9 ms·
The cryptocurrency bubble is strangling innovation?
- rasengan 9y agoI think people will come up with good sharding and safe off chain solutions to mitigate transaction speed latency. I think the bubble actually incentivizes that.
- realusername 9y agoI think it already started in that direction with the next-generation of currencies like Raiblocks and IOTA. You will probably have currencies which will iterate on top of that in the future to improve it even more.
- malux85 9y agoWe have this with our "Hybrid nodes" they are doing exactly that - compensating for the chain weaknesses until the technology catches up, and we have systems in place to easily migrate this functionality on-chain so that we're ready ahead of time
- xur17 9y agoAre there specific projects that are using hybrid nodes? I'm curious to read more about this.
- wyldfire 9y agoThere's delegated proof of stake coins that have better scalability. Raiblocks doesn't have contention over a single blockchain and gets much better throughput and latency. "Lightning Network" will really help the PoW coins too.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Beltiras 9y agoThere's a lot of infrastructure out there to come up with a solution to these problems. Someone will and get very very rich off it.
- thisisit 9y ago> It remains an open question whether even much, much lower fees would be viable in the long run. The problem is not fees rather usability. If today I speak to a layman about bitcoin he is confused. It doesn't help that people start talking about hardware wallets, multisigs, Segwit etc. Most of those guys find that using cryptocurrency is a pain and want to stick to real money. Yes, it doesn't stop them from speculating by putting some money in these coins. One thing has to be noted, while there is a constant parallel drawn with dot com people forget that there was at least 7-8 years head start for a layman to understand "internet". There has been no run up here, things have just exploded.
- acdha 9y ago> One thing has to be noted, while there is a constant parallel drawn with dot com people forget that there was at least 7-8 years head start for a layman to understand "internet". Bitcoin has been around for 8 years so it's not like there hasn't been enough time. The difference is that the internet was easy to explain to people because it had a number of immediately useful applications: you could almost immediately send email, read the news or stream audio content (by 1995), lookup stock information and place trades, download software, buy things, chat, find a date or adult content, etc. — in most cases things people had been able to do starting at some point in the late 1970s using online services like CompuServ or bulletin boards, only easier and cheaper. Most of these were also easy to explain because they had familiar analogues: buying a book or CD online in the early 90s was immediately familiar — it's like buying from a catalog except that you don't have the delays receiving the catalog and mailing or phoning in your order. The difference is that Bitcoin doesn't solve a problem which the average person has. To the average person it sounds like using a credit card except that most places don't take it, the fees are orders of magnitude higher, and there's no fraud protection. How many people have a legal reason to prefer it other than paying ransomware or speculating on its price?
- viggity 9y agoDoesn't solve a problem that average american has right now. The key feature of crypto currency (to me) has always been that it can't be easily manipulated by a government. Specifically with bitcoin, were it not so expensive and have such high fees, it could be of real use in countries with hyperinflation and black markets (Venezuela, Zimbabwe, etc). Hopefully bitcoin and the myriad of alt-coins can fill the gap. Once it takes a foothold in a failed state, I can only imagine it spreading. I hope that hyperinflation and/or economic collapse don't come to America/Western Europe. But i'm not so naive to think that it can't.
- alistproducer2 9y agoDapps can be awesome when you want to avoid counter-party risk. Ether Delta is a great example; however, it's super expensive to use ED (every interaction costs $0.80-$1.60) and unless you're playing with a lot of money it's cost prohibitive to use. Even though they had the dns hijacking a while ago, you can still access the market via direct calls to the contract. When it's time to liquidate a large alt holding back into ETH, ED is the only place I trust because I don't have to trust anyone.
- paxpelus 9y agoYou may want to have a look on Etherdelta Guard Chrome Extension (FYI: I built it). I open sourced it https://github.com/paxpelus/etherdelta-guard https://github.com/paxpelus/etherdelta-guard and you can download the plugin here https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/etherdelta/beeeoaadbehhmejefhdbhgmhgfnogiij https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/etherdelta/beeeoaa... When etherdelta deploys - they call a script of mine that calculates the md5 of their files in github and creates automatically a new version in Chrome Web Store. I use my plugin whenever I visit etherdelta so I can be sure that their deployed version matches the one on github.com
- alistproducer2 9y agoNice work.
- Tepix 9y agoIs there an alternative frontend for etherdelta when the website is once again overloaded? Also are open orders only stored on the website?
