27 ms·
Hacker News's Undocumented Features and Behaviors
- parliament32 9y agoThis is pretty neat, thanks!
- kaffeemitsahne 9y ago> and moderators can set a comment to automatically be collapsed if necessary (e.g. meta-discussion). I'd like to be able to turn this off in my profile. Or maybe it can be linked to "showdead".
- mintplant 9y agoYou could send an email to hn@ycombinator.com requesting this feature. They're very responsive.
- nukeop 9y agoI've always been amazed that a proprietary engine with unclear rules and unavailable source code is the dominant source of news for the hacker community. Although it is designed better than reddit, unpopular opinions are still punished, which can stifle discussion and results in users self-moderating themselves and preventing themselves, even subconsciously, from expressing certain opinions from fear of downvoting. Many of those undocumented behaviours are described with speculation - why don't we have a clear image of the capabilities and inner workings of Hacker News available anywhere? Security by obscurity?
- IntronExon 9y agoObscurity is a poor sole means of security, but as part of a robust system it’s a valid layer.
- morinted 9y agoThere are lots of open source discussion systems, and lots of transparent ones. For whatever reason, the closed and opinionated Hacker News reached the popularity that it did. I don't mind it. Something about the mystery and the relatively tight moderation has kept HN from becoming too off topic and silly. Do you think Hacker News has somehow avoided Eternal September?
- krapp 9y ago>For whatever reason, the closed and opinionated Hacker News reached the popularity that it did. I don't mind it. It being owned by a multimillion dollar VC company might have something to do with it.
- kbenson 9y agoI'm sure that helped, especially in the beginning, but at this point I think the number of people that value it for the community and discussion far exceeds those that use it to keep abridged of YC developments.
- krapp 9y agoStill, being seen here has value in part because of who sees you, itself in part because of the VC and startup culture behind the site. Keeping abreast of YC developments doesn't even matter - some people want to hang around the water cooler where very important people might happen to walk by. I suspect that if this were just a tech and programming forum, it would be about as popular as a niche imageboard like lainchan.
- icebraining 9y agoHN was already pretty popular while YC was only distributing $1M/year, back in 2010. But posting was encouraged to YC participants (IIRC), which probably did help it quite a bit.
- malnourish 9y agoI see plenty of disagreement in the threads I visit. The things I tend to see downvoted are things that contain blatant falsities and bigoted comments. I'm OK with people self-censoring those. I'm willing to grant that I might be missing things I would otherwise agree with.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoI see a lot of substantive comments that are grey; quite often there are dead comments that seem pretty good too.
- malnourish 9y agoI'll try to keep my eyes open and vouch/upvote those.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoDo you get the option to vouch? I'm at >26k karma and still don't have the vouch option, which leads me to believe it's been turned off for my user.
- grzm 9y agoIt’s only visible in the individual comment view (like the flag link) iirc, and it’s only available for dead (not just flagged) comments. For example, I have a vouch link available for this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16439776 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16439776 You might want to shoot the mods an email to check the if there’s something particular with your account.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nosuchthing 9y agoAh yes, you have to click the [X hours ago] link and directly flag/vouch from that page. Otherwise it's not an option on the normal comment page. Thanks for clarifying.
- craigsmansion 9y ago> that a proprietary engine I'd rather call it in-house than proprietary. Maintaining or even publishing a project in the open is a lot of work, and it's not like there aren't a lot of open-source forums available, so I can imagine the maintainers deciding it's really not worth it. In fact, the comment system of LWN is in-house as well, and I doubt anyone would accuse them of proprietary sympathies. They're getting there, but it's just nor a priority, or even that important in the open source world.
- blattimwind 9y agoA (very old) version of this software's code is available.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoBack when we had scores shown most people would seem to vote towards their ideal score for that post -- that was the consensus in voting discussions I was party to (IIRC). I'd vote down highly voted comments that I agreed with because the comment wasn't that good; also upvote any comment that was negative that seemed to have value. But then I learnt pg said basically 'downvote if you disagree', which IMO makes the site much worse. Also then votes were hidden and so I spend most votes on things I disagree with because they made a good point and I believe others should at least be able to see the text of the comment. I also dislike hidden censorship, hidden rules, and hidden moderators/moderation (eg covert post promotion for Ycombinator companies).
- DanBC 9y agopg said different things about downvoting. The last comment I link to seems to agree that some downvoting is a problem. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=658683 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=658683 > IIRC we first had this conversation about a month after launch. Downvotes have always been used to express disagreement. Or more precisely, a negative score has: users seem not to downvote something they disagree with if it already has a sufficiently negative score. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171 > I think it's ok to use the up and down arrows to express agreement. Obviously the uparrows aren't only for applauding politeness, so it seems reasonable that the downarrows aren't only for booing rudeness. > It only becomes abuse when people resort to karma bombing: downvoting a lot of comments by one user without reading them in order to subtract maximum karma. Fortunately we now have several levels of software to protect against that. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2403716 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2403716 > [...] Another problem is that people use point scores as a guide to voting. It's clear from voting patterns that many if not most users vote not to express approval or disapproval, but to cause the comment to have what they believe is an appropriate number of points. If I didn't display points, people couldn't do that. Perhaps that's not a problem. But if it turned out that that's what voting was for, then this could break voting, which would in turn break the sorting of comments, which would be a problem now that there are so many. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1057338 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1057338
- aplorbust 9y ago
- patwalls 9y agoWhat about https://news.ycombinator.com/best https://news.ycombinator.com/best ?
- DeanWormer 9y agoAnd https://news.ycombinator.com/active https://news.ycombinator.com/active
- chillingeffect 9y agoIt's scary to think I've been here long enough to know things others don't.. Or maybe "those that would know won't tell." Either way: https://news.ycombinator.com/leaders https://news.ycombinator.com/leaders
- colanderman 9y agoAll the above are accessible from the "Lists" link at the bottom of most pages.
