13 ms·
Half of the US government's financial assets are student loans
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ceedan 9y agoFound posted earlier here https://www.advisorperspectives.com/dshort/commentaries/2017/12/07/the-fed-s-financial-accounts-what-is-uncle-sam-s-largest-asset https://www.advisorperspectives.com/dshort/commentaries/2017... Other charts as well
- thinkloop 9y agoOne thing to keep in mind is that "assets" are far from "spending". Governments generally do not accumulate assets, everything they collect is reserved for spending (besides some operational accounts and things like foreign reserves). The student loan program is an exception and so figures heavily in this stat.
- philipov 9y agoGovernment owns a lot of land, and land is most certainly an asset. Does it figure into these stats? It would be rather deceptive to craft your definition of asset to exclude the most important one.
- bradleybuda 9y agoThese are so-called "financial assets" (which I'm guessing are a relatively small portion of the US government's total assets).
- d--b 9y agoYes, the title makes it sound like the US government is in a dire situation because it has its solvency tied to students paying back their loans... But mostly the government is a borrower of cash and not a lender. Here the government is indirectly financing people's education by offering cheaper loans than the market would give. There is not much to talk about...
- prostoalex 9y agoThe rate that the government can borrow at is determined by the quality of underlying assets. US 10-year note is 2.58% at the moment, but Argentina's is 7%.
- marshray 9y agoWell the US is somewhat special in that the dollar (or currencies tied to it) is used by 70% of all global transactions. The other day a minister in China floated the idea of buying less US Treasuries. It became apparent that there just weren't a lot of other instruments available with which to invest that sheer volume of money.
- CodeSheikh 9y agoThanks to baby boomers for depleting resources of this nation and now younger generations are stuck in this financial mess. Had they been more visionary with better overlook then today there would have been better opportunities for younger generation to earn and pay back those loans. https://www.vox.com/2017/12/20/16772670/baby-boomers-millennials-congress-debt https://www.vox.com/2017/12/20/16772670/baby-boomers-millenn...
- dnautics 9y agoLet's not be too harsh on the baby boomers, they were trying to create a better world for the next generation, they chose chose to do it via an unsustainable system that relies on top-down direction of the economy using inappropriate tools. Can you blame them for that? Top down worked great at things like rebuilding europe after a war (admittedly an eminently unfalsifiable task)... True, there were minority voices clamoring that this would result in ruin, but to be fair there are still well regarded "smart" people who argue that the problem for millennials is that those people in charge just didn't do it ENOUGH.
- marshray 9y ago> they were trying to create a better world for the next generation I don't see a lot of evidence for this, except perhaps Reagan's program of deficit spending on an arms race to bankrupt the 'evil empire'. Maybe people should be forgiven for believing in the trickle-down lie once, but it's now simply a transfer of wealth scam.
- dnautics 9y agoWell the current neoliberal program of low or negative interest rates to stimulate economic growth and 'reinvestment' is basically trickle-down, too, just in a less direct fashion plus actively impoverishing the poor (instead of merely taking less from the rich). So it's basically still believed - just as a more obfuscated scam.
- ThrustVectoring 9y ago
- jdoliner 9y agoDebt is the American way, it has been since the very beginning. When George Washington was elected President he was so broke he need a loan to get from Mount Vernon to NYC for his own inauguration.
- evanpw 9y agoNotwithstanding entirely valid concerns about student loans, this is pure clickbait. The feds also own 30% of the nation's land (640M acres), and have the exclusive right to collect $3T+ per year in taxes (not to mention they can literally print dollars).
- fixermark 9y agoWhat is the impact to the American economy when the Federal government has to write down the value of over half its assets as the average lendee dies without paying?
- hidenotslide 9y agoNothing? That person was also collecting social security and medicare if they were old enough.
- koolba 9y agoAnd if they weren’t they don’t have to account for that unfunded mandate.
- prostoalex 9y agoAFAIK land is not used for collateral to estimate credit worthiness. Taxes are, but it's understood that the figure is ballpark and subject to economic fluctuations. A portfolio of loans, however, can impact the credit worthiness of the borrower if the default rate exceeds historic expectations, which is what US experienced in 2008 with mortgage-backed loans.
