13 ms·
Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her affordable rent is not
- ttul 9y agoAutomated cars will make this kind of commute a lot more practical and enjoyable. A warm, comfortable and clean Uber will pick you up and drive you directly to your destination while you start your work day.
- wbl 9y agoWe've already got the technology to do that. It's called a train.
- stuxnet79 9y agoI had to laugh at this. Crazy how car-centric some regions are.
- strictnein 9y agoI'm not sure why the inaccurate statement that a train can pick you up at your house and drop you off at work made you think about how "car-centric" some regions are.
- wbl 9y agoThe World Trade Center is over a train stop. A typical Wall Street commute is two five minute walks at either end of a train ride.
- strictnein 9y agoThis doesn't improve your argument.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- knowaveragejoe 9y agoNot quite, at least not in the US.
- lykr0n 9y agoThe NYC/Hudson Valley area has this.
- Terretta 9y agoFTA: ”The train leaves at 4:43 a.m. and Cherry, 60 years old and a couple of years away from retirement, rides it all the way to the final stop, more than two hours away. That’s Union Station in downtown Los Angeles. Scheduled arrival time: 7:05.”
- noobermin 9y agoThe solution to this is: more train lines, more frequent and faster trains.
- intopieces 9y agoTrains don't pick you up where you live and drop you off where you work. Self driving cars can do this.
- carbocation 9y agoImagine a combination of self-driving cars and trains. Perhaps the self-driving car can take you to the train station that is nearest, if there is a train that is coming in a reasonable amount of time.
- intopieces 9y agoFor trains to be truly useful, we needed to not build our cities around the highway, around sprawl. We didn't do that. So self-driving cars will prove to be far, far more useful than trains, especially since trains require long term public investment, which Americans generally do not favor.
- ecshafer 9y agoWe can change that. The current city is built around an combination of parking minimums, subsidized free parking, and a system that supports building detached single family homes and not dense mixed use housing. If we change the policies that ruin the cities and design them around the human and not the car, we can make transit work more.
- intopieces 9y agoWe absolutely can change that and we absolutely won't. Rich people don't like transit, they like personal vehicles and sprawling neighborhoods, not loud trains and dense apartment blocks. Rich people write laws.
- wbl 9y agoSo no millionaires live in Manhattan?
- closeparen 9y agoA train picks you up where you live only if you are a 1%er who can afford the extreme real estate premium for transit access on an infrequently spaced system (i.e. BART), or the train stops so frequency that it barely adds value relative to a bicycle (i.e. Muni).
- s0rce 9y agoI suggest, if you haven't you visit London, many places, not all expensive, are a 5-10 minute walk to a regional train stop that can get you to city center in 45minutes.
- closeparen 9y agoI will have to check that out! I suspect that these neighborhoods have a level of density that, if proposed in a typical American suburb, would spark cries of "Manhattanization."
- wutbrodo 9y ago> I suspect that these neighborhoods have a level of density that, if proposed in a typical American suburb, would spark cries of "Manhattanization." Well yea, density is what enables a transit-centric, and American having an intense phobia of density is part of what makes them so car-centric.
- s0rce 9y agoThere is a big middle ground between suburban ranch homes on 0.25 acres and "Manhattan", see some nice areas of dense row (aka. townhouses) houses in London suburbs.
- drieddust 9y agoI have travelled in London for 5 years and it is anything but predictable. My commute of 45 minutes would last anywhere between 45 minutes to two hours depending upon the excuses they will cookup. Sometimes my train travel will be converted to a nice picnic on London bus as train will be cancelled abruptly. Their list of excuses is legendary[1]. And then comes these patronising messages "This [Chrismas|Easter|Weekend|Holiday] I am working for you." I saw those messages for 5 years and still saw services going downhill. One funny anecdote probably illustrates their lethargy. Station I used to board from was upgraded and platform extended to allow boarding from 10 carriages. This happened long before I started living their. But announcement always said only 9 carriages will open. I lived their for two years and same message was played everyday. [1] https://www.standard.co.uk/news/a-year-of-excuses-to-rail-against-6353246.html https://www.standard.co.uk/news/a-year-of-excuses-to-rail-ag... [2] https://www.networkrailmediacentre.co.uk/news/check-before-you-travel-over-christmas-and-new-year-as-investment-on-london-to-norwich-line-continues https://www.networkrailmediacentre.co.uk/news/check-before-y...
- matte_black 9y agoBut at what price? How can a company afford to have a car transport one person at a time for hours for a low price everyday?
