. Even though it was the highest voted question of all time, with thousands of responses from beloved members of the community. You both should feel ashamed of yourselves. -by Vlad The Impaler, Feb 2 '14 at 20:41 https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/2c59xe/what_i_learned_from_answering_questions_for_30/cjc8pr9/ https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/2c59xe/what_i_... I love that they wanted to be an answers site. I hate that they forgot sometimes the answers people desperately need are, "What do you think is the right way to do this?" Or, "What's your favorite solution to this problem?" It could have been another Stack Exchange site, sure. But they just didn't do it. And they should have.
- compsciphd 9y ago
- qwerty456127 9y agoI can hardly imagine how can StackOverflow be specifically hostile to women or racial minorities. I have never witnessed anybody being rude to another person for just their gender or skin colour there. Do anybody even care about who the author of a question or an answer is? A question is either interesting or nonsensical or normal, an answer is either useful or not. I don't think many people care to explore the author profile to write a gender/racially-specific answer/comment, also nobody is forced to disclose their race, sex or real name on StackOverflow AFAIK. At the same time all the "question quality" stuff seems a purist loon crazy well beyond reason. There are many highly-upvoted and much-bookmarked questions that are reasonable and interesting and have useful, highly-upvoted answers but get closed and deleted for stupid reasons so only high-rank users can see them. As for me I use to upvote (and hurry to answer if I can) reasonable and valid questions that others vote to close out of pure protest.
- stankypickle 9y agoThis is just all sorts of ass backward rhetoric that misses the point of Stack Overflow. People don't go to SO expecting emotional support. They expect answers to their questions.
- sureaboutthis 9y agoI thoroughly disagree that SO is hostile to "everyone". I've been there for nearly nine years and find that the only people who complain about such things, as listed here, are those who never took "The Tour" and aren't aware of the rules for asking and answering questions as out lined in the Help Center. I rarely ask questions anymore but, when I did, they have never been downvoted or questioned because ... I follow the rules ... but too many people come their and treat it like a forum (it's not) or like (shudder) reddit. That's when they get themselves into trouble. I'm a high rep user and visit every day. I don't answer many questions anymore because, nowadays, they are mostly about canned software (CMS, frameworks, etc.) and not real programming. So I help clean things up and I'm one of those guys who lets you know when you've violated the rules. "Can someone give me teh codez?" is my favorite. Believe it or not, it gets asked every day and I help close at least three every day. And I get irritated.
- nottorp 9y agoThe fact that SO isn't a forum any more is a problem because it has stopped encouraging learning. If you can't discuss the problem, all you'll get is canned answers for copy/paste monkeys. And then you'll wonder why you can't hire a competent programmer any more...
- sureaboutthis 9y agoSO has NEVER been a forum. That's where most people are confused. It has NEVER been a platform for open discussion.
- nottorp 9y agoPerhaps, but it was more useful when they didn't enforce that. My recent experience with SO is: i reach it via googling a problem or feature, I find a question describing my problem that is closed because of being a duplicate of... ... except the other question isn't a duplicate in subtle ways and has nothing to do with my problem. I've also seen moderators encouraging people to post answers as code ready to copy paste instead of answers helping the recipient to learn something. How is that useful?
- lanbanger 9y agoI recently had one of my questions that "Closed - opinion based" six years after I asked it, and received several useful answers. I consider StackOverflow read-only these days, it's years since I've bothered to ask anything, and I definitely don't bother to answer anything.
- chx 9y agoAnd this doesn't talk about how smaller StackExchange communities become a toxic fiefdom of their moderators.
- Lazare 9y agoI think they've identified a major problem with the site, and I wish them luck changing it. I was a very early user of Stack Overflow, and racked up a bunch of karma long ago, but I fairly quickly felt pushed out. I felt that the site became less useful as a place for me to get answers, and I felt that it became much less welcoming as a place for me to answer questions. Much of that revolved around the increasingly militant gatekeeping and arcane rules the community adopted. Nowadays, I mostly run across Stack Overflow when someone links a fascinating question thread which will - invariably - be locked for being the "wrong" kind of content. (Because of course it is.) It is a bizarre, broken community, and one I don't think is meeting its original goals. (And I say that as someone who had what was, back in the day, a pretty high score.)