- NoGravitas 9y agoOne thing I think it should have mentioned is that although comment scores are not shown to anyone but the user, it is easy enough to infer them, at least approximately. Obviously, negative scores are shown by desaturation. And positive scores are shown by sort order.
- lucideer 9y agoDon't new comments get momentarily bumped to the top before dropping, before they get any votes?
- blattimwind 9y agoThey do. I also have the impression that the number of childs influences sort order.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoI hate the desaturation, I should add a user.css entry for it or something. Effectively silencing non-mainstream views seems so contrary to hacker culture to me.
- Larrikin 9y agoContrarian views aren't usually down voted here, low quality posts are. Troll posts that may have some semblance of an actual point should be rephrased to actually be part of a discussion.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoI disagree - the are at least 2 top level comments on this story now that are greyed out. I consider them to be well-made, definitely not flames or spam, clearly written but contrary to the apparent majority view. Even uncontroversial statements of fact get down-voted. Take this: >"Also, I don't think vouching for [dead] comments actually does anything beyond warm fuzzies." // assuming the commenter didn't lie then it is a fact, they started their thought. Now the down-voters may know vouching revives comments, but that's no reason to downvote, that's reason to respond with a source. Even if they are mistaken, it's harsh to downvote a view that can't be easily corrected because of hidden information. Meh.
- NoGravitas 9y agoAlso, I don't think vouching for [dead] comments actually does anything beyond warm fuzzies.
- jlgaddis 9y agoI think it does. I have, in the past, seen [dead] comments that (IMO) shouldn't have been, clicked on "vouch", and when the page refreshes they are no longer [dead]. Or maybe HN just shows it that way to me and it is, in fact, still [dead] (kinda like hellbans).
- maxerickson 9y agoI'm pretty sure it works in the obvious way. I would guess that some comments take less vouching to be reborn than others though.
- Jtsummers 9y agoIt actually brings them back, they do not lie to you about them not being [dead] anymore. I've vouched for a number of shadowbanned users when they have a comment that ought to be visible and then other people reply to it. You can verify (should you run across this again) by logging out or using incognito mode to view the page after you vouch.
- blattimwind 9y agoI've noticed that sometimes [dead] comments don't seem to be revived by - presumably - just me clicking vouch. Perhaps vouches and flags and other criteria are balanced against each other or something like that.
- IntronExon 9y agoThe OP article explains that vouch only works once, and if there are more flags it stays dead.
- gergles 9y agoThe value of vouching, like everything else on HN, is secretly manipulated behind the scenes depending on how much you agree with the hivemind. If you vouch for things that then get flagged again (because the hivemind doesn't want to read them,) your vouches will carry less and less weight.
- book_mentioned 9y agoMy latest campaign has been to find a way to add the tiniest bit of accountability for downvotes. I believe at a minimum the total number of downvotes given should be shown publicly on user profiles. As things function now, downvotes are for all intents and purposes anonymous.
- pvg 9y agoWhy do any votes need 'accountability'? Their purpose is to identify comments worth reading. Almost everything people write about voting itself is not worth reading and the less of it, the better.
- book_mentioned 9y agoMy intention is to ensure contributing to publicly censoring/censuring costs something (intentionally tiny, but greater than zero/nothing) each time, beyond the one-time minimum karma requirement. "Downvote to disagree" seems unlikely to scale indefinitely, particularly as mobile means less willingness to contribute beyond clicking up/down (specifically now that there are apps catching on that remove all "fat-fingered web UI" friction!). It's perfectly fine to disagree with this belief; HN itself does! [Edited]
- pvg 9y agoI know it's perfectly fine, I'm trying to follow this (very common) line of thought and adherents never seem to explain it in a way I can understand. For one thing you're not really 'censoring' anything but even if we say, for the sake of argument, that you are why should it have some cost different than the cost of 'promoting' something when you upvote? The mods' argument that meta is bad for actual conversation is also quite compelling. What's the counter to that other than stuff that mostly seems to boil down to some version of 'getting downvotes kind of feels bad' (of which calling downvotes 'censoring' seems like a particularly overwrought variant).
- book_mentioned 9y ago
- olfactory 9y agoIt will be interesting to see how we look back on the moderators' decision to stifle political discussion on HN. In my opinion it is a horrible abdication of responsibility among technologists to simply hide any content that pertains to politics. But it is fitting that the political monoculture of the valley would give rise to an HN moderation regime that includes aggressive censorship. I love HN and have learned a great deal from the articles and comments, but censoring political discussion is a form of sides-taking and HN mods are unabashedly responsible for it. It's a truly shameful dark cloud in what is otherwise a vibrant and flourishing ecosystem of ideas.
- minimaxir 9y agoIt's worth nothing there was a full-on Political Detox experiment awhile back: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13108404 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13108404 It did not go well.
- gergles 9y agoI love the statement of fact here, as if your opinion alone determines what "went well" means. The outcome that people threw giant hissy fits about not being able to Trump-bash or insist that Silicon Valley is the most sexist institution ever created for a week does not mean that the experiment didn't go well. In fact, I'd argue the exact opposite. It illustrated how deeply embedded a certain sociopolitical view is on this site despite everyone constantly patting themselves on the back over how smart, tolerant, and accepting they are. I think the experiment went quite well at illustrating what HN has become.
- grzm 9y agoI've seen what you describe as "hissy fits" (and well-reasoned, substantive comments for that matter) come from all points of the political and ideological spectrum. The most deeply embedded sociopolitical view I'm aware of is the natural human bias that "it's the $otherSide that's responsible for misbehavior".
- dang 9y ago
- ChrisSD 9y agoMissing from that list is everyone's favourite feature: Using code blocks as block quotes so as to make them almost unreadable on mobile. Especially when the post is already indented a few levels.
- Y_Y 9y agoUsing code blocks as block c What's wrong with that?
- Jtsummers 9y agoThe default styling results in it having too narrow a view so it requires a lot of side scrolling on mobile devices. It gets really annoying for block quoted text past 80-90 characters.
