11 ms·
Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain
- provost 9y agoHopefully this thread will be different than all the others. Someone is likely to appear here with a counterargument, which I'm looking forward to reading. However, in addition to any counterarguments, please describe why standard tech and/or a 3rd_party is insufficient for your proposed use-cases. This is HackerNews after all, and we desire the deeply technical discussion and context, not propaganda.
- adamnemecek 9y ago“What’s the point of http when you can write a custom protocol”. It’s not about the single solutions themselves, it’s about the ecosystem of solutions that you can integrate relatively painlessly. Same reason why standards are important. What do you consider standard tech btw?
- dreit1 9y agoI know this isn't an answer that you will like....but blockchain allows me to invest in high risk investments that would typically only be allowed for accredited investors. Having the shares/coins in a blockchain provides for transparency and authenticity and makes legit companies act in a way that is generally favorable for the small time investor
- Daishiman 9y agoWhich investments?
- dreit1 9y agoI'm into mainly into stuff that either pays or plans to pay dividends, NEO, WTC, ARK, ETH etc.
- zacurry 9y agoOff topic - I keep hearing that WTC (Walton) is a scam . How confident are u about it ?
- dreit1 9y agoIt is 100% not a scam. You can watch some videos where a youtube visits the office and talks to the team here. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RzhXncTVOzA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RzhXncTVOzA Whether or not it will be a successful project or not is up for debate.
- bob2001 9y agoCan you explain how having shares/coins in the blockchain increases transparency/authenticity? Easily audit-able records would exist just the same if you bought your shares via wire transfer.
- dreit1 9y agoSo imagine an ICO company that has a premine. You know the address of all their funds that they raised, and you know all the funds that are held through their premine. You can easily track the money to make sure nothing fishy is going on. This isn't that big of a deal for a tiny company, but imagine this for a huge corporation or government body. All of them CAN produce auditable records for the consumer, but they don't, blockchains force the issue.
- chadcmulligan 9y agobut isn't that just taking advantage of a (temporary) loop hole? The real problem there imho is that for some reason the government has decided that oh we need to step in and protect the unwise. Strangely this is by the same people that say government shouldn't be involved in the financial markets. There is no guarantee that having an ICO makes the investment any more bullet proof.
- adventured 9y ago> There is no guarantee that having an ICO makes the investment any more bullet proof. Right now it's the exact opposite. There's nothing less bullet-proof (eg in the US) than investing into an ICO, outside of perhaps junk penny stocks.
- dreit1 9y agoEntire industries can be built on regulatory loopholes, Uber and Lyft come to mind. Cryptocurrencies are forcing govts to reexamine regulations that I argue are generally favorable to massive institutions/ high net worth individuals and unfavorable to the small timers
- kemonocode 9y agoHow would you expect someone in a third-world country to keep money away from a hyperinflating currency, without access to international banking? And no, we-will-suspend-your-account-if-you-look-at-us-funny PayPal is not an option. Cash in foreign currencies is extremely risky.
- aaavl2821 9y agojewelry is a good option, as long as you can tell real jewelry from fake: valuable, somewhat liquid, holds value reasonably well, easy to hide, portable
- adventured 9y agoYou get massacred on jewelry anytime you need to actually sell it. If you paid $2,000-$3,000 for that diamond ring, you'll get $150-$200 for it from a buyer in a crunch. Jewelry being resold does anything but hold its value, it's a truly epic beating you'll take to the downside. 75-90% of the value of retail jewelry is bullshit, you're almost never paying the bulk of the retail price for the actual gold / silver / diamond, you're paying the mark-up from a store (as a validated trinket, to verify by reputation sharing that it's hopefully the real deal). Take a nice engagement ring into a pawn shop to sell it, you'll get $0.10-$0.15 on the dollar if you're lucky, and that's a good scenario where you're not under pressure to move it to an even shadier buyer. The only way to go with the concept you're suggesting, is to buy actual gold (coins or similar). With something like gold coins, you'll still suffer a discount on a need-to-sell, but it won't be nearly so bad. Do not think under any circumstances that jewelry holds its value in a resale, it holds a small fraction of its value (unless we're talking a million dollar extraordinary specimen (equivalent to art in the jewelry world), but that's a super rare context, and you'll still sell it at a hefty discount in a crunch).
- hanselot 9y agoThis is exactly what happened in Zimbabwe.
- root_axis 9y agoThe people who are so poor that they don't have reliable access to banking services very often are lacking reliable access to internet connected computing devices and sometimes even electricity. Additionally, trading cryptocurrency for spendable money is time consuming and expensive. The idea that cryptocurrency is a viable option for the participants of third-world economies is absurd. I'm not saying that nobody in the third-world uses cryptotokens but its very uncommon.
