41 ms·
Reddit and the Struggle to Detoxify the Internet
- overcast 9y agoThe only way to detoxify the internet, is to get rid of the "social" aspect. Starting with gasp comments. My online experience has been that much better, since adding comment blockers to my browser.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- vesrah 9y agoWhile I agree with you, and I also run a comment blocker, I find it difficult to believe that sites are going to willingly give up the engagement that comments brings.
- golergka 9y agoThis is a comment though.
- overcast 9y agoHN doesn't allow such negativity though. Reddit flourishes on it.
- dymk 9y agoAny thread about Facebook, and most threads about Apple are cesspools of negativity. I think you've got some rose tinted glasses when it comes to the kind of discourse that HN offers.
- irrational 9y agoIt really depends on the subreddit, doesn't it? I only visit subreddits like r/boardgames and while there is the occasional rude person, overall thos subreddits are welcoming uplifting places. Some parts of Reddit are horrid and some parts are beautiful, just like real life. I just don't go to the horrid parts - just like I would avoid the horrid parts of a city.
- Gargoyle 9y ago>HN doesn't allow such negativity though. You do read this site, right? My opinion is that getting rid of voting is step one to making both sites infinitely better. Extremely draconian human moderation is step two.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoI would encourage you to read any thread on harassment or the treatment of women and marginalized people in the tech industry and then revisit that thought.
- jstanley 9y agoI assume the irony of writing that in a comment is not lost on you.
- ASalazarMX 9y agoIt might if he blocked it.
- gruez 9y ago>The only way to detoxify the internet, is to get rid of the "social" aspect. Starting with gasp comments are you talking about the "social" comments, or commenting in general (including this site)?
- ranie93 9y agoPersonally I'm guilty of often seeking out comments before or soon after viewing an article or video online. As social creatures I think its reasonable to want, even need, others opinions. The effects of receiving these opinions may not always be positive, but I think they are necessary. Pragmatically, comment sections can have bots, ads, instigators. I think there is a better solution than outright getting rid of online discussion. There's room here for innovation (Not even technical innovation, I think there's low hanging fruit here in terms of comment section design)
- prepend 9y agoSimilarly, I use comments as a quick screen to filter through the PR/targeted journalism of stories. Not perfect and will eventually stop working as media companies wise up. Similarly, I will frequently check Wikipedia before the company/film/whatever. Flaws, but frequently better than official channels.
- gurkendoktor 9y agoIt doesn't even have to be targeted journalism, sometimes people write junk because they make mistakes or aren't aware of counter-arguments...not even scientific papers are safe from this. Cunningham's Law[1] to the rescue :) I can feel that hostile internet comments take a toll on my overall happiness, but I don't want to be ignorant of valid counter-arguments to the content I read. [1] https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Cunningham%27s_Law https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Cunningham%27s_Law
- jerf 9y agoI've been kicking a design around in my head for the past few weeks which retains most of the outward form of something like Reddit, on the grounds that it has proved to be a model that can attract users, but redefines the upvote and downvote process such that an upvote now means "I want to see more of this poster's comments, and transitively (and weaker as the links go out) what that user sees" and a downvote now means "I'd like to see less of this poster's comments and transitively what they upvoted". The difference here being that upvote no longer means "I think everyone should see more of this comment", but now "I think I should see more of this commenter". I think it ought to be unidirectional to prevent obvious attacks. I'm not too worried about the "filter bubble" because I think you are inevitably in a filter bubble, and it's on you to manage it, not expect random sites on the internet to somehow pop you out of it (they basically can't, by definition). I think I'd still want categorizations for subject, just to give things some sort of focus. The result is that instead of /r/politics or /r/$ANYTHING being captured by some sort of single monolithic gestalt, multiple simultaneous gestalts could be running side-by-side. You'd want some deliberate mixing, both to keep things interesting and because I think you'd want to ensure some "heat" in the simulated annealing sense to ensure that things don't get too isolated and things keep moving. (Communities themselves keep moving, after all.) The net effect of this is that while trolls would still exist, anyone not interested in trolling should naturally filter them out of their view relatively quickly, while the trolls get each other to troll at. Since they can not be eliminated, all you can really do is fence them off. One of the other interesting side effects is that you ought to get some other interesting communities in there, too; the community of people who thoughtfully comment, the community of "doers", etc. One interesting possibility is that this may even allow "celebrities" to have a "social network" that nominally anyone can join, but requires sufficient social proof that it isn't just "anybody with a Twitter account and an itchy trigger finger can get the first reply below $CELEBRITY's tweet.", wrecking the utility of social media for the celebrity. I haven't quite solved the question of how to initialize the communities once the system gets going, but it's probably feasible. What stops me from coding this up is that whenever I start really fleshing this out into an implementable system, I realize it violates one of my life rules: "Never engage in an endeavor in which the worst case scenario is complete success." I don't want to run a community site like that. So for me personally, the outcome matrix boils down to "Failure -> waste of time, Success -> oh shit". Because even if this did miraculously fix all social issues, which I am hardly naive enough to suppose, there's still legal compliance, DMCA compliance, etc., all sorts of things I personally have no desire or drive to do. However, by all means, feel free to "steal" my idea. While I am by no means an expert in this field (the aforementioned paragraphs are pretty much the sum total of my thinking at this time), I'll even spot you some free "consulting" in the form of playing intelligent-rubber-duck to bounce ideas off of if you'd like. And let me know if you get to deployment.
- ploxiln 9y agoAnd yet here we both are, commenting, on the internet ...
- ASalazarMX 9y agoReddit has a large user base and a myriad of subreddits where different solutions have been tried. So far, the best I've seen is strong moderation: clear rules and swift enforcement. AskScience is a shining example of a high quality subreddit, although the comment section usually looks like a graveyard with 90% of the comments removed.
- jstanley 9y agoI'd like to see moderation decoupled from the forum namespace. So you'd subscribe to a forum namespace in order to see posts about a topic (say, AskScience), but you would then also subscribe to whichever moderators you want. The moderation wouldn't be inextricably tied to the namespace. Anybody can post anything in any namespace (and anybody can declare themselves a moderator of any namespace), but people will only see posts if their chosen moderators allow it. You could have all of the same moderation powers that exist at the moment, except any given moderator's actions are optional to any given user's view of the forum. We wouldn't need a situation like with r/bitcoin and r/btc where disagreements about moderation resulted in a splinter group creating a separate namespace: those who disagreed with moderator X would simply unsubscribe from X's moderation. I don't know if this would result in a better forum, but I'd be interested to see how it's different, and I don't know of anywhere it's been tried. (And in case someone out there is granting wishes... can I also have it decentralised e.g. using IPFS's pub sub?)
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoYep. That was usenet. But in those days, we didn't have 3rd party recommended filters - but there's no reason why they wouldn't work now. Maybe it's time to remake Usenet, minus binaries. Binaries, piracy, and their data load per server are what killed Usenet. (Yes, I know it's still living on in paid-service world. But gone are the days your ISP runs a machine.)
- jstarfish 9y ago> Binaries, piracy, and their data load per server are what killed Usenet. Binaries and piracy were two of the biggest reasons to use Usenet. Spam is what killed it.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoI agree, on areas of general topics (news, current events, et cetera), the comments are cancer. As more comments are posted, racism/sexism/ageism/horribleness approaches 1. The comment section changes a lot if you stick with tech sites and peoples' blogs, or project sites like github/gitlab/hackaday.io . In those cases, people are 99% of the time pretty decent. They may demand a feature on a FLOSS git* page, but aside of entitlement attitudes, it's relatively non-poisonous.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- JorgeGT 9y ago> Huffman can no longer edit the site indiscriminately There's precisely zero proof of this.
- ManlyBread 9y agoWasn't there a case where he did precisely that by editing a post of a Trump supporter?
- saynay 9y agoObviously not, there is no way to prove it.
- bduerst 9y agoi.e. You can't prove a negative
- adpirz 9y agoIt's described in the article... EDIT: I misunderstood OP, I thought the comment was saying there was zero proof of Huffman's ability to tamper in the first place. Agreed there's no way to prove he can't do this anymore.
- Nadya 9y agoMind quoting the passage that describes the measures in place? I just read the entire article and absolutely zero proof is provided that Huffman can no longer edit things. It mentions Spezgiving, followed by Huffman's apology, and then moves onto banning subreddits, to the meeting about banning subreddits, and ends at /r/Place and the worry it'd be nothing but swastikas. Absolutely nowhere is anything described about the measures in place to prevent Huffman - or anyone else at Reddit for that matter - from editing posts.
