19 ms·
Newman's Own faces mammoth tax bill after lawmakers fail to spare the foundation
- mikestew 9y ago“The problem is a 1969 tax law that bars foundations from owning more than a small stake in private businesses.” So this isn’t exactly news, and it certainly wasn’t news when Newman’s lawyers wrote his will. As much as I want to sympathize and scream “those Republican bastards!”, I kinda think this is a problem of Newman’s (be it the man, the company, or the foundation) own doing.
- tomcam 9y agoUpvoted, probably futilely, because it's unpleasantly true
- mikestew 9y agoI kinda posted that hoping someone with a qualified opinion would come along and say, “no, you fscking idiot, you’ve got it all wrong, and here’s why...”. Because I like the products, and the Newman entities at least appear to do good stuff. Alas, 28 points of upvoting later, no one’s calling me an idiot.
- sitkack 9y agoBeing correct != being right
- rashkov 9y agoThat may be so, but don't we want a company like newman's own to exist and do good in the world? Maybe they shouldn't exist under the current tax regime, but it's not the company that's in the wrong but rather the system that it operates under.
- adventured 9y agoPlease explain, if you would, why you think a charity should be able to own majority positions in for profit operating businesses and shield the profits from that private business behind a charity-based tax approach. That can enable, among other things, vast abuses by companies that set up charities just to act as a front for private businesses to shield profits from high tax brackets. The charity still has to distribute a certain modest percentage of their assets per year, and that pales in comparison to paying 30% or more in taxes. So you set up Burger Charity (or call it McDonald's Charity), which owns BurgerStand USA (operating restaurants). BurgerStand generates profit and kicks it back to Burger Charity almost entirely tax free. Burger Charity uses the tax free proceeds to accumulate vast amounts of real estate, which it then leases to BurgerStand (at an artificially cheap rate made possible by the low tax structure, providing a competitive advantage) for restaurant locations. Then they can do the same for equipment in the restaurants as well (Burger Charity owns the equipment and leases it to BurgerStand at an artificially low rate). Perhaps you set up Burger Equipment Corp that you own, and Burger Land Holdings Corp that you own, they all work with BurgerStand USA (the profits of which all kick back to Burger Charity mostly tax free). Cycle and repeat for an astounding tax avoidance scheme that provides a blatantly unfair advantage to an entity willing to abuse the charity approach.
- StanislavPetrov 9y ago>That can enable, among other things.. You're entirely missing the point. The point is that our tax laws should be written in a way to enable an entity like Newman's Own to operate without enabling the many abuses you describe.
- Ntrails 9y ago> The point is that our tax laws should be written in a way to enable an entity like Newman's Own to operate without enabling the many abuses you describe. People have this naive view that tax law is insanely complex and full of loopholes for fun and/or profit. It isn't. It's largely because well intentioned people tried to do a "right thing" for some specific circumstance and unintended consequences made the outcomes wrong. So you plug two holes when there's an outcry but 2 months later some other politician has a great idea and accidentally makes three new ones.
- isleyaardvark 9y agoIt was also a decision by the Parliamentarian, which is a non-partisan position. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parliamentarian_of_the_United_States_Senate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parliamentarian_of_the_United_...
- stuff4ben 9y agoNOOOO! I love their salad dressing!
- dvdhnt 9y agoIdiotic and laughable result - much like our tax code.
- dvdhnt 9y agoLol down voted... I see the $heep are in full force :)
- shas3 9y agoThe most famous case of foundations being sued for owning businesses is Howard Hughes Medical Institute and Hughes Aircraft, which was then the largest defense contractor in the US: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hughes_Aircraft_Company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hughes_Aircraft_Company
- mirimir 9y agoThey can sell formulas and names, right? So it'll only be the charity that's missing.
- code_duck 9y agoI wonder what charities primarily benefit from Newman?
- DoubleCribble 9y agoHere's one. (I'm sure Butch & Sundance would be proud.) https://www.holeinthewallgang.org/about/Founder-and-History/ https://www.holeinthewallgang.org/about/Founder-and-History/ There are undoubtedly others he created and/or the foundation continues to support.
- code_duck 9y agoWhat I'm speculating about specifically is whether there is any political issues around the charities or causes that Newman's Own supports. There could be more to the story than just an arbitrary rule enforcement.
