11 ms·
Musk explains why SpaceX prefers clusters of small engines
- craig1f 9y agoTL;DR; - You get more fault-tolerance with a large number of smaller engines
- nine_k 9y agoInterestingly, the Soviet Н1 Moon-bound rocket [1] used a similar setup, and it was plagued be reliability problems: making many smaller parts work reliably at the same time is harder for obvious reasons. Either reliability of engines went seriously up, or software control (impossible in early 1960s) made it possible to operate a bunch of less-than-ideal engines successfully. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N1_(rocket) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N1_(rocket)
- tibyat 9y agoso...you didnt bother to even glance at the article but you still invested the time to write this post... people are confusing.
- russdill 9y agoA more accurate description would be that it's really hard if you never test things and rush them into a launch because of political pressure
- orbital-decay 9y agoActually, N1 failures had little to do with the complexity itself, and engines were reliable enough for the time. Due to the lack of funding (the soviet lunar program was given the priority well into the moon "race") they were using the old methodology of testing it in the actual flight, not doing any static fires and only doing a bare minimum of ground testing. Saturn V, on the other hand, heavily relied on the ground testing before the launch. That's why Saturn V mostly worked and N1 failed. Energia worked perfectly much later, because it was developed with the proper amount of ground testing.
- shmerl 9y ago> engines were reliable enough for the time. Engines alone could be, but the their combination wasn't reliable because of interactions between them and need for synchronization. As Musk points out, it was an avionics problem.
- Florin_Andrei 9y agoThe main reason why they failed is - they pushed testing into production, just like MySpace, because their funding and leadership disintegrated at the beginning of the program. See my other reply in this thread.
- shmerl 9y agoSure, their management was erratic. But the bottom line, their combination wasn't technically reliable (why, is already what you are saying).
- Florin_Andrei 9y agoThis meme of the "inferior Soviet technology" needs to die in a fire. It's soothing for the fragile Western conservative ego, but it's just not true - not, at least, with regards to space. The failure of the N1 program was a leadership issue, period. Just like America trailing the Russians at first was a leadership and lack of focus issue. One team kept winning, then they lost their captains and their funding. Meanwhile, the other team got great leaders and awesome sponsors and started busting their collective ass really hard around the same time - and the wheel of fortune suddenly turned. Funny how that works, isn't it? What's strange is that the true events sound a heck of a lot more "american" (work hard and reap the laurels, or slack off and be a loser) and yet you keep hearing the same bullshit all the time as to how "the Russian stuff was just inferior". It's not true. And it's not a good story to tell your kids.
- shmerl 9y ago> This meme of the "inferior Soviet technology" needs to die in a fire. Technology turns out to be inferior, when quality control is superseded by political agenda. It should be quite obvious. See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nedelin_catastrophe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nedelin_catastrophe > The failure of the N1 program was a leadership issue, period. Surely leadership failure is a key factor, but there was also an economical one. Space race was very expensive.
- IshKebab 9y agoIt's almost like you read the article.
- Maybestring 9y agoThe N1 had insufficient component level testing. They decided to go straight to full up tests due to the cost of the test stand needed. The big complication with the N1 was that they tried to steer it with variable thrust, rather than the usual approach of thrust vectoring.
- 0xfeba 9y agoRAIE - Redundant Array of Inexpensive Engines
- Klathmon 9y agoIt makes sense from a reliability perspective to have more smaller semi-redundant parts, especially since it sounds like they have the whole control system down, "scaling up" from managing and controlling 3 engines probably isn't all that different from managing 9, and eventually 31. (obviously this is still rocket science, and nothing is "easy") I'm curious if there are other benefits. I'd imagine that manufacturing the smaller engines gets easier and faster and more reliable as they make more of them. Also, I wonder if this plays into their reusability? If there is a defect found in one of the 9 F9 engines, theoretically you could replace just that one and refly the rest. I have no idea if this is even possible, but it seems like it could be.
- hinkley 9y agoBut there has been talk in the past, including from Musk if memory serves, about the limits of reliablility. We aren’t talking about hard drives here. You throw a couple more in and if one fails you just turn it off. Hard drives don’t explode and destroy the hard drive next to them or cause the enclosure to fail. More rockets is more things trying to explode in only the same direction. The other responder talked about the operational excellence that can’t be achieved if the numbers get too small. That seems more likely.
- hinkley 9y agoJust an addendum, while Musk in fact compares the rockets to computers, I have found that what the management takes away from conversations with engineers is often not the most important part. But typically everyone on the team has opinions about success or failure of the project and we all discount something important. Managers doubly so. They rarely credit the spotters who keep them from falling when their process has huge holes in it.
- SpuriousSignals 9y agoIt all depends on how an engine fails. A failure to provide thrust is survivable with more engines. But a vulnerability that causes a fuel line to go boom, taking out the whole rocket, is made more likely by having more engines.
