29 ms·
This might just be a bargaining move on Apple’s part, but I don’t think so. I think that long term they are much better off controlling their entire hardware st
by mark_l_watson 9y ago
This might just be a bargaining move on Apple’s part, but I don’t think so. I think that long term they are much better off controlling their entire hardware stack. I wouldn’t be surprised to even see them make their own display screens.
As an Apple customer, I like this idea also. For 20 years, I used to be a desktop Linux fanatic and later became a fan of Android. In the last few years, I have switched to using all Apple devices.
Even though I am a computer scientists, I actually spend more time on my iPad and iPhone, by far, than on my Mac laptops. I only use a laptop for software development (because of the nature of my work, that is often just SSHed into Linux servers), the rest of my workflow and entertainment is on iOS devices.
The older I get, the more I want to get my work done expediently, leaving time to study new technologies and spend time with family and friends. At least for right now, I am maximally effective in Apple’s environments.
As a bonus, I trust Apple more that Microsoft, Google, Intel, etc.
- baq 9y agointeresting, i only use my ipad as a remote to the avr so i can play tidal from my hifi... it's gathering dust otherwise.
- criddell 9y agoThe only thing I have a hard time trusting Intel with is the way they have handled questions around their Management Engine. I think they have done a poor job convincing us that it's safe or at least benign. It will be interesting to see if Apple includes a secretive management engine. If they do, then the speculation that it's required by one or more governments will be dialed up to 11.
- madez 9y agoWith Apple's documented interest in owner's control of their devices and delivering the required documentation for it, they won't tell us what is included in the chips and what's not.
- criddell 9y agoApple has done a very good job with documenting iOS security: https://www.apple.com/business/docs/iOS_Security_Guide.pdf https://www.apple.com/business/docs/iOS_Security_Guide.pdf If they included a management engine and produced a document like that, I'd be satisfied.
- saagarjha 9y agoApple is probably going to produce a similar document that details at a high level how the security works. If they follow the example that they set with iOS devices, what they won't do is provide the source code for these components.
- mynameisvlad 9y agoI mean, of course, it's still their right to release or keep any source code they produce. We shouldn't be expecting them to release the source code, but even a whitepaper is better than what Intel is doing.
- Cyph0n 9y agoI always see this document linked to on HN even though it's a (relatively) high level description of what is happening on the device. Besides, there is absolutely no guarantee that Apple isn't just being "semi-open" with their security mechanisms. In other words, who is to say that there are no redundant, undocumented mechanisms in place? But I will concede that Apple is ahead of everyone else in this regard. It's just that I think Apple being ahead doesn't mean that the information they're providing is enough.
- criddell 9y agoYou're right that a whitepaper isn't enough to be really sure. That takes disassembly of binaries and then you are still stuck with judging the trustworthiness of the hardware and I'm not sure how you solve that problem.
- 9y ago
- diogenescynic 9y ago> I wouldn’t be surprised to even see them make their own display screens. I think they're already working on that: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-03-19/apple-is-said-to-develop-displays-to-replace-samsung-screens https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-03-19/apple-is-...
- sydney6 9y ago> I think that long term they are much better off controlling their entire hardware stack. But CPU/GPU aren't the only chips Apple is sourcing from 3rd party. Think wireless modems like WiFi, LTE, etc.
- hinkley 9y agoI don’t know what the current status is but they have definitely looked at making their own baseband chips before.
- djrogers 9y agoClose, but Apple already produces it's own WiFi/BT chipsets (the S1/S2 etc SOCs in Apple watches for example, and the W1 chipset in AirPods and new Beats headphones), and is rumored to be working on an LTE/GSM chipset. I think Apple is intensely interested in controlling the entire stack.
- Someone 9y agoProduces? Are you sure you don’t mean designs?
- sneak 9y agoApple is as yet fabless, correct. By choice, clearly, as they have enough cash on hand to build and operate more than anyone else on the planet if they wished.
- wbl 9y agoWhy? A lot of these parts are commodetized. Are they really getting that much better battery life from their own stuff?
- eanzenberg 9y agoFor performance. They can outcompete against others by moving to bespoke hardware. My iphone x cpu is ~ 13” MBP in performance, which is bonkers.
- samayylmao 9y agoTo play devil's advocate.. While you may trust them more, you can't deny they have had many significant software security issues of late. How could consumers trust the security of their chips?
- abritinthebay 9y agoGiven software !== chips and their ARM chips are - hands down - the best on the market... yeah, I'd think people would trust them.
- mlloyd 9y agoGiven the amount of evidence you presented, how could anyone refute your opinion? OP raised a valid argument - Apple's QC has been crap lately and trending downwards. There's a lot of feedback out on the net to support that line of thinking.
