21 ms·
Bay Area hammered by loss of jobs: Lack of affordable housing strangles hiring
- allengeorge 9y agoSeems a touch hyperbolic no? 4700 jobs does not sound like a “hammering”.
- wavefunction 9y agoFor the second straight month? Sounds pretty brutal, especially for people who lost their jobs in an expensive place like the Bay Area.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoMaybe. The way this reached #1 with no comments (until yours) makes me think that people have strong opinions about it but said opinions are too divergent from what's popular/accepted around here for them to feel comfortable expressing them. It has a sort of "everyone expects the bubble to pop but nobody wants to admit it" sort of vibe to it.
- cobookman 9y ago4.7 net lost. There’s likely more than 4.7k ppl who lost their job.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 1024core 9y ago4700 out of 3894200 is 0.12% ... not exactly an earthquake, as the article sounds.
- misterHN 9y agoThis is all based on the false premise that the Bay Area is underpopulated and needs more people. This only drives out people who want to live in a place that isn't stuffed with cars that clog the streets and emit filthy pollution. Pretending that the Bay Area needs more people, more cars, more pollution is stupid. It's just plain stupid.
- rahimnathwani 9y agoThe # of jobs rose by ~25% between Feb 2010 and September 2017. How does that make September the "worst month for employment locally since February 2010"?
- binthere 9y agoThe worst month of employment growth, meaning, growth is slowing down. Not hiring enough + layoffs.
- biesnecker 9y ago4700 isn't a lot in the whole scheme of things, but part of what makes a bubble a bubble is that it either keeps growing or it pops.
- bduerst 9y agoSF Bay is definitely in a housing bubble. One of the signals from the 2008 housing crises was when mortgage and rental payments diverged, and even with the high-rents in the bay now you're starting to see mortgage payments outstrip them.
- msluyter 9y agoAustin resident here. My wife and I have been talking to renovators and have heard several times that projects simply take longer these days because many workers now must live farther out from the city core than they used to. I wouldn't be surprised the same thing happens here -- to a lesser degree perhaps, as we have more geographical space to expand into -- with avg commute time being the primary constraint on growth.
- tfha 9y agoYeah. It's not so much about distance, it's about time. Better infrastructure for moving people in and out of the city enables a larger city, and a more populated one.
- state_less 9y agoShouldn't we at least be talking about working remotely and why that doesn't happen more often? I would bet most people have to drive in primarily because there manager did it that way when he/she was in the developer role. Working remotely is friendlier on the environment and saves time commuting. It's also cheaper for the company and more easily scales as head count increases.
- tfha 9y agoIt's not just about work. Sports stadiums, bars, meetup groups, nightlife, concerts, comedy clubs, etc etc all involve bringing people into the city. Commuting is just part of the battle
- state_less 9y agoWorking remotely might give a town more years before they have to expand the highway due to rush hour traffic. They may work in the next town over too, so more diffuse nightlife, bars, etc... It's not a panacea, because of some of the activities you mention (stadiums), but I think it could help with infrastructure and reduce our carbon footprint.
- 9y ago
- microcolonel 9y agoI don't want to live in California, but it seems like a lot of the recruiting and employment matchmaking systems these days focus almost entirely on the SF Bay area. Added: I think the hype might have pumped the job market too full, and net outflows are the only way for the system to concentrate more desirable candidates, with employee compensation being the signal.