- gh02t 9y agoPaying the driver is a pretty big cut. If there's no driver to pay and fuel is cheap (because electric / hydrogen / whatever futuristic efficient tech) then the numbers start to work out. You've also got a persistent customer, so you can probably operate on lower margins since you have a fairly stable customer base.
- JetSpiegel 9y agoAnd then some data miner will discover most workers live near each other and will cut costs by getting a bigger self-driving bus to pickup several people. And then another data miner will discover the bulk of the traffic time is spent on traffic, so they will buy land to create a right-of-way lane to optimise the commute times. Finally, the Ouroboros eats his own tail by creating a private subway system.
- gh02t 9y agoHeh, what I had imagined in my own little scifi vision of the future was a hub system. Everybody gets their own little single seat self driving car pod thing that drives you to the train station. But here's the twist, instead of getting out and boarding the train the pod just drives up and latches in. You're then whisked away in the comfort of your own personalized vehicle, which automatically undocks at the appropriate station and delivers you to your workplace.
- aninhumer 9y agoSo you're carrying around tonnes of useless metal just so people don't have to walk a few feet and sit next to other people?
- xocyabencl 9y agoIf that sort of commute becomes popular, it'll just lead even more massive congestion around job centers. In the limit, you'll reach your destination halfway through the workday and immediately turn around to go home.
- joe_the_user 9y agoCars will simply become mobile bedrooms. It's not legal to camp in your car in a parking place but with a self-driving car, people can just sleep in the back while the vehicle drives aimlessly around. If this process makes traffic go very slowly, so much the better - less gas spent and a gentler ride.
- xocyabencl 9y agoI don't think our roads have the capacity to allow everyone to be sitting on them in their own personal automobiles all day. And even if they do, the roads won't actually function as transportation infrastructure.
- joe_the_user 9y agoNo, indeed the roads don't have that capacity. I was being a bit facetious above and aiming to show the multiple contradictions that seem to be in play in the idea that self-driving cars could solve the interlocked high-rent/absurd-commute problems. I mean, sure, maybe the final absurdity is going to be a mass of people telecomuting from the back of their self-driving RVs as these inch along in some random location but maybe the complex will fall to pieces before this.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoIf all cars were self driving, road capacity could be optimized by 2-3X, at least (they could move smoothly bumper to bumper). It won’t happen in the states first, but highly contested Asian cities in autocratic countries sure.
- mtgx 9y agoHopefully we'll have better options than Uber by then.
- myth_drannon 9y agoTrains are nice too. I can hack on my projects, that's the only time I can work on them during the day. I used to take the subway and it was hell, specially during Canadian winters.
- untog 9y agoExcept that scales horribly. Autonomous cars can't replace public transit, no matter how paranoid Elon Musk is about serial killers.
- Clubber 9y agoI have a 30 minute commute and I dread it every morning and every afternoon. I used to have a 10 minute one.
- hamandcheese 9y agoDo you drive, or take some form of public transit?
- closeparen 9y agoPublic transit at commute-hours crowding levels is a vigorously and overwhelmingly repulsive place to be. Getting away from squeezing into standing room on the 110dB screaming-in-your-face jerking, putrid interior of BART and onto my own feet has been incredible for my mental health, even though the end-to-end time is similar. Tried the Transbay buses also; I can barely stay standing since the drivers seem to rapidly alternate between slamming on the brakes and flooring it. At least the acceleration curve on BART isn't designed to kill you.
- awalton 9y agoI'm pretty committed now to a no-car-ownership lifestyle in the Bay Area, and my commute to and from work is optimally 45 minutes to go ~8 miles. It still feels like a huge sacrifice that I moved down the bay and added ~15 minutes both ways. I'm not sure I could even imagine commuting six hours a day - that has to be soul crushing. And I love riding trains...
- ImSkeptical 9y agoIn my previous location I rode the bus about an hour each day to work. Noise cancelling headphones, plus some good podcasts and a subscription to audible made me quite enjoy it. I almost miss the fact that I'm about two hours a day short on my podcasts and audiobooks.
- shove 9y agoSame. I told recruiters that increase would cost $20k/yr
- 9y ago
- paulsutter 9y agoOnly 42 minutes at 200kph “Without tunnels we’ll be in traffic hell forever” -Elon Musk
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- strictnein 9y agoOnly 1 second at 504,000kph
- ecshafer 9y agoUnless we move to more walking and transit friendly cities with denser mixed use housing. Traffic is a by product of the single family detached home and lack of transit options.
- Clubber 9y ago>Traffic is a by product of the single family detached home and lack of transit options. That's a small part of it. Traffic is also a byproduct of increased population, jobs consolidating into a few large cities, in the US, middle America jobs going outside the border (gotta move to cities), requiring workers to be in the office, even when it's mostly unnecessary, and probably plenty I'm missing.
