26 ms·
China Bans Bitcoin Executives from Leaving Country, Miners “Preparing for Worst”
- adamnemecek 9y agoIs it just me or has China been doing some crazy regulatory stuff recently. Idk if there's an overall mosaic I'm missing or if these are unrelated.
- mincon4747 9y agoChina's economy is crashing, and Chinese government is panicking.
- codefined 9y agoCan you give any more details on "China's economy is crashing"? I must admit I haven't heard anything negative about their economy, thought it was on the up and up.
- adamnemecek 9y agoExactly it can't keep going up and up. https://www.google.com/amp/www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2017/08/15/chinas-debt-boom-could-lead-financial-crisis-imf-warns/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2017...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fwdslash 9y agoTrue but it hasn't crashed yet.
- inferiorhuman 9y agoAMP links? Really? Here's the non crapified link: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2017/08/15/chinas-debt-boom-could-lead-financial-crisis-imf-warns/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2017/08/15/chinas-debt-b...
- voidz 9y agoThanks. People sharing amp links... it was only a matter of time, and really, really sucks.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoThey have a lot of debt building up as well as a huge real estate bubble that makes SF look tame. However, it hasn't crashed yet.
- AlexCoventry 9y agoIt's all sovereign debt, denominated in a token they can create at will. It's not like a household with an out of control credit card habit.
- westiseast 9y agoThat means they can't go bankrupt; it doesn't mean the debt isn't a problem.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoSure. But it still can't grow forever without dragging down the real economy, at some point soon growth has to stop, and then what?
- AlexCoventry 9y agoFrom the PRC's perspective, the yuan is a just a tool to stimulate productive activity in their population towards the goals expressed in state budgets. If they can muster the political will, they can simply levy highly progressive taxes to reduce inflation and keep on spending. There is nothing stopping them, ideologically.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoIf growth is mostly currently debt fueled, that growth can easily stop and reverse when the debt is pulled back. Recession at best, depression at worst, definitely there will be a few crashes along the way. Do you think real estate can really be sustained at it's current levels? Much of it has been bought as a speculative asset (no property taxes makes that easy) with the idea that it can only keep going up because of urbanization. However, farmers are generally poor not rich, it is not clear where the "bigger idiots" are going to come from. China's tax burden is already high for those that pay them. Going after those that don't at the high end is difficult because they tend to be officials or highly connected to officials in the first place.
- almost_usual 9y agoHave any sources to back this up?
- bjshepard 9y agoIf you understand the population distribution in the PRC, have spent time in a Tier 2 or Tier 3 city, and think deeply about economic growth, the idea that the Chinese economy could "crash" is laughable: there is a vast pool of emerging customers that will continue to fuel growth over the foreseeable future. The question is whether global trends, especially related to climate change driven instability, will interfere in the emergence of the socialist/communist market economy. If you find a contradiction in the conception of a socialist/communist market economy, check Dominic Losurdo's "Has China Turned to Capitalism?—Reflections on the Transition from Capitalism to Socialism" published in the March 2017 issue of International Critical Thought.
- ue_ 9y agoAlthough a Socialist (using this in the sense of lower-stage Communist, rather than as Marx used it as synonymous with Communism) market economy can be practicable, China does not have it - most notably because there is wage labour and private property is protected by the State. The State is also not in democratic control of the workers. These rule out China from being either a Socialist country or having a Socialist (market or not) economy.
- EZ-E 9y agoYes there has recently been : - promise to block all VPN services from accessing blocked website - law to hold chat group owners responsible to what the members say (controverse political talk or gambling for example can lead to arrests) - most of casual barbecue that were held in the streets last summer have been forced to close this year in my area - tightening and more scrutinity on visa applications for foreigners (there has been some abuse so this is legitimate) - more random drug tests and work visa checks on foreigners (again there are many illegal teachers so can't blame them) - ban of many cheeses (like blue cheese) - ban of Winnie the pooh from social media following a picture mocking Xi as looking like Winnie China is getting more and more authoritarian and strict. Some of these moves are because of the big party congress in one month where Xi is excepted to renew his term
- samstave 9y agoWhy would they ban blue cheese? Is drug use high among foreigners or is that just a harrassement control to keep them in mental check, so they fear the unpredictability of the government and the power they hold over individual fate?
