14 ms·
SteamOS, Linux, and Steam Machines
- Zhyl 9y agoThis is a good update for Linux Gaming fans. There was definitely uncertainty when the Steam Machines page was delisted, some even thinking this was game over for gaming on Linux. Those who were there at the beginning of the Valve Linux Offensive (circa 2012) will remember Gabe Newell stating that the main driver for investing in Linux is their dependency on Windows as a platform. Valve has never been one for dependencies at the best of times (creating their own engine to replace quake, creating their own sales platform to replace retail) and having a dependency on a platform that explicitly seems to be trying to emulate the iOS/Android approach more and more is absolutely a reason to at the very least have a plan B. Having Valve come out and say that they're still invested in Linux is important, but what is highlighted in the post is also poignant - in 2012 it seemed the barrier to adoption was interest in the platform and access to a Linux machine. The solution to both of these was to create a high-profile, easily accessible form factor which was Linux by default. It turns out that this may not have actually been the right solution. Linux adoption has risen and the back catalogue of available games has increased incredibly, despite lacklustre sales. The problem now, and perhaps always was the graphics APIs and cost of porting. Valve are actively investing in Vulkan which is absolutely the right thing for them to be doing. The only downside is that it looks like they're neglecting the 'movement' they started with Steam Machines. I hope to see big things from Valve in the future. If I were them, however, I would invest in creating a truly fantastic desktop experience with seamless transition from Windows, lots of toys to play with, riced desktops etc. Hardware and the console form factor should be secondary to creating a PC desktop experience worthy of the people who created Half Life and steam.
- onli 9y agoYou and they are probably right. Investing in Vulcan and the attractiveness of non-Windows platforms in general is the most important thing they can do. The many games that are now available for Linux are what makes Linux a good gaming OS, not the steam machines that were never sold. Still, it is a bit sad. Steam machines could have worked, but they were severely flawed. Buying a steam machine did not guarantee that one would get a machine actually capable of playing current games, they were very different and often underpowered. Linux-compatibility alone is then not enough. I think they could be great if they had been more controlled: Define a form factor, define the minimum cpu and gpu power needed, buy those in big quantities to be able to give a discount compared to buying a PC manually. Release it at the start of a gpu-release cycle, so it does not need to be updated that soon. Pre-install SteamOS on a machine like this and add a starter game (Portal) and one would actually have an upgradeable gaming console developers could target games for.
- shrewduser 9y agoSteam machines biggest flaw was they eschewed the biggest benefit of a game console, being a common hardware Target for devs. They should have a rolling release built around a good Apu and move from v1 through to v2 etc revisions of the hardware every couple of years. Maybe throw in a pro version of the hardware for people with money to burn
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bryanlarsen 9y agoSteamOS / Linux releases are always and always will be afterthoughts. The games are developed for Windows and consoles. No significant effort is put into the Linux port, it's released because it's easy to do. So a common hardware target would do absolutely no good. No games would be developed specifically for that target.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoDon't see why that's a given. Had Valve really thrown their weight behind it, devs would have followed. Just because the market is a certain way doesn't mean that's out of necessity. There are large markets in developing economies that would benefit much (as would everyone else) from getting out of MS's grip.
- bryanlarsen 9y agoDevs aren't the problem. There are a huge number of games available for Linux on Steam. Linux gaming on Steam is a success, well beyond the expectations of most. Steam Machines are the failure. Making them even more expensive would not have helped.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoIt seems to me that the reason why they failed was because they were too expensive due to a reliance on OEMs like Alienware who inevitably put out overpriced junk. There were too many options. That's not how you win the market. Not sure they were really interested in doing so...it was more of a hedge against MS.
- m_eiman 9y agoThose who were there at the beginning of the Valve Linux Offensive (circa 2012) will remember Gabe Newell stating that the main driver for investing in Linux is their dependency on Windows as a platform. I see a problem that is just as big, or probably bigger, here for the (PC) game industry: the near-monopoly of Steam. I try to buy non-Steam versions of the games I buy, because I dislike Steam's online DRM and their client, but it seems that Steam is the new Windows when it comes to gaming. "Everything" is released on Steam first, and it seems a lot of times only on Steam. Which means that we're one focus shift or stolen password away from not being able to run the games we've bought and paid for. gog.com has a better offer, IMHO, by being DRM free. Are there any other similar competing services? Humble Bundle seem to be selling Steam keys these days, so they're a subset of Steam.
