16 ms·
Under-building of new homes, high construction cost perpetuate housing shortage
- taprun 9y agoNo, the #1 reason it's so hard to find an affordable home is that potential buyers can get huge loans at very low rates. Since buyers compete with each other, prices go up. I guarantee that if interest rates were allowed to creep up, and the government stopped guaranteeing loans made by the banks, we'd have cheaper homes almost immediately.
- mooreds 9y agoAgreed. There'd be some howling from the mortgage and real estate industries though. I have often thought that the mortgage interest deduction is actually a subsidy to banks (because if you pay cash you get no deduction) and existing homeowners (because it supports existing prices).
- tehlike 9y agoCheaper house, sure, but does that also mean less monthly payments? Or would i still pay the same monthly, but most would go to interest. Alternatively in the bay area there are a lot of wealthy people. I dont know how it would affect them
- bradleyjg 9y agoEven if the monthly payment for a 30 yr fixed were to stay the same the buyer would be better off with a lower price. American mortgages have no prepayment penalty, so the buyer has the possibility of refinancing at a lower rate sometime over the payback period or even just making extra principal payments.
- Simulacra 9y agoDo you have a source for this? Huge loans at very low rates? The current is about 3.85% even for an FHA loan. Even then they won't loan you huge amounts unless you have the income to justify it. Even if interest rates were allowed to "creep up" the government will not stop guaranteeing loans, and banks won't stop lending. They'll find some other way to offset. With higher interest comes higher payments which means only higher income people will be able to afford that housing. That will horribly exacerbate the problem. Now the middle and low income people don't even have a prayer of owning a home. Is that your intention?
- zaroth 9y agoIt turns out people buy generally the most home they can afford, and this is in terms of monthly payment. As interest rates increase, demand falls for higher priced homes and the new equilibrium price ends up hitting just about the same monthly payment as you had before. Low interest rates have the same effect in reverse. Prices adjust so that regardless of interest rate your monthly payment is about the same, but low rates do transfer huge wealth to existing homeowners. As down payments have come down over time this is only more pronounced. From 50% down with a 5 year term in the early 1900s to peak-mortgage 5% down 50 year terms a few years ago.
- closeparen 9y agoNominally cheaper, sure, but not more affordable, since ability to pay would fall proportionally.
- codingdave 9y agoIf rates went up, the homes may be cheaper, but you'd then be paying more on your monthly mortgage, and more money would be just going to the banks. I'm not a finance expert, but this doesn't sound like a good solution.
- matwood 9y agoIt would not really work that way. People buy houses based on payment. If rates went up, the price would go down, but people would still compete on who can pay more each month.
- sytelus 9y agoNot really... these days 20% downpayments are the norm. I know several people holding off purchases because they simply don't have downpayment. Higher home prices reduces number of potential customers but right now we have so many of them that reduction doesn't matter and margines are much higher on higher end.
- planteen 9y ago80-10-10 loans are quite popular right now from talking with friends.
- scarface74 9y agoFHA loans are easy to get and the down payment required is 3.5%. Even with mortgages that don’t qualify for FHA it’s relatively easy to get 5% down payment loans.
- prostoalex 9y agoThey generally require PMI, so still an extra payment out of pocket, are usually hard-capped at 30% of buyer’s current income, and take looong time to close compared to strong cash offers with conventional loans, so sellers view them as last-resort. It’s possible, but not very realistic for an FHA applicant to outbid everyone else on price.
- scarface74 9y agoYou can get prequalified for an FHA loan just like any other loan. Everyone doesn't live in SV where houses go so fast you're constantly having to outbid people.
- prostoalex 9y agotaprun's comment was describing a competitive market "potential buyers can get huge loans at very low rates. Since buyers compete with each other, prices go up".
- 9y ago
- pfranz 9y agoMaybe in general? I don't have numbers, but over the past few years a lot of the competition I've seen seems to be all-cash buyers. At least on the west coast (Vancouver, Seattle, LA). Low interest rates elsewhere in the market could be freeing up the cash, but I don't see it being the primary driver for getting mortgages.
- mooreds 9y agoTldr: new homes cost too much due to labor. And building affordable housing doesn't make sense when the costs to build a larger, luxury home are not radically more, but the profits are. I wish they'd talked about the problem in a more systemic manner. They didn't address: * Commuting * Land prices * Price to rent ratios * Density * Economic opportunity where housing is cheaper
- pxeboot 9y agoWe would love to build more affordable starter homes, but when high-end homes cost the same to build and are far more profitable, we lose the incentive to build smaller units This is a major reason why prices are so out of control. Land prices aside, there is no reason somebody couldn't build a nice ~1000sqf house for under $100k. But without literally doing the work yourself, these places just don't get built.
- thriftwy 9y agoCan't you contract the building part if you have a suitable piece of land?
- jdavis703 9y agoI hear an argument a lot, "housing in the Bay Area is expensive because because labor cost is so high." According to this report in San Francisco it costs $269,000 to build a new housing unit. With the median home sale price over $1,000,000 it seems fair to say that the labor component isn't the primary driver of the high costs, it's probably related to the inability to legalize enough housing.
- tehlike 9y agoLabor is definitely not the main driver. Often quoted construction price is about 300$/sqft around where i live. If you were to build new, you would spend 750k-850k. Now, you cant buy land for less than 1.8 in mountain view that can hold 2500sqft home. And sale price would be close to 3m anyways.
- maccard 9y agoMaybe one of the issues is the expected sizes of homes in the US - 2500 sq ft is about 250 sq m - which is pretty darn big. The average home in the uk is about 85 sq m...