- jballanc 9y agoIIRC, the engines in the Falcon 9 are pretty well separated from each other, such that even a catastrophic failure of one engine is survivable by the rest. Indeed, that seems to be what happened the one time an engine did fail (albeit on a very early version of the Falcon 9 with the "square" engine layout): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dvTIh96otDw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dvTIh96otDw
- Klathmon 9y agoI believe that was actually the reason why they moved to a "round" configuration. They realized that the "corner" engines were doing more work, and if one of them failed it caused larger issues than they were expecting. However in the "round" layout, all of the engines are doing the same amount of work and have a similar amount of control over the rocket, so one failing can be more easily compensated for by the surrounding engines.
- vlasev 9y agoI believe it was not due to this but due to mass savings. The square grid layout uses more material and in a less symmetric way too.
- sebazzz 9y agoIt is not an explosion. From the first comment: Engine didn't explode, it detected an anomaly and shut itself down. Here's spacex's statement concerning the event- "Approximately one minute and 19 seconds into last night's launch, the Falcon 9 rocket detected an anomaly on one first stage engine. Initial data suggests that one of the rocket's nine Merlin engines, Engine 1, lost pressure suddenly and an engine shutdown command was issued. We know the engine did not explode, because we continued to receive data from it. Panels designed to relieve pressure within the engine bay were ejected to protect the stage and other engines."
- pensivemood 9y agoCan we have less spacex here please? Thank you.
- always_good 9y agoBe a big boy and click the downvote/hide buttons instead of hoping the universe adapts to you.
- bischofs 9y agoYou work for ULA?
- TeMPOraL 9y agoNo, we need more SpaceX, since this is one of the most interesting and actually important things happening right now on this planet.
- ksk 9y ago>For computers, Musk said, using large numbers of small computers ends up being a more efficient, smarter, and faster approach than using a few larger, more powerful computers. I always figured, in theory, a super-super-powerful single threaded single processor would out compete the multi-threaded multi processor design on efficiency, because of the hardware and software inefficiencies in inter processor hardware connections and communication. In practice, I suppose there is always a physical limit on the total capacity of low latency addressable ram and storage you can manage to shove into an architecture.
- bluedino 9y agoDepends on the task - it turns out rocket thrust is quite parallelizeable
- perlgeek 9y ago> I suppose there is always a physical limit on the total capacity of low latency addressable ram and storage you can manage to shove into an architecture. Some people even argue that, due to these physical limits, storage access time tends to scale O(sqrt(N)) with the size N of the storage, including for RAM. http://www.ilikebigbits.com/blog/2014/4/21/the-myth-of-ram-part-i http://www.ilikebigbits.com/blog/2014/4/21/the-myth-of-ram-p...
- simonh 9y agoOne thing not mentioned is throttle range. Larger engines can’t throttle down as low as smaller ones. That’s irrelevant for launches, but matters crucially for landing. I know the F9 engines can’t throttle down to a hover, even on a single engine with the fuel tanks mostly empty, but I’m sure they did all their landings up until the last few on a single engine that throttled down to its lowest setting for a reason. Controllability matters and while max power suicide burns are theoretically ideal in practice landing at full thrust on all engines would be highly unlikely to ever be workable. If F9 had say 3 larger engines, I doubt landing would be possible at all. Also you need to be able to build a configuration with an engine in the middle.
- rocqua 9y agoThe recent falcon heavy launch (and some falcon 9 launches before it) actually had the boosters land using 3 engines. So going by ratio, it should still be able to land if it had 3 larger engines. This 3 engine landing failed for the centre core, which is why it was lost. Specifically, there wasn't enough 'lighter fluid' to relight all 3 engines required, only one engine was lit. Thus the booster tried a 3-engine landing on a single engine, and hit the water at 300mph IIRC.
- simonh 9y agoSure, which is why I said up until the last few, but if you look at the footage of the two boosters landing closely they didn’t simply do a 3 engine landing burn. They powered up the centre engine, then lit two engines either side of it, but then turned those off a few seconds before landing and still actually landed on a single engine for the last ten seconds or so. It’s hard to be sure exactly because the telephoto footage of the booster catches the start of the burns but misses the side engines shutting down. But when it pans back on to the engines, it’s clear only one of them is still lit (with one other flaring off some unspent fuel). That’s a very precise and tuneable thrust curve you wouldn’t be able to do with one bigger engine.
- rocqua 9y agoAh I see. Interesting about the final part of the landing occurring with a single engine even with a 3 engine landing. Makes me wonder why they don't do something like 9 engines for the breaking burn and then switch to a single engine for the landing part. It might just be that is their final plan but 3 is easier to test than 9.