- asabjorn 9y agoIncreased housing population would not cause traffic if it was connected to work in a way that did not cause traffic. It is demonstrated at this point that sprawl results in traffic pretty quickly, while dense cities with good public transit have a much smaller commute time (e.g. NY, London). In places like Manhattan you could walk to work on Manhattan, so other types of transit is a convenience rather than a necessary.
- jacobolus 9y ago> Traffic is also a byproduct of increased population, jobs consolidating into a few large cities There are plenty of large cities in the world where most people have reasonable (e.g. <30m each way on transit) commutes. The problem with the US is that the infrastructure and regional/urban planning is largely designed to only support low-density development, with unscalable and extremely space-inefficient car transportation for every trip, so when population goes up beyond the capacity of key bottleneck roads everyone is screwed. If you instead build subways, BRT, pedestrian friendly streets, and both office space and medium-density housing near transit corridors, then scaling is much easier by just adding more frequent trains/buses.
- z3t4 9y agoWhat if you could do the commute while sleeping ? Actually every time I get into a moving vehicle I get rocked to the sleep.
- kenhwang 9y agoIt's not uncommon to hear these stories in LA because the math generally works out very favorably. That 280k house in Riverside easily goes for 2-3x where he works in Norwalk. If you could effectively triple your pay by "working" an extra 3 hours a day, would you do it? Especially if those extra commute hours are by train where you could be doing a wide variety of leisure activities, like reading, games, crocheting. No part time second job that I know of can be more enjoyable than a hobby on a train.
- awalton 9y ago> If you could effectively triple your pay by "working" an extra 3 hours a day 6 hours a day - the commute is 3 hours both ways. In other words, she works 9 hours a day, commutes 6 more, and then has 9 more hours to do with what she will, like sleeping (which normal folk like to do for 6-8 hours). So she has about an hour-three hours a day of actual non-work involved free time.
- sliverstorm 9y agoWhich is a sinister part of the whole "buy a nice house far away & commute". The further from work, the less time you even get to spend at that nice house...
- niftich 9y agoThe benefits of that nice house (and the neighborhood, schools, etc.) are ostensibly more so for the benefit of the family than the long-commuting employee themselves -- whether misguided or accurate. When one is single and (relatively) unattached, the calculus is different, as Silicon Valley neatly shows.
- sjg007 9y agoA faster train would help but everyone is upset about building the boondoggle.
- eru 9y ago
- Cyphase 9y agoReminds me of Sam Cookney, who found it to be cheaper and a higher quality of life to commute from Barcelona to London than to live in London. His blog post: https://bestburgerinnorthwestlondon.wordpress.com/2013/10/24/cheaper-to-rent-in-barcelona-and-commute-to-london/ https://bestburgerinnorthwestlondon.wordpress.com/2013/10/24... A Guardian article: https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2015/aug/11/commuting-from-barcelona-a-london-worker-who-makes-it-pay https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2015/aug/11/commuting-fro...
- kaybe 9y ago> “But I think the lifestyle I do have now though is very sustainable.” Considering the amount of fossil fuel that goes into flying, I don't think so. Commuting long-distance by plane is insane on that perspective.
- icantdrive55 9y agoAnd I knew a guy who lived on the Mendocino coast, and arrived in the financial district before at 7:00 am. (It's too depressing, even now, to even look up the millage.) He was slightly excentric, but certifiable after 9 months. They let him go---locked the doors and prayed. Then I knew guys who slept in their cars after work. At first, I thought they were crazy, but so many times I thought maybe I just might try it. You used to be able to rent rooms in the bad parts of SF for under $50, but those days are gone. When I was commuting, I was in construction, and the way I looked really didn't matter. Oh yea, I built Luxury Condos. I knew, I would never be able to set foot in one after I finished building them. It's a great life--for the wealthy.
- spraak 9y agoWhat's crazier is only 4.5 hours of sleep each day. That makes me feel sick thinking about. Makes me feel even more grateful for my 15 second commute from my bed to computer :/
- s0rce 9y agoSleep on the train might help a bit, still crazy.
- duck 9y ago4.5 hours and she is 60 years old. I know for me the older I get the more important getting 7-8 hours is, so not sure how she is pulling that off!
- schuke 9y agoIt's natural that older people tend to need less sleep though.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoIt's normal, but we don't really know why people tend to sleep less as they get older. A lot of things we traditionally viewed as a normal part of aging are now seen as disease pathology. She's also been doing this for 16 years, so age doesn't really explain it anyway.