- microcolonel 9y agoI'm thinking it might be worthwhile to engineer a scalable, high-traffic city(maybe city's the wrong word, it could be sprawling and fast, instead of dense and slow) from the ground up, somewhere there isn't one already. You don't need to build the transit immediately, you just need to have the restraint to reserve the space for a time when you will want it. Other useful constraints aside from transit reservations, might include: setting aesthetic standards (line of sight corridors[through zoned height restrictions] to natural beauty, stylistic restrictions, above-ground pedestrian accommodation planning), extensive mixed-use zoning in the sprawl, multiple downtowns (hierarchy of pedestrian/two-lane/light rail accessibility > main street/express light rail > freeway/full sized rail arranged in superblocks). Added: Three-dimensional land parcels would solve a lot of the problems with properly valuing natural beauty, direct sunlight, and underground access. Added: Environmental (noise[aggregate peak SPL, loudness], ground vibration[aggregate peak amplitude], air pollution[aggregate peak particulates, ozone, maybe fuel fumes, maybe heat], ground pollution, EMR [including radio and light]) sensor networks could be used to make it simpler to uphold agreements and ordinances, or litigate environmental property devaluation or damage (reduction in air quality, disturbance of quiet, excessive night time light, ground shaking). You could also include on-board detectors for things like gunshots, car crashes, or desperate cries for help, to aide emergency services. Data like these could be made completely public so that public offices don't need to waste their time determining access.
- prostoalex 9y agoOr just copy Singapore.
- 9y ago
- client4 9y agoMontana, a land of National parks, natural beauty, fast internet, and a low cost of living has a number of high tech jobs open. Full disclosure, I own an internet company here and want more tech savvy people in the area ;) Social Finanace (SoFi) | Helena, MT Oracle | Bozeman, MT OnXMaps | Missoula, MT Zaneray Group | Whitefish, MT Submittable | Missoula, MT Applied Materials | Kalispell, MT
- damnyou 9y agoHow friendly to trans people is Montana?
- client4 9y agoUsually if you don't be a dick (if you have one or not) nobody cares. Missoula would be the best town if you're looking for an inclusive city culturally. Our state pride is pretty big. https://www.bigskypride.com https://www.bigskypride.com
- dboreham 9y agoIt isn't Portland or Seattle or San Francisco but it isn't as bad as you might expect (based on what I hear from LGBT friends and my observations). There's a tradition of leaving people to do their thing. We have a democrat governor. Probably best to keep to the left half of the state though. The college towns and tech firms are in the western half.
- micro_cam 9y agoI'm outside of Missoula. There are a few trans people on the reddit and I've heard adds for clinics offering care on the radio. Generally Montanas seem to have a "you mind my business and I'll mind mine" attitude. So while there is a large right wing component they seem to be mobilized more by gun rights and logging/mining jobs then being anti gay/trans. Our rural county did stop taking federal money for the women's health clinic as a tea party grand stand which is unfortunate.
- Mz 9y agoHave you considered doing something more organized than a random comment on HN? I would very much like to see real solutions to some of the problems the US is experiencing wrt concentration of "good" jobs in a few places and them going utterly to hell because of it. I keep kicking around ideas and starting various small websites that often go nowhere. But, I think the internet is a potential means to start giving pushback against this trend and start creating a healthier fabric than we have currently.
- jimmywanger 9y agoI'm quite familiar with the bay area. Lack of housing and traffic are familiar complaints, but it bears repeating. I remember when there was never any traffic on 280, now it's a parking lot during rush hour. If you're just starting out in your career, it's simultaneously the best and worst place to work. Best in that there's a lot of opportunity and you're kinda bathed in the tech ecosystem, worst in that you'll probably be paying 40k (after taxes) for a one bedroom apartment in the city, or stuck commuting for an hour easy way.
- nimbius 9y agoMost of the bay area employees are divided into 3 categories from anecdotal experience: young rockstars that are willing to live in relative squalor for a chance to prove themselves, vested and moneyed elites (CEO's, presidents, VC funded overlords) who are so out of touch with the average employee its best they not show up to the office that frequently, and H1B visa recipients that endure the soul-crushing San Jose or beyond commute every day because their job represents something more than just the sum of their skills, its a ticket to citizenship and a better life for their family. Ive turned down more bay jobs than I can count because at some age you begin to accept the fact that SFBay isnt that great. Rising levels of increasingly aggressive homeless, the inability to afford any housing, and the price of food and public transportation in general are just a few factors that led me to say no.
- chis 9y agoIs it worthwhile to work there for a few years as a 20-year old though? I'm thinking it's a unique experience even if monetarily it's a poor choice.
