13 ms·
The beginning of the end for copper wire
- rmason 9y agoThis really hits home for me. I'm using a DSL modem and still have landline phone that is far more reliable for me than my cell phone.
- distances 9y agoHow does unreliability show itself with a cell phone? My data isn't always flowing perfectly, but can't remember problems with calls since 2000 or so.
- rmason 9y agoTwo reasons basically: 1. I needed a separate box at home tied to my wifi to even get a signal on my phone. Thankfully after switching to Google Fi and a Pixel phone I no longer need the box. 2. If I'm making a business call and making the sale depends on a clear connection that will not drop the landline phone still wins out.
- ams6110 9y agoRepublic Wireless will automatically place and receive calls over your home (or any connected) WiFi. Works great for me as I get barely 1 bar of cell signal at home.
- exabrial 9y agoThe article brings up DSL, but I thought DSL was a short haul technology (you have to be pretty close to a branch office or something)? Would it really affect rural customers anyway? I'm also curious if the newer faster fiber technologies are sort of "subsidizing" the carrier's copper business.
- lostlogin 9y agoHere in NZ copper is lining teleco pockets to the extent that The Commerce Commission investigated them, and gave the a slightly hard time. http://www.radionz.co.nz/news/business/282222/cheaper-copper-wire-price-hits-chorus-profit http://www.radionz.co.nz/news/business/282222/cheaper-copper...
- delinka 9y agoI have DSL and I'm 10 miles away from the nearest ... building with lots of switches. However, the copper line used for my DSL is less than a mile long. I live inside the town limits, but out at the edge of town, there's a roadside hub. And there's fiber into that hub.
- maxerickson 9y agoThey put in cabinets/huts and run it from there.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- toast0 9y agoDSL with nice speeds requires a short run, but something like 768k can work reasonably far (5+ km)
- abalashov 9y agoIt was originally a short-haul technology, but quickly extended by way of remote DSLAMs. Copper from the neighbourhood into the DSLAM, fiber out the back.
- bluedino 9y agoAT&T has basically been bullying customers out of their POTS lines for the last few years. Instead of paying, saying $34.95 for a line they'll increase it to $89 or $135 per line. Then they'll sell you a 'bundle' with a cellular phone or tablet with data plan at a lower price than your old rate for just the old analog line alone. Not sure how the math works out. Since the contract is up after a year, then you have start a new bundle or pay up. They're selling WebEx, Office 365...everything.
- asmithmd1 9y agoLuckily phone companies cannot do this. Because AT&T was granted a monopoly, each state has Public Utility Commission that sets the rate the AT&T "Baby Bell" phone companies can charge: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_utilities_commission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_utilities_commission
- abalashov 9y agoA lot of times, the process looks more like: - AT&T declares the rate it will charge in its [Red State] PSC tariff filing; - [Red State] PSC stamps it. But yes, it is certainly true that they cannot just charge capricious and whimsical rates that change daily at their pleasure, or anything like that.
- twunde 9y agoYou can remove the red state. It applies to blue states as well for telecom and energy
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoThis. Nobody has a monopoly on corruption and back room dealing.
- thenewwazoo 9y agoOf course not, but one of the two major parties has absolutely made such things one of their policy planks. Don't make a false equivalency.
- thecybernerd 9y agoThis is exactly what Verizon did to parts of the NE after Hurricane Sandy. They provided CDMA/LTE based pots services in areas in which they didn't feel it was economical to rewire with fiber.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ztjio 9y agoThe point is that they won't have to do that. They won't have to do anything. They will be allowed to simply leave such people without an alternative if they want.
- knolan 9y agoCopper can still play a role. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/G.fast https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/G.fast
- Godel_unicode 9y agoFrom Wikipedia: "...for local loops shorter than 500 m"
- maltalex 9y agoIt's doable in many cities. A large part of the infrastructure you need to replace when upgrading is inside buildings. With a 500m radius, you can avoid rewiring buildings and have loops terminate in the street.