- nicksergeant 9y agoThat is a common misconception: https://sleepfoundation.org/sleep-topics/aging-and-sleep https://sleepfoundation.org/sleep-topics/aging-and-sleep
- gozur88 9y agoIt's not that they need less sleep, it's that they don't sleep as well as they did in earlier years.
- maxxxxx 9y agoSleeping is harder but you still need the sleep.
- mrhappyunhappy 9y agoI did a 2hr commute from Irvine to la via Metrolink. The actual Metrolink route took 1hr but from home to station and from union station to 8th and grand the total was 2hrs. People asked me why I wouldn’t just drive to work which would take me about an hour. I for one did not care for traffic and having to stay alert for an entire hour whereas on the Metrolink I could just fall asleep, read, listen to podcasts or eat some food. Needless to say the commute was kind of hellish If I had to do it for 16 years. I was happy to quit just 2 years later. After that job I worked remote from home for several years and now freelance full time. I feel pity for anyone who has to commute to work. I should point out that I left work at 4 and was usually home by 6. Nobody left as early as I did but I just didn’t care and made up my own schedule. Nobody objected.
- jmspring 9y agoI'm primarily remote as well. I bounce between the Bay Area and the mountains, depending on time of year. That said, lately driving reverse commute down 680 towards San Jose in the afternoon, I see all those people doing what you yourself mentioned avoiding -- multi hour commutes. In the Bay Area, heading towards Vacaville/Fairfield/the Central Valley, there isn't a real viable non-car option. So much time lost.
- ac29 9y ago> In the Bay Area, heading towards Vacaville/Fairfield/the Central Valley, there isn't a real viable non-car option. The Capital Corridor Amtrak line goes from San Jose to Sacramento, up the East Bay and through Fairfield/Vacaville (where there is a stop). Its the 4th busiest Amtrak line in the country, and largely used by commuters. Connections to Caltrain in San Jose and BART in Oakland are available. No matter how you do it though, an 80+ mile commute into Silicon Valley isnt quick during commute hours.
- jacobkg 9y agoI used to commute from Redlands (60 miles east of LA) to downtown. I rode the Metrolink train. It cost $26 round trip and was 4 hours per day. This was better than driving which I also did. I could work on the train (Ruby on Rails, on Rails). However now I WFH which is far superior. We did only pay $1450 per month for a 2bd/2ba townhouse though.
- mrhappyunhappy 9y agoDid you work on side projects or work work?
- jacobkg 9y agoWork work. I used it as part of the workday so I spent about 6 hours at the office and 4 hours on the train
- bane 9y agoOr another way to look at it, you spent and additional $563/mo on transportation costs. It's an interesting optimization...how much further in could you have moved to get the same housing for the ~$2000/mo you spent for housing + transportation? (my guess is not enough to make the transportation costs drop to near $0)
- mainguy 9y agoLOL, I wonder how many people do "Rails on Rails" as I've worked on multiple projects in the Chicago area where we did just that (1 hour train ride plus 40 minute drive each way for me BTW)...but yes WFH or fly-in fly-out is far better...
- skookumchuck 9y agoAt least on train you can nap. I wonder why Cherry does not.
- osteele 9y ago“I chat, I sleep, I listen to music, my mind wanders, I think about the past and the future.”
- Cyphase 9y agoThe timestamps don't specify seconds, but your comment's id is 4 less than mine, so congrats. :P
- niftich 9y agoIf you're interested in timestamps of comments, the HN API has this [1]. Here's the API request for that post [2], and yours [3]. [1] https://github.com/HackerNews/API https://github.com/HackerNews/API [2] https://hacker-news.firebaseio.com/v0/item/15943530.json?print=pretty https://hacker-news.firebaseio.com/v0/item/15943530.json?pri... [3] https://hacker-news.firebaseio.com/v0/item/15943534.json?print=pretty https://hacker-news.firebaseio.com/v0/item/15943534.json?pri...
- Cyphase 9y agoI figured there was a way; thanks.
- Cyphase 9y agoThe last line of the article: > “I chat, I sleep, I listen to music, my mind wanders, I think about the past and the future,” Cherry says as the train from the land of affordable living arrives on time, halfway through another day of compromise. So she does sleep sometimes.
- skookumchuck 9y ago
- stolk 9y agoI would go home for weekends, and during the week sleep in a van in the parking garage. This works even better if you can make your work week 4 long days, then 3 day weekend away from the city.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoSleeping in a van doesn't sound much better to me, when I was contracting away from home I would often stay in some shitty B&B during the week. It was miserable.
- theNJR 9y agoA nearly exact article was written about someone in SF. To the point I thought this article was old. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/17/business/economy/san-francisco-commute.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/17/business/economy/san-fran...