- hyperpallium 9y agoUnfortunately, you can't legislate kindness. The best you can do is harness jerks - that's what capitalism does; that's what stackoverflow does. The problem is high-karma jerks, because "maybe they are right to be a jerk about your helpfulness" and you can't do anything about them anyway. Traditional clubs/organisations like Rotary International, masons, toastmasters, churches or even AA might have more insight on making an organization welcoming, yet preserving rules. I would love it if copy and forms could have at least some impact, so looking forward to see how this goes.
- citilife 9y ago> Too many people experience Stack Overflow¹ as a hostile or elitist place, especially newer coders, women, people of color, and others in marginalized groups. First part sure, last part.. No one knows who you are on Stack Overflow unless you make it known, so no. I don't think marginalized groups are treated any different, although perhaps they may take more offense. Now, if you said something like: Vim is the best. Perhaps that could be a marginalized group, but in reality, I don't think that's what was being discussed.
- saltyoutburst 9y agoThis is a very long-standing problem that Stack Overflow has had so it's good to see them taking it seriously (regardless of whatever the underlying motivations may be). How long-standing you may ask? Here's my answer from _2010_ to https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/481/whats-the-single-biggest-barrier-to-entry-on-stack-overflow/50282#50282 https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/481/whats-the-singl... I feel sorry for the poor n00bs who come here thinking it's awesome, ask a seemingly innocent question, and then get shouted/voted down for asking a dupe and not searching properly before they asked. And yes, I said 'shouted down', because despite what a lot of experienced users many think, that's what it'd feel like for a new user who's unfamiliar with the S/OFU culture.
- duxup 9y agoAs a noob learning programming one of the issues I see isn't as much hostility as it is the people who seem to vote the most already know the answers. This creates a bit of an issue at times where folks who know the answer and appreciate an elegant solution provide an answer that while 100% correct... also doesn't tell me much about WHY it is correct. I'm sure it is obvious to the voters, less so to me, and a lot of the "it worked" responses from the people asking make me think they just cut and pasted and I'm not sure learned either. Having said that there are great people who provide multiple answers in their response with some detail. I don't expect a novel, but I do really appreciate those responses.
- mbfg 9y agoI'm curious, how do you know a persons ethnic group or sexual orientation, or other categorizing group on stack overflow, unless you the person wants that information out there? I can certainly understand some responses and/or behavior are troublesome, but i don't get the tie in between the bad answers tied to certain groups. Their certainly can be a superiority complex problem, but it seems to be more around people's sense of their mastery of a language, or technology, or coding style or whatever. I certainly haven't traveled to all corners of stackoverflow but have contributed a good bit, and yes, my java is better then your java (or whatever) is present, but is it really tied to people's identities?
- twblalock 9y agoThey can start by accepting that a lot of the good answers on the site are outdated and aren't applicable to current versions of the language or software they pertain to. Stop flagging questions as duplicates when the question they are supposedly a duplicate of is 6 years old.
- zxia31 9y agoSO's culture is one of the most toxic among all communities. People hesitate to ask and hesitate to answer. Announcement like this is more like a "will fix" comment. The key to solve it is to change the mechanism of some SO's rating and comment.
- kichuku 9y agoI really appreciate the SO team in bringing this up and considering this as a priority issue. Many people have been the "third group" as mentioned by "sigstoat" above, just because of the hostility. >there's also the third, silent, probably much larger group, who neither asks questions nor answers them. >it seems as though the single authoritative, comprehensive answers is what helps those people the most. I hope something good comes out of this effort from the SO team. However, I just hope that this effort to be lenient though doesn't lead this site from being a fairly reliable site for learning purpose, to becoming "Quora 2.0". i.e far too many duplicates and far too many low-quality questions, that it actually drives away the current expert crowd away from the site.
- swyx 9y agoI like the idea of a Beginner box. Github is doing the same with issue templates. I would suggest going one step further - give a “question quality” score made up by some algorithm that SO controls. could be machine learned, could just be a bunch of rules like a Linkedin Profile score. Gamify asking great questions, not just answering.