- jasonmaydie 9y agoI would argue we don't need to detoxify the internet, stopping trolling is missing the point however we should stop the spread of misinformation, in fact sites like reddit and facebook rarely create information, they just consume it blindly without questioning the source
- Infernal 9y agoI'm less sure regarding Facebook (as I'm rarely on it) but there is a large amount of information created (or at least initially disseminated) on reddit. Places like /r/DIY, /r/woodworking, and countless others are chock full of original content and helpful users willing to answer questions and get into a dialogue down in the weeds.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ScipioAfricanus 9y agoIt's not that the "trolls are winning", it's that people are allowing the trolls to bother them. Trolls have always existed; it's our heightened sensitivity and inability to just shrug them off or laugh in the face of their obscenity that's letting them "win".
- dieterrams 9y agoTrying to get everyone to not be bothered by trolls is a massive and neverending undertaking.
- Infernal 9y agoBut policing the expression of wide (and fluidly defined) swaths of thought that some believe to be "toxic" isn't?
- dieterrams 9y agoI just don’t think saying “people shouldn’t let themselves be bothered” is at all a viable solution. Automated troll detection is clearly a hard problem, but I’m not convinced it’s unsolveable. Whereas getting people to not be bothered is, unless people start living forever and have no offspring, by its very nature a commitment without end.
- Karunamon 9y agoYet much more modest than the policing of content that Facebook and the like seems to be interested in. That goes double when it’s two clicks to permanently dismiss someone from your attention. The best troll repellant is and always has been to ignore them.
- taurath 9y agoIts also impossible. You're not going to have a close conversation with a group of people when a little kid is jumping up and down and screaming for attention in public. Ignoring them doesn't work for either trolls or bullys. Either they run the show, or you do something about them, end of story.
- castis 9y agoAs long as there are no consequences to being a dick to people over the internet, "toxic internet" is here to stay.
- devmunchies 9y agoSticks and stones. More concerning is the large scale propaganda and marketing.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Slansitartop 9y agoExactly, but only as long as you take precautions that no one can escalate online harassment to something that's a real-life problem. I'm pretty comfortable online, but mainly because I only post under frequently-changed pseudonyms and never leak much personal info. If someone gets obsessively mad at me, I can just abandon the account and be done with it.
- castis 9y agoThis has nothing to do with "getting your feelings hurt". If someone is a dick to you IRL, you just go about life without them and its of zero consequence to you. Imagine if they stayed in your life outside of your own accord and just yelled dumb shit at you from the sidelines. Not everyone is built as strong as you, it bothers some people.
- superkuh 9y agoBeing someone who choses to take offense and get upset about every little thing is their problem. Not everyone elses.
- castis 9y agoGenerally speaking, you and I agree on that much. However, we're talking about how filters and algorithms won't stop people from being dicks to each other.
- mozumder 9y agoSocial media sites are learning the hard way that they're media properties like any other media property, and that they have to have strong editorial control over their media property to be a proper media business. Reddit is a hive of working-class populism, which is incompatible with any advertising-oriented business. Advertisers don't want their ads next to shitty toxic content. They want their ads next to elite, well produced content. You think Calvin Klein wants their beautiful fashion ads next to a photo of a dead body? Sure they can get 10 cent ads of your neighbor's garage sale to place next to the photo of a dead body, but to get the $5 million ad buy from Proctor & Gamble, they'll need editors to raise the quality of their content. Detoxification is central to any ad-based business. How quickly they learn this is the question for Reddit.
- xenihn 9y agoReddit initially rose to prominence because of bad decisions on Digg's part. Reddit is nothing without its users. Any decision that potentially drives users off its platform can't be made lightly.
- mozumder 9y agoAs a media business, they can be a lot more profitable with fewer high-quality users than hordes of low-quality toxic users. A fashion magazine only has 1 million subscribers, but can make $400 million/year in revenue, basically printing money.
- Slansitartop 9y ago> As a media business, they can be a lot more profitable with fewer high-quality users than hordes of low-quality toxic users. I see no evidence of that. > A fashion magazine only has 1 million subscribers, but can make $400 million/year in revenue, basically printing money. A fashion magazine doesn't outsource its content production to its subscribers.
- mozumder 9y ago
- minimaxir 9y agoIt's worth noting that instead of community management, Reddit has been soft-pivoting to become a new Facebook with features like group chat, new profile designs, and a News Feed-esque view on the official mobile apps. Incidentally, Facebook itself hasn't solved the problem of its community/fake news, hence the recent algorithmic changes to the News Feed to surface more content from friends, and a public push toward Facebook Groups. To be like Reddit. It's a never-ending cycle.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ben_jones 9y agoThey couldn't make enough money with their current monetization model so they're copying the arguably most successful player in their market (FB). It'll be interesting to see how it plays out because of reddit's "anonymity", its lack of real social connections (friends, family, that cute person who sits next you you in econ), or any kind networked apps (whatsapp, instagram, messenger, ...).
- digitalantfarm 9y agoReddit used to be a place where you could post links to anything on the internet (kind of like this place) and comment on it (without signing up with your email). Now it's place more like Facebook with algorithms based on your personal taste, geolocation, forced email, shadow banning, banning of politically incorrect subreddits, endless political posts and "Futurology" and "Uplifting" news articles. Free speech on reddit died a long time ago.
- klodolph 9y agoI’ve also noticed recently that Reddit has gotten extremely aggressive towards people using it without an account or using it on mobile without installing the app. I’m addicted to it enough, thank you, without having a dedicated app for it.
- skrowl 9y agoReddit only used free speech as a draw until it got enough user to make money by pushing agendas. It's been agenda-pushing high censorship for years now, but some people just started noticing around the 2016 US election where they didn't even try to hide their obvious bias anymore. In an age where any opposing opinions are consider "toxic" by some, I don't think trying to "detoxify" should be a goal. If you don't like the opinions of a subreddit, don't go to that one.
- taurath 9y agoIts been relatively rare that unpopular opinions offered in good faith are punished with anything other than downvotes on reddit. People don't post opinions with the intent to convince, they post with the intent to deceive or create a reaction, IE trolling. That has been the big wave that has taken over, its just taken the conservative political sphere over far quicker. The other wave is the circle-jerk - a relentless and all-encompassing embrace of confirmation bias, institutionalized to keep a fundamentalist purity of thought. This is beyond a normal echo chamber, these are high powered ideology amplifiers. We've never had the concept of unlimited freedom of speech, and most of the time that its been curtailed, it has been to protect against those who use it in bad faith (fire in a crowded theater, etc). That is the toxicity - IMO Reddit is going to learn this lesson far too late, and allow a group that doesn't want to be there anyway take down the whole site when they leave.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- TAForObvReasons 9y agoGiven that reddit is a Y Combinator alumnus, did anyone at YC contemplate the current mess of the internet back when they applied? I'm curious about the questions asked back then and how they would be answered now
- panarky 9y ago> Struggle to Detoxify the Internet The internet isn't toxic. It's the people who are toxic. These people are just as noxious in real life even if some of them hide it when their identities are known. Can anything be done to detoxify the people, or do we just treat them like spam and filter them out? And what happens next when millions of rabid voices are suppressed? The toxic people don't cease to exist, we just won't be able to see them as well. Perhaps we'll find the social and political environment of 2022 to be much darker and more dangerous than 2018.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoThese people are just as noxious in real life even if some of them hide it when their identities are known. I suspect most of them are rather pathetic in real life.
- majos 9y ago> It's the people who are toxic. I half-agree with this. The internet doesn't make a genuinely kind and empathetic person into a troll. But I think it does amplify certain bad little impulses that are latent in pretty much everybody -- the temptation of quick and cutting putdowns, mob and tribal mentality, lobbing rhetorical bombs then ignoring the consequences... There is a qualitative difference between a back-and-forth on Twitter (or even HN) and a back-and-forth in real life. There's way more trust in good faith in the latter.
- ecommerceguy 9y agoAnd Reddit has been toxic since day 1. https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/z4444w/how-reddit-got-huge-tons-of-fake-accounts--2 https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/z4444w/how-reddit... They were Fake news before fake news was a thing.
- nostalgeek 9y ago> These people are just as noxious in real life even if some of them hide it when their identities are known. I don't think so. A lot of people, and this is especially true with Twitter, get noxious because they found an audience there to "amuse" and entertain, which might amplify the temptation for "troll behavior", especially when that audience is of the same political/cultural leaning as the speaker. Social media inflate egos. Some people who might feel insecure in real life find a community there where they can feel like someone, not by doing something positive but by being mean and condescending to whom they deem their ennemy. However social media didn't create these divisions, they just amplify them. IMHO Twitter is a proof that even with real identities, people will engage in toxic behavior provided they feel supported by a large audience. Of all the social media I found Twitter to be the nastiest of all. By contrast, aside from a few brigading, Reddit communities are often isolated, self contained and don't "leak". It takes a user to actively go on a sub to see its content, while Twitter is constantly pushing stuffs to its users, even the nastiest ones.
