19 ms·
Bitcoin has little shot at ever being a major global currency
- KasianFranks 9y ago3 points. More nice bias.
- moxious 9y agoWhile the mainstream argues about whether bitcoin is or isn't this or that, while bitcoin attracts all the attention because of its spectacularly high price, people are working on blockchain things all over the place, relatively quietly in the background. Whether or not bitcoin does this or that is immaterial to growth of non-currency blockchain applications.
- joshuamcginnis 9y agoWhat's a good resource for finding and following new blockchain projects?
- tenaciousDaniel 9y agoThis is particular to Ethereum, but https://www.stateofthedapps.com/ https://www.stateofthedapps.com/
- bitoneill 9y agoQ: What are the best news sources about blockchain technology? https://www.quora.com/What-are-the-best-news-sources-about-blockchain-technology https://www.quora.com/What-are-the-best-news-sources-about-b...
- lurr 9y agoYeah, but is anyone working on useful blockchain applications as opposed to shoving Blockchain in because HYPE.
- sebleon 9y agoBitcoin/Monero/Zcash are already incredibly useful by making things like Wikileaks possible, which was previously shut out of the world financial system from US Govt pressure. This contribution to international politics alone has changed the world.
- paulie_a 9y agoDoes anyone see WikiLeaks as a good thing anymore? The concept is interesting but WikiLeaks is beyond worthless and Julian is just an attention seeking whore, being played by global superpowers
- cortic 9y agoi'd expect that kind of stupidity from reddit, but here? Has mainstream media truly got such a hold over everyone? that they can destroy the reputation of a service (and a political refugee) while doing absolutely everything they accuse the service of doing, except blatantly and malevolently? Starting to wonder whether the west deserves a service like Wikileaks; maybe we should be condemned back into the days where whistle blowers were quietly dealt with and the population could live in dumb ignorance.
- lurr 9y ago> i'd expect that kind of stupidity from reddit, but here and the very next sentence > Has mainstream media truly got such a hold over everyone
- ghostcluster 9y agoEven mainstream media admitted its sins the day after the 2016 election. This is from the political director of CBS News: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/commentary-the-unbearable-smugness-of-the-press-presidential-election-2016/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/commentary-the-unbearable-smugn... Unfortunately, it's only seemed to have gotten even worse over the past year, even after such a mea culpa.
- vadimberman 9y agoTrue, but the article is not about the blockchain; moreover, I'd be shocked if CNBC were discussing inner works of software and technical concepts that the general public has no interest in.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hanselot 9y agoI'd be shocked if CNBC discussed any news that was based on fact.
- malloryerik 9y agoYes and no, sadly. If bitcoin collapses in disgrace, many people might be biased against all things blockchain for quite some time.
- disordinary 9y agoAs a means of investment, which is never what it was intended for, but they won't care at all about underlying technology.
- panarky 9y agoYes, the longer they don't take us seriously, the farther ahead we'll be when they finally understand. Let them think cryptocurrencies are a passing fad. Let them believe they're secure in their offices and studios. The longer they believe this the better for us.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- User23 9y agoOne reason that people are working on blockchain things all over the place because money is pouring into it at an absurd rate thanks to investors' fear of missing out on the next big thing. This is not a criticism, there is nothing wrong with entrepreneurs going where the capital is.
- beefield 9y agoWell, you could argue that there is something wrong in entrepreneurs going where the capital is if the capital happens to be in a wrong place.
- marcosdumay 9y agoI would instead argue that this is a problem with the capital, not with the entrepreneurs. This is relevant because if you want to fix it, it would be completely useless to act on the entrepreneurs.
- ghostcluster 9y ago> people are working on blockchain things all over the place, relatively quietly in the background "Kodak shares have more than tripled since company announced 'KodakCoin'" https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/10/kodak-shares-have-more-than-tripled-since-announcing-kodakcoin.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/10/kodak-shares-have-more-than-... This is not the future I signed up for..
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoBut seriously there is great potential in a blockchain system that tracks intellectual property ownership in a distributed fashion.
- stuntkite 9y agoAlso verifying image authenticity in a world quickly hurtling past a the uncanny valley with turn key neural nets to fake just about any media at no cost and with no special skills.
- easytiger 9y agoAll this can be done better as a non distributed system.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoI think what might be happening here is that the traditional software development practices and habits would get on that, turning it into a project costing millions, taking years, and not doing what it promised.
- ourmandave 9y agoI think someone is doing a pump and dump at Kodak. At CES they also came out with the Kodak Kashminer. The terms are so hilariously bad it can't be real. https://twitter.com/chrisbhoffman/status/950861459302445056 https://twitter.com/chrisbhoffman/status/950861459302445056
- disordinary 9y agoThere are very few good use cases for blockchains, a lot of companies are doing things with blockchain tech that are not suited and they would be better off simply using a traditional database and APIs. But, for the right use cases it's revolutionary.
- andirk 9y agoRight. Satoshi, brought us bitcoin, but possibly more importantly, he brought blockchain in eyesight of the master branch.
- ur-whale 9y agoMainstream media tends to bundle in the term "blockchain" two separate things: 1) an append-only, verifyable, transaction log/db 2) a distributed consensus based update mechanism #1 is IMO fairly mundane and uninteresting. Unfortunately, a whole lot of the "blockchain" work happening is focusing on it. #2 is much more interesting and what will power truly interesting innovations. Sadly, it is largely under-advertized.
- lmm 9y ago10 years on there are no non-currency blockchain applications that make any sense. And even if they did exist, since the blockchain integrity guarantees only work if there is a valuable reward for "mining", a failure of blockchain-as-currency would doom non-currency blockchain applications as well.
- jupp0r 9y agoI'm not an economist, but the argument in the article seems a little constructed. There are plenty of places where cryptocurrencies can be exchanged against cash. On the other side, when did the author last try to buy a pizza with actual gold?