- paxpelus 9y agoOpen orders are actually transactions that have been made to the smart contract. It is possible to monitor the smart contract and get informed on all the open orders. You may want to have a look on Etherdelta API if you don't want to use directly the smart contract. https://github.com/etherdelta/etherdelta.github.io/blob/master/docs/API.md https://github.com/etherdelta/etherdelta.github.io/blob/mast...
- prophesi 9y agoIt's a bit odd that the articles focuses entirely on Etherium. You can just build your Dapp on a different blockchain with smart contract support, that hopefully addresses the issues Etherium currently suffers from. And, blockchain innovation isn't just Dapps. There are likely many markets that would benefit from several aspects of blockchain technologies that we've yet to come up with.
- fortythirteen 9y agoMore than anything, the cost to transact with Bitcoin or Etherium (which this article weirdly focuses on), stagnates mainstream adoption. Sure, I could create my own coin to use as an in-app currency for my project, but why? A coin is only worth what you can buy with it, and nobody is going to sell anything worthwhile with some random, in-app coin. Even Bitcoin was just abandoned by Microsoft, because it's so overpriced you'd have to be insane to trade anything for it other than high-risk investment cash. Until this bonkers hype cycle gets to the peak of productivity, the blockchain has no real world purpose other than as a shared database.
- cantrip 9y agoI don't think it's weird to focus on Ethereum as, as the article correctly states, most new currencies are not a separate chain themselves but are simply tokens on the Ethereum blockchain. Ethereum is also the only blockchain with a real developer community, and the article focuses on building applications. Microsoft didn't abandon Bitcoin because it was overpriced, they abandoned it because it was volatile. One could argue that a blockchain's only real world purpose is as a shared database, just as http's only real world purpose is the transfer of data between computers.
- fortythirteen 9y ago> Microsoft didn't abandon Bitcoin because it was overpriced, they abandoned it because it was volatile. It was "volatile" when they adopted it. It's now volatile and overpriced. If MS thought that Bitcoin was a good investment, volatile or not, they would have stuck with it. "Volatile" is acting as an excuse for their real sentiment, that it's time to short Bitcoin.
- cantrip 9y agoYou don't generally hold onto Bitcoin when you take it as payment, you sell it immediately, so no, Microsoft was not "investing" in Bitcoin by taking it as a payment for their products and they're not shorting Bitcoin either. The volatility is what makes it untenable as payment, as you can't sell it fast enough to ensure that you get the same exchange rate you gave to the customer.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dragontamer 9y agoNo? Because before cryptocurrency, dumb money was in dumb apps like "Yo". The problem isn't cryptocurrency or fads. Its stupid investors spending money on stupid things. I mean, its fine, its their money and all. But obviously, if investors spent the money on more useful things, it'd be better innovation for everyone (and those investors would surely get better returns). At the moment, we're in an "everything bubble" and people just don't know what to put their money into. Bonds have low yields, the stock market has a dangerously high P/E ratio, and everything in venture capitalism has the word blockchain in it (even Hooters and Long Island Ice Tea). I'm sure there are some smart investors out there who have figured out what is truly useful, but like the old rule says: 90% of everything is crap. And that includes investments...
- overcast 9y agoPeople aren't investing in cryptocurrency, I don't care what /r/bitcoin has to say about it. People are speculating in hopes of making a lot of money off of a bigger fool.
- dragontamer 9y ago> People aren't investing in cryptocurrency http://money.cnn.com/2017/12/21/investing/long-island-iced-tea-bitcoin-blockchain/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2017/12/21/investing/long-island-iced-t... Erm, yes they are. And they're doing it in roughly the stupided manner possible. There's a ton of people who literally hear the word "blockchain" and then just throw money at it. That's why these no-name penny stocks go up 200%+ when they change their Facebook page to include the words "blockchain", even if it makes no freaking sense.
- overcast 9y agoNone of those people are going long term, which is what I consider investing. They are looking for quick money.
- brndnmtthws 9y agoAlternative perspective: maybe cryptocurrencies are valuable and represent real innovation?
- tqkxzugoaupvwqr 9y agoCounterpoint: “Dogecoin, a parody cryptocurrency, just broke $2B for its market cap” although development stopped two years ago. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16096119 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16096119
- pavel_lishin 9y agoGoatse cryptocurrency.