- harlanji 9y agoAll this centralization has created all these problems. We need to federate our systems, perhaps at the app level even. I worked at OpenTable for a short and their arch was interesting. Each PoP in the old version is its own system that pushes data central. Tho they’re replacing it with a new generation of centralization presumably due to eng maintenence concerns. Similar with their regional frontends, seems they’re being consolidated. I am coming to think nested intranets and special purpose vpns might be a good approach to global commerce and expression. I love building massive scale no touch systems, but they’re never that perfect once they start being used. Eg. Usually you end up with more severe and harder to solve issues with one massive db vs. smaller systems with derived data and links. And on the FE a lot of hard problems go away, beyond i18n etc also cyber bullying etc become tractable.
- tabeth 9y agoSo we've tried: - Real identities (Facebook comments) - Voting and self moderation (Reddit, HN, etc.) - Strong moderation (Reddit, HN) They all result in toxic comments, trolling, an echo chamber,or worse, a complete lack of participation. There's no real solution to this problem. However, if you create consequences or a cost to commenting you'd eliminate toxic comments and trolling at the cost of less participation and an echo chamber (though, you could argue that not all participation is equal and you're mainly removing poor participants). There's no perfect way to do this because even if you made a subscription necessary, for instance, you may just create an echo chamber. As part of the solution you'd need to prevent the creation of new accounts to circumvent any punishment received. I'd say the most straightforward solution is that you have a forum and you get an account. Physical mail is sent to your house in order to get a single account. Then, regular moderation practices would be taken seriously as there's no way to create another. The community would be left with those who care enough to not be banned. The problem is that the moderators themselves may be corrupt or wrong. Thoughts?
- jasonmaydie 9y agoThe real solution is making blatant lies and misinformation illegal.
- tabeth 9y agoWithout perfect information and transparency there's no way make lies illegal.
- bufferoverflow 9y agoAnd who determines what's true and what's not?
- Consultant32452 9y agoDonald Trump, obviously.
- belltaco 9y agoAt the risk of excessive red tape, the judicial system has been doing a reasonable job of determining facts in most modern countries.
- wnevets 9y agoReddit has zero problem leaving post that threaten the lives of an entire religious group on their frontpage. If they were serious certain subs would be nuked.
- favorited 9y agoYeah – until it affects their PR or advertising, they don't care. There are some vile, disgusting subs out there.
- oreo81 9y agoPeople might think the subs that you frequent are vile and disgusting. Which is fine, they don't have to go there, just like you don't have visit the subs that you don't like. Just because you consider them vile and disgusting doesn't mean you get to decide that for other people.
- ralusek 9y agoYou realize that is a perfectly reasonable objective for a site to be a mostly impartial, user-moderated forum, right? I don't consider any view I encounter on reddit to be endorsed by the platform. If people want content moderated with a specific slant, just subscribe to the subreddits that suit your tolerance, there are plenty that are heavily moderated. Personally, I love seeing things that I disagree with on reddit...it's honestly one of the last places left that gives me the feeling of exposure to different bubbles.
- overthemoon 9y agoThe parent commenter specifically said "post[s] that threaten the lives of an entire religious group". Hardly comparable to something someone can simply disagree with.
- ralusek 9y agoThose are also specific posts, but most of the posters who share the sentiment of the commenter typically advocate for the removal of entire subreddits. Also, to be frank, I think that posts of that nature are exactly the kind of thing that someone can and should disagree with. Suppression of those beliefs by silencing them just means they are moved away from platforms through which their views can be better contextualized for them. The prevailing attitude that some people are just not worth debating says more about the person who holds that belief than it does about those they're accusing of never budging. I have had my mind changed many times, as well as changed the minds of others.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoI don’t know if you can do this. The problem with social news sites is not that the trolls are winning but it is that the moderators aren’t properly compensated because no website has the capability of moderating large websites. Also to get advertisers on your platform you need a moderated forum that aligns with your advertisers. The internet always had free speech and with that comes trolls by definition . The difference now is that there are competiting ideologies associated with websites that want to control vast parts of the internet . We have websites that want your pictures , attention and comments for free in exchange to promote other people’s products. On the site operators side they need to do deals with advertisers who don’t want that controversial topics. So the advertisers force discussions on the platform to only align with them. Or the site operators do this. Solving the troll problem is not going to be solved just by reddit.
- randyrand 9y agoDoes detoxify mean getting rid of mean speech?
- jimhefferon 9y agoA few minutes reading /r/The_Donald shows that there is a vast difference between saying "that guy on the internet hurt my feelings" and "this is a threat to civil society."
- randyrand 9y agoSo what does detoxify mean exactly?
- s73v3r_ 9y agoThere was a post on /r/The_Donald not long ago calling for shooting all refuges in the US on sight. Do you feel that is just "mean speech"?
- oreo81 9y agoI saw that exact post on r/sandersforpresident!
- prepend 9y agoIt depends on the discussion and I’d need to see the link. While obviously calls for violence are illegal (FBI steps in), there are many possibilities where the discussion could be useful (eg, convincing people to better understand refugees). Largely I’ve been desensitized to complaints about TD as typically it results in hyperbole (eg, election was a direct threat to people’s lives).
- s73v3r_ 9y ago"It depends on the discussion" You're gonna have to provide a context in which this wouldn't be a terrible and unacceptable thing to say, cause I can't think of one.
- randyrand 9y agoWould it be sufficient for every user to just have client side configurable filters? Or is this movement more about denying "toxic" people a platform to begin with? If it's the latter case, I can't get behind it. Free speech means everyone should have a platform to speak. As society transitions away from using our mouths to using our keyboards, the first amendment implies that speech should be protected on the common medium - whether verbal or text.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoFilters can work after the fact, but they don't prevent a lot of it to start. As for "toxic", the article is referring to things like /r/CoonTown, or brigades like the one that went after Leslie Jones on Twitter a number of years ago. The people behind those already have a platform to speak: The Internet. They're not entitled to space on another platform like Reddit or Twitter, and they're not entitled to force their speech in front of someone else's face.
- prepend 9y agoCoon town is obviously offensive, but easily avoided (ie, not a problem). I casually followed the Leslie Jones incident and don’t see the problem. The brigading seemed easily avoided by Jones and was actually amplified by media covering how bad it was. My twitter feed doesn’t show mentions by randos, so Jones should have been able to easily filter out at the client. She may have for all I know. So both your examples seem easily solved by client filters to not force speech in faces.
- s73v3r_ 9y ago"Coon town is obviously offensive, but easily avoided (ie, not a problem)." It is until it starts to leak. "I casually followed the Leslie Jones incident and don’t see the problem." I honestly cannot see how one can see the incident, and cannot see a problem with thousands of posters telling an African American woman that she's an ape. "The brigading seemed easily avoided by Jones" That is blaming the victim. "So both your examples seem easily solved by client filters to not force speech in faces." Except they're not.
- kazanz 9y agoI'd argue that a cross-internet reputation service would fix this problem. 1. The reputation system is affected by voting on all sites in which you participate. 2. The history of your participation across sites is viewable in your history (ala reddit, HN) 3. Your reputation is displayed with you participation wherever you participate. Sites could then put reputation limits only allowing users above a certain reputation to participate. Making the cost of toxicity increase. The biggest problem would be getting the walled gardens to adopt the system.
- bufferoverflow 9y agoEven if you can make that work, that will only lead to the tyranny of the majority. You're filtering for the most common denominator opinions. I wouldn't want to be a part of this kind of sterilized community. And how will you solve brigading? All it takes is two large groups disagreeing on something, and your reputation goes down the drain if you're in the slightly smaller group.
- kazanz 9y agoYour reputation will go down, with THOSE people. If they refuse to agree they refuse to agree. There is nothing toxic about that. An accounts "history" and "reputation" will be tied to each site. A liberal who posts regularly on echo chambers on both sides of the aisle will have a middle of the road reputation. On Fox news for example you'd see next to their comments: FoxNews.com Rep: -123 Global Rep: 38 A high global rep is due to the high score posting comments on WashingtonPost articles. Where you would see: WashPost.com Rep: 161 Global Rep: 38 I'd expect someone with a reputation of 0 to be an honest individual gaining views on both sides of an argument. Someone with a global rep of -1833 is probably a troll or someone who doesn't interact with "like-minded" people, which could of course be seen by looking at the history of where the reputation came from. You as a consumer, would most likely flag site reps to show on all pages, so maybe you on every site you visit would see a users reputation like so regardless of the site you are on: Current Site Rep: 3 FoxNews.com Rep: 283 WashPost.com Rep: -87 Global Rep: 221 And you could, of course, dig into their history of reputation, and even Hide/star particular users who you notice are trolls/note-worthy to you personally.
- throwaway84742 9y agoAside from the degenerate cases like “kill all white men” or “liberalism is a mental disorder”, one man’s “toxic comment” is another man’s “common sense”. And as frustrating as it may be to SV digital overlords they don’t get to decide which is which, at least not without unpleasant repercussions down the line. So there’s really no way to solve this. There is a way to contain it somewhat: create homogeneous bubbles. Which is what we’ve been observing over the past few years.
