15 ms·
How slot machines are designed to be addictive
- sigi45 9y agoA general thought about gambling: If you lose, you give someone else your money. If you win, you take money from someone else. Doesn't feel fair or nice or cool or whatever. It feels strange to give or take money from someone else. Alone the fact, that my winning is not just winning but taking money from others makes it broken. I do not want to have an advantage over others per pure chance.
- creaghpatr 9y agoAddiction by Design is a book that takes a really comprehensive look at slot machine design it’s pretty wild how much thought is put into it and this is before ML became practical, I’m sure casino company’s are leveraging it now.
- mschuster91 9y agoI remember reading an article years ago where a video-poker machine manufacturer "trained" the machine using real playing behavior of famous poker stars... For German machines I can say they're not a target market for ML or other "experimental" stuff given the ultra strict regulations here. More or less illegal online casinos however are the new Wild West of the gambling industry.
- Buttes 9y agoThere have to be verifiably fair ethereum gambling contracts right?
- a_t48 9y agoApparently, yes. I wonder how legal it is, it's probably got pretty good margins.
- sirclueless 9y agoI've certainly seen gambling sites around bitcoin, where there is an indelible audit trail if not an actual enforceable contract.
- YeOakAye 9y agoVideo poker and the type of poker played by 'famous poker stars' (Texas Hold'em generally, if it's televised) are entirely different things.
- lostboys67 9y agoAnd technically Poker isn't gambling as the outcome is not random like wise horse racing.
- kschmit90 9y agoThe content of this article is fantastic and frightening. However, viewing this page on mobile, you can’t help but appreciate the interactivity that feels as though it’s been designed with the mobile reader in mind. It’s marvelous.
- IMTDb 9y agoApparently it was designed for mobiles. On a desktop it's a nightmare.
- finalight 9y agosure, it might not look very well done, but on desktop it doesn't sound as bad. in fact, it's pretty pleasant as well
- Jasper_ 9y agoI am sitting here on an upgraded Nexus 9 tablet with the latest Google Chrome. This thing came out less than 3 years ago and yet I literally cannot read this article. I wait ten seconds not touching the page for it to finish loading as fonts, banners, sounds all pop in and try to settle around me. Barely touching the screen to scroll it down causes a button to start sliding around the page, overlapping on top of a bunch of text telling me I can stop pushing the button any time. The roulette wheel animation in the background spins at 2fps while the motor in my fan spins at 7200rpm. Trying to touch the button causes the whole page to refresh. The page regresses to "Loading" on white while a banner ad and a pop-up self-congratulating the site for using cookies comes up. Another ten seconds to wait for my now baking sheet to cool down and I try sliding past the button while the music stutters, failing to play. The tab reloads again. The only words I was able to read were the banner ad, the bit that tells me I can stop pushing the button, and "Loading". I think this is an apt metaphor for the modern web.
- brokenmachine 9y agoYour Nexus 9 tablet has a fan that spins at 7200rpm?
- joezydeco 9y agoThe original patent on virtual reels was granted in 1984 and is known in the industry as the "Telnaes patent" https://patents.google.com/patent/US4448419A https://patents.google.com/patent/US4448419A The original design of virtual reels was more about decreasing the jackpot odds, since a high-payout combination was no longer bound to the physical stops on the reels. Machines that offered higher jackpots were more appealing, and also gave birth to things like progressive jackpots and progressive networked games. It also made IGT (the owner of the patent) a giant in the industry. Many workarounds were tried and typically failed in the lawsuits that followed. The most successful deviation was the "bonus game" where a particular symbol set would trigger a small video game or some other activity that had its own paytable independent of the main slot paytable. The psychological design of near misses didn't show up until probably a decade afterward, but since '419 is now expired it's become the new secret sauce of slotmakers.
- AgentME 9y agoUsing a random number generator to pick the spot a wheel stops spinning is enough for a patent?
- sirclueless 9y agoThat's the title, but the main innovation was using a random number generator to choose from among more positions than symbols that the physical wheel possesses, thus allowing different odds for different symbols. The interesting bit comes from claim 8 and 9: > a random number generator for selecting one number from a plurality of numbers each representing one of said different angular rotational positions, said plurality of numbers exceeding the number of rotational positions of said reel such that a plurality of numbers represents some of the reel positions; and ... > assigning a different quantity of numbers to each position to obtain the win odds desired.