- Y_Y 9y agoI'm on android Firefox at the moment and I can confirm that it becomes problematic after about thirty characters. That's what I meant by my previous post.
- kbenson 9y agoUnofficial HN community guide: Short comments meant to be viewed as sarcasm end up being interpreted incorrectly often when used in a serious forum. A short clarifying rider sentence explaining your real opinion often helps. That may ruin the joke, but if your comment was just to make a joke, it probably wasn't strong enough reason to comment anyway (for additional info on jokes, see the section entitled How to make a joke and not get downvoted). Addendum: Poe's law is alive and well. (The above is of course my take, and other people will follow their own best practices)
- MaulingMonkey 9y agoSarcasm marks (e.g. "/s") are another option, although I was able to get it without the annotation.
- postit 9y ago"after users reach 500 Karma, they gain the ability to downvote another comment" Ahh that's why I don't see a downvote button :) - I thought it was a feature reserved to super privileged users
- postit 9y agoBut not it made me wonder, how a positive enforcing behavior is only allowing down vote until you reach a threshold. It makes you engage and understand the community better before making your judgment.
- 2close4comfort 9y agoIt is also a way to manipulate HN to allow those with similar views to prosper and reinforce those same ideas. Those who don't agree have less power...
- rubidium 9y agoIt's not hard to get to 500 thru purely technical commentary. If you're here for politicizing or snide remarks, then yes I hope it's hard to to get to 500.
- plopilop 9y agoI don't find it easy personally, my most upvoted comment has 14 points, most are under 4 points. But then, I don't comment often and I don't care about being able to downvote, so I think I'll survive.
- the_watcher 9y agoComments are worth a point, so as long as you're not posting comments that are regularly downvoted, just participating will get you there.
- 9y ago
- IntronExon 9y agoThis is a great write up, and answered a question I had about comments which are automatically collapsed. I understand the frustration around the lack of politics/diversity discussions, but I agree with the way it’s handled here. Those discussions need to be had, but do they need to be had here? They are divisive, and often leave lasting wounds which lead to the creation of factions. Mostly though, the internet is short on places like HN, and long on places to endlessly discuss politics, usually in a very predictable circle. I don’t believe that much good comes from anonymous text exchanges online where politics are concerned.
- Y_Y 9y agoPeople like discussing things on hn because the quality of discourse tends to be (relatively) very high. Naturally people would especially want to discuss politics or anything else that's almost universally a shitshow in a place where they thing commenters are thoughtful and fair and level-headed. Of course it could well be the case that we have such an environment here _because_ debating politics is discouraged.
- IntronExon 9y agoOf course it could well be the case that we have such an environment here _because_ debating politics is discouraged. I strongly believe this, and I think the evidence is the content of threads where the mods gave people a chance. The volume, in both senses of the word, becomes extreme, with hundreds of angry nested comments.
- dang 9y agoYou've put your finger on one of the fundamental problems of this site.
- tptacek 9y agoThere's another phenomenon at play with political stories, I think. Much of what occupies the front page is sort of implicitly siloed. Rust programmers are the active writers in Rust threads. Data science programmers are active in ML or word vector threads. People interested in math are active in math threads. There's a story on the front page about Google's "TPUv2's". I don't even know what a Google TPU is, so you're unlikely to have to deal with my comments on that thread. Not so political threads! Everybody is on equal footing in them. There's no "people with expertise relating their experience" and "people asking questions" and the rest of us reading with interest. Rather, everyone's broadcasting. That's not inherently bad, I don't think; there are lots of other kinds of threads that are like that and they seem to be fine (for the most part) for HN's culture. But politics is a particularly toxic combination of broad-spectrum and polarizing. There are never voices of reason or experience, the most active participants are often on a hair trigger, and participation is amplified because everyone's got an opinion.
- codingdave 9y agoJust a side note, but... why are people using github as a content publishing platform? It just isn't a good UX for that, and there is no lack of workable CMS systems out there.
- malnourish 9y agoIt could be multi-fold: * It's free * People are already signed up for it * It brings exposure to your github profile
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ztoben 9y agoYeah, exactly this. If your article/gist/etc gains some traction it's an easy way to get people to look at your other projects. Github's success is largely dependent on the social aspect.
- blattimwind 9y ago* github profiles are rarely deleted and content put up once will stay there for many years Seriously, dead links to github.{com, io} are super-rare IME.
- tgb 9y agoAren't they deleted if they're inactive for N years?
- mintplant 9y agoI don't believe this is the case. They may become eligible for reclamation if someone else wants the name, per the Name Squatting Policy [0]. [0] https://help.github.com/articles/name-squatting-policy/ https://help.github.com/articles/name-squatting-policy/
- Semaphor 9y ago
- throwaway4u098 9y agoI've noticed when using a VPN, my posts would be shown in my own account but not anyone else's. Thought this was a strange behavior. Wasn't certain whether this is a consistency issue or whether posting through a VPN isn't possible. Anyone know why? May be good to add it to the document.
- blattimwind 9y agoHN has shadow-banning based on an unknown set of criteria.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoTo be clear, are you saying if you're on VPN you're shadow-banned, effectively, but the same account works fine when not on VPN?
- grzm 9y agoI seem to recall 'dang mentioning this can happen, and that they can whitelist accounts. If you see it happening to yourself, you can contact them and they'll look into it.
- oldcynic 9y agoProbably multiple accounts, and/or rate limits, coming from a single IP which is likely on a VPN. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html (Last item)
- ohyoutravel 9y agoCould be a popular VPN. For example my VPN is very popular so I would be shocked if others weren't using it, and it must look like all users are coming from the same place.
- LethargicStud 9y agoGreat article, I learned a lot. I've wondered for a while why some usernames appear green, it would be nice to include that too.
- linuxguy2 9y agoNew accounts are green. Seems that two weeks is the threshold for showing up normal.