- vasilipupkin 9y agoYou should go where the opportunities are. Optimizing for things like cheap rent, etc. is silly. You should aim to make so much ( eventually ) that rent doesn't matter any more
- cat199 9y ago> You should aim to make so much ( eventually ) that rent doesn't matter any more Unless this is an unrealistic aim, in which case you are throwing your future away on a false hope..
- vasilipupkin 9y agowell, aren't we being a little melodramatic? if you get a decent job in the bay area and your rent is high, you aren't really "throwing your future away" even if your career doesn't take off.
- codemac 9y agoWe gained 50k jobs in the last year, this is a loss for september of which happens every year as temps etc are usually hired again in Nov. > Over the 12 months that ended in September, the Bay Area added 50,400 jobs, a 1.3 percent increase in total payroll jobs during the one-year period. The interesting part is the percentage slow down over the year, which is what requires more thought than headlines about "hammered job losses" that included area-wide growth.
- theDoug 9y agoIn my five months of living here I've noticed the Mercury isn't exactly known for its depth or subtlety in reporting.
- taxicabjesus 9y agoI've been thinking that apartment cooperatives might be a way to break "investors'" stranglehold on housing. The last landlord I had was a decent fellow - the property was well maintained and he fixed problems promptly. But my rent certainly went to pay his mortgage on the property, and I now have nothing to show for the $thousands I paid him. One time he was showing off the little 8-unit complex to someone he wanted to go into a partnership on another property with him. My cousin has a few low-end houses that he rents out. He's jokingly referred to himself as a "slumlord", but... rent is what economically strangles his renters. My grandparents owned both their homes free-and-clear, and stayed in their homes for 40-50 years. This is the hope of anyone who buys a house: independence from the landlord & bank. The cooperative I'm envisioning would channel rent payments into a fund. After long enough, you'd be able to live there for just maintenance costs, or you could "work off" the monthly fee by contributing somehow. And if a person moves out of the coop, their "equity" could be returned to them over time... Or something like that. (minor edit on 'work off')
- njarboe 9y agoI'm not sure if Poe's law is working here but, if not, you are talking about condominiums (condos) and, at least in California, they are really popular since the 1970's. In many cities, especially San Fran, the laws actively discourage and prevent the conversion of rentals into condos.
- kingnothing 9y agoSounds like you want a condo.
- taftster 9y ago> "But my rent certainly went to pay his mortgage on the property" Um, yeah. That's the way it works for property investors. Find a property, borrow money to purchase, rent out property to cover mortgage costs. This happens at low scale (individuals) and high scale (property investment companies, REIs, etc.). > "I now have nothing to show for the $thousands I paid him" Presumably, you had a job at the time, for which you decided it was an equitable trade to have the job and not buy a property to live. You made a choice, and the outcome from that choice is what you have to show. You do the math on the rent/buy decision. In places like New York, San Francisco, etc. it's very common to come out on the side of renter instead of buyer. If you're in the mid-west, you are probably buying. But don't say you didn't have nothing to show for the rent.
- trumpownsyou420 9y agopay a ton of money to deal with idiots and illegals? no thanks LOL.
- jostmey 9y agoI've only visited SF. From what I've seen, there are far better cities such as Seattle, San Diego, ect, ect. I live in Dallas and couldn't be happier. I've been able to start a family as a Postdoc! http://dallas.culturemap.com/news/city-life/03-29-17-us-census-bureau-report-dallas-fort-worth-population-growth/ http://dallas.culturemap.com/news/city-life/03-29-17-us-cens...
- ng12 9y agoWhat makes Seattle better? I've visited friends there a few times and I can't shake the feeling that it's only trailing the Bay by a few years in of affordability and transportation woes.
- Analemma_ 9y agoThe housing situation isn't quite as fucked as the Bay, in that Seattle is actually building more units (there are dozens of high-density apartment complexes under construction at the moment). It's not enough to stop rents from going up, but it's something. And hey, we can always hope that Amazon opening a new HQ somewhere else will ease the influx.