- bobcostas55 9y agoIf you visit the original goatse domain, you will find exactly that. "Meme creation on the blockchain", it says.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoRight, I wasn't making a joke, I was saying that Dogecoin isn't the most ridiculous example
- leoc 9y agoI'm not sure to what extent doge was ever really a parody, even if it was started as a lark then marketed as zany and relatable. And for a number of years it's been shepherded by a small group of devs who seem to be competent and diligent, and exceptionally up-front and down-to-earth by cryptocurrency standards. (Disclaimer: I know one of them personally. Additional disclaimer: this isn't anything resembling financial advice.) I don't know much about cryptocurrencies, but afaik doge's fairly low transaction fees and continued strong commitment to be inflationary may also justify some of the interest. https://www.reddit.com/r/dogecoin/comments/7oxi53/developer_brain_dump_incoming/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dogecoin/comments/7oxi53/developer_... > I feel some are using our rise to illustrate the absurdity of cryptocurrency pricing (http://uk.businessinsider.com/dogecoin-cryptocurrency-has-market-cap-above-2-billion-2018-1 http://uk.businessinsider.com/dogecoin-cryptocurrency-has-ma... for example). To me, in an environment where a cryptoasset with $30 USD equivalent transaction fees has a market cap of over a quarter of trillion dollars, I don't think we're the absurd one. Yes we take ourselves less seriously, but that doesn't mean we're not serious behind the scenes. We're a 4 year old currency with transaction fees barely over a cent and significantly higher throughput than most other cryptocurrencies. EDIT: Ross has asked me to point out the continuing development at https://github.com/dogecoin/dogecoin/pulls https://github.com/dogecoin/dogecoin/pulls . Version 1.14 is apparently on its way.
- api 9y agoThere's another issue that I don't see mentioned much here. I was contemplating writing a blog post about it. Over the past year I've seen a serious decline in early stage angel investment. I've talked to a lot of people who have said similar things. What I've heard and in some cases observed is that it's all going to crypto. All the people who would be making speculative angel investments are now buying into cryptocurrency coins and ICOs in the hopes of riding the bubble. This is really awful for two reasons: (1) Few if any of these ICO systems have any utility at all, while many early stage startups end up creating things of actual value. It represents a shift in investment from value creation to pure speculation. (2) When -- not if, but when -- this bubble pops, a lot of that wealth that could have been used to fund angel investment will be vaporized. Yes most startups fail but at least angel funding tends to support attempts at value creation. In this case we're losing tons of money to support nothing but the burning of coal to heat the atmosphere. Everything else this article says is spot on-- any value that could be present in cryptocurrency is being harmed by its relentless appreciation. Hyper-deflation is not a desirable characteristic in a currency. I lived through the dot.com bubble and that one was much less vapid. Even though many startups were over-funded and speculation ran the stock market into crazy land, a lot of actual value did get created. In this case I see almost none. This whole thing feel like a reductio ad absurdium of financial capitalism, which ironically is the system Bitcoin was created to replace.
- adventured 9y agoIf history is any guide, and it usually is within reason, the crypto bubble is nearly over. When you start seeing people like the Ripple CEO showing up near the top of the global rich list overnight (for something that currently has almost no economic utilization), the zenith of the mania is approaching. The dotcom bubble only lasted 2.5-3 years. Most of the housing bubble's value inflation happened in 3-4 years.
- jboggan 9y agoThis is what I thought the article would be about. There are people in my circle who would be angel investors but all they want to talk about instead are which altcoins are likely to moon in the next month. It's a difficult early stage environment because even a "sure thing" in the next Google doesn't offer the return that a pumped cryptocoin can offer, and immediately! I hope this bubble unwinds itself sooner rather than later, before too much damage is done.
