29 ms·
Uber London loses licence to operate
- superpope99 9y agoSo, what does this actually mean? Will Uber not be able to operate in London, or will it just not be sanctioned by TFL?
- k-mcgrady 9y agoSupposedly they can't operate legally after 30th Sept unless some temporary transitional agreement is put in place.
- disordiary 9y agoThat often doesn't stop them though.
- alexfoo 9y agoIf they don't appeal their license expires on 30th September. "The Private Hire Vehicles (London) Act 1998 includes provision to appeal a licensing decision within 21 days of it being communicated to the applicant. Uber London Limited can continue to operate until any appeal processes have been exhausted." So they will leave it to late September to launch an appeal, and whilst the appeal process is ongoing they can continue to operate. How long they can push it after the 30th September isn't known as I've no idea what the TfL appeal process involves. Alongside the reasons in the link (crime reporting, medical certificates, DBS checks, greyball) it's probably also got something to do with the huge increase in license fee: https://www.standard.co.uk/news/transport/uber-licensing-costs-in-london-to-rise-from-3000-to-3m-in-next-five-years-a3637866.html https://www.standard.co.uk/news/transport/uber-licensing-cos...
- k-mcgrady 9y agoI don't understand why Uber can't get their shit together. In the US they have competition from Lyft and I can almost understand why they have to push the boundaries. In London they have very little competition and therefore don't need to engage is controversial business practices. Personally I don't see what my alternative will be if their service ceases, they have that little competition. Although I am kind of annoyed at the decision it's understandable. I hope with Kalanick out Uber will quickly become a better corporate citizen and get this license renewed. NB: I'm aware of black cabs, Hailo, etc. but none of these are as convenient or cost effective as Uber. I can see the night tube getting a lot more use but I know quite a few people who don't like to take it after having more than a few drinks for safety reasons.
- bencollier49 9y agoWhat's Lyft like here in London? I just downloaded it, much use?
- k-mcgrady 9y agoAFAIK it isn't available in London.[1] [1] https://www.lyft.com/cities https://www.lyft.com/cities
- dabeeeenster 9y agoIt's not available in the UK at all.
- chairmanwow 9y agoLyft is US only
- gtsteve 9y agoThere's MyTaxi, Gett and Addison Lee has an app. I used to use Hailo before it became MyTaxi. It's certainly not as cost-effective but what I did like were the flat-rate rides you could get. They weren't black cabs, but more like Uber Luxes or Uber Execs and probably 20% cheaper than black cabs. With Uber gone, I'm sure the market would provide something else.
- dogma1138 9y agoAnd Kabbee which just unifies all car hires. In London Uber was the cheapest for short drives < 15-20 min for pretty much everything beyond that the reverse bid system or Kabbee provided cheaper fares.
- gtsteve 9y agoThanks, I hadn't heard of that firm. Looks like I might be needing it.
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Viper007Bond 9y agoSome existing discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15310631 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15310631
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dipthegeezer 9y agoUber will appeal no doubt and probably promise to sort out their problems, say they are reforming etc.. and then get the license back
- pavlakoos 9y agoI cannot understand why you need a license to ride other people from A to B...
- aw4y 9y agofor the same reason you need a license to drive: regulations.
- pavlakoos 9y agoBut there is a license for that: a driving license. And the one which is given allows to drive a car with passengers inside. It should be enough...
- k-mcgrady 9y agoThere's a difference between driving another person from A to B and charging that person. As a comparison you can invite a friend to your house and cook for them. If you start charging people for that there will be food safety regulations etc. you need to comply with.
- pavlakoos 9y agoSo perhaps adding the insurance for Uber drivers would solve the issue? I really don't see other reason. Except for the governments fighting with concepts which disrupt current, inconvenient and outdated state of things.
- anilgulecha 9y agoFull details: https://twitter.com/BBCBreaking/status/911175207871762432 https://twitter.com/BBCBreaking/status/911175207871762432 Criteria failed on: 1) Criminal reporting 2) Medical certificates 3) something about DBS checks 4) Use of Greyball to identify and block regulators. Edit: Updated to new tweet.. they deleted the original
- kawsper 9y agoThat gives a 404.
- treerock 9y agoThanks for that. It's pretty bad that the BBC posts more information in a tweet than they do on their new article.
- Angostura 9y agoI imagine the proper news story will be updated with the hour.