- jostmey 9y agoMy opinion: - Seattle has more diverse industry. I toured the bio-science companies down at the harbor and was really impressed. Seattle is more than just "tech". - SF is way too restrictive with allowing new housing to be built. I did not perceive the problem to be as bad in Seattle. - In SF, a lot of the streets reeked of weed--It's like when someone cranks up their music too loud forcing everyone to listen to it. I don't care if someone smokes weed, I just don't want to smell it everywhere--it's not family friendly. Meanwhile, Seattle's streets appeared much cleaner to me when I explored the city (on foot).
- ng12 9y ago> In SF, a lot of the streets reeked of weed What? Where did you live? I never once had that problem. It's not like the entirety of SF smells like weed 24/7, I think that's a pretty absurd strike to give a city (especially since it's legalized in WA).
- acangiano 9y agoWhy aren't tech companies buying or building massive apartment complexes, making them appealing with a few amenities, and renting them out for cheap to their employees? I know building development in San Francisco proper is limited, but in the general bay area or South is not. Now you have a very attractive package: a relatively big salary and somewhat affordable housing. Talent would be much more willing to relocate, even if your tech lab is outside San Francisco proper.
- ghaff 9y agoLeaving aside any restrictions on development which do exist, it’s still a pretty awful thought. Now if you leave for any reason you presumably also have to find new housing in short order.
- theDoug 9y agoMany seem very keen to, but most housing initiatives brought before at least the Mountain View and Sunnyvale councils (in my experience) face hard opposition from individual homeowners. And that's how you keep the market up for $2.4 million homes that would go for $300k elsewhere http://www.mercurynews.com/2017/09/12/now-this-is-ridiculous-782000-over-asking-for-a-house-in-sunnyvale/ http://www.mercurynews.com/2017/09/12/now-this-is-ridiculous...
- Apocryphon 9y agoYou'd think that if big software corporations can lobby in D.C., they could lobby in local communities as well.
- Chirael 9y agoBecause tech companies want to be in the tech business, not the real estate business. And investors would rather see slightly higher salaries for employees who then fend for themselves, instead of the business getting involved in real estate as a potential huge distraction.
- tyingq 9y agoNot a new idea... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_town https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_town They tend to become exploitative though.
- Feniks 9y agoReminds me of good old Johannesburg where the maids, nannies and cooks had to get up at 4 in the morning for the long bus journey to their work place.
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoCould somebody please explain why in a region with just about more millionaires and billionaires than anywhere else, there is almost[1] no serious muscle for residential development? Perhaps I am naive, but it is my understanding that many of the wealthy people of the Bay Area made the majority of their money through commerce and technology, not by purchasing a house a few years or decades ago and quashing any attempt at increasing the housing stock. Would it not be in the self interest of all tech corporations, executives, venture capitalists and angel investors in Silicon Valley to ensure the development of housing for their future tech employees - and thus spur their future profits - and the greater economy's service workers? Even if one buys the insane argument that service workers perhaps ought not to live in the expensive Bay Area, one still must acknowledge that these line chefs, janitors, security guards, hairdressers and many others must live and commute in from somewhere, which affects everybody in the Bay Area, regardless of their wealth. Everything about Silicon Valley makes sense to me but this. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/oct/02/rise-of-the-yimbys-angry-millennials-radical-housing-solution https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/oct/02/rise-of-the-y...
- maerF0x0 9y ago~$470000000 in lost economic potential due to NIMBYers Its time for San Francisco (and other bay area) to build more housing.