- baud147258 9y agoFor Ubisoft, there's Uplay. But I don't think you'll like their client either. Also, Origin, EA's shop, carries non-EA games.
- maccard 9y agoUplay is the worst of them. UPlay has modal ads for other games in the store when you close a game, or if your game crashes!
- baud147258 9y agoThe worst is when you're forced to use Uplay in addition to Steam.
- masklinn 9y agoGOG is probably the sanest competitor to steam, especially since they launched Galaxy so that you can manage your local installations without having to download and run individual installers. Next up is probably itch.io. UPlay, Origin and whatever the hell Blizzard's client is called these days are just lock-ins from their respective publishers.
- mAritz 9y agoThe biggest issue I've faced when it comes to playing games on Linux that have good support (for example CS:GO) is that mouse handling in linux is not easy to configure and vendor mouse drivers are often atrocious if they exist at all. Specifically for first-/third-person games this means getting the right sensitivity and disabling mouse-acceleration (or setting it in a very specific way for some hardcore quake pros supposedly). Last time I checked, disabling mouse accelleration is a huge hassle and no working UI exists. The average gamer will not go into config files of the OS to try and find the right formula that makes their mouse move the way they expect it to. This isn't really an important issue in normal desktop usage or point-and-click games. Thus support by linux developers is understandably lacking.
- headsoup 9y agoIt does seem unfortunately that the best method is to install the mouse on Windows somewhere and save the config to the mouse itself. This obviously requires the mouse have on-board memory, but it works at least.
- asfdsfggtfd 9y agoHave you tried rtfm? man xset
- nhaehnle 9y agoAside from the unnecessary snarkiness, here's my main reason for downvoting you: Even somebody who is familiar with the concept of man pages would have no chance of knowing that xset is the one to look for. Discoverability is super important. Luckily, the kind of desktops people actually use tend to have a System Settings app in which mouse acceleration can be figured.
- e12e 9y agoDidcovdrability isn't great, but eg: "apropos input" suggest "man xinput" and a quick search points to acceleration along with a pointer to the "xset(1) man page". Unfortunately it looks like the path from "apropos mouse" might be a bit more convoluted.
- imjustsaying 9y ago>The problem now, and perhaps always was the graphics APIs and cost of porting. Perhaps some special financial incentives from Valve to big studios would be able to get the rock moving down the mountain? Temporary discounts perhaps?
- Aardwolf 9y agoI love how many good games are available for linux in steam! Factorio, Terraria, Silicon Zeroes, ... It seems that it's even trivial to release Stream games for linux when using any common game engine, and I hope developers will make use of that as much as possible. Fallout 3 has no linux version in steam unfortunately, but I actually could play it perfectly by running the windows client of steam in wine. Everything just worked (I had to do a memory patch to support 64-bit CPUs, but so do windows users have to so no difference there)
- aveao 9y agoI tend to prefer GOG over Steam lately, mostly because of how shady Valve is at certain stuff. The first 2 of the 3 games you mentioned are available DRM-Free on their site. Playtesting takes time and money and it's entirely possible that just exporting the game for linux won't run perfectly, so I can see why some companies using the common game engines don't do it, I kinda wish they did, though. Wine runs a lot of Windows games properly.
- baud147258 9y agoI remember a indie dev saying that he won't port his game to Linux, since, even if it was working, he couldn't do enough testing to guanrantee a stable enough release.
- robert_foss 9y agoValve has been making serious amounts of contributions to Linux graphics in the past few years. Vulkan, RadeonSi and VR to name a few. They deserve all the recognition they can get for it.
- CodeArtisan 9y agoThey also open sourced GameNetworkingSockets and made it independent of steam for allowing games that use it to be ported to other markets. https://github.com/ValveSoftware/GameNetworkingSockets https://github.com/ValveSoftware/GameNetworkingSockets
- nukeop 9y agoSteam as a platform is completely, utterly atrocious in all regards. Their client is ancient, outdated, and barely usable, there's no content quality filtering, the greenlight program is a failure that only succeeds in bringing complete bottom of the barrel dreg in 99% of cases, even from a developer's point of view the platform is just a major PITA. But it has the first mover advantage and that is really everything. Even platforms that are infinitely better, have better tools, support, and pricing (such as itch.io that doesn't require a cent to publish your games) are heavily disadvantaged just because it takes extra work for developers and gamers to adopt them. There's no easy way out of this and Valve can continue being lazy and make major slip-ups every year and there's very little others can do to endanger their heavily entrenched position on the gaming market. As far as PC (or GNU/Linux in particular) gaming is considered, Steam is everything, and it's not going to change any time soon.