- andygates 9y agoHmm, does that mean they used Greyball in London, or just the known sleazy uses? British regulators, just like CARB, have famously little sense of humour for stuff like that.
- Haydos585x2 9y agoBig news. I'm sure there's a few parties working to make this happen and Uber sure doesn't help themselves with the way they act. I suspect there'll be enough community backlash along with very good lawyers working to get this fixed very quickly. I suppose if it doesn't get solved it could be the first of a series of moves that take out Uber. I bet there's a lot of cities looking at this. Personally, I really don't want to have to use my local taxis and love the alternative whether it's called Uber or not.
- Angostura 9y ago> to get this fixed very quickly Uber could fix this quickly by amending some of it's businesses processes that effect safety.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sambe 9y agoWhen I have reported black cab drivers misleading passengers, lying about pricing and regulations or bus drivers driving dangerously and being rude to everyone, TfL are totally uninterested. They give the impression that they know the scams operate and don't care. It's an interesting comparison with my Uber experience, which has been almost flawless and issues are usually fixed by Uber themselves promptly.
- iamben 9y agoLast time my (getting rather elderly) mother came to London I told her and her husband to get an Uber as it was easier than them standing in the rain trying to hail a cab. They flatly refused. They'd been told by a black cab driver the night before there was a 'strong possibility' they would get raped or robbed by 'foreign' drivers.
- Nursie 9y agoWhy not suggest one of London's myriad of other options, which don't have so much in the way of unethical baggage?
- raverbashing 9y agoThe tube is fine for the most part but it can be a drag going from the eastern parts of London to LHR directly (or to Paddington or Victoria)
- dx034 9y agoAddison Lee is a good alternative. Drivers tend to be a bit more professional, prices are not that much higher and cars are generally nice.
- crtasm 9y agoTheir previously voiced views on cyclists should be taken into account though. http://road.cc/content/news/56999-addison-lee-chairman-airs-his-opinion-london-cyclist-deaths http://road.cc/content/news/56999-addison-lee-chairman-airs-... The Keen Group have always been reliable for us (but could hold similar views for all I know)
- xedarius 9y agoIs this the first domino? Will France (and other European countries) then turn around and say, ah oui we too don't think Uber is fit to operate. Uber is pretty crappy in London, I had one the other night and the guy wasn't even the guy who's picture was on the app (yes the driver did not match the registered uber driver). This is before we even get onto the fact that he didn't know where he was going.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoUber is already 100% banned in Denmark, for refusing to adhere to hire car regulations.
- w4tson 9y agoThis happens all the time in black cabs. My wife and I rely on uber all the time. It feels right for a city like London. This is a step backwards in my opinion I’d like to add that most black cab drivers make out like their card machine doesn’t work. It’s a total cash scam to avoid VAT. I’ve had a black cab deny picking me up before because I didn’t want taking very far (I had a twisted ankle and just wanted to shorten my walk home)
- Nursie 9y agoIf the meter is on, it's reported and recorded income, is it not?
- denzil_correa 9y agoIs the meter connected to a server? If not, i don’t see how that would even count as accounted income.
- Nursie 9y agoIt doesn't need to be connected to a server if the meter is periodically attached to a computer that downloads the data. That said I have no idea if that's something they do. I am now going to try to find out. --edit-- it's not easy to find data on this. So far I have found out that most taxi meters have to be taken in to an office or depot to get the fare-structures updated...
- iam-TJ 9y agoThis is after the original (5 year) renewal in May 2017 was not granted and they only got a 4-month extension which expires Sept 30th. So Uber have been on-notice since May that they need to comply with the regulator's requirements for an operators license and haven't done so.
- matthewrudy 9y agoThis is an important piece of information missing from the article. Namely this is not out of the blue.
- matthewrudy 9y agoGuardian article from may 2017. Uber's London licence renewed for only four months https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/may/26/ubers-london-licence-renewed-for-only-four-months https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/may/26/ubers-lon...
- iand 9y agoIt's in the article.
- matthewrudy 9y agoI think they updated it a lot after my comment. Apologies that it's no longer correct.
- rdl 9y agoUber is worse than random minicab businesses in London? This seems like a real stretch.
- kuschku 9y agoRandom minicab businesses do not use Uber’s Greyball to avoid regulatory inspections.
