17 ms·
Facebook Secretly Saved Videos Users Deleted
- feelin_googley 9y agoMeanwhile: http://fortune.com/2018/03/31/facebook-employees-are-reportedly-deleting-controversial-internal-messages/ http://fortune.com/2018/03/31/facebook-employees-are-reporte...
- yorby 9y agothat link doesn't work for me... this one appears to be the same thing: http://start.att.net/news/read/category/politics/article/fortune-facebook_employees_are_reportedly_deleting_controv-rtime http://start.att.net/news/read/category/politics/article/for...
- feelin_googley 9y agoSorry about that. Its just a brief article. Heres a no-Javascript version: curl -o 1.htm http://amp.timeinc.net/fortune/2018/03/31/facebook-employees-are-reportedly-deleting-controversial-internal-messages sed -i '/<p>/,/<\/p>/!d' 1.htm ; firefox file:///1.htm ;
- fwdpropaganda 9y agoCue wave of outraged HNers because some people believed Facebook cared.
- dang 9y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments here.
- fwdpropaganda 9y agoI don't think pointing out how disconnected half of the userbase here is is unsubstantive. 99% of people who use Facebook has not the fainstest idea of what Facebook is doing, why they're doing it, and why it might be wrong. Still, on each of these threads the top comment invariably starts with "why is anyone surprised that.. etc". I could find you links to prove my point, but I'm can't believe you're not aware of this. So I strongly disagree my comment is unsubstantive.
- throwawaylp0 9y agoHN users live in this weird Silicon Valley bubble that is divorced from the real world..
- dang 9y agoOnly about 10% of HN users are in Silicon Valley, and many of those are critical of it.
- dang 9y agoIt was unsubstantive by the standard we moderate HN for–shallow and repetitive, made worse by snark and tropiness. Please don't post like that here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- garyvee_ 9y agoDecluttered: https://outline.com/zAZ4BM https://outline.com/zAZ4BM
- guessmyname 9y agoThis reminds me of the long conversations that I used to have with family members and friends several years ago. With their continuous requests to create my own Facebook profile so I can keep in contact with them and with their activities as well as to share my whereabouts. I always used the same argument to reject these suggestions — "I don't want Facebook to have too much data about me, more than the data that you already provided". I got used to the looks of disbelief, thinking that I was some sort of hermit, an antisocial. I also got tired of answering the frequent "Why don't you have Facebook?" questions. I remember the last time I had this conversation with someone, last year (2017) around August. I found a new love partner, and after the long intimate talks on the phone, they requested the usual "intimate pictures", not necessarily sexual but certainly sexy. While I have no tabus with regards to my sexuality, having an understanding of how the Internet works, I have always refused to send that type of images/videos/audios, and I always tried to be patient with the other person to explain my constant denials. Unfortunately, expecting a non-tech-savvy person to understand how data moves around the Internet is most of the time based on hope, and even if they understand, they ultimately don't care because the result doesn't change: you don't get to share something with them and that affects personal interactions. I am sure that the deletion of media files in services like Facebook has never meant to be absolute. Many of my colleagues believe the same thing that I believe: Facebook and other services do not actually delete data, they just mark it as "deleted" and purge it only if they need the space. The same way a hard drive works, you don't really delete a picture when you hit the "delete" key, nor even if you clear the "trash" folder, the data is still there, where it was, it just loses the links to the metadata. It is sad how this information becomes news only when bad things happen.
- renegadesensei 9y agoI went through the same issues with friends and loved ones wanting me to create a Facebook account. I resisted for years with the same arguments you made. It had some unfortunate consequences: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16675681 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16675681
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoFacebook is powerful and insular. Taking it down requires extraordinary organisation. Outrage is helpful in that respect. Agreement is better than disagreement. Would I prefer we had agreement earlier? Yes. Is agreement today better than agreement tomorrow? Absolutely. Now that we have a constituency, the important thing is to mobilise. The past is in the past. Our job, in the present, is to protect the future.
- themihai 9y agoWell, once you give permission to your data you no longer control how it's stored and shared(at least physically). To make sure you are not caught off guard you should always expect the worst.
- markhahn 9y agoFB is not dropbox, so "deleting" means a different thing.
- danso 9y agoMaybe, but that’s not the case in this article, which describes an obsoleted video feature.