- selectodude 9y agoDepends on how old the copper is, though. If it needs to be replaced, you might as well run metro ethernet or FTTH.
- philjohn 9y agog.fast is good for more densely populated areas, which is why it'll work quite well in the UK if BT ever get around to rolling it out properly - 90% of consumer premises are within 500m of a street side cabinet.
- mjevans 9y agoI consider that 'the option' for when a building owner refuses to re-wire with something that can be serviced by metro-Ethernet. Ethernet is, of course, ~90-100 meters (not 500) but most MDUs need to have utility closets/areas within 100 meters for other reasons anyway; so you often there can either be copper or fiber back-haul links past that first switch. The major pain point is probably neighborhoods where the exposure to outside conditions means increased likelihood of some idiot trenching incorrectly and/or disasters where high voltage might come across the line (making fiber to at least the side of the building preferable for safety reasons).
- JackFr 9y agoI'm in an apartment building in NYC. While a new service elevator was being installed, the elevator guys cut my phone line 3 times, and 3 times Verizon came out to fix it, at no cost to me. However after the third time, the building management refused to allow copper wire service to continue in the building. It turns out I was 1 of only 2 apartments which hadn't already moved to a cable/internet/phone package from one of three available providers. It annoyed me to have to switch, but ultimately it turned out to be cheaper, even after the initial contract expired.
- justin66 9y ago> the elevator guys cut my phone line 3 times I would be a little concerned about the safety of that elevator.
- oh_sigh 9y agoHard to tell. The phone line may have been wired incorrectly or poorly which required the tech to do that
- justin66 9y agoA POTS telephone line, which is what we're talking about here, can handle being cut and reconnected without a fuss. It would appear the elevator guys did not notice what they had done or did not understand its importance.
- oh_sigh 9y agoI agree. But if a field tech knows that a low voltage line is incorrectly in his work space and that someone will fix it if he does cuts it, then the tech may just cut it and let someone else deal with the problem.
- bcoates 9y agoParticularly after the POTS line was disabled! I'd be inclined to check the emergency call button on that elevator and see if anyone picks up.
- maltalex 9y agoPardon the possibly ignorant question, but what do the telecom companies have to gain by destroying their own infrastructure? I feel like I'm missing something about the US telecom market here. Aren't these companies making a profit on this infrastructure? Are they selling more profitable services and they want users to switch over? Are the maintenance fees that high?
- bm1362 9y agoIt’s not destroying the infrastructure, it’s abandoning it. The article states that prior to this ruling they’re required to maintain or replace with comparable functionality for existing copper customers. This ruling let’s them abandon them altogether from what I gathered.
- maltalex 9y agoOk, but there are still paying customers on the end of that infrastructure. Are they not profitable enough?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Rovanion 9y agoSince they have local monopolies they can trust they will regain the user but on infrastructure that is cheaper to maintain.
- andrewtbham 9y agoMy understanding is rural access is often unprofitable. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Service_Fund https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Service_Fund
- imglorp 9y agoYet we've been paying into this fund decades, which was supposed to pay for rural access. Now, Relieving the telcos of this obligation despite them not completing universal access amounts to corporate welfare for those poor starving giants. Then there's E911. Of a bigger concern in rural areas will be losing access to 911. A lot of homes still keep landlines just for the 911 capabilities. Under the old rules the carriers had to demonstrate that customers would still have access to reliable 911, but it seems the carriers can now walk away without worrying about this. This is also a health and safety issue.
- gigavinyl 9y agoAhh so they're trying to eliminate non-evil DSL competitors like sonic.net so we have no alternatives after Title II kicks the bucket.
