10 ms·
New Tech Centers Sprout in Europe
- montrose 9y agoI had been optimistic about Krakow becoming a big tech hub, but the Polish government's shift toward authoritarianism makes that less likely.
- kozikow 9y agoOur startup is split between Silicon Valley and Poland. I would say the biggest problem with the current government are taxes. Desperate to fund the socialist policy of "500+", the government changes the "interpretation" of the current tax code. Suddenly programmers are taxed at a higher rate: e.g. https://www.wykop.pl/link/4196755/informatycy-nie-moga-byc-pewni-pit-ow-za-ubiegle-lata/ https://www.wykop.pl/link/4196755/informatycy-nie-moga-byc-p... . Besides that, the government tries to be friendly to tech startups. Another problem is GDPR. It sounds like the life of European startups is going to get much harder. One potential upside is EU funding. Having used both VC and EU funding I am not sure if it's really worth it, even if it's equity free.
- thraway180306 9y agoPolish tax code and adjudication has been a mess for a very long time. The actual rates have not changed, interpretations do change constantly and you can't get a binding one. There is no such thing. You can officially request some advice from the ministry explaining what the dues are in your case, but what this says is not binding for the revenue service if they choose not to refrain from harassing you with their creative interpretations. Combined with lack of precedence law every issue becomes a potential court gamble (and it is a gamble) if not resolved amicably. That this is new is just hot air about the current government (despicable for other good reasons).
- LaGrange 9y agoAlso the air quality is rather terrible.
- kss238 9y agoIn Krakow? Has it changed a lot in the past years? I was there in 2014 and the air was great.
- kornakiewicz 9y agoWere you in summer? The problem with air pollution is rather seasonal and while in warmer months it's not an issue, winters are terrible. Source: I lived in Kraków for 4 years.
- kss238 9y agoYeah I was, so that was probably it.
- eafkuor 9y agoIt's so bad that Dynatrace, who is hiring in Gdańsk (another Polish city), is trying to convince devs from Kraków to move there with this: http://zmiensrodowisko.pl/ http://zmiensrodowisko.pl/
- Guest9812398 9y agoI spent some time in Krakow and it has horrible air quality. Summer feels normal like any other city, but certain times during the winter it's difficult to see due to the smog. See the below video for reference. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7nxugvTmJo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7nxugvTmJo
- navaati 9y agoWow darn I'm never throwing the stone at China again, seeing this in Europe, so close to home !
- FranOntanaya 9y agoIn the whole area. Where I spent time people still use coal heating and you had garbage pick up once a week (and you had to tip), so even tho burning garbage in the stove is illegal you surely knew when a neighbor was doing it. Part of my coming back home culture shock was not seeing cars covered in sooth.
- fatfox 9y agoAgreed. Krakow, Poznan, many cities in Poland are full of talented young people and they produce great stuff. But the current line of the Polish government will make it a less than ideal place for investment.
- oyvey 9y agoI prefer to make less money than to live in a multicutural paradise like in the west.
- cmdkeen 9y agoHaving visited recently and met with several tech companies and western firms utilising it I'd say it is already a tech hub, and has a bright future. The sheer number of graduates being produced, and the proven ability to scale up operations there makes it really attractive. It is also a lovely city to visit, which is always worth bearing in mind when it comes to where companies might open a satellite office...
- yazr 9y agoAre the devs/QA english speaking or just the managers ?!
- expertentipp 9y agoNo we not speaking English. /s
- zootam 9y agoenglish is typically taught in primary school to everyone
- marak830 9y agoWhile I don't want to disagree with you about that locale, it's also taught here in Japan, and the English level is abhorebt. (Source: part time English teacher in Japan in my free time, taught every level from kindergarten to senior highschool). My point being, teaching from an early age, while is an advantage, does not necessarily mean a good comprehension or ability to speak.
- Tharkun 9y agoI had a chat with a bunch of Japanese university students last month. They told me the same thing. They told me their English classes weren't too bad when it came to grammar, but they hardly ever practiced speaking the language. I can't even imagine learning a language without speaking it! Edit: sausage fingers
- 9y ago
- badpun 9y agoI'd say they're much less radical than Trump. Does Trump make America a bad place for tech? I don't think he has impacted the SV ecosystem much for example.
