11 ms·
Cloud companies consider Intel rivals after security flaws found
- mc32 9y agoEnter Itanium. I mean, we know they are all saying "arm" and "amd" both as negotiating tactic as well as strategically diversifying microarchitectures. That said, I'm not sure it's like amd can deliver more instructions per second per dollar. I wonder if it would make sense for some loads to prepare for Itanium usage, or even older Atom architectures? Does any one deploy Itanium in the cloud?
- DSMan195276 9y agoIt's worth noting that only pre-2013 Itanium CPUs are not vulnerable to meltdown (The same as with Atom CPUs). Intel has also said that the Itanium chips released in 2017 would be the last Itanium chips they will develop, so I don't think there's any reason to bother switching to Itanium. I would wager it's guaranteed you'll be better-off with the latest AMD instead of a 2013 Itanium, and AMD supports x86-64 so it doesn't require making your full software stack support Itanium (Which it likely doesn't).
- benjaminl 9y ago> and AMD supports x86-64 I am sure you didn’t mean it this way, but it struck me as funny saying AMD supports x86-64. Of course AMD supports x86-64, they invented it. That is why Microsoft and Linux refer to that architecture as AMD64. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X86-64#History_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X86-64#History_2
- jcastro 9y agoIt feels like now would be a good time for the openpower folks to get a tad louder.
- milankragujevic 9y agofwiw Kimsufi is offering N2800 Atom CPUs for cheap, which don't appear to be vulnerable...
- noway421 9y agoItanium is not binary compatible with x86. Might as well think about arm if it would require change in ci pipeline/the set up from app developers.
- colejohnson66 9y agoDoesn’t it have an x86 emulation mode? If not, Intel messed up there.
- shawn 9y agoThe Intel flaw exposed something interesting: We could get a >50% performance boost by ignoring security. Think about that. 1.5x - 2x boost, on a single core. That's like doubling a CPU's clock speed, except more powerful since it involves caching memory (which is usually the bottleneck, not raw horsepower). What would the TempleOS of CPUs look like, I wonder? We ought to have the option of running workloads on such CPUs. Yes, they're completely compromised, but if you're running a game server you really don't have to care very much. Most data is ephemeral, and the data that isn't, isn't usually an advantage to know. Being able to run twice the workload as your competitors on a single core is a big advantage. You saw what happened when performance suddenly dropped thanks to the patch.
- bitwize 9y agoSome Amiga people still believe that "virtual memory" is a passing fad, and when the Amiga comes again in glory we'll all realize how futile and self-defeating it was to prevent people from accessing the raw hardware and OS.
- akvadrako 9y agoAlso, unikernels move in this direction. If you just run one program per VM, virtual memory doesn't gain you much security.
- snaky 9y agoIncludeOS especially. > One service pr. VM means no need for virtual address spaces, and no overhead due to address translation. Everything happens in a single, ring 0 address space.
- cm2187 9y agoPlus this is not a security issue on a single tenant server running only the game server code.
- AdamJacobMuller 9y ago
- discoursism 9y agoIf you weren't considering Intel alternatives before this, I'd argue that's a real failure of imagination and risk management. I'm sure some of the really small cloud providers weren't, but all the big players keep tabs on the path to and pain of migration, at a minimum. Just because they weren't actually using PowerPC/ARM/AMD does not mean they did not know how.
- cm2187 9y agoAre PowerPC and ARM real alternatives? Most server software is developed for x86 only, if you only offer ARM and PowerPC machines, who will be your clients?
- kikoreis 9y agoA lot of server software is actually open source and runs on most commonly available hardware architectures, including ARM and PPC. You are right that everybody develops assuming x86, though, and there is some friction in that transition regardless of software portability.
- nine_k 9y agoMore important is, are PPC or ARM competitive at the amount of computation per watt, and amount of computation per dollar. Power 8 and 9 are pretty good at number-crunching but also pretty expensive, and I don't know about power efficiency. ARMs used to be pretty power-efficient, but likely cannot offer very high single-threaded performance (must still be great for IO-heavy applications that are hit hardest on Intel).