- kbenson 9y agoI think moderators can bypass that as well. I'm fairly sure I've seen accounts go from green to normal within hours when it was the author of some paper or project that someone submitted finding out they are on HN and making an account to answer questions. I suspect moderators authenticated the user separately, or used the comments to do so if it was completely obvious.
- krapp 9y agoI'd like to see the second chance pool made public, if only as another entry under /lists.
- jacquesm 9y agoThat's already there, it's the new pages beyond the first one.
- cs702 9y agoIt's also a good idea to review the guidelines every once in a while: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- d--b 9y agoSomething I frequently use is search HN on algolia.
- bpicolo 9y agoThat's builtin (bottom bar of hn)
- reichardt 9y agoOne question that's not answered: what do green usernames represent? Would honestly love to know!
- blattimwind 9y agoNew account
- grinsekatze 9y agoAs far as I know, new users are green for a certain time period. edit: under 2 weeks old
- yeukhon 9y agoI thought earning enough karma would adjust the color to default, I guesd I am wrong.
- minimaxir 9y agoGood catch. Added.
- singularity2001 9y agoI honestly always assumed these are verified celebrities with a million karma.
- favadi 9y agoI always thought they are original poster.
- mercer 9y agoThat's red, I think.
- mintplant 9y agoIf you mean orange: > Additionally, founders of YC companies see each other's usernames show up in orange, which--although not an explicit benefit--does allow fellow YC founders to immediately identify one another in discussions. Submitters' names aren't highlighted in any way.
- oldcynic 9y agoI was hoping to find all the unlisted URLs some of which I can never remember, like /leaders etc. Interesting nonetheless. There does seem to be some attempts to game HN lately that I don't remember in the past - like a recent tendency of some new accounts to ask dozens upon dozens of questions. I can only assume there's some karma gaming behind that.
- lainon 9y ago> I was hoping to find all the unlisted URLs some of which I can never remember, like /leaders etc. https://news.ycombinator.com/lists https://news.ycombinator.com/lists
- oldcynic 9y agoThanks! That's one I hadn't encountered! :)
- fao_ 9y agoInterestingly enough this doesn't include Hacker News Classic, one of my favourite frontends: https://news.ycombinator.com/classic https://news.ycombinator.com/classic
- jedberg 9y agoI don't understand the difference between this and the regular front page. I can see it has different content, but why? Does it use a larger time factor? It seems like everything there is older, but maybe that's just because it calculates less frequently?
- russellbeattie 9y agoHow does one contribute to the code running HN? I read the site almost exclusively on my tablet, and I would love a "open links in new window" settings option and would be quite happy to help write the code to make it happen.
- thedirt0115 9y agoNot sure what tablet/browser you're using, but several have extensions to create a whitelist of sites to always open links in new tabs. I haven't tried this one in particular, but Chrome has an "Open in new tab" extension where the description actually says "Useful for websites such as hackernews where you would ideally like to open links in new tab."
- burnte 9y agoI have a couple suggestions too.
- johannes1234321 9y agoThis shouldn't be the default ever. I the user, have the control of I want a new window/tab or use the current one. Sites opening links in new windows/tabs try tomorrow me on their site, for their reasons, not mine. When building a web application: Make sure to not play with links in a way that Ctrl+click, context menu or, on mobile, long touch don't work, but allow me to open new tabs, and keep the state if I go away and then use the back button to come back. Even for non-powerusers this is a good habit. Non-powerusers are often surprised bu new windows popping up.
- russellbeattie 9y agoNever said it should be the default, just an option (like it is in Reddit). Also, one would hope even the below average HN reader wouldn't be surprised by a new window.
- mintplant 9y agoThe code isn't generally open to outside contributions, but you can email your suggestions to Dan and Scott at hn@ycombinator.com.
- digi_owl 9y agoThey also have a "fun" half way house before shadowbanning, limiting your comments to X pr Y hours...
- sbuccini 9y agoI didn't realize you could see all topbar colors that have been set on the site. Would be a really interesting way to implement message passing.
- Karunamon 9y agoOne more - flagging and vouching have an invisible weight to them, and I'm about 90% sure that weight is based on how well your flags and vouches line up with what everyone else does. I've been here for years, and it used to be that when I flagged things, they went dead instantly. After a particularly controversial thread or two, not so much. Vouch is the same way - one time I vouched a comment that was pretty plainly insulting, but had something that I thought was valuable for discussion in it. I vouched it, it went alive instantly, I replied, and it was apparently later flagged again. My vouches no longer appear to do anything. I hate all this cloak and dagger stuff, to be honest. I've more than once stopped myself clicking "flag" because I know that I'll be penalized if I get it wrong (read: enough people disagree with me). And all that stuff above? It's pure speculation, because it's all the UI gives me. Worse, barring the occasional bit of moderator invention to unkill a post, all of these mechanics serve to enforce a hivemind, whether or not that's the intent. Quality doesn't matter as much as consensus, because the consensus is enforced transparently, the quality with intervention.
- Tomte 9y agoI‘ve had the same experience. I thought about not flagging anymore, but so what. I‘m offering my ratings, and if HN doesn‘t want to use them, so be it. And it feels good to flag shitposts.
- fpgaminer 9y ago> I hate all this cloak and dagger stuff, to be honest. I'm sure most agree. But the purpose of the obfuscation is to make the jobs of those who wish to abuse the system harder. So we, normal users, are trading the inconvenience of an opaque system in exchange for (hopefully) a less abused system. I'm willing to make that trade and, as the sibling points out, you might as well flag/vouch/vote/downvote and let dang and company do as they please with the data you've offered them. Personally, as long as HN continues to be better than Reddit, for the kind of discussions I come here for, I will continue to participate regardless of the underlying system.