- m_ke 9y agohttps://www.geekwire.com/2018/fewer-international-grad-students-seeking-computer-science-degrees-u-s-first-time-years/ https://www.geekwire.com/2018/fewer-international-grad-stude...
- adventured 9y agoThe figures in the article, representing the drop, are 27% above 2012 levels. For science & engineering the student numbers are 46% higher than 2012. So much for that premise. The decline shown is between 2016 and 2017. Trump wasn't President. Any decisions to attend in the US would have been considered well before it was even clear he would have a serious chance of winning. There are two likely reasons for that dip. First, the cost of university education in the US is quite high. Second and in tandem with the first issue, countries like China that formerly would have sent a lot of students to the US, increasingly have the education systems and infrastructure - along with the post education opportunities - in place to retain their own talent pools.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The decline shown is between 2016 and 2017. Trump wasn't President. Trump was, in fact, President well before the 16 April — 15 November period covered for the 2017 data. > Any decisions to attend in the US would have been considered well before it was even clear he would have a serious chance of winning. But would have had ample time to be reconsidered after he won, and even after the initial implementation of the travel ban. > There are two likely reasons for that dip. First, the cost of university education in the US is quite high That was true I've the 2012–2016 period of increase, too, it didn't change between 2016 and 2017. > Second and in tandem with the first issue, countries like China that formerly would have sent a lot of students to the US, increasingly have the education systems and infrastructure - along with the post education opportunities - in place to retain their own talent pools. That also didn't dramatically change between 2016 and 2017. What did dramatically change between 2016 and 2017 was the visible attitude of the U.S. public and government to foreigners.
- nukeop 9y agoKrakow thrives under the so-called "authoritarian" (actually very mundane and liberal) government. The conditions for the growth of the tech sector are there, and most people working in it agree that they are better off than they were a couple of years ago and it's still getting progressively better.
- pjf 9y agoRe: Polish government, I wouldn't trust the news hype on "authoritarianism" at all - IMHO, these "news" are largely just some powerful people doing dirty politics
- Freak_NL 9y agoIt is a sentiment shared by the EU though. The Polish government's approach to dismantling the trias politica is worrying, to say the least: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/dec/08/polish-mps-pass-supreme-court-bill-criticised-as-grave-threat https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/dec/08/polish-mps-pas...
- m_fayer 9y agoAs someone descended partially from Jews from that area, calling the attempted rewriting of some very personal and painful history "hype" strikes me as malicious and insulting.
- expertentipp 9y ago> Polish government's shift toward authoritarianism makes that less likely. In case of Krakow I would rather worry about the awful air pollution. What you hear about Polish politics is a political war resulting with plenty of nonsense media content produced.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rehemiau 9y ago> Lisbon, Kraków, Poland, and Edinburgh are among the cities that have become popular for the industry Since when Poland is a city?
- LaGrange 9y ago1795. But it's not in Europe.
- biesnecker 9y agoI guess Kraków just isn’t there for name recognition yet? Reordering the sentence would have made the overloaded commas a lot clearer.
- heavenlyblue 9y agoThey did the same to Vilnius though
- gpvos 9y agoApparently also not well-known enough. But by what criteria, I have no idea...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mabbo 9y agoThey may have been trying to specify it, like [Lisbon], [Kraków, Poland], [Edinburgh]. They're readers may have literally not heard of Kraków before and need that. Unfortunately, the English language uses the comma for multiple purposes so you get messes like that headline.
- yorwba 9y agoI think they could have used a semicolon instead, as in "Lisbon; Kraków, Poland; Edinburgh are ...".
- 9y ago
- Metaluim 9y agoNow all I need is for wages to be actually attractive in Lisbon, given the rising rents.
- coinerone 9y agoYou mean like Berlin, where you get max. 36k€ a year for Full Stack Dev and pay 13k€ for Rent? I think the main reason for Cities in Europe become tech hubs is the extreme low cost for Devs and other tech people.
- kakwa_ 9y ago36K euros a year "Brut" (before social security) was my starting salary in the Paris area. I know that Berlin is a little bit cheaper (in term of rent) than Paris but I would expect it to be about the same as Paris in term of salary. For information in Paris, currently I'm at ~50K a year "Brut", which means ~35K a year "Net" ("go home" salary). I'm costing ~75K per year to my employer in term of salary (there are taxes on his side to). My rent, for a small flat (22 square meters) in Paris is around 10K per year. My taxes are around 6K per year. I'm an SRE/software engineer with ~8 years experience.