- Nursie 9y agoIf they can't or won't reform then excellent, let's be rid of them. I don't want to give any business to a company that are seeking to become a worldwide cab monopoly, and squirrel away any profits to the US. We have a perfectly healthy cab ecosystem in my city, app-driven and with fare competition and city regulation. Which I suppose is why Uber, though present, hasn't really taken off here. That said, talk of profits may be a little early and AFAICT they're losing money by the fistful. Which kinda says that they're engaging in some dodgy market distortion to me...
- dandare 9y agoHowever, the article would greatly benefit from more factual information. What "threat to Londoners' safety and security"? Be specific please.
- Nursie 9y agoThis does appear just to be a summary article and a bit more background would be good. A click on the subject tag gives me some recent political criticism from the Chairman of the All Party Parliamentary Group on taxis (who knew such a thing existed?) - "It stands accused by the police of failing to properly handle serious allegations of rape and sexual assault of passengers. It had to be dragged through the courts to recognise its responsibility to provide even the most basic rights and protections to Uber drivers. Its business model is based on saturating London's taxi and private hire market to drive its competition off the road."
- mino 9y ago> What "threat to Londoners' safety and security"? https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/vv598m/uber-drivers-are-at-the-center-of-another-rape-allegation-storm https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/vv598m/uber-drivers-a...
- onion2k 9y agoFailure to report serious crimes and allowing the driver to continue driving for Uber: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/aug/13/uber-failing-to-report-sex-attacks-by-drivers-says-met-police https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/aug/13/uber-fail... http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/uber-drivers-accused-of-32-rapes-and-sex-attacks-on-london-passengers-a7037926.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/uber-drivers-accused-of... Failure to properly check medical certifications: https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/1897962/investigation-reveals-dodgy-gps-getting-cash-to-help-minicab-and-uber-drivers-fake-medical-test-over-fitness-to-drive/ https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/1897962/investigation-reveals-... Failure to follow up DBS (criminal records) checks (can't find an article about that one). Use of Greyball to dodge regulators checking on the service: https://www.ft.com/content/2ab3c0e8-0076-11e7-96f8-3700c5664d30 https://www.ft.com/content/2ab3c0e8-0076-11e7-96f8-3700c5664... (not specific to London but they're being sued all over the place for it) TfL's statement about the ban - https://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/media/press-releases/2017/september/licensing-decision-on-uber-london-limited?intcmp=50167 https://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/media/press-releases/2017/septem...
- 2T1Qka0rEiPr 9y agoThinking it through - Uber (indirectly) leads to 40,000 drivers being employed (if I read correctly). I suspect this is just TfL flexing their muscles and Uber will use these 21 days to find a compromise...
- TomK32 9y agoI think they are self-employed, and not employed by Uber.
- emodendroket 9y agoWell, it depends on which way is more convenient for whatever they want to argue at any given moment.
- bencollier49 9y agoI think that is the situation that Uber would prefer, but sadly (for them) not: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/oct/28/uber-uk-tribunal-self-employed-status https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/oct/28/uber-uk-t...
- nosho 9y agohttps://www.judiciary.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/aslam-and-farrar-v-uber-reasons-20161028.pdf https://www.judiciary.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/asla... Court rules drivers are employees, Uber's appeal starts next week.
- 2T1Qka0rEiPr 9y agoThat's why I said indirectly. There are other platforms, sure - but I'm not sure there's any with less friction / the size of network to accommodate
- jowsie 9y agoConsidering they've been on notice for the last 4 months and are yet to find a compromise, I wouldn't hold your breath.
- cm2187 9y ago
- alva 9y ago40,000 jobs.. No coincidence this comes a day before Labour Party conference.
- oneeyedpigeon 9y ago40,000 drivers. "40,000 jobs" is a misleading figure when those jobs can vary enormously in terms of hours worked.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jjp 9y agoThe TFL press release summarises the points on why the licence is not being renewed - https://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/media/press-releases/2017/september/licensing-decision-on-uber-london-limited https://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/media/press-releases/2017/septem... TfL considers that Uber's approach and conduct demonstrate a lack of corporate responsibility in relation to a number of issues which have potential public safety and security implications. These include: Its approach to reporting serious criminal offences. Its approach to how medical certificates are obtained. Its approach to how Enhanced Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) checks are obtained. Its approach to explaining the use of Greyball in London - software that could be used to block regulatory bodies from gaining full access to the app and prevent officials from undertaking regulatory or law enforcement duties.