- abvdasker 9y agoOr, rather than giving up or "creating homogeneous bubbles" instead you could look at things on a case-by-case basis as Reddit is doing. At the end of the day the privately run company does get to decide whether content warrants removal or not since they are running a business and advertisers don't like advertising in a space associated with extreme or harmful content. They also have an incentive not to take the moderation too far since to do so would put the company's most valuable asset — its user base — at risk.
- throwaway84742 9y agoTrouble begins when you try to define “harmful” content outside the most egregious cases. Politics inevitably creep in. Worse, these days some people think that “words are violence”, that being offended gives them any rights (and thus creates the vicious cycle of being offended by more and more inane things), and that everyone who voted for Trump is a Nazi. How far are you willing to go, as a private company, to please your advertisers? And how far will your user base allow you to go before deserting en masse?
- zeristor 9y agoThis, to me, sounds like the zombie apocalypse we were promised.
- UrukParthian 9y agoToxic statements = statements from a different political orientation Why are people so willing to embrace Orwellian doublethink? My prediction is that such a sword will do decapitate undeserving people of all political aisles.
- sincerely 9y agoThe article is largely about removing flagrantly racist content (the subreddits they listed as examples were like r/KKK and r/CoonTown) and various illegal content like bestiality videos. It seems disingenuous to classify these as simply "different political orientation".
- prepend 9y agoAs much I disagree with racists, I believe that a healthy society must allow them to speak. I tried to find a quote from Dershowitz’s book on defending Nazis but gave up due to paywall. Toxic is not an objective measure for speech. But like in real life, toxicity depends on the dose. Life doesn’t eliminate toxins, it reduces them to manageable levels (or dies). There’s also the practical effect that banning is irreversible. Toxicity is not terminal, but banning doesn’t allow for redemption.
- cryoshon 9y agoagreed. but consider how the people being banned will see things. i don't suggest we cater to them, just that we realize their way of thinking and reacting.
- UrukParthian 9y agoWhat's wrong with racism? I spent two years homeless on Skid Row. I will never, ever, move to a black majority neighborhood. That's not "toxic", that's me making an intelligent rule. It doesn't mean I denigrate my black friends. The ones I know are "salt of the Earth". As in I'd die for them. It doesn't mean I won't hire a black applicant. It might seem impossible but one can adopt general rules and still hold exceptions for corner cases. Or even (gasp) withhold judgement of individuals until you get a better idea what type of person they are.
- rdl 9y agoRather than censorship, just give readers better filtering tools. This was largely solved on USENET years ago, has been largely solved in email (to a great degree) -- it's just Twitter, FB, etc. which seem to have a hard time solving it. If you made certain sets of filters the default, or available in groups, and did filtering based on your best beliefs about the desires of readers (based on keywords, senders, and maybe other characteristics of the conversation), it would go a long way.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoHow would you do that in such a way as to prevent a Twitter army from piling on someone? Or at least make it so they don't feel they're being bombarded?
- CaptSpify 9y agowildcard filters on content and meta-data go a long way
- rdl 9y agoAt some point go whitelist or raise thresholds very high (like, on twitter, only people you follow, or blue checks, show up in your timeline if abuse is detected, as a very rough pass. Could easily do something far better.)
- CaptSpify 9y agoI think this is the real solution. Instead of giving people useable, client-side filters, we've let companies push us to using shitty, broken website filters so that they can control the flow of information. Client-side filters work great, and they are how we generally solve these types of problems with other communication methods, and do so relatively successfully.
- apeace 9y agoA lot of commenters here are mentioning that better education could help solve this problem. I agree. What if there were a new type of "teacher" who replaced or augmented regular mods on sites like Reddit? Universities strive to hire professors who will teach students to be open-minded, consider the sources of information, and just think better in general. The prestige of each university is largely based on this factor. We tend to measure this by looking at the research accomplishments of the professors, or by looking at how many great thinkers/leaders come out of those universities. What if sites like Reddit did the same thing, and tried to build their prestige based on excellent moderation? Could they be measured by how many great ideas/movements come out of the platform? How do universities prevent the "echo chamber" effect where a few mods or a few users can take the whole conversation in one direction?
- VLM 9y ago"How do universities prevent the "echo chamber" effect where a few mods or a few users can take the whole conversation in one direction?" They turbocharge group think. Probably not the best example of an open minded community. A distant cousin of my wife went to a Seminary; within a relatively narrow range of beliefs, he claimed there was a lot more intellectual freedom than universities along the lines of teaching how to talk to devil's advocates and heresies and converting non-believers. More of a carrot and stick than university which is solely stick-style, who can most emphatically say "I can't even" and so on.
- aje403 9y agoMost people are idiots. Consider that half of the population (hypothetically) has less than a 100 IQ score. Idiots did different things together 100 years ago and, 1000 years before that, groups of idiots would get together to raid and rape and pillage. They still do that in other places in the world. Now they come onto the internet to send hateful things and porn to one another. Most of the biggest idiots do not go on reddit. When the idiots on reddit act up, management cleans it up a little bit. Is there an issue that needs to be fixed here? I think anyone even claiming to have a solution may belong to the former group
- rexpop 9y agoThe human brain is a fantastic computer. Most people are geniuses, constantly crunching stochastic phenomenal trajectories, and navigating ever-changing real and virtual terrains. The problem isn't how smart we are, but on what we focus.
- aje403 9y agoGreat point. Then perhaps we should aspire to be like gorillas, instead. Instantaneous, implicit martingales and brownian motion calculation in their minds subconsciously, exactly like us, except, they don't shitpost on the reddit.
- wufufufu 9y ago"Since the early 20th century, raw scores on IQ tests have increased in most parts of the world. When a new version of an IQ test is normed, the standard scoring is set so performance at the population median results in a score of IQ 100. The phenomenon of rising raw score performance means if test-takers are scored by a constant standard scoring rule, IQ test scores have been rising at an average rate of around three IQ points per decade." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligence_quotient https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligence_quotient You assume too much about half of the human population.
- aje403 9y agoI suspected that I shouldn't have put that into my post or should have qualified it with a statement regarding how completely useless of a metric it is. My general point was that probably around half of the planet is humping a tree as we type at our computer and pontificate about the human potential and dignity, regardless of a useless score that slightly correlates with things.
- calebgilbert 9y agoOh, mai. Where is the tldr; for this one
- siegecraft 9y agoThis problem is easy to solve: give users the tools to do their own filtering. But services like to pretend that it's a hard problem because they don't want to actually cede that control to their users. The whole point of controlling the communication networks is to control what and how people say and hear.
- prepend 9y agoIt’s surprising how much social media bullshits on this issue. RSS had the standard and solution a decade ago. Being able to filter even by simple regex would be so much better than Facebook/Google’s “algorithm.” But it would allow us to filter out ads. It would also allow for community-driven white/black lists. But again, wouldn’t allow Coke and HBO to make you look at stuff.
- sbarre 9y agoIndeed.. Social media users don't get those tools because they are not the customers, they are the product.
- Torwald 9y agoThe people who downvoted you are idiots.
- gowld 9y agoAnd Usenet and email had the solution a decade or two before RSS. The march of progress is in dumbing things down so the average person doesn't have to think, and the intelligent person isn't permitted to think.
- gdubs 9y agoWe tend to think we’re more in control of our behavior than we actually are. That is, our brains are operating from habit a large amount of the time, and the idea of the CEO brain consciously deciding our every action is largely an illusion. This is why emergency exit doors must open outwards. People have died in fires in theaters trying to push on doors that said “Pull”. The crash bar on an emergency exit door is what’s known in design as an affordance. When you present people with a door handle that affords “pulling”, they will pull even if the sign says “push”. Now consider the fact that the primary affordance of social media is the “reaction”. Is it a surprise that content that garners a reaction will trend towards the outrageous? If proactivity is the road to a more fulfilled, more civilly minded life and society, maybe we need to think of our affordances. Because we’ve made it awfully easy to be reactive, and awfully cumbersome to be proactive. Edit: The comments below correctly point out an error; what I should have said was that there’s a danger in putting a “pull” handle on an emergency door that pushed outward, because of the confusing affordance.
- InvisibleCities 9y ago>This is why emergency exit doors must open outwards. People have died in fires in theaters trying to push on doors that said “Pull”. The crash bar on an emergency exit door is what’s known in design as an affordance. Is this true? I always assumed it was because it's pretty much impossible to pull open a door when you are being crushed by people pressing against one another trying to escape.
- piptastic 9y agoI think it's true to some degree, I've seen people push on doors that say "pull" even when there is no fire. But I think your assumption is probably more correct, past a certain point they have no option to pull anymore.
