12 ms·
Report: TSMC's 3nm Fab Could Cost $20B
- mmanfrin 9y ago3nm is hugely smaller than anything else I've heard of. I know Intel is stuck at 14nm, and Samsung is at 10nm for their ARM chips (? someone correct me on that) -- could someone educate me on what 3nm chip technology means? Would it be 3x the speed density/possibility compared to 10nm chips?
- vorotato 9y agoWould it even work I think is the more meaningful question. Last I heard we we having trouble with electrons tunneling across the gates as we got smaller.
- klodolph 9y agoThat's just one of many problems…
- tankenmate 9y agoYou have to start wondering if they will use quantum behaviour like Anderson localisation that sets up a standing wave effectively stopping electrons from tunnelling in certain places (design it to bias against and/or stop gate leak tunnelling). Svitlana Mayboroda discovered a lanscape function that allows you to predict (and hence design) this kind of behaviour. As to how actively using these kinds of quantum behaviour affects feature size / speeds / feeds / yields will probably eat several tens of millions / years as well.
- topspin 9y agoThis is an announcement for construction of a "5 or 3nm fab as early as 2022." So, five years out, minimum, and the node size is a moving target. The title is a bit clickbaity.
- foobarian 9y agoI found some side concerns interesting: - an earlier node was delayed due to environmental permitting - this project will require a lot of land - the Taiwanese government is committed to keeping this fab at home, and willing to work with TSMC on the environmental issues.
- microcolonel 9y agoYeah, I think it'll be important from the perspective of the... tenuous relationship between PRC and ROC. In that sense, there is almost no environmental stress that wouldn't be worth overcoming.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mozumder 9y agoAs for end product realization compared to current gen stuff, it'll be about the scale of difference between the XBox360 to the XBox One.
- earenndil 9y agoI think 7nm exists somewhere, but I could be wrong.
- icegreentea2 9y ago7nm chips (TSMC manufacturing for Qualcomm) are in the pipe for 2018 chip launch (so maybe 2019 in phones). http://www.androidauthority.com/qualcomm-drops-samsung-to-work-with-tsmc-at-7nm-779197/ http://www.androidauthority.com/qualcomm-drops-samsung-to-wo...
- zanny 9y agoIt exists as a buzzword. Nothing about the TSMC 7nm node means actual 7nm gate widths. It will still only be about as good as what Intel is calling 14nm++. The simple reality is that all these fab companies have some recent fab tech, that will be roughly the same across all of them, with the exception of Intel usually being slightly ahead of the rest. The names they give them are pointless now, though. Since the nm doesn't really matter to consumers outside purchasing individual hardware components themselves, just getting the newest parts is all you can really care about. You look at the performance, power draw, and cost and make a judgement from there, and things like "Intel 14nm vs TSMC 7nm vs GF Finfat 10nm or Samsungs whatever" are meaningless marketing drivel.
- kyrra 9y ago(this is my ignorant understanding of how CPU sizing works) Process size isn't the end-all be-all stat to follow for CPU manufacturing sizes. While Intel may not be leading here, they are leading when it comes to feature sizes. https://www.extremetech.com/computing/246902-intel-claims-three-year-advantage-10nm-process-wants-change-define-process-nodes https://www.extremetech.com/computing/246902-intel-claims-th... The idea being of how large the features of the CPU are to make up the building block for parts of the system. While Intel's process may be larger, they end up getting smaller overall chips because they can still get more "Features" into a smaller area. Also, Most CPUs aren't made at a single process size. They will mix 2-3 generations of process sizes when producing CPUs, and only put the hot-path parts of the CPU in the newest process size (to help improve yields).
- dom0 9y ago> Also, Most CPUs aren't made at a single process size. They will mix 2-3 generations of process sizes when producing CPUs, and only put the hot-path parts of the CPU in the newest process size (to help improve yields). No, you can't mix different processes on one wafer. I think you mean that not everything on a CPU is at the minimum viable size of that process.
- kyrra 9y agoThanks. Would you say this article describes the whole situation well? http://wccftech.com/intel-losing-process-lead-analysis-7nm-2022/ http://wccftech.com/intel-losing-process-lead-analysis-7nm-2...