- 5706906c06c 9y ago38, two kids and a wife. Have been living in a 900SQ/FT apt, I don't know how much longer I can take this before rage quitting and relocating somewhere else (don't know where). The sad part, as a ethnic-minority, I have just found our community for my kids, etc. It would be really tragic if I have to tear my kids away from that. Don't get me wrong, my daily 30 minute commute on BART isn't the worst. The worst part is that I make $185,000-$238,000 (with bonus and all) and still can't afford to buy a home because I can't compete with other investors that have deep pockets filled with cash, not to mention buying a semi-decent home in a semi-OK neighborhood sets you easily back by $850K-$1.2MM. It's insane! The best I'm able to do is to pay for a $3550/mo rent and tuck away as much money as I can while providing for the wife and kids, which isn't the cheapest. Anyway, thanks for reading. Back to work. Edit: Armenian. Also, I'll check myself, there are others in far worse financial/living condition in the Bay Area. Comparatively speaking, I have it easier than most.
- mabbo 9y agoGet out, man. The region isn't trying to help people like you, with families, it's trying to help the entrenched who bought 20 years ago. You may make less money in terms of income in most other cities, but your retirement savings will grow a lot faster regardless. I work on a traveling/remote team. One of my teammates lives in Chattanooga. His 3 bedroom house with I think 2 or 3 aces of land put him back a whopping $200,000.
- nether 9y agoLots of places like this. Check out this 3-bedroom with front porch, backyard, for $70,000 in Iowa: https://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/IA/pmf,pf_pt/87001013_zpid/19_rid/0-70000_price/0-254_mp/priced_sort/44.115197,-89.637452,39.719863,-97.141114_rect/6_zm/ https://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/IA/pmf,pf_pt/87001013_...
- biesnecker 9y agoUgh, look at the school ratings on that house, though. :-( Not that there aren't a lot of places in the country with good schools and affordable housing prices, but for a lot of people with kids schools matter as much or more than housing prices.
- horsecaptin 9y agoAdd that to the lack of gender balance and one wonders why so many men are conned into moving there.
- davidw 9y agoI'm surprised no one has mentioned http://www.sfyimby.org/ http://www.sfyimby.org/ They're the go-to people if you want to be involved in fixing things.
- dmode 9y agoFYI, California state legislature has passed a number of housing laws this year intended to accelerate housing development and affordable housing. I am hoping this really makes a dent. On the other hand, I don't think real estate would ever be cheap in coastal California as the demand for such real estate extends far beyond the US.
- davidw 9y agoThey were involved in some of that legislation.
- mabbo 9y agoIt seems ironic that the land of self-aggrandizing free market disruption (Uber, AirBnb) seems so against the obvious free-market solution to their problems: increase supply. You have too little of something, and it's causing prices to skyrocket because demand is increasing. So make more of it, reducing the price. I just got back from a visit to the Bay Area. Outside of SF itself, not a single building over 4 stories tall. All that air space that could be condos, homes for people, anything at all, wasted so that "people can see the mountains better". Meanwhile, my friend and his girlfriend are paying $4000/month for 1000 sqft. Their rent is more than the median total pre-tax income in large swaths of America. This is a self-inflicted wound. I have little pity.
- JimboOmega 9y agoSo I generally agree, even within SF itself, basically nothing outside a tiny area of downtown is the height it could be. Tons of the bay area is under built. The regulatory environment is a nightmare. There is intense fear that any new building will bring newcomers that will destroy the community. That said... San Jose and Oakland both definitely have downtown portions with 20 story + buildings. RWC has been building bigger too.
- wils1245 9y agoTo me, Mountain View is the most egregiously under built city in the bay. Huge corporate campus for Google and others, but the housing stock of a suburb.
- taway_1212 9y ago> All that air space that could be condos, homes for people, anything at all, wasted so that "people can see the mountains better". Meanwhile, my friend and his girlfriend are paying $4000/month for 1000 sqft. My guess is that, if significant amounts of extra housing were added in the Bay Area, software devs salaries would fall. Right now, software companies need to pay insane money in order to offset the insane cost of living (as otherwise, they'd lost their workforce). So, filling BA with high-risers would not help members of this forum that much (it would likely be very helpful for people in low-wage jobs though).
- overcast 9y agoBoy am I glad I stayed in Upstate, NY. Stress free, five minute commute, little traffic, low cost of living, fall weather, fingerlakes, Adirondacks, no earthquakes/hurricanes/firestorms/tornadoes, and great food. Of course, now we're bidding to get Amazon to move here. Sigh.