- withdavidli 9y agoFun fact, There are actually both gold and bitcoin backed credit/debit cards.
- empath75 9y agoMost of the bitcoin cards got cancelled.
- bendauphinee 9y agoMost of the cards from one issuer got cancelled. There are apparently still other issuers that aren't having that problem.
- richardknop 9y agoNone of them are nothing else than classic fiat debit Visa or MC cards. They just make an API call to exchange some gold or crypto for cash at point of sale. Merchant still gets paid with fiat from the "gold" card.
- jstanley 9y agoMerchant still gets paid in his local currency even when you pay with a foreign visa card. The merchant sees his favourite currency, the customer sees his favourite currency, and all the exchanging goes on behind-the-scenes. I don't see why a bitcoin or gold debit card is materially different to any other foreign debit card, from the perspective of either the merchant or the customer.
- richardknop 9y ago
- jejrjntkpou 9y agoPeople said the same thing about clay baubles with small markings impressed upon them! Oh wait...
- bitoneill 9y ago"Cryptocurrency wealth is valued in dollars, isn't that ironic?" No, it's not. I don't get his point about this.
- ajsharp 9y agoCNBC is a joke. It's the Techcrunch of financial news. Occasionally they publish something of value, but mostly it's just repurposed press releases and garbage commentary.
- finkin1 9y agoThere is no point. A paragraph later, "I understand that the entire development of this ecosystem is new, hence the need to compare it to existing forms of money. And, yes, 10 or 20 years from now, dollars may be obsolete and bitcoin could be the world's reserve currency." This article is terrible. One empty contradictory statement after another with zero actual analysis. It really is shameful this kind of thing gets published by someone who calls himself a senior analyst & commentator.
- neo4sure 9y agoThe whole point is not to be a major global fiat currency.
- ajsharp 9y agoBitcoin will never be a currency in the traditional sense, as it fails the stable store of value test, which then impairs it's ability to serve the other functions money (unit of account, medium of exchange). However, Bitcoin and other cryptos are more like investments that also happen to be massively efficient global wealth transfer systems (relative to existing methods). CNBC's crypto coverage continues to be shallow, click-baity, disappointing garbage.
- ryanfreeborn 9y ago>it fails the stable store of value test ...when compared to a handful of fiat currencies, maybe. It's not fair to gatekeep with top performers, in my opinion. There are many national currencies that lack stability. That doesn't make them "not currencies". It just makes them volatile currencies. In fact, that's precisely why Bitcoin has become so popular in those countries—particularly Latin America; Bitcoin may not be stable, but it's a more reliable store of value (for now) than the bolivar or Argentinian peso.
- rusk 9y agothat's precisely why Bitcoin has become so popular in those countries I wonder though, if this relative stability is more to do with the stake invested in it from more stable currencies like Dollar, Euro and Yen. In my head I can't get away from the idea, that beneath all the value vested in bitcoin is the actual olde worlde currencies that ultimately people need to change it back to in order to buy things.
- marcosdumay 9y ago> That doesn't make them "not currencies". When currencies experience hyperinflation, people stop using them. Even the people required to use them by law (wherever there is hyperinflation, there are always capital controls). They can still nominally be called currencies, but they are not much of anything.
- bufferoverflow 9y agoI don't think anyone ever complained about their savings appreciating in value. I had used bitcoin for years to buy things online and send money to friends/family, until the fees went nuts. Now we use other coins like ZCash and Ethereum.
- jerkstate 9y agoyeah, and Netscape isn't the dominant web browser, and I don't order pet food from pets.com, my grandma no longer uses AOL, and I don't listen to music with Napster anymore. What's the point?
- zitterbewegung 9y agoIt doesn't matter if bitcoin becomes a global currency or not. Napster never survived it was replaced with Limewire and then Bittorrent. V1 of a technology as disruptive as this doesn't necessarily survive in the end. Version 2 or Version 3 is where it gets really interesting.
- tmh88j 9y ago>V1 of a technology as disruptive as this doesn't necessarily survive in the end. Version 2 or Version 3 is where it gets really interesting. The technology that's here to stay is blockchain, the currencies associated with them are irrelevant in the grand scheme for now. I think Bitcoin has the brand recognition to hang in there for a while, but if nothing new is brought to the table with every newly introduced altcoin they're destined for failure. Even Kodak is trying to get into cryptocurrency/blockchain game. I think DRM via smart contracts is a feasible and cool concept, but no one is going to take Kodakcoin (it's a real thing) seriously unless it has liquidity and value beyond photographers. Until they can leverage atomic swaps it's going nowhere in my opinion.
- prostoalex 9y ago> The technology that's here to stay is blockchain, the currencies associated with them are irrelevant in the grand scheme for now. But blockchain's validity is validated by miners, and miners stick around because they're compensated for constructing a valid block. How does miner compensation work in the cryptocurrency-free environment, and if there are no miners, what are the guarantees that some central entity did not rewind and fork the blockchain?
- tmh88j 9y ago>How does miner compensation work in the cryptocurrency-free environment, and if there are no miners, what are the guarantees that some central entity did not rewind and fork the blockchain? You can establish whatever hypothetical situation you desire, but in the real world not all blockchain/cryptocurrencies are designed to operate the same way. Bitcoin, Ethereum and Ripple are all different approaches. They each have their own incentives and use cases, but they all sit atop blockchain.
- User23 9y agoMoney has/is currency when it is generally accepted. Bitcoin is unlikely to ever be generally accepted for various reasons. The transaction costs are too high, it's inconvenient for typical currency users, and you can't pay essential expenses such taxes in it.
- mccoyspace 9y agothe cost of transactions has stayed mostly constant when priced in bitcoin. Like the article says, why always convert back to the dollar price?
- User23 9y agoTo pay US tax obligations on BTC transactions.