- headsoup 9y agoI feel like Valve has certainly been putting effort into Linux, but not serious effort. They seem to be going low-moderate risk/investment. Sure there's progress, but then the Wine devs are moving pretty steadily too at the moment. If Valve wants to really be serious: - Offer incentives to Devs to support Linux/Vulkan - Release a goddamn new game (HL3 - dreams) and make it Linux exclusive for a time - develop and release new features for Linux first (maybe if GoG ever get the Galaxy client over to Linux Valve will get a kick in the pants to act...) - Promote SteamOS and (maybe) Steam Machines, like at least some. Show Steam Machines as an 'out-of-the-box Windows gaming replacement, not a console competitor. - Fund Linux devs or take a lower cut from Linux releases - Convince Adobe to release their suite on Linux! Push for/fund official Unity and Unreal Engine Linux versions - Offer the ability to natively launch games through Wine (and either use 'community' environment files or require one exist, or have a link to WineHQ for help) Be serious Valve, be genuine and get your flat structured 'follow the shiny thing' company focused and determined.
- gambiting 9y ago>>Release a goddamn new game (HL3 - dreams) and make it Linux exclusive for a time I think people seriously overestimate how popular that game would be. If they really did release it as a Linux exclusive, a lot of us nerds(and I mean it as a compliment here) would install Linux in a heartbeat just to play it, but I think overall, the game would sell very poorly. It has been so many years since the last one that the mainstream public doesn't care about it anymore - a group of hardcore enthusiasts would buy it + some people interested in what the whole Half-Life hype is about, but I'd be surprised if it sold million copies.
- mohaine 9y agoAgreed but all they really need to do is make the BETA Steam OS only. This still gets the hardcore enthusiast interested while not alienating everyone else.
- epicide 9y agoI also think about the other side of it. I love teaching people about Linux/(F)OSS/etc. However, I would hate to see HL3 exclusive for Linux. It would largely hurt the community, I think. Let's assume millions did rush to buy it and install Linux. Think of how many of them would be installing it just to play one game. Most would gripe about not being able to do something they're used to in their other OS [0]. While I love Linux, there are some pain points on desktop. Just getting it installed on your machine is not always trivial even when you know what you're doing. Something you've done a thousand times sometimes just doesn't work for no real reason and you just have to try again [1]. Linus help them if they need a proprietary driver [2]. I imagine most of the people trying Linux for the first time would be trying it with the intention of playing a game instead of learning a new system. That sets them up to be annoyed every step of the way and walk away angry at the new system (Linux). On top of all that, it could cause some frustrations for people like myself who try to help others install and learn Linux. I imagine having several conversations with friends/family thinking they want to finally learn some of this Linux thing I keep talking about. Only to discover it's just because they want to play HL3. [0]: http://linux.oneandoneis2.org/LNW.htm http://linux.oneandoneis2.org/LNW.htm [1]: I realize this happens with computers, in general. The point here isn't to bash Linux (heh). [2]: obviously, not a fault of the Linux ecosystem, but that doesn't change the fact that it is incredibly frustrating. EDIT: formatting.
- _pmf_ 9y agoThere exists a world where the Switch is the Steam Machine. It would have been very well possible if Nvidia had chosen Steam instead of Nintendo as distributor for its Shield. We'd have an open handheld platform for indie games.
- eloisant 9y agoIt's not "Nvidia choosing Nintendo as a distributor", it's "Nintendo choosing Nvidia as a component provider". Let's be realistic, the success of the Switch is more because of Nintendo software (Zelda, but also the promise of other Nintendo IPs coming) rather than the hardware. The success of indies on the Switch is more a byproduct of the Switch success that the other way around. Nvidia Shield existing before Nintendo Switch, it did have a focus on gaming but it didn't cought anyone's attention. I don't see a partnership with Steam changing much about that.
- sp332 9y agoNvidia already had two generations of Shield products, and the third generation was hotly anticipated. After a delay, it was revealed that the Switch was going to be the third "Shield" generation. Nvidia was always going to make another tablet.