- singold 9y agoThis is why I've never really deleted my FB account, I've just deactivated it. If I don't believe they would truly delete the data I might better have it available if I want it
- thinkingemote 9y agoJust an anecdote. I had a day set aside to purging my Facebook entries a year or two back. I manually deleted comments and posts. Of course there was too many to do and it was very boring so I only spent a couple of hours at it. But that's nots what's interesting. What happened was that I got a huge uptake of people commenting on some old post I made, like a profile picture change. I think Facebook saw I was purging my data slowly and reached out to my FB contacts encouraging them to interact more with me. It was very odd.
- dennisgorelik 9y agoYou made changes to old post (deleted comments), so Facebook decided that because there are some updates to old posts - it makes sense to treat these old posts as new. So Facebook started to show these posts to your friends in their news feeds.
- r00fus 9y agoIsn't that against the goal of a deletion? FB should honor intentions and let deleted stuff not be flagged as "new".
- dennisgorelik 9y ago"What to show" prioritization should mostly focus on the interest a reader (not the writer). I, as a reader, want to see posts with recently deleted [or updated] comments.
- multibit 9y agoIs there not a way to delete all posts and comments at once?
- adventured 9y agoI don't believe so, at least not in the recent past. I purged my FB of all content about 18 months ago, and had to do it manually. Took several hours spread across a few weeks, whenever I could force myself to spend the time on it. For whatever reason I kept finding posts/comments for a few weeks after that; I'd go back to make sure I got everything, scouring the timelines, and there'd be something I missed somehow, quite bizarre.
- hux_ 9y agoAh the 24*7 auto polarising, meme and outrage generating factories built on top of social media attack social media. It's a nice time to be China :) Have fun guys!!
- GavinMcG 9y agoThis is not a substantive comment, and it has no place here. If you have an actual argument to make, especially where you can point to reliable evidence, please do.
- bamboozled 9y agoMeanwhile, FB share price is on the up again ha
- scottmf 9y agoBut still very much down from before the CA story dropped.
- feelin_googley 9y agoHeres something that I noticed earlier today that might be of interest: 420 million Facebook profiles uploaded to archive.org http://www.newshub.co.nz/home/new-zealand/2018/03/the-kiwi-social-network-that-still-has-your-deleted-facebook-data.html http://www.newshub.co.nz/home/new-zealand/2018/03/the-kiwi-s...
- danso 9y agoDefinitely worth noting as another example of how data can be harvested — but also important to point out it was a third-party created archive made from 2007 and 2010. People will still be (justifiably, IMO) unhappy. Just as they were when YourOpenBook made the risk so blatantly obvious.
- mabbo 9y agoHuh. So now I'm starting to think: what if I purposely recorded thousands and thousands of meaningless video? None of my friends would ever see them since I never published them, but Facebook would use up hard drive space storing them. What if a lot of people did that? Suddenly Facebook's cost for hanging onto all these videos would become quite high with no value in doing so. Anyone feel like making a website to help automate that process?
- pishpash 9y agoYou should upload random-pixel uncompressible videos and delete them over and over again. It not only increases storage cost but makes the profile SNR very low. There are general-strike level attack surfaces on these networks, but people don't really care that much.
- r00fus 9y agoDoes their AUP/TOS allow them to lock you out in that case? Lockout would be worse than account deletion. You would have no recourse to fight back on any of their use of your data right?
- philipwhiuk 9y ago> You would have no recourse to fight back on any of their use of your data right? Yes you would if you were European. You can't stop people exercising their legal rights because they broke your terms of service.
- libdjml 9y agoThe scale you’d need to achieve to have even the most minor effect on facebooks vast infrastructure would be enormous. I feel the effort you and countless opt-in people would expend could be redirected to much more fruitful efforts. Convincing people to delete their profiles, for example.
- mynameishere 9y agoWhat if a lot of people did that? That is exactly what a lot of people do. I don't think Facebook is conspiratorially hording funny cat videos. It's just standard practice to flag things as deleted. Everyone does it. I certainly have.
- WovenTales 9y agoThe most unsettling part is in Facebook's response: “We’ve heard that when accessing their information from our Download Your Information tool, some people are seeing their old videos that do not appear on their profile or Activity Log. We are investigating.” Who wants to bet against their investigation being “how to keep users from seeing it.” Anyone?
- pishpash 9y agoIt's no bet. The investigation results in a ticket for another intern to add "WHERE deleted = 0" to the download tool.