- Bud 9y agoThere's been Apple-bashing "feedback out on the net" since Apple was founded. Most of it has been laughable. The stuff you're talking about is firmly within that laughable camp. If Apple's QC were "crap" you'd see that in customer satisfaction ratings for their #1 product: the iPhone. But guess what? You don't see that. And there is no downward trend.
- monocasa 9y agoShipping Mac OS so that anyone can just YOLO login as root? https://www.macworld.co.uk/how-to/mac-software/how-stop-someone-getting-root-access-your-mac-3668317/ https://www.macworld.co.uk/how-to/mac-software/how-stop-some... Storing the full disk encryption password in plaintext on the disk? https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208168 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208168 How do you explain these except for atrocious and trending downwards QC?
- 9y ago
- lhorie 9y agoHow's this different than going back to PowerPC architecture? When they switched to Intel, I recall there being a lot of talk of benefits to running on the same chips as everyone else. From what I've been hearing lately about Apple, the impression I keep getting is that Apple doesn't think of Mac as a product with a specific target market, but more as a sort of just-a-really-really-big-ipad. The closed garden approach worked well with iOS, where for the most part people just play throwaway games, but I really don't see that being a viable underlying philosophy for laptops, where interop with digital plumbing is important.
- npunt 9y agoApple is in a much different state now. Making your own chip requires significant resources, and before they didn't have the leverage nor talent to get the chips they wanted built. Now, they have a trillion dollar product (iPhone) and a mature chip development team that many consider the best in the industry, and they can throw tons of money at the problem. The benefit of running the same chips as everyone else was about leveraging the investment of other products into the Intel architecture. Now they're doing that, just with their own chips.
- Tijdreiziger 9y agoIt doesn't need to be a closed garden. Look at what Microsoft is doing with x86 emulation on ARM.
- snowwrestler 9y ago> When they switched to Intel, I recall there being a lot of talk of benefits to running on the same chips as everyone else. They switched to Intel first and foremost because PowerPC was not going to get them the performance/power ratio that they wanted. It was holding them back in laptops. For example, Apple never shipped a laptop with a G5 chip because it took so much damn power to run a G5. Intel was basically their only option. A secondary benefit, which they marketed heavily, was the opportunity to boot your machine natively into Windows. They thought this would help overcome the reluctance of "switchers" who were worried that they would miss something about Windows. These days, the role of the OS as a gatekeeper is basically gone. There's greater diversity in client OS (Windows, macOS, Linux, ChromeOS, iOS, Android, etc.) and most anything important is available through a browser or a native app. And Intel is no longer their only option. They've proven they can run big businesses making their own chips. I do wonder how this will affect VM performance on Macs though. I don't see how it can be maintained, unless Apple chips are so much faster than Intel that they can absorb the translation overhead.
- sreque 9y agoI am a software developer, and I detest working on my mac laptop. At $lastjob I had a Linux desktop and it is, I believe, the most productive environment I have ever developed in. The job before, I had a windows desktop, and I prefer that to mac. You say you want to just "get things done expediently," but in my experience apple software is flat out inferior and OSX is the worst of the 3 major operating systems I have to choose from. Lastly, what does Apple have to gain by switching away from Intel? Not much, at least, not much that benefits me as a customer. Likely they are interested in making their laptops have more in common with their iOS devices, which does little to nothing for me. Apple's behavior towards OSX and macbooks in the past few years should be of great concern for anyone, especially if you actually like the devices.
- fastball 9y agoWhat exactly does your development workflow look like where Linux was so much better than MacOS?
- garmaine 9y agoWhat was the workflow in which windows was better than anything UNIX based....
- ratsimihah 9y agoI’m missing the logic as well. Linux > Windows > macOS?
- pjmlp 9y agoDesktop software development, graphical debugging tools. The only UNIX based that tops it is macOS.
- garmaine 9y agoBut Linux is better for that?
- linkmotif 9y agoThere was a post on here recently that said Apple was interesting in making their own displays.
- mr_toad 9y agoMaybe they’ll make a TV that doesn’t sell information on everything you watch and say to all and sundry.
- davidy123 9y agoYou can't easily share media between the Apple ecosystem and others. You can't access some Apple services at all from Linux. There's no way to run userscripts/WebExtensions on IOS. Your device is no longer a user-focused tool to access media, your browser is closer to being a "smart tv" than a customize-able information explorer and augmenter essentially controlled by no one. You're giving up an awful lot for the sake of convenience, trends that if amplified could irrevocably change the character of the Internet for the worse. I also don't get what's missing from a modern Linux desktop, especially since nearly everything is on the web these days.
- electricslpnsld 9y ago> I also don't get what's missing from a modern Linux desktop Adobe software, for one.
- mehrdadn 9y agoI have also yet to find an IDE as nice as Visual Studio...