- baxtr 9y agoFrom an outside perspective it is interesting to see, that a place, which is accepted as the planet’s hotbed of innovation is not able to produce a solution for this pressing problem. Maybe Elon or someone else should be city below the sea.
- binthere 9y agoI've been living in the bay area for about 7 years working as a software engineer. When I arrived, rent was around 1.7k for a 2 bed 2 bathroom apartment. Today, the same place charges you around 3.5k. The cost more than doubled while this is pretty much not true about your salary. You either need to get huge promotions in 7 years to double your salary which is very difficult (and this is just to keep your living standards) or be forced to move to somewhere farther and face a crushing commute of at least 2 to 3 hours everyday. Roughly speaking, buying a house is also not a win since houses closer to where you work will usually be more than 1 million dollars. Mortgage would be around 4k-5k with 20% down payment. So again, you'd be forced to buy somewhere farther. There's really not much to do about it, it's supply and demand and you need to accept it. There are a couple of things though that tech companies could do: either working with local authorities to help improve public transportation or decentralize the workplace. Companies, however, are doing exactly the opposite: Buying lands which were previously residential areas and building huge mega-structures so everyone can work in a single place while not having the best from public transportation (e.g. Apple). I naively thought that making the lives of their employees easier would be in the best interests of tech companies but I just see things getting worse every year.
- StreamBright 9y agoMust read in the subject: https://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/ https://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/
- matchagaucho 9y ago"although the East Bay eked out a gain of 500 tech jobs" This is the good news. Home prices in the East Bay are 50%-70% of SF prices, and the infrastructure for employers is comparable to SF (public transit, internet, hospitals, restaurants, culture).
- PatientTrades 9y agoSan Diego has the same problem. Impossible to find decent housing. Studios going for +600K, 3 bedroom homes going for 1M. More and more of us are living 1-2 hours away from work just to live comfortably. Eventually this will reach a breaking point, and the housing market will crash like 2008. House flippers basically playing hot potato with these inflated prices.
- howcool 9y agoAnother aspect that isn't mentioned here is this. Over the past 7 or 8 years Bay area companies have had to keep gradually increasing their employee's salaries to accommodate for the rising real estate profits, which has caused competing companies to have to do the same and so on. We've finally hit a point where companies are now realizing it isn't profitable to continue paying employees higher salaries and are letting folks go, and those folks are moving to more affordable areas in the country.
- ojbyrne 9y agoIt says “some experts” attribute this to housing costs, but nothing has really changed there in the last year (in fact in my opinion rents have softened somewhat). It seems to me the anti-immigration atmosphere is a more proximate cause.
- beatpanda 9y agoIf you're living in the Bay Area and you don't have any other reason for living here other than for work, please do yourself and everyone else a favor and move away. Many of my friends who are not tech workers, who have lived here since before the last boom got ridiculous, live in semi-legal and often unsafe housing and are doing everything they can to stay here for reasons that transcend the current economy. If you have no attachment to this place other than your job, for the love of God, get out.
- marcell 9y agoWhenever these threads come up, the NIMBY pitch forks come out. I 100% agree that we should build more housing in the Bay Area, but some perspective is helpful. The Bay Area is already one of the most densely populated regions in America: http://ecpmlangues.u-strasbg.fr/civilization/geography/maps/US%20Population%20density,%202010%20570x361.png http://ecpmlangues.u-strasbg.fr/civilization/geography/maps/... And San Francisco is the 3rd most densely populated city in America, if you look at cities with over 100k people: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_by_population_density https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_b... So I disagree with the narrative that Bay Area NIMBY-ism is out of control. It's probably similar to anywhere else in America. There are two unique factors at play here: (1) Massive growth of high paying jobs in the tech sector, with typical wages for an engineer ranging from $100-200k. This has caused housing to double/triple in cost over the last ten years. (2) The Bay Area has very unfortunate geography: there is a giant bay in its geographic center, and mountains/oceans all around. This makes traffic and commuting more difficult, and also makes development "outwards" harder.