- eloisant 9y agoSure, but I don't think that third tablet would have had any more success than the previous ones if it wasn't a Nintendo console.
- swebs 9y ago>We'd have an open handheld platform for indie games. They already had a standalone Shield years before the Switch. Nobody wanted to support it since games had to be reworked for ARM and the Android framework. Same with the Ouya. It's not a particularly difficult obstacle, but there were so few users that it wasn't worth it. Breath of the Wild alone was enough to sell millions of units. There are now over 15 million Switches out in consumers's hands.
- 9y ago
- z3t4 9y agoWhen leaving Windows for Linux I kinda gave up on gaming, but not only some but most of my favorite games do work on Linux! For example Kerbal Space Program (which unfortunately get more and more buggy for each update, and is currently unplayable due to space ships spontaneously rip apart spreading parts all over the galaxy)
- bitL 9y ago> get more and more buggy It's probably because they don't pay their developers and fire everyone that expresses any discontent with it... KSP is not a good citizen.
- z3t4 9y agoIt basically goes like this: Company have thin margins and dev's agree to work for slave wages. Company starts to make millions in IP profits. Employees want to increase their salaries. Company says no. Employees quit. Company hires new employees, but doesn't have to increase salaries much due to market prices. The employees could probably get employed at some enterprise IT shop and make CRUD forms all day with decent pay, but what a waste of talent.
- julioneander 9y agoMost of the big game engines were ported to Linux at this point, so it has become easier for developers to target these platforms. There are multiple AAA titles running natively on Linux, with comparable performance to their Windows counterparts (some people have noticed even better performance). I've been playing older titles that now have official Linux versions, like Bioshock, Metro 2033. Let me tell you, I would never have predicted I'd be playing AAA titles natively on Linux.
- cup-of-tea 9y agoI stopped using Windows about 11 years ago and I've been using Linux ever since. I actually played so much Dota 2 on Linux that I had to uninstall it. I used to play a lot of Enemy Territory; Quake Wars too. I was very disappointed that both Quake 4 and Doom 3 BFG edition were Windoze only, though. Otherwise I would have bought those instantly.
- yAnonymous 9y agoI value their commitment. >While it's true Steam Machines aren't exactly flying off the shelves I hope they didn't expect anything else. Steam already has a limited choice of games and a console that is even more limited is a niche product at best. To make it succeed, they need a lot of resources to get GPU manufacturers and game publishers on board (also those who took their games off Steam and created their own launchers). They need both of that only to have a chance to attack regular consoles.
- ionised 9y agoIf Linux could play all of my favourite games I would drop Windows in a heartbeat. There is absolutely no reason for me to have a Windows machine except the games I play that don't work on Linux/Wine.
- p0nce 9y agoLook no further than this to understand why Linux doesn't work for most game developers https://www.gamingonlinux.com/articles/linux-game-sales-statistics-from-multiple-developers-part-5.10064 https://www.gamingonlinux.com/articles/linux-game-sales-stat...
- goodroot 9y agoI recently received an invite for the GeForceNOW beta. For the unaware, GeforceNOW is game streaming; they leverage cloud GPUs to render games, then stream the results back to you. My take away is in-line with critical consensus. If you have a sublime Internet connection, it's an awesome service. It's prone to the odd dip in quality, but all-in-all it's a major paradigm shift. I have been a proponent of gaming on Linux most of my adult life, but I can't help but think that Valve might be missing the boat by sinking resources into gaming on Linux local hardware. Times are a-changin'.
- errantspark 9y agoI could see this working for something like Civ or casual RPG play. I can't see this working well for anything competitive. Even in a best case scenario with a huge pipe and a server right nearby you'll probably be looking at one or two frames of delay at 60 fps which is already pretty frustrating for games where timing is important, and I doubt that's going to be the case in general. Physics is just going to get in the way, and we're not even considering 144Hz or higher resolutions, the bandwidth/latency requirements quickly get way out of hand.
- srslack 9y ago>might be missing the boat Valve's goal was to hedge against a "Windows Store" model for games at a time when it seemed that it was inevitable. Also, and I don't mean to sound dismissive, but that streaming model simply will not work. When it comes to anything more than visual novels or turn based RPGs, the only way you'll be able to solve the problem of latency, which players of these games are very sensitive to, is by using tachyons. I think there are better uses of hypothetical faster-than-light particles, personally.