- Robotbeat 9y agoReading the original Satoshi paper, the point of Bitcoin is to be decentralized/trustless and to enable microtransactions by lowering transaction fees. Both these goals seem to have failed in practice, the latter spectacularly (although other cryptocurrencies have done better in this regard). To truly be trustless, you can't generate keys/addresses on some website like bitaddress or use some other online wallet, as you're clearly trusting bitaddress to not be copying your key (and/or have the ability to fully and carefully audit their code... few people have this capability and even fewer have the patience to do so). You have to do something like this: generate them offline using a computer which can never communicate with the Internet after you use it. And you need to do it at least twice with two completely different implementations to ensure your public and private key truly match. In practicality, I have to send a picture of my ID to some third party exchange in order to use it. REALLY? Why don't I just use PayPal? In practicality, Bitcoin is only /ritually/ trustless and decentralized. And it's worthless for microtransactions. (Etherium is better, but not perfect.) I really do think the whole industry has become too enamored with the cloud and with centralization, but these steps toward decentralization seem self-defeating as they rely on (centralized!) apps from a centralized appstore in practice. Might as well trust PayPal or Apple or whoever. Or even just a regular bank. Or even better, a credit union that you, as an account holder, have voting power over. If I'm using Windows, I trust Microsoft. If I'm using Ubuntu, I trust Canonical. If I use Android or Chrome, I trust Google. If I use iOS, I trust Apple. On some level, I also trust Intel and/or AMD and/or NVidia and my chipset provider, too. Trustlessness only exists in theory (and even then, only with certain assumptions--like a distributed mining pool or stake that hasn't become centralized), and you can make a good case that in practicality cryptocurrencies actually INCREASE your trust attack surface area. It all starts looking like a lot of overhead for transactions.
- adventured 9y ago> Both these goals seem to have failed in practice, the latter spectacularly That will stop being the case once people stop treating all the coins as investment speculations. That won't occur until the bubble pops. After that, with the typical trauma that goes with it due to financial losses, it will become almost impossible to convince people to plow large amounts of money into inflating a given coin (as in the case of so many of the lesser crypto-coins that are seeing musical chair speculation booms). The speculation on a stray coin to moonshot next, is no different than the speculation on which beanie baby will soar next circa 1998/99. Once the bubble gave way, you could no longer convince anyone that they all should be worth large sums, or that the musical chairs of inflating one beanie baby to the next should continue. It's classic group hysteria and it tends to reverse violently. Once that occurs, you'll find the exact opposite problem more common: nobody will want to bother wasting any money on nearly any coins, in any regard (whether for transactions or sheer speculation). Group think will shift to nearly all coins as being worthless, as they actually are.
- KasianFranks 9y agoQuite the opposite.
- 659087 9y agoDepends on what kind of innovation you're talking about. If we're talking about blatant internet-based scams and cash grabs, for example, ICOs have fueled lots of innovation in that sector.
- api 9y agoThat's yet another nasty thing about this-- namely the amount of money scammers, con artists, and the mob are making off this bubble. That money is going to go to fund a lot of not-so-good things in coming years.
- leroy_masochist 9y ago> Look at the dot-com boom. A lot of people lost a whole lot of paper money, but it brought us a cheap worldwide fiber backbone and companies like Amazon and Google. If the point the author is trying to make is that Amazon and Google were made possible by the dotcom boom, and that the collapse of the dotcom bubble was part of the price we as a society had to pay to have the services provided these companies, that's a really really bad argument. Amazon was founded in 1995 and IPO'ed in 1997, before the IPO market got crazy. Google was founded in 1997 and IPO'ed in 2004 when tech stocks were still a punchline. Neither of these companies is an example of any kind of silver lining for your Uncle Bob losing thousand of bucks after buying into a rapidly appreciating security (or currency) whose underlying value he does not understand whatsoever.
- qaq 9y agoGoogle bought a ton of dark fiber for cents on the dollar. So the bust did enable Google to develop much more rapidly and with much smaller $ investment.
- zeroxfe 9y agoThis applies to pretty much any company/individual that took advantage of the market prices. And not just dark fiber, but pretty much all infrastructure.
- leroy_masochist 9y agoYes, and the boom times of 1998-2000 inspired a bunch of young people to spend more time learning about tech, and some of them grew up to be programmers who added significant value at Google and Amazon. There are lots of these kinds of secondary effects and many of them were significant, such as your fiber example, which is a good one. The point though, is that both Google and Amazon were able to get themselves off of the ground without taking advantage of all the stupid money that flooded the Valley in the 1998-2000 time period, quite to the contrary of the argument I quoted in the parent comment.
- Goladus 9y agoIf the point the author is trying to make is that Amazon and Google were made possible by the dotcom boom, and that the collapse of the dotcom bubble was part of the price we as a society had to pay to have the services provided these companies, that's a really really bad argument. Well, the article actually refers to that argument as a "desperate rationalization," although rather than delving into refuting the analogy he focuses on his primary thesis which is that right now, the speculative bubble is preventing any real determination of whether the blockchain technology has (or does not have) any practical uses.