- nebulous1 9y agoThe author seems to go out of his way to demonstrate that he doesn't understand how cryptocurrencies work, and half the article is somewhere between factually incorrect and misleading. It's amusing that he felt the need to demonstrate that the dollar is the more established currency. At the end he's pretty much correct though. Crypto has a long way to go before it's demonstrated to not just be a speculative bubble. I hope it gets there ... or at least I think I do.
- 4684499 9y agoBeing a major global currency is never the goal. Even if it's something people want to achieve, there are still many factors, how loose the central banks control fiat money flow is one of them.
- themagician 9y agoBitcoin has shown us exactly why centralized monetary authorities are so important, and that alone was worth it. With a decentralized currency you end up with something that is neither stable nor easily liquid, because it’s not in the interest of those who hold the most to provide either. It was an experiment worth playing out.
- nickthemagicman 9y ago*IS an experiment... It's still in the very early stages. :)
- laretluval 9y agoIt's very unclear that Bitcoin's problems are a direct result of its decentralized nature.
- dboreham 9y agoDecentralized _operation_ might be ok but decentralized management and oversight seems to have not worked out. "Market Forces" don't seem to produce good architecture.
- laretluval 9y agoAs far as I can tell the biggest problem with Bitcoin right now is the high transaction cost, which happens because it's not worth it for miners to validate transactions unless you essentially bribe them. If mining were more lucrative on its own, this wouldn't be a problem, but the reward rate for mining is hardwired. So in this case I'd say the problem isn't caused by the market but rather by the hard-coded nature of the monetary policy and the fact that there isn't a good process to change such core matters.
- disordinary 9y agoNo, the high transaction costs are because the blocks are too small. As the currency has grown in popularity the volume has increased but the blocks have not, therefore the competition to get your transaction into the block has grown and market forces means prices have increased because of it. Mining is incredibly lucrative.
- rjromero 9y agoOpinions are irrelevant. People will store the value they generate by working in any medium that offers them the most security and long-term increase of value over time. If a cryptocurrency is more secure, convenient, and less deflationary than someone's local fiat counterpart, why would they not store most of their value in it? If we go through 20 years of seeing Bitcoin outperform the inflation of a dollar, no hijackings of the blockchain, no breaking of SHA or ECDSA, why would I not store a majority of my value in it?
- numbchuckskills 9y agoThe same Oracle of Omaha who said; "I was wrong on Google and 'too dumb' to appreciate Amazon" Not exactly known for getting tech right (but right about nearly ever other industry)
- disordinary 9y agoHe's completely wrong. In his experience people talk about their value not in bitcoins but in dollars, that's because he's talking with speculators who are not interested in what decentralised and distributed ledgers mean. People who think that we're in a revolution of not just currency but also government talk about the value of their crypto in terms of bitcoins and not dollars. Bitcoin is still young and the technology is immature. What we see today is not what we're going to end up with. But, at one point the idea of separating church and state would have seemed insane, now in a big chunk of the world having any religion associated with government would be unthinkable. Likewise in the future we could look back at the dark ages where centralised authorities managed currency and manipulated it for the benefit of the few. The thing about revolutions is that people often don't see them coming.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- unabridged 9y agoIt may never overtake USD, EUR, or other majors. But it doesn't have to, even just making it to the top 10 currencies would put it into the trillions. As more country's currencies fail or get reset, bitcoin becomes that much more trustworthy.
- diego 9y agoWith all due respect to Warren Buffett, I wouldn't listen to his opinion on Bitcoin. He doesn't even pretend to understand it. Who cares if Bitcoin does or doesn't have a shot at becoming a major global currency. There is a virtually infinite variety of valuable assets of which currency is just one kind. Bitcoin is an asset, and has value. Same for many other cryptocurrencies. As long as there's a use case for cryptos (currency or something else) they will have some value. End of story.
- funkymike 9y agoThis is a genuine question. What value does bitcoin have if not as a currency? What use case is there?
- scottmf 9y agoA store of value — digital gold.
- rrobukef 9y agoBut how does it keep it's value stable? How does a store of value weather a small panic when the hope and excitement has died down? When the hodl has stopped because everybody is tired, living their lives, and using Bitcoin. Bitcoin isn't `the magical internet money' anymore, it won't stay buzzword of 20xx either. Bitcoin needs an inherent value otherwise it will crash. I always believed Bitcoin provided a service to keep it's value stable. You argue against this.
- rusk 9y agoI agree broadly with what you're saying here, but with respect to GP, you could indeed say the same thing about gold ... it's only worth the value ascribed to it in terms of "real world" things. Except that gold does have a few pretty nifty usecases based on its intrinsic properties as well, such as for jewellery and electronics. I wonder if the same could be said about BTC, in that mining is effectively digging up new prime numbers right? and prime numbers do have intrinsic value for many communications and computing applications no?
- anonu 9y agoFrom the article: > Anytime bitcoin is mentioned, it is expressed in U.S. dollar terms. So this is a bad thing? If so, we should probably expect the demise of gold and oil barrels, and pretty much anything else in the world!
- itsmegoddamnit 9y agoWhile I don't agree to the general sentiment of the article, gold and oil barrels were never really considered currency. The question becomes: is bitcoin currency or a commodity?