- tomc1985 9y ago> I have been a proponent of gaming on Linux most of my adult life, but I can't help but think that Valve might be missing the boat by sinking resources into gaming on Linux local hardware. Times are a-changin'. No they aren't. There is just now a large amount of hammer-wielding cloud idiots on the scene who think everything local is a nail. There is an entire industry built around computer building, and a very large proportion of the PC gaming crowd see the two as inexorably intertwined. Part of the joy of PC gaming is the satisfaction of building a powerful system and watching it play 3D games really well.
- opensourcenews 9y agoPotentially unpopular opinion: There is no money to be made in consumer desktop operating systems in 2018, so there is little funding for innovation in the consumer desktop operating system space. Until a business model emerges which challenges this, the status quo will remain roughly the status quo. The two major commercial producers of proprietary operating systems are basically giving away their operating system at this point. Free Linux distributions offer basically the same functionality for most users; the only things preventing migration from one OS to another are existing applications. For non-gamers, that's often moot, because the world exists in a web browser now. Yes, there are other applications causing OS lock-in too, but they're mostly on the business side, not the consumer side. There is still plenty of money to be made from enterprise operating systems, but the innovation there is in a totally different direction than what consumers would find valuable. Example: Linux containers are great! But who's spending the R&D money to make them a viable way to distribute games? There's plenty of work being done on containers and graphics chipsets for ML applications, but not for consumer use.
- tomc1985 9y agoThere are a number of packaging technologies already being worked on, and games are just programs, why do games need a special focus? AppImage, snapcraft, etc
- e12e 9y ago> The two major commercial producers of proprietary operating systems are basically giving away their operating system at this point. Huh? Windows 10 home and pro aren't free? It's true that Apple doesn't charge for upgrades, but they do charge a significant markup - and they will happily sell you a licence to run Os X on a hackintosh although they'll forbid you from doing it in their licence ("non apple hardware"). > Until a business model emerges which challenges this Appstores. Windows, and Os X have app stores. Steam is an appstore. Microsoft and Apple bundle a competitor to steam with the Os. Just because both apple and Ms suck at making/marketing/developing their App stores... Doesn't mean valve don't want to stay in the business... They can't get in on ios, Xbox, ps4, etc. They could probably make an appstore for Android - but I'm guessing they'll just focus on streaming games from the cloud to Android (esp Android TV). With hw support for virtualization, Linux could be the universal runtime - allowing the same game to run on Mac, Windows and Linux...
- wink 9y agoI'm really confused if PC gaming is a winner-takes-all market. Most of the people I know (let's be honest, it's probably 90%-95% of your friends) play games (AAA, bigger indies, the "household names") on Windows and only a very fervent minority plays on Linux. I personally have been using Linux on work computers and personal laptops (almost) exclusively for.. I don't know, 10 years? - but my "gaming pc" is still on Windows and I'm not in the mood for experiments with WINE or grasping at the games that run on Linux. Does anyone play major games on Windows and Linux? I'm really excited for the idea of Linux gaming, but it's not a thing I'm willing to compromise and fiddling if the games I want to play really work.
- woolvalley 9y agoIt's about platform independence. Basically it lets steam tell microsoft, us and our ecosystem can move our PC 'console' to a linux foundation any time.
- wink 9y agoSure, but that was neither my point nor my question. I'm not interested in what Valve wants to achieve (in this scope) - but if there's a tangible benefit for gamers and not just a hypthetic one :)
- erikpukinskis 9y agoI don’t understand why no one is talking about Linux on stand-alone VR headsets. Valve’s hardware team has been very busy, designing the Vive in 2016 and the knuckles controller in 2017. They’ve said they are working on multiple full length VR games, but that they wanted to be able to design the hardware (knuckles) and the games together a la Nintendo. This is public knowledge. It’s also known that Oculus is releasing two standalone VR devices in the next couple years. Valve has a headset, controllers, and a Linux OS. It seems obvious to me where this is all going: a stand-alone Valve VR device running SteamOS. Of course they’re not investing in screen-based games and desktop Linux boxes. They’re perfectly positioned to release a medium-defining device in a green field new computing paradigm. They are at least as well positioned in this fight as Microsoft, Facebook, and Apple. That’s the big leagues. Valve makes good money on Steam, but not that kind of money. And you know Apple and Microsoft aren’t going to use Linux. So having Valve means there’s a Linux horse in the VR race.