- tvural 9y agoHealthcare is a much bigger problem for the government than student loans. The federal government spends about 1 trillion per year on healthcare, while the total of all student debt in the U.S. is around 1 trillion. This is true on a societal level too. U.S. healthcare spending is 17% of GDP, up from 5% in the 1960s. The problem with student loans is that the burden falls mostly on the least financially secure people. This is as opposed to Medicare/Medicaid where the government tries to foot the bill rather than allow people to get in massive debt.
- mxpxrocks10 9y agois this for real? does anyone have any info that proves this right/wrong?
- hidenotslide 9y agoAlmost assuredly false. The Federal Reserve balance sheet is US treasuries and mortgages, and Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac are mortgages as well. Probably not a complete data set.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- FabHK 9y agoUS treasuries and mortgages are liabilities, though, right? This is the asset side of the balance sheet.
- hidenotslide 9y agoTreasuries are liabilities when the government issues them and assets when the Fed holds them. One person's liability is another person's asset.
- FabHK 9y agoRight, and the graph was about the assets of "the US government", not about the Fed.
- noobermin 9y agoIf that's the case, shouldn't this be flagged? Also, you mentioned the Fed, which isn't the same thing as the US gov't, right?
- hidenotslide 9y agoI don't really want to go down the conspiracy theory rabbit hole of who does what at the Fed but it's main decision makers are government appointees, it was established by an act of Congress, and it remits its profits to the Treasury. Ginnie Mae is part of the government as well (also mortgages). Fannie/Freddie are GSE's but currently under directly government control since the financial crisis. I'm not sure how the accounting works, but they are somewhat autonomous and have their own balance sheets.
- jjoonathan 9y agoOof. What happens when a huge chunk of these default because educating everyone doesn't magically create jobs for everyone?
- TheRealPomax 9y ago2008.
- fixermark 9y agoThey're protected from defaulting by law, because they can't be divested by bankruptcy. ... which merely means you need to calculate where the knee in the curve of issuing them was, extrapolate to life expectancy, and know when to cash out. Convenient!
- tboyd47 9y ago> you need to calculate where the knee in the curve of issuing them was, extrapolate to life expectancy, and know when to cash out. Sorry, what does that mean?
- marcelluspye 9y agoI believe what they were implying was that such a bubble can only "pop" if a bunch of the debt is discharged at once, which in this case means a bunch of people who still owe student loans on their deathbed die with more debt than assets. The commenter suggested trying to figure out when this would happen, and making sure one is ahead of it.
- r00fus 9y ago> and making sure one is ahead of it. I was with you till the last bit. How does one "keep ahead" with that timescale?
- fixermark 9y agoCorrect. The question is what, precisely, you'd use to bet against the student loan market. Since of the people who "successfully" shorted real estate found themselves running into trouble cashing out because the same institutions they'd bet against got hammered when housing popped and themselves defaulted. How do you successfully bet against the stability of the world-stabilizing fiat currency---the one other countries jam under their mattresses to back-stop against domestic economic turmoil?
- trsohmers 9y agoI have been skeptical of the real "value" of cryptocurrencies (outside the technical ability to allow for value transfer, which does not necessitate the coins having value inthemselves), but assuming this is true I have a lot less faith in dollar bills and the fact that they are backed by the "full faith and credit" of the US government. If the student debt bubble really does pop, the government (and thus all of us tax payers) are going to be the ones holding the bag.
- bradleyjg 9y agoIn what sense is it a bubble? What assets are being bid up by enthusiastic investors and could suddenly collapse in value?
- trsohmers 9y agoThe fact that private lenders are incentivized to give out more and more leads to universities charging more and more. Even with all the money being spent, the same (or in some cases less) level of education is being provided. On top of that, how do you repossess someones education in the case of default? You can't, so the government can do one of three things: 1.Pay off the loan holders (by printing money, huge inflation) 2.Allowing indentured servitude 3.Debt forgiveness (now all the lenders are out of money) Sadly, I think the 3rd option is the best one, but is by no means actually a good one.