- wool_gather 9y ago> give a “question quality” score made up by some algorithm that SO controls This exists, and in some cases the evaluation results in some JIT help for the poster. In other cases, it puts the post into a "Help and Improvement" queue where more experienced users are waiting to suggest (or directly make) improvements.
- swyx 9y agook well double down on it. put a big honking number and an incomplete pie chart that yells at you for not achieving a 100% score on your question. subtlety is wasted on this stuff.
- wool_gather 9y agoWorks for me!
- justinzollars 9y agoI've noticed this for years. As an early member of Stackoverflow with many internet points I've abused my privilege to reopen "bad questions". As someone who started his career in technology as a community college chemistry instructor, I've never been a fan of shutting people down when they ask a question.
- d--b 9y agoIt's easy to say that SO is a hostile place when you get downvoted or closed for asking what seems like a perfectly fine question. This happened to me a couple of times and is pretty infuriating. But it is also annoying to try and give back to the community and find newbies who are at times extremely rude and ask "do you haz teh codez" questions. That's why this issue is so difficult to tackle. As an answerer, I downvote questions that are not well formed because I do not want other answerers to lose their time looking at that question. I personally believe SO lacks "triage" for incoming questions. Not every c# answerer should read every c# question. A new question may be marked as "for triage" (maybe this step could be skipped for users with some reputation), then reviewed as such by some community members. Badly formed questions would go into a bin for helping the user differently than a normal question. other questions could be sent directly to super user, code review or computer science or what not...
- interfixus 9y agoWhen I end up on StackOverflow, it's almost always from something I searched on DDG. I haven't compiled a statistic, but it seems like most of the actually useful answers I find there belong to questions marked as not a good fit or whatever took some snarky moderator's fancy that day. So all too often, even if get my question answered, I leave the place with a net negative impression. And don't come back except if directed by DDG.
- tziki 9y agoThis is definitely not exclusive to stackoverflow. Math.stackexchange has the same problem, and from what I've heard, so do many other sites of the same format.
- cup-of-tea 9y agoLooks like another community is about to get ruined in the name of social justice.
- PeterStuer 9y agoIsn't this the natural evolution of long running public discussion sites? In the end, the 'Netiquette Nazi's' [1] take over. Because some might be willing to push back on them, but eventually, the proverbial 'never wrestle a pig, you both get dirty but the pig loves it' will assign victory by attrition. [1] http://web.archive.org/web/20080701090858/http://redwing.hutman.net:80/~mreed/warriorshtm/netiquettenazi.htm http://web.archive.org/web/20080701090858/http://redwing.hut...
- Lapsa 9y agooh. hoped for something substantial, worthwhile. Jon Skeet attending pride parades unfortunately isn't that. early StackOverflow model was way better (the one w/ code golfing, silly joke questions and whatnot). it was like one ring to rule them all - THE resource for programmers, flooded with brilliant minds. now it's just a boring directory of some answers full with zealots. continuously degrading in quality.
- KnightOfWords 9y agoI see it as a systematic problem: When everyone's a moderator there is a trend towards the strictest interpretation of the rules. If five moderators take a look at a post the first four may see nothing wrong with it, but the fifth may still flag it.
- bambax 9y ago> only to be told that on Stack Overflow, “please” and “thank you” are considered noise I don't know if this is still in place but it should be stopped. Saying thanks to someone who helps you is the most natural thing in the world, it's something normal humans do. If you forbid it, then you become an unnatural place, a weird place that feels weird and uncomfortable. You also become a kind of cult, where insiders know and accept how to behave weirdly. And cults are very unwelcoming to newcomers (kind of their point, actually).
- Chyzwar 9y agoIn my opinion SO is not very useful. The longer I code less likely I search SO. I prefer to read docs, search on issue tracker or just read the source code. I think SO is mostly for "noobs", people that are asking how to add two numbers or use jQuery plugin. For me, it would be more useful if answers describe alternatives, big O and more context. Most answers just suggest copying few lines of code. Even for juniors, it is not good and just slows down growth.