- joezydeco 9y agoYou have to remember this was invented in 1982. Using RNGs, stepper motors, and mapped tables was certainly enough for a patent in that era.
- gboudrias 9y agoI'm taking a learning psych course this semester, honestly you barely need to design them at all. Any random positive outcome will cause (on average) a non-interrupted repetition of the preceding behavior. Most mobile games nowadays are "designed" (read: made crappier) with such a feature. Just try and find a "free to play" game where the outcome isn't random... It's just not as profitable.
- joezydeco 9y agoBut truly random systems will be volatile. In terms of slot machine design, that means long dry periods of no wins (big or small) at all. If you talk to slot designers, the word "volatile" is used about every 30 seconds. The virtual reel and near-miss concepts are designed to give the appearance of a less volatile machine, which converts into a player staying on the machine longer. TLDR: fake near misses hide the actual randomness of the reward system.
- partycoder 9y agoMany gambling games exploit a cognitive bias known as the gambler's fallacy (e.g: the fallacy that playing more will increase your odds of winning). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gambler%27s_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gambler%27s_fallacy
- jnordwick 9y agoWith modern slot machines, isn't this actually true though? I thought one of the benefits of computerized slots was to be able to control the pay outs better.
- solipsism 9y agoNo, it's not true. Every draw is independent, so past performance has zero bearing on future performance.
- brokenmachine 9y agoEach roll has fuck-all chance of winning then.
- partycoder 9y agoThere are usually regulations on what is the maximum the machine can retain. It's not truly pseudorandom but rather weighted pseudorandomness.
- Buttes 9y agoIn 10 years: How Facebook is designed to be addictive
- duncan-donuts 9y agoPeople are already talking about social media and how it's addictive[1]. 1) https://www.google.com/search?q=how+social+media+is+designed+to+be+addictive&ie=UTF-8 https://www.google.com/search?q=how+social+media+is+designed...
- bricksmart 9y agoHe's pointing out that the material in this article has been discussed ad nauseam and this doesn't present any new ideas.
- scrame 9y agoWhat do you think "stickiness" or "user engagement" are measuring. Same metrics that ran Farmville, and the same metrics putting lootboxes in games now.
- stubish 9y agoOr perhaps how Facebook succeeded, because it happened to be more addictive than its competitors. Evolutionary mechanisms will ensure that the most successful social network is the most addictive one.
- Hasz 9y agoI recently read an excellent book about this subject exactly -- Addiction by Design: Machine Gambling in Las Vegas, by Natasha Dow Schüll. It has research from every angle -- former addicts, the casinos, current addicts, game programmers, game manufacturers, anyone who has a hand in the industry. It's incredibly comprehensive, and definitely worth a look, if a bit long.
- froindt 9y agoShe also did an interview for Adam Ruins Everything for people looking for a shorter time commitment than a book. http://www.maximumfun.org/adam-ruins-everything/professor-natasha-dow-schüll-how-casinos-slot-machines-are-designed-facilitate http://www.maximumfun.org/adam-ruins-everything/professor-na...
- imroot 9y agoIt pains me to say this, but, back when "Gamification" was a major growth tool, I read this book so that I could identify potential avenues for "gamify-ing" the product that I was working on, but, the stories of the addicts are really what drove me away from even considering that for what I was working on. I'll +1 on it being a really comprehensive book.
- kaffeemitsahne 9y agoThe book "Hooked: How to Build Habit-Forming Products" is exactly that. Minus the cautionary tales, I guess (haven't read it).
- byron_fast 9y agoIt may be this stuff is true for current slot machines, but it isn't immediately obvious if you try one. In fact, current slot machines are an incoherent mess. When I played recently, I couldn't tell whether I had a near-miss or even a win until credits counted upward. I couldn't feel any excitement because I didn't know what was going on. It would have taken me several hundred dollars worth of play to even understand what was happening. Maybe this is part of the plan, or maybe their product gets used no matter how bad it is - as long as those rewards pay out randomly.