- bradleyjg 9y agoPrivate lenders are tiny part of the market in student loan originations, even a smaller part in undergradatute loans. The federal government is the overwhelmingly dominant player and they set the terms by fiat rather than any kind of market. The “lenders” are the USG, and the cost of capital is only the imputed inflationary effect of transforming a loan into spending. Given the experience of the last decade those inflationary pressures may well be smaller than we had thought.
- NegativeK 9y agoIn the same sense that the mortgage industry was a bubble. For mortgages, the investor lent money to home buyers and expected a long-term payment schedule. The houses were being bid up. If you assume student loans are a bubble: the long-term earnings potential of students is being bid up (and will collapse, leaving the government with lower worth/worthless assets.)
- gesman 9y agoRecent reports from the Treasury Department show that the US government owns nearly $1.5 trillion in student loans. That’s pretty sad when you think about it: the US government’s #1 financial asset is debt owed by tens of millions of its young people for university education that didn’t even necessarily qualify them for a real career. Millennials are the most educated generation in history. Yet there are record numbers of them working off student debts as waiters and bartenders, and supplementing their income on the side with ‘gigs’ (like being an Uber driver). ... On top of all that, young people will spend their entire working lives paying into a pension system that likely won’t be there for them when it comes time to collect. The Board of Trustees of Social Security tells us that the program is going to completely run out of money within the next 15 years. Millennials’ retirement horizon is far beyond that. ... Miami-based homebuilder, Lennar Homes, recently announced it would pay a big chunk of a student loan for any borrower buying a home from them. Through its subsidiary Eagle Home Mortgage, the company will make a payment to a buyer’s student loans of as much as 3% of the purchase price, up to $13,000. Debt has become such a keystone of our society, that the only way we can afford something is to swap one type of debt they can’t afford with another type of debt. -- Simon Black
- ProAm 9y ago> The Board of Trustees of Social Security tells us that the program is going to completely run out of money within the next 15 years Can you cite any sources on this? Im fairly certain it will not be completely out of money, but will be to a point where more money is going out than coming in.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoThe Social Security Trust Fund does exhaust it's surplus (if no additional changes are made to the system), but that reduces benefits to ~3/4 of those promised; benefit payments do not disappear entirely. "In the annual Trustees Report, projections are made under three alternative sets of economic and demographic assumptions. Under one of these sets (labeled "Low Cost") the trust funds remain solvent for the next 75 years. Under the other two sets (the "Intermediate" and "High Cost"), the trust funds become depleted within the next 20 years. The intermediate assumptions reflect the Trustees' best estimate of future experience. Some benefits could be paid even if the trust funds are depleted. For example, under the intermediate assumptions, annual income to the trust funds is projected to equal about seventy-nine percent of program cost once the trust funds become depleted. If no legislation has been enacted to restore long-term solvency by that time, about three-quarters of scheduled benefits could be paid in each year." As long as the government continues to exist and has the ability to tax, Social Security will be around. https://www.ssa.gov/oact/progdata/fundFAQ.html https://www.ssa.gov/oact/progdata/fundFAQ.html https://www.ssa.gov/oact/solvency/index.html https://www.ssa.gov/oact/solvency/index.html
- rgbrenner 9y agoSo here's the US financial accounts report from the Fed (the source listed): https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/z1/current/html/default.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/z1/current/html/defa... I don't see anything in that report that confirms this.. did I just miss it? where did the data come from?
- 1986 9y agoI was able to get similar numbers from: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FGCCSAQ027S https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FGCCSAQ027S and https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FGTFASA027N https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FGTFASA027N
- mylons 9y agohow does this bubble pop? isn't this debt something you can't default on?
- chatmasta 9y agoJust because someone can’t default on their loan doesn’t mean they can pay it. It’s also not hard for me to imagine, in the near future, a social media movement like “don’t pay back your loans.”
- mylons 9y agoya, I had this thought as well, but then the IRS garnishes your wages until you die. So how does it pop? Seems like a lot of people would have to go to jail or something along those lines for it to actually happen?