- 0_o 9y agoIts the first way to have a trustless, digital cash system as opposed to a digital payment system. In a payment system, people essentially exchange IOU's. Like writing a "good for $x note" or cheque. Payments always incur counter party risk, and thus can only happen among users who trust each other - or they must rely on a trusted third party (bank, paypal, credit card company etc). Bitcoin allows peer 2 peer cash settlements, where users do not need to trust each other, because there is no counter party risk since they exchange something of value. Think gold, or although that is somewhat confusing, paying with bank notes (bank notes really are IOUs, but issued by a bank or central bank, so when we use them, we consider them valuable because we trust the bank, not the person paying with them). With cash payments, you dont rely on a third party, you dont take on counter party risk, you exchange things that actually have value, that you have to be sure can not be forged. Sounds trivial, but its a really difficult thing to pull off. Even in the real world, its not easy, bank notes can be counterfeit, gold may be fake, etc. In the digital world, its even harder because you also have to make sure each coin can only be spent once (its trivial to copy data). Bitcoin was the first solution to this problem. source: https://np.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/6ufksx/am_i_the_only_one_who_believes/dlswpcr/ https://np.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/6ufksx/am_i_...
- jhwang5 9y agoWhat people confuse often that the Blockchain != Bitcoin. The concepts behind the Blockchain are certainly valuable, but to equate all that value to the value of Bitcoin itself is a logical fallacy. Folks should learn to appreciate the Blockchain separately from any cryptocurrency. We can have a world where Blockchain is widely used, but we don't use any of 1500+ coins and tokens out on coinmarketcap.com.
- beefield 9y ago> With cash payments, you dont rely on a third party, you dont take on counter party risk, you exchange things that actually have value, that you have to be sure can not be forged. Funny. To me, practically only value bitcoin and gold have is based on the trust that you find a third party tomorrow who is willing to change it to something actually valuable (actually as in actually useful in your life). So you very much rely on third parties.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoIn the early days, detractors would said Bitcoin paper doesn't make sense. Then they admitted the paper makes sense, but said there is no value of the coins. Then they admitted the coins had value, but they said only criminals would use it. Then after many established legitimate businesses adopted it, then they said it is only usable by people with computer smarts but not for average folk. Then average folk started using it and they said it is not scalable. Then all these low transaction forks and innovations like the lightning network we're coming out, and then they say, "little shot at ever being a major global currency". The bar has been constantly rasied, and the crypto currency community continues to pass it. The fact that this mainstream news article is making the high criticism that it won't be a global currency and not one of these earlier lower criticisms is evidence of success.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoMainstream news articles are making this hype train go much more faster. Feels like a bunch of PR firms are hyping bitcoin and I don't know why. I even saw another Bloomberg post that has the opposite conclusion today. Someone is ordering a bunch of submarines. (See http://paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://paulgraham.com/submarine.html )
- 34b907j 9y agoI'm guessing various holders of large sums of Bitcoin have been employing those PR firms to pump their asset.
- lalaland1125 9y ago> Then they admitted the coins had value, but they said only criminals would use it. Then after many established legitimate businesses adopted it, then they said it is only usable by people with computer smarts but not for average folk. And now many criminals and legitimate businesses are beginning to drop support for Bitcoin [1][2][3]. The crypto currency community is failing to reach pitifully low bars that were set years ago. [1] https://steamcommunity.com/games/593110/announcements/detail/1464096684955433613 https://steamcommunity.com/games/593110/announcements/detail... [2] https://btcmanager.com/end-bitcoin-debit-cards-visa-tells-card-issuer-wavecrest-close-accounts/ https://btcmanager.com/end-bitcoin-debit-cards-visa-tells-ca... [3] https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/cryptocurrency/microsoft-halts-bitcoin-transactions-because-its-an-unstable-currency/ https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/cryptocurrency/microso...
- scalablenotions 9y agoThis is laughable. Bitcoin is already a major global currency. The sixth largest by circulation.
- magwa101 9y agoTwo words 'derivatives trading'. There is no end of people willing to bet against each other. Bitcoin has great use mostly beyond US borders. "Bubble world", work grows to fill the population.
- vim_wannabe 9y agoCNBC demonstrated "how easy it is" to buy Ripple via Poloniex exchange on television. They also often have a "Ripple watch" counter on the screen displaying current worth in dollars. Also an article: https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/02/how-to-buy-ripple.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/02/how-to-buy-ripple.html
- johndough 9y agoThey skipped the step where, after trying for days due to server overload, you have to verify your coinbase account with a webcam photo of your id which will then get rejected for unknown reasons.
- tylerruby 9y agoI'm glad I'm not the only one. I lost money because of this.
- pc86 9y agoI'm still waiting for the 9 BCH they owe me for the BTC I held on 8/1. If anyone knows a good lawyer for this please let me know.
- emanreus 9y agoIndeed. Quite a few exchanges are either having serious performance issues or they completely stopped new user registrations. And good luck with the verification process. If you succeed after a month, consider yourself lucky. On the positive side the mess is a result of an enormous demand. If you had a serious exchange that's taking new users and a quick verification, you'd make a killing.
- paul7986 9y agoIt's easy? First you have to buy Ethereum then wait for it to placed into your Coinbase account. Once you own Ethereum there's a bunch of steps to buy Ripple using Ethereum.
- shepardrtc 9y ago
- jaimex2 9y agoWhen I first saw bitcoin I loved the idea because for once we had a shot at a currency government couldn't print.
- dovdovdov 9y agoyea, they have to mine it...
- rusk 9y agobut that's different. There's only a limited amount of btc you can mine, whereas currency can be printed as profligately as you like ... it's more like "gold" in that sense ...
- dullgiulio 9y agoWhat about forks and alt-coins? Aren't those just "profiligate printing"?
- rusk 9y agoInteresting point. I wouldn't say profligate since creating a new coin, and getting people to adopt it is far less trivial than printing a bundle of notes. But, I think you're right in pointing out that it is a side-channel through which more money can be "created", but in this case it's not a fiat (government) policy decision.
- dullgiulio 9y agoYes, the point being that it is (generally) easier to control a few government decision makers than exactly everyone who can make a website and start a cryptocurrency first node. There are many international institutions that check such things (IMF, or just the international money markets, etc). Basically everything that the cryptocurrency-libertarians folks keep on ignoring: turns out such problems were basically solved already.