- jclardy 9y agoThe push/pull "mistake" is usually caused by poorly designed doors. Like putting a vertical grab handle on a door that pushes open.
- cup-of-tea 9y agoI quit reddit for good on Saturday. There are two major problems with it: - Downvoting creates echo chambers, - No accountability for moderators. I think the downvoting should be removed completely. Downvoting is basically giving people the power of a mini-censor and the people love it. Subreddits can be completely censored by moderators and there's no way to know this is happening. Maybe reddit can develop a way to judge the behaviour of the moderators. Like showing what posts they removed, for example. I've been part of plenty of internet communities that don't become like this. Even completely public forums and IRC channels. I guess HN isn't as bad as reddit because we have an above-average intelligence crowd, but there are some opinions I am careful not to mention here as well.
- prepend 9y agoHow do you filter out user sentiment without downvotes? I think there are flaws in downvoting, but they are less than systems with only upvote (eg Facebook). Upvote only encourage extreme views that attract attention because if 5% like and 95% dislike (theoretical) this is ranked higher than 4% and 0% dislike. What we really need is a score that is like as percentage of views that will be more meaningful. Mixing in some sort of cost to post/vote will help as well because people will be more judicious with likes. Currency is hard to work out as steem is a big fluffed-fest. Maybe something where you get credits every day and can exhaust or bank them.
- cup-of-tea 9y agoI've never actually used Facebook so I haven't seen the effects of only upvoting. But up/downvoting is not meant to signal agreement or disagreement anyway. It's meant to signal whether it's a useful post or not. But people treat it as the former which is why it creates echo chambers. I think the Facebook "upvote" is meant to signal agreement. Does it also make the post go to the top?
- prepend 9y agoSomething like that. Ultimately it doesn’t matter what up/down vote is supposed to mean. It matters what the outcome is. Up means prioritize, down means deprioritize.
- VLM 9y agoFor, uh, purely scientific purposes I've noticed the posting volume on pr0n subreddits like /r/gonewild and uh, a few dozen similar subreddits, is perhaps 100 to 1000 times the sheer posting volume of a controversial subreddit like /r/the_donald. The sheer volume of relatively R rated pr0n is perhaps 1000 times the volume of everything else. There seems to be tap dancing around the issue that reddit is a 1960s Playboy magazine fifty years in the future. There's just enough excellent articles to keep the advertisers amused, but the fact has to be faced that 99% of the traffic is young men looking at scantily dressed young women. You need a little submarine PR to stay controversial about subreddits nobody on a statistical basis reads to keep things legit appearing, whereas all the traffic and money is over there at /r/randomsexiness Just like the old saying about Playboy, I only read it for r/ama not the nekkid ladies. I'm not complaining; I'm just pointing out that reddit is THE most successful pr0n site out there with the most brilliant strategy I've ever seen. Please don't confuse it, and its achievements within the pr0n industry, with legacy news media or anything like that.
- naasking 9y ago> There's just enough excellent articles to keep the advertisers amused, but the fact has to be faced that 99% of the traffic is young men looking at scantily dressed young women. Then again, these young men probably aren't paying attention to the ads (unless maybe they're porn ads!), so those subreddits aren't a target audience.
- andrewmcwatters 9y agoThat's legitimately hilarious. Thanks for sharing this tidbit.
- IshKebab 9y agoWhat tidbit? His totally made up statistics? Because I've noticed that the amount of posting on mainstream subreddit is maybe 5-7 gazillion times more than the porn ones so he's full of shit.
- andrewmcwatters 9y ago
- allthenews 9y agoI detest this smug mentality, that so called trolling is trivial to identify and differentiate from legitimate, but unpopular opinion. I feel strongly about it because it creates opportunity for censors, both in the form of moderators and communities themselves, to stifle debate under the guise of "detoxification." This kind of communal policing is ground zero for the echo chamber phenomenon. We live in a reality where there will always be those who abuse platforms of communication for nefarious purposes. We also live in a reality where we are able to temper our own outrage, and we must if we wish to maintain healthy, open dialogue. Offense is taken, not given.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoAnd I detest this smug mentality that this subject is concerning things that are mere differences of opinion, like we're discussing tax policy. That's not the case in the least.
- allthenews 9y agoYou don't seem to understand that terms like "toxic" are as arbitrary and subject to abuse as the word "obscene". In fact, I'm not even sure as to what you're getting at. Are you seriously suggesting that what is toxic is somehow universal? It does not bother you that dozens of serious contemporary, controversial topics, with severe consequences for our society, are regularly censored on websites like reddit under the guise of so called toxicity? You aren't bothered by such vague conceptions of offensiveness being used by corporate giants to push their narrative at the expense of others? Of the danger of self-censoring group think on community moderated boards?
- s73v3r_ 9y ago"It does not bother you that dozens of serious contemporary, controversial topics, with severe consequences for our society, are regularly censored on websites like reddit under the guise of so called toxicity?" I think you're gonna have to provide an example for this. An example of something that is being labeled as toxic, but wouldn't appear to be.
- bskinny129 9y agoI just started reading a book that got me thinking about this - Conspiracy: Peter Thiel, Hulk Hogan, Gawker, and the Anatomy of Intrigue [0] If you can remove just a couple of the worst actors from the internet, does it have an outsized benefit? Are those people defining "acceptable behavior" and by example giving more reasonable people permission to behave that way? Interesting questions regardless of the specifics of the Thiel/Gawker case. [0 affiliate]: https://www.amazon.com/Conspiracy-Ryan-Holiday/dp/0735217645?tag=breakoutmentors-20 https://www.amazon.com/Conspiracy-Ryan-Holiday/dp/0735217645... [0 non-affiliate]: https://www.amazon.com/Conspiracy-Ryan-Holiday/dp/0735217645 https://www.amazon.com/Conspiracy-Ryan-Holiday/dp/0735217645
- confounded 9y agoAlgorithmic/centralized vs Human/community moderation is the largest divide between Facebook, Twitter, and Google vs. Reddit, HN, Twitch, Mastodon, etc. I’m thoroughly in favor of the latter. Algorithms can be used as tools to aid human moderators, but context, discretion, and diversity are important. In the case of bad communities, you have a much more tractable problem in terms of tracking/banning/avoiding what goes on —- as both a platform and as a user.
- mancerayder 9y agoI'm an old BBSer. I was on message forums seeing the entire array of so-called problems of today, which people summarize as "toxicity." I saw the full gamut of what can happen, including court-ordered restraining orders, personal harassment in real life, fights. But I also saw communities of what were (in those days) teenagers and young adults (sometimes older adults) finding self-moderation through trial and error and experience. We were anonymous in those days and no, it wasn't more toxic, it was less. I credit those days with teaching me to learn to write correctly, to learn a style of approach to the world which is a mix of rational and skeptical, and with being exposed to numerous philosophical and ethical viewpoints that I would NEVER have been exposed to in the actual toxic environment that I experienced as "high school in America." Now, this was in the mid 90's. Fast forward to the Internet revolution, we start to see the beginnings of message forums online. Fast forward a little bit, we're shocked to find an extremely low level of intelligent engagement, and a high level of emotive hissy-fitting, anger and knee-jerking. Worse, there's a set of interests and focus areas that belong to the masses. My BBS friends and I quickly abandoned our years-long dedication to messaging. It was finito. Because suddenly, a computer nerd niche was exposed to the masses, and the interests of the masses overwhelmed this niche, to the point that intelligent message forum discussion boards because extremely hard to find. RIP intelligent message forums (that I could uncover, anyway) circa early 2000's. Now, to me Reddit is the pinnacle of that. I've never written a single item on Reddit but I've read hundreds of posts. And to me they are: -- Very short, one or two sentence one-liners Me-too's, "this!", etc. Blanket dismissals. There's nothing inherent about anonymity or any other element of the media itself that leads to that. -- Controlled by autocratic "mods" who delete or otherwise punish views that aren't held by them. The political ones are classic examples. Newsflash, guys, there's nothing inherent about politics that should lead to that, and it's not the medium that leads to that degree of censorship. Echo-chamber my butt - that's not an echo chamber, that's a top-down dictatorial type of dictatorship. And evil at that. An echo chamber is when people self-select (in my view) and bounce and reinforce each other's ideas. -- Emotiveness. This is number 1. In any discussion, whether discussing a muscle pain in one subreddit, Trump in another subreddit, or altcoins in another, what you find are people view the message medium as a chance to express their feelings. And so when one person disagrees, it's almost an attack or a failure to acknowledge the other's feelings, if you look at this psychologically. But it's perceived as "toxic." What you say is toxic is a manifestation of people who are not USED to rational back-and-forths -- they didn't qualify for the debate team if you know what I mean -- and they think that it's about expressing personal feelings. Almost like they are VOTING on what is true and false. Folks, I assert this: it's not the anonymous aspect. It's not "toxicity." There's no "cure." There's only people. And levels of education and intelligence (yes, I'm sorry, intelligence plays a role here.). I was going to talk about Facebook but I deleted the paragraph as it's a whole other set of variables in addition to these. If there's ANY cure it's education. Teach people what argumentation is. Ad hominems being the first thing they should learn is naughty. Next, a code of conduct for MODERATORS. If you have moderators who behave like the Stasi intercepting private correspondence and throwing out the bad ones, that should be number one on the hitlist. It's about a, education on argument logic, b, ethics on what moderation is (and isn't). Again, my BBS peers learned this when we were 13-18, gradually.
