12 ms·
A glut of PhDs who can’t find academic jobs
- Overtonwindow 9y agoI think what we have is a glut of people who don't want to enter the workforce, and have this naive dream of academia, tenure, and doing research. In my humble opinion, the purpose of a professor at a university is to TEACH. Not research, that should be secondary to their teaching duties. Universities are deceiving PhD students into thinking this magical world of research, and lifetime tenure awaits them at the end of the PhD rainbow.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rjsw 9y agoAs the child of a tenured professor, the employment contract didn't even used to mention teaching, the job was to do research.
- oddlyaromatic 9y agoMine didn't. I did an MA and got an up close view of the life of many academics and recognized it was not for me. But the general impression I got was there are two good reasons to do a phd: 1. For pleasure/curiosity/enjoyment (as in you are independently wealthy). 2. If you can't see yourself being happy in any other life and you understand the compromises you have to make (poor income, high competition, having to move a lot, etc.) I know some wonderful PhDs who got doctorates with this very understanding and love their lives. But I didn't have the wealth to do it for fun, and I generally land on my feet and get happy no matter what, so I didn't borrow any more trouble and moved on with my life. America's universities maybe may be different but this is how it was in Ireland!
- mjfl 9y agoI'm a PhD student with no intention of going into academia. I just love science, and being able to do it for 5 more years is inherently fulfilling to me. That's why I came back to grad school after working for two years. Let's be real, real life kind of sucks. Now I get paid less but I feel like I'm living in luxury. I have no illusion about the money I'm sacrificing but in my mind I've made a fair trade.
- enraged_camel 9y ago>>In my humble opinion, the purpose of a professor at a university is to TEACH. Not research, that should be secondary to their teaching duties. No. PhDs are extremely specialized on a very narrow topic within a single field. They spend years researching that topic to the exclusion of everything else. Asking PhDs to teach is like asking brain surgeons to treat common cold. They probably can do it, but it's a gross waste of their skills and expertise.
- barry-cotter 9y agoIf there is no demand for your skills they can’t be wasted. There’s no necessary reason why being really good at literary criticism is any more socially valuable than being really good at Counter Strike. If no one’s willing to pay you for it I hope you had fun learning to do it because otherwise it was a waste.
- greglindahl 9y agoDo you have a source for this tale of successful deception of poor grad students by universities other than your own imagination? When I went to grad school in the sciences in the 1990s we were all well aware of the job market, because students were constantly finishing and we'd know what jobs they got.
- ineedasername 9y agoWell, yes & no. It is an oddly contradictory system in this way, especially when you consider Teacher Ed. programs that certify their graduates to teach below the college level. Implicit therein is a recognition that teaching is a specialized profession requiring specialized skills. Yet faculty in higher ed are not expected to have any specialized training in this area, and all learning of it is "on the job". The result is an educational environment where the most visible job requirement for faculty is to teach courses in their field. But that is the portion of their responsibilities for which, from an incentives perspective, they are least accountable. Instead, to obtain a tenure-track position and ultimately earn tenure itself, primary requirements are research and publishing output, with double++ good to eleventy for bringing research grants to their institution. Teaching and advising/mentoring, not quite an afterthought, is much lower in priority & weighting in tenure review.
- ineedasername 9y agoI should add that the faculty most consistently dedicated to quality instruction and student mentoring seem to be those who already have tenure, though it is a minority of them. Anecdotally, I perceive higher consistent quality of instruction from adjunct faculty though. I'm not sure if that is because they often end up teaching more courses and gain more experience thereby, or because they have less need to sink time into other research, or some other factor. I have seen faculty in tenure track positions penalized for focusing too much on the side of student instruction, advising, etc. In one particular case tenure was denied on the basis of a light research portfolio despite an extensive and impressive track record of well-rated course instruction and an impressive dedication to meeting with students far more the the minimum required time. (2.5 office hours/week) Of course there may have been more to the denial, I only know the publicly available details from the fallout when a dispute was filed.