- nosuchthing 9y agoSee this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16440450 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16440450 You need to click the [x time ago] link to see the flag/vouch option.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- camtarn 9y agoHas anybody analysed how karma works for submissions that make the front page? It feels like there's either a rate limit on how much karma you can earn from a submission, or the amount of karma earned per upvote is inversely proportional to the number of upvotes, or something. I've noticed that I earned 1 karma for 1 upvote for the first few upvotes, and also 1 karma for 1 upvote when the article's been off the front page for days but people are still reading and occasionally upvoting it. But in between it's definitely not a 1:1 - maybe more like 10:1 or even less. It feels like there are probably some really interesting rules involved :)
- a13n 9y agoI've also noticed this and would like to know more. I feel like this didn't happen on HN 5 years ago, but it does now. I always wondered if maybe it keeps track of who has voted on your submissions in the past, and only gives you karma if the voter hasn't voted on you before.
- jjp 9y agoNot sure whether it's influenced by your existing karma. My perception (with sample size of one) is that when my karma was lower I accrued at closer to 1:1, whereas now definitely not accruing at 1:1.
- chopin 9y agoSame with me. However, rules may have changed over time and I am only slowly accruing karma.
- minimaxir 9y agoTo my knowledge, upvotes which are suspected to be inauthentic do not count toward the overall karma gained (I have no citations, which is why I did not include it in the list)
- kbenson 9y agoDo you ever notice that you'll lose two points on a comment at the same time, then later they'll come back? I see that relatively often (once every couple weeks), and on completely uncontroversial comments, which is how I started noticing it. I wondered if it was some vote manipulation detection, where they've linked two accounts voting similarly and nullified their upvotes, but later clear them so they votes are reapplied. In any case, it's always two together (which is why I don't think it's an accidental downvote), and seems to be close to the same time if not the exact same time.
- gadders 9y agoThere is also the "Slow down, you're posting too fast" feature that kicks in, likely to calm down flame wars, Unfortunately it seems to block everything, not just the thread in question.
- dang 9y agoThat usually means your account is rate-limited. Various explanations at https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comment&storyText=false&prefix=false&page=0&query=by:dang%20rate%20limit https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme... We're always happy to take the rate limit off if people give us reason to believe that they want to use HN as intended and will abide by https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html in the future.
- gus_massa 9y agoA nitpick about notation: For me, "Shadowbanning" or "hellbanning" means that the post of the user/site are [dead] but the systems lies to the user and to nim/her show the post as alive. And the only way to notice is to logout or get another computer and check the post from there. Killing the post form an user or site automatically, and showing to the user that the posts are [dead] is not shadowbanning. I call it "autokilling" but I'm not sure that it is he official name. Almost all the recent case/discussions of similar cases were simply autokilling. In the initial times of HN it was more common to have hellbanned users, but it's very rare now. Moreover, I remember a comment of dang where he said that they were considering to remove all the hellbanning and only use autokilling. I'm not sure if they finally made that change.
- Kenji 9y ago> Moreover, I remember a comment of dang where he said that they were considering to remove all the hellbanning and only use autokilling. I'm not sure if they finally made that change. Nope, that change has not been made. I'm hellbanned.
- DanBC 9y agoNot really. Hell banning is a silent action. You don't tell the user they were banned. You got several warnings, and then you were told you were banned. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14938232 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14938232 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14960370 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14960370 EDIT: just for clarity: I'm not a mod.
- Kenji 9y agoI didn't mean to complain. I respect and accept your decision to ban me. There are large parts of this community that truly aren't for me. I just wanted to say it to educate the people that the shadowban mechanics are still active, with myself as the example.
- gus_massa 9y ago@Kenji : You have a sibling comment that now is [dead]. Do you see it marked as [dead] or it looks to you like a normal comment? How do you know that you are banned? [EDIT: Someone vouched your comment, so I see it now as a normal comment. I was going to vouch it after the experiment :( .] Just to be 100% sure that we are using the same definitions: Can you post a screenshot in imgur of your sibling comment, so we can see how it looks to you? For comparison: I see https://imgur.com/a/1Z3dF https://imgur.com/a/1Z3dF PS: Please don't downvote the GP comment, so we can have a nice conversation. Try to keep it black, or at least dark grey.
- weinzierl 9y ago> There is no upper limit on the score of a comment, but the minimum score is -4 points. According to the The Unofficial Hacker News FAQ [1] this is only partly correct, but I don‘t feel like testing it. [1] > I’m at -4 for a comment and still my karma is dropping, how come? > HN is ‘subtle’ in that not everything always is what it seems. Votes are not always counted and those votes that are counted are not always displayed. So even though your vote count for that comment shows as -4, in actual fact it may be much lower. Take your lumps, analyze why you got those downvotes and if you feel they were justified then try to do better in the future. A side effect of the votes still being counted past -4 seems to be that people tend to delete their comments with a much higher frequency than in the past to cap the damage to their karma. https://jacquesmattheij.com/the-unofficial-hn-faq#badcomment https://jacquesmattheij.com/the-unofficial-hn-faq#badcomment
- betterworldb 9y agoCounting system sounds like Reddit voting system where 1 upvote != 1 vote
- thaumasiotes 9y agoI can confirm that the minimum display score is -4 points regardless of the amount of karma lost on a comment.
- grzm 9y agoI think what your parent is getting at is that you'll lose at most 4 karma regardless of how many downvotes a comment may eventually accumulate. At least in my experience I haven't seen my karma fall more than 4 points due to a single comment, as far as I can remember. Have you a different experience?
- thaumasiotes 9y agoYes, of course. Downvotes are not shown (past the 5th), but karma losses are. Just as described in my parent comment: >> I’m at -4 for a comment and still my karma is dropping, how come?
- laken 9y agoMy favorite little-known HN feature (not even mentioned on this link!) is the noprocrast mode. You can set in your profile to be locked out of HN for a set amount of time, after another set amount of time on HN. Prevents procrastination :)
- a13n 9y agoOh wow, that's a good one! My favorite is being able to change the nav color (`topcolor`). I changed it to the purple brand color from our startup [1]. [1]: https://canny.io https://canny.io
- gkya 9y agoI can imagine that being used as a security feature for UIs, against phishing attacks: now that you are registered and logged in, choose one of these colours/pictures for this certain, easily visible area of your dashboard. If the use saw a different colour, would know that's phishing.