- procinct 9y agoGreat idea! I'll make an FB app for that ;)
- jlmorton 9y agoI honestly don't understand this cynicism. Facebook does not want your deleted video, and they certainly don't want to keep it given the current media frenzy, with the CEO under fire. Every application of any complexity has features which inactivate, but don't delete data. At Facebook scale, deleting data is non-trivial, and it would be impossible to immediately delete something. We all have bugs, including extremely critical security bugs, availability-threatening performance bugs, or many other types of bugs. It's strange that we accept those bugs as merely bugs, without assuming a backdoor, or intentional sabotage, but when it comes to personal data, suddenly it's a nefarious plot. It's an odd position to take that Facebook is not only saving these deleted videos intentionally (for what, exactly?) but that they'll now lie to us and pretend to delete them, but only remove it from their Download Information tool. Kudos to Facebook for even having such a tool.
- oculusthrift 9y agothey had to have the tool for gdpr. not because they are good guys
- 9y ago
- AndrewOMartin 9y agoDid they save any of the videos that Google Drive have recently deleted?
- sp527 9y agoOne fascinating outcome of all this fallout is that there's now a readymade excuse to stop using Facebook. My personal observations are that a good number of people have felt 'fatigued' by Facebook for a very long time, but were also unsure of how best to extricate themselves without incurring a social penalty. But now there's an impetus that most people can understand. I'm not sure about how many people will move away or how quickly it'll happen, but the network effects Facebook capitalized on can also work in reverse: if you have just one or two very vocal privacy proponents in a friend circle pushing to get off the platform. One group I'm in recently migrated to Telegram for this very reason.
- adammenges 9y agoDefinitely. I’ve been off Facebook for years but always felt judged for it. In the past few weeks it’s gone from being judged to being applauded for calling it.
- fastball 9y agoIf you truly want privacy and security I would recommend Signal over Telegram -- Telegram has had some controversy with respect to their encryption protocol not being audited, as well as some weird stuff with a very large recent ICO that seems entirely unnecessary except as a money grab and Russian subpoenas for their master private keys.
- eitland 9y ago> and Russian subpoenas for their master private keys. While I cannit defend (or attack, I'm no cryptographer) their crypto they seem to have a solution to this: They say they don't store keys in the same datacenter or even jurisdiction as the customer data they protect. According to them this means getting unencrypted data through a legal process would mean getting a warrant in two or more countries at once.
- philipwhiuk 9y agoThis only works in the US due to the Cloud Act.
- halukakin 9y agoI don't think facebook really deletes any data. You deleting a comment or a picture pretty much means: isvisible=false;
- xab9 9y agoBtw why do we think that the downloadable archive contains everything they have? Because they said so? Just add a bool field to the table "canExport".
- fiatpandas 9y agoI don’t think we think that. Obviously, in the context of HN crowd, FB has no real credibility / ethical compass.
- throwaway2016a 9y agoThis (and the GDPR - even though my company is in the US) are why I now tell the developers on my team to not collect info unless they have a definitive use case as to why to store it. And make sure to delete delete data as soon as it is no longer needed. It helps that my business doesn't monetize via advertising. My guess is what actually happened here is that they had a use case to store it for a few hours or so (incase, say the user changed their mind about posting it) and no one ever bothered to write a cleanup script because "storage is cheap" and possibly "maybe we might have a use case for it someday" I can't imagine this being intentionally. Even if I try to consider malicious use cases I can't think of any where it would be beneficial for Facebook to actually store this data besides being too lazy to clean it up. Edit: Wow. Who new applying Hanlon's razor to this would get me downvoted so badly? I'm going to leave this here unedited and eat the downvotes of the people on an anti-facebook warpath because I think it is important to state that we as people who make tech products often take short cuts (like avoiding dev work because it is cheaper to just keep data in storage) and we need to stop doing that. There is plenty of stuff Facebook does that is beyond the pale but this one is more likely contributed to lazyness, and if you are going to downvote me without explaining why you are not contributing to the conversation.
- dna_polymerase 9y ago> I can't imagine this being intentionally. Even if I try to consider malicious use cases I can't think of any where it would be beneficial for Facebook to actually store this data besides being too lazy to clean it up. Nope. They wrote a routine that makes the video invisible to the actual user but refrained from deleting it right away. That is intentional.
- throwaway2016a 9y ago> That is intentional. It's funny you are so sure of this. And you essentially just called me wrong without providing a use case. My statement was I couldn't think of a use case for them to do this intentionally and your statement does nothing to disprove that. Hiding a video can and probably is just an "UPDATE videos SET visible=0 WHERE id=123" And it is extremely common to soft delete things for hard delete later in case the user made a mistake or law enforcement requests it or any number of reasons. Especially in large distributed systems where things often need to happen asynchronously. Not permanently deleting a soft delete file is not necessary intentional. Anyone who has ever worked on a large software project knows about backlog stories (say, hypothetically, "free up space from soft deleted videos") not being done for years because other priorities keep pre-empting them. Similar reason when writing in a garbage collected programming language the memory isn't freed immediately. Does that mean it was unintentional? Not necessarily but it certainly is plausible that it was unintentional.