- opportune 9y agoUniversities just need to do a better job of separating teaching and research in my opinion. Someone with a PhD in algebraic graph theory isn't going to want to teach 20 year olds what a group is, or grade their tests, and they shouldn't have to. For every undergraduate class, there are probably more than enough 25 year olds with degrees in that subject capable of teaching that class better than that professor might. But, whoever teaches the class should first and foremost be a good teacher who actually wants to teach, and not whichever professor/grad student could be drafted into duty. The main problem with universities these days is that they are given the duty of both teaching and research, but they force people to teach that don't want to (some professors, grad students). In addition many people view universities more as job training than learning about a specific subject. If you go to college to get a degree in CS, but all you want to do is get a job at Google, you don't need CS experts to teach you intro to data structures or how to write SQL. I think the long term solution is to entirely separate the realms of research and teaching, or to make teaching as a research professor entirely "opt-in" outside of discipline specific classes (the algebraic graph theory professor should probably be the one teaching algebraic graph theory). My university has been relying more and more on teaching-only professors to teach CS classes and I think it's a wonderful solution. The teaching-only professors are much more personable and engaged in the actual teaching, and the research professors get to focus on what they're good at.
- mikebenfield 9y ago> Not research, that should be secondary to their teaching duties. Why?
- martin1975 9y agoI'd say because teaching has a higher payoff for the students being taught. They can get jobs immediately after college and contribute... Research on the other hand, outside of the self-serving aspect - like how many papers one gets published - has hardly any immediate benefits relative to the benefits of teaching... and few long term benefits. It's more of a gamble.
- pacala 9y agoThe PhD system is a Ponzi scheme. First and foremost, a PhD program trains one to become a professor. During a professor career, one is expected to graduate 5, 10, 20 PhD students. It is mathematically impossible for the majority of these students to find a professor job. The explosion of higher education, internally and globally, masks the problem to some extent, just like a good old fashioned Ponzi scheme appears solvable for a period of time. Edit: It is pretty well known that there is exactly "One True Path" for a research career. See [0] or [1] [0] https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/doing-good-science/careers-not-just-jobs-for-phds-outside-the-academy/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/doing-good-science/care... [1] http://ethicsandscience.scientopia.org/2008/11/20/excuses-for-discounting-people/ http://ethicsandscience.scientopia.org/2008/11/20/excuses-fo...
- chrisseaton 9y ago> First and foremost, a PhD program trains one to become a professor. No it doesn't! It trains you to be a researcher. You can be a researcher without being a professor.
- whyever 9y agoIn most countries, being a professor is the only way to have a permanent position as a researcher in academia. You can be a researcher without being a professor, but it may involve changing your position (and country) every few years.
- chrisseaton 9y agoI can't understand why you think this is the case. You can get a full-time job in industry being a researcher. Why would you need to move every few years?
- jccooper 9y agoAs the first step on the path to understanding, first consider: "in what fields do people get doctorates?" As a second step, consider for each of those "what industry will employ them?" If you step over to the non-STEM (and to a lesser extent non-TE) fields, the answer to the second question tends to diminish to "academia".
- frozenport 9y ago>>Despite our moans about hours of work, pay, and pensions, being an academic is still the best job in the world for those of a particular temperament and talents. I have a slave temperment and enjoy being hauranged by my PI? My talents include falsifying experiments and writing endless papers about how our method is superior to all other methods? Yet we, much like the communist revolutions in the 20th century, have been working on it for the last 20 years?
- apersona 9y agoHave you actually been in a PhD program?
- frozenport 9y agoYes :-(
- computerex 9y agoAd hominem much?
- sitkack 9y agoAcademia is one sink for PhDs. The whole idea of "too many educated people" has to torn down!
- chrisseaton 9y agoWhy does everyone think PhDs want or need to go into academia? I never planned to be an academic when I decided to start my PhD. I think that's fairly common.
- ineedasername 9y agoProbably because, outside of a STEM discipline and a few other exceptions, there isn't a distinct non-academia/teaching career path. Combine this with both a larger social push for higher education, declining state support for local public institutions that in turn drive a need for higher enrollments to cover costs without (even larger) tuition increases. And add to that a k-12 educational pipeline that has failed in (fully) addressing the need for quality STEM education. This, of course, oversimplifies the situation to a large degree. But the above factors contribute strongly. Intelligent and driven students, coming into the Higher Ed community with an interest in advanced degrees but relatively weaker STEM backgrounds, are disproportionately represented in humanities & social sciences programs.
- kaeluka 9y agoI saw it as an option, but an unlikely one.
