14 ms·
The U.S. Gets Less Subway for Its Money Than Its Peers
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoTL;DR unions, shady contractors and expensive project requirements in no particular order. Edit: Was this not an accurate summary of the key issues mentioned?
- homulilly 9y agoSpecifically bad union rules. European countries also rely on union labor and don't have this problem. Another factor mentioned in the article is poor management which seems to be a common theme in America.
- ng12 9y agoWhat do Europeans do differently? In the US the non-corrupt unions fade to obscurity.
- rebuilder 9y agoI wonder if it's that European unions have long had legitimate political clout, while it sounds like in the USA, unions have been under more suppression, and have developed tactics to match? This is entirely based on my thoroughly unresearched preconception of the matter, BTW.
- maxxxxx 9y agoWhen I look at Germany it looks to me that both sides are more reasonable and try to find compromise. In the US either employers want to squeeze all they can out of the work force and get rid of unions or the unions get greedy (see police unions who happily bankrupt municipalities for their pensions). Maybe it's a reflection of the "winner takes it all" political system.
- rebuilder 9y agoI'm reading these articles and wondering: why do these unions have rules for e.g. the number of workers that must be posted to a specific task? Safety? It seems like a tremendously inflexible way to go about it. I'm genuinely curious btw. I wouldn't be surprised to hear it's a counterreaction to historically irresponsible employers, for example, but I do wonder about the rationale behind U.S. union rules as reported.
- bhhaskin 9y agoIt is because they are so corrupt. It has nothing to do with safety 99% of the time, but ensuring they need more workers on the job site. The mob got heavily involved with unions in the USA fairly early on, and influenced their tactics to what we have today. Europe didn't have that same issue.
- wahern 9y agoI can't find it ATM, but recently there was a good article that linked this phenomenon to the disappearance of unions. As unions disappear in the private sector they become increasingly dependent on the public sector to employ their laborers. Because union members vote and because unions so visiblly represent the working-class, in many cities the best way to be pro labor is to support union labor. In areas were unions are strong but increasingly relegated to public sector work, that translates to pressure to bloat public sector projects with union labor. One way to think of it is as a form of work program. On a related note, some conservative commentators have pointed out recently that if you combine U.S. healthcare spending with U.S. welfare spending, it roughly equates to what European countries spend on healthcare + welfare. IOW, we don't overspend on healthcare so much as we trade-off social welfare spending for healthcare spending. Similarly, I wouldn't be surprised if you combine the overspending on public works projects with similar jobs programs, it would likewise roughly equate to what European countries spend on public works + jobs. IOW, public works projects are expensive because we refuse to adequately fund training, long-term unemployment benefits, etc. I think this is all comes down to Americans' inability to embrace the necessity and role of social welfare programs. But because we can't admit of the need doesn't mean our society doesn't ultimately respond to the need; our response is just obscure and indirect in a way that preserves the fantasy of the free-market. For example, we can blame these excessive public works projects on "corruption" and "bloat" rather than admitting that they're pressure-relief valves for legitimate political, economic, and social demands. Something similar could be said regarding the Trump phenomenon.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thebradbain 9y agoI don’t know enough about the topic to discuss the last two, but unions don’t intrinsically slow down metro development: France, for example, has one of the largest transport/trade unions (CFTD and CFT) and much stronger union laws than the US. And yet Paris has the second busiest and comprehensive metro in Europe, second only to Moscow. Not to mention how clean it is compared to anything in the US, a beautiful feat of design, architecture and engineering on its own, even! [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Democratic_Confederation_of_Labour https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Democratic_Confederat... [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_Métro https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_Métro
- bsder 9y agoUm, the article in no way supports the first two as the primary problem. And, I would also like to point out that the cost per mile drops dramatically as the NUMBER OF MILES goes up. Note that most of the foreign projects mentioned are 3+ miles. And note that even the US projects which are longer magically cost less. So, perhaps the issues are: 1) a mayfly has an attention span longer than the average US voter and so getting projects approved and committed to for long durations borders on impossible 2) most contractors understand that their funding could be pulled at any time due to the vicissitudes of said mayflys, so they book as much revenue as possible and do as little work as they can until the pressure becomes overwhelming and the voting public is actually COMMITTED to funding and completing the project
- kposehn 9y agoThis is a dupe of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16248036 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16248036
- heurist 9y agoThe US seems to get less of everything for its money than its peers. Geographic spread is a major macro factor, but you'd still think that a supposedly efficient capitalistic market would at least handle local services better.