- cperciva 9y agoHighly relevant quote: At one time, 80% of AT&T's capital value was the copper in the local loops. AT&T was then, in effect, the world's largest copper mine. Fortunately, this fact was not widely known in the investment community. Had it been known, some corporate raider might have bought AT&T, terminated all telephone service in the United States, ripped out all the wire, and sole the wire to a copper refiner to get a quick payback. -- Andrew S. Tanenbaum, Computer Networks
- alexandros 9y ago...because organizing a hostile takeover, paying for the contract terminations, ripping out all the copper, cleaning it and gathering it all up in a form that can be delivered to a copper refiner, and finally shuttering the business and tying all loose ends is actually free, and in fact will somehow magically pay you not only the missing 20% of the price you paid, but an additional 20-60% you need to justify your trouble.
- matwood 9y agoExactly. Plus getting past the government when you announce you're canceling phone service for the entire country.
- olympus 9y agoIt is likely that someone did realize this, did the math on the labor costs to pull all the wire up across the country, and realized it wouldn't actually be profitable. There are guys that track individual ships across the ocean to decide what/when to trade, I doubt everyone missed the value of ATT's physical assets.
- cperciva 9y agoI don't think that Tanenbaum was being completely serious. The point is to put the value of that copper (and the cost of replacing it in the event that it is damaged) into perspective.
- coding123 9y agoIts silly to think that copper itself is going away simply because the phone system won't be using much of it anymore, almost all electricity from AC to DC wires run over copper and various alloys.
- chrisper 9y agoAlso all Speaker wires are copper.
- microcolonel 9y ago> ...almost all electricity from AC to DC wires run over copper and various alloys. Aren't most OPLs aluminium these days?
- icantdrive55 9y agoYea, copper and it's alloys are relative cheap. Aluminum wire did not work out for residential/commercial wiring. It's going to be here for awhile.
- HumanDrivenDev 9y agoBy AC to DC wires, are you referring to your typical laptop power cord? IE, copper from the wall to the transformer/DC converter, then copper to the power supply of the laptop? I remember having an labouring job installing power supply cable underground. It was all aluminium, and you rolled it off a giant spool because you could barely bend it.
- colechristensen 9y agoPower lines for the grid are generally aluminum. You'll generally only find copper in consumer goods and the walls of your house. You can get aluminum wiring in your house but there are details that require more installation expertise to do it safely so copper is used instead.
- ztjio 9y agoThis isn't about all copper wire. It's using copper to refer to the old copper wire based POTS.
- mrmondo 9y agoWhile the Australian right wing govt scrapped all the fibre to the home work that was underway and decided that copper from the node to the house was a great upgrade. The internet in Australia is so bad I had significantly better in New Zealand a decade ago.
- walshemj 9y agoFTC Fibre to CAB and using existing coper for the drop to the house makes sense as you can get good performance with VDSL over 20MBS at a 2K yards
- jackvalentine 9y agoThis chart suggests at 1800m you can expect below 20mbps https://www.increasebroadbandspeed.co.uk/2013/chart-bt-fttc-vdsl2-speed-against-distance https://www.increasebroadbandspeed.co.uk/2013/chart-bt-fttc-... Which is both slower than the fibre that had already been planned, and slower than the then incoming government's "25mbps for everyone by end of 2016" promise (which they missed). It also doesn't have a good cheap upgrade path and assumes that the copper is good and doesn't need to be replaced (it isn't, and it does in many places).
- walshemj 9y agoAnd does the average consumer need more than 20MBS and more to the point be willing to pay for it. Some of the more extreme claims that we all need GB speed links don't make sense its like saying every house/flat needs a 56Kv 3 phase power supply.
- jackvalentine 9y ago> And does the average consumer need more than 20MBS and more to the point be willing to pay for it The most commonly purchased NBN service in 2016 is 25mbps Down 5mbps up. (51%) and 14% of customers buy 100/40: So yes to both questions. And that’s 2016. Why skate to where the puck is rather than where it’s going?