- wilun 9y agoNodes are hard to compare, and pretty much everybody agrees that what Intel called 14nm is roughly equivalent to other foundries' 10nm. (Maybe some of the 10nm processes are 10 or 15% more dense than Intel's 14, but nothing like the 2x we should have with more straightforward comparisons) And that's not even the end of the story. Intel 14nm++ is expected to be slightly LESS dense than their previous 14nm and 14nm+, to alleviate some of the problems that start to appear with such small nodes. Let's not even talk about EUV processes, that will be needed to go under 7nm (IIRC). We are not even sure they can be used for mass production. Probably they can, but there are still a lot of things to fix in this area. 10 years ago it was expected to be in mass prod today or even 1 or 2 year ago - and it is still very far from ready. Fur sure they will be crazy expensive too, so tons of chip will continue to be produced on processes with bigger nodes. So talking about 3nm now is bound to not be extremely precise, given all the unknown. Its dubious it will come as soon as 2022. It will be crazy expensive, but we already knew that.
- megy 9y agoDon't get stuck up on the numbers, they are all marketing numbers.
- Animats 9y ago3nm. Wow. Synchrotron, or laser tin vaporization soft X-ray source?
- cromwellian 9y ago3nm isn't even on the international semiconductor roadmap (that stops at 5nm, and 4nm half-node) How can they build a fab for a process node that isn't even designed yet? Has anyone even produced prototype chips at this node yet?
- valarauca1 9y agoThe International Semiconductor Roadmap was properly tossed out the window at the 28nm node. In the past year they're more or less retconned the industry's current node system _into_ the road map. Modern pitch measurement is more a marketing term then a _real_ measurement of engineering precision. A smaller/newer value is roughly equal to 1/2 power consumption, it no longer implies 2x density.
- toufka 9y agoIs 3nm an actual measure of a distance, or is it entirely a marketing term like 3G cell phone service? I can't quite get a straight answer. As far as I could tell from outside the field it felt like at ~15nm the measure stopped being a measure of a feature, and more a measure of precision, and then a 'version' to be decremented rather than relating to a 'meter' in any way. When I look at electron micrographs of the transistors they don't appear to be 3nm in size... Anyone able to help here? At 3nm, you get smaller than a biological protein and have features with countable numbers of atoms. And as far as my education went, quantum effects start to dominate, and bulk material properties start to (mis)behave very differently.
- marcosdumay 9y agoFeature size was always a measure of precision. It's just that one used to be able to draw artifacts 1 feature wide, while doing that nowadays seems to be useless. Just as a comparison, the Bohr radius of an doping election in a silicon crystal is around 10nm. I don't think you will see 3nm wide transistors unless they are fin-fets.
- spuz 9y agoI can't understand your answer to the question. Is 3nm a measure of distance or not? If so, what is it a measure of?
- DigitalJack 9y agoImagine graph paper with the length of the side of a square being the feature size. 3nm. Where you shade in represents the metalization. Now imagine you have a design rule that says a metalization trace must be no less than 3 squares wide, for the sake of functionality. That's a 3nm process. You might get away with putting to 9nm lines within 3nm of each other, or you might come up with some interesting transistor shapes that would not be possible on a larger process. But a trace would still have to be 9nm.
- icegreentea2 9y agoAt some point, the feature size stopped being a measurement of any specific feature on the IC, and just a generalized metric. But ya, I mean if you forced them to, their engineers could probably produce the formula that mixes together a bunch of actual physical feature sizes, and explain why 3nm is not a lie - but its very much a marketing thing. One obvious hint at this is how the different manufacturer's 'x' nm nodes have obviously different performances.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoOne wonders how "real" this announcement is and how much of it is positioning. The press releases from TSMC isn't very informative[1]. As interesting as it is to consider that someone might actually be putting money on the table today, given the pains people seem to be having with the 7nm node I would not expect to see even a 5nm node until 2022 - 2023. That said, if they do get to a 3nm node, assuming that actual circuit elements are 3 - 9nm that is still a lot of billion transistor chips on a wafer. I'm guessing 30% of the wafer would be consumed with die pads rather than actual chip :-) [1] http://www.tsmc.com/uploadfile/pr/newspdf/THWQGOHITH/NEWS_FILE_EN.pdf http://www.tsmc.com/uploadfile/pr/newspdf/THWQGOHITH/NEWS_FI...