- minimaxir 9y agonoprocrast is in the FAQ, which is why I didn't add it.
- tzury 9y agoThank you Max! Well done.
- desireco42 9y agoI feel like this is not enforced enough Implicit Downranking of Politics The Guidelines state that political discussion is off-topic. However, as of recently, the line between technology and politics has become extremely blurred. Most tech related submissions with a hint of political partisanship will quickly be flagged to death by users (or die a slow death due to the inevitable flame war).
- nugi 9y agoYeah, half of what I flag is political articles thinly disguised as tech or science articles.
- dang 9y agoThe guidelines don't state that, as you can see by reading the second paragraph of https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and, to quote pg from long ago, noting those words 'most' and 'probably'. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4922426 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4922426)
- erikj 9y ago"Discussions about race/gender" is also political discussion, it's very strange that the author doesn't understand this unless he has some implicit intentions here and separates these topics on purpose.
- tyrust 9y agoThere's nothing strange about drawing a distinction. You calling it "strange" in an attempt to create controversy where there is none is uncool.
- ryanianian 9y agoNot to get too meta, but the fact that "discussions of race/gender in tech == politics in general" is a call-out that many may not think of. E.g., an article discussing women tech leaders may not seem like regular politics, but recent politics tend to prove otherwise.
- minimaxir 9y agoA good example of the Hacker News reaction to gender topics (and no relation to partisan politics whatsoever) is what happened when a YC engineer launched a online community for women: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16159808 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16159808
- SAI_Peregrinus 9y agoPolitical discussion should be understood to mean discussion about the activities and policies of governments. Discussions about race/gender are far more often about tech companies internal policies, and thus a separate (but related) category.
- aleyan 9y ago> Both are very responsive when contacted at hn@ycombinator.com True in my experience when I asked for my comment to be deleted. > Complaining about being downvoted is discouraged and usually results in even more downvotes. It works sometimes however. My comment [1] was controversial and was moving up and down between negative and +4 votes for the first two hours of its life. After I made the edit complaining about the downvotes, it started rising rapidly and is now resting at +22. > Hacker News encourages a single discussion on a given story. All others are marked as a [dupe] and will be killed without the ability to vouch. An addendum is that from my experience, it is unclear which story the mods will consider the dupe, sometimes the earlier posted story will be called the dupe. > Relatedly, moderators can also invite users via email to resubmit a post which didn't get much traction. This happened to my "All the goodness gone from tea (1688)" [2] submission. I am amazed that a moderator read a submission that was only +2 in its original form and also had difficult ergonomics because it was on google books. > One popular "trick" for obfuscating voting manipulation ... This trick doesn't actually work. So, undetectable vote manipulation hasn't been detected and there fore doesn't exist? I have trouble believing this. This seems more like a call to not even try claiming that it won't work, because it just might work. I wish some charitable soul with gray morals would step up with their story of voter manipulation that wasn't detected. Tooling could be developed to curb its use by other individuals. They can do this privately to the mods. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15994458 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15994458 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15324547 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15324547
- smsm42 9y ago> So, undetectable vote manipulation hasn't been detected and there fore doesn't exist? I think rather the point was that this particular way of manipulation is detectable and is being detected. That of course doesn't preclude other ways of manipulation which are not.
- alsetmusic 9y ago> It works sometimes however. My comment [1] was controversial and was moving up and down between negative and +4 votes for the first two hours of its life. After I made the edit complaining about the downvotes, it started rising rapidly and is now resting at +22. Downvotes are also disabled after a period of time. A comment can only go up or maintain its rank once that has happened. This is evident when reading older threads. That probably doesn’t account for all of the upvotes in your example, of course.
- colanderman 9y agoA few more of interest: • You cannot downvote a comment after 24 hours have passed. (There is no time limit for upvotes.) • You cannot downvote comments which are direct replies to your own. (There is no restriction to downvote further descendants.) • You cannot unvote/undown a comment after (I think) one hour has passed. • You cannot reply to a reply to one of your comments for a certain number of minutes, which increases based on some relation with nesting depth. However, the reply link appears sooner on the permalink of such comments than it does from the story page. • You cannot edit a comment after (I think) one hour has passed.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y ago>You cannot reply to a reply to one of your comments for a certain number of minutes, which increases based on some relation with nesting depth. Is this the 'you're posting too fast, please slow down' message?
- digi_owl 9y agoThat one shows for a number of conditions, including if they have limited your account to X comments pr Y hours...
- colanderman 9y agoNo; in the case of replying to a reply, you simply are not shown the reply link.
- dkarl 9y agoYou cannot downvote a comment after 24 hours have passed. This is a nice feature. One reason I stopped using certain subreddits was that people would look up your comment history and downvote all your comments that weren't archived. I think those downvotes would eventually disappear, but it annoyed me enough that I stopped reading the subreddits where it happened.
- jandrese 9y agoEh, it's all fake internet points anyway. I occasionally get hit by an angry downvoter, but as long as your normal content is quality their effect is a drop in the bucket.
- misnome 9y agoQuestion on “hidden” features: Sometimes sub-level comments (not even particularly deep) don’t have a ‘reply’ button - is this turned off for particularly controversial (in voting) comments? > Hacker News encourages a single discussion on a given story. All others are marked as a [dupe] and will be killed[...] The addition to this is that after a while this isn’t enforced - which is why you’ll see the same articles coming up reasonably regularly.
- DougWebb 9y agoI've noticed the missing reply button; my impression is that it won't appear right away after a post is submitted, which is probably intended to reduce flamewars.
- Karunamon 9y agoIt's still possible to reply directly, but you have to click the permalink above the specific comment (the one with the time in it - "X minutes ago") before the reply button/box are visible.
- grawprog 9y ago>Both are very responsive when contacted at hn@ycombinator.com, and is the best option for resolving any issues on Hacker News. Bahahahahhahahahahhahahahaha that's the funniest thing I think I've read all day....whooooooo that was a good laugh.