- radicaldreamer 9y agoI imagine that the data in those downloads is a fraction of all the data Facebook collects. It seems that they disclose only what is required based on local laws, so it's unlikely they will ever disclose derived data unless forced to (for example, the location data they collect and combine to figure out which people were present at the same party etc.)
- craigvn 9y agoThis is no surprise, virtual delete is common design pattern.
- gsich 9y ago"surprise"
- rapind 9y agoI have no such duty. I'll teach my kids when they get a bit older, but trying to teach adult friends is an unrewarding exercise in futily (mansplaining even).
- Sir_Substance 9y ago>mansplaining even I am fascinated to know how you are going to wedge gender politics sideways into this completely gender neutral conversation. I agree that talking data storage strategies to people that aren't interested is unrewarding, but please mansplain to me how explaining technical concepts is mansplaining? Ideally, also define mansplaining in the process.
- wolco 9y agoI believe the label mansplanting is used by non males to describe men teaching something in detail (often the complex idea is over the head of the person making the label comment). For some they would not like to be educated by males and men explaining technical details that no one asked for qualifies. Many males have stopped educating for fear of that label as most thought they were doing a favo(u)r by sharing. Society as a whole is affected.
- smt88 9y agoYou seem not to know what mansplaining is supposed to mean, whether you believe it exists or not. It just means explaining something to someone who already understands it.
- spicyj 9y agoIt’s most often used when an idea is far _under_ the explainee’s head to the point that any explanation is absurdly unnecessary. That is, mansplaining usually refers to explaining while incorrectly assuming the incompetence of women.
- meddlepal 9y agoIt's simple: - most folks in tech are men - most men date women - in 2018 any attempt a man makes to explain something to a woman is a candidate for being accused of "mansplaining". I'll say one other thing: I honestly have no clue if mansplaining has a more technical definition but in general I see most people interpreting it as a man explaining anything to a woman.
- feelin_googley 9y ago"The guy who was showing me around pointed out where they were building "apartments for our people to live". "So they'll work on campus, they'll eat on campus, they'll socialise on campus and now they'll sleep on campus?" I asked. I wondered whether maybe that was kind of unhealthy. Creepy, even. My guide looked right at me, and for a moment, his megawatt smile faltered. When he first worked there, it reminded him of the Dave Eggers book, The Circle, he said. Then he started talking about the opportunity to connect the world's people, and I stopped listening." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Circle_(Eggers_novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Circle_(Eggers_novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Circle_(2017_film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Circle_(2017_film) Source: https://www.irishtimes.com/life-and-style/people/jennifer-o-connell-i-have-finally-deleted-my-facebook-account-1.3436928 https://www.irishtimes.com/life-and-style/people/jennifer-o-...
- andr 9y agoWhile this may sound creepy for a foreigner, getting a decent apartment in the SF Bay Area is really expensive and the commutes are horrible. So in this context, that could be a good thing.
- AlexandrB 9y agoI think the opposite is more likely to be true. This sounds creepy because it is creepy and the only place it seems reasonable is in the increasingly disconnected culture of Silicon Valley.
- jdavis703 9y agoMany undergraduate, graduate and postgrads live on campus in housing provided by the university, and get paid by the same university. Soldiers in the military live in barracks, even some who would otherwise have the option to live off base. Even expats working for private energy companies abroad sometimes live in corporate housing campuses.
- 9y ago
- arthurofbabylon 9y agoI’m looking forward to HN letting go of this enthusiastic expectation of FB’s demise and putting forth higher quality articles. (Note: I feel the same enthusiasm. I just want to read more meaningful, comprehensive articles.)
- dictum 9y agoFortune cookie: Forgive and forget. Someone must do it and everyone else will not. https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/01/facebook-uses-10000-blu-ray-discs-to-create-petabytes-of-cold-storage/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/01/faceb...
- sandov 9y agoIsn't it kinda obvious that fb 'secretly' stores everything that may be beneficial to the company?. Who is still so naive as to believe that they care about your privacy?
- aidaman 9y ago"They're looking into it." AKA they will continue harvesting the data but be better about not letting you know what is being harvested.
- BadassFractal 9y agoHow do I mass-delete all of my Facebook data? Likes, posts, etc. Is there a reputable tool out there that can take care of it for me since Facebook doesn't provide you with one? I'm generally ok with keeping Facebook just as a contacts list, but I'd rather not have it have anything else.