- heavenlyblue 9y agoBut not petrol.
- aeorgnoieang 9y ago> a supposedly efficient capitalistic market The 'new commanding heights'[1] of the modern U.S. economy are all the least capitalistic markets: education, healthcare, and housing. Nor would I expect "local services" to be much more 'capitalistic' if you're referring to services provided by municipal governments. [1]: [The New Commanding Heights | National Affairs](http://www.nationalaffairs.com/publications/detail/the-new-commanding-heights http://www.nationalaffairs.com/publications/detail/the-new-c...)
- DrScump 9y ago'new commanding heights'[1] That source is from 2011, in the depths of the recession.
- bkohlmann 9y agoFor market based goods, the US does deliver pretty phenomenal, innovative and minimally priced outputs. Groceries, energy, technology, etc. "Local services" are almost always driven by non-market based considerations. Politics, not economics, determines contract awards for public works. It's as far from the market as you can get. And our society receives commensurate "value."
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoNote, too, that the New York City Subway was almost entirely privately funded and built.
- Hasz 9y agoNYT has a great writeup on the East Side Access tunnel. In short, the costs work out to 3.5bn/mile (!), there's ~200 "ghost" workers, and the usual spot of corruption and favoritism. It's a mess, and the MTA is deferring regular maintenance to pay for it. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/28/nyregion/new-york-subway-construction-costs.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/28/nyregion/new-york-subway-...
- bsder 9y agoAgenda much? Is anybody in this thread doing basic math? 200 ghost workers at $100K per year (probably a bit high, thanks) is $20 million per year. Um, so much for that causing the cost overrun. Project management is generally the failure. And, generally, it starts with the asinine "low bid" rules. Everyone successful at dealing with the government knows that you bid as low as possible to get the contract and then you charge them a fortune on the back end. Edit: Okay, even if I BELIEVE the $1,000 per day (and I don't) that's $300K per year and is still only $60 million. Edit2: I have read and searched the original article several times and cannot find that $1,000 number anywhere. Edit3: Oh, it's in an article linked in the comment. And the linked article says that they laid off those contractors once they found them. Project management and oversight failure--again.
- nostromo 9y ago$100k isn’t a high estimate at all. The article says they were costing $1k a day. > All we knew is they were each being paid about $1,000 every day.
- trophycase 9y agoOk that's great and all but don't try to derail the major point which is that this pay is an extremely small fraction of the cost.
- InitialLastName 9y agoYou're doing that math wrong. Take $73mil a year. Make it $100mil a year, to cover other employment expenses (employees cost more than their salaries). The extension took 10 years, so call that $1billion. That sounds like about 1/7 of the cost of the 2 miles of track, not an "extremely small fraction"
- Symmetry 9y agoA pretty good article I read recently getting into the breakdown of what exactly we're paying more for in the US versus other places. https://pedestrianobservations.com/2018/01/27/construction-costs-metro-stations/ https://pedestrianobservations.com/2018/01/27/construction-c...
- yonran 9y agoNote that both the citylab article and pedestrianobservations are from the same author, Alon Levy. I also liked his article (https://www.the-american-interest.com/2017/02/10/why-we-cant-have-nice-things-2/ https://www.the-american-interest.com/2017/02/10/why-we-cant...) summarizing best practices from Madrid (offline: https://tunnelbuilder.com/metrosur/edition2pdf/page2.pdf https://tunnelbuilder.com/metrosur/edition2pdf/page2.pdf archived: https://web.archive.org/web/20171216155555/https://tunnelbuilder.com/metrosur/edition2pdf/page2.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20171216155555/https://tunnelbui...).
- scythe 9y agoIt seems like European infrastructure construction is more centralized than its American counterpart. In the Bay Area, there are two competing transit providers, each funded by the same taxpayers. Every city seems to run its own show, and CAHSR infamously rejected offers from European companies to do construction. It's just my view from 10000 feet, but the average city council has few civil engineers on board, so maybe a more top-down system could be better. The Boring Company might be a meme but at least there's not a different one in every city.