- cjcole 9y agoIt's a plausible inference given the timing and Newman's politics while alive [1], and maybe it does apply to the other charities (I don't know one way or the other), but at least with respect to The Hole in the Wall Gang Camp (for seriously ill children), in my personal experience, it is conspicuously apolitical. So much so that I suspect that the staff is trained to that effect. [1] https://www.alternet.org/story/100666/paul_newman%27s_politics https://www.alternet.org/story/100666/paul_newman%27s_politi... "Unrepentant liberal, Newman was dedicated to civil rights, women's rights, gay rights, and was determined to elect opponents of war and militarism."
- code_duck 9y ago
- RichardCA 9y agoThis just means the issue needs to be addressed in a separate, "clean" bill rather than being piggy-backed on top of the reconciliation process. If things were normal in Congress, it would be a no-brainer.
- kbutler 9y agoHave things ever been "normal" in Congress? The practice of piggy-backing your little bill on other bills that are likely to pass has been around a long time. Presidents have asked for a line-item veto since at least Reagan, and it was even in the Confederate States constitution. But yes, there should be a general rule and practice that bills don't address multiple unrelated topics.
- ubernostrum 9y agoThe CSA Constitution is kind of the perfect example of the "stopped clock is right twice a day" aphorism. It was intended to create a separatist society in which brutal race-based slavery would be permanently enshrined and protected. And also happened to include line-item veto and a provision forbidding "Christmas-tree" style multi-subject bills.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoThe Nazis built good rockets. Just because you don't like someone's politics doesn't mean they can't do other things well.
- smt88 9y agoPoint taken, but "someone's politics" is really underselling the Holocaust and hundreds of years of chattel slavery.
- deadmetheny 9y agoThe idea that everything bad people did is inherently bad is nonsense. The holocaust and slavery aren't the point of the discussion.
- abtinf 9y agoHow does this work with the Mozilla foundation owning a massive for profit company?
- dangrossman 9y ago"Mozilla Foundation" is not a private foundation, but a 501(c)(3) public charity. That's the difference. Public charities are exempt from the private foundation rules that prohibit excess business holdings.
- rconti 9y agoThis is sort of ironic, because isn't this precisely what the president is accused of doing? Sheltering money from taxes in a foundation? Or is it accusations of laundering rather than tax sheltering? I guess I don't quite get the difference, either. Regardless, both cases show that it's pretty hard to actually get caught doing it.
- hkmurakami 9y ago>Sheltering money from taxes in a foundation? That's more what Soros is doing. Edit: since I'm being down voted to hell, here's my source https://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/george-soros-transfers-18-billion-to-his-foundation-creating-an-instant-giant-1508252926 https://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/george-soros-transfers-18-b... WSJ is biased in general but their reporting of tax loopholes here is legitimate. Avoids accumulated capital gains tax on all transferred assets. $18B in gross assets. I am happy to hear counter arguments of how this is not a foundation based tax dodge / tax shelter.
- dailyvijeos 9y agoConspiracy theory bullshit rhetoric has no place on HN. Go back to Alex Jones.
- hkmurakami 9y agohttps://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/george-soros-transfers-18-billion-to-his-foundation-creating-an-instant-giant-1508252926 https://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/george-soros-transfers-18-b... Here is my source. WSJ is biased in general but their reporting of tax loopholes here is legitimate. Avoids accumulated capital gains tax on all transferred assets. $18B in gross assets.
- plcancel 9y agoThere is an interesting interview with Robert Reich on foundations and philanthropy here: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2017/09/rob_reich_on_fo.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2017/09/rob_reich_on_fo.htm... Transcript at the bottom. Coincidentally, Reich offers anecdote regarding Soros and taxes at about 30 minutes into interview. However, I'm posting this for its general coverage of the topic. (edited to clarify)
- ggg9990 9y agoThis is not a big deal. It will get saved with a special bill that will pass 99-0, Rand Paul will probably abstain.
- calebm 9y agoThey should just follow the Scientology path of suing the IRS like 24k times and hiring PIs to follow around IRS workers :)
- jstewartmobile 9y agoHumorously cut to the heart of the matter? Go to your room! And don't come out until you're ready to admit that US laws aren't just lipstick on raw power.
- bartart 9y agoIt seems like it would be best for the foundation to sell Newman's and use the proceeds to create an endowment. They could use investment gains from the endowment over time to find their charitable mission, and it would also be good because their assets wouldn't be so concentrated in the food business, which is hyper competitive and pretty low margin.
- onion2k 9y agoWould it be possible for the Newman's brand to continue profitably without the charitable aspect of its messaging? Would customers remain loyal if, say, Kraft bought it? If not then it's not going to sell for very much..