- Kequc 9y agoStorage costs next to nothing, recovery costs a lot. Why would facebook who depends on this data for income ever delete it. You get two massive benefits from keeping it and setting a "deleted" flag. Why would anyone expect anything different. How entitled do people feel they are.
- speedplane 9y agoIt's quite simple: if someone says they deleted something, you expect them to delete it. If they don't, they are lying, and you can't really trust them with anything else.
- Kequc 9y agoFacebook has been embroiled in back to back privacy scandals since it opened and you still trust them? How much simpler does it get, I agree, that's pretty simplistic!
- luxnoo 9y agoAt what point was any of this news? TOS is clear on this so if this was to bother anyone they would have read that before hand. If I was running a data collection business like google for ad-analytics I wouldn't delete anything either, that's your bottom line your wiping away!
- siruncledrew 9y agoStorage is so cheap, it wouldn't be surprising they save everything they possibly can.
- whalesalad 9y agoIs this really a secret or a surprise? Most SaaS companies of this size don’t really ever delete anything. They set a deletion flag and call it a day.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- derimagia 9y agoYeah for most things this is a good way to do it. For user data when they delete the account it would be ideal if they actually removed it though
- fiatpandas 9y agoWhy would that be the good way to do it? Especially if that deletion action was behind a confirmation, or if the data was never recoverable by the user? At that point, just delete delete it.
- derimagia 9y agoA lot of reasons, here's a simple example: If you have a "product" which had a CRUD interface to make and users who add it to the card, deleting it would cause relationships to fail - as in if users who already purchased the item or added it to their cart would no longer be able to see it.
- m-p-3 9y agoIt's kind of unsurprising. As soon as you upload some data into another system that you do not fully control, you can't really expect or trust the other party to discard it because you want to. Unless there's a good an easy way to store that kind of data and share it with End-to-End encryption (and the server NEVER has access to those keys) so that only authorized users can view the plain data, that problem will remain.
- Capaverde 9y agoLol I'm not impressed by anything at this point. I thought it was clear from the start, they don't care about you, you're the "useds" of facebook, as Stallman would say. But still, every new evidence that comes up confirming this must make into a separate headline, and we'll keep on getting plenty of those until... I don't know. Until it either dies or rebrands itself well enough to pretend all of this never happened, I suppose.
- peter303 9y agoThe has happened numerous times in the past, especially when they switched to timelines. Everything you thought deleted reappeared. Basically once in Facebook, always in Facebook.
- jsemrau 9y agoI always believed in the right to be forgotten. That's why I am not on Facebook nor Google Plus
- ipsum2 9y agoHow does being on HN help? Your comments can't be deleted after a certain amount of time (a few hours).
- PaulStatezny 9y agoAt least Hacker News is transparent about that that behavior. Facebook et al. are not.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jijji 9y agoSomeone should mention also that in the downloadable facebook archive, in the html/ folder, there is a file called contact_info.htm and its a pretty large file. It is apparently every google contact you ever had, all synced to facebook, for every device you ever logged into. So, if you ever might have used a friends device to check your facebook account using then facebook app, then all of that persons contacts are there too, as well as their sms history metadata and call history metadata.
- scottmf 9y agoI’ve let quite a few people log into the Facebook app on my phone and now I’m pissed. I was always careful with privacy settings on Facebook, but the thought never even crossed my mind of what I’d be “agreeing” to by letting someone briefly use my phone. I’m sure someone will come along shortly to tell me I deserve it and should have know better and was asking for it but whatever. How will the GDPR handle instances like this?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ori_b 9y agoYou mean they follow what many people consider best practices? https://softwareengineering.stackexchange.com/questions/159232/should-we-ever-delete-data-in-a-database https://softwareengineering.stackexchange.com/questions/1592... https://stackoverflow.com/questions/820466/never-delete-entries-good-idea-usual https://stackoverflow.com/questions/820466/never-delete-entr... https://serverfault.com/questions/31455/should-i-ever-delete-sql-and-db-anything https://serverfault.com/questions/31455/should-i-ever-delete... https://www.infoq.com/news/2009/09/Do-Not-Delete-Data https://www.infoq.com/news/2009/09/Do-Not-Delete-Data http://udidahan.com/2009/09/01/dont-delete-just-dont/ http://udidahan.com/2009/09/01/dont-delete-just-dont/ https://stackoverflow.com/questions/2549839/are-soft-deletes-a-good-idea https://stackoverflow.com/questions/2549839/are-soft-deletes... https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/blog/soft-delete-for-azure-storage-blobs-now-in-public-preview/ https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/blog/soft-delete-for-azure... I find it fascinating how much shock there is that Facebook is doing what nearly everyone else is doing, and what many people here have likely implemented.