- supz 9y agoThanks for this. I seemed to recall reading the exact same thing a few months ago, but the persons commute was from Stockton... and here it is. Modularized journalism!
- chrisseaton 9y agoThat article has some caveats - like she gets up at 2:15... but doesn't actually leave the house until 4:00. She gets up so early because 'she likes to take her time'. So while she does have an arduous commute, she just chooses to get up even earlier which makes it sound more extreme than it is.
- vcool07 9y agoI've seen people doing the same in South Korea, where people used to travel from a whole other town to work. They used to leave office around 10 in the night, and would be back in office by 7:30 AM the next day. I used to wonder if they even slept ! Even here at Bangalore/India, I spend close to 3 hours in travel. Fortunately I've pick-up/drop facility to office from home. So, I just sleep in the office cab. It's only strange until you get used to it. Once you are used to the travel routine, you can start to explore newer ways to make the commute time more productive (reading/writing a book, learning a new programming language, taking a power nap etc).
- mainguy 9y agoSo 3 hour commute in Bangalore is what...5km? :) It routinely took me 30-40 minutes to go about 1km...I'd have walked if there was decent sidewalk to be found. THAT city needs to have it's planners fired...but that's a different discussion.
- hkmurakami 9y ago>But I was adamant about my kids having a better life than me." The motivator for many a seemingly crazy, very large sacrifices. I hope things work out well for her children!
- serpix 9y agoThe kids will only learn that it's okay to sacrifice yourself as well. They will learn to do the same and the cycle continues. If she really wants her kids to have a better life she should start from herself.
- juicyfroot 9y agoThen maybe she should work from home
- dawhizkid 9y agoI lived in the TL in SF for 2 years. A studio in a new construction building for $1795/mo with a rooftop (with bbq area and small gym!). My walk to work downtown was 15 minutes. It's actually very funny how the (perceived) worst/cheapest area in SF is right in the center of the city with easy transportation everywhere. Of course, after 2 years I felt mentally exhausted from walking around so many mentally ill homeless and seeing garbage everywhere, but it was a calculus I made at the time and looking back the pros of a short commute, cheap rent for sf, and being centrally located with short walk to lots of transit at civic center muni/bart outweighed the cons.
- ringaroundthetx 9y agoSF is a little unique in that post apocalyptic way A fifteen minute walk with the Walking Dead theme song playing on spotify always beats the commute from hell. You get exercise, cardio, and All of us here are able to monetize those additional 2-9 hours daily to amplify our salaries #yayinequality. Plus lets be honest you can always just walk on Van Ness or summon an uber.
- KeepTalking 9y agoTBH - It makes no economic sense for startups to get $$$$ address in downtown SF than to massage the ego of the founders. This obsession to locate in downtown SF is costing both the company and employees tremendously. If they really want to be located in the city have an ego office in downtown and open satellite offices in the east bay or south bay. Makes for happy employees and cheaper costs.
- junkscience2017 9y agowhy stop there? the last "who's hiring" post made it clear to me that more and more startups are locating outside of the Bay Area entirely
- closeparen 9y agoOne of the factors that permits Bay Area employees to take risks on startups is the density of alternatives. Few people are willing to move across the country as frequently as a normal startup employee changes jobs.
- EGreg 9y agoThis is the problem: http://www.cnn.com/2016/08/23/health/longer-commutes-health-problems/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2016/08/23/health/longer-commutes-health-...
- sethammons 9y agoHey, a relevant article to me. I ride the metrolink from the same station she used to ride from. I have a 35 minute drive to the Riverside metrolink, and I take it down to Orange, another 55 minutes. This is about to expand to 1 hour and 15 minutes when my work moves its office to Irvine. My typical day, I wake up at 4am, drive to Riverside to do some crossfit from 5:30-6:30, and hop on the train at 7am. I get to the office shortly after 8am. Fortunately, I leave around 4pm and am usually home by 6pm. I tend to work on the train, but I can use that for side projects or leisure when I feel like it. After 5 years of doing that, I shifted to working in the office usually 3 days a week, and then remote the last two days of the week. It really has helped. Why do I do it? I really love where I work. It is fantastic. I also really love where I live in the mountains of SoCal. My coworkers have a hard time wrapping their head around dealing with wildlife like bears and things like ice and snow in the winter :). Many also can't process that my mortgage is under half of what they spend on an apartment (that they split with a roommate). My wife is a part time crossfit coach and full time mother, doing home school with our two youngest kids. I've thought about moving close to work, but housing is just so expensive there. Counting commute costs, I would have to spend 4x on a mortgage in the city. I would like to do things like save money for my future and eat healthy foods. So I stay where I'm at. And I'm happy.