- discoursism 9y agoIn the sense that those processors can compute things which are computable, yes, they are a real alternative. The correct question is, "How much worse would the situation have to be with Intel before the cost of these alternatives was less than the benefit of switching to one of them." The answer, I guess, is: "much worse than things are now." However, if you're running at billions in revenue per quarter, you can afford to spend a few million to limit your downside risk by keeping yourself apprised of what the costs would be of moving to another platform.
- pkaye 9y agoAren't ARM processors are vulnerable to some of the same security flaws? What are the alternatives? AMD got lucky in a sense but the reality is you can't be on any one horse.
- electrograv 9y agoAMD is no more lucky than ARM, though Intel was ‘unlucky’: Spectre affects Intel, AMD, and ARM alike, while Meltdown Intel CPUs disproportionately (AMD and ARM CPUs have been mostly unaffected by it).
- berkut 9y agoSome ARM CPUs are vulnerable to Meltdown: https://developer.arm.com/support/security-update https://developer.arm.com/support/security-update
- DSMan195276 9y agoThat's not entirely accurate. There are a lot of ARM CPUs that are not vulnerable to Spectre, and that includes a lot of them that are in use in actual devices. For example, my phone happens to use a Cortex-A53, which is not vulnerable. It is however easy to miss this detail from their 'security update' [0] because the table doesn't list CPUs that aren't affected. Also, I don't believe the single ARM CPU that's vulnerable to meltdown (Cortex-A75) has actually been included in any devices at this point, so for now it is safe to assume any ARM-based device you have is not vulnerable to meltdown. [0] https://developer.arm.com/support/security-update https://developer.arm.com/support/security-update
- Narishma 9y agoI believe Apple's ARM CPUs are vulnerable to Meltdown.
- colejohnson66 9y agoNot the Watch though. Apple, as expected, hasn’t said why.
- shaklee3 9y agoFor what it's worth, the power9 servers look great. Not sure if they'll live up to the hype, though.
- kyrra 9y agoGoogle was one of the founding members for OpenPOWER. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenPOWER_Foundation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenPOWER_Foundation The large providers are always looking around, it would be silly not to.
- newman314 9y agoPOWER is vulnerable to Spectre. I’m trying to get definitive confirmation that it’s affected by Meltdown (firmware notes say yes)
- shaklee3 9y agoI was coming at it more from a "having alternatives is good" comment instead of saying it's not vulnerable to the new problems. The specs look interesting enough to benchmark on, and perhaps if it actually does perform better, then even with patches it will stand out.
- newman314 9y agoFor those who are curious about POWER, here is the firmware link for a 880. https://download4.boulder.ibm.com/sar/CMA/SFA/07d79/0/01SC860_138_056.html https://download4.boulder.ibm.com/sar/CMA/SFA/07d79/0/01SC86... In response to recently reported security vulnerabilities, this firmware update is being released to address Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures issue numbers CVE-2017-5715, CVE-2017-5753 and CVE-2017-5754. Operating System updates are required in conjunction with this FW level for CVE-2017-5753 and CVE-2017-5754
- earenndil 9y agoI don't think throwing intel out entirely is a solution, but rather, diversification. What if there later comes out another vulnerability granting arbitrary code exec given a specific bytestring in memory, which only intel processors are immune to? Better to have as many as possible of as many different CPUs as possible. Just like, e.g. backblaze has done with HDD manufacturers.
- martin_bech 9y agoThat could be a nightmare to maintain, and also garanties the opposite. Everytime there is a CPU exploit, you will be hit.
- NiklasMort 9y agothe AMD EPYC single socket processors are definitely worth considering, love them
- thisisabore 9y agoCan you explain why, at least briefly?
- ihsw2 9y agoThey have vastly more PCIe lanes, which makes them exceptionally suitable for high-density GPU nodes (or, similarly, high-density NVMe storage nodes). AMD also offers superior value for the money on a per-CPU basis, even after discounts (which both Intel and AMD offer generously). This makes them exceptionally suitable for high-memory nodes.