- opportune 9y agoI'm surprised this article doesn't try to address the reasons this is happening. It mentions that the employers (universities) benefit from students funding themselves, and I'm not super familiar with the UK's academic system, but this seems to be an oversight by the author/editor since most PhD students (in the US, at least) are funded to do their research. I think the most important reasons we have a glut of PhDs who can't find academic jobs are that 1. Education is becoming more universally accessible and overall education is increasing. This causes a larger proportion of the population to be interested in getting PhDs and also to be qualified (academically) to do so. Similarly, to stand out in the job market, some people may be getting PhDs to differentiate themselves from people with masters/bachelors (or equivalents), since there are so many people with these degrees now. 2. A university spends less money on salaries by having a small number of professors with huge labs and armies of PhDs rather than a larger number of professors: a graduate student will work for 10-25% of a professor's salary, and without tenure. Maintaining this ratio requires having many more graduate students than professors, but doesn't give those graduate students anywhere to go when they graduate. 3. PhD programs are often used an immigration tool rather than as preparation for academia. Many PhD students I worked with were getting PhDs so that they could emigrate from India/Pakistan/China to the US and get a well-paying job. I'm sure a similar phenomenon occurs in the UK. 4. Research spending hasn't caught up with the increasing number of PhDs. 5. Because of the research boom in the post world-war period (this occurred in the US as well), most people getting academic jobs around then were around the same age. Many of these people haven't retired yet, and they may subconsciously have introduced a new part of academic culture: you need to be old before you get a professorship. 6. Many students graduate with PhDs but without having done significant enough research to merit continuing in academia. This could have a variety of causes: publish or perish, admitting unqualified/unmotivated candidates, the academic "low-hanging fruit" getting harder to research with time.
- cupscale 9y ago> A university spends less money on salaries by having a small number of professors with huge labs and armies of PhDs rather than a larger number of professors It's also worth pointing out that this is pretty necessary from the lab's point of view, especially in some of the more high-end labs: PIs (in my experience, anyway) are frequently spending >90% of their time just writing grant proposals and dealing with the funding side of things. There's very little time for them to do anything besides the funding circuit, and so the actual research part falls to graduate students and postdocs: People who obviously have less experience as professional researchers (and thus many more of them are required).
- TimPC 9y agoI'm not sure we have a glut of PhD's at all. At least not in fields where there is actual research in industry. I work in industry on a team where almost everyone has a PhD and those that don't have a Master's degree (or two). The team I'm on publishes research, reads papers regularly, attends research conferences, has visiting professors and researchers give talks, but also ships product. Maybe CS and AI is an outlier in terms of having huge demand in industry (relative to the work available, there is a huge shortfall of AI PhD's), but I wouldn't be surprised if much of industry is like this. Plenty of people go into a PhD to go into industry in a research-oriented role. The claim that we would be better off with a less educated society is so extraordinary it requires extraordinary evidence. A handful of cherry-picked data points and a skewed interpretation is very unconvincing. Yes there is a cost in an investment of time. But for many PhD students these are happy years they remember fondly for the rest of their lives, even if they end up outside academia. If we have an actual genuine glut, show me a survey with good methodology showing that most PhD graduates regret doing their PhD's. We don't have anything close to that.
- alexasmyths 9y agoCS+AI is an outlier. There are a lot of humanities PhD's who will have a hard time in any capacity outside of academia leveraging their credentials. Saw a doc on the making of a film, they have linguistic advisors for accents ... a PhD. I'd gather hard to come by.
- mikebenfield 9y ago> Maybe CS and AI is an outlier Yes, it is a huge outlier. Probably the most extreme outlier there is. > Plenty of people go into a PhD to go into industry In CS? Yes. In most other fields? Absolutely not.
- yeukhon 9y agoI come from a city university, and in my experience many of the master students there (information system or computer science program) are not up to standard when they leave the program (i.e. they can't really program, let alone with theories). I think this is the problem with my school, but when I had this conversation with an old friend he felt that his master classes focused on theory, very little room for programming. He also had the feeling that in PhD, unless one's research requires programming, theory is emphasized over engineering. Perhaps this is an edge case... I don't know. Then a long time ago, someone claimed to have PhD failed my interview. I asked this candidate to pick a language and write a function to determine whether a string is palindrome or not. He couldn't even start with a function declaration (I don't even program Java but I know how to write a function declaration). I was disappointed, but I gave him another chance. This time I wrote the declaration on the board, and I asked him to write code to determine whether a number is even or odd. He flunked again. Our recruiter never followed up to request evidence for his PhD degree because he failed the interview anyway. Even though I still believe he lied, but if he didn't, how did this university, a university with good reputation, gave him his degree? (btw, every single time I bring this up on HN, I get downvote, I never understand. So challenge me if you think I am lying.)