- adrianratnapala 9y agoMy guess is food safety. Not quite real food safety, but also not made up. Some European cheeses are not available in here Australia because of regulations about how dairy products have to be processed (Pasteurisation I guess). Not only might that logic work in China too, but the culture is less tolerant of a food-stuff what is after all curdled milk with a fungal infection. (And we in the west get grossed out by chicken feet!).
- pertymcpert 9y agoWait til you hear how bread is made!
- warcher 9y agoFood safety is a great way to backdoor agricultural import restrictions. Europe has been doing it for decades on GMO's.
- nrp 9y agoI'm by no means an expert on this, but the timing for several of these likely relates to the once every 5 years National Congress of the Communist Party of China occurring next month. There are competing factions, and it's probable that some of these decisions benefit one over another.
- dogruck 9y agoWhy is it "crazy"? They are a sovereign nation.
- pertymcpert 9y agoSo any action by a sovereign nation can always be described as "sane" or "reasonable"?
- dogruck 9y agoTo me, calling them "crazy" is insulting to their culture and people. For the label to be justified, you'd have to argue the action contributes to ruin. For example, I think the Venezuelan leadership has made crazy decisions that are being borne out now. But, I would not put a ban on BBQ in that same category.
- pertymcpert 9y agoNo you don't have to argue that, what on earth are you talking about? Good god... Look at the way the word is used in this context. "Crazy regulatory..." That doesn't insult the culture or people, that's specifically talking about regulations. It's widely accepted that laws can be "crazy", i.e. silly, stupid, unreasonable, in every country. It's not a personal attack on the people. Contributed to ruin...wow
- kobeya 9y agoThat gives them the right to do crazy things. That doesn’t stop it from being crazy.
- mincon4747 9y agoChina's fast descent into totalitarianism is fascinating and scary. One can easily replace 'bitcoin executives' with 'foreign executives' or 'foreign assets' and see where this is going. I wonder if those companies that choose to outsource all the jobs in their country to China realized what they've done.
- dilap 9y agohonest question, hasn't it been totalitarian for like the past 70 years?
- synicalx 9y agoYes, yes it has. I'll never understand why people are perpetually surprised when China bans X, or rounds up people for doing Y.
- est 9y agoMore like 2000 years of totalitarian.
- B1FF_PSUVM 9y agoIf you mix up monarchy, empire, dictatorship, etc. all in the same bucket and call everything 'totalitarian', our ability to think about politics gets rather reduced. It's even anachronistic, the concept itself is recent: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Totalitarianism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Totalitarianism
- acjohnson55 9y agoHas China ever not been a totalitarian state?
- mirimir 9y agoThere was some democracy in the late 1800s to early 1900s. But it didn't gel with the Confucian ethos. Stephenson's Diamond Age is actually pretty informative.
- gggdvnkhmbgjvbn 9y agoAll comments so far have been pro-bitcoin... does nobody think this could actually be a sensible decision?
- adamnemecek 9y agoWhy would it? The govt let's you go to casino, I should be allowed to do what I want with my money. Totalitarian and Aldo totalitarian govts are scared of bitcoin.
- tanilama 9y agoHN like Bitcoin because it is cool. HN hates government intervention in general. The outcome is pretty predictable.
- CamelCaseName 9y agoHN has a fair amount of "Bitcoin is overvalued" people as well. Note that the type of thread to reach the top of HN tends to be something groundbreaking, which will skew the discussion to the extremes. Also, the comment you are responding to complained about all of three pro-bitcoin comments (Two top level) that were all posted less than 3 minutes before his. This seems a little unfair to me as it's possible that this thread was likely buried (hence no replies for >1h) and just surfaced to the top of HN. I speculate there's a lot more resentment on HN towards cryptocurrencies than you might expect.
- eberkund 9y agoChina is a closed economy, it makes sense that they would put a ban on a technology which outside of speculative investment is largely used to facilitate money laundering.
- josu 9y agoMoney laundering is currently not an issue, it has more to do with capital controls.
- samstave 9y agoSerious question: how are capital controls vs money laundering different from the perspective of the one with the money?
- mkwldbttr 9y agoDepends if you obtained your funds legally or illegally? With former you are betting against Chinese economy with latter you are looking to leave less traces of activities that got you those funds.
- mirimir 9y agoThat's not such a strong distinction, I think. I mean, "legally" and "illegally" are defined by the State. And there's plenty opportunity for selective/surprise enforcement.
- tehwebguy 9y agoYeah but that's what laundering is. Making money that would be designated dirty by the state look clean. This is more of just hiding it outright, I think?