- oaxacaoaxaca 9y agoThat's amazing. So do you live in Arrowhead?
- sethammons 9y agoOther side of the mountain, up hwy38
- snowpanda 9y agoYou described what I kind of hope my future to look like, I'd love to live somewhere like that and commute/work remotely. Question: was it hard to get reliable internet out there? With the mountains and all.
- 9y ago
- Reason077 9y agoJudging by the photos, that train looks amazingly spacious and comfortable for a commuter train. It looks luxurious compared to British standards! If you're going to spend 3 hours commuting, that wouldn't be a bad place to do it.
- cjensen 9y agoIt's a Bombardier[1] which are the most common Coach used in California. It's MUCH tighter than it looks in those photos. For example, at the table seats it does not fit two laptops entirely on the table at the facing seats. It's squishy, but serviceable. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombardier_BiLevel_Coach https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombardier_BiLevel_Coach
- Reason077 9y agoAhh, yes. I've ridden those before on the GO in Toronto. But the GO Train is certainly not as well-appointed as Metrolink's version looks!
- randyrand 9y ago*3 hr commute. The title is off by a factor of 2.
- efrafa 9y agoFirst year when I was living in Ireland, I used to commute 1.5h in the morning, and same in the evening. It was a total nightmare, and would never go back to commute like this.
- ksec 9y agoOne reason why we need Full AV. And its lucky to be working in places where 8- 9 hours are norm. In places like South Korea, Japan and HK where you are expected to work from 8 - 8 or more, hours of commute is literally torturing.
- Jyaif 9y agoMore like "One reason we need perfect VR".
- NiklasMort 9y ago"The cost of a thing is the amount of what I call life which is required to be exchanged for it, immediately or in the long run." - Henry David Thoreau
- spike021 9y agoI live in San Jose and commute into downtown SF three days a week (fortunate to have a manager who allows 2 WFH/work from SJ office days a week). My commute is typically 1.5-1.75 hours each way per day, door to door, and that excludes days when Caltrain has some incident or another. But right now I pay a third what I'd be paying, at least, to live closer. I get to save a lot more money, which is nice, but the commute is awful when you realize you're basically throwing away 4 hours a day on the commute. I'm not the type that can get work done on the train either; it's hard enough sitting comfortably for an hour when people elbow me because they think they own the middle arm rest and beyond into my space.
- DrScump 9y agoHalf of the rolling stock has single seats in almost all of the upstairs portion.
- spike021 9y agoIn the mornings when I luck out and get the older trains I always try to get those single seats. But it's tough to luck out and get that rather than the slightly newer stock (I take the bullets). Wish the newer trains (and the next gen ones coming in the next decade) had single seats. Rather unfortunate.
- erikstarck 9y agoWith self driving cars this might become more normal. I wonder how that will affect urban planning and house prices.
- randomsearch 9y agoDon’t have the reference, but I believe that one of the most universal determinants of happiness is the length of your commute, i.e. in cities across the world people who commute longest are least happy. I’ve done commutes ranging from 10 minutes walk to 90 minutes by bus, with lots in between, and strongly recommend that minimising your commute should be a top priority. There’s no point living in a nice place if you don’t see it five days out of seven. Live somewhere convenient and “commute to the country” on the weekend. You can’t get that time back.
- galfarragem 9y ago> "I believe that one of the most universal determinants of happiness is the length of your commute" 1000x this. I've done commutes ranging from 0 to 4,5h daily and I can even affirm that commute discomfort is exponential: a 4,5h commute is way more painful than a 3h commute. I would also add that the sweet spot, IMO, is not zero but around 20 minutes of daily (walking/biking) commute. > "Live somewhere convenient and “commute to the country” on the weekend." Once again, 1000x this.
- erikb 9y agoIt's an important factor, but other factors also come into play. For instance train is way, way more relaxing than any road based commute. And if you struggle to make it to the end of the month because of too high rent, then you are unhappy as well.
- syshum 9y ago>>There’s no point living in a nice place if you don’t see it five days out of seven The point would be your family see's it even if you do not... >Live somewhere convenient and “commute to the country” on the weekend. You act as if people choose to live in the country for ascetics, not economic reasons... Some do, I did at one time, but this article is about people moving to where they can afford to live, and I dont thing they are talking about home in the country side with a stream and woods....
- jhiska 9y ago>I believe that one of the most universal determinants of happiness is the length of your commute. The unemployed must be immeasurably happy.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mfukar 9y ago4 hours of sleep and 6 hours of commute, I bet any person doing that is sane and happy.