- athenot 9y agoIn Paris, you have the national train company (SNCF) who competes with the Parisian subway system (RATP). To make matters even more complicated, some suburban rail lines are operated by one over the tracks of the other. This is seamless until one of them goes on strike... For the geek part: when trains shift from one network to the other (RER B between Châtelet and Gare du Nord), they free-wheel while they transition power from one network to the power of the other one. On the rare occasion that a train has to stop in the middle of that dead zone, it can't move anymore...
- bhups 9y agoThis is half true: European infrastructure construction is almost perfectly decentralized to the point that it's (for the most part) fully centralized at the level of each member state. The US half tries to fund and administer infrastructure at the federal level, state level, as well as local level, depending on the state. As an American, I find the EU to have phenomenally good infrastructure, but I think that's because decisions aren't being made in Brussels, they're being made concurrently in Paris, Berlin, Amsterdam, London, etc. I feel that the US would do well to emulate the EU, and centralize the funding, regulation, and administration of its respective systems in each member state.
- indoordinosaur 9y agoThis is why I'm not entirely opposed to the Trump infrastructure philosophy of encouraging states and local governments to pay their own way. It also encourages more private investment in infrastructure which is something that has contributed to the success of the subways in Seoul, Hong Kong and Tokyo as well as the original builders of the NYC subway.
- purplezooey 9y agoPlease don't compare activities in the private market to public infrastructure. They serve different purposes and the latter is there for the good of humanity, not to make a profit, be innovative or be disruptive.
- rco8786 9y agoThere's plenty of things that public infra does that are innovate and disruptive. Would switching to single payer not be disruptive to the entire insurance industry? How much innovation has come out of military research?
- closeparen 9y ago“The good of humanity” is not served by delivering worse outcomes at higher cost.
- ucaetano 9y agoThe US probably has the best, most efficient private sector of any developed country. And the worst, most inefficient public sector of any developed country. It chooses to prioritize the private sector over the public sector. Other countries choose otherwise. Each model has its advantages and disadvantages. This (efficiency of building public transit) is the outcome of the US model.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jessriedel 9y agoI don't really see why we should expect any tradeoff between the two. Most efficiency innovations would transfer.
- ucaetano 9y agoIt isn't about "enfficiency innovations". You always have to make tradeoffs between the collective and the individual, the private and the public. Allowing private companies to extract economic rents from the public is good for the private sector, bad for the public. And vice-versa. Take social expenditures, for example. The US spends 80%-90% of what Germany, Netherlands and Switzerland spend per capita PPP, yet the public services and social welfare in the US are abysmally bad.
- jessriedel 9y agoEconomic rents benefit owners of entrenched corporations, but they don't make them more efficient. They also don't explain why US corporate practices make foreign companies more efficient when they are exported. And you haven't addressed the difference in public service efficiency since 10% in scale is not nearly large enough to explain order-unity inefficiencies in the US public sector. (And in absolute terms the US is larger, anyways.)
- ucaetano 9y ago
- WJW 9y agoAlternatively, US subway construction companies get more money for their subway than their peers in other countries.
- crocal 9y agoThis is worth upvoting AND repeating because many could think otherwise. US Subway has no funding issue. It is a pure productivity issue.
- skate22 9y agoI clicked on this expecting an article about sandwiches lol. Edit: although im being downvoted, lowercase subway would make the title less ambiguous.
- Frye 9y agoIdk, I get $5 foot longs pretty much wherever I go
- dang 9y agoWould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments to Hacker News? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- twblalock 9y agoThis ultimately has to come back to voter standards. Other first-world countries in Europe and Asia manage to create comprehensive public transit systems cheaper and faster than the US does -- yet they also have environmental reviews, safety standards, unions, contractors, etc. They are able to do it simply because the people running the city fear that they won't be reelected if they fail to provide comprehensive, properly functioning public transit. Voters there believe that providing public transit is one of the basic duties of government. It's amazing how streamlined a public project can become if the politicians fear for their jobs. In the US, voters don't punish politicians for problems with public transit, even in places like New York where most people use it. So it's no surprise that it sucks.
- narrator 9y agoWhy does it cost 1 billion dollars a mile to build a subway in San Francisco? Where are all the costs coming from? It's the same with healthcare. Nobody knows why it's so ridiculously expensive. I wish they could hire some smart forensic accountants to figure out what is behind the ridiculous cost and then actually fix the problems by replacing the guys who are price gouging or work with the government to change regulations to make it cheaper.