- dx034 9y agoI'm quite certain that the last one is the important point. All the others can easily be fixed. But that the company had a program to avoid regulation should be enough to ban it. Unless they do a full code audit, there's no way to know if they still use these techniques.
- aidos 9y agoInterestingly they claimed that technology is to defend themselves against fraudulent activity (fake accounts, competitors, sting operations). From what I understand, it works by marking accounts as fake (using credit card lookups etc) and then showing them fake cars that never pick them up. Imagine being falsely flagged by that system and just always having a terrible time getting a cab and not knowing why!
- baby 9y agoCan you quote with ">" instead? We can't read your comment fully. EDIT: Here is the quote: > TfL considers that Uber's approach and conduct demonstrate a lack of corporate responsibility in relation to a number of issues which have potential public safety and security implications. These include: > Its approach to reporting serious criminal offences. > Its approach to how medical certificates are obtained. > Its approach to how Enhanced Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) checks are obtained. > Its approach to explaining the use of Greyball in London - software that could be used to block regulatory bodies from gaining full access to the app and prevent officials from undertaking regulatory or law enforcement duties.
- thepratt 9y agoThere is a mention of the taxi association being a major opponent. The black cabs have had numerous strikes regarding uber for their own wrong doing, it just seems like another tirade from them. There was legislation passed that required all black cabs to hold card readers, the overwhelming majority refused to allow you to use them, install them, or acknowledge the legislation ~2 years after the fact. They only have themselves to blame. At a point in the past black cabs used to be good, this is no longer true. Not having uber (or an alternative - black cabs are not) will be more a problem than most realize.
- necessity 9y agoIt's a shame for the people of London. Specially the not-so-rich-as-HN ones
- Stranger43 9y agoDid gett do to Uber in London what HailO/mytaxi did to them in Ireland? This could simply be a case of Uber not adding enough value for independent drivers who don’t need Uber’s regulatory avoidance scheme to get on the road in the first place.
- orloffm 9y agoSo, can they become a mere client for black taxis, as they are in Berlin, for example?
- tim333 9y agoIt probably wouldn't work well. There's already a well established one - Hailo. Cabbies would probably use that rather than Uber who they don't like much. Edit- now it's become mytaxi app.
- jnsaff2 9y agoHere's a little perspective from another company trying to bring Uberesque services to London. Not trying to defend Uber but the motives of british establishment might be a bit more selfish then they want you to know. https://blog.taxify.eu/2017/09/bringing-fairer-ride-hailing-to-london/ https://blog.taxify.eu/2017/09/bringing-fairer-ride-hailing-...
- UK-AL 9y agoBlack cab drivers are very active, and quite violent lobbyists towards tfl. I have literally seen black cab drivers spit at uber drivers.
- tim333 9y agoAs one of the 3,500,000 users I hope they sort it out. I've not heard any demands from us fellow Uber users to have the service banned for our own protection. The assaults and muggings which happen are usually because someones walking sometime's because they can't afford a cab.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoI think you'll find sexual assault happens because an assailant sexually assaults someone, not because someone can't afford a black cab. Do you really consider it acceptable for Uber not to do legally required background checks (DBD, health)?
- tim333 9y agoI think Uber should do background checks. I think the chances of sexual assault are considerably higher walking down the street than getting a cab/Uber the same distance.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoI'm not so sure, we'd need to look at statistics for that. Regardless background checks should be done; just like cleaning checks in commercial kitchens, you may be more likely to get sick from home cooking, that seems largely irrelevant. Another analogue: Most child sexual abuse is by family members, I don't see that as a reason not to do background checks on care workers.
- Angostura 9y agoThis would be an interesting tine for Lyft to launch in London if it can meet the regulatory requirements
- beegeezuz 9y agoI signed the petition too.
- bentossell 9y agoLaunched this off the back of this news: http://uberdrivers.london/ http://uberdrivers.london/ - crowdsourced thoughts from Uber drivers and users in London
- eadz 9y agoWhile I don't particularly feel good about the business model and lack of employee rights etc, one thing I prefer Uber for over Black Cabs is the pollution. Many Ubers are Toyota Purises. Black cabs have 2.7L Diesel engines which contribute to London's terrible air quality. Especially as I often see black cabs without passengers driving around - not sure if the're looking for rides or not, but there is no reason for an Uber driver do be doing the same - I see them waiting with the engine off.