- hanselot 9y agoIt's been a while, but https://youtu.be/WnEYakUxsHU https://youtu.be/WnEYakUxsHU has some interesting thoughts on it. Essentially trust based companies are the logical product of blockchain, but they will require an essential shift in how we approach business.
- wallacoloo 9y agoIt's hard to write a good counterargument to this. The article goes in so many directions that it could never cover all his points. Any counterargument I can construct boils down to a difference of opinion & values. The author trusts his bank and his government to (a) handle his money in the way that he thinks is responsible and (b) handle disputes in a way that benefits him. On the other hand, I trust myself to handle my money responsibly, and I view my government as a great uncertainty because I don't understand the limits of their power (in the least nefarious, but relevant point, who can predict by how much my government will increase the monetary supply and deflate my purchasing power over the next decades? More nefarious, if I dissent, government can trivially lock most of my digital assets that aren't cryptocurrencies - e.g. bank account or investment funds).
- richardwhiuk 9y agoSure they can - put you in prison with no internet access.
- wallacoloo 9y agoSure, but there are plenty of dissenters that manage to escape being in the physical custody of their government. One might reasonably decide to leave the country before dissenting, in some scenarios. You can bet that Edward Snowden had all his US assets seized, for example. But if he had any cryptocurrency, he may have been able to take those with him.
- mrep 9y agoSo, for Illegal activity? The article has already consented that illegal markets are 1 of the 2 current use cases. Got any others?
- wallacoloo 9y ago> So, for Illegal activity Say I'm someone like Ed Snowden (again). I own a house, a car, the clothes on my back, and Bitcoin. I up and leave one day to share government secrets with the press and hide in a different country. Did the car aid in the crime? Probably, to some degree - it let me physically make my way to the airport, and on to journalists to whom I shared secrets. Did the house aid the crime? Did the clothes on my back aid the crime? Both of those allowed me to live a safe and comfortable life. I wouldn't have made it past airport security without my clothes, after all. Did the Bitcoin aid the crime? Only in the same sense that a treadmill and a good diet aids a bank robber by making it easier for him to leave the scene in a hurry. So I think the claim that having bitcoin in your possession when committing a crime necessarily enables that crime (to a greater deal than any other everyday thing) is a bit nebulous. It didn't facilitate the crime, it just lessened the punishment. Possession of $USD cash provides a similar thing in the form of being used to pay bail.
- adamnemecek 9y agoThis article reminds me of Clifford Stolls 1995 article http://www.newsweek.com/clifford-stoll-why-web-wont-be-nirvana-185306 http://www.newsweek.com/clifford-stoll-why-web-wont-be-nirva... In which he says how the promises of the internet have been inflated. Progress is generally on the exponential (or sigmoid) curve, so it’s slow at first, but explosive later.
- superbrama 9y agoInternet connected the world, and changed how we interact fundamentally. Blockchain uses the internet to create politically resistant money as a primary use case. Just not seeing how blockchain fits into any ongoing revolution, in part because it only can exist because of government/corporate controlled pipes on which it relies.
- adamnemecek 9y agoRight, block chain will do the same. The ongoing revolution is the fight against ruling classes, same as over the last 5000 years. Not really true that it depends on the government. And even if it is, you only need like one government supporting it for it to be valuable. Why couldn’t your argument be used to say the internet won’t work?
- etr-strike 9y agoYou can’t have a blockchain without a Bitcoin. The two are inseparable. Every blockchain needs a token reward which has monetary value to secure it.
- Cyberdog 9y agoThat doesn't seem to me like a fundamental law. Certainly with "internal blockchains" or other cases where at least a majority of the operators are trusted, mining and tokens are completely unnecessary.
- 9y ago
- kapauldo 9y agoThis is such a breath of fresh air.
- kc1116 9y agoThis reminds me of the reporter that asks Jeff Bezos in a sarcastic tone “So your telling me Amazon will be bigger than Sears??” https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6cTjhzSgdwE https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6cTjhzSgdwE
- nerfhammer 9y agoDoubly amusing because Sears was the Amazon of the 1900's.
- juicyfroot 9y agoPayments? Hello.
- baxtr 9y agoHas anyone thought about this in terms of a hype cycle [1]? Basically, the theory says that any new technology will be hyped at first and then falls into a state of disillusionment, where all the hopes of the first phase are shattered. Finally, when integration barriers etc are resolved the technology picks up. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hype_cycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hype_cycle
- drdeadringer 9y agoRecently I saw a question asking if there were any social impact projects going on that were using blockchain technologies. I have no idea how blockchain technologies can apply to social impact projects; all I could come up with was verifying that my donated can of soup made it into the hands of Homeless Joe via a verifiable route, but I don't know how much I'd need that. I trust that the soup kitchen [or whatever] directly feeds people, and if I didn't I'd be volunteering up front as well or not even bother at all. Perhaps again I just haven't applied my imagination to it.
- atsjie 9y agoA solidity developer I spoke to a couple of times told me much the same as this article. He believed in the blockchain as a concept; but its current overall benefit to human society is meagre (and some might argue destructive). This represents a first awkward phase for everyone. We'll definitely see blockchain become dominant in a some or multiple fields of business. When? Perhaps not for 20 years. Internet as we know it took decades for it to fully develop and take off. We could get a crash before this succes happens, the word "blockchain" and "cryptocurrency" might become toxic for a while. Thinking of the 2000 IT bubble, so much money poured into any crazy business proposal with "web" in it; and suddenly the music stopped. Billions evaporated. All the while I'll just be grabbing popcorn and hoping to sell my coins on time ;-)
- autokad 9y agoagree. I seen the same comparison between the internet and AI/Data science/ML. a big bubble, everyone is 'doing it' but most are doing it wrong, and then a big collapse. When the smoke clears, the ones that 'got it right' are the big future titans, and the whole sector grows again.
- stri8ed 9y agoAs it stands, block-chains do not scale. So it's hard to say if lack of adoption is due to lack of actual use cases, or inability to implement use-cases given state of the network. I think prediction markets may be one of the first real use-cases.
- pedalpete 9y agoThis reminds me of the naysayers from the early internet, and I think we can look at each stage of the internet's growth with these same glasses. 1) email: it will never replace the post-office. You can only send text. Oh, ok, they've added images now, well, its' too slow for most people to download them, and now I've got all this spam. We use it in our company, but it isn't really for consumers. Oh, then hotmail... 2) You're not going to buy things online. The shipping costs will be too high. The logistics are all wrong. Will you trust an online shop with your credit card?? No way! This e-commerce thing is dead in the water. Sure, you point to the 'growth', but it's equal to "the proportion of US GDP comprised by toothpick sales" 3) Blogs?? Seriously. We're a news agency. We pay professional journalists to research and write compelling stories. Can you trust some random person in their basement writing a blog? Sorry, no contest. Blogs can't compete with major media companies. 4) Music downloads? Why would you spend 20 minutes downloading a song ILLEGALLY?? Where are you going to get it from. We'll stop all of this. CDs are the way forward. Oh, this internet thing has just destroyed our business model, iTunes to the rescue. But now people want to stream music. No they don't internet speed isn't fast enough to stream, and people want to own music, this music streaming thing isn't going anywhere! 5) Video? You've got to be kidding. Oh, that youtube thing is fine for weirdo's who want to make video's for their friends, but people will keep going to movies and paying for cable. The quality isn't good enough, and they don't have the great content. This internet thing isn't going anyway. 6) Rent someone's apartment online? Are you nuts! I'm not going to let some crazy person stay in my place, and I'm not going to stay in somebody else's. These internet people are crazy. Our hotel business is just fine. In fact, I think we should increase prices and start charging people hidden fees like "resort charges"... 7) Get in a stranger's car? A stranger that I found online!!??? Look, when I was a kid, my parents had two rules. Don't talk to strangers, and never get in a strangers car. Now you're telling me to go online, find a stranger and get in their car! This is madness. Just get in a cab! They'll take you where you want to go and you can trust them! Please add your own "this is going nowhere" stories, I'm keen to see what else is out there, there are TONS. The blockchain may use the internet as an underlying protocol, but it is as disruptive to the finance industry as Napster was to music, AirBnB to hotels, Uber/Lyft (please come to Australia Lyft) was to cabs, Amazon to retail, etc. etc. The difference being, that blockchain is an open technology that is enabling this disruption, rather than a single company.
- darcys22 9y agoAs much as everyone hates ICO's. They make equity funding rediculously easy.
- linkmotif 9y agoThat’s ridiculous.
- davidpatrick 9y agounregulated equity funding...
- Animats 9y agoSome big banks are gearing up to use a blockchain to track interbank settlements.[1] But this isn't a coin, nor is there mining. It's simply a shared ledger that can't be altered without cooperation between a majority of the parties. All alterations are clearly visible to all parties, which is good for auditing. Only big banks who have signed up for this have active nodes, and they are not anonymous. This is an alternative to setting up a neutral party for the purpose, such as the Bank for International Settlements or Depository Trust Corporation. Those organizations are expensive to run. It's a real shared ledger, but it's no more than that. [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-blockchain-banks/six-big-banks-join-blockchain-digital-cash-settlement-project-idUSKCN1BB0UA https://www.reuters.com/article/us-blockchain-banks/six-big-...
- Rapzid 9y agoIt's interesting too that it will be much easier for them to agree on architectural changes when necessary to compensate for scaling or other issues. This is a major issue for something like Bitcoin, but a small speed bump for banks utilizing agreed upon blockchain tech.. It's at least interesting to consider the benefits of centralized(exclusive?) guidance coupled with distributed execution.
- cm2187 9y agoI don't understand how they go around the confidentiality. If you are a trader at big bank A, the last thing you want is traders at big bank B and C to know everything you have in your book.
- cbcoutinho 9y agoThis probably has to do with payments the banks are making to each other, not between banks and clients. If banks are paying each other, there's going to be a nonzero cost associated with the accounting for those transactions, and this system would remove that cost. What I didn't understand from the article was the point about membership. If the contributing banks are the only ones using it, why is it giving information about what _I_ could do with one of these USCs - apparently nothing because I won't be able to join the chain
- Namecoin_Dammit 9y agohttps://namecoin.org/ https://namecoin.org/
- hanselot 9y agoI was just wondering why blockchain doesn't get used to manage government data on citizens. One immutable record of a person with all the metadata stored in sidechains.
- ssijak 9y agoYeah, government is sure first to get on a hyper new tech. In the US alone you got like XYZ ways to count votes on elections in different counties, most of which are decades or more old.
- brokensegue 9y agobecause they can just use a database...
- ThomPete 9y agoPeople always overestimate the short term and underestimate the long term. Go to any country perhaps with the exception of Estonia and you will see that digitalization was supposed to change governments for the better. Instead they mostly have created very sporadic successes but a lot of failed implementation sometimes even making it worse. Yet there is no doubt that in the long run things are changing for the better. The problem isn't the technology but the problems around legality and implementation and who it disrupts. There is however plenty of usages for blockchain just off the top of my head. Digital Pokemon cards, 2nd hand ebooks market, 2nd hand digital assets market, digital art certification, tracking of how money for NGO's are being spent and of course as a gold standard for important deals done between large organization and of course as a truly international wiretransfer system. All these things will happen with new generations growing up and finding natural uses for them.
- mutteraloo 9y agoSo 10-15 more years? In the meantime we can use blockchain/bitcoin to scam money from grandmas, retired folks, and millenials. So they can hate us technologists even more. Oh, and cause global warming and destroy the planet. That way humans will have to come up with a non-government backed currency.
- kindfellow92 9y agoI’m worth 13 million dollars because of crypto and I’ve diversified half... tell me more about how Bitcoin is a scam. :)
- mutteraloo 9y agoI'm worth way more than 13 million, and you will most likely lose your million because you can't read :)
- kindfellow92 9y agoI can read. I’m a millennial and I haven’t been scammed. Bitcoin is changing lives for the better and has allowed me and my family to join you in wealth but you seem to hate that.
- jackfoxy 9y agoThe folks at https://sweetbridge.com/ https://sweetbridge.com/ make a case for supply chain being a natural fit. Some of the low hanging fruit here is international trade between less developed countries, where settlement has to be done in dollars, and independent truckers. The thesis is that huge amounts of capital is tied up in invoice settlement all along the supply chain. (And supply chain refers to every thing from the dirt -- grown or mined -- all the way to the end consumer.) Settling invoices on the blockchain would eliminate a huge amount of friction and open the possibility of immediate low interest (or even no interest) loans on a substantial amount of outstanding invoices.
- Cyberdog 9y agoWhat about a blockchain/distributed ledger improves supply chains in ways that a standard centralized database could not? Explain like I'm five.
- meri_dian 9y agoI've been asking this exact question of blockchain enthusiasts and evangelists for over a year now, and have never received a clear response. I understand the difference between a distributed ledger and a database, but in all use cases I've heard mentioned as ripe for blockchain derived innovation, not once has a blockchain really been necessary or even an improvement over a traditional database based solution. To give you an idea of how buzzwordy this all is, my friend works in venture capital and was trying to explain to me how blockchain was going to change the world after he got back from a blockchain conference, saying that it would "revolutionize VR/AR, AI, etc...", technologies that have absolutely nothing to do with one another. I just laughed.
- davidpatrick 9y agoNothing to do with each other, in the way that internet protocols would have nothing to do with how we purchase goods. Crypto creates a validated economy in a VR/AR world. Digital goods have a certain tangibility with crypto inside of a VR/AR environment, that creates true ownership.
- crispinb 9y agoIt has at least one psychological use. For many it is a vehicle of self-deception, wherein they persuade themselves they are in the purportedly honourable class of investors, connoting productive use of wealth. They must understand somewhere underneath the fakery that they are speculators/gamblers.
- jnsaff2 9y agoI used to work for these guys https://guardtime.com https://guardtime.com . They do keyless digital signatures/timestamps based on block chain way before bitcoin and are quite useful.
- wslh 9y agoI think you are in a position to add something to this discussion: have they found added value in the distributed ledger ecosystem?
- jnsaff2 9y agoWell they issue timestamps/signatures at a rate up to 2^64/second without PKI to provide tamper evident guarantees for data integrity. Their ledger is public and based on universally accepted proofs/primitives. Is it distributed, I suppose no, is it a good use for blockchain I’d say yes.
- pipio21 9y agoPersonally I believe in blockchain, but not current blockchain. Like anything it will take multiple steps and failing several times before it works. The perfect example is the internet, it was so wrong at the start, so ugly, and so naive. But it was free and open. Everybody said "internet is the future", and that created the dotcom bubble when everybody agreed and wanted to profit from it. I had friends at the time that got rich in the process, and I have friends today that have gotten rich with bitcoins(they have already sold all of them). At the end of course Internet was the future, but not "that Internet", it has evolved a lot and will continue evolving. With blockchain the same is happening: we have a tremendous bubble right now that will be painful when it pops. But it will continue evolving into something extremely useful in my opinion. It will be no bitcoin, it will something else be easier to mine, with more transactions, and so on...it will evolve over time learning from its errors, like anything in the History of mankind.
- zeep 9y agoBut this is not like anything... If it was like any other software, someone would have found a bug to be able to steal all Bitcoins
- Geee 9y agoI think you haven't been following the scene very closely. There's already multiple solutions to these problems. Take a look at RaiBlocks (raiblocks.net) for example, which has instantaneous zero-fee transactions with very high throughput (hardware limited) without losing decentralization or other security properties (not proven atm). RaiBlocks uses delegated proof-of-stake with a block-lattice architecture. Another example would be Cardano, which has the first provably secure proof-of-stake protocol with same security guarantees as Bitcoin, and is also secure in a scalable setting with blockchain sharding (as is planned in Ethereum too). Proof-of-stake doesn't require energy to mine blocks and can be scalable but is very hard to secure. There's multiple other solutions as well, such as IOTA, Byteball, Steem, BitShares and others which might be more centralized and less secure to achieve scalability. Then there is Bitcoin Lightning Network almost ready, and also MimbleWimble coming out soon (http://grin-tech.org/ http://grin-tech.org/). Lots of things are certainly happening faster than you can anticipate. Additionally, there's projects like Enigma and Aion, which add scalability, privacy and interoperability on top of existing blockchains. This territory starts to get a bit complex for me.
- KirinDave 9y agoGithub and the linux git repo are merkle trees with a variety of governance controls. I will die on this hill if I have to.
- masterjack 9y agoThat is actually fascinating. You could build a ledger on top of github, transactions are push requests,there’d be a centralized party approving valid push requests and merging forks, but following a standardized formula that anyone can check and audit. Token ingress and egress are potentially hard to do, but it would be a fun idea to develop.
- mooneater 9y agoA blockchain is a Merkle tree that increases you valuation /s
- malux85 9y agoI have a product built on blockchain, it has real, paying customers. It was not funded through an ICO and we do not have our own coin. Https://hydrachain.io/
- chadcmulligan 9y agoa tl;dr on what it is might be helpful? I'm afraid I don't quite understand what your product is after looking at the web site.
- malux85 9y agoI know it’s not very good explanation, the site was put up quickly before we pitched to a large government contract and it was aimed at them and not a casual reader. New site coming soon with examples and a demo. It’s a generic asset management platform - so one current use case is tracking the movement of goods through a supply chain, and also recording transactional history in an industry that is currently full of corruption and tax avoiders. Having an immutable transaction record that’s publicly visible is the correct usage of blockchain and it solves this problem very well. We are talking about amounts that are so large, this system will likely be regulated by the government. Another current use case is tracking physical (and very valuable) assets - again the use case is an immutable pubic record. The immutability is key - sure you could Store this data in a database, but the problems we are solving are the fact that when you have a single entity running a database then at a certain level of wealth you’re practically guaranteed corruption or unethical behaviour. This is the reason we use blockchain - blockchain has a good use case for avoiding the corruption that massive centralised systems are often plagued with
- etr-strike 9y agoSure, if you don’t consider a decentralized and trustless currency a use. If you don’t consider a store of value a use. If you don’t consider a public ledger of transactions a use. If you don’t consider programmable money a use. If you don’t consider permissionless payments a use. If you don’t consider a financial system wich never close a use. If you don’t consider instant payments a use. Then sure, no use has been found.
- pjc50 9y ago"Blockchain" the data structure probably will have some persistent uses. "Proof of waste" on the other hand is like leaded petrol or cloroflurocarbons: it certainly works, but the environmental downsides are going to have to result in it being banned.
- anigbrowl 9y agoDon't forget that lasers were a solution in search of a problem for ages. Blockchain's potential uses are great, but they have to overcome the deficit of (maybe) lack of privacy and (usually) big and busy ledgers - traffic you'd probably rather not have going constantly, but if you outsource it to a local specialist you're defeating the purpose.What blockchain needs is an application where privacy doesn't matter but depth and resolution do. I wonder if it secretly longs to be united with mapping applications.
- sremani 9y agoDistributed Ledgers have real application, blockchains are one way of solving them. DLT 2.0 like hash graphs and DAGs are interesting, but Blockchain is the whats in "production" thus far.
- eksemplar 9y agoMaersk is using blockchain to validate container ownership claims. Revolutionary tech in a world where crime meant the confirmation papers cost more than the container to ship. Several countries outside the west are moving to do registration of land ownership on blockchain tech because their bureaucratic system is corrupt. Banks have moved to cryptocurrencies for transfers. Sure it's not the unregulated ones, but it's still block chain. In government in Scandinavia we're doing various proofs of concepts on blockchain. Because it cuts out the need for a legal "middle man" it has huge potential even in less corrupt parts of the world. Everything from simple paperwork to lock/key systems in elder apartments (don't know the English word sorry) is being tested. Blockchain is certainly full of scams, but it actually offers tremendous value in enterprise, especially when you do any form of bureaucracy. The thing is though, in this world 10 years is nothing. Just look at RPA, it's a tech from before the internet and it's only now beginning to be applied in real world situations that isn't cheating in a video game.
- tom_mellior 9y ago> Several countries outside the west are moving to do registration of land ownership on blockchain tech because their bureaucratic system is corrupt. Do you have a source for this? I can't imagine how it might work.
- dozzie 9y agoWhy not? Blockchain is a document timestamping system, which means its whole purpose is to tell which of the two connected documents was issued earlier. As such, it doesn't care if the document was subtracting a number from one account and adding the same number to another account or if it was some text telling who gets the ownership of a described plot. In fact, this particular use is one of the few that blockchain is actually good for (because it was designed as document timestamping), unlike stuff like voting or databases.
- tom_mellior 9y agoThis is a particular use for a public database. The public database must be writable (only) by the corrupt authorities. What exactly does a blockchain do to make the authorities non-corrupt here?
- mythrwy 9y agoUnsuitable parallels are the bread and butter of hypers and shills. Just imagine it's 1893 and no one can see how big cars are going to be. Well this gizmo XYZ is just like cars were then! You'll wanna get in on this now! And so this gets internalized and repeated to friends and family regardless of objective merit. Because it sounds "truthy". The parallels between blockchain and the Internet are similarly contrived. They are different phenomenon and the line "X is like Y thus what happened to X will happen to Y" doesn't have objective merit in this case near as I can tell. (Apologies to the half a dozen or more posters who have probably posted something to this effect on the thread). The _potential_ uses for blockchain are much more limited than potential uses for the Internet for instance. (And there are a number of other differences). That being said I have no doubt there are uses for blockchain technology. Making people rich with cryptocurrency for one. And hey, I'm all in favor. Let's just don't get carried away with the parallels.
- meri_dian 9y agoBlockchain may have some legitimate uses in which it's an improvement over a traditional centralized database, but they are very few and niche. It would be silly to say blockchain has no use, but I can't help but laugh at people who talk about it being "the next Internet"
- LoSboccacc 9y agoland claims
- LoSboccacc 9y agoseriously what's wrong with this community?
- wslh 9y agoI think the author is right with the current state of the affairs and the insane pumped hype but he misses the core issues serious engineers and researchers want to solve. First, private blockchains is a misleading term since they don't share the core innovation behind Bitcoin: solving (under certain assumptions) the double spend/transaction problem in a decentralized way. This is the start of a series of computer science innovations playing with game theory, cryptography, politics, and finances. The nature of public blockchains makes it difficult, if not impossible, to significantly scale and speed up them (without losing some of its original features). Second, the core ideas behind private blockchains predates Bitcoin. Nick Szabo’s smart contracts concept is from 1994 [1] and if we go back in time we can find the AMIX project in 1988 [2][3]. The focus of these ideas is having a way to specify and plug contracts between different entities. Ad-hoc APIs are the natural solution for this problem but in the future there can be ways to quickly specify interactions and agreements with smart contracts. Also ideas of log immutability can be traced back to a 1995 Spanish article titled “VCR y PEO, dos protocolos criptográficos simples” [4]. Bruce Schneier also published similar works in 1997 with Automatic Event-Stream Notorization Using Digital Signatures and in 1998 as “Cryptographic Support for Secure Logs on Untrusted Machines” [5]. Regarding private blockchains/distributed ledgers performance, the top achievement is 80000 tps using BFT-SMaRt consensus with an security tolerance of <50% crash faults and <33% malicious [6]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_contract#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_contract#History [2] http://erights.org/smart-contracts/index.html http://erights.org/smart-contracts/index.html [3] http://erights.org/smart-contracts/history/index.html http://erights.org/smart-contracts/history/index.html [4] https://www.coresecurity.com/system/files/publications/2016/05/2Protocolos.pdf https://www.coresecurity.com/system/files/publications/2016/... [5] https://www.schneier.com/academic/paperfiles/paper-secure-logs.pdf https://www.schneier.com/academic/paperfiles/paper-secure-lo... [6] https://github.com/bft-smart/library https://github.com/bft-smart/library
- kens 9y agoAs a serious question, is there a service (other than the blockchain) that provides a public, timestamped, immutable database? For applications such as putting supply chain data on the blockchain, I assume there's an easier service to use, but I couldn't think offhand of what would be a replacement.
- lordnacho 9y agoSomething close enough is perhaps proofofexistence.com Pretty simple idea, you hash a any document and you get a blockchained stamp of that hash. Now you can prove to anyone that the document (eg contract) existed at that time.
- svantana 9y agoThere is one obvious use case where it's already in use: illegal trade. The article mentions it as an aside but it's definitely not small business; if half the world's drug, weapon and human trafficking trade were to happen in bitcoin, it would justify the current exchange rate and then some. Of course, that would force governments to outlaw the exchange services, which would make bitcoin way less attractive to criminals and law-abiders alike. To me that seems like the most plausible outcome of all this.
- Balkie 9y agoI would love to re read this post and Comments in 2-5 years and see which large corporations have been replaced or have adopted blockchain/tangle technology
- moonlighter 9y agoIBM has a blockchain platform [1] and BlueMix APIs [2] available. [1] https://www.ibm.com/blockchain/ https://www.ibm.com/blockchain/ [2] https://console.bluemix.net/catalog/services/blockchain https://console.bluemix.net/catalog/services/blockchain
- GuB-42 9y agoThe blockchain is not just a support for currency, it is a decentralized ledger. A bit like git, but more secure. A use case that doesn't involve currency is product tracking.
- Agebor 9y agoTalking about distributed ledgers, blockchains is kind of misleading. Fundamentally, this technology implements distributed trust. You can put some information there and it will remain, forever. Everyone can see that this data (and hence, some event in the world) is there, was created at particular time by a particular person. You can tell someone: "Hey, I did X and you can see it here". Sure, it's slow as hell now, but look forward 10 years. What if people in year e.g. 1000CE suddenly got telepathy (internet) and ability to persist each other's thoughts? How would that change their society?
- DenisM 9y agoHere's a vague idea... How about a reputation ledger? My reputation will accumulate over time, and people will trust me, simplifying some transactions. For example I could rent a short-term stay at a lower rate because I am such a nice fellow and will never mess anything up. Because my reputation has direct monetary value I would be hesitant to mess it up by being a dick, unless for a very big gain. The counter-parties will know the value of my reputation as well as the total value of outstanding liabilities against my reputation, so they will not give me any resources worth more than my current reputation capacity. This has nothing to do with mining or coins, just an immutable public ledger. For all I care every notary public will be given a right to sign a block in the ledger, and collectively they will establish consensus. Yelp on steroids, basically.
- twright 9y agoSounds like a good idea for a credit rating company, it might certainly be more transparent than current ones. Or, Black Mirror series 3 episode 1, it's a fine line.
- tomtomistaken 9y agoHow to reward not being a dick: You can earn a token for being nice. With this token you can lend a stake for POS.
- djangowithme 9y agoI would NOT necessarily suggest Verify.as as an investment by any means but what they're trying to accomplish is quite similar. If you can track reputation fairly then every time you make a transaction you don't have to go to court because its expensive and time consuming.
- __Duncan__ 9y agoSounds like a black mirror episode...
- prodtorok 9y agosounds like a dystopia.
- arisAlexis 9y agoamazing how wrong this article is
- angel_j 9y ago"Sixty years in, nobody has come up with a use for linked lists."
- tarikjn 9y ago1. Blockchain technology could be theoretically used to secure elections. Some example usage: When people register to vote, assist them with setting a key pair and allow them to enter their public key with their registration. They could then verify how their vote was counted after the election. Not sure if it would be superior to paper voting still as it could then be used to buy votes, but maybe there are some narrow applications, or a multi-sig approach where someone could know, but not prove it is their vote without the help of a third party. It is still better than current electronic-voting in this scenario. As a side note, there is definitely a use for public key registration associated with government identification as it would solve ID theft for good. 2. It could also be used for public records and secure/lower cost for chain of custody applications.
- tehlike 9y agoFor 1: Do you need blockchain at all? Or do you need public/private key signing?
- tarikjn 9y agoWhere would you register all the votes and verify the counts? The blockchain would help secure that database from an actor targeting votes of people not likely to verify their votes.
- M2Ys4U 9y agoBeing able to (trivially) verify votes sounds like a recipe for buying votes and/or intimidating voters to me. Inefficiency in voting technology is a feature, not a bug. Pencil on paper is the best system we have for precisely this reason.
- tarikjn 9y agoYes, I agree with all that and pointed it out in my first answer.
- WhitneyLand 9y agoThere are countless examples where a promising innovation, or even a seemingly useless but novel result became important at a much later date than 10 years. Even the Internet was criticized by some after 10 years for failing to live up to “change everything” hype, and it’s true it hadn’t really close to doing so at the time. Some companies like Blockbuster Video weren’t a bit concerned for quite a while. To me the current state of blockchain applications doesn’t tell us much about what it’s ultimate utility will end up being.
- mrep 9y agoThe iPhone was first released 10 years ago. 10 years is a massive amount of time in tech.
- davidpatrick 9y agoThe iPhone wasnt an innovation, it was an iteration.
- Barrin92 9y ago> There are countless examples where a promising innovation, or even a seemingly useless but novel result became important at a much later date than 10 years. While that might be true, that doesn't mean that a lack of success actually indicates success. That'd be a useless tautology. More importantly, earlier innovations that took their time usually at least had a clear proposition of value. When electricity was introduced it took decades before businesses had adjusted their manufacturing and supply lines to the new technology, but everybody could trivially see that powering things remotely and sending information over long distances is pretty darn useful. There is no such hypothetical justification for blockchain technology, or at least there isn't in many cases were people rabidly keep advocating for it. As the author points out, in many fields the blockhain technology is less energy efficient, slower, and provides the opposite of what most customers want. That is
- WhitneyLand 9y agoOf course I agree it doesn’t indicate success, I assume you understand I was only making the weaker claim, that lack of success at 10 years doesn’t set any ceiling on ultimate success. Just saying it’s not unprecedented as other concepts have, however unlikely, eventually found success, and there are maybe a few parallels with basic research. Some computer science has come out of all of this already, some of which might be pieces to a puzzle we can’t entirely see yet.
- olfactory 9y agoThis article is generally why I'm optimistic about Bitcoin and blockchain in general. A reasonably well-informed person can have all the facts and yet still not get it.
- gersh 9y agoIt seems useful as way to keep records in poor or very corrupt countries without stable institutions. For example, if you don't have a very stable government, it seems like it is a good solution for keeping property records or storing voting records. It also seems like an alternative for creating universal financial records without requiring the same level of regulation. Fundamentally, the technology is disrupting the way government functions. However, if we live in countries with stable, existing governmental institutions it may be hard to fully understand the disruptive potential.
- blueprint 9y agoIs it ok if I reply without reading the article if the title is able to be proven patently false? That is... unless we're bending word definitions... :-P
- emodendroket 9y agoProbably, because you'd miss the author's point: other than currency speculation and buying illegal goods there is no compelling use case for the Blockchain. Crowing about BTC appreciation like Bitcoin lovers like to do doesn't disprove the thesis.
- PatchMonkey 9y agoWhat a crock. This is why Medium, as a news source sucks. Literally anyone can say literally anything. Im no bitcoin fanboy either. Bail out, leave the bankers with the bill as revenge for 2008. It was the wrong application of a brilliant idea - a democratically-distributed, obifuscated DNS replacement for secured communications like TOR seems more applicable than the whims of an unregulated currency. But this author doesnt see food-sourcing happening. This author doesn't see banks adapting the blockchain for their own internal uses to protect sensitive info. Or anything else you might find in google.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> This is why Medium, as a news source sucks. Medium isn't a news source, any more than, say, blogspot or LiveJournal is.
- sebleon 9y agoWikileaks is possible because of the blockchain. No question that the world has been changed by this kind of organization. I’m happy that the cartel of financial institutions can no longer shut folks out arbitrarily, looking forward to seeing what else is made possible by the blockchain.