- jdavis703 9y agoNo, this doesn't have to do with construction costs (which are about linear with square footage), it's other factors. For example, even if someone wanted to build a tiny home (i.e. less than 500 square feet), it's illegal in many places because of minimum square footage requirements. The problem comes from bad land use planning, not because "dumb" Americans don't understand a larger house costs more money.
- tehlike 9y agoTrue that. There's the other side of the coin though. South bay (excepting San Jose) is what you'd call suburbs. People who choose to live low density areas. Part of it is because of the employers. I, for one, do not like a lot of people around me, and I grew up in a city of > 15M. I like the low density. I think it goes both ways. companies in the bay area choose to headquarter in low density areas (so they can grow).
- chiefalchemist 9y ago"We would love to build more affordable starter homes, but when high-end homes cost the same to build and are far more profitable, we lose the incentive to build smaller units,” said Isaac Stocks of Azure Northwest Homes, a Seattle-area home builder. That sums it up. Plus, more expensive homes means more property tax revenue, so there's little incentive for state/local gov to encourage lower end housing. Finally, it would help to know about financing. How willing are banks to issue loans at the lower end? The whole system is "tuned" for larger more expensive houses. It works for those it works for, and doesn't for those with little to none socio-political clout.
- WalterBright 9y agoThis is one reason why the per-square-foot cost metric is lousy. Making a house bigger with the same quality level reduces the square-foot cost substantially. This is because the cost of walls goes up linearly while the square footage goes up as the square (!), and most of the cost is in the walls.
- tehlike 9y agoConstruction price, yes, but i think it kind of scales semi-linearly with the sale price. When average sqft price is 1000$, a 2500sqft house goes for 2.5M even though construction was much much smaller.
- tehlike 9y agoI am not sure if banks care about lower loan balance vs high. Sure, high is more lucrative, but there are a number of government-backed loan programs that could make up for it. As for cities, yes. They like the house pricing go up. It helps with school budgets, particularly. Then it goes into positive feedback loop with better schools raising house prices, too. For cities like seattle, it's not hard to see houses in different price bands (single tech earner, couple tech earner) and so on. Hard to find a solution, unless the big employers diversify their locations.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ilaksh 9y agoMy belief is that radical changes are needed. Much smaller plots, truly mixed use areas, for starters. The tiny villages concept I have shown at http://tinyvillages.org http://tinyvillages.org takes it to an extreme, but even 2 or 3 uses for the old plot size would make a dramatic difference. I think that this idea will be better in many cases than building condos everywhere.
- madengr 9y agoHere in the Kansas City area, it seems most of the new housing is mixed use; commercial on the bottom and apartments on top. Not many single family homes. Maybe it is because millennial not wanting/affording a house, and prefer dense urban living. Though that is beginning to change as they have kids, and are now moving to suburbs. So they now build little cities within the suburbs.
- ashark 9y agoIn the northland, at least, there are tons of new boring ol’ suburban houses going up. Construction slowed for a couple years after the crash, but came back fast and now they’re putting up new houses and plotting new neighborhoods as fast as they can.
- purplezooey 9y agoConstruction pricing is definitely out of control. Part of the problem is that the entire industry is funded with low interest purchase and equity loans and not cash. Another problem seems to be that a lot of construction entities went offline in during the crisis and never came back. Any construction quote easily runs into the $100,000s for even a tiny addition to a house. It's way out of control. If there would exist a construction company that would have upfront pricing, not insanely expensive, and can get most jobs done within several weeks, they would get a huge amount of business. Instead it's always months out, pricing 5x what it should be, and often just impossible to find anybody.
- ikiris 9y agoYou don't seem to understand what you're talking about. The reason for those months out is because everyone is overbooked, and the pricing reflects demand vs supply.
- purplezooey 9y agoExactly. It is a market out of whack.
- EGreg 9y agoFunny to read this after all the articles about China's "ghost cities" and the follies of central planning.
- crdoconnor 9y agoThere seems to be a lot of articles posted on HN purporting to explain the housing crisis from companies that profit from it. Bearing that in mind, it's not so surprising to see "labor shortages" get the blame while untaxed land, low interest rates and wealth inequality/property hoarding go unmentioned.
- bgitarts 9y agoWhy isn't there a tech company trying to disrupt home construction? People speak of Uber being worth so much because of the giant market it's going after and transportation is big being the second largest consumer expenditure at 17% of wallet share. However housing is first at nearly 30% of wallet share and the biggest dent you can make in that figure is lowering the upfront cost which is several years of income for the average buyer.
- Analemma_ 9y agoBecause the cost is labor, materials, land acquisition and permits, none of which can really be “disrupted”.
- bgitarts 9y agolabor has been disrupted through automation. materials can be disrupted through better manufacturing and or new materials. permits can be disrupted by removing or streamlining the process through regulatory changes or personal changes/increases at the Department Of Building(s).
- maxerickson 9y agoThere are plenty of companies bringing technology to building. It just doesn't speed it up all that much. But there are all sorts of new building techniques (new foundation systems, new wall systems, new roofing systems, modular, etc). Or just things like nail guns.
- sytelus 9y agoThis is also because of mass migration to urban centers in recent times. Every major urban center in US is currently facing massive number of incoming people. When everybody wants to live in same little place, prices are obviously going to shoot up. This should also explain why there are no too many new homes being built - because urban centers have little room to expand. This is current phenomenon in much of the world. Even if you go to 3rd world countries and look at prices in core urban centers, you will see exact same trend as in 1st world countries. This always had been a trend through out history but in recent times curves have crossed the knee and has taken a vertical leap.
- wbl 9y agoUrban centers can grow vertically. 80% of SF is single story construction.