- Nitramp 9y agoWhen people clamour about housing development projects destroying their way of life because they increase density etc, this is the other side of the story. The blockade on building might keep some comfort for the fortunate owners of those homes, but forces other, less well off people into pretty terrible living conditions.
- l8again 9y agoSpecifically speaking for tech jobs, why are we still commuting? I honestly don't think why a distributed team can't just work. I have seen teams that are entirely distributed, or with a few members remote that work great. The times I have seen it not work is when there are other things that smell, but remoteness of team members becomes an easy scapegoat to pin the blame. Also, I don't think working from home as a norm is radical. Why do we all have to swarm back and forth to some magical place? Making employees commute is an awfully expensive proposition for quality water-cooler time.
- golergka 9y agoDepends on amount of communication and informal "connectedness" of the team required for the task at hand. There are projects where tasks are clearly separable and all communication required can be done through a task tracker. There are also projects with a lot of active research, tasks constantly shifting, and cultural connection between employees critical (like game dev, with everyone on the team making creative decisions affecting the final product).
- yummy 9y agoSometimes normal verbal communication is just faster. You will never wait 30min to get a simple answer. Want to debug something together? You just do it right away on your computer. And if the office is like 30 min away from home, there's no commuting problem. Yes, that's an hour a day, which is still potentially significant, but on the other hand you don't work at home. I hate working at home and I'm not alone.
- solatic 9y ago> I honestly don't [know] why a distributed team can't just work. So much of human communication is non-verbal. When you're building not just a product, but the team behind the product, getting people in the same room is often crucial for building empathy and trust. That doesn't mean that we shouldn't normalize remote work - most development tasks require uninterrupted concentration in front of a computer and there's no reason why somebody can't spend time at home or a co-working space or wherever else getting it done. But team members need to meet in-person on a regular basis in a non-formal setting to develop that team "jelling".
- IkmoIkmo 9y agoI really wonder if that's the best she can do. Article states her rent is $800 instead of double that, $1600. But it also states she has $400 in commuting costs. (and citing the environment is a reason to take the train, heh). But she's moved into that home when her children were still kids. Surely she doesn't need the space now that they've moved out, and surely something else must be available. I mean, she works 9 hour days, travels for 6... If you add a normal sleep pattern of 8 hours, she's got 1 hour left for life, so she breaks down her sleep structurally. But even then, there's just no time on any of her working days to actually live. In addition, it's as if she had to spend 6 hours in a room every day, unpaid, on a noisy chair. I can't imagine she can't optimise that. I'm hearing: I spend $400 per month to sit in a room 6 hours a day without pay/productivity/leisure, to live in a home with 2 redundant bedrooms, because equivalent rent is $800 more expensive. Surely: 1) can live in a smaller home. 2) can find a slightly better rent. 3) can reduce her commute costs. 4) can earn money through extra work (to trade for leisure) or get more leisure time by cutting commute costs.
- electriclove 9y agoI imagine it has just become her routine now and she is comfortable with it and another 2 years of it until she retires is no big deal to her.
- trophycase 9y agoSo basically she's trading the commodity time for the commodity money.
- mabbo 9y agoI've done 4+ hours of commuting per day before, in the Toronto region. I nearly went crazy. I'd leave at 6:45am and get home after 7pm absolutely exhausted. I'd eat dinner, go to bed by 9, and repeat the process the next day. I couldn't have hobbies other than reading. I couldn't get a gym membership. I couldn't have any real social life outside of weekends. Grabbing a beer after work with coworkers was possible, but it meant a 3 or more hour bus trip home instead, getting home at 11 if I left the bar by 7. It's no way to live. After a year, my wife got a job in the city. She now walks to work and I take the subway. What blows my mind though was the number of people doing this. Why? So that they're kids could have a yard. Never mind that the kids don't use the yard and miss their parents. Any future child of mine will grow up in a condo, but at least they'll grow up with present parents.
- funnelsgun 9y agoI’ve just moved from a 3 hour commute from the suburbs to a 15 minute walk to work. While there are lots of positive changes to living so close to work, I’d just like to add some of the negative ones I’ve found since I moved: 1. A 3 hour commute would leave me exhausted when I got home. I would wake up at 7:30, get into the office at 10:00, leave at 19:00 and be home around 20:30. I’d eat dinner and then settle down for to bed. Since moving I now have so much time in the evenings for practising guitar, video games, reading and social events, but I’m no longer tired in the evenings which is preventing me from sleeping. 2. Living in London is stressful. I’m on a quiet street, but it’s a lot of people, a lot of light pollution and a lot of noise pollution. I’m used to pitch darkness and dead quietness. The air is also no where near as fresh. 3. I find that living so close to work makes it harder to unwind. Upon getting home I’m still in work mode. The commute was a nice chance to forget about work and calm the mind. 4. I used to walk almost 25 miles a week, it’s less than 10 now. Sure I can go running more often, but it requires more effort to enforce the habit. 5. I spend so much more cash living in London on rent, food, social life and dating, which leaves almost none for savings and motorsport/track events/cars.