- chatmasta 9y agoThey can only garnish your wages if you’re a W2 employee, or use the banking system. Contractors need to pay their own taxes, and the IRS can’t garnish what it can’t see. Gig economy + cryptocurrency + social media + student loan debt could lead to some very interesting times.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago“Interesting time” as in jail time for money laundering and wilful tax fraud?
- tzahola 9y agobuy gold now. you’ll thank me later
- nkrisc 9y agoDelicious, nutritious gold.
- dang 9y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments here.
- dukeflukem 9y agoGold is so passé
- dmix 9y agoAdministrative bloat feeding into administrative bloat.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jdoliner 9y agoAnytime the US wants the world to be a certain way but just can't quite get reality to conform debt is our answer. Everyone should be a homeowner but for some reason isn't? Simple, just give them cheap loans for houses. Everyone should be educated but it doesn't seem to be happening? Debt time. Why do we do this? Because it allows us to pretend that complicated long-term structural problems are simple short-term capital problems. People just need some activation energy to get over the hump, that's all. We're addicted to debt, if we ever admitted that it's not solving these problems for us we'd have to contend with reality, and who wants to do that? Especially a reality as dismal as that of public education.
- eemax 9y agoWell, it does actually solve the problem in the sense that it actually causes houses to be built and students to go to college. Probably this indicates the real problem is more about bad monetary policy and bad tax policy, not a fundamental shortage of resources. Of course, it would be better to improve monetary policy rather than just making a bunch of dumb, risky loans leading to a dramatic boom and bust. But that would require policymakers understanding basic macroeconomics, so don't hold your breath...
- jdoliner 9y agoIs that really solving the problem though, or does it just give us houses no one wants to own and college graduates no one wants to employ? That's what it looks like to me at least. I don't think it's bad monetary or tax policy per-say, although those are bad, but just bad policy in general. But the badness of the policy comes from a fundamental over estimation of what the government is capable of doing for a society.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- eemax 9y agoWell, to some degree, people probably do want to live in big, new houses. There's also probably some "real" underlying demand for an education, outside of people needing it (or believing that they need it) to get a good job. But the point is, regardless of how much people "actually" want them, it is in fact technologically and ecologically possible to provide most people in the U.S. with these goods. (The evidence is that a lot of people do in fact have these things, even if on paper they are underwater on a mortgage or saddled with a big student loan.) The bad policy is that by subsidizing and insuring these loans / mortgages far too cheaply, the government is driving up demand, and as a result people buy a bigger house than they need, or get an education that isn't useful for getting a high-paying job. If the government stops subsidizing mortgages and student loans with bailouts, insurance, laws preventing default, etc. the result will probably be 1) the cost of a college education goes down and also that less people actually go to college 2) people don't buy as many homes and buy smaller houses than they otherwise would have If you then want more people to have houses, education, healthcare, food, etc., whether or not they are able / willing to sell enough of their labor to pay for these things themselves, the next step is to solve wealth inequality. We could probably fix wealth inequality with good monetary policy (e.g. NGDP targeting) and "taxing the rich" in a sane way, e.g. with land value taxes, luxury consumption, VAT taxes, etc. After that, you're probably done, but for the remaining poor, the government can just give them cash, e.g. basic income, instead of trying to subsidize a million different services like healthcare and education and homes, in which case the subsidies end up in the pockets of doctors and administrators and landlords.
- MollyR 9y agoUS government backed student loans were a huge mistake. We needed something like rent control enforced on public universities, for government backed loans. But we didn't. So it created a situation that caused an enormous amount of millennials to be taken advantage of by universities and colleges. Those universities and colleges pumped full of government loan cash became increasingly predatory. They increased their administrative costs, they increased their tuition costs, and they lured unsuspecting teenagers into taking enormous debt for worthless degrees like gender studies over engineering. This has been a catastrophe, that will be used as a case study of unintended consequences. The extreme amount of student loans has lead to extreme unrest, unless action is taken quickly it will only get worse. We see it in the rise of the alt-left and alt-right fueled by extreme fanatics in desperate and angry situations.
- mjevans 9y agoWell, rent control isn't exactly the correct option. Econ 101: if you want the price of a 'product' to go down, increase supply. The correct thing to do is to provide more supply (full ride public institution, paid for by taxpayers at government run community colleges) and focus production on fields valued by society.