- navaati 9y agoSo in the end including your taxes, you have 29k to live with (19k if you remove the rent) while costing 75k to your employer. Ladies and gentlemen of the world, this is what is costs to have our (indeed very nice) social security/health insurance !
- dep_b 9y agoSounds a lot like Amsterdam to me. I always thought German speaking countries valued engineers more. But perhaps it's just the Swiss?
- coinerone 9y agoIn Germany there are Places where you get paid very well, like Munich or Hamburg. But Berlin is like the Cheap and hyped City where you can pay less and find good employees who are willing to pay high rent, sometimes half of the monthly earnings, only to work for a Startup or a Big Name Company.
- pjc50 9y agoPaywall skip: http://archive.is/9O1sv http://archive.is/9O1sv Not very much detail on Edinburgh, just mentions Brainnwave (sic) and not Skyscanner. It's a very cultural but also fairly expensive city. Perhaps people will start moving into startup space round about the gentrification of Leith or the space vacated by RBS.
- cmdkeen 9y agoExpensive yes but a survey the other year had it as the best city in the UK for disposable incomes, an average of £800 per month. Probably in part due to the sizeable financial and legal sectors here. Given the fairly stiff competition for developers in the central belt of Scotland my (biased!) opinion is it is one of the best places to live in the UK, especially if you have, or are planning, a family.
- pjc50 9y agoOh, I'm very fond of it myself, especially since I moved from Cambridge which was far more expensive! I'm still trying to get a good feel for market depth. Everyone wants frontend web devs it seems.
- gsnedders 9y agoSkyscanner has a decently large office in Glasgow, too.
- tradedash 9y agoThe question we have to ask is: what classifies as a tech hub/center?
- mabbo 9y agoVery happy to see Edinburgh get more recognition. I spent a year on exchange there while at University and was just blown away by the city. Great tech scene, incredible University (of Edinburgh), so much history and just wonderful people. If I ever decide to leave Canada, that's probably where I'll go.
- JPKab 9y agoHow affordable is it? Always wanted to spend some time in Scotland, and love the idea of checking out a tech scene.
- dep_b 9y agoOf the cities mentioned it's the only one I would actually consider to live. Perhaps Lisbon but I never visited it. Probably working for a local wage makes it a lot less romantic.
- pouta 9y agoYou should give Porto a look. Way more romantic than Lisbon and a more thriving tech/startup scene.
- passiveincomelg 9y agoOr Edinburgh in the summer, Porto the rest of the year. :)
- grkvlt 9y agoI am based at Codebase [0] in Edinburgh, a tech incubator office complex, with lots of startups based there as well as co-working and hot-desking spaces, where I work at a cloud orchestration company [1] where I am building a new blockchain network infrastructure for another company, [2] also based there. There's a lot of innovation going on here, definitely. Oh, and the Linux Foundation is holding the Open Source Summit 2018 conference [3] here later this year, too! 0. https://www.thisiscodebase.com/ https://www.thisiscodebase.com/ 1. https://cloudsoft.io/ https://cloudsoft.io/ 2. https://blockchaintp.com/ https://blockchaintp.com/ 3. https://events.linuxfoundation.org/events/open-source-summit-europe-2018/ https://events.linuxfoundation.org/events/open-source-summit...
- vadimberman 9y agoCan anyone comment on the taxation situation? I mean, it may not be very interesting in the beginning when the earnings are not very far from zero, but as the startup grows, and the stock incentives become more tangible, it's becoming relevant. I was personally looking at Barcelona once but the moment I looked at how much taxes they pay, I dropped the idea.
- pjc50 9y agoFor the UK, the magic words are "EMI scheme" https://www.magma.co.uk/enterprise-management-incentive-schemes-basics/ https://www.magma.co.uk/enterprise-management-incentive-sche... Options received under an EMI scheme are tax-free, although you may eventually have to pay capital gains tax at time of exercise.
- hackbinary 9y agoYou'll pay more in taxes, but there is universal healthcare available free at the point of delivery. So taxes might be higher here, but you and your employees will access to some of the best healthcare in the world. I do not think taxation should get singled out as a deciding factor where to setup a business, but could be considered in the round with all the other operational costs. Low taxes might seem good, but if the key services are non-existent or corrupt, then your costs of operation will be significantly higher than in a place that has high(er) taxes, but civil society is run efficiently.