- PaulRobinson 9y agoPriuses can't take wheelchairs, have a wider turning circle and have other drawbacks that make them unsuitable for black cab workloads. That said, the UK is committed to eradicating all petrol and diesel cars over the next 22 years, and the black cab drivers are looking at what you're talking about: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/jul/11/black-cab-turns-green-new-electric-london-taxi-levc-tx https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/jul/11/black-cab-t...
- gsnedders 9y agoYes, from 1 Jan 2018 all new registered taxis are required to be all-electric or petrol-electric hybrids. There's going to be a £5k grant for taxis over 10 years old (note there is a maximum age of 15 years that has long been in force), which will hopefully push the oldest third of taxis to get replaced more quickly than normally.
- PaulRobinson 9y agoLondoner here. The license is not being renewed not because TfL isn't interested in innovation (they actively encourage it), not to retain power for the black cab drivers, and not because London isn't interested in companies like Uber operating here. It's because of the rapes. The Metropolitan Police (the part of the UK police force that polices London), has objected to their license. In 2015 alone, they had to deal with 32 cases of Uber drivers raping or sexually assaulting lone female passengers. In the entire history of the hackney carriage (black cab) license - going back to 1662 - I know of only one case of a driver having been prosecuted for rape, about 5 years ago. Uber is not reporting crimes, not co-operating with the police when they are reported, is not doing suitable background checks on criminality or medical suitability for being a private hire driver on its "workforce", and there is suspicion that they are both price gouging and specifically trying to go around the private hire regulations they claim to support. Also from the TfL statement: > The Private Hire Vehicles (London) Act 1998 includes provision to appeal a licensing decision within 21 days of it being communicated to the applicant. Uber London Limited can continue to operate until any appeal processes have been exhausted. That means they're not shutting up shop soon, they can appeal in the next 8 days, then continue to operate until the appeals process is over. That means if they start dealing with driver checks, crime reports and regulations properly within the time frame of the appeals process (which can be years), they'll be allowed to continue to operate. As a Londoner, I'm OK with that. If they aren't interested in conducting criminal record checks, medical checks, making sure my gf is safe when travelling alone, etc. I don't want them in my city. If the regulators bring about these changes, they are doing their job and I'm happy for them to scare the holy fuck out of Uber and their management team in the process to make that happen. In the meantime, other operators have upped their game a lot in recent years whilst Uber has been operating. Addison Lee (one of the larger private hire firms) has an app almost as good as Uber's, with fixed cost pricing. We will not miss Uber if they go, they are going to need to show that they are worthy of being a part of the diverse and amazing London community if they wish to remain.
- Nursie 9y agoAbsolutely! If they can reform, great. If not, well they've certainly forced the hands of other operators to modernise and offer a better service, but that's no excuse for the rest. (ex Londoner who still visits once in a while...)
- bogomipz 9y agoDoes anyone know how much time is left for them to operate in London on the current license then?
- chillydawg 9y ago30th Sep
- beedogs 9y agoCan they get rid of those dreadful oBikes next?
- dagaci 9y agoRegardless of the merits of losing the London licence - which will almost certainly be temporary. I hope there will be some other group to take advantage and bring competition. London Black cabs complain too much... about _everything_ .. yet I have not heard about them modernising.
- dx034 9y agoIf they just lose it for a week this could be fatal. I can imagine most drivers will now start signing up for competitors. As soon as the license is gone, people will switch to a competitor. If they offer similar service and price, there's no reason to come back to Uber. The only way then is to start giving away free rides again.
- osrec 9y agoUber as a company is immoral from time to time, however their service is great, and I'd be sad to see it go from London. TfL operates one of the most expensive public transport systems in the world, and is happy to license black cab drivers (who in my experience, can be rude and are an absolute rip off a lot of the time). Not only that, black cab drivers in my area regularly drive through zebra crossings while people are on them, but I am yet to see an Uber driver do this (I'm sure they do as well, but black cabs drive around London with a sense of arrogance and entitlement that I find most irritating).
- dx034 9y agoDid you try Taxify? Started in London recently, could imagine many drivers will sign up there now. Haven't tried it yet (didn't take an uber over the past weeks) but their offering appears very similar.
- jnsaff2 9y agoThey've been shut down as well: https://blog.taxify.eu/2017/09/bringing-fairer-ride-hailing-to-london/ https://blog.taxify.eu/2017/09/bringing-fairer-ride-hailing-...