- lickedydiff 9y agoTo be fair to universities, at the same time that happened, states have been decreasing funding. Also, topheavy administration is everywhere, not just education, part of the unnecessary MBA-ification of everything. And there would be no demand for loans if corporations weren't trying to offload all their employee financial responsibilities in every way possible: just as companies are reclassifying everyone as consultants and freelancers, and decreasing everything to part-time, they stopped seeing themselves as providing career training to anyone, expecting people to do that themselves at universities and through unpaid internships. So I wouldn't blame much on US backed government loans. The US government could offer free loans for people wanting to get Justin Bieber tattoos, and it would increase tattooing I'm sure, but wouldn't cause a generational economic crisis.
- bluntfang 9y ago>worthless degrees like gender studies Worthless eh? I bet if companies Uber hired some of these gender studies majors they might not have fucked up?
- cs702 9y agoThis ignores $2.466 trillion of US treasuries and $1.771 trillion of Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and Ginnie Mae mortgage-backed securities owned by the Federal Reserve.[a] Although the Fed, as the US's central bank, operates independently of the federal government, its balance sheet should properly be consolidated. The largest financial assets owned by the US federal government are therefore US treasuries and government-sponsored-entity mortgage securities, not student debt.[b] -- [a] Figures are as of November 2017. See page 12 here: https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/files/quarterly_balance_sheet_developments_report_201711.pdf https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/files/quarterl... [b] Many people don't realize or understand that the largest creditor of the US federal government is the US federal government, through the Federal reserve. The US federal government currently pays interest on $2.466 trillion of treasuries to the Federal Reserve, which, at the end of each year, sends all that interest back to the US Treasury.
- wavesound 9y agoThis chart is very informative. It looked a bit familiar to me and it reminded me of this link: https://www.advisorperspectives.com/dshort/commentaries/2017/12/07/the-fed-s-financial-accounts-what-is-uncle-sam-s-largest-asset https://www.advisorperspectives.com/dshort/commentaries/2017... The charts look a bit too similar...
- nickysielicki 9y agoThis is such a huge problem and it's so easy to see the collapse over the horizon. There are just a few small differences between education today and education 30 years ago. Off the top of my head, you can go online today and see lectures for upper level MIT courses for free... Literally, the best university in the world has lectures available for free. And instead of learning the dewey decmial system and taking 10 books and flipping through looking for a specific answer, you can google any specific topic and immediately get relevant information. And you can go on reddit.com/r/askscience and ask questions to experts in any field. Just a few small differences. What the hell are people paying for, then? The "college experience"? Does it really cost tens of thousands of dollars to validate that someone has adequately learned from consuming educational material? Schools today have dorms that look like luxury hotels and the best gyms in the country; what the fuck is going on? Meanwhile, primary education hasn't fundamentally changed in 100 years, outside of a select few schoolboards adding iPads to the classroom and thinking to themselves, "Yes, now we're modern." Nevermind that we still exclusively group children by their age group rather than their educational progress until they're 18. Nevermind that we have never questioned the idea of teaching children 7 different topics every single day, wasting extraordinary amounts of time with context switching, instead of focusing on a topic for longer periods (as it works in the real world.) I just do not understand how this debt is going to be managed when (not "if") the education system is fundamentally disrupted. Economists more or less universally agree that federally guaranteed student loans are unsustainable and make education more expensive. So what's taking so long?
- snarfy 9y agoPosition Requirements * Bachelor's degree in CS As someone without a degree, there are quite a few positions unavailable to me. Some positions state a degree is required even though they would take an exceptional developer, but many others are very strict and require the degree. The pedigree of the employees can be important when the company is in the market to be bought or sold.
- fjsolwmv 9y agoThe bachelors isn't important for it's inherent value, only as an arbitrary way of ranking people in a rat race.