- stillsut 9y agoGive me a 'noob' view of answers: Disregard (or even reverse) super-user downvotes on answers, and never delete anything other than spam. Motivating example: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/5664741/watching-variables-contents-in-eclipse-ide https://stackoverflow.com/questions/5664741/watching-variabl.... My first time trying to develop an android app in Eclipse, I had no idea a GUI-based app like Android could print to console, and assumed console and gui are mutually exclusive. I was trying to debug a large existing codebase in a very rudimentary way. In this question you'll see an answer that didn't really help me at +94 and the answer that did help me at -1. Five years later, sure, that -1 answer is self evident. But at the time, that was the key to get me started on altering the codebase to my particular ends. It's like a recommendation algo on Netflix: don't tell me what the most sophisticated film critic thought was the best movie if all I do is watch Pixar films; tell me what the best film was according to other Pixar movie enthusiasts was.
- ivanhoe 9y agoIt's hard to make a balance between "anybody can ask anything" and "usable for professionals to quickly find the best solution". In my (many) years online I've seen a number of great dev forums becoming popular and then quickly becoming overwhelmed with newbie chit-chat and same questions asked over and over. And I don't mean there's anything wrong with it, it's a natural progress of things, there's always many more beginners at any given time so they overrun the space and that causes the level of discussions to water down. Of course beginners deserve their space as much as anyone else, if not more, but problem is that interests of those two groups don't overlap much, you just can't a balanced mix of newbie and advanced topics that both side will appreciate equally, it never works. I think it's the best (only?) solution to draw a clear line, make SO Start and SO Pro, and then relax the rules on the Start side, and make them more strict on the side meant for experienced users. And of course, don't tolerate assholes on either side. Just my $0.02.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- coinerone 9y agoAnd He said: "There can only be ONE Question and ONE Answer in this World of Code!" - Stackoverflow Answer LVL 5000+ BTW: I have registered at least 3 Accounts to ask silly programming Questions when i was beginner and Stackoverflow managed to kick me in the motivations everytime i was stuck at something.
- tradedash 9y ago>We trained users to tell other users what they’re doing wrong, but we didn’t provide new folks with the necessary guidance to do it right. What makes you believe that YOU know how it should be done? I am not saying that people shouldn't be nice but over and over and over we see these tech companies embark on social justice missions to set guidelines that end up backfiring because they underestimate the complexity of the range of possible human behavior. At best, rules generally dont get enforced equally and at worst they become a disaster that affects the inner workings of what made the site worth visiting in the first place. And this right here tells me what to expect will happen in the future > the nice thing about problems that relate to how people feel is that finding the truth is easy. Feelings have no “technically correct.” I love stack overflow and would hate to see it devolve into something that deviates from what it truly is about: code.
- nottorp 9y agoI stopped even attempting to answer questions on SO (most of the time i wasn't succeeding because it seems to be full of full time reputation builders that copy/paste examples as soon as a question is asked) when I noticed that "teach the man how to fish" answers are discouraged, called "too generic" and other crap. Only ready to copy/paste answers that just give the man a fish seem to be encouraged.
- Rainymood 9y agoThe problem, and I'm personally guilty of this as well, is that sometimes you have a small quick problem and you're stuck. You quickly whip up some text and post it to stackoverflow. Then you get aweful reactions because you didn't put enough effort in your question and SO isn't going to make your homework. The point is that a lot of people have quick and dirty questions and don't need a full answer of half a page. All they need is a push in the right direction but SO is exactly not what that is about. SO is a site for detailed questions with detailed and high-quality answers. The point is that there are a lot of "low-hanging" fruit questions and SO is the best place to go, alhtough it is not meant for that. There should be like a StackOverflow for "bad" questions. If someone asks "How do I append to a list in python?" it wouldn't be closed but someone could just comment "read the #$# manual (link to docs here)".