- wufufufu 9y agoYou are making the problem seem worse than it actually is. Account age and inability to delete comments make an anonymous reputation pretty realistic on HN at least. Just in this thread we see examples of toxic comments being downvoted into invisibility (oblivion). Or is the problem that /r/the_donald exists? Just don't go there if you don't like it. And don't go to /r/trees if you don't like marijuana.
- enraged_camel 9y ago>>Or is the problem that /r/the_donald exists? Just don't go there if you don't like it. I think the issue with r/the_donald, and other extremist subreddits (and online communities in general) is that they generate lies, whip each other into a rage-induced frenzy over those lies and then spread that hatred elsewhere on the Internet, and some of that even spills onto real life via certain conservative news outlets. In addition, anyone who even slightly disagrees is banned with prejudice. This makes the problem difficult to ignore.
- notMick 9y agoThen why not remove r/politics for your same reason? Or r/latestagecapitalism. Crazies from that subteddit have the nerve to post in other parts of Reddit. The biggest problem, imho is that there is an attempt to 'deplatform' dissenting views. (That term was coined by people on the left actually doing it) Quite simply it boils down to vilifying your opponents, classifying dissenting views as 'toxic' or 'hatespeech', and screeching loudly and as often as you can to get the opposition removed. If they move, do the same to them on the next site. This is big money apparently pushing for this as an 'online strategy' to remove opposition. Heck I can buy as many reddit accounts and votes as I like. We need to push back and see it what it is - to try and remove any wrong think and get people thinking as a controllable single mass.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoThe problem is that reddit is one site. You can live in other "neighborhoods" on reddit that are not /r/the_donald, but you are still forced to live in the same city. That means people from there will show up in all of the other sub-reddits, voting and commenting away and twisting every single part of the site to be what they want. It's exhausting to put up with, and if you don't notice it then count yourself lucky. There are many regional city/state/province sub-reddits that have come under concerted "attacks" by /r/the_donald posters. Folks from there will re-post links (or share via chat) to "controversial" posts in other sub-reddits to coordinate brigading, for example.
- at-fates-hands 9y agoSince the dawn of social media, as an anthropologist, I find the way it has evolved to be incredibly fascinating. The original point of social media was to bring people together and build communities. Now, more than a decade removed from it's inception, it is doing the exact opposite. It's tearing people's communities apart, making people more polarized, and driving huge wedges into the very foundation of this country. And yet, with all the privacy concerns, people continue to use it more and more, seemingly unaware of the consequences of doing so. It's like a train wreck you see coming a mile away. Yet you continue to stare, thinking or hoping its going to get better.
- nostalgeek 9y ago> The original point of social media was to bring people together and build communities. Now, more than a decade removed from it's inception, it is doing the exact opposite. It's tearing people's communities apart, making people more polarized, and driving huge wedges into the very foundation of this country. "Corporate" Social media are businesses, they are not here to bring people together but to sell influence. Businesses like Google,Twitter or Facebook have been very good at that. Social media are no different than TV or any ad sponsored business. The customer is the advertiser. How do you think these businesses are making billions without their users paying anything? Venture Capitalists decided to support these business models with massive amounts of money, allowing them to reach critical mass. The whole "bringing people together" was just marketing ploy during the growth period in order to acquire an audience. But that's not how VC got their return on investment. Remember when Facebook was a website acting as a private network for families and friends? they quickly pivoted away from that because it doesn't make that much money.
- dalbasal 9y agoWith the benefit of hindsight, I think “free-form platforms” like reddit or youtube may be the road to mediocrity. Youtube is still the major player even though twitter, Facebook & netflix grew around them. It is less opinionated on how video should be consumed. Less opinionated on what should be consumed. Anyone can post. Anyone can see it. Problem is, youtube doesn’t really have a purpose that it is trying to serve. At least not an obvious one. It has a lot of content. It’s searchable (I hate that the web is no longer searchable..). It’s the obvious place to put stuff. It’s everywhere. But… The platform does not distinguish between the lazy mashup with a clickbait headline and the youtuber making original content for people who would really miss it, and could not get it anywhere else. No preference. No values. No taste. No goal. Just views. One content is as good as the next. Monetisation reinforced this, as did the partial rollback. Go to the youtube homepage now. Is the content good? Read the comments. If the conversation interesting? In the middle is Facebook. It started off highly opinionated. Use real names (big deal at the time). Connect to your real friends. Watch their videos and read their posts. Over time though, Facebook has lost opinions. Stuff is stuff. Views, likes, pokes, plays and comments. Features that get users doing more stuff, they win. This caused their political pickle. Political baiting gets lots of views, likes, pokes, plays and comments. So, as they “optimized” for more stuff, that’s the stuff they got. On the other end of the spectrum are wikipedia and stack overflow (for example). Highly opinionated. Wikipedia is for XYZ. Stackoverflow is for ABC. If you want something else, go someplace else. HN is opinionated too. It takes effort to avoid comment threads full of bullbaiting an even more to avoid a flood of one liners. So Reddit… Reddit did avoid uniformity, that’s a nice way of putting it. It has values. It has things (e.g. censorship) that it does not want to do. But, I feel it still lacks purpose. What does Reddit actually want, what’s the ideal comment or post or sub reddit? Personally, I would love more HN-like places, more wikipedia like places, places with a job to do. gdubs has an excellent comment about what Reddit is doing wrong (promoting impulse gut reactions), and I suspect it’s related. When you don’t have an opinion about what you are trying to do or be, and so you’ll tend to end up with whatever is cheap. It happened to youtube and it happened to Facebook.
- jeffreyrogers 9y agoI don't know about youtube. There's a lot of really interesting, useful stuff from people who just want to share a bit of what they know about some niche topic. If you know what you're looking for youtube is a great resources. But if you're just trying to browse to find fun stuff in your free time, then I guess it's not as useful. I agree that a lot of the bigger channels get worse as they make videos primarily to get views. Although I think this is true of most content producers: You only have so much good material, but it's hard to quit when there's still money to be made at the margins.
- cwkoss 9y agoI think, somewhat counterintuitively, the ability to "anti-like" or "Report as bad take" could actually make the internet a much more positive place. The insulation from negative perceptions of those outside your in-group causes polarization and rewards unpopular but extreme opinions.
- deviationblue 9y agoWhy do we think we'll succeed at "detoxifying" the internet? To me it seems like wanting everyone to say things that don't differ from what everyone else says. That doesn't happen off the internet. Off the internet, most people interact with those who are more or less like themselves, so there's less chance of disagreement. For anyone who differs significantly from you, you hold back your real thoughts and/or stew silently. We just have to accept that echo chambers are an inevitability on the internet with censorship and moderation, and discontent is an inevitability otherwise. If people knew how to talk diplomatically or to get along, this wouldn't be a problem in the first place. Maybe that's something that can be taught, but it's not a problem that gets fixed on the internet, or is a problem caused by the internet- fix it at home; this may also take care of the trolling problem.
- austincheney 9y ago> Why do we think we'll succeed at "detoxifying" the internet? We won't. Honestly, most people don't want success in any form. They want validation, comfort, and instant gratification. If you have to direct success toward a broad enough group it will never be achieved lest you temper your expectations. This applies to all things. It even applies to choice of career, income expectations, and hiring decisions as well as expecting more mature behavior online.
- txsh 9y agoSticks and stones can’t break my bones but words make me cry in the fetal position.
- yummybear 9y agoWhat are your thoughts on requiring or at least encouraging verified accounts - somehow putting a verified name behind the poster?
- floren 9y agoI can't wait for the word "toxic" to drop out of favor. It implies that the person is not just giving a bad opinion, but is in fact fundamentally flawed and dangerous. Arsenic isn't toxic because it had a bad day at work, arsenic is by its nature a deadly poison and you can't change it, only avoid it. The vast majority of people labeled "toxic", though, are just humans with a variety of opinions and beliefs, some you may agree with and some you surely disagree with. They may change these beliefs, but not by being vilified and told they are intrinsically bad.
