12 ms·
I think the implication is more, "why are you only paying attention to us? If you think this is a bad practice, then you should be going after our competitors,
by derefr 9y ago
I think the implication is more, "why are you only paying attention to us? If you think this is a bad practice, then you should be going after our competitors, too."
Corporations tend not to mind if you take away a business strategy of theirs, as long as you take it away from everybody else at the same time. If you only take it away from one corporation, that corporation will be temporarily outcompeted by the corporations you haven't yet taken the business strategy away from, so they heavily resist that.
- scotty79 9y agoActually it sounds more like an excuse. "Why have you singled us out for dumping 1000 tonnes of ash into environment each day? Look, this guy is dumping his ashtray on the grass right now!"
- mannykannot 9y ago> Corporations tend not to mind if you take away a business strategy of theirs, as long as you take it away from everybody else at the same time. Not so if it is the only way for the business model to be profitable. More generally, this argument assumes that there is a fixed profit to the business, and the only thing to compete for is a bigger share of that fixed profit. The reality is that corporations are amenable to increasing the profit all around so long as they get part of it, and don't particularly care who gets exploited in the process. Conversely, they do tend to protest when the pool is reduced, even if it affects their competitors similarly.
- chii 9y agonobody likes to be made an example of. However, regulators like to make examples of bigger corporations since the publicity is more effective with them, and also they are able to both pay up and/or change.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoFair application of regulations is essential to rule of law. Going after one company for a common practice but not others is simply the more tyrannical rule by law.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rb666 9y agoIt's a matter of priorities as well. There's hardly funding to prosecute everyone that breaks any sort of law. So you aim for the big fish. Many more are "hurt" by FB's practices than some random other small player. In that sense, FB is committing the larger crime.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoPicking the large foreign company is always an easy target, it can easily lead to protectionism: enforce laws on the outsiders but not the insiders. China is an extreme case of this: foreign companies must walk on egg shells while domestic companies are able to easily break laws now and ask for forgiveness later if the party decides to crackdown.
- rb666 9y agoYou add in the word "foreign" for no apparent reason. What makes you think the EU is targeting FB for being American? I see no proof of this. Size, sure, but the EU also has many regulations for the internal market. For example, we actually have net neutrality, and there's now regulations to limit roaming charges.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoThe argument they’ve made is that they are targeting FB and not their competitors. If true, it has many possible abusive implications, one of the common ones being protectionism. It might not be that, but it is a huge red flag that it could be that.
- anigbrowl 9y ago
- colmvp 9y agoFunny. If your site drops dramatically on Google's search results, or if YouTube/Facebook bans your account for reasons, tough luck. They are a corporation and can do whatever they want without resorting to any sort of internal consistency. But heaven forbid governments hold a dominant corporation accountable in the public interest.
- EggsOnToast 9y ago>Funny. If your site drops dramatically on Google's search results, or if YouTube/Facebook bans your account for reasons, tough luck. They are a corporation and can do whatever they want without resorting to any sort of internal consistency. That's not really relevant to the parent's observation that Facebook is likely arguing that they're being singled out in an environment where their practices are so rampant as to be standard. >But heaven forbid governments hold a dominant corporation accountable in the public interest. "accountable to the public interest" is an incredibly disingenuous way to say "enforce their laws". The difference matters in this context because the counter argument would be "why is the law being enforced predominantly against a handful of American companies instead of the industry at large?"
- ludston 9y agoThis law has to be enforced somewhere first. Either it is enforced against Facebook first, and Facebook complains "Why don't all of the the small fries have to do it yet" and if it is enforced against the small fries, they will say, "Why doesn't Facebook have to do it yet"? And the answer is, the justice department will probably enforce the law in the way that the expect to have the best effect for themselves. It is not necessary to wait until you are sued before you become legally compliant?
- em3rgent0rdr 9y ago> "This law has to be enforced somewhere first." Still, the lawsuits should be simultaneously served to all companies. Preferably with a courtesy heads up.
- gesman 9y agoYeah. How many times this line saved you? "Officer, The guy in front of me was driving fast too, so why not him?"
- lokopodium 9y agoThis business strategy is only viable if your market penetration is huge. No wonder the biggest infringer is tackled first. Also, this probably is a precedent-setting decision with more to follow.
- thisisit 9y agoI don't think many of their competitors have the same reach as Facebook. Nowadays sites have social plugins to allow their customers to "share" content. This in turn adds the problematic cookie/pixel.