- mhandley 9y agoThere are two other reasons which SpaceX has mentioned before: - When you're landing a rocket, you need to be able to throttle down quite low. Even a single Merlin 1-D engine, throttled down, is too much thrust to be able to hover with a nearly empty booster. It's really hard to get stable combustion at very low throttle settings. Having only one engine out of nine running for landing makes this much more manageable. - There are economies of scale and reliability when you're building large numbers of something. Ariane 5 only launched 6 times in 2017. It uses one first stage engine, so they're only building one engine every 2 months. Falcon 9 launched 18 times in 2017, with 9 first stage engines per launch, that's roughly an engine every 2 days. More continuous construction, better economies of scale, more repeatable.
- vannevar 9y agoThere are economies of scale and reliability when you're building large numbers of something. Yes. One of the biggest predictors of reliability in aerospace systems in general is time in operation---the longer you've actually run something, the closer it approaches the upper limit of reliability for that component. Running 27 small copies gives you 27x the time in operation vs a single big-ass engine. The downside is complexity, and in particular unknown failure interactions which could bring down the entire system in a cascade. As long as many of the components are identical, though, an improvement in reliability of that component should translate directly into lower probability of failure interactions since there are fewer failures, period.
- bunderbunder 9y agoHow does one quantify the risk of cascading failure? My initial instinct, informed by computing, is to say that it's easier to avoid cascading failures in the system that is composed of more, smaller parts. All other things being equal, in a rocket with 5 engines, if one of them fails, then each of the remaining ones needs to pick up 1/4 of the slack to compensate. In a rocket with 9 engines, not only would each of the remaining engines need to pick up only 1/8 of the slack, but the total size of the gap would be a little over half as much, too. (This is obvs ignoring the possibility that the failure in question is catastrophic.)
- grondilu 9y agoWould it then make sense to plan for even more smaller engines? Like while BFR is meant to have 31 Raptor engines, could it have 60 Merlin engines instead or something?
- Maybestring 9y agoThey certainly could use more smaller engines for the BFR, but just because one dimension of the design benefits from smaller engines doesn't mean the optimal design uses a nano-scale rocket array.
- ygra 9y agoOne goal of BFR is Mars, from which you can only get back if you can produce fuel on the ground. Which kinda rules out RP-1 as propellant. Hence the need for a methane engine. Unrelated to the number of engines here, obviously; just another point to consider. And if they end up designing a new engine they could just as well apply what they have learned in the meantime. Merlin is a very conservative design, favouring simplicity and cost over thrust. If you plan for re-using your rocket a thousand times, cost of an engine isn't that much of an issue anymore and you can prioritise other aspects.
- philipwhiuk 9y ago> from which you can only get back if you can produce fuel on the ground Is this actually realistic?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- theothermkn 9y agoAn important source of loss in smaller engines is viscosity. Proportionally, more of the working fluid is in contact with the internal surfaces, more of it is inside the boundary layer, which is the only place where viscosity matters. For a large engine, your boundary layer goes up as the area (square), and the contained goes up as the volume (cube). (The growth of the boundary layer goes up as something like the square root.) It's one of the few places in rocket science where the square-cube law helps provide a useful result, despite the insistence of many a misguided layperson. Even here, it may be something like a 2.5-cube law.
- jlebrech 9y agoand soon it'll be clusters of boosters, there's space to fit another 4 in a hexagonal pattern. you could lift a mini hexagonal mars base fully assembled that way, land it and land the next one quite close.
- phinnaeus 9y agoImagine seeing 6 boosters land simultaneously. Just nuts.
- jlebrech 9y ago7 including the central one.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- marktangotango 9y agoIn the post Falcon Heavy press conference, he specifically mentioned scaling up to a Super Heavy with two additional side boosters, four in all. Sounded like they had designed for that, from the way he just threw it out there. Seems odd to me, since FH is an interim vehicle until BFR comes on line in 5-10 years.
- gizmo385 9y ago> Seems odd to me, since FH is an interim vehicle until BFR comes on line in 5-10 years. I thought they were targeting launches much sooner than 5-10 years out for the BFR?
- Maybestring 9y agoThey are, that doesn't mean you should expect them to hit that target. Musk doesn't seem to set timelines with the expectation that they will be attained. They are always best case, but development never is.
- avmich 9y ago> The Russian Soyuz rocket has five engines, each of which has six thrust chambers. RD-107 on the four side blocks has 6 chambers, RD-108 on the central block has 8 chambers.
- aurizon 9y agoA large portion of the efficiency of small engines comes from the reduction of "hoop stress". This is the linear tension in the wall of a pressure vessel(rocket engine) which varies as the square of the diameter. Twice the diameter = 4 times the pressure (hoop stress) the walls must take. A rocket is a special case of a balloon - with an expansion nozzle attached to couple the impedance of the combustion chamber to the outside environment. This means that 9 smaller rocket engines will weigh less than 1 large rocket engine of the same thrust. On top of this is the small engine basic throttling capability with the overlay of cutting out engines to add greater capability.