- 9y ago
- akerro 9y agoCNBC has little shot at ever being a trustworthy news source.
- koonsolo 9y agoI see a lot of value in Bitcoin, but strangely enough, I can see that value without looking at Bitcoin at all. Confused? Let me explain the non-obvious reasons why I think Bitcoin has a fair chance. (I've been following Bitcoin since it was at $1, so I had a lot of time to think about it ;)). 1. I don't expect my kids to ever carry around wallets or keys when they are older. Everything will be in their smartphone. Passport, pictures, credit cards, VISA card, car key, key of house, etc. There is nothing there that couldn't (technically) already be in your smartphone. When doing payments, I expect them to just physically hold their phone close to some shops terminal, or when doing personal payments, send it over chat. 2. What is the value of Dollar or Euro's nowadays? (I thought a lot about this, but think to have a proper answer). The value is in the network, just the same as with Facebook. In US, every shop supports Dollars, so it has value there. In Europe, Euro's, so that has value. Same with Bitcoin, the new technology might instigated it, but in the end, it's the network of people using and supporting it that give it value. 3. The world is bigger than the industrialized countries alone. Dollar and Euro might be considered more stable than Bitcoin, but not all currencies are like that. For a recent example look at Zimbabwe. 4. (A) A bubble occurs when people think something has more value than it actually has. (B) People think the numbers on their bank account is the money they instantly have available. (C) Fraction reserve banking multiplies money so that the number on your bank are not actually money that is available instantly. 5. Which do you trust more: (A) governments and banks or (B) math and algorithms? 6. A global currency would be very convenient for people who travel a lot. Of course, there are still a lot of questions too. 1. How will government legislation treat cryptocurrencies in the future? 2. Will some cryptocurrency ever have a stable enough price (such as gold), so that goods can be expressed in it? 3. Will some app make it simple/easy/convenient enough and have a big enough network so all people can agree on starting to use it for making and receiving payments? 4. Will lightning network and/or sidechains be enough and a good solution for the limited payments per second? Final conclusion: In the end, it will all come to which payment system will have the network. If people want to get payed in Dollars because everybody else works with Dollars, that will have the network. If people want to get payed in Bitcoin because everybody else works with Bitcoin, that will have the network. Is Dollar/Euros Facebook, or is it MySpace? Who can tell? I think nobody at this point. But it is fair to say that fiat money might be Goliath and crypto might be David. Only time will tell.
- luka-birsa 9y agoI love this article. It just shows how mainstream is still clueless about Bitcoin. Dolar denominated trades? (All but the largest are denominated in BTC or ETH on any serious exchange) So small its insignificant? (Yeah, exactly like when it was 10M marketcap beginning 2017) This is the best indicator tgat the bubble is nowhere near its bursting point. Worry the day when CNBC starts talking about paradigm shift.
- shusson 9y agoI'm worried because family and friends of mine who are not tech oriented at all, are buying bitcoin as investments. They are my canary in the coal mine.
- himlion 9y agoSame here, a lot of my non tech friends are trading cryptocurrency parroting the technobabble in the ICO whitepapers without any understanding of the technical basics.
- andruby 9y agoYup. I've got the same canary dying at this point. Work colleagues are asking me "which crypto" they should buy. 4 years ago, when btc hit $1000, it was my uncle who asked me to buy a couple. A few months later it dropped to $300. Crypto currencies feel a lot more mainstream this time around. It makes me worried that a crash could actually impact the "real" (as in non-crypto) economy.
- flatfilefan 9y agoDid he ask you to sell those couple B at $20000 recently? Well, even if he did not then, selling at $13000 now isn't that bad either.
- lagadu 9y agoIn your uncle's defense, buying bitcoin at $1000 turned out to be a huge bargain.
- jondubois 9y agoI think that cryptocurrency will take over eventually. There might be big booms and busts in the meantime but it will take over. For many people, cryptocurrency has become an ideology so they will keep buying back every time it drops.
- onion2k 9y agoI think that cryptocurrency will take over eventually. It's likely that cryptocurrency won't be Bitcoin though.
- akerro 9y agoNo, because it will be at least 40 cryptocurrencies and BTC in that group.
- TillE 9y agoThat's the state of the world now. Long term, if cryptocurrencies are to be genuinely useful and pervasive, it will probably be exactly one that nails all the design issues and captures 99% of the market.
- onion2k 9y agoI don't think that's true. A cryptocurrency can be optimised, so there'd be currencies for fast and cheap transaction validation (like raiblocks), currencies for more secure transactions (ethereum?), currencies that are strongly private (mimblewimble), and so on. There's likely to be more than one of each 'type' as popularity of a coin will ebb and flow. We'll see lots of them come and go. I don't think Bitcoin is really optimised for anything. It's a brilliant and successful proof of concept, but there are too many flaws compared to other coins for it not to be surpassed. I used to think it could hang on as a base currency that people transfer money between other currencies, but that'd be horribly inefficient and probably unnecessary so I don't think so now. Eventually its price will plateau as people actually start to use cryptocurrencies rather than speculate, and then it'll die. All entirely speculation on my part though, obvs. I don't hold any currencies so it makes no difference to me really.
- bengrunfeld 9y agoAs I see it, the major issue that Blockchain based technologies face is their scaling problem: they max out at about 2-7 transactions per second. Sure this can be increased by changing block size, but not that significantly. Fred Ehrsam discusses this in his article (below). https://medium.com/@FEhrsam/scaling-ethereum-to-billions-of-users-f37d9f487db1 https://medium.com/@FEhrsam/scaling-ethereum-to-billions-of-... Essentially, no matter how much we yell "We'll win!", cryptos won't be able to be adopted by the masses until this bottleneck has been alleviated - if that is even possible. That means that CNBC is correct, and this is simply a ridonkulous bubble. And trust me, I hate admitting that. Also: https://blockgeeks.com/guides/blockchain-scalability/ https://blockgeeks.com/guides/blockchain-scalability/
- creo 9y agoI love how it states in the list: "Anytime bitcoin is mentioned, it is expressed in U.S. dollar terms." So ignorant. Do they even read articles in other languages (ex. Chinese), or just assume that universe orbits around US?