- thinkingemote 9y agoI find IRC to be best for quick and dirty questions. But there's still etiquette and finding the right room
- kabacha 9y agoAs a pretty big contributor to stackoverflow I feel that this is getting blown out of proportion. I'll usually go extra mile to help someone out but I like my time and the platform to be respected. I often feel that people either expect for their minds to be read or are just bad at explaining there problem. I don't think SO community has to carry the burden of teaching people how to request help - I think it's a skill you earn by trying and failing. Sure your question got closed and someone pointed you to "how to ask a question" FAQ - just reformat your thoughts try again! It hurts nobody. A lot of other issues like racism, sexism are pretty much unheard of so to me it seems like this article is very much just to pander some recent threads.
- jgtrosh 9y agoI pretty much agree with the sentiment, but it seems to me that what you're condoning (i.e. showing what was done wrong and then the culprit will try again and improve) is problematic for many newbies. Think of the many students in math class who fear the idea of being told they're wrong more than the actual problem. I enjoy building a work environment where I can be expected to be corrected and I can safely correct people, but that is not a given in a public forum. I think the answer is to enable newbies to partake in a try-fail-try cycle but in a much more forgiving/inviting environment. The difficulty is in improving/designing that without sacrificing the overall quality of the forum.
- ruirr 9y agoAs all the walks in life, you find everything and every culture. On one hand you also find people who simply want answers, however do not want to make the minimum investment in time writing something decent, and then you also find kids. I have had Indonesian kids going after my linked.in or fb profile and asking me for a connection. (Sorry, no kids in my fb, except if family)
- k__ 9y agoThey have the Wikipedia delete-nazi problem. First they wanted all content, then they started to go for quality, whatever that means. But the culture they built doesn't change as fast as the shareholders like, often it never changes and they lose users to a new service.
- GenericsMotors 9y agoA good rule of thumb for asking questions on StackOverflow is to only do it as a last resort. And then, put effort into your question: - explain clearly what you've tried, and how it didn't work - link to other resources that appear on the surface to be the answer, but really aren't because of x, y, and z reasons. - provide code! don't just dump a metric tone of it in the answer though, provide only what is necessary to demonstrate the problem. if for some reason you can't provide the actual code for IP reasons, try to reproduce the problem separately with a very minimal example. for larger code samples, linking to Github gists or repos is a good idea. I've asked very few questions over the years, and one of the main reasons is because I ended up finding the solution myself; the steps above force you to review your own work thoroughly, and lay out the problem clearly, so you might catch a mistake that wasn't obvious after cursing at your screen the first time around. For those questions that I have asked, I've never been downvoted or had the question closed; at most no replies but that was it. If readers see you put in effort to ask a question, then they are also more inclined to put in effort to help.
- LandR 9y agoExactly this. I've had a couple of issues I've wanted to go to stack overflow with but in the process of clearly elucidating my problem, I've ended up solving it / realising what my issue was. Too many low effort questions make SO a pretty useless place nowadays IMO.
- IanSanders 9y agoMinorities part is nonsense in my opinion; apart from that I can see both sides of the problem. It is definitely an issue the way community treats new users. My guess is that when going through review queues, one gets into that mode. On the other hand, it would kill the website if it was drowned with low quality duplicate questions and vague questions with no details - which are asked and closed constantly. (Just look at what superuser has become)
- telltruth 9y agoThere is a time that arrives for many companies where they stop being from cool, fast, creative, whimsical to... well, just collection of business suits. So first consider the fact that this is written by Jay Hanlon, EVP of Culture and Experience. When you see titles like this for individuals working in full time position at about the highest level of executive staff, you know what I was talking about. To confirm my fear, I looked up if this EVP guy actually has account on Stackoverflow. All I can find is jhanlon with no real profile, no contributions and no real activity. So we indeed have a suit who has no first hand experience with the product, it’s culture or experience. In typical fashion of suits, this guy also stays on the safe side of “be kind” without ever diving in to details, pro and cons, data or real remedies. If Joel is still running this thing he needs to wake up.
- jsmeaton 9y agoYou don’t think he’s involved in this process? You don’t think many of the employees are? Who do you think hired the EVP of culture. Joel is currently writing about this same issue. There’s a problem. Data backs this up.