- agjacobson 9y ago“I don’t envision AT&T and Verizon tearing down huge amounts of copper in towns immediately.“ That’s not the point. When failures occur, they stop fixing the wires and send you a letter telling YOU what your new mode of service is, or nothing. There is no tearing down. The unsupported wire is left to rot or be salvaged at their convenience.
- killjoywashere 9y agoThe term we used was "abandoned in place".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cavisne 9y agoDoes ATT have an alternate asset? As far as I know they dont run a cable network or a significant fttp network so I dont see why they would remove any broadband customers. Dial up and landline only customers I can see being moved to LTE. I dont see anything about the USF going away so I dont see why anyone would be left behind, USF's are normally highly profitable for the telco. For the edge cases that cant receive a mobile signal with a roof mounted antenna, I guess a subsidized satellite phone will be the solution.
- rayiner 9y ago> USF's are normally highly profitable for the telco. USF is paid for by a tax on telecom service which, in effect, redistributes money from telcos with more urban/suburban customers to telcos with more rural customers (and imposes a deadweight loss on the industry as a whole from the tax). AT&T probably falls into the bucket of telcos that lose rather than profit from the USF scheme.
- sitkack 9y ago> ATT have an alternate asset National fiber network and land.
- maxerickson 9y agoThey segment their reporting, page 18 of this document shows their consumer segment: https://investors.att.com/~/media/Files/A/ATT-IR/financial-reports/annual-reports/2016/att-ar2016-completeannualreport.pdf https://investors.att.com/~/media/Files/A/ATT-IR/financial-r... They had as many people on Uverse video (which I guess is fiber) in 2014 as they had on copper phone lines in 2016.
- abalashov 9y agoAnother important goal of this strategy, given relatively short mention in the article, > allows the telcos to eliminate old copper wholesale services like resale. is to cut CLECs out of the circuit game, to the extent they still sell T-circuits and (more likely) Ethernet transport over telco copper through the UNE (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unbundled_network_element https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unbundled_network_element) facility). Since the Telecommunications Act of 1996 (TA96), UNE rules have required incumbents to lease portions of their physical plant to CLECs at regulated rates. These do not apply to fiber. Making it impossible for CLECs to ride portions of their network to compete with them has been a major goal of pulling out copper, and has often led to it being pulled out more aggressively than it otherwise would be.
- sitkack 9y agoMany of the owners of copper lines have gotten huge subsidies on their switching centers. Those switching centers which often take up an entire city block are now free for land development. Hundreds of billions in land value just got "given" to the largest telcos.
- Zenst 9y agoCertainly an opportunity for VOIP services and a router with a PSTN connection so you can plug in your existing phone will work out as a perfect solution. Such routers been around for ages, some even have DECT built in. One avenue that could be taken by the companies to mitigate any loss of voice service. Customer would be just changing the point they plug the phone in, socket wise and that would be that. I had a Draytek 2910vg 10 years ago doing exactly that, so very very doable. But then, that was always a solution under the existing criteria and with that, this change just allows companies to not offer that solution. Which does raise one question - will customers be able to keep their existing number and port it to a VOIP provider of their choice? That is one aspect that could of been covered in these changes. That would certainly open up the markets and in a good way.
- abalashov 9y agoTA96 rules mandate number portability. But you can't port a number outside of a rate centre. To put it simply, to port a number to a new carrier, the carrier has to be able to pick the call up somewhere, by way of the appropriate connections to the incumbent's "tandem" offices (think of it as a kind of hub for the spokes that are Bell central offices). The underlying PSTN origination supply chain for the VoIP industry consists of a small oligopoly of CLECs at this point (e.g. Level3, Bandwidth.com, Verizon Business, Onvoy and all the companies they bought, etc.) and they don't necessarily have the interconnections and footprint in these same markets — most especially not the "Tier 3" plus rural markets.
- Zenst 9y agoSo they end up locking you into a call forwarding service, which entails you end up paying for them to do very little, with any maintenance liability already covered by existing liabilities. Starting to see why they wanted the change now.