- romanovcode 9y agoAssume, because otherwise they would realise how wrong this sentence would be.
- tim333 9y agoIn some ways it's already a significant currency. Just yesterday I changed euros to btc to buy some shares in Kucoin and used btc very much like I'd use US dollars to say buy shares in eTrade. Fair enough it's rubbish for buying a cup of coffee but btc and etherium are the standard currencies for crypto trading. And that's not a small market - $50bn was traded in the last 24hrs according to coinmarketcap.
- joekrill 9y agoTo me, it's not "very much like [you'd] use US dollars" at all. You didn't actually buy anything, did you? You used it to trade more bitcoins. I mean, if people were just pushing around dollars, exchanging them with each other, and not purchasing actual goods and services with them, then maybe it would be the same. On the other hand, my knowledge of all this is pretty superficial. But the one thing that sticks with me that the naysayers keep bringing up is just that: no one (or very, very few) is actually using bitcoins in any useful way other than trading them with other bitcoins.
- tim333 9y agoI bought some Kucoin Shares (KCS) (https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/kucoin-shares/ https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/kucoin-shares/) which actually pay a dividend (in other cryptos) which should be 15% of the Kucoin exchange's trade fees. It doesn't seem so different from buying shares in eTrade which will hopefully pay some dividends in USD paid out of the profits from their trading fees. KCS are a little unusual in paying dividends but the whole crypto markets I think are moving towards being more like traditional financial markets. At the moment it's just shares in a business trading crypto but in the future I could see maybe shares in a business doing more normal things.
- joekrill 9y agoMaybe I'm misunderstanding what Kucoin Shares are. Are they not just shares in other bitcoin markets? It looks to me like it's just a "currency exchange", really. Or are you actually buying shares in some underlying company that provides value? If it's the latter, then sure, it's like buying shares on eTrade. But if there's no underlying company or product you're investing in, then I don't seem them as being similar at all.
- jondubois 9y agoMaybe everything is in an economic bubble right now. If you work in a big city and look around; there are tall office buildings everywhere; packed with millions of people. But what do these people actually do? Is that an efficient use of their time in terms of creating value for each other? Maybe cryptocurrency is a bubble, but maybe also everything else is a bubble. Companies like Snapchat are worth billions of dollars, but they lose billions of dollars each year. At least most cryptocurrencies don't lose money (except some of them due to electricity costs). Even companies like Facebook which are themselves profitable are deriving most of their profits by providing services to companies that are unprofitable. Maybe the total value of all cryptocurrencies isn't actually going up, maybe it's the value of everything else around it that's hyperinflating. Maybe the current system is just begging to be dismantled.
- realPubkey 9y ago'But what do these people actually do?' Awesome. Thats exactly what is in my head for so long. I myself go to one of these offices, and yes I do sh1t which produces no value, only money for my company. We get paid by another company doing sh1t. I spend half my live learning to code. And now I code shitty forms and buttons which will get thrown away and replaced in 5 years by the next guy doing the same.
- teekert 9y agoThat's pretty negative. If someone is willing to pay you money, by definition your work has value for someone. Keep in mind that value is subjective. Creating anti AIDS medicine would probably be considered work of value by you? But it's not to me, at least not now.
- realPubkey 9y agoI don't know. If you pay Sisyphos to roll a stone uphill once a day, does he create value just because you pay him doing it? My definition of value may be opinionated, but recreating the same software again and again, based on an outdated stack and thrown into garbage has no value for me. Maybe it's different somewhere else. But where I live most coders do exactly this.
- tobiaswk 9y agoBitcoin is currently not what Bitcoin was when it was created. Slow peer-to-peer transactions and high processing fees. Average fees are hovering around 60 dollars. That's an average. Unconfirmed transactions has been at over 100k for months. The mempool is also hovering around an ATH. The Bitcoin is crippled. Sentences like "store of value" are now the term used to describe Bitcoin. Very far from what the Bitcoin used to be. I think there is a real possibility of a "death spiral of the blockchain". Fees will increase and it will become impossible to move coins on the blockchain besides the upper 10% of bitcoin holders. For traders on exchanges bitcoin seems fast; because no transactions are taking place. When you actually decide to move your bitcoins to a wallet you own you'll pay high fees... if not your transaction could take months to clear or never actually clear. The fork that occurred on 1st August created Bitcoin Cash. This fork is much closer to what the Bitcoin was. Bitcoin Cash is this today. Removal of the segwit code (which hasn't solved anything), disabling of RBF (replace-by-fee) enabling 0-confirmation transactions again. A new DAA (difficulty adjustment algorithm). Finally increase the block size to 8MiB. The Bitcoin has been crippled on purpose by Blockstream deep in the pockets of bankers and insurance companies. Blockstream is the main contributor to the Bitcoin development. Look at the sponsors; https://www.blockstream.com/about/#investors https://www.blockstream.com/about/#investors Before the bankers, and their followers, got indirectly involved in Bitcoin development there never was any discussion about limiting the block size to 1MiB; in fact the opposite was discussed. See; https://twitter.com/adam3us/status/636410827969421312?lang=e... https://twitter.com/adam3us/status/636410827969421312?lang=e.... https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1314.msg15143#msg151... https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1314.msg15143#msg151.... https://np.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/71h884/pieter_wuille_im... https://np.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/71h884/pieter_wuille_im.... Now all of this has led to a complete divide and clusterfuck of the community. It is an very ugly and toxic environment and is sad to look at. On top of that we now have thousands of alternative coins and blockchains. The current version of bitcoin is crippled and completely unusable as a currency as is.