- scoofy 9y agoWhataboutism isn't an argument... if you're going to start somewhere, you have to start with someone, especially in civil court. Setting precedents will open up other websites to lawsuits
- anigbrowl 9y agoThat leads to writing a law for every little technological innovation, which is an arms race legislators can't possibly win. Prosecuting a corporate body for violating a general principle sends a clear signal to other market players using an unethical tactic: comply or you're next.
- polskibus 9y agoWhy don't they point out others and cooperate with EU to stop this practice altogether then?
- mgoetzke 9y agoThere is a rule in Germany called "Im Unrecht gibt es keine Gleichberechtigung". Meaning when you are breaking the law you cannot point to others also breaking the law as defense.
- kazen44 9y agoAs far as i know, isn't this basically global? atleast in civil law systems, i yet have to find a country where this isn't the case.
- pfortuny 9y agoThey were the ones being denounced. It is like a drug kingpin being caught and saying “why am I the only one”, we all do the same? Well, you are just the fisrt one and the biggest one.
- noway421 9y agoThis is the reason regulation and fair competition should exist.
- amelius 9y ago> I think the implication is more, "why are you only paying attention to us?" I read that as: why are you only paying attention now? (i.e. after allowing the industry to reach its current, pathological state)
- simion314 9y agoEU is working for years on laws to protect the citizens rights from this internet companies, the laws take years to be created and when done are announced and it also takes a long period of time before the laws will start to apply. Do you prefer that we create laws for fixing problems that do not exist yet?
- AndyMcConachie 9y agoThere is this thing called legal precedent. You set it once and it can be applied over, and over, and over, and over....
- gregknicholson 9y agoLegal Java!
- rowyourboat 9y ago> I think the implication is more, "why are you only paying attention to us? If you think this is a bad practice, then you should be going after our competitors, too." "But, officer, everybody else was speeding, too!"
- amelius 9y agos/speeding/downloading ;)
- EggsOnToast 9y agoTo be pedantic, I can attest that in California drivers ed they teach you that it's safest to keep with the flow of traffic. The difficulty is in proving that traffic was going as fast as you.
- simion314 9y agoIs this rule above the other rules like speed limits, stooping at red light ? It seems to me that this kind of fuzzy rules can undermine the others.
- vlozko 9y agoThey both can apply. The flow of traffic laws, such as the one in California, are to prevent people from going significantly below the speed limit. Its a better approach, in my opinion, then a minimum speed limit law that many states use. That said, you'll end up driving white-knuckled and fearful of your life if you dare go the speed limit on the Mass Pike. You'd have to drive 70-75 minimum here just to feel safe.
- simion314 9y agoYes, it makes sense for the minimum speed, here in Europe the max speed can't be exceeded and on top of that you have to adapt your speed to the actual condition, if is ice or the road is wet, or there is fog the law says you have to reduce your speed until you are safe, if you did not reduced it enough and did an accident you are guilty. I hate when someone drivers respecting the limit and you get jerks with big cars or trucks behind you and force you to go faster(by force I mean get close behind you, use the horn and other bad behavior that can intimidate a new driver).
- sorokod 9y agoI think this is an odd defence to follow if indeed this is a defence. It's as if a convicted criminal demands to overturn the conviction because some other (alleged) criminals haven't been on trial yet.
- Someone 9y ago"The privacy lawsuit dates back to 2015 when the Belgium privacy watchdog brought a civil suit against Facebook for its near invisible tracking of non-users via social plug-ins and the like. […] The same year, after failing to obtain adequate responses to its concerns, the Belgian Privacy Commission decided to take Facebook to court over one of them: How it deploys tracking cookies and social plug-ins on third-party websites to track the internet activity of users and non-users." If I go to the police to complain that my neighbour is spying on me, it's only natural that the police only investigates that neighbour.
- candu 9y ago...and one obvious answer is: as one of the largest companies doing this, they benefit more than all of those other corporations. Also: from the jurisdiction's point of view, this is perhaps the only efficient way to allocate legal / judicial resources. You go after a small handful of big-name "make an example" cases, and hope that this deters use of the business strategy by the long tail of smaller companies you can't afford to go after.
- learnstats2 9y ago>Corporations tend not to mind if you take away a business strategy of theirs, as long as you take it away from everybody else at the same time. That's not true in this case. As the large incumbent in social media and advertising, Facebook are the company most impacted by this, whether or not their competitors are impacted.
- hannnoi 9y agoI'm sure other companies do this, but I'm way more familiar with Facebook's indiscretions. If they're made an example of what's going to be a standard, I wouldn't be surprised if it happens to other companies soon.