- stupidcar 9y agoUber isn't going away in London. Never mind the passengers, consider how many thousands of (mostly Labour-voting) people drive for Uber as a job. They might not love their employer, but that doesn't mean they'll be happy become unemployed en-masse. This is a political tactic to try to force Uber into improving its safety and regulatory practices. Whether it works will depend on whether Uber or City Hall blinks first.
- osrec 9y agoI hope you're right. I genuinely believe if Uber was to go away from London, it would be a step backwards. They are the modern taxi, and I would bet they are more fuel and time efficient than black cabs driving round London in the hope of someone flagging them down.
- letsmakeit 9y agoHello again hacker news socialists.
- dx034 9y agoNot a lawyer but I find it interesting that they say to "immediately challenge" the decision. Since they can operate in the meantime, shouldn't they file it on the 21st day? They can already announce to appeal but challenging it now could just shorten their life span?
- velox_io 9y agoThe same week I read about the Gett-Blackcab bus partnership (woohoo one route, that will make a difference..). £20 for a hour's drive in a Mercedes E class (with a driver) is hurting the protection racket? Other news, the government is offering huge subsidies/ grants for conglomerates working on driverless cars and lorries. Btw: I trust a computer more than most London drivers.
- overcast 9y agoUber needs to license their software to existing companies. Stop trying to push cab companies out of business, and start trying to be cabOS. The user experience is why we use the thing, I don't give a rats ass who is picking me up, as long as they are safe and courteous. And they come pick me up with a few taps of a phone app.
- cityzen 9y agoI've been thinking about this as well and not only for Uber. Airbnb and other similar companies could create platforms to allow people to do this on their own. The sad reality, though, is you don't make billions by enabling people, you make billions by controlling people.
- beager 9y agoYup, cabOS is a niche, even FOSS-with-SaaS company. Not a $60bb company.
- overcast 9y agoYou mean like Oracle, and Microsoft? Taking a small % of every cab transaction, sounds like a billion dollar business to me. Right now the only thing Uber is doing is spending more money than it makes.
- brentm 9y agoThey won't license their software any time soon. They decided against it in the earliest days and it really wouldn't fit with the Uber brand today. Maybe once they are a public, growth from new markets has slowed and they are chasing profits they sign license deals to open up otherwise closed off markets. I am skeptical that many taxi commissions in major cities would line up to license though. As of now the current system obviously works well enough for them (and that's to say nothing about the little those orgs likely trust Uber). If they have successfully banished Uber (etc) to the point where Uber wants to license software just to join the market I'd expect revenue split terms would be so unfavorable to Uber that they would not be interested.
- shamas 9y agoUber's response to the assault claims. https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/vv598m/uber-drivers-are-at-the-center-of-another-rape-allegation-storm https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/vv598m/uber-drivers-a... I suspect that this is actually behind doors shenanigans by the hands of incumbents. Uber is big... They have many more rides than anyone else (outside of Central Central London), and there doesn't appear to be any evidence that more crime proportionally is happening with them than any other company.
- Tycho 9y agoIs there clear evidence that Uber is less safe for drivers and passengers than competing services? They've been operating for a while with millions of users, so I expect any shortcomings would be evident in the statistics by now.
- tomblomfield 9y agoI don't think the Mayor of London or TfL really expect to shut down Uber. It would be a deeply unpopular move. There's an acceptance that Uber has improved things for riders, albeit at the expense of the Black Cab industry, and London wants to welcome innovative technology firms. However, I also suspect that Uber hasn't been as co-operative as TfL would like on several issues mentioned, and so this feels like a warning shot to get them to be better corporate citizen. Quote from an MP; "No company, however big and powerful, will be allowed to flout our laws and regulations." Uber could have reacted by saying "we acknowledge our shortfallings, and we'll work closely with TfL and the Mayor of London to ensure we put passenger safety first. We hope to avoid any interruption in service and continue to play a valuable part in London's diverse and effective public transportation system." Instead, they took a typically Travis-ish stance and said "Screw you, people love us because we're cheaper, we'll fight this and we'll win," without any acknowledgment of their failings. Perhaps new leadership can change this approach.