- noobermin 9y agoFacebook lost billions in days and is poised to lose more. I imagine there are more pressing issues than the difficulty of implementing a schema.
- scottmf 9y agoNot just billions but tens of billions. Somewhere around $50B.
- bitexploder 9y agoDisclaimer: I deleted my Facebook account a couple years ago and never looked back. That said, Facebook is who is just getting collectively stabbed with the pitchfork right now. Engineering best practices are one thing. My right to privacy is another. As an engineer I care about efficiency. As a human I care about privacy. My rights win over any technocratic babble. Sorry if I am being harsh. I am, of course not surprised. Engineers are lazy at best and at worst, something truly sinister is brewing.
- kerkeslager 9y agoSecretly? Secretly from whom? There is nothing I've come across, ever, that has lead me to believe that Facebook, Google, Amazon, etc., ever delete anything, ever. Not even to clean up space as some people on this thread are suggesting. Hard drive space is cheap and data is valuable. This isn't a secret, this is a fairly obvious business practice that all the big players, and most competent small players, are engaging in.
- oh_sigh 9y agoGoogle deletes your data within I think 64 days if you request them to or delete your account. https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/32046 https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/32046
- kerkeslager 9y agoThere's nothing there which clarifies that "delete" isn't a euphemism for "flag it to no longer be displayed to users" like it is everywhere else where companies collect data on users, so you'll excuse my skepticism.
- lerpa 9y agoExactly and they have the perfect excuse: "Well when talking about deleting we mean we do the exact same thing the file system does to a file, it flags it, but doesn't actually erase it's content. Acting like a filesystem delete operation is what people expect when using that word"
- kerkeslager 9y agoThat would be somewhat reasonable if it were just an implementation detail. But unfortunately, it's not just an implementation detail. When a filesystem has data to write and runs out of hard drive space, it overwrites the data which was flagged for deletion. But when a web 2.0 company has data to write and runs out of hard drive space, they buy more hard drive space, usually automatically.
- lanevorockz 9y agoI can't believe people don't pay attention. Facebook never removed any data generated, they just remove the index from the data. Deleted data is can be more valuable than data that is kept there.
- Havoc 9y agoI considered this a feature. It's interesting to compare true convo vs what's left after people have backtracked and deleted messages. Especially when the convo was daring so to speak. ;)
- gall_anonim 9y agoI don't care. I stopped caring about my privacy. Nobody will hurt me by knowing too much about me. Facebook can have all of my life, because nothing is private for me. It is a great tool for keeping up with friends, it allows to cultivate friendships a lot easier than anything before. We can have a lot of friends when we don't keep secrets, because by being open with your weaknesses you create new friend, not an enemy. You create enemies with secrets and lies.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cvaidya1986 9y agoHi Mark!
- z3t4 9y agoWhat you put on the Internet might stay there for ever, is an important lesson.
- phwd 9y agoI've downloaded my zip file to try to verify what's going on in the article I think I have an idea of what might have happened. When you add a video to the composer window One of the requests is https://vupload-edge.facebook.com/ajax/video/upload/requests/start/?dpr=1&__a=1 https://vupload-edge.facebook.com/ajax/video/upload/requests... (Look it up in the network tab of whatever browser dev tool you are using) With the response as, for (;;);{"__ar":1,"payload":{"video_id":"11111111111111","start_offset":0,"end_offset":353662,"skip_upload":false},"bootloadable":{},"ixData":{},"gkxData":{},"lid":"1"} The video 11111111111111 is now in an "unpublished" state. "unpublished" here meaning it's uploaded to Facebook but not linked to a post yet. You can verify this by taking that ID and doing the following https://www.facebook.com/11111111111111/ https://www.facebook.com/11111111111111/ -> redirects to https://www.facebook.com/phwd/11111111111111/ https://www.facebook.com/phwd/11111111111111/ "Sorry, this content isn't available right now" Your options now are to either discard the post or publish with a privacy setting which will make the link above available. (Notice I didn't say discard the video, the video is still in an unpublished state) Now for the archive. You can verify by going to view-source:fb.com/me in a browser Search for the string "access_token" there will be a long string appended. (e.g. access_token:"EAAAAU...) With that token go to your archive and roll over one of the links in the video section that has an issue and doesn't appear in the activity log. file:///Users/phwd/Desktop/facebook-phwd-from-zip/videos/11111111111111.mp4 grab the ID 11111111111111 and do the following https://graph.facebook.com/11111111111111?access_token=THE_TOKEN_FROM_view-source:fb.com/me https://graph.facebook.com/11111111111111?access_token=THE_T... That shows an unpublished video for me, it wouldn't show in your activity log (that's the only part of the story I can agree and can confirm with what I have available) To delete add the method=delete to the request. https://graph.facebook.com/v2.9/11111111111111?method=delete&access_token=THE_TOKEN_FROM_view-source:fb.com/me https://graph.facebook.com/v2.9/11111111111111?method=delete... Response should be { "success": true } The next part would be to verify that the video is deleted from the archive. Since Facebook is still giving me the first download zip, I guess I'll have to wait a while (it's 1 am here so I'm heading to bed) until it resets so I can make it build a new archive and confirm the hunch. This is just my guess, I'm NOT discounting what the Facebook user encountered. I'm just providing a possible background to how it can happen as well as a solution to deleting the "deleted" video. There is also the chance I might be wrong... References to confirm for yourself. developers.facebook.com/docs/graph-api/reference/video Disclosure: I don't work for Facebook, however, I do play with their API a bit.