- mythz 9y agoMany of JetBrains IDE's are better and they're cross-platform. I've switched to Rider after getting sick of constant white screen of deaths, crashes, locking and perf issues in VS.NET. Rider is on par with VS.NET/R# for C# and superior for pretty much everything else except for visual GUI designers - although I haven't used one seriously in over a decade.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mehrdadn 9y agoI'm very skeptical but I will try out JetBrains, thanks for the pointer! :) EDIT: These all seem to be .NET development? I use Visual Studio mostly for C++... for that would you recommend CLion?
- Spooky23 9y agoThe problem is that Apple’s focus on this distracts from the software that defines the user experience. The MacOS ecosystem is both beautiful and deeply troubled.
- npunt 9y agoOn the other hand, with Marzipan (shared libraries on iOS/MacOS) and a single processor architecture, you could say that Apple is putting 'more wood behind fewer arrows' and will have more engineers developing software that reaches MacOS as a result.
- wintercharm 9y ago> The MacOS ecosystem is both beautiful and deeply troubled. So, shifting it to ARM and letting universal apps in the iOS App store now run on macOS in addition to iPad opens up the mac to a metric fuckton of developers that are happy to make cross-platform apps, since the iOS app store is SO lucrative. Apple showed, with the iPad which was a totally new product category, that the sheer number of iOS developers could push the iPad from a platform with zero apps to the best tablet in the world (with an incredible app ecosystem) and universal apps who's UI adapt to the screen they're made for.
- zeveb 9y agoWhat I'd like is for a company like Apple to provide me (and others) the tools & APIs we need in order to take advantage of that integration, without locking us into their UI paradigms. I would like everything to Just Work™; I wouldn't mind a Macintosh laptop; I would hate to be stuck using the macOS UI. A lot of what Apple really does is hardware integration. Let me use the hardware to run a free OS, and also take advantage of the excellent hardware integration. Let me use a free operating system, StumpWM, emacs and some nifty APIs which let me talk to the integrated hardware system. Give me, in the words of Steve Jobs, a 'bicycle for the mind,' not a tram to nowhere.
- alerighi 9y agoI have a mac, it's a great piece of hardware, and it works great for doing basic stuff, surfing the web, responding to emails, writing documents, but for my work I find Linux so much simpler to use. Linux just works, sure it's isn't pretty like macOS but it let you get your work done fast, I know perfectly how everything is put toughener, there is a problem surely I can fix it in seconds, just edit some config file and done, it has far more tools for developers, if you need to install software you have the package manager, sure on macOS you have brew but it have some problems, and a lot of developer tools either don't work on macOS, or doesn't work correctly, or are similar but not the same as Linux. In fact on my mac most of the times or I works with remote servers or with VMs on my computer, because for development work Linux it's far better.
- amelius 9y agoWe should all not forget that if IBM, in the 80s, controlled its hardware and software stack like Apple does now, we would not have the modular desktop PC and we would not have Linux. I consider the extreme vertical integration of Apple as a bad development (Apple recently is trying to control even rare Earth metals). I like the market to be "modular", with many different vendors, making replaceable parts that fit together like in the desktop PC. And I wish for a future where I still have a choice, instead of being forced to use iDevices for everything from scientific computing to consumer media players.
- pohl 9y ago...we would not have the modular desktop PC and we would not have Linux. There’s probably no way to support that counter-factual. We could easily have ended up with some other open-architecture personal computer and open source operating system.
- no_wizard 9y agoThere is actually: BSD. In 1991 BSD transitioned to open source https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berkeley_Software_Distribution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berkeley_Software_Distribution Which of course gave us FreeBSD in 1993 Thats just one simple example I can think of. Intel, as well, was never monopolized as a chip manufacturer. They could sell chips freely to IBM competitors. Also, the reverse engineering of the IBM platform is what made Compaq computer successful in the mid 80s. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compaq https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compaq I don't think even a quick examination of the histories involved here would yield any other result than open hardware and software was always going to be a big component of desktop computing. These things ebb and flow anyway, historically what you usually see is that for at least a decade (sometimes more, a lot more, and sometimes dramatically less) what ends up happening is vertically integrated solutions are favored as they bring the most harmony to the average customer of said platform ('it just works!' was as slogan of many firms, not just Apple). Then as complexities can be either mitigated or eliminated these things tend to open themselves up. I believe Mobile devices are going through this phase. I think in another decade or two you will have a situation where you start seeing really useable open alternatives to the major platforms even though right now it does not seem intuitive or obvious how that will work
- jeena 9y agoIt's the old story of convinience vs. freedom. I myself am willing to trade a bit of convinience and the need of tinkering with the system for a big chunk of freedom. Not only for me but by using and making Linux better, hopefully it's also a (small) investment for future generations. This way I hope they still will have the choice to run software they (can) trust on their own devices. If everyone would just go for the convinience, at least desktop Linux would dissapear as an option.
- walterstucco 9y ago>> The older I get, the more I want to get my work done expediently, My experience is different The older I get, the less I want my bike to have training wheels