- phil248 9y agoI'be had the same experience, though you will start to get the hang of more complicated machines after a couple dozen spins. I wonder if that complexity adds to the allure. "Now that I understand this complicated machine, I better not let that that hard earned knowledge go to waste"
- quickthrower2 9y agoThere is definitely a machismo about being able to master the UK pub slot machines with all the features and tests of "skill".
- darrenf 9y agoWhen I used to throw tons of money at the things, what amazed and impressed my friends wasn't that I would regularly win money - I wouldn't, and I was always up front about how much I was pissing away - but just that I understood what the hell was going on. It felt like neither mastery nor machismo.
- thinkingemote 9y agoWhat did it feel like? Honest fatalism, a happy cynicism? I'm thinking your experience may not be unique, perhaps most gambling addicts are fully aware what they are doing? Maybe it's a common thing with all addicts, or perhaps gambling as it's less, well, chemical allows the brain to see things clearer.
- dbatten 9y agoThese "articles" with embedded scroll-hijacking garbage have got to stop. I really wanted to read about slot machines but I'm not suffering through that. Does this need to be a new hn flag? This is the second of these today.
- syntheticcdo 9y agoThis one is better than some. At least the content is still scrolled naturally, and only the media on the right is locked. Nothing is worse than a site that is completely hijacked, where no matter how many rolls of the mouse wheel, you have the wait and see each downward animation one at a time.
- nickevershed 9y agoThis isn't scrolljacking. Scrolljacking generally refers to modifying the normal or expected scrolling behaviour. This has a single sticky section floated over the top of a normally scrolling page.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoI agree it does look quite atrocious- apologies, but I felt it was interesting enough to post anyway.
- aaron695 9y agoPersonally I think this is less intelligent design and more evolutionary. It's an important distinction because scenario one is a stack of evil old men cackling away, scenario two is just people doing their jobs. "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity" has a corollary I think "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by evolution"
- 2474 9y agoAre we sure it's the design that hooks people in? I tend to believe that's the nature of gambling. The exploitation of human's desire to want more than they have.
- elvirs 9y agoive been to casinos many times, played slot machines many times. dont find them fun or addictive at all. those machines dont make even a smallest suggestion that i would ever win any serious amount playing them. people addicted to slot machines are basically stupid
- stubish 9y agoThe article only briefly mentions other games. While Hacker News readers may not be that familiar with slot machines, a higher portion will certainly be familiar with 'grind' in various computer games, which is essentially the same thing using many similar tricks, and a mechanism to extend play time; most noticeable on MMOs when they get hundreds or thousands of play time out of a customer, when the equivalent budget single player game would get 20.
- 35bge57dtjku 9y agoThe one guy's glasses look animated.
- caitriona 9y agoYes! What is going on with those glasses. They look like they're drawn on.
- a_c 9y agoI wonder what makes HN so addictive. I have no facebook, no twitter no reddit. And no youtube during work. But damn, I can't miss all those goodies on HN!
- Synaesthesia 9y agoThe same effect, novelty which presents at random is highly addictive, creating compulsive behaviour of constant checking. (Guilty over here too)
- deathhand 9y agoI think being an information junkie is more of the reason of HN addiction.
- kerbalspacepro 9y agoIf you're a human being in the normal (+- 3 standard deviations) bands of brain functionality, you're an information junkie, but people have different information diets/highs.
- smallstepforman 9y agoDisclaimer: I design the machines and games for a living. 1) regarding near miss, with basic math knowledge you can easily calculate the odds of near miss. Eg. with 2 special symbols per 30 symbol reel, for a 3x5 reel game, you have a 1:5 chance of seeing the special symbol per reel, or once per spin for a 5 reel game. The odds of a 4 symbol near miss is (1:5)^4, which is 1:625, or once every 30 minutes. With a bank of 30 machines, someone will have near miss fanfare every minute. If a bigger win is (1:5)^5, that is 1:3125 spins, or every 150 minutes per machine. That same 30 EGM bank will be paying out a large win every 5 minutes, ie. just short enough for every player on the bank to realise that the machines are “hot”. Its not planned, it just works out that way. 2) when it comes to addiction, if the stats the media are stating is correct, every 6th employee in the industry would also be addicted (using the definition of addiction used from chemical substance abuse). Since there is no measurable difference in addiction levels for employees (who spend 40hrs per week interacting with slots) and players who spend less time, the addiction argument looses its basis. 3) games adjusting payouts based on the outcome of previous games are illegal. The industry is heavily regulated (independant compliance agencies), and no operator wants to lose their license doing illegal things. 4) people have a natural tendency to arrange items, from socks and underwear in drawers, to payout symbols on the screen. There is a natural high people get when they complete a sorting job. I’ve worked with 3 big slot companies, and none of them had paid psychologists on call - there is no need. 5) its a voluntery activity. There are lots of people who enjoy the activity, the excitement, the thrill, etc and they’re responsible enough to only wager less than the cost of a theatre ticket. Sometimes they finish the night with more money than they brought in. Its a regulated activity for adults.