- wool_gather 9y agoThis, so much. Jay Hanlon is the single worst thing that has happened to Stack Overflow, hands down. His relentless focus on inclusion is all form and no function: making things seem nicer, without addressing the actual painpoints experienced by all users, new or veteran. Those painpoints engender frustration and lead to the hostility that comes from both sides. For all his insistence on the primacy of people's feedback, he completely ignores and dismisses the concerns of existing, engaged users. Whatever gains have come from the the means he has chosen come at the very real cost of the expertise that makes the site useful. Eight, even six, years ago, when you clicked that link from Google to Stack, you got your answer, first time. Now you're lucky if you can find it among the broken code masquerading as a task-oriented question and copy-pasted answers that reply.
- wool_gather 9y agoHis account is named jaydles (last I knew, anyways).
- thom 9y agoIt's very difficult to be optimised for people Googling in their hour of desperation, while also being a community between the rest of the time. I have to admit that I'm somewhat hypocritical, in that I get angry when I see Wikipedia-style policing of content, but I also appreciate when I land on a well-edited, general-case answer to a problem that I'm having. I don't think I've generally ever been disappointed with the Google-optimised workflow, but I've never cared much about scoring points on the site itself, and I only very rarely have to ask a question.
- DougBTX 9y agoRandom idea: replace the terminology of "duplicate" questions with "similar" questions. Add a mechanism where, if an answer could apply to two very similar questions, show the answer in both places. Rather than closing a question as a "duplicate", add UI to group "similar" questions, eg, rather than filtering out "duplicate" questions from search results, instead show "similar" questions as groups, with the "best" questions and answers shown first in that group. The "best" way of asking a question may well not be as it was written the "first" time. Or phrasing another way, remove the "older is better" bias. Another example: currently, a new user, unfamiliar with the site, comes along, asks a basic question that has been asked a hundred times, and they ignore the "related questions" prompts. The community reacts by down-voting and closing their question, pointing to a better question. How about instead of "related questions", the question was immediately responded to with "related answers" instead? Rather than being snubbed for asking a simple question, new users would be encouraged by getting a quick response. As the questions would be grouped and the answers shared, low quality questions just wouldn't get much upvote attention, and could likely would get filtered out of searches and lists of "hot" questions, as they wouldn't be the best in a similar group of questions.
- wool_gather 9y ago> Random idea: replace the terminology of "duplicate" questions with "similar" questions. This is not at all a bad thought, and it's a perfect example of something that Stack (company) could have tried to actually address complaints rather than just papering over them and telling users they're too mean. Addressing the actual UX issues would do far more to improve interactions than just policing language. Unfortunately, we've gone around the sun many times with plenty of smart proposals like this simply being ignored by the company.
- talltimtom 9y agoA side note to the article. We really have come full circle back to the mid 90’ies. What’s that LEGO unicorn doing in the middle of the article? I might as well have been a flame gif. It’s just a random “I thought this was cool so I put it right smack in the middle of everything”. Naturally it is much more calculated today and ofcause it is aimed specifically at popular memes... buck back in the day flame gifs where popular, and one day we too will grow tired of unicorn-everything and doge memes. Some faster than others.
- talltimtom 9y agoInteresting that they are not doing the extremely simple technical change that would help out with a lot of the unwelcome signaling: removing negative scores. There is absolutely no value in a post being -10, it just tells the poster that 10 unkind people disliked the individual for not knowing the answer to his own question. Just let new questions sit at 0 if no one upvotes. New inexperienced users should not feel like they are being put on display for stupidity when they ask questions for fear of it being a duplicate something trivial or what else.
- q12we34rt5 9y agoAllow me to translate the article: All you assholes that have been blessing our site with your free content and gotten us at number 1, 2, and 3 position on the first page of Google in every country and made us untold millions of dollars, guess what? We don't you no more. You aren't cool and trendy and you won't get us any likes on TwitFace so shove off. We have a new demographic.
- merinowool 9y agoFor me Stackoverflow long time ago has stopped being a place to get answers. I'd rather explore problem on my own using books, documentations rather than search on Stackoverflow or ask there. Low content quality and hostility of the users is what drowned this what used to be useful site.
- nojvek 9y agoTo add a comment you need points, to get points you need to answer questions. Answering questions is a really really challenging thing to do because for all sorts of things you'd get kicked out. Not only that, but I went into negative because someone didn't like my answer about Typescript. That was it, I just use stackoverflow when google shows me a result. I won't contribute to it, because its ridiculously difficult unless you make it your mission to get over the hostility from elite users.