- dredmorbius 9y agoThere are in fact system dynamics in which specific behaviours are unhealthy. Toxic, if you will. Consider these, generally, hygiene factors. There are substances which are toxic in specific concentrations or circumstances, which are otherwise healthy: oxygen, CO2, water, vitamin D, salt, nutritional iron. Certain forms of discourse. My view increasingly isn't that there are things, but interactions or behaviours. A thing isn't, but is what it does or how it behaves. (This ... tends to simplify numerous ontological questions.)
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> My view increasingly isn't that there are things, but interactions or behaviours. A thing isn't, but is what it does or how it behaves. The "belief in things" is itself a cognitive simplification we make, probably for the sake of efficiency. To use a programming analogy, toxicity as a concept is a function of at least three arguments - toxic(what, to-what, context) - but we attach it as a label to the first argument and store it there. Compare e.g. with beauty, itself a function of at least two arguments - beautiful(what, to-whom). But we usually assume to-whom = "human like me", and stick the whole thing as a label on a thing, because 99% of the time, that's the correct thing to do (incidentally, the quote "beauty is in the eye of the beholder" is literally a reminder that the concept of beauty is a function of multiple values). Confusing the "arity" of concepts seems to be the cause of quite a lot of misunderstandings between people.
- 9y ago
- ecommerceguy 9y agoNot one word about the HUGE Antifa presence or doxing by left wing conspirators and agitators. This is exactly why I don't read the New Yorker. I would consider reading it if they gave light to both sides of this issue. But they don't. This is not journalism. Edit: u/spez was caught editing user comments on certain subs he publicly disagrees with. How he's still CEO is beyond me. At least he admits he's a troll. Edit 2 - Downvotes all you want, all I'm saying is FACTS. Here's more FACTS: https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/z4444w/how-reddit-got-huge-tons-of-fake-accounts--2 https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/z4444w/how-reddit... Reddit culture starts at the top and this is Steve Hoffman. He should resign. He's completely in over his head.
- ecommerceguy 9y agoDownvotes but no replies. School yard bully techniques. Triggered you are.
- dragonwriter 9y agoFrom the guidelines: “Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading.”
- ecommerceguy 9y agoDitto. You know what ff that. The downvote system is broken. If you downvote, say why or don't allow downvoting. It's a petulant drive-by mentality and is exactly what makes Reddit "Toxic". Keep Downvoting.
- switch007 9y agoJust the past week: - New Yorker publishes this article - Mayor of London at SXSW called for tighter tech regulation. - UK Culture Secretary declares social media "broken", states he wants to time-limit children's access to social media and "impose stricter checks on the age limits when children can first set up a social media profile" - Tim Berners-Lee said "we must regulate tech firms to prevent 'weaponised' web" - The Economist prints an article "On Twitter, falsehood spreads faster than truth" (reporting on a recent study by MIT’s Laboratory for Social Machines) - A report is delivered to European Commission: "Final report of the High Level Expert Group on Fake News and Online Disinformation" - The House of Lords International Relations Committee concluded tech firms were negatively affecting our society Blimey...
- mattdeboard 9y agoYep, I agree. Politicians & their PR firms are getting the bee hive stirred up, swaying public opinion. It's the governmental version of http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html
- 1337biz 9y agoHad to scroll down all the way to your comment until somebody finally gets the meta view. Just amazing how the usually brilliant minds of HN are baited into this morronic censorship discussion.
- verylittlemeat 9y ago- moral panic over video games in the news again - florida legislature declares porn a health risk rather than debate guns after school shooting
- skookumchuck 9y ago> which brand themselves as strongholds of free speech and in practice are often used for hate speech. Um, hate speech is free speech.
- DanBC 9y agoHate speech is used to silence people. Hate speech is not free speech.
- skookumchuck 9y agoYou're referring to threats, which are not free speech. Hate speech is free speech.
- lopmotr 9y agoBack 15-20 years ago, forums didn't like personal abuse or being off-topic. Now, the problem seems to be "dangerous ideas" or "might influence people to believe something I don't". It's changed from staying reasonable to trying to influence real world politics by silencing dissent. Why not have freedom of political ideas on a political forum? Stop worrying about influencing voters in the "wrong" way and meddling in elections and all that nonsense. Even on HN, there are "wrong" ideas that you can't even hint at, even when they're on topic and you're being non-abusive. It's dominated by aggressively enforced political opinion.
- skookumchuck 9y ago> Reddit was also an important part of Trump’s strategy. Parscale wrote—on Reddit, naturally—that “members here provided considerable growth and reach to our campaign.” So were Hillary's and Bernie's campaigns, who each had a major presence on Reddit, both much more than Trump's.
- seany 9y agoI can't be the only person who is just not bothered by this kind of thing at all, am I? I'm way more worried about political indoctrination in upper education than trolls on the internet.
- 1337biz 9y agoThen you are running in the wrong circles where you can't just reject any oposing viewpoint as 'Russian bots'.
- verylittlemeat 9y agoIn the past month I've had 2 comments accuse me of being a Russian bot or a shill on hacker news. People really do just see what they want to see.
- seany 9y agoI'm not quite sure I understand this comment. Can you expand?
- adamrezich 9y agoI'm the same, and I take it a step further: I personally believe that the push to associate emotional triggers with words, phrases, and news events to the point where seeing someone else "say the Wrong Thing" causes anything resembling emotional distress, is the most powerful weapon of social destruction in use today. The solution to "toxicity" on social media isn't better moderation, better filtering, better banned words and phrases lists... it's being able to see 280 characters on the screen, representing ideas you wholeheartedly disagree with, and not get worked up about it as your eyes move to the next thing on the list and you go about your life as usual. Sadly, the current structure of things incentivizes the former behavior and disincentivizes the latter. Corporations (especially news corporations) and politicians see no problem with conditioning people on a mass scale, and few people seem to question the narratives being spun all around them instead of just blindly believing whatever their social sphere agrees with.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ziikutv 9y agoReddit doesn’t owe anyone anything. how about asking kids parents to detoxify their kids than solving the problem way down the chain of command? People are shitty online because they have anonymity. Now instead of going ahead and removing that, it might be worth going backward even more and going to the person. people need to be nice on the internet. The internet does not need to be nice to people. Detoxifying internet is no different than censorship. I can say this with certainty that as soon as we ask companies and governments to detoxify, it will get misused [un]intentionally.
- Retra 9y agoSo it's going overboard to police what people say in a public forum, but it's not going overboard to police what parents teach their children in their own home? You're more afraid of censorship in the public space than state-mandated parenting practices in private?
- ziikutv 9y ago> state-mandated parenting practices. I hope I can become a good parent and can teach my kids to be good people by the time I am ready. If you need a state to tell you that, you probably should not be having kids. Having is a privilege and unfortunately also a right. Edit: In all seriousness, what I was saying is that we should be teaching kids to be good people rather than acting good on the internet. Also, we should be smart enough to know that all this article is doing is spewing shit on Reddit to generate them pageviews. That is all journalism is now a days.
- intended 9y agoPeople are shitty even without anonymity. Theres enough people on Facebook who say horrible things, or push for horrible and hurtful ideas.
- verylittlemeat 9y agoOne more opinion for heap? People are too sensitive about seeing their snowflake opinions validated. Upvote and downvote do not map to right and wrong. What makes an opinion popular has as much to do with rhetoric and appealing to a million fallacies as it does to facts or logic. This is human nature, not an inherent problem with the internet.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- InclinedPlane 9y agoI think you replied to the wrong comment.
- dang 9y agoYup. I moved that one to its intended parent, and detached this one from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16572878 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16572878 and marked it off-topic.
- austincheney 9y agoBah, I recently deleted my 5 year account with nearly 4000 comment karma on Reddit. Reddit is toxic. Saying something benign but mildly disagreeable caused some people to get emotional, and I do mean exceedingly emotional like you just crapped in their car and had sex with their girlfriend. I am not talking about politics, but subreddits like javascript and programming. Worse than being toxic, Reddit is an echo chamber. Many users find vote counts as more than a validation but rather a righteousness or correctness, which contrarily means opposing votes are not a disagreement but a vilification. I just found myself becoming progressively more depressed contributing to conversations there. In the end it seemed to almost never be about the conversation but about being RIGHT + 1!!! Since deleting my account a month ago I am a much happier person. Hacker News has voting as well, but with an incredibly important distinction. The votes are hidden from all but the respective contributors so as to eliminate votes from ever being used as any kind of vindication by ignorant people.
- zaarn 9y agoThere are definitely reddit communities were this isn't true, though these are largely small community subreddits that focus on some particular topic.
- ohtwenty 9y agoThis is often mentioned but the examples for it keep changing—any of the small nice communities that grows too large will become filled with noise and become unpleasant. It's the reason I've been moving to lower-volume/higher intimacy websites recently, hoping to filter out noise. Unfortunately it's not really easy
- derptron 9y agoYou state your karma like it means anything to anyone.