- beatpanda 9y agoNIMBYs in San Francisco scream bloody murder and call it "violence" when developers want to build on empty parking lots. I am not exaggerating. The idea that "geography" is the limiting factor here is willful ignorance.
- marcell 9y agoGeography definitely impacts it. There is substantially cheaper housing in the East Bay, compared to SF/Peninsula. However there's no good way to get from the East Bay to where the jobs are: you are limited by one of three bridges, all of which have terrible traffic. Imagine if we filled up the entire SF Bay with concrete, and demolished all the mountains surrounding the Bay Area. I'll bet you would see improved traffic and more even prices between East/West bay.
- tmh79 9y agothere is a lot you're leaving out here or misunderstand. The reason that there is a housing crises int he SFBA is that all of the cities in the SFBA have produced an order of magnitude more office space than housing in the past 10 or so years. Look at communities like Cupertino, building the apple space ship for 14k people, but adding virtually no housing to the city. Lather/rinse/repeat for Palo Alto, MPK, MTV, etc and you have a terrible region-wide housing crises.
- Bhilai 9y agoI still get a couple of emails every week from recruiters with job openings in Bay Area. I always tell them I am willing to talk but only if I don't have relocate to Bay Area. I rarely receive a reply back and if I do they usually tell me job location is not negotiable. The multitude of tech companies that refuse to allow remote work (or do not allow working from a different office because of location of hiring team etc.) are also a big part of the problem.
- c1utch1 9y agoI'm under thirty and bought a place in San Francisco this year using my own savings from my paychecks. No, I'm not being crushed by my mortgage either. It's definitely achievable, just need to work hard and save your money. Costs are higher here but wages are almost much higher than anywhere else so it's not as terrible as it seems. The Mercury News publishes this same article every 5 years despite home prices continuing to push higher over the long-term.
- top256 9y agodo you think it's the start of a downturn?
- yalph 9y agoI still dont understand why people here and Reddit claim that Bay area housing is more expensive than New York. In manhattan you get a frigging hole for a million bucks. Is it may be because it is a new phenomenon in the west coast and people are shocked?
- randyrand 9y agoPeople losing their jobs is the most sure fire ways to lower housing costs. This title makes no sense.
- nfriedly 9y agoMy wife and I lived in the Bay Area for a year. It was great - beautiful weather (San Mateo), incredible farmers market, and we met some really cool people. I'm glad we did it, but I'm also glad that I moved back to Ohio now. Beyond having my extended family around here, it just feels like a better place to raise a family and be part of a community, whereas SF seemed more geared towards single or childless folks who were very focused on their carriers. The Bay Area is also incredibly expensive. After moving back, I went to a movie with a friend, asked for two tickets, then tried to correct the attendant because the price was so low that I thought she must have rung me up for a single ticket. That's just one example, but nearly everything costs more in SF. Oh, and our house in Ohio cost slightly less than my current annual salary - I had an apartment and the mortgage overlapping for a couple of months here, and even paying both was less than what my rent was in San Mateo.
- aabajian 9y agoI place blame on the location of the tech hubs in the Bay Area. Not one mega-company, save Tesla, has setup shop in East Bay. There is affordable housing across the water, and new construction as well. Facebook has mitigated this somewhat buy purchasing Sun Microsystem's campus right next to the bridge. Also, note that SF isn't the fastest growing housing market anymore, it's Seattle (https://www.seattletimes.com/business/real-estate/seattle-no-1-in-home-price-growth-again-starter-homes-require-half-of-income/ https://www.seattletimes.com/business/real-estate/seattle-no...). Seattle didn't feel as much housing-pressure with Microsoft due to the remote location of its campus in Redmond/Bellevue. That's changing with Amazon; the sales giant is located in prime real estate, just like the tech companies on the peninsula.
- reducesuffering 9y agoTeslas development still happens in Palo Alto or San Mateo. They only setup the factory in Fremont because the building had already been built 30 years ago.