- svick 9y ago> Answering questions is a really really challenging thing to do because for all sorts of things you'd get kicked out. You're not going to get kicked out if you honestly try to answer questions.
- wiseleo 9y agoI answered more than 7000 questions on Quora with a heavily enforced Be Nice Be Respectful policy. My monthly pageview count is hovering around 200,000 and I have a lot of followers in addition to the Top Writer title. These questions often started vague and incoherent because the asker did not know the vernacular for that problem domain. It is very frustrating to be unable to express the question in a way an expert can understand. As an expert, I wrote an initial answer and asked the poster to clarify the question. Once we clarified the question, I would re-write the question and incorporate some of the comments into my answer. Other experts can then answer the improved question without spending mental energy on parsing its meaning. Quora has a feature to comment on questions and not just answers, but it has been well-hidden on the mobile device despite my many pleas to make it more visible so we can improve the question before writing an answer. Have you ever tried to describe an automotive noise in sufficient detail with enough precision so a mechanic can diagnose the problem? They can communicate with each other easily, but most people don't have that knowledge. That's how it is for non-expert programmers attempting to ask a question on SO. So, they ask it on Quora instead. :)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cmcginty 9y agoI think it would help if they placed more limits on how much one person can interact with the site at a time. If you are someone that sits on SO for 8 hours a day every day, then there is a high correlation you become one of the people that starts driving new/casual users away. I can imagine other improvements but all would hurt the site popularity in the short-term. Enough that I doubt SO would ever implement them. This is probably at the core of why the reputation for SO continues to worsen over time. Hopefully they can turn it around since the core features of the site are invaluable.
- epigramx 9y agoThe simple reality is that most moderators on the internet are 18-24 year-olds that are still too much into a teenage ego trip. More mature people are often more busy with work or they just don't give a fuck. That's why the only fora that are fun are either vote-based or almost entirely unmoderated.
- voidr 9y agoSO is a website where people ask technical questions and get technical answers, by default nothing about a users identity is exposed. This posts just looks like a a poor attempt at jumping on the whole "helping the marginalized" bandwagon without actually helping or doing any research. > Let’s do something about comments. Condescension and sarcasm have been reluctantly tolerated in comments for too long. We’ll research possible feature changes, but let’s start by working with the community and our community managers to start flagging and deleting unkind comments now. I'm sure there will be no backlash from what used to be their core user base.
- ftarlao 9y agoGiving more constructive comments/directions to newbies is important but I think that an high threshold for questions is still mandatory in SO. Majority of people are lazy and don't like to think deeply or search first and.. it is normal for this lazy people to protest; rewards and punishments are needed for a society to work. About the discrimination part, I have never seen "not respectful posts" for women or people of color... imho this is a no-problem for SO and I think that it is dangerous to create a discrimination case when there is none. Because in this way, you are creating artificial discrimination and real distance between people.
- FuNe 9y agoSo -basically- SO says that a lot of its contributors behave like bullies but, being unable to actually yell at them (because SO needs them) tries to fuzzy out/alleviate the issue by taking the blame for them. I don't see any way that can work out. For what is worth I can testify my own little experience from that pit. * Contributors who downvote other answers without any excuse/explanation/commend (I guess it makes their own answer seem better). * A tiny minority of users ever upvoting (that's a largely thankless community). * Moderators that are being extra harsh with language usage (I'd say most of SO users are not native English speakers but this does not stop some native ones considering themselves somehow superior). *Extended usage of points, badges and several other facebooky notifications to tap into your dopamine receptors.
- ynottho 9y agothis is ridiculous
- ynottho 9y agoThis is ridiculous.
- jinushaun 9y agoCan’t answer the question of gender and color since I’ve never experienced those kinds of problems on SO, but the site policies are definitely unwelcoming. The barrier to entry to ask and answer questions is really high. You have to earn it by voting on existing answers. I see good questions and good answers shut down all the time. I kind of wonder what the quality bar is for these moderators.