- abalashov 9y agoPretty much, yeah. For a CLEC, interconnecting in any given LATA[1] is a complex and costly endeavour—I mean the actual interconnecting, not opting into an interconnection agreement (ICA) for one purpose or another. CLECs are not beholden to any universal service obligations or similar social policy objectives, and will only connect in higher-density metro-type markets in which there is profit in doing so. The business case has to be there, and that generally comes in the form of downstream VoIP service providers having customer demand in that area. So, hyper-rural folks are deeply out of luck. We deal with this scenario all the time in my line of work: "hey, anyone know someone who can port a number in this $LOCAL_YOKEL territory out in $NEVER_HEARD_OF_IT?" [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local_access_and_transport_area https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local_access_and_transport_are...
- gerbilly 9y agoMan we're getting to be so cheap. In Canada we stopped minting pennies because copper was too expensive. Also those pex pipes they install in houses are probably popular because copper is expensive. What's next, the return of aluminum wiring? We had a week long blackout here a few years ago, my wall phone running off copper twisted pair was the only electrical thing working in the house. I was glad, because I had better things to do than line up at starbucks to charge my cellphone like everyone else was doing. Remember that ancient looking phone Adama was always shouting into on Batllestar Galactica? Maybe they were onto something. That ship survived because it was the oldest ship in the fleet.
- RyJones 9y agoyou're right: one advantage to PEX is price of PEX itself. Other advantages: easier to install, no sweated joints, easy to color code, of no value to meth addicts. No sweating lowers the fire risk (which tbh is very low, but non zero). I suspect even if PEX cost 5x copper tubing, the TCO for PEX would still be lower over the lifetime of the plumbing. Shipping and moving around a spool of PEX is much easier than monkeying with a load of copper tubing. I wish the US would join Canada in dropping the penny.
- gerbilly 9y agoI'm not so sure about pex though. Seems like a cheap replacement to copper pipe. There have been defects causing lots of water damage. Plus I'm not sure i want my drinking water sitting in plastic all day picking up whatever chemicals they used to make the pipe. Copper is naturally antibacterial, and just seems safer to me, given that we've been using it for decades.
- ztjio 9y agoIt seems like a lot of commenters don't understand the problem. The issue is not about whether that copper wire can be useful. It's not about whether there exist alternatives to provide in places where the copper is too expensive to maintain. The point is that regulations previously required the telco provide an alternative service that works just as well as the existing copper before they are allowed to stop maintaining the copper. But that is no longer the case as of this vote. Now when the telco doesn't want to pay to maintain the copper they can simply do nothing at all, which absolutely will leave people without any form of telecommunication in some areas.
- lucio 9y agoThen that will be a good market for a startup, or other players. Are the telcos obliged to provide you with telecommunication?
- maxerickson 9y agoHistorically, yes, telcos have been obliged to provide service. The post you replied to mentions this: The point is that regulations previously required the telco provide an alternative service that works just as well as the existing copper before they are allowed to stop maintaining the copper. But that is no longer the case as of this vote.
- chx 9y agoUnder current rules yes and they are paid for it. Check Connect America Fund
- brians 9y agoYes, in return for getting poles along streets throughout the rest of America. Similarly, they have to interconnect with other telcos.
- charliesome 9y agoIn other parts of the world, yes. Telstra in Australia is bound by the Universal Service Obligation, for instance: https://www.acma.gov.au/Industry/Telco/Carriers-and-service-providers/Obligations/universal-service-obligation-obligations-i-acma https://www.acma.gov.au/Industry/Telco/Carriers-and-service-... This is an area where it's critically important to regulate the market to make it actually work for the people, not just profit margins. If the service providers were not obliged to provide service to people in remote areas at the same price as everyone else, no service provider would.