- theothermkn 9y ago> This is the linear tension in the wall of a pressure vessel(rocket engine) which varies as the square of the diameter. Twice the diameter = 4 times the pressure (hoop stress) the walls must take. This is incorrect. Cutting the cylinder in half lengthwise and taking a unit length, we see that the cross section of the walls of the chamber (unit length x 2 x wall thickness) resists the pressure force from the contained fluid (2 x radius x unit length x pressure). Since the pressure and unit length are constant under scaling, this resulting force grows linearly with the radius. Thus, wall thickness has to grow proportionally to the radius, and there are no mass penalties from the chamber wall from either a smaller or larger engine. A similar result holds for spheres. Indeed, the particular result is independent of the geometry of the pressure vessel. The larger immediate result is that pressure vessels scale just fine with size, up or down, and there's no benefit at either end of the length scale, in relation to contained volume. What you do get for a smaller engine is more manageable combustion instabilities. Look at the 5-fold symmetry (odd, rather than even) of the injector baffles in the SSMEs. This is to stop a tangential oscillation mode, an important failure mode of larger engines. What you lose for smaller engines is that you have more of the fluid "close" to the walls. The boundary layers don't grow linearly, so you get more heat transfer at the boundary in proportion to the contained fluid. (Radiant transfer in the engines complicates the picture, but convective transfer is definitely proportionately worse for smaller engines.)
- Robotbeat 9y ago
- Robotbeat 9y agoWe can mark this inaugural Falcon Heavy launch as the point when people stopped laughing at BFR. The latest version of BFR is only about twice as much thrust as the final FH variant (which will launch in a few months with slight thrust upgrades) and around the same number of engines. Recovery, even with such a complicated bunch of stages, seems to work pretty well, validating SpaceX's knowledge of reentry and reuse. Launching crew within about a year from now is when people will stop laughing about SpaceX sending people to Mars. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0qo78R_yYFA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0qo78R_yYFA
- DanCarvajal 9y agoHey it worked for the N1.....wait.....
- allthenews 9y agoThere's something I don't understand about space travel. We made it to the moon in 1969, on the first computer to use ICs[1]. Since then we've seen monumental advances in computer science, material science, manufacturing, rocketry, and just about any other component of space flight. Why 50 years later is it still such a relatively difficult task to launch a rocket into space? Why is it still so expensive and failure prone, when we were able to launch so many vessels with substantially less capable technology? It seems like space travel simply has not scaled with the rest of our technology, but I imagine I'm missing something. Perhaps the ratio of human life to risk tolerance has increased, such that we effectively spend more time and resources designing away failures and refuse to launch with the same level of risk that was acceptable decades ago? 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_Guidance_Computer#Design https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_Guidance_Computer#Desig...
- robbiep 9y agoLiterally what you are witnessing now is the scaling of that. Rockets are expensive - there hasn’t been the opportunity for rapid iteration such as during the rise of automobiles or planes, so there have been less opportunities for the sorts of experiments such as what SpaceX, blue origin, armadillo before it, and the electron are doing.
- adventured 9y agoApollo cost ~$120-$150 billion in today's dollar. Falcon Heavy cost $500m-$1b to get right. Given some time, Musk could probably make it so a trip to the Moon costs $300 million, maybe less. We've (they've) accomplished an extraordinary cost improvement. It's still such a monumental task, because the laws of physics have not changed. Building a huge rocket, putting people in it, and firing it at the Moon, is not the hard part per se (not killing them in the process, and bringing them back safely, is). We could have done that all over again at any time if we desired to spend the money. The next level of difficulty, is turning it into a truly routine task, and building something on the Moon. That's a dramatic leap up from only exploring the surface of the Moon. We've avoided doing that, not because we can't, but because it's a cost benefit equation, and the benefit has not been considered worth doing at the cost, even as the cost gradually declined. Now that cost benefit equation has improved dramatically enough to favor it being worth doing. Simply put, as a society we're not willing to spend $500 billion or $1 trillion to build a Moon base. But we might be willing to spend $50 or $100 billion over time to do it. We're not willing to spend $10 or $20 billion for a trip to the Moon, but we are probably willing to spend $300 million or even a billion.
- RachelF 9y agoPerhaps another reason is that they already have these small engines? Why not use what you have already built and debugged rather than build a bigger, expensive engine, for only marginal gains.
- XR0CSWV3h3kZWg 9y ago> using large numbers of small computers ends up being a more efficient, smarter, and faster approach than using a few larger, more powerful computers Huh? Using large numbers of small computers is definitely smarter and more cost effective. I'm surprised by the claim that it's more efficient and faster. The moment what you are doing needs to hit the network you eat some real costs in terms of efficiency and latency.