- makomk 9y agoThat's the Bitcoin Cash spin, which gets a fair amount of play given that one of its backers is wealthy enough to own or have investments in a lot of Bitcoin-related businesses and websites. The trouble is that it's not true. Transaction replacement is so much a part of what Bitcoin was intended to be that Satoshi included a 32-bit field in every single transaction solely to provide ordering for replacements. (It was disabled only because the original design let people spam the network with unlimited replacements for free, which was later fixed by requiring replacements pay higher fees.) If you want to accept 0-conf transactions, you just have to check they're not marked replaceable - and the way you check is the same as in Satoshi's day. What does break 0-conf transactions is the transaction malleability problem that Segwit was designed to fix. It's not safe to accept 0-conf transactions from people you trust entirely, or even from yourself, because third parties can invalidate them by malleating the transactions they depend on. This majorly broke outgoing payments from some Bitcoin Cash exchanges shortly after the fork and required manual intervention to fix. Satoshi's original code was even less able to cope with malleability; it got completely confused and wallet transactions tended to get permanently stuck. Also, the new difficulty adjustment algorithm in the 1st of August fork was terribly broken. It had a design flaw that allowed miners to repeatedly drive difficulty down much lower than it should be in a relatively short period of time, then mine large numbers of blocks at the lower difficulty, creating new Bitcoin Cash at a much more rapid rate than intended. Not only that, but during the drive-down phase blocks took hours to mine, making the network almost unusable a large chunk of the time. That's why exchanges resorted to using change from unconfirmed withdrawals as inputs to subsequent withdrawals, causing chaos when someone exploited malleability. It's also why supporters were so keen on promoting 0-conf transactions as safe. On, and the tweet you're pointing to as proof that there was no discussion of limiting the block size until the evil Blockstream got involved was written by one of the key employees and co-founders of Blockstream after he founded it. Meanwhile, the most ardently small-block of the core devs is Luke Jr who's very conspicuously refused to work for them in order to preserve his independence.
- sureaboutthis 9y agoMy nephew works at [insert very large financial institution here]. He's been telling me for a long time that bitcoin is already dead. Financial institutions are already working on their own crypto-currency and, in two years, no one will hear of bitcoin again.
- tczer 9y agoIs that the new "my uncle works at Nintendo" ?
- 110011 9y agoIt is not a currency today, just a source of endless speculation that is bound to end badly for many. Let's not forget that above all it's just a horribly inefficient way to trade value. I suppose all the people who think Bitcoin is bs just wait and watch this ponzi scheme unfold while the others who have invested in it heavily defend each such article in the comments here. Unless people solve the engineering problems underlying its inefficiencies there is absolutely zero chance it will become a currency, let alone a global one.
- wslh 9y agoSince 2008, I personally know much more millionaires from the cryptoeconomy than from startups. Which makes me reorder the average guy lucky taxonomy from the luckiest "gambling" in descending order: 1/ Lottery 2/ Founding startups 3/ Working in startups (this item is from YC Startup School 2017 Episode 1) 4/ Cryptoeconomy 5/ Just working in the IT field in a place with high salaries, and saving/investing the money.
- charls_Aws 9y agoI rem that YC startup school lecture], I guess what the speaker missed out was that it also takes a lot of skill or luck to actually figure out which startup to work in. Each of these startups claim to be rocketships but in reality, only maybe a 1% of these ships even take off the ground. I personally know a few friends who have wasted their prime years working in startups which never took off.
- wslh 9y ago> I guess what the speaker missed out was that it also takes a lot of skill or luck to actually figure out which startup to work in. That is true in the first stages but it is easier to predict it later on. For example, Microsoft created a lot of millionaires at later stages.
- siculars 9y agoAnd so did google and Facebook and amazon. But the trick is that as an employee you had to be there relatively early on (within a few years) or you missed the boat. If you join one of these places now you’ll get a good salary and bonuses and stocks but it will take years to save a mil or two.
- montrose 9y agoYou could agree with this title and still want to buy bitcoin, because even if it were true that bitcoin has little shot at ever being a major global currency, the expected value of owning it could still be higher than the current price. If bitcoin became a major global currency its value could easily be 100x what it is now, which means there only has to be a 1% chance of that happening for it to be worth buying.
- ThomPete 9y agoWhy do people keep thinking about bitcoin as a currency? It was its original intent but these days it's more seen as gold. The value of the bitcoin is the money invested in it that alone can be used for something where the need for transactions aren't high, as an example for large international contracts. I don't know anyone with just the slightest understanding of bitcoin who believe it's a currency anymore.
- czechdeveloper 9y agoPeople bought gold because it's historical stability. People buy Bitcoin because of it's volatility and crazy growth. Gold could survive wars, you can pack small fortune to take on person, it's recognized by everyone. I just don't see how Bitcoin fits the picture here.
- jrsks 9y ago> Gold could survive wars, you can pack small fortune to take on person, it's recognized by everyone. That's a lot to carry when you could just take your brain wallet with you.
- ThomPete 9y agoYou try and buy a shirt in H&M for your gold. People mined gold because it was very valuable, gold have also been doing it's ups and downs the same have currencies historically (before the central banks). Bitcoin is gold for the digital space. Bitcoin can survive any one company or institution going down it can survive wars too. Bitcoin is 9 years old gold is thousands. Golds value could easily go to zero in the future. Most bitcoins are in the hands of people who didn't buy beause of it's growth but because they believe it ads value to the digital space.