- vadimberman 9y ago> I do not think taxation should get singled out as a deciding factor where to setup a business, but could be considered in the round with all the other operational costs. Simple math. Say, if your venture succeeds, you net a lump sum of, say, $300K - $500K? Plus, in the advanced stages, you'll be paying yourself around $80K - $100K p.a., which falls in the high tax bracket everywhere. The difference between high taxes and low taxes may make a difference between you being able to buy a new home for cash or not. If you're planning to spend a few years to have fun and immerse in a different culture and believe your venture is likely to fail, sure. If you are there to make money, think again. Of course, it's not the primary consideration. The primary consideration should be whether there is a market for your products and services. > Low taxes might seem good, but if the key services are non-existent or corrupt, then your costs of operation will be significantly higher than in a place that has high(er) taxes, but civil society is run efficiently. That's not necessarily how things work. I live in Singapore now, where the income tax is in single digits and the foreign sources of income are not even taxed, so if you're not an American, you can have your passive income tax-free. The key services are anything but non-existent or corrupt.
- dziungles 9y agoSo is the Lisbon tech startup scene active? I like the city a lot and was thinking about moving there. What about language barrier? Do people speak English?
- glaberficken 9y agoThe majority of people in Lisbon under 40yo speak English to a good level. In a tech "setting" English level would be even higher.
- cpursley 9y agoYes, I've been to tech meetups there. They asked if there were non-Portuguese speaking folks in attendance and all presenters used English.
- gpvos 9y agoEnglish speaking ability is pretty good and widespread in Portugal. In Spain, however, it's the opposite.
- expertentipp 9y agoLisbon? I've heard only horror stories about the rent/salary ratio. Portuguese emigrate in volumes comparable to Poles/Romanians and there is a reason for this. Krakow? If you fancy working at the complete bottom of the corporate hierarchy at IBM/Capgemini/Accenture/etc, or for some Scandinavian/German cheapskates. Rents went through the roof as well.
- mping 9y agoTech salaries are getting bimodal, If you are on the right (pun intended) side of the curve you will be fine. you will end up working for a foreign company or remoting. I do hope rent goes down, it's fugly to see working class people being driven out of the city...
- Ftuuky 9y agoRent is Lisbon is getting very expensive and salaries don't closely follow that trend. However, the article is right about many corporations coming here to setup global shared services for operations and support desks.
- Daishiman 9y ago> Portuguese emigrate in volumes comparable to Poles/Romanians and there is a reason for this. This used to be the case up until a few years ago but having spoken with many young Portuguese there's a serious resurgence of tech and arts scenes.
- pjmlp 9y agoThere is, but since I live abroad the community on my region has been increasing quite a lot in the last 10 years, with very few willing to return.
- didymospl 9y agoI think you're too harsh. Akamai, Oracle, Samsung, UBS, HSBC and plenty of other well-known companies have R&D centres in Krakow. Even Google had been there but their office was merged with the Warsaw one a few years ago. Obviously, if you're an aspiring manager you'd be better off working in the corporate HQ but from a developer's POV it's a decent city to work.
- schnevets 9y agoI was extremely impressed by Budapest and Bratislava on a recent trip to Europe. I'm surprised the article doesn't mention either of them by name, but I suppose if, as the article states, "Every company is a tech company now”, then any city with a half-decent economy is a tech city now.
- bane 9y agoI suspect Budapest's tech companies exist because there's a very unusual market in Hungary due to being a language isolate. I saw lots of homegrown companies and ways of doing things of all types there. Bratislava on the other hand looks like it's being rebuilt almost from the ground up, has a reasonable tech scene (even hosts demoscene parties!) and also has some of the friendliest people I've ever met anywhere. Eset seems to be the anchor company.
- skrebbel 9y agoHey, even Saarbruecken hosts demoscene parties :-)
- mrisoli 9y agoI am an expat engineer in Budapest and the tech scene here has a lot of ups and downs, definitely meet a lot of engineers just by walking around, it isn't quite a tech hub yet. The very low cost of living and high salaries for engineers make it quite attractive, even though rent prices keep going up it is still a very good place to live, decent quality of living, centrally located within Europe with lots of options to travel and all, I'd definitely recommend, and hope it becomes an even bigger tech hub in the future.
- pavlakoos 9y agoWhy is country name enlisted in one line with city names?