- donatj 9y agoWhat I think so many privacy advocates don’t realize while frothing at the mouth is that odds are 99.9999% no one really wants your old photos or data specifically. Surely in large aggregate, but on a macro level you are no more interesting than anyone else. You’re not. You have a delusion of grandeur. Sure, you might get some targeted ads by data used in aggregate and put you into a group but so what? If I had to see ads, I’d rather them be things I am interested in.
- philipwhiuk 9y agoAh the old nothing to fear argument.
- donatj 9y agoOh, there’s plenty to fear, this just isn’t it. The proliferation of cameras and cellphone tracking hooked to state owned machine learning predicting your decisions - which is publicly happening in China and almost certainly quietly happening everywhere else? Terrifying. Data collection on crap that’s nearly public anyway? Merely a distraction.
- enigmaY 9y agoHow about youtube? Is there any law specifying website must delete the data user choose to remove?
- dbg31415 9y agoI'm shocked. No one saw this coming. * Facebook reads your private messages, California class-action suit alleges. || https://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2014/01/03/facebook_reads_your_private_messages_california_class_action_suit_alleges.html https://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2014/01/03/facebook... * Facebook asks users for nude photos in project to combat 'revenge porn' | Technology | The Guardian || https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/nov/07/facebook-revenge-porn-nude-photos https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/nov/07/facebook-... * Facebook CEO Admits To Calling Users 'Dumb Fucks' || http://gawker.com/5636765/facebook-ceo-admits-to-calling-users-dumb-fucks http://gawker.com/5636765/facebook-ceo-admits-to-calling-use...
- Demcox 9y agoThis can not be a surprise to anyone with a just a bit of skepticism.
- speedplane 9y agoAgreed, but most do not have much skepticism. You and I may have known about Facebook and had accounts (or deleted them) for over a decade, however many current users are relative internet novices.
- izacus 9y agoThere are people on this very site complaning about how "hard" it is to delete data on request to be GDPR compliant. Highly paid developer experts are literaly throwing a fit when told that they should be able to delete data when "Delete" button is clicked. It's not just Facebook.
- john_minsk 9y agoThe funniest part of it: All the media hype around the topic is generated... BY DATA collected by NYT/Bloomberg/Techcrunch/you name it. Those articles generate additional views and they just continue to ride this wave. And all those publications share this data with 3rd parties (ad networks, analytics providers, cpa networks) On top of that, you know what else do they measure? SENTIMENT. So until kicking Facebook generates more revenue - the articles will paint Facebook as a world's main evil. But the day sentiment changes you will see all the articles about Facebook following best practices. And in the end? Some EU commission will be created and make a law which oblige to "show cookie usage disclaimer", because of which 90% of sites welcome you with ugly popup and ruin the experience providing 0% advantage in managing your privacy...
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> On top of that, you know what else do they measure? SENTIMENT. So until kicking Facebook generates more revenue - the articles will paint Facebook as a world's main evil. But the day sentiment changes you will see all the articles about Facebook following best practices. So what you're saying is that sites like nymag will only run stories that are profitable?
- john_minsk 9y agoKind of. When everyone is writing articles AGAINST Facebook, it will be very hard to 'sell' article which SUPPORTS Facebook to the editor (because of the potential PR nightmare when potential 4chan starts attacking you) Article can't go through editor -> article is not published
- nsaaass 9y agoI really do not like fb at all!