- umanwizard 9y agoI assume you get downvoted because theoretical CS research really doesn't need to involve coding, so it's not as odd as you seem to think.
- brians 9y agoDijkstra famously compared this to astronomers who have no interest in telescopes or observing. I love theory, would happily retire to it—but I can’t see how anyone could have the right imagination calibration without lots of practice.
- dagw 9y agoDijkstra famously compared this to astronomers who have no interest in telescopes or observing That certainly isn't my interpretation of the quote (unless you're thinking of a different quote than the one I'm familiar with) The quote I know is: "Computer Science is no more about computers than astronomy is about telescopes."
- kchoudhu 9y agoI'm probably going to go back to get a PhD at some point in my 40s. Not because I want to become a professor, but because I think it'll be good to sit down for a period of four or five years and just think in the company of other agile minds. Of course, this is only possible because I'll have made sure to have had an entire career behind me, and I will not be worrying about putting food on my family's table or keeping a roof over their heads. A PhD is to me, therefore, not a profession but an avocation. Something to do after you've done everything else. The idea of doing it a few years after college, with the intention of making academia your profession? That's terrifying to me.
- msb 9y agoThis is me. I am 43, entering my fourth year of PhD. If you have money saved and want to challenge yourself in new ways a PhD is a worthwhile goal. A couple of thoughts: 1) Many of my 20 something peers are struggling financially, 20-30k a year is difficult to live on in CA. I made good money in my 20s and enjoyed life, having less now does not bother me. 2) I don't have children. My peers with children face a much different set of challenges than I do. I suppose it comes down to the support structure in your life, but I am not sure I could do this with school age kids. 3) I cannot stress enough the importance of a top tier school and a strong advisor.
- kchoudhu 9y agoYeah, by the time I plan on heading back to school, I'm going to have a six year old and a seven year old, and I don't think money will really be a problem (I'm effectively coasting and working on random side projects now anyhow, going to school won't really change anything). I suspect that a lot of the stress of grad school goes away once money isn't an issue, and your progress in school isn't an existential issue. I really do wish mature grad students were more of a thing.
- wbillingsley 9y agoPhDs are a research training scheme, not an academic training scheme. As the economy has become more competitive, and more of the population has bachelor's degrees, proven research skills (as well as proven skills at independent work, dealing with complex unknown problems, sticking at a long and difficult task for 3+ years to make a unique contribution, and solid evidence that you are at the leading edge of your field) are quite valuable in the industry job market. Of the cohort of PhD students I went through with, from a rough guess (I haven't taken exact count), the most common role is now "startup CEO", followed by "engineer at enviable company", followed only then by "teaching and research academic". The other side of the coin is that (in some countries) academic careers are changing, in that things are becoming more specialised between teaching and research -- funding crunches are pushing universities into letting teaching loads increase, while research grant funding is competitive largely based on "how many previous grants have you won" (which as it gets more competitive depends on having a lower teaching load to focus almost single-mindedly on research). A curious side-effect of which is that teaching posts are often continuing (there's a steady flow of students to teach) while at the start of a research career, research-focused staff may be on fixed-term contract (research grants are time-limited). In other words, your family situation (how much you can move around to build a research career, how much you need a stable income) also has a big impact on your pathway.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThe only time I have missed not getting a PhD was when lawyers have me explain to someone who has a PhD what I mean so that they can bring my testimony into an IP case by a more identifiable 'expert'. That said, there is a particularly annoying type of PhD in the tech world, it is one who assumes that the person they are talking to who doesn't have a PhD, doesn't have that degree because they were incapable of getting it, rather than they simply didn't bother. That is, I suppose, human nature. It is always amusing when I encounter it because I know the person underestimates people.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoI don't thing those kind of PhDs really exist in significant numbers, especially in research. "Ya, that guy who just got that breakthrough in machine learning? He only has a master degree" is so common it's already normalized.