- dang 9y agoWe reply to nearly every email, but not all. For example, if an email is hostile and doesn't ask a specific question, answering usually just leads to more hostility. I learned that the hard way. If you didn't get an answer, it might be that your email looked like that kind. Which doesn't mean it was, of course—we have to guess, and don't always guess right.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- grawprog 9y agoHaha wow im surprised this actually got a response...I didn't even think this would show up. Nice of you to make this one comment visible to prove whatever point you'd like to make. That's even funnier now. Bahahaha. You must just sit and personally curate the comments on every story. Haha wow. Still no answer to the email though. :)
- dredmorbius 9y agoI use the address probably a few times a month on average, and think I've always received a response. Some delayed, most within a day. Even when disaagreeing strongly with HN's behaviour or policies.
- gkya 9y agoAlso, IDK if this is mentioned anywhere, but HN comments have a maximum character limit. Once I made a veeery long comment [1], had to split them up in three pieces (which when I downloaded them using the API, take up 7.5kb, 6.5kb and 5.9kb respectively. I guess 7.5kb is a good approximation, but I did not try to make an accurate measurement. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15373653 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15373653 This was about the decline of schools in my country, so I guess I'm going to be excused for this much of logorrhea :)
- b0rsuk 9y agoI would love to see something like this: (Steve Jobs Died) (14 articles, newest on 11th of fyftember) Articles on the same event within short timespan would be compressed into a single line you can expand by clicking. One implementation could be some kind of special purpose tagging functionality, similar to flagging, but with a keyword argument. Maybe the tag should even have a limited lifespan - until you can no longer assign it. Submissions under the same tag would be compressed into an expandable list, similar to threaded comments. Please make the chat flood stop!
- joshschreuder 9y agoThe mods normally merge in comments from duplicates if the duplicates pick up a substantial amount of comments and the context is similar enough.
- b0rsuk 9y agoIf they're true duplicates offering no new perspective, I guess. But if the articles each show the event from a different perspective, they don't technically fall under the HN "dupe" rule. But it is still a boring subject to some HN readers, and it can fill most of the HN front page.
- z1mm32m4n 9y agoThis doesn't directly solve your problem, but if you click through to the comments section of an article and click the "web" link (between "past" and "favorite"), it'll search Google with the text of the post submission. So if you're looking for multiple viewpoints, this is a ~frictionless way to start reading multiple perspectives.
- b0rsuk 9y agoMy problem - hinted by the term "chat flood" - is that some of the events don't interest me at all. I want to hide redundant submissions! It's times like those when I'm reminded how US-centric HN is. I understand Steve Jobs is an American hero, but many people outside US only want to know that he died. Some major security vulnerabilities fall into this category too. Usually some people with deeper understanding need to take care of it and push the changes upstream. I only need to know to watch out for X or Y hardware or service Z. "Vote on net neutrality" type political submissions - you need to be an US citizen to vote.
- ender89 9y agoWell now I want more karma so I can customize the top bar.
- amyjess 9y agoI'll add that I've also seen the [flagged] tag appear on submissions that aren't dead. I assume it means that it's been flagged heavily enough to downrank it but not to kill it.
- 0x7f800000 9y agoIt would be nice if 5x duplicates didn't show up in the RSS feed.
- ixtli 9y agoThis is a great resources, but i'm forced to laugh at this bit: > However, as of recently, the line between technology and politics has become extremely blurred. > as of recently We really, really need to require CS majors to take ethics classes. Everything you do as an engineer has an impact on the world around you. Everything. This is actually really good, because most of us are good people! But you can only escape "politics" by escaping people and you simply will never do that.
- dang 9y agoRight on both counts, that it can't be separated and that it isn't recent. The OP needs to amend "The Guidelines state that political discussion is off-topic". The actual guidelines say most and probably, precisely to indicate not all. Political articles that are on topic are those that contain material of intellectual interest, aren't just garden-variety politics or ideology, and contain substantive new information. Those are comparatively rare, but better able to support substantive discussion. Sometimes they get more upvotes than flags, or we may turn off the flags. There are plenty of examples of this—so many that we hear the complaint "HN has been taken over by politics" at least as often as its inverse. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4922426 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4922426
- ixtli 9y agoI think the greatest possible contribution to all of science that hacker news (the piece of software + the community) could provide would be to extend its general self-reinforcing conversational tone to include issues of conscience and the ethical, moral, and political implications of the subjects discussed here. We simply can't treat the two groups as separate.
- dang 9y agoThat sounds great, but isn't doable. It only seems doable, because of the dynamic described here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16438476 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16438476. What would actually happen is that it would make the community nastier and dumber until it died. Whom the gods would destroy, &c. The fundamental tradeoff: the better HN gets, the more people want to use it for things that worsen it. This puts a cap on how good HN can ever get. All we can do is find ways to wriggle out of that tradeoff here and there.
- rweba 9y agoMore and more websites are getting rid of user comments on their websites. Just in the last couple of months the National Review and The Atlantic have got rid of comments. In simple terms they couldn't keep up with comment moderation and were not able or willing to invest in enough moderators. So I have to give credit to HN to having one of the most civil comment sections on the internet. What I like about HN is that the comments VERY RARELY descend into the inevitable political sniping that seems to happen almost everywhere else on the internet, even when discussing controversial topics like Trump, and even the percentage of snarky and dismissive comments is kept pretty low. So, keep it up, dang and sctb!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hw 9y agoThe beauty of karma, and community moderation.
- chrisper 9y agoTo counter your argument: take a look at reddit. Community moderation has also the risk of creating an echo chamber.
- funkymike 9y agoI wonder if a big part of the difference is that HN has only one stream of postings. If there were a HN-politics, HN-tech, etc. each may end up as an echo chamber like reddit.