- vertex-four 9y agoThey already had a warning shot four months ago, when their license renewal was denied in favour of a temporary renewal for four months. This one is the next step in the process. Uber isn't magic - if there's pent-up demand for a company that fills Uber's boots, one will pop up. The issues TfL have with Uber aren't to do with the service they provide, it's failing to comply with TfL's administrative requirements. You could easily build a company that does what Uber does in London without the hate for local Government that is ingrained into Uber's culture - and there already are a number of minicab companies that do what Uber does, just minus quite as fancy an app.
- UK-AL 9y agoThere have been few companies that have tried. Some mentioned in thread. They all had trouble working with tfl. One company licenced their software with an existing cab company in order to work with them. TFL started an investigation and unlicensed the previously legally licenced private taxi company for no stated reason. Make no mistake they are activity hostile against innovation that could make taxi travel cheaper and faster. https://blog.taxify.eu/2017/09/bringing-fairer-ride-hailing-to-london/ https://blog.taxify.eu/2017/09/bringing-fairer-ride-hailing-... I suspect anyone who looks like they could be the next uber would simply be shutdown.
- dalbasal 9y agoUber is such a contentious topic that a decision like this is ipso facto political. There are [1] competitors (especially black cabs)that have a very strong interest to lobby against uber. [2] There are pro labour politicans that see Uber as workaround for labour laws, and the vanguard of a wider threat to labour norms. [3] Now, there are feminists and work culture interested people reacting to all the accusations about Uber's internal cultural issues. Those aren't the quoted resons for the decisions, but they are a relevant political context. The cabs were the first (and obviously self interested) objectors and Uber got used to fighting them and their politcal influence. This seems to have lead them down a cultural path. An agressive, ask-forgiveness-not-permission culture. A embattled rightous self image. "All the accusations against us are self serving incumbent bullshit!" "Transport for London and the mayor have caved in to a small number of people who want to restrict consumer choice." Disprupting taxis is/was the goal, so that antagonism was inevitable. On-demand labour is the method. Without that, they couldn't have grown like they did. The stuff they lost their liscence over,... that was an unforced error. "reporting serious criminal offences, obtaining medical certificates and driver background checks." - also greyball There's no good reason for Uber to lose a big market over that. Complying would not have disrupted their operations one bit.
- KaiserPro 9y ago> There's no good reason for Uber to lose a big market over that. Complying would not have disrupted their operations one bit. This is the thing, Uber assumes that london is just like NYC, where its a highly regulated market with a massive barrier to entry. Its simply not the case. A minicam license to operate costs ~£500 (https://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/taxis-and-private-hire/licensing/private-hire-driver-licence https://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/taxis-and-private-hire/licensing...) There is a rich and thriving minicab market. Uber are really quite late to the party, Addison Lee having an internet based hailing serivce in 2007, and an app since at least 2010. The only thing new they bring is "cachet"
- unityByFreedom 9y ago> Complying would not have disrupted their operations one bit They're required to do fingerprint checks in NYC and seem to do alright there. Uber drivers are taxi drivers and should follow the same rules. It's very straightforward.
- randomsearch 9y agoAnecdotal evidence, but I can confirm black cabs are pretty rubbish and extremely expensive in London. Broken card machines ("broken"?) are a thing. Friends complain similarly. Uber experiences all good so far. Not an Uber lover here, just astounded by people reporting that black cabs offer a decent service. I really like the design of black cabs, but since those bad experiences I have avoided them completely.
- irpapakons 9y agoI have switched to using black cabs with Gett, I find it a much better experience. I like knowing what to expect, lots of space, the drivers are professionals and there's no pressure to chat. For me that's a good thing, I prefer to have a bit of free time instead of a social interaction with a stranger.
- joering2 9y agoWait I thought they already operated above the law and didnt care about any licensing stuff. Thats how they were able to offer low fees. What changed here? Why would they care about some licensing all of sudden??
- vvvv 9y agoSo, what are the best alternatives to Uber in London right now?
- retube 9y agoThere are loads of alternative private minicab firms in London. Addison Lee has excellent mobile site. No need to sign up or install an app. And in my experience has always been excellent service and keenly priced.
- billphipps 9y agow.t.f.? does this mean no more uber in London?
- billphipps 9y agoBlack taxis in London are a 150+ year old institution also. As a Londoner I found it sad seeing the drivers looking unhappy waiting for passengers at Paddington....not getting so many. Black taxis just seem to me to be as much of a part of London as Big Ben, Red Telephone Boxes and Red Double Decker busses.