- DennisP 9y agoHe claims the gas price mechanism doesn't help Ethereum because the fee market is driven by supply and demand. Of course it is, but that supply and demand is independent of the ETH price; it will govern the real cost of fees and that will be translated into some amount of ETH depending on the ETH price. We can see this when network usage drops, or the gas limit increases. Fees drop to low levels in dollar terms, even if the ETH price stays up. There is one way that the ETH price sets a minimum on gas costs: miners race each other to make blocks, processing transactions causes delay. The more valuable the block reward, the higher the expected cost of that delay, and miners demand compensation for that. But this doesn't seem to be a large effect since gas prices are sometimes quite low. (Full proof of stake would eliminate this race dynamic.)
- temp-dude-87844 9y agoI fail to see the article's point. Yes, you can spin your own token on top of the Ethereum chain, but with transaction prices so high, as the article notes, what would be the point? If anything, this would incentivize a company serious about deploying an altcoin to form their own chain unbound from anyone else, or give some long and hard thought about whether a centralized server-side DB would suffice. The people most discouraged by high fees of cookie-cutter coins are the exact sort of low-effort attempts that are trying to capitalize on blockchain mania, instead of leveraging the technology for its specialized merits. This isn't strangling innovation: it's a first-layer filter that separates the wheat from the chaff.
- narrator 9y agoI wonder how many Bitcoin transactions these days are people arbitraging with the futures market. Tail starting to wag the dog?
- blueprint 9y agoVirtually the entire article is about Ethereum. Ok, sure, a poorly and intentionally differently designed system is choking at scale. But Ethereum != cryptocurrencies. In fact I would stay very much away from calling it a currency at all since it's not fungible. So I am struggling to see how this article is not just a big false equivalence.
- SN76477 9y agoWhat I have seen is a lot of people in my space have dropped what they are doing to focus on blockchain/crypto. They are chasing novelty, they do not seem dedicated to their craft. I think this is a bit of a problem.
- AlexCoventry 9y agoBy space, do you mean field? If so, which?
- DennisP 9y agoHow can you tell they're not dedicated to their craft in the blockchain space?
- RandomInteger4 9y agoWhy would studying and working with a new and profitable technology mean people lack a dedication to their craft? That's a poor assertion at best.
- dopamean 9y agoI have a friend who just quit his job on Friday to join a company that just laid off 2/3 of their staff to do a blockchain project. The company currently does nothing related to the blockchain and they do not have an idea for a product yet. It seems like such a weird thing to do.
- arisAlexis 9y agowhat if it is not a bubble? what a conviction of authority from "experts"
- phaser 9y agoThe incentives for building a crypto product with real intentions of bringing a product to people vs. writing a whitepaper for fundraising are alarming. Besides the rising fees (which can be mitigated with added protocol layers like lightning) the real problem is people understanding cryptocurrencies as investment. "Crypto investors" and people hoping to get rich quick who don't understand the fundamental philosophy of Bitcoin/Crypto are strangling innovation by adding "noise" attention to whatever developers like us "signal" are making. Personally, I hope the bubble bursts, everyone lose their money and we go back to the original community of people building stuff, who see cryptocurrency as a technology, not an "investment". If Bitcoin drops to $1, I will still write software for it and won't miss the 'craze' factor.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pc2g4d 9y agoIsn't this driven by the fact that crypto clients use a default transaction fee rather than dynamically negotiating a good fee on the market? E.g. if your client's default fee is .001 bitcoins or whatever, back in the day that was super cheap but now it's $15. But the intrinsic cost of carrying out that transaction has in real-world terms probably gone down rather than up. So you'd expect the market to arrive at roughly the same USD-valued equilibrium regardless of the BTC-USD conversion rate, but this clearly hasn't happened. So in practice there is no market for crypto transactions because everybody just uses some default transaction fee. Yeah?
- Goladus 9y agoI believe the real-world costs of transactions are actually going up, not down. As more miners are added to a network, the difficulty rating goes up and more CPU cycles are required to compute the next block.
- xiphias 9y agoThe answer is clear no. There are more smart developers than a year ago, but improving cryptocurrencies needs really hard cryptography. While the geeat devs grow exponentially, it's not 10x / year.