- sigi45 9y agoDo you have much experience in taking a look who is playing your slot machines? I mean do you really go to places and check it out for a few hours? Here in germany there are small casinos. Not real casinos but with a few machines like 5-20. I went to such a place because there was a pool table in thenext room. I saw, while playing pool, how a few people used multil machines at once, feed those machines 10Euros and more (around 11$) in a quick feshion. Do you think, that those people, who play on a saturday afternoon enjoying this? i mean do you really think "yes the experience im providing for them through my job is is an activity they enjoy and the enjoyment stands in relation to the amount of money they are spending". I only thought "holy shit, poor people, throwing there hard earned money away" I felt sorry for those people. so sry that i was thinking if or how i could approach them. My pool table for 2 hours and 4-5 drinks was cheaper of what one person was putting in those machines. I think they are addicted.
- keerthivar 9y agowonderful idea and very natural
- nottorp 9y agoUnreadable. Too bad, the title seemed interesting. Also, sound?
- frik 9y agoVideo games in the Free2Play niche inherited a lot of slot machine and casino gamification mechanics. Now even proper video games of the triple-A full prize segment $70 come with "loot boxes", helix points, DLCs, trading cards, always-online that unnerves the greater audience but a few (rich) noobs (so called "whales") get sucked/addicted in and pay tausends of dollars for virtual goods additionally to the full prize game. Former sound gameplay mechanic got changed and dumped down to incorporate the gamification mechanics into proper full prize games, where formerly skill played a major role, it's now "invested time" to play ("grind") or to pay real money for shortcuts, to reduce the time to collect the virtual currency. Games like Forza 7, Assassin's Creed Origin, Diablo 3, NBA 2k17, and many more from big publishers feature such addictive gambling slot machine mechanics. Loot boxes have reached a new low with Forza 7’s “pay to earn” option: https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2017/09/loot-boxes-have-reached-a-new-low-with-forza-7s-pay-to-earn-option/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2017/09/loot-boxes-have-reach... Loot boxes in video games will soon get a review flag from OpenCritic: https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2017/10/loot-boxes-in-video-games-will-soon-get-a-review-flag-from-opencritic/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2017/10/loot-boxes-in-video-g... China will force games with loot boxes to publicly expose their drop rates and probabilities: https://www.vg247.com/2016/12/08/china-will-force-games-with-loot-boxes-to-publicly-expose-their-drop-rates-and-probabilities/ https://www.vg247.com/2016/12/08/china-will-force-games-with... UK Government Responds to Loot Boxes as Gambling Petition: http://www.kotaku.co.uk/2017/10/19/uk-government-responds-to-loot-boxes-as-gambling-petition http://www.kotaku.co.uk/2017/10/19/uk-government-responds-to...
- lsmarigo 9y agoVideo game industry is pushing these tactics to new heights with loot box gamification, even better the target consumers are young, mentally underdeveloped children who are much easier to addict to gambling. It's beyond evil and should be regulated immediately, China/Japan have had regulations about this for years already. America leading the way in letting businesses exploit underage consumers, encouraging addictions to gambling for profit.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoTo make matters worse, after all this effort to hook players in with a promise of a win just around the corner, it seems that casinos often don't pay up when players win big. Instead, they blame jackpots on malfunctions. Three cases of this from Ars: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/10/1-4-million-jackpot-is-voided-because-bingo-machine-malfunctioned/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/10/1-4-million-jack... https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/06/sorry-maam-you-didnt-win-43m-there-was-a-slot-machine-malfunction/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/06/sorry-maam-you-d... https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/04/sorry-grandma-that-42-million-slot-machine-jackpot-was-a-computer-glitch/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/04/sorry-grandma-th... The incomprehensible thing is that courts have stood behind the casinos in such cases.