- pcurve 9y agoAgreed, but the article does explain why it costs absurd amount cost per mile. Unnecessary roles that don't reflect modern construction techniques, high union labor costs, regulations, and concession to people to minimize quality of life disruptions, etc. I'm all for fair wages, but $110+/hour or $225,000/year? Give me a break. You'd have lines going out to NJ if they open up the job to everyone at $85,000/year. I work in healthcare and we all know WHY it costs outrageous amount here in the states, but nobody wants to fix it because EVERYBODY has his or her finger in the pie. Yes, price gouging is a problem, but it's only side effect of a bad system. Healthcare is expensive because there are too many damn fingers in the pie, and nobody wants to pull his or hers out first. Doctors, hospitals, private insurance, drug distributors, medical device makers, lawyers, pharma, pharmacists, physical therapy center. Guess what all these entities have? IT, HR, Sales & marketing, etc.
- stcredzero 9y agoThe U.S. also pays a lot for highways that don't have warranties. Last time I read something about it, German highways were procured with warranties. Italian highways didn't. Lots of people also grumbled that Italian highway building was plagued with corruption.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- johngalt 9y agoSSC had a great article on cost increases in a general sense. One of the more depressing articles I've read. Makes it sound like we are dying by a thousand papercuts. http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/02/09/considerations-on-cost-disease/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/02/09/considerations-on-cost-...
- rictic 9y agoVery closely related is the concept of cost disease: https://www.the-american-interest.com/2017/04/11/notes-on-cost-disease/ https://www.the-american-interest.com/2017/04/11/notes-on-co...
- dzonga 9y agoAmerica rich 3rd world country. I'm Zimbabwean, but the levels of corruption are comparable. Why would a 'top' tier city have shitty public transportation and centuries old signaling systems ?
- cbayram 9y agoBecause you aren't dealing with the competent willing who can pull off such projects. Instead, you are dealing with crooks who take their cut and pass the irresponsibility to the next. Taxpayer money is the true lottery.
- 1024core 9y agoI read this article, and the NYT one linked herein. But I don't understand why the MTA is involved in the nitty-gritty at all? Why can't there be 1 contract given out to some private entity, and then leave it up to the entity to build it as it sees fit.
- crocal 9y agoMaintenance is the main reason. If you don't get into the nitty-gritty you cannot achieve the amazing feat of keeping a system up and running 30 years passed its design lifetime
- 1024core 9y agoThey don't get into the nitty-gritty of train manufacture either. And they last a long time. I'm not buying that, sorry.
- fatjokes 9y ago"...Rosenthal talked about labor problems: severe overstaffing, with some workers doing jobs that are no longer necessary..." I learned that in one of the office buildings in NYC, there is one (sometimes two) custodians who press the elevator buttons and call out the next one to arrive. These are modern elevators with indicator lights above them. I learned it was because of a union requirement. I always liked the idea of unions, having learned about how workers were trampled on "in the old days". After moving to NYC, however, my opinions toward them became a bit more tempered.
- crocal 9y agoI have spent more than a decade working with US colleagues in this sector. Overall, three things come at a disadvantage for US that explains overall this puzzling productivity problem. First, management. I don’t exactly know where it comes from, in the land of Westinghouse, Edison, Tesla, and the likes, but being an engineering project leader is not seen as the career path of a winner. It’s all about business, storytelling, laws and politics, where the power and the money is. Compare that to Germany where the chancellor is a PhD in physics and there you go. Second. Individualism. No. Team. Spirit. Everybody wants to be with the best at what he/she does and recognized at such. There is no willingness to fill cross functional gaps, people are absurdly specialized, resulting in very inefficient performance at the collective level and surprisingly high level of bureaucracy. Third. Protectionism. US established market is protected against foreign competition. The net result is that the US consumer is never benchmarking what he gets against real alternatives. His appliances are crap. His social protection is bad. His car is a good laugh compared to most Japanese or European models. As a consequence he as no notion of how good a deal he is getting on such things (and in most cases, he is being ripped off). The combination of the three explains quasi all of the shortcomings noted here. I believe these problems were not as acute some decades ago. I think these behaviors have been pushed to the extreme through the various US tax reforms that have allowed very few to capture most of the wealth, thereby promoting the above behavior. It’s not the first time in US history though. I believe it will be fixed eventually because it’s becoming too absurd. :)