- stcredzero 9y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/NeutralPolitics/ https://www.reddit.com/r/NeutralPolitics/
- timbo1642 9y agoReddit has done nothing but censor. Its own CEO spez has edited comments of others. The mods have removed all the comments that don't fit their narrative or liking in every big news or political sub. Anything pro conservative or anti-liberal has been removed no matter how true it is. Its pure censorship and nothing else. They even banned a complete subreddit because they found out the people that were working at reddit were removing things without the mods knowing about it and when they found out and proved it, they banned it the NEXT DAY. Fuck reddit. It anti-free speech
- hooph00p 9y ago> pro-conservative or anti-liberal hmm... you might be on a different part of reddit than I am.
- Clanan 9y ago> “Does free speech mean literally anyone can say anything at any time?” Tidwell continued. “Or is it actually more conducive to the free exchange of ideas if we create a platform where women and people of color can say what they want without thousands of people screaming, ‘Fuck you, light yourself on fire, I know where you live’? This comment, by Reddit's General Counsel, says a lot about their approach. They believe that minorities/women will be subjected to nonstop violent comments unless Reddit pursues proactive and forceful moderation, free speech be damned. I think (hope) that's a very cynical view. The author of the piece does a great job juxtaposing this quote with the results of r/Place, however, in pointing out that it did not devolve into swastikas and "toxic" content when left to its own devices. But reddit moderation is not just about quality content. I think many commenters here miss this. Moderation of a hugely successful website is not just about the technical issues or the logistics. Huffman, the CEO, is quoted as saying he believes Reddit can sway elections. So now moderation is about power. Imagine the temptation: you're one click away from destroying the popular, impactful subreddit of a political candidate you detest. One click to sway an election, maybe. Edit: spelling
- kakarot 9y ago> you're one click away from destroying the popular, impactful subreddit of a political candidate you detest I hope they put that behind at least two clicks.
- intended 9y agoMinorities and women are subject to nonstop violent comments. God help you if you are a moderator and a member of a popular community and known as member of one of those groups. And its even worse if you are a mod, a minority member, AND a mod of a minority community. ---- The best way to think of social media/reddit is a beautiful cleave sort process. People form a community, and then they have to deal with attackers or outsiders. Eventually a drama even occurs and people get expelled. These people who are expelled form their own community and this process continues ad infinitum. On top of it, some people will independently create subs just to target you, or create subs that inadvertently target you (from the old forum days - nazi forums would actively harass Jewish forums.)
- kerkeslager 9y ago> Some of the conspiracy theorists left Reddit and reunited on Voat, a site made by and for the users that Reddit sloughs off. (Many social networks have such Bizarro networks, which brand themselves as strongholds of free speech and in practice are often used for hate speech. People banned from Twitter end up on Gab; people banned from Patreon end up on Hatreon.) Other Pizzagaters stayed and regrouped on r/The_Donald, a popular pro-Trump subreddit. Throughout the Presidential campaign, The_Donald was a hive of Trump boosterism. By this time, it had become a hermetic subculture, full of inside jokes and ugly rhetoric. The community’s most frequent commenters, like the man they’d helped propel to the Presidency, were experts at testing boundaries. Within minutes, they started to express their outrage that Pizzagate had been deleted. This is a critical thing that we as a society need to recognize about censorship and political correctness. When we censor people or ostracize them for saying things we don't like, even when what they say is legitimately awful, these people don't disappear, change their minds, or stop voting. They go elsewhere, become more entrenched in their awful beliefs, and because we've pushed them all together, they become more united. They become stronger. And because they become stronger away from us, we don't notice, and we're blindsided when they flex their political power. Underlying this mistake are some important truths: 1. People who say hateful things are human beings worth engaging with. No, I don't like reading a lot of what people say. It's easy for me to forget that they are human beings with their own struggles and traumas that cause them to believe the awful things they believe. When we dismiss them as trolls, we're dehumanizing them. Such a society doesn't leave room to be wrong and learn--if you're wrong, you're dismissed--and it dismisses the people who are the most dangerously wrong. It's not our responsibility to educate people, but that's irrelevant to the fact that if we don't educate people no one will. We need to engage people who believe awful things, try to understand what needs cause them to believe those things, and try to address those needs with compassion and courage. Truth is the antidote to hate. 2. Free speech doesn't just matter in a legal context. Free speech is protected in the US constitution because it's important in a free society. If we're going to let the discourse of our society move into privately-owned platforms like Reddit/Facebook/Twitter instead of publicly-owned platforms like street corners where newspapers are sold (or, the rest of the internet) then we have to value free speech on those platforms as well. Too many people are stuck in this idea that the Trump election was an anomaly--that in November Congress will change and in 2020 we'll have a new president. I see no reason to believe this will happen. We have changed nothing about our behavior and we're hoping the ones who elected Trump to change.
- mirimir 9y agoOK, so how did r/Trees end up focusing on marijuana, and r/MarijuanaEnthusiasts on trees? Was r/Trees first, and then tree lovers did r/MarijuanaEnthusiasts as a joke? Was there a war? Edit: tone
- sureaboutthis 9y agoDecent, moral people avoid people and places like reddit altogether in their every day lives while walking down the street. A news analyst, on NPR a few years ago, called reddit a "Frankenstein's monster they can't control".
- AllegedAlec 9y ago> To its devotees, Reddit feels proudly untamed, one of the last Internet giants to resist homogeneity. Waitwhat? Reddit is a huge hivemind, with each subreddit having more or less the same views, since people who do not agree to the narrative of that subreddit are quickly downvoted so much that they can't post more than once a day or something.
- Shivetya 9y agoand one fact they want to ignore, many of the politically oriented subs are managed by PACs who worked for years to get their people into moderator positions if not create subs as they needed them. then through mailing lists, text alerts, and such, they know what stories to post and act on. reddit is anything but wild wild west anymore, its been co-opted by those who know how to manipulate opinion of products and persons
- AllegedAlec 9y agoI don't think this is all that specific to Reddit, though. I mean, even /pol/ was 'infiltrated' by the likes of CTR (although this of course doesn't work, since 4chan is aggressively anti-everything). Furthermore, the fact that all moderated political (and even many nonpolitical) forums are pushed and pulled towards the extreme fringes is understandable, even to be expected: those who take moderator jobs are those who are most driven about the subject at hand, and those are most often the ones with a fringe opinion.
- treerock 9y agoThat's not my experience. There seems to be subreddits on every conceivable topic, and you can subscribe to whatever variety you want and you'll get a wildly varied range of views/politics/whatever. There are even 'change my view' type subreddits for people looking to understand and debate the 'other side' of their arguments.
- AllegedAlec 9y agoI wasn't too clear in my phrasing. Although Reddit as a whole has relatively diverse views, each subreddit has a very specific hivemind.
- valeg 9y agoThe article reminded me about another proposal of how to fix reddit: http://chuqui.com/2015/07/fixing-or-replacing-reddit-some-quick-thoughts/ http://chuqui.com/2015/07/fixing-or-replacing-reddit-some-qu... I see a problem with this but there are some valid points. Maybe mastodon.social is heading there: So I wouldn’t host the stuff. But I could build an easy to install environment that would be a standardized system that could be installed on effectively any hosting site. Start with WordPress, WordPress’s P2 theme, a forum plug-in, the Disqus commenting system and a couple of weeks of hacking some custom work, and you’d have something that could be easily installed and run by a non-geek on any hosting service that supports WordPress. There are big advantages to this: If someone really wants a topic to exist, they can get it going for well under $100 (including domain name) and keep it running for $10-20/mo. Most of these sites will be very low traffic and a lot of them will in fact be pop-up and collapse as people figure out running sites is work and audiences don’t appear by magic — but the good ones will thrive and grow, and for most of these, it’ll be cheap enough to operate that most people can run them out of pocket. By building it as an independent site, though, that person would have the option of doing advertising, or running a Patreon or GoFundMe, or find other ways to pay for hosting the content of the site. It also shifts the liability for the existence of the content to the owner and host of the site and away from the central authority. If that person wants to find an offshore hosting service that doesn’t care what the content is, that’s up to them. So you’ve removed the need for a central authority to have to censor to protect its own interests. You still need a way for people to find these topic-specific sites. Enter the central authority. It hosts a directory, much like the original Yahoo! directory was. Building something like this is dirt cheap and easy to host, so someone (like, ahem, Reddit) could do so at low cost so that it doesn’t have to host those subreddits any more but could still support them by hosting a directory of them where they could be found.
- el_cid 9y agoI'd take toxicity over censorship any day. The media machine & politicians have been going at it recently. I wonder when being toxic will become illegal.
- pbalau 9y agoThis is stupid. Facebook, reddit, twitter are trying to make the internet this beautiful family friendly place. This is bullshit, we as humans are toxic. This is the way we function. This is the way react on things. Censoring all of this might affect things we should not censor. Fuck family friendlyness if it has a chance to affect free speech.