- Chris2048 9y agolink 1: "Gambler has no right to contest non-payment because casino is on tribal land" link 3: "there was "clearly a display malfunction" and that the machine's maximum payout was programmed for $6,500" link 3: "the user-agreement, available on the touch screen, said the maximum payout was $10,000" Why incomprehensible? Because you know (the latter 2) aren't really malfunctions?
- isolli 9y agoFrom the article: the courts did not stand behind the casinos, they said that they do not have jurisdiction.
- Retric 9y agoThis is reasonable when machines list a maximum reward of say 10,000$ and then it says has someone win 2000x that. After all, the players did not make the bet thinking such a payout was possible. IMO, it is a sign the machines are not setup to follow the states rules. But, people are suing for the amount listed not trying to shut the casino down.
- thunfischbrot 9y agoIt would make sense to still pay out the maximum amount listed in that case.
- zelos 9y agoHow soul-destroying a job must it be to develop these games? Spending all day designing software to trick more vulnerable people into giving you their money?
- point78 9y agoYou just described probably 80% of video games and software...
- zelos 9y agoCertainly addictiveness is an issue for all gaming - I'm pretty sure Blizzard hired psychologists, and look at the increasing use of loot box mechanics, even in full-price console games. That said, there's a kind of distilled evil in the slot machine case. There's no gameplay to hide behind, it's just insert money, win/don't win.
- yomly 9y agoI am sure people agree with you here and there will be plenty of people who find the casino industry distasteful but I would avoid projecting your own value set onto this. For every person whose life has been ruined by gambling, there are many who are able to enjoy it responsibly. Same goes for any of the other classic vices such as tobacco or drinking, or even food. I am sure there are plenty of people who are comfortable distancing themselves with the responsibility of the impact these products have on users but take pride in their ability to improve upon the metrics that warrant success in their field. If it were so soul-destroying, no one would do the job... (unless the pay was phenomenal)
- mrweasel 9y ago>trick more vulnerable people into giving you their money I don't really have an issue with casinos as such, I'm sure it can be fun for a holiday. What I do mind is all the smaller gaming kiosks that started popping up when Denmark opened up it's gambling/betting marked (because EU required it that it not be a government monopoly). There's so many small crappy looking kiosks that now offers gambling on slot machines, but it's not people like myself that pops in on a Friday afternoon on the way home from work to spend the equivalent of $10 - $20 to relax. It's societies weakest members that banging on the door to be the first at the slots and won't leave until their asked to leave at the end of the evening. The people sitting at the slots are the people who can afford it the least. It's absolutely terrible that this is legal.
- lsmarigo 9y agoVideo game industry is pushing these tactics to new heights with loot box gamification, even better the target consumers are young, mentally underdeveloped children who are much easier to addict to gambling. China/Japan have regulated these practices for years already (with minimal effectiveness because money wins and publishers have found loopholes), but at least they're trying. Over here we just let companies go to town on our youth, mental health and stability be damned. They are printing money at the expense of hooking children into gambling. This is no different than tobacco companies targeting children with advertisement which was rightfully outlawed. - Corporations encouraging and nourishing gambling addiction in underage consumers (with the help of trained psychologists) for profit is despicable. Don'tunderstand why more people aren't upset about this.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoMy guess is lot of us adults don't really see much of it, cause it's not targeted at us. I see the regular "come to hopping awesome great casino" ads on tv/radio/internet. My thoughts - thats where people go to lose money. But these loot boxes, I had to research what this was referring to. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loot_box https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loot_box And after reading how they're used, yeah, thats like years ago when I played and bought Magic The Gathering. Sure, a pack was $2.95, but it was a complete gamble on what rare you got. You didn't buy packs for commons and lands - you bought them for a chance at the chase rare (now ubers). Maybe its just my age. But I think lowly of "buying" some digital construct in a game that I don't own is completely ridiculous. I get spending time and running up levels, but spending actual hard cash (past a per month cost) is just.. bad.