- mirimir 9y agoWell, domestic capital leaving China is largely illegal. So circumventing laws through Bitcoin is arguably money laundering. And indeed, US laws against money laundering apply regardless of the source.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- acjohnson55 9y agoWhat's interesting to me is that no amount of bad news appears to affect the price of BTC. I'm not a professional or amateur trader (I've got no position on BTC at all) but the price fluctuations really seem dominated by sentiment over any sort of fundamentals.
- rlayton2 9y agoIt does seem to have some effect. Bitcoin "crashed" last week quite a few pecentage points (see https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/bitcoin/#charts https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/bitcoin/#charts click 1M or 3M and see September 15th). Like stocks though, it is always hard to pinpoint why, because it's a market with lots of different opinions.
- samstave 9y agoWouldn't sentiment based fluctuations smooth out over the maturity of the instrument. Bitcoin is an infant compared to stocks... so volatility will be 100% based on youth/ignorance/fear of what is happening with said insturment
- qznc 9y agoBitcoin price volatility is decreasing over time: https://bitvol.info/ https://bitvol.info/
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bdcravens 9y agoIt's a 24/7 market; the price responds a lot faster than other markets. So looking at day-over-day price isn't a good gauge. Additionally, by the time a story is known at large, it's usually been known for a bit among those who follow Bitcoin, so you'll see it already priced in.
- mirimir 9y ago
- Animats 9y agoSo the PBOC is taking further steps to plug the leak. Not unexpected. China has exchange controls. Internal yuan cannot be easily converted to euros or dollars. There are limits on capital outflows. The controls are leaky; the classic leak is to send all your relatives to Hong Kong loaded up with the maximum allowed amount of yuan in cash. The current limit is about $50K/year/person. Small leaks are thus tolerated. Big leaks get plugged, eventually. Bitcoin has apparently been moved to the "big leak" category. (The US does not have exchange controls. If you want to wire transfer a million dollars from the US to Switzerland and buy a house in Geneva, the US has no objection, provided that you report it for tax purposes. Some Bitcoin enthusiasts are unclear on this. Why China has tight exchange controls is beyond the scope of this discussion.)
- deepGem 9y agoThe situation is very similar in India. You can't just convert INR to USD freely. There's a limit of $250,000 per person per year. I don't know if anyone mines bitcoins in India (because of horrendously expensive power), but if they did, they'll be subject to similar scrutiny.
- zeusk 9y agoSolar power is really cheap though, I run a smallish scale operation near my hometown and solar is abundant with rare clouds and rain.
- OscarTheGrinch 9y agoHey bitcoin miner! Power is one cost but I've always wondered about other costs at scale like hardware and labor. Devices tend to wear out after a while, bitcion mining seems quite intensive, how does this kind of issue effect your buisness / profits?
- Flammy 9y agoJust pointing it out... you don't need to mine the coins in the country to assist Indians (or anyone) in converting their currency to USD beyond the normal limits. So the price of power to mine the coins doesn't really have much to do with it.
- siculars 9y agoFirst they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win. -Mahatma Gandhi
- Cookingboy 9y agoExcept in China it goes like this: First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you are never heard from again.
- gscott 9y agoand your family goes missing too.
- westiseast 9y ago* then you appear on state TV apologising for your tax crimes 10 years ago.
- endgame 9y agoPeople always quote this for all sorts of causes, but the fact that you're at one stage doesn't mean you're going to move to the next: - First they ignore you. Nobody ever notices you. - First they ignore you, then they laugh at you. Nobody takes you seriously. - First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you. You lose. - First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win. Congratulations! Now who are you ignoring? ISTM you need to have a plan for crossing each of the three filters, rather than saying "they're fighting us, therefore we'll win". EDIT: It's even funnier if you realise that the quote is symmetric and using it as an argument also proves its opposite. Activists often sub in government/"the system" as the "they", but activists could be the "they" from the system's perspective. They start by ignoring the system, then mocking it, then fighting it, then the system wins?
- schoen 9y agoAlso Gandhi apparently didn't say this in exactly this form: https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Mahatma_Gandhi#Misattributed https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Mahatma_Gandhi#Misattributed https://quoteinvestigator.com/2017/08/13/stages/#more-16632 https://quoteinvestigator.com/2017/08/13/stages/#more-16632
- joelrunyon 9y agoCurious if this will have an impact on "liquid' domain names (3 letter .com domains). They spiked a few years back as