- therealmarv 9y agoDid Intel said WHEN this is fixed in hardware? Or are we supposed to buy this hardware bug in the next generations???
- burnte 9y agoThere won't be a hardware fix, you can't patch CPUs (aside from microcode which is just more software). Since this is a pretty fundamental issue wit how certain things work, yes, you'll have to wait for a new generation, and I couldn't expect anything in less than a year at the absolute earliest. It's a multi-year process from design to tape-out and fabrication. Honestly, I'm not sure how far back in the design process fixing this will take, it is something that can be added in as permanent microcode after fabrication/during packaging? Can current designs be "patched" before moving on to tape out? Do we need to go back to square one and rethink a couple key premises? I don't know. But it's not quick.
- MilnerRoute 9y agoI've been wondering if this will be the thing that brings a wave of new users to open source RISC-V chips, starting a virtuous cycle of new chip development and then more users for those new chips. https://hardware.slashdot.org/story/17/10/09/0019212/linux-now-has-its-first-open-source-risc-v-processor https://hardware.slashdot.org/story/17/10/09/0019212/linux-n...
- walkingolof 9y agoI hope this will give RISC-V a boost also, more competition from more vendors is what the CPU market need.
- PyComfy 9y agoQualcomm Falkor (ARMv8 AArch64) vs Intel Broadwell and Skylake https://blog.cloudflare.com/arm-takes-wing/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/arm-takes-wing/ Multicore AVX512 lowers the frequency The Qualcomm CPU only has the 128-bit wide NEON SIMD, while Broadwell has 256-bit wide AVX2, and Skylake has 512-bit wide AVX-512. This explains the huge lead Skylake has over both in single core performance. In the all-cores benchmark the Skylake lead lessens, because it has to lower the clock speed when executing AVX-512 workloads. When executing AVX-512 on all cores, the base frequency goes down to just 1.4GHz---keep that in mind if you are mixing AVX-512 and other code.
- acd 9y agoApple could start their own cloud servers their CPUs are fast enough. Apple are competitive if you weight in power/performance. Geekbench scores Apple A11 CPU multi score 10176 Intel Intel Xeon E5-2696 v4, 2 cpu score 82225 Geekbench scores of Intel https://browser.geekbench.com/v4/cpu/5249111 https://browser.geekbench.com/v4/cpu/5249111 Geekbench scores of Apple https://browser.geekbench.com/ios_devices/51 https://browser.geekbench.com/ios_devices/51
- reacharavindh 9y agoWe just had tech sales folks from major hardware vendor approach us with a pitch to strongly consider AMD EPYC based servers for our next compute purchase. They highlighted * Value for money * memory performance on inter core access * more memory channels per core * still within x86 ISA negating the need for any Se rewrites. Our workloads are memory access bound. So the above points hit home. We're going to try AMD servers for the first time at this research group. If they do hold the promise, intel finally got some active competition in our realm!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- amelius 9y agoBy the way, how secure is GPU programming, when the GPU is accessed by multiple users?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jnwatson 9y agoNot at all.
- qwerty456127 9y agoThough not an unquestionable and not ultimately reliable one, using comparably rare hardware and software usually is a valid security measure. Now as Linux has gained solid market share the "no viruses for Linux" era comes to its end and Linux-capable ransomware is emerging I am considering moving to OpenBSD not only because security is among the top priorities of its design but because it's a way more exotic too.
- jacksmith21006 9y agoThought Google had already ported their services to Power?
- known 9y agoThis is a serious bug; A website can read data stored in the browser for another website, or the browser's memory itself. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spectre_(security_vulnerability) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spectre_(security_vulnerabilit...
- xemdetia 9y agoMy funniest thought of this whole affair that whatever performance upsizing happens in the front is probably going to be with manufacturer discounts from Intel from Amazon Google complaining and the cloud providers may end up with a windfall in the gap.