- nsaaass 9y agoWhat app can put 2 major spy agencies in same app ? Cia and fbi in facebook app.
- MobutuPehuenche 9y agoI would think this is common practice. I know that YouTube, for example, retains videos indefinitely, because I've personally been able to retrieve videos that were deleted in as early as 2006. It was possible for anyone to do this until some time in 2017, when they started requiring signatures for RTSP streams. All that was needed was the video ID (the eleven characters in every YouTube video URL). Didn't matter if they were private (IDs for these could be enumerated if the channel ID was known), "deleted" over ten years ago, or behind a paywall. From ~2008 until 2015, you could do the same but with higher quality streams through the now-retired Apple TV API.
- appleflaxen 9y agoA lot of these revelations are coming from the fact that Facebook allows you to download the information it has stored about you. There is an exceedingly high chance that the managers are going to notice this. And, rather than doing the right thing by storing less information, they are going to lie about what they have, and put a filter in place regarding what they let you download (a bit) vs. what they actually have (everything). We need to be nuanced in our approach to the world, but it is becoming increasingly clear that Facebook has created a business model that incentivizes (and maybe depends on) evil behavior.
- stjohnswarts 9y agoThis is why for those 'special' videos one should always just use a handheld camera and not their cell phone. But the public will never learn.
- crb002 9y agoCould be non-malicious if they want to prevent redundancy of the same video going up twice or just laziness in engineers who didn't build D in their CRUD.
- charkubi 9y agoGiven any data submitted to FB legally becomes their property, they don’t have any obligation to delete it.
- lanmannen 9y agoIn all likelihood, this is simply the tip of the iceberg. I see Twitter's stock is collapsing, due to similar concerns. Nothing is private anymore in this day and age. And yet - If we're concerned about what Facebook has on us, then just imagine what kind of treasure trove the government sits on.
- Eleopteryx 9y agoI'd have been more surprised if they didn't save them. I always assumed that anything remotely hosted that I "delete" is soft-deleted, and that anything I edit is actually just versioned. (I'm not claiming to be especially smart, just cynical.)
- anonymousab 9y agoFor maximum honesty, they should just rename all of the Delete buttons and text to 'hide' or better yet, 'hide from friends'. Short, simple and to the point.
- feelin_googley 9y ago"I do also think that, you know, Facebook has a responsibility to its users to protect their data and not just to protect it but make sure that people understand what data they're producing and whether they own it, who has access to it and when. And Facebook has failed them, you know, across the board. And the question now is not just what - you know, what can be done to ensure the security of that data. It's, how can we use this moment to ensure that we're having a broader cultural conversation about the data that we're all creating on Facebook, Google, Amazon, through our phones, et cetera and make sure that the companies are held accountable for it?" Source: Facebook co-founder, Chris Hughes https://www.npr.org/2018/03/30/598208043/should-facebook-users-trust-ceo-mark-zuckerbergs-apologetic-tone https://www.npr.org/2018/03/30/598208043/should-facebook-use...
- blackrock 9y agoIt was already known that Facebook burns all user data onto a bluray disc. How do you erase data that's been permanently burned onto an optical medium? You can't.
- schrep 9y agoThis was a bug. There was an old feature that used to allow you to record and post directly from the browser. Those videos were streamed to FB as they were being recorded. If you decided not to post those draft videos should have been deleted but were not. They showed up in download your information (DYI) as expected because that tool is designed to show you the data Facebook has about you. Thanks to New York Magazine for the flag. If you see anything in DYI that doesn't look right, let us know and we'll investigate. This was a bug, and we really do appreciate any help in finding them so we can fix them.
- kough 9y agoI downloaded my information and then deleted my account before realizing that the archive I downloaded did not include any of the photos or posts that I had been tagged in, because I made those posts only visible to me on my timeline.
- dbg31415 9y ago* This Is Why You Should Delete Facebook Permanently || https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/entry/delete-your-facebook-matthias_n_5460164 https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/entry/delete-your-facebook... From 2014. Good summary video.
- wemdyjreichert 9y agoAnd this is why I never signed up for social media in the first place. Remember the afage about stuff on the internet never really going away? Yeah, it's true. Another interesting note: some friends hiring in Austin, TX have told me they can't hire in town because almost every kid has a social media containing drunk pics.
- adamnemecek 9y agowho cares they have pics containing drunk pics online? is the employer supposed to dictate my morality?