9 ms·
Totally agree. It seems one of the factors that helped the US until the 90s was that housing was affordable so people could move around easily. A "strong" housi
by maxxxxx 9y ago
Totally agree. It seems one of the factors that helped the US until the 90s was that housing was affordable so people could move around easily. A "strong" housing market seems to indicate that there are no productive places for investing and no wage growth so people need to gamble on houses to rise instead.
- expertentipp 9y ago> A "strong" housing market seems to indicate that there are no productive places for investing and no wage growth so people need to gamble on houses to rise instead. You've just summarized the situation in Prague, Czech Republic.
- jankotek 9y agoPrague has problem with supply, new flats are build slowly.
- Yizahi 9y agoSame in Ukraine
- novalis78 9y agoSame in Munich... QE money looking for a 'tangible' home
- contingencies 9y agoSame in China. Same in Australia.
- marvin 9y agoSame in Norway.
- expertentipp 9y agoboooom? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TpCb3xjh-Kk#t=04m05s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TpCb3xjh-Kk#t=04m05s
- paganel 9y agoSame in Romania. For the first time in my life (I’m 37 now) I heard a couple of acquantainces saying something like “We’re 20,000 Euros reacher now compared to last November, our apparment is now worth 90,000 euros compared to 70,000 euros last November”. This discussion happened this summer, since then I’ve heard at least a couple other different couples saying pretty much the same thing (only the sums were different). Never mind they their investments are a hell of a inliquid ones and that the banking rules can change anytime, just like that (like it happened after 2008), which would send the real estate market collapsing.
- bobowzki 9y agoI hear this almost everyday in Sweden.
- opportune 9y agoI think a strong housing market may be the result of lack of productive capital, but I think it has more to do with supply and demand. Most average people pay for a house using a mortgage payment, so when buying a house, they'll be looking for a house that has an affordable mortgage payment. Let's say Joe wants to spend / can afford a $1000/month mortgage payment. If interest rates are 5% and the maximum mortgage period is 30 years, Joe can afford to buy a house worth $190,000. However, if interest rates go down to 2% and Joe can now take a 40 year mortgage, Joe can now buy a house worth about $330,000. Great for Joe! The only problem is that housing supply is relatively inelastic, so the supply of housing didn't magically increase overnight. When Joe buys a house, he's essentially bidding against a bunch of other people for that house. If those other people's mortgage payments were affected the same way, then the actual effect is that what was once a house worth $190,000 is now worth $330,000. This sounds like a problem out of an Econ 101 exercise. Either politicians are stupid, or more likely, they know that "homeowner policy" like this can make them and their other rich buddies even richer.
- Gustomaximus 9y agoHomes are important to people and they tend to buy as good as they can afford. When employment is stable and interest rates are low people will spend more because they can and feel safe doing so. Early movers purchase a higher grade of home than they could have previously. Eventually this shifts the market as a whole as income distribution remains stable. Then people buy the same house they would have previously at a higher price. Now nothing has changed and people are more in debt as the cycle returns to normal, if it ever does. Plus the whole investor (foreign and domestic) vs owner occupier discussions we are seeing plenty of...
- samsonradu 9y agoIsn't it inherently bad to buy "as good as you can afford"? Employment is rarely stable throughout a 30-year period. Shouldn't people be much more careful when maxing out their mortgage relative to 'the good times'?
- 9y ago
- bmm6o 9y agoI don't think it's that there aren't productive places for investing. Housing is unique in that a regular person can get a loan to purchase an asset that normally appreciates, and they can deduct the interest from their taxes. There are a lot of transaction costs, so the market isn't as liquid as some others, but where else can the average person get that kind of leveraged investment?
- api 9y agoThere's been a number of great bits of research over the past few years arguing that our "strong" housing market is a primary cause of economic stagnation. Let me count the ways: (1) reduced labor force agility as you say (2) high rent and mortgage cost soaks up money that could otherwise fuel consumer spending, creating a demand constrained economy (3) high housing costs in major cities also contribute to poverty elsewhere by preventing people from circulating between high priced urban and lower priced rural areas (4) high housing costs risk actually destroying centers of excellence like the SF Bay Area and New York by making it impractical for new talent to move there
- eli_gottlieb 9y agoGot any reading on that? I'd never thought of it that way, but when you say it, it seems very plausible.
- gsam 9y agoI somewhat disagree. The opposite can also occur. Because everyone is gambling on the house market, the amount of productive places for investing diminishes as they are left to be forgotten. This can be obviously self-perpetuating but this is how I would characterize New Zealand.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoYou are correct, but VR will wreck the housing market within 10 years* , so it’s not a long term concern. * 1st sub-$400 all-in-one with 6dof, face and finger tracking + 5 years