- dozzie 9y agoI'm glad that both cities, Poland and Kraków, are popular. The journalist should learn how to read a map, though.
- shaki-dora 9y agoOrt you should learn to read, period. They’re just specifying the country, not including it in the list. They do it even in London, England.
- dozzie 9y ago> They’re just specifying the country, not including it in the list. Yeah, no, not quite. Only one city got that treatment, so it's not an invalid interpretation. The alternative to the journalist who cannot read a map is that the journalist should learn how to write, but either way it's an error of WSJ.
- pjmlp 9y agoNice to see Lisbon on the list.
- tomcooks 9y agoIt's going to be a pity to see that beautiful city disappear due to startupgentrificageddon.
- pjmlp 9y agoFully agree, but we already have quite a few problems there, not sure if startupfication will make it much worse. I see the positive side of keeping people there instead of having to try their luck abroad. Actually I would like to see all district capitals enjoy startup fever, specially the inner country ones.
- to_bpr 9y agoDepends on how it's handled. If it's bastardized with US companies coming in to exploit the existing low salaries and then suppress them by co-ordinating and fighting to bring in others from other low-paid countries, then yes it's likely going to be ruinous to it. If it's a small, European centric scene, by Europeans and for Europeans which grows organically outward then it stands a chance to enrich the city. Personally I'm not much of an advocate for Europe welcoming SV folks and their VC masters in.
- apexalpha 9y agoNothing for Amsterdam or Eindhoven? Also, they seem to mean 'software' not 'tech'. But sure.
- amelius 9y agoI hope they are real tech centers, and not centers where investors can pour money into hyped up IT products.
- expertentipp 9y ago> centers where investors can pour money into hyped up IT products We don't have these in EU. More like centers where the profits are sucked out from the cheap and desperate labor.
- Gys 9y ago> “You might say every company is a tech company now,” said Tom Carroll, European head of corporate research at real-estate services firm JLL. Where 'tech' is probably to be understood as 'relying heavily on software'.
- munchor 9y agoAbundance of highly skilled engineers willing to work for low rates make a perfect setting for large consulting (and others) companies in Lisbon (and probably other cities mentioned in the article). Yes, the city is beautiful but don't expect high paying jobs. I know a couple of YC-backed startups in Lisbon that get away with paying their software engineers around 24-30K euros per year (post-tax).
- munchor 9y agoI can't edit this on my phone but I meant 12-16k post tax. I multiplied 1000,0 by 12 and somehow and got 24.
- zemvpferreira 9y agoBear in mind that the fully-loaded cost for an employee in Lisbon will be ~2x take-home pay, meaning the low end of your range translates to a net salary of 1K euro/month. Which is absolutely in the ballpark for a new grad. It doesn't go up much, either. An average senior engineer might cost 40K euro/year and the absolute cream of the crop can be had for 100-150 K euro/year. This for engineers from a top school that you can expect to be fluent in english and 5 time zones away from the east coast. It's a great place to have a second office.
- 4387wreiysu 9y ago>24-30k per year that's better than the average in Portugal. If you go to USA working at a job getting $100k a year you probably pay 30k or more in taxes. You're forgetting the cost of living.
- vasco 9y agoEven factoring the cost of living, if you're getting 1500€ after tax in Lisbon (which is an excellent salary for Portugal), and you pay rent on room in a shared house (~400€) you're not going to be saving much. Plus, an iPhone costs the same in Portugal as in the USA, if not more.
- mping 9y ago
- Glawen 9y agoI'm surprised to see Edinburgh, when I graduated in Glasgow 10 years ago, me and my fellow students had to find jobs in the London area. Has the situation changed so much ?
- giobox 9y agoI wouldn't argue it has changed hugely in that time frame, but there have been some developments - notably Amazon now have a development center in the city. > me and my fellow students had to find jobs in the London area This is arguably still true of most any career path you care to choose in the UK - the UK economy in geographic terms is so heavily slanted to the South East/London, especially for "professional" type careers.
- gsnedders 9y agoAs someone who graduated from the University of Glasgow in 2014, those from my year (and those who did an MSci, graduating in 2015) who've remained in Glasgow (that I'm aware of) mostly work at one of two places: JPMorgan (who have a large tech centre in the city) and Skyscanner.
- expertentipp 9y ago> Skyscanner What's their product exactly? In terms of flight search ITA's Matrix beats them IMO.