- zxcmx 9y agoYep, but you can't necessarily sell it for full value because the process of doing that damages the brand.
- winslow 9y agoIs it looked down upon with what Newman's Own does with the charity? They make good products and it is neat that they donate profits (after tax) to charity. Just curious how well it was utilized etc. Quick research shows that it helped some pretty good causes at least on the surface. Does anyone know any more about it?
- adventured 9y agoNo, it's just not getting attention in the current atmosphere. Newman's Own has held on to their status (in terms of how their structure is treated) by the skin of their teeth over the years, usually getting one exception granted after another (the can being kicked down the road). Republicans haven't made a big show about disliking Newman's Own or what they do, there's no indication they're doing this to specifically hurt them.
- cjcole 9y agoI have personal experience with "The Hole in the Wall Gang Camp" and have nothing but positive things to say about it. I don't and can't know how efficiently they use their money (I didn't notice any extravagance), but it is an extraordinary experience for the children attending and they (as far as I could see) uniformly love it. https://www.holeinthewallgang.org/ https://www.holeinthewallgang.org/ The Hole in the Wall Gang Camp is dedicated to providing “a different kind of healing” to seriously ill children and their families, free of charge.
- youdontknowtho 9y agoSo they knew that the law imposed this penalty and then didn't comply? I have to admit, I support confiscatory taxes. We can't depend on wealthy people's charity to operate society.
- dnautics 9y agoWhat makes you say we're doing a good job of relying on government stewardship to operate society? Is a popularity contest the best way to select the person who has the last call on charitable management? How's that going?
- youdontknowtho 9y agoyeah, democracy is overrated.
- dillondoyle 9y agoIf the problem is a fixed max % ownership rule, why not just create 3 or 4 separate holding companies so each has ownership below threshold - surely there's a reason this isn't the simple solution?
- drtillberg 9y agoThe tax is reported as two times income. To me, a 99% charge might be a tax, but a 200% charge ought to be a Fifth Amendment taking.
- tomohawk 9y agoRegardless of the merit/demerits in this case, this is an aspect of tax law that I've always found distasteful - the special little one-offs. Laws should be general and apply equally to all. The US Constitution forbids bills of attainder. These special loop holes for individuals seem very much like bills of attainder.
- dragonwriter 9y agoA bill of attainder is an act of a legislature declaring a particular person guilty of a crime and prescribing criminal punishment; they aren't the same thing as this, which is (in effect of not in name) a private bill, which are well established as Constitutional.
- bovermyer 9y agoOK, so while everyone else is arguing about whether Newman's Own should be allowed to operate as it has or not, I'm curious about a different issue. What's a parliamentarian, and why can they unilaterally change bills? Or am I misunderstanding their role?
- kale 9y agoThe senate has the filibuster provision to give the minority party the ability to slow down or block legislation. To overcome a filibuster, 3/5* of the senate have to vote to end it. At some point, the senate was afraid of gridlock, so there was a special provision made for things that deal with money (not sure if tax only), where things that have a minimal impact on the budget can overcome a filibuster with a simple majority. The parliamentarian is the one who decides if a bill is "minimal impact", which is set at $1.5T at the moment. Therefore the parliamentarian has decided that changing the non-profit law would cause this tax bill to be more than $1.5T in net change, meaning it can be filibustered. Edit: Wikipedia article [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parliamentarian_of_the_United_States_Senate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parliamentarian_of_the_United_... [2] * corrected my math, thanks to dragonwriter
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The senate has the filibuster provision to give the minority party the ability to slow down or block legislation. In theory, that's not the purpose; the Senate has a tradition of unlimited debate, to assure proposals are fully vetted before being decided, though, yes, they clearly have that effect. > To overcome a filibuster, 2/3 of the senate have to vote to end it. No, to invoke cloture, 3/5 of the Senate have to vote to end debate [0], which is why you hear about a 60 vote bloc being filibuster-proof. [0] https://www.rules.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?p=RuleXXII https://www.rules.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?p=RuleXXII
- probablyfiction 9y agoThe parliamentarian is someone who is thoroughly familiar with all of the Senate's rules. They ensure that bills that are passed comply with the rules that the Senate operates under. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parliamentarian_of_the_United_States_Senate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parliamentarian_of_the_United_...
- nerdponx 9y agoCan't Newman's Own reincorporate _itself_ as a charitable organization?