- ianai 9y agoThat’s funny because every “engineer” or “analyst” my job employs has that exact attitude. They don’t even have PhDs.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoI'm not sure I get what you mean? If the specific title of PhD is unrelated to people using their titles as false sources of authorities, then what I said isn't wrong. I guess you could argue that in research many people have PhDs, so whether you have one or not is no longer a big deal.
- ianai 9y agoThe average occurrence of that sort of mentality across the population suggests most PhDs would have at least that majority view as being a subset of the larger. There’s also no reason to assume the factors that lead someone to obtain a PhD counter an elitist attitude. If anything, it certainly bolsters the odds through sunk cost and other psychological factors. Put another way, it’s been my experience that nearly everybody has a view that they’re better than average or different in some positive, unique way. The worlds full of hostie personalities as well.
- analog31 9y agoIf you are taking a PhD, especially in the sciences, look away now. It may be stale news but I’ve just seen a graph from a 2010 Royal Society report suggesting that of every 200 people completing a PhD, only seven will get a permanent academic post. Only one will become a professor. Stale, as in, 70+ years old. I got my PhD in physics, in 1993. At that time, science students were talking about something that we referred to as the "birth control problem," which was that each professor only had to produce one professor in the next generation, and the rest of us belonged to what could have been referred to as a glut. I mentioned this to my dad, who got his PhD in the 1950s. He listened to my lament, and said: "Yeah, we knew about that when we were grad students too." I finished my degree and went straight into industry. Just as my dad did.
- porter 9y agoDoesn't that assume zero student population growth?
- analog31 9y agoIndeed, but even a moderate growth model still has a birth control problem, with a different threshold. On the other hand, it's also offset by the decline of tenured faculty in college teaching.
- frozenport 9y agoBut industry also has the same problem with management positions. The real problem is the terrible treatment of postdocs due to a lack of "non-training" positions. Imagine if your boss made 5x as much as you because the only two jobs at your company are intern and manager.
- analog31 9y agoIndeed, post-docs are a whole 'nother ball o' wax. I skipped doing a post-doc altogether. In fact, when I knew that I wasn't headed for academia, then suddenly a lot of the hoops vanished, including the need to have a lot of publications.
- danieltillett 9y agoI finished a Ph.D and became a tenured professor (top of the greasy pole) and I have no regrets despite not being part of academia anymore. The experience of doing a Ph.D changed me for the better and gave me the confidence to take the risk to start my company. We don't train too many Ph.Ds, we just undervalue them outside of academia. One thing I think would help is to not allowing someone to start a Ph.D until they had a few years work experience outside of academia. Too many students end up on the Ph.D railroad without experiencing anything outside of school.
- paultopia 9y agoThis too. IME, the phd students who do well are those who had a life pre-academia, and hence didn’t get super-invested in aforesaid greasy pole, didn’t get weird parental issues with their advisors, etc.
- euske 9y agoGuess it's more or less a management problem. I think it's possible to rebrand a PhD program to be a more targeted education, not just "how to become an academic". Specifically, a doctoral program could teach people how to: 1. identify "known unknowns" and formulate the problem. 2. search and study existing literature and properly cite them. 3. cook up a clever way of evaluation and publish the results. etc, etc. Unfortunately, in most universities, these techniques are kinda sorta taught, but they're far from being systematic. And many of them don't have the body of knowledge and staffers for this kind of things, probably because they're incentivized for wrong goals (e.g. the number of papers, media recognition, etc.)
- mrdrozdov 9y agoThis article is outdated. From 2015.
- fspeech 9y agoMaybe academia shouldn't be considered a normal career. Rather it is a reward for pursuing something you are passionate about. You are willing to do it for free so anything you get is a bonus -- perhaps not literally, but that is the yard stick one should use when considering an academic career. At least that is what I am telling my older one who is applying to colleges right now.
- Chinjut 9y agoLots of people are passionate about academic research in their chosen field, and extremely talented and qualified and even PhDed, and still don't get to do it (certainly, it's difficult to get time to do things for free in a world where one needs money to live), so, I dunno…
- fspeech 9y agoThat does sound sad. It could happen when your love becomes a profession and you are pressured to do things that keep you the job rather than make you happy. This is what I warn my son about. It may be a happier outcome if one just focuses on using one's skills to make the best living and keeping one's passion a hobby instead, except one may suffer excessively from FOMO (fear of missing out). I really don't know what the answer is. Everyone has to make their own choice.