- dagaci 9y ago3 Crypto Problems: #1 - Bitcoin. And Bitcoin's #1 problem is the 1MB limit. I expect none of the bitcoin developers (except Satoshi of course) anticipated that people would actually try to use it already (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tongue-in-cheek https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tongue-in-cheek). The Noobs have been unceremoniously walked into that "slow and expensive" wall this winter and they are bitter. #2 - The general immaturity of the "leadership": https://www.reddit.com/r/vergecurrency/comments/7mamgt/xvg_whale_discussing_meeting_verge_creator/ https://www.reddit.com/r/vergecurrency/comments/7mamgt/xvg_w... https://www.cnbc.com/2017/12/20/bitcoin-jesus-says-investors-should-be-ready-in-case-bitcoin-falls-out-of-favor.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/12/20/bitcoin-jesus-says-investors... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UTbgbePa1XQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UTbgbePa1XQ http://fortune.com/2018/01/08/coinmarketcap-removes-korean-exchange-prices/ http://fortune.com/2018/01/08/coinmarketcap-removes-korean-e... #3 - China https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-01-09/how-china-s-stifling-bitcoin-and-cryptocurrencies-quicktake-q-a https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-01-09/how-china...
- snarfy 9y agoMost of the value of the US Dollar comes from international treaties that require barrels of oil to be sold in dollars. This gives the dollar an intrinsic, positive energy value, backed by the military. Contrast that with Bitcoin which has a negative energy value. There are no treaties requiring oil to be sold in Bitcoin. Energy is what is scarce, has real value, and what drives the economy. At some point in the future, after the hype has died, it won't be worth the energy to mine bitcoin.
- Retric 9y agoOil has almost nothing to due with the value of USD. People need to pay a few trillion dollars in US taxes every year based on the size of the US economy. If the dollar was worth 1/10 as much they would then need to pay 10x as many dollars in taxes because people pay taxes as a percentage of value creation not simply arbitrary units. On top of that people who want US goods like movies need USD to buy them. Further, US companies foreign profits need to be converted back to USD to pay out dividends. Apple may sell a Chinese made iPad in China, but the profit needs to be converted to USD.
- kuschku 9y agoOil and international transactions has everything to do with the power of the USD. There are more transactions, and of larger volume, and more savings between EU citizen than between US citizen. Yet, the EUR is only ~20% of global currency volume, and over 60% is in USD. That is all due to international transactions.
- Retric 9y agoTrading volume has little to do with a currency's power. To be a medium of exchange something needs to have value. Euro's are unstable due to polical issues, but the EU's economy is why it has any value in the first place. Now this has and will change over time, but it's really stability not military power that backs the adoption of USD's.
- xdeqx366 9y ago
- Lower456 9y agoI feel these are some articles written to get some traffic in which they are successful. Apart from that if anything i have learned by invsting in crypto is nobody is an expert, everything is an opinion.
- mathgenius 9y agoBut ripple (xrp) does. It may only be a slim chance, but it is real. It could be the first currency (like the euro, yen, swiss franc, etc.) backed by a private company. But unlike the sovereign currencies, xrp is totally transparent. No cooking the books like the banks have been caught doing with the LIBOR rates.
- ethics_gradient 9y agoCooking the books with libor? What does cooking the books mean?
- soundwave106 9y agoBankers colluding to keep the LIBOR rates fixed at preferential values. The LIBOR rate is in theory merely an indicator of the average of interest rates estimated by the leading banks in London, that they would charge to borrow from other banks. In practice, this rate has significant impacts downstream, since it affects many other loan / savings accounts / etc. rates. So the fact that this rate was manipulated, not a true reflection, ended up being A Very Big Deal. An article about it from the Economist: http://www.economist.com/node/21558281 http://www.economist.com/node/21558281
- shepardrtc 9y agoI don't know if Ripple will truly become a currency like USD. But I think it will be adopted by companies as a way to facilitate easier movement of government-backed currencies, which will give it a value all its own. So perhaps more of a happy medium.
- craigc 9y agoThis article is probably true but this is just typical clickbait from CNBC. The author begins by saying > Admittedly I'm green with envy for failing to foresee the explosive rally in the price of bitcoin when it was first brought to my attention several years ago. That should be enough to stop reading right there. I don’t know how articles like this make it to the top of hacker news. Just because Warren Buffet doesn’t think crypto currencies don’t have a future doesn’t mean they don’t. He also still uses a flip phone, and didn’t invest in tech stocks at all until recently. He admitted to not understanding crypto currencies at all. Also the dollar as reserve currency is the weakest argument I can think of as to why Bitcoin can’t be a global currency. I personally trade crypto from time to time, and I care much much more about the Bitcoin (satoshi) value of my portfolio than the dollar value. In the crypto world, Bitcoin IS the reserve currency. Most other tokens trade vs. it. It’s not that insane to imagine a world where people’s net worth are expressed as a number of Bitcoin. Do I think that is likely? No, but it is certainly a possibility. Just because CNBC and other mainstream media outlets use dollars to explain net worth “Winklevoss twins are first Bitcoin billionaires” that has less to do with Bitcoin as a currency and much more to do with explaining things in a way that is easy for regular people to understand.
- siculars 9y agoThis. Exactly this. I’ve been an investor in BTC and trading crypto on multiple exchanges for years. BTC is -the- reserve currency of crypto. It is the currency all other crypto is denominated in. BTC will exist long after many of the anchors and writers on CNBC have retired.
- tinus_hn 9y agoIt already is a global currency. It isn’t very useful but neither are bulk amounts of gold.
- nippples 9y agoMost of the stuff I read about Bitcoin seems to be articles trying to make something positive or negative happen to it, rather than accurately describing what's happening with Bitcoin.
- ppbutt 9y agoThis is one of the most poorly written articles I've ever seen.
- xori 9y agoI don't know, right now it's easier for me to purchase BTC than for me to purchase ¥ or € online. If treated as a foreign currency and not a future, I think it has promise.
- mmcnl 9y agoWhy does Bitcoin need to become a major global currency? Even if were to attain a 0.01% global market share (very minor) that would still be a huge achievement.