- lsmarigo 9y agoyou're absolutely right you can trace the roots of this back to Magic and if you want to go further back Baseball cards. It was fairly innocent back then, with the advent of gaming technology and research into dopamine-releasing mechanics/skinner boxes it's reached insidious levels.
- 9y ago
- pottan 9y agoThey are abusing kids to get their money printed
- kopos 9y agoSadly, the article does disservice to a lot of actual mechanics of the industry. And the amount of hard work that goes on to actually makes these games addictive. It is not for no reason that these are called one-armed bandits. * This industry is highly regulated; but it rarely does help those really in need. If the regulations were very strictly implemented (player wager limits, player time controls, self-regulation), none of the gambling / gaming companies would make any money. For eg: the wager limit are compulsory to be implemented on a daily / weekly / monthly basis; however these numbers are so high, that it rarely makes sense but for the most serious addicts * Most of the victims are from the already high-risk demographics, as is with tobacco, alcohol, payday loans and drug abuse, the low income, unstable jobs, low literacy, blue collar jobs or are already on social support. The offers by data-analysis is always to target them. I think most of the time - these addicts are just there to get that one chance to make a big win (which almost never happens). * Near miss is a very old tactic. The interplay of sounds, music, imagery has been very well polished to really give a feel of high end experience (vs plain gameplay). Gamble rounds (double or nothing) at the end of a game are targeted at those twitchy fingers. * Slot machines work at payouts of 94% - 97% (ie when wagering 1000$ the player will only get 94 - 97$) on a long timeline. So yes, the house edge is quite small. What is problematic is not the money lost but the fact that addiction over a long time, is definitely at the cost of a small fortune. * I am pretty sure no one has any idea why some slots work and some don't. When they do work, they earn the makers millions though. However, whenever such numbers come up, I am always sure that these tactics are no different from any industry that is fighting for coveting the attention of the user. I am pretty sure Facebook (or Zynga) has a bigger data science time and data analysis team that these casino companies have to identify the psyches of players and customize the experience to the users / players. * Disclosure: I have worked in the technical design & implementation of these games.
- hollander 9y agoWith a mechanical slot machine I can understand the reel thing. But with electronic screens, software making up reels, how do I know that the software does not fool me even more? Take the given example with first slot 1/16, second 1/32 and third 1/44 chance of winning big. Now assume the generated numbers are really random, and that day or week the machine has given two big prices. Then a third big number combination is created, and here a new rule takes over, changing one of the numbers so the price is smaller. Is this regulated or how does this work?
- chiefalchemist 9y agoThe Atlantic did a great piece on gambling/gaming earlier this year. Unfortunately, I can't seem to find the link. Sorry. Perhaps someone else can do better than me.
- reubeniv 9y agoIt misses a few things, noting the time taken to reach zero portion you'll notice the large spike at the beginning, the machines are intentionally generous at the start to hook the player. That said, the odds are actually fixed and the payout % are required to be displayed on the machines by (UK) law. Normal pay to play arcade videogames that are't as regulated, and have no age limits also have the same difficulty spike mechanics I'm almost sure, f2p games with micro-transactions definitely have this mechanic.
- awjr 9y agoI was lucky. I remember being 18 years old and putting the money for my bus ticket home into a slot machine because "it had to pay out this time". I lost and had a 5 mile walk home. I have avoided the machines ever since. Meeting a programmer of these devices some years ago and him explaining a lot of what they did re-enforced my view to stay away from them.
- tudorw 9y agoIf you're a parent, you can play this strategy on your children, instead of a simple star reward chart, where good task = reward, reward spuriously and without cue, when you reward them, tell them you know they are always trying hard to do the right thing and are proud of how often they make a good choice, maybe point out something they could have done better if it's recent enough to be recalled... With a star chart children are adept at learning the minimum requirements for reward, and the point of the reward, for good behaviour, is lost in the game...
- turc1656 9y agoIt just occurred to me the same randomized reward mechanism mentioned in the article is the same one that occurs (for me, anyway) on the HN main page. Clicking refresh and not knowing what new awesome thing will be there.
- kazagistar 9y agoGame developers are similarly employing psychologists to maximize addictiveness of gambling in games targeted and children and teens in the form of "loot boxes", and due to lack of regulation, they are allowed to use even more scummy techniques that the gambling industry had long been prohibited from using, in order to more effectively squeeze money out of players.