- lewis500 9y agoWould it be better if banks owned all the debt? I think the really bad statistic is just how much student debt there is. Progressives in Oakland want the city to create a municipal bank. If they do, maybe progressives will then complain "Y% of Oakland's assets are mortgages and small business loans." For any level of student debt, I think it is obviously better that the government own a lot of it, as the payments the government receives can be used for spending. The payments banks receive go to shareholders. In fact, given the government can borrow money at 2% while student loan rates are like 4-8%, it might not even be a bad idea to have the government issue treasuries and buy more student loans. Administratively, perhaps this would be bad for reasons I can't guess ex ante, but off the cuff I can't see why it's bad for the government to own lots of student debt, especially when government is what enforces the debt contracts (siphoning off your wages in the event of default, etc). One could argue that the government should just cancel all or most of that student debt. Maybe so, but if that would cause the government to forgo $X billion in revenue every year, I think it would be better to just have another $X billion in spending. However, if the $X billion would just go to more tax cuts for the super-wealthy then perhaps it would be a good idea.
- Turing_Machine 9y ago>In fact, given the government can borrow money at 2% while student loan rates are like 4-8%, it might not even be a bad idea to have the government issue treasuries and buy more student loans. If 40% of the loans are in default and/or the borrowers aren't making payments for some other reason (which is the actual case) it would be a very bad idea.
- lewis500 9y agoIt is possible to choose the loans. The default rate for for profit colleges is high, but you don’t need to buy those loans. https://www.brookings.edu/research/the-looming-student-loan-default-crisis-is-worse-than-we-thought/ https://www.brookings.edu/research/the-looming-student-loan-...
- remind_me_again 9y agoWhat happens if US Government forgives the student loans? What's the share of that debt payment in the government budget?
- gumby 9y agoTrivially solved by magically declaring it off the books as was done with mortgages. This isn’t actually a meaningful number, The far more important number is the converse: what percentage of total student debt (and total residential mortgage debt) is held by the US government? Almost all of it. Those “markets” only exist because the government is the industry, and everybody would save money if the govt cut out the intermediaries (banks) who are collecting huge fees for nothing.
- njarboe 9y agoThe number one asset is the ability to tax an economy of $20 trillion(ie. 320 million Americans) to extract $3.7 trillion annually(2016). Holding the equivalent in 3% 30yr US bonds to give you that income would be about $125 trillion dollars. So this asset is 100 times the student debt one.
- yorby 9y agoSeems like a fairly safe investment since even bankruptcy doesn't take care of them... Until the Government will have to forgive all of those loans...
- joshuaheard 9y agoThat looks like just intangible assets. It doesn't seem to include land, buildings, vehicles, vessels, etc. The US Government is the largest landholder in the Western states. A single aircraft carrier is worth billions. Also, back when I took out a student loan, the government was merely a guarantor, which would be a liability. I wonder if they offset that. I think they need a more precise source citation.
- krsdcbl 9y agoThis might be a bit idealistic and not align with US principles - but doesn't this actually show it would be much smarter to keep education free for everyone and just straight up pay for it with a higher taxation? These numbers look to me a bit as if gov is paying anyway, but with the current model it gets the money back only (eventually) after the citizens education, and pushes a lot of people into debt. All of that for essentially avoiding that one person might add a few $$$ to the pot that could benefit another... I know US policy sees the self-responsibility of the individual completely differently, but having grown up in Austria and profited from top education that is _naturally_ free for everyone, all of this student debt stuff looks like madness to me.
- Keisha22 9y agoBack in 2016 we had one major drawback. Hubby lost his job, I had an accident that made me quit my job as well. We collected thousands of money from our Home Equity line of credit (HELOC) account which works sort of like a credit card to raise our son through college. This caused our credit scores to drop drastically, the bank almost terminated our line of credit and at that point I almost regretted my existence in life. I am using this opportunity to say a BIG THANK YOU to my sister and her BFF she introduced to us as a credit score hacker and counselor. He cleared our HELOC debt of $142,000 and raised our scores to 765 and 758. My special thanks goes to this genius hacker, we purchased our second home last week for our son. As we have promised to give him more clients if he should successfully fix our problems. We are living testimonies and confident of this miracle worker to handle all jobs, I will implore everyone facing challenges with credit scores, credit report,bankruptcy,mortgage issues to reach him on pyramideye(.)hack (AT outlook(.) com )