- Animats 9y agoOK, jobs are down a little, and this means the housing problem is getting worse? That seems backwards.
- floydman 9y agoThis isn't really a bay area specific issue but rather a problem with any area that is desirable to live in with jobs. I live in Honolulu and we see the same issues here. Home prices are even more out of sync with salaries here as there are no where near as many high paying jobs as in the bay area. We also have a large homeless problem like SF
- ajeet_dhaliwal 9y agoThe lack of affordable housing is strangling the middle class (typical worker type) in every major city in the UK and Canada too, it’s nothing to do with SV specifically, yes that lead to the higher population but other cities have had their own industries. The real problem is interest rates are low in all these countries and speculation means people will borrow like crazy to keep on increasing the prices. We also allow it to be fine for one person to own 1000 homes while local authorities in some cases limit supply.
- Apocryphon 9y agoSeeking Bay Area relocation stories in this Ask HN thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15536213 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15536213
- chenpengcheng 9y agoDouble income $500K/year (common among folks who work for the Internet companies) can borrow up to $3mil (6x income). There are still many homes affordable to such folks. For listings below $2mil, there are usually 8-10 offers. For the hot ones, there can be 20 offers.
- captainbeardo 9y agoI grew up in the Bay Area and got a feel for the tech sector up there. People always throw around the "network" argument out there for why they decided to move up. Truth is you can get just as much networking in if you move to an emerging tech hub along with positioning yourself better by more easily establishing yourself/buying cheaper property. I'm looking at you Portland, San Diego, and Denver.
- primeblue 9y agoThe whole world is overpopulated and congested, get over it and accept you're fate of living in towers of tiny boxes, it's called progress.
- hx87 9y agoIf SF Bay Area cities can't be bothered to build enough housing, they should at least have the decency to tax the fuck out of business until they start moving out and housing prices regress to 3x the median rent. If you want the companies, you must take their employees. If you don't want their employees, you shouldn't have the companies.
- taysic 9y agoThey could just stop approving new office space. I've noticed a lot of the prices increases started around when Twitter moved to Civic Center and SOMA began to open up to tech startups. I think the number of jobs vastly increased.
- throw2016 9y agoThis has a roll on effect as business with increased real estate costs pass it on to consumers. So you are not only directly paying higher rent or purchase but also for products and services. What's supposed to happen is inflated prices take up an unjustifiable portion of income and make things like families impossible forcing people to move. Wages are supposed to keep rising to keep pace rendering some business unprofitable, making others expensive and forcing others to move altogether, all adding up to cause a correction in prices. But in the real world its not really working that way. While wages are rising there is also large import of labour keeping wages in check with people resorting to more and more desperate measures like sharing rooms. Without that perhaps the labour crisis would become unmanageable forcing businesses and government to rethink some policies. At the moment its the financial and real estate sectors making out while the average person faces the brunt. This is replicated worldwide in most major cities.
- vadym909 9y agoToo many Chinese buyers, rich businessmen, corrupt bureaucrats, made money speculating on Beijing real estate and middle class speculators with children planning to study in the US have flooded the housing market from Vancouver, Seattle to SF Bay area. I guess they probably form at least 10-25% of buyers. Just making overpriced metros ineligible for foreign buyers could ease the pricing pressure.
- jaredklewis 9y agoWhen you sell stuff to foreign people that’s called exporting. Exports are good. They bring money from foreign countries to your country. So SF could stop exporting with some sort of ban on foreign buyers. For what's it worth (not much), I think such a ban would have almost no effect, as unless the US bans all Chinese capital wholesale, all the same money can makes it way to SF real estate through less direct means. Or we could fix our taxes and regulations. The current regime of taxes and regulations actively incentivize speculation, and penalize land use. We need tax revenue, might as well collect it in a way that discourages speculation.
- valuearb 9y ago“Nobody goes there anymore. It's too crowded.” Yogi Berra and San Jose Mercury News on Silicon Valley.