- gwern 9y agoGlobalFoundries was estimating $14-18b would be needed for the next generation of chip fabs: https://venturebeat.com/2017/10/01/globalfoundries-next-generation-chip-factories-will-cost-at-least-10-billion/view-all/ https://venturebeat.com/2017/10/01/globalfoundries-next-gene... Their CEO notes that the 3nm or 5m numbers being tossed around aren't really too meaningful, but the budgets speak for themselves.
- lquist 9y agoSo am I correct in understanding that Moore's Law marches on? If we see 5nm in 2020 and TSMC is seeing 3nm in production in 2022, this is on track, correct?
- manigandham 9y agoSide note, for anyone interested in how chips are produced, this is one of my favorite videos: Indistinguishable From Magic: Manufacturing Modern Computer Chips https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NGFhc8R_uO4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NGFhc8R_uO4
- deepnotderp 9y agoPSA: 3nm doesn't actually mean ANYTHING except that it's smaller than 5nm (and larger) nodes from the SAME FOUNDRY. If you want a general benchmark now, TSMC "7nm" ~= Intel "10nm". Note that this isn't because Intel is pious and searching for the true node name or anything, their nodes used to be less dense than the industry standard (back above ~45nn) but just turned out denser now.
- phyller 9y agoThe eetimes article is just a short summary of the actual article at https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-10-06/tsmc-ready-to-spend-20-billion-on-its-most-advanced-chip-plant https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-10-06/tsmc-read...
- amelius 9y agoI thought this article was more interesting, and also has interesting comments: https://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1330971 https://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1330971
- auvi 9y agoAnd who is making the lithography equipment for TSMC for its "3nm" Fab? I guess ASML?
- abpavel 9y agoAtomic radius of Silicon atom is 0.11nm, which results in width of about 0.22nm. So even tightly packing atoms will make the barrier only ~13 atoms thick. Van der Waals radius is about twice that, resulting in 7-atom-wide barrier. Quantum tunneling [0] is apparent at 3nm, and gets worse from there, so I don't see how they would be preventing electrons leaking through the barrier, unless "3nm Fab" would have a shovel of marketing salt to boot. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_tunnelling https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_tunnelling
- typon 9y agoNone of the technology node names have corresponded to actual physical gate length since probably the 45nm node.
- baybal2 9y agoyou can grow a layer of silicon on top of something with slightly more compact lattice
- esmi 9y agoTransistors have always leaked. The main thing is Ion/Ioff > 1. The higher the ratio the better but with digital one can get by with surprisingly little gain and still get useful circuits.
- nmz787 9y agoWhy don't these numbers ever list the width AND height AND length... I'd really like to know how many atoms each transistor was composed of.
- ksec 9y agoThis is in Intel's terms 5nm. We know real Intel's 10nm / TSMC 7nm has finished and is matter of yielding. We know TSMC Intel 7nm / TSMC 5nm is pretty close to complete. This is coming out to market in roughly 2020. We know 3nm is coming in 2022 / 2023. But what comes after 3nm? Will we need some material science breakthrough? Process and Material that can run at 10Ghz with the same power usage. More transistor hasn't given us more performance. IPC, Core Count, Clockspeed, Special Instruction Set (Its funny how we swing from RISC to CSIC again ), and larger cache. It seems we have reached a plateau where we cant have more performance from CPU Hardware. GPU is different since it scaled very nicely with transistor count, and is more limited by bandwidth. And fast, simple, high performance, easy to programmed for Programming languages + framework hasn't really come along. But cost for Fabs, Wafer and Designing is rising. Or have we reached a stage, performance no longer matter for majority of people?
- jlebrech 9y agowe're merely hitting 1.2ghz mean use and 4ghz peak usage. 10ghz is very fast.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]