- smrtinsert 9y agoWhy are these would be professors not reading these articles? It's well known for years academia is no place to look for a great job. Find something else, I'm sorry to be harsh, but for the well educated, you should be able to find something else - especially given such early warning.
- 2_listerine_pls 9y agoThe positive side is that they can work for you in exchange for cereal and milk.
- watwut 9y agoThe interesting part is that this coexists with "we need many more people in science" narrative which pops up when talking about students choices ffor major. Nope, we don't nee more people aiming for science, we ain't got jobs for them.
- Gatsky 9y agoThe real problem is the inverse. We have too many people ready to contribute new knowledge.... and we think this is a bad thing? Because, all diseases are cured, the jails are empty and we aren't actively destroying the planet? I think this is actually how we want the future to be (we would prefer more bankers and real estate agents?). The real problem is nobody has worked out a humane way to fund it.
- puranjay 9y agoWhile I appreciate the sentiment, making a living is a real concern.
- amelius 9y agoFrom the increasing number of PhDs, can't we state that the PhD is the new MSc? Shouldn't we define a new level?
- steve_gh 9y agoI work in engineering consultancy. Some of our best consultants come from non-engineering backgrounds. Two in particular - one is an architect by training, the other an ancient historian, with a background in reconstructing ancient power hierarchies from the inscriptions on funeral carvings. In my field, the transferable skills from academic research are far more important than the domain knowledge.
- 201709User 9y agoDo they get their hands dirty?
- mercurialshark 9y agoA classic tale, where the product is valuable, yet the demand is scarce. A system where there are few alternative avenues for those who place second or third. It's disheartening to say the least. People look at Blade Runner 2049 and think dystopianism, yet here we are, a system over-saturated, yet, inexorably undernourished.
- mhandley 9y agoI'm a CS professor, so take everything I say as biased or whatever. We all know and expect that most PhD students will not end up in academia. The best PhD students often aren't those who want to be academics, but ones who are just insanely curious. There aren't many times in life when you can work on something that just interests you in great depth and (hopefully) push forward what we collectively know. A PhD allows that. If you're doing it just for the qualification, you won't get nearly as much out of it, and may not finish at all. So, what should you get out of a PhD? If the advisor does it right, the PhD student should learn what it is to do high quality scientific research. That is, ask a question, figure out a series of experiments that might allow that question to be answered, evaluate the data, and come up with conclusions supported by evidence. It turns out this is insanely hard to teach, and I've never seen a new PhD student, no matter what their background, who can do this at the start. No undergraduate or MSc programme manages to teach this, though some students seem naturally somewhat better at it than others. We try only to admit those. With a new PhD student, many of the ideas, most of the suggestions for experiments to run, and much of the interpretation of the results will usually come from the advisor. As a PhD progresses, the student should be gaining experience in what it takes to frame a good experiment that might actually answer the question you want to answer. And they should be gaining experience on how to interpret results and what you can conclude from them. During this phase, much of my role is staring at graphs the student has produced, and asking "why does it do that?". An experienced student would already have an answer, a semi-experienced student will have noticed the anomaly, but not know how to figure out the cause, and an inexperience student will not have noticed anything is strange. By the end of the PhD, a great student will be ahead of me in suggesting the experiments to run, and will have already run them before they come to see me. Only about 10% of PhD students reach this point. In the end, people over-rate what the topic of a PhD is in the educational process. What most people get from a PhD is an apprenticeship in scientific method. Those are transferable skills, and the reason PhDs have endured as a qualification is we really don't know any other way to teach them. Of course, no-one actually teaches professors to teach PhD students - we learned it by osmosis too - so the quality of professors in teaching these skills is pretty varied.
- dekhn 9y agoI worked with a japanese postdoc who, when he finished up, said he was returning to Japan. I asked him if he was going to get a job as a professor and he said "no, I have to wait for my current advisor to die before I can be a professor". I used to think that was just Japan, but then I tried to become a professor (during the post-NIH-training exponential burst of the early 2000s) and found that it's basically the same in the US now.