- philipkglass 9y agoI participate on HN but only lurk on reddit due to so many upvoted garbage-comments on the latter. I don't much care if reddit posts/comments in futurology are always "woo! yay technology! future!!" and everyone in babyelephantgifs is just celebrating baby elephants all the time, with no dissent. I do care about endlessly repeated/upvoted noise in comments. Puns instead of topically relevant comments, political sniping completely unrelated to the story, catchphrases from the poster's favorite movies/TV series/games, and basically everything from reddit site:knowyourmeme.com. Yes, I know, smaller subs and content that never makes it to the front page don't suffer in the same way. I do enjoy reading the rust, programming, and AskHistorians subreddits.
- nodesocket 9y ago> One popular "trick" for obfuscating voting manipulation on Hacker News is to link to the Hacker News's /newest page of new submissions (instead of a direct link which would otherwise make voting manipulation obvious), and asking friends to upvote the submission from that page. This trick doesn't actually work. How does this not work? I am failing to see how legit people visiting new can be distinguished between people who are told to go to new and search for {{$title}} and upvote.
- mountaineer 9y agoI noticed that too. The voting ring detector may only use the landing page component as a part of the overall algorithm? Other factors likely include the time since posting and common shared upvotes?
- libria 9y agoSlight nitpick: I believe downvoting is available >= 501 karma, i.e., above 500.
- esnard 9y agoTo anyone interested in reading Hacker News source code, it is available here: https://ycombinator.com/arc/arc3.tar https://ycombinator.com/arc/arc3.tar
- mintplant 9y agoIt should be noted that that's an old, old snapshot of the code. The currently-live HN codebase is closed source.
- another-dave 9y agoThink it would be interesting to include something on what the community expect from "Ask HN" and "Show HN" posts — thought I'd double-check the guidelines/FAQ before posting one before & realised they're not mentioned there at all. Also, would be good to call out what flavour of formatting is supported by comments.
- giarc 9y ago>All comments start with a score of 1 point (but in order to prevent bandwagoning, the comment score is not visible to users other than the author). How great would this be for news stories on Facebook?
- keithnz 9y agoNot sure if this fits with the purpose of your page, but there are "easter eggs", like in the "Ask HN: What has HN given you?" thread( which is an awesome read https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16409768 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16409768 ) I noticed a MailGun cofounder mentioning the "HN Cofounder wanted spreadsheet" at https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Sygd1fhGYRS-ZvRP0IVV6rf3OUyED9_b6Da4tVWdS08/edit?toomany=true#gid=9 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Sygd1fhGYRS-ZvRP0IVV... which is how he ended up involved with MailGun EDIT: this probablly isn't suitable for this page. I've started a page to track these things for myself at https://github.com/keithn/HackerNewsCommunity/ https://github.com/keithn/HackerNewsCommunity/ If anyone has any other gems that are worth tracking I'd love to know about them.
- foobaw 9y agosorry if I'm being ignorant but how is that an easter egg?
- keithnz 9y agoIt's not in the sense it's not built into HNs website, but it's an easter egg of the community in that you wouldn't know about it and nothing really documents things like this specifically related to the HN community. It's like your page you are making, it's another easter egg of the community. Just disappears from view except for those who track it.
- genieyclo 9y agoSomething I noticed this week for the first time is the date on profiles changed from x days ago to the specific date a user's account was created. It's also now a link to the frontpage on that day.
- dang 9y agoWe just did that. It seems like a neat way to tell people about https://news.ycombinator.com/front https://news.ycombinator.com/front, plus it's amusing to look at how HN was on someone's 'birthday'. We also made older timestamps say "May 4, 2009" instead of "3124 days ago".
- adrian_mrd 9y agoGreat list minimaxir, thanks for that effort. I’d love to know what the user activity is (over time zones) over a 24 hour period? Obviously, YC is biased towards USA West Coast time (due to their location), so would be interesting to know how much user submissions vary by UTC time? Also, I assumed that usernames in green type meant that those users had engaged/replied to one of your posts/submissions. But ‘green’ users - as in new - makes a lot of sense (once you know the ‘rule’).
- tedmiston 9y agoI've wondered about the distribution across timezones for posts, comments, and votes as well. The HN data set on BigQuery might be helpful here. https://cloud.google.com/bigquery/public-data/hacker-news https://cloud.google.com/bigquery/public-data/hacker-news https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10440502 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10440502
- chopin 9y agoOne thing which is not clear to me: I just recently had a submission which had more than twice of upvotes than had been added to my Karma. As far as I understand voting rings may be responsible for that. I am however much too lazy for engaging that way (I also have no social media accounts), I spent my time rather on HN ;-). Does someone has an explanation for this? Do others engage in those rings to get favorable submissions onto the fron page?
- ggm 9y agoPlease don't over feature-ize it. This is about as good as it gets, for a simple text-predominant mechanism. I could wish for some things, but I could also expect pushback for their consequences. So ... well done I guess. You gots it about right.
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago>Implicit Downranking of Politics The free pass given to certain genres of political content show which demographic lines HN is mostly homogeneous on.
- asterius 9y ago@minimaxir for your list: - Not possible to downvote some posters, as the authors have extreme karma (e.g. >10,000, though I don't know the exact number), even if you have >>500 karma. It is notable that HN does not support blocking particular users, or indeed annotating that you like them. Though plenty of fans will upvote well known authors, it is not possible for you to keep a list of people who you think have written well in the past. I'd love it if I could, e.g., mark favourite author names in green. HN is also notable from my perspective for having some people with good technical sense and clear writing, but very extreme views on other matters, to the extent that they would be pariahs in RL situations.
- tedmiston 9y agoI've wanted a feature to "follow" certain users as well. Presumably it could be built as a separate app or into a browser extension.
- bookofjoe 9y agoThis is a FANTASTIC resource! Bookmarked! Thank you!
- guru4consulting 9y agoTo me, the quality of discussions across various forums is: HackerNews > Quora > Medium(comments) > Reddit > Facebook > Twitter > everything else And these days, I use only the first 3 :)