- JosephHatfield 9y agoShortly after I moved into my current place, I wanted to switch to the most basic copper-based landline service available, and I had to work through a series of six service reps and managers before someone would even acknowledge that such a plan was available. Since then, I get monthly mailings and quarterly phone calls from them strongly encouraging me to sign up for some fiber-based service. So far, I've resisted, but I fear this ruling may signal the beginning of the end of my inexpensive, reliable, phone line.
- gumby 9y agoLet's not forget alarm service, which is why I keep my copper loop.
- jgowdy 9y agoNewer alarms often have cellular modems and enough battery to make the call even if you cut the power.
- gumby 9y agoIn a crisis, the wired phone network, even with a neighborhood concentrator, is more likely to stay up than the cellular network. Of course, in a crisis, I may not get a response to the alarm.
- twothamendment 9y agoTrue, but it sounds like rural homes are the ones at risk of losing copper. They are the same homes that done have reliable cell service. I don't have reliable cell service at home. It is ok some days, but I bet there is only one tower and some days it just disappears.
- chmaynard 9y agoThe FCC chairman appears to be listening only to corporate lobbyists. I consider this to be a dereliction of duty, but of course Trump thinks otherwise. As long as Trump is in power, the rules are going to keep changing in favor of corporate interests. Those of us who oppose the new regime at the FCC need to start thinking about what economic tools we can use to discourage telecoms from taking advantage of FCC rule changes that we think will harm internet freedom and the common good.
- alsetmusic 9y agoWhite House petition: https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/we-people-call-resignation-fcc-chairman-ajit-varadaraj-pai https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/we-people-call-res...
- MertsA 9y agoUnfortunately it seems like the Trump administration doesn't even bother responding nowadays.
- inetknght 9y agoOkay, so telco companies are Title II. ISPs are not. This rollback effectively means telcos can "upgrade" to no longer be telcos.
- thrillgore 9y agoDespite copper's technical limitations, this smacks of the inmates once again running the asylum. Once again, I am putting my decision to vacate the US back on the table.
- cstrat 9y agoCome to Australia, we abandoned a national fibre network and are now sticking with copper and HFC where possible... facepalm
- anotherjesse 9y agoThe point is sometimes copper connections are the only options for voice and data. And now ATT and friends can stop servicing rural / small communities. I live in a small community an hours drive from San Francisco. There is only ATT DSL. (no cable, only a couple cell services and none at all for some - including myself - due to the hills and valleys) I am lucky and have DSL (5Mbps, and most of the time really 2Mbps, barely any upstream and it slows the downstream to a crawl when using it - example: watching youtube on 240p setting freezes when checking your email). Many in my town have been without home internet for years. And even if you have cell coverage, the 10G of tethered data per month (that is what Verizon "unlimited" is) - can be eaten away in a day by a person not realizing their computer is updating or watching netflix on 720p. There was once a healthy ecosystem of local ISPs. the big players killed them and now those healthy ecosystems will need to grow back. But it will be painful for those who have to go through networking withdraw.
- blaisio 9y agoI know it's not entirely the town's fault because sometimes people make mistakes, and hindsight is 20/20, but some of that is the fault of the local government. Houses without solid internet access are way less valuable on the market. A lot of local governments are filled with people who have no idea what they're doing and end up really hurting their community. So if this is bothering you, you should get involved.
- Gibbon1 9y agoSome places companies are making point to point microwave links available. As long as there is someplace you can get direct line of sight, you're good. Personal feeling, copper or fiber can't compete with that on price at all.
- Sami_Lehtinen 9y agoMany people opt for mobile data, this has been happening in many countries for a long time. When 3G data came, people started to switching to mobile data from physical connections. Many people seem to think that having physical networking infrastructure is great waste of resources. This is also one of the reasons why some countries got mobile data average traffic over 15 gigabytes / month. That's because people watch Netflix and YouTube all day using mobile data. Number of people who actually need high speed networking is quite low. Yet this naturally means, that the high speed option might not be available at all, with reasonable cost. 4G and 5G means that there will be less and less wired (copper or fiber) connections.