- mabbo 9y ago> I spend so much more cash living in London This is the weird part for me: moving into the city saved me money overall. In the suburbs where we lived, every person needs a car. It was a 30 minute walk just to get to the nearest store. So we paid insurance, gas, maintenance, etc on two vehicles. In the city, we have one car that we rarely use. If it dies, we'll get a car-share membership. (Frankly, I'm not certain we wouldn't save money if we just did that immediately). The commute wasn't just long before, it was expensive: $400 CAD or more per month. Inside the city, $140 has me covered. Utilities on the small house we rented were nuts, especially in the winter. We pay a fraction of that now. Adding it all up, the increase in rent was less than the saved amount. The only real danger I find now is that I can go out with friends. I have more opportunity to spend money- but at least I'm enjoying spending that money.
- Osiris30 9y agoA very similar article from August 2017 in the NYT on a 4 1/2 commute from Stockton to SF. "A 2:15 Alarm, 2 Trains and a Bus Get Her to Work by 7 A.M" - discussed previously on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15038433 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15038433
- twobyfour 9y agoThat she needs to commute six hours to have affordable rent is crazy.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoIf the place she works can't pay enough for the workers to afford to live closer then shouldn't it be somewhere else? Presumably there's a cost saving (or revenue increase, whatever) for them being there, but they're not pushing on that money to the workers? Could just/largely be a case of controlling forces leeching off workers?
- jhiska 9y agoThe real estate free market is in need of regulation and enforcement.
- TheMagicHorsey 9y agoThese housing issues are a man-made problem. Do you know why you can buy a single-family, 4-bedroom home within 15 minutes train ride of downtown Tokyo for less than $600,000? Two reasons: 1) Japanese zoning laws are set country-wide as a federal matter. There are a fixed number of zone types and local governments (cities and towns) can only choose how to zone their land by assigning land in their control to these different zone types. Examples of zone types are things like: heavy industrial, light industrial, high-density mixed-commercial/residential, residential, etc. These zoning rights preserve a delicate balance between the rights of the property owners and the rights of the city to prevent construction that would cause externalities. It is virtually impossible in the Japanese system for filthy, greedy, piece of shit, bastard landowners to capture local government regulations and use that regulatory capture to push up their property prices by restricting future development. The mix of rights in the Japanese zones is set at the Federal level, local bastards can't add in their own idiosyncracies. You can't do, for example, what San Francisco's dumbshit homeowners do, and turn neighborhoods into no-build zones. In America we try to solve the issue of housing supply by applying band-aids in the form of rent-control, under-market housing, etc. Millenials constantly gripe about not having access to rent-controlled apartments, when really what they should be complaining about is the fact that their parents' generation is not allowing housing to be built. Everyone wants to be one of the lucky ones that gets a rent-controlled apartment in SF. But that's just another way of asking to win the lottery. Other economic problems of Millenials stem from the lack of housing. Millenials can't easily move from economically depressed parts of the country to booming parts of the country (like SF) because housing is so unattainable. Kids that in earlier generations would be moving to new markets and growing their careers are now stagnating in their hometowns, unable to move to brighter pastures. Or if they do move, the move, and the financial burden created by the cost of living at the destination fucking decimates their ability to get a decent start in life. They can't start new businesses, they live in shitty circumstances that prevent them from accumulating a safety fund. Man fuck the baby boom generation ... just writing this comment is getting me so mad. The WORST generation ever. edit: just realized I didn't even get to point 2. Well I have to start work, so I'll have to come back and edit this at some point.
- cornholio 9y agoThe horrors of the american (lack of) urban planning and fixation with the suburban house. A satelite view of LA area shows vast areas of suburban houses with pools and lawns - people living in those areas don't want tall buildings in their backyard and enjoy the appreciation in property value, but the society as a whole is losing 10 times as much by commuting, infrastructure to suport it and lost productivity.
- bluekite2000 9y agoOn a related topic, what are the pros and cons of having a toll on the freeways during peak hours? I find this works well in many countries.
- jswizzy 9y agoThis is why I live in the South. Cost of living is low and you can live like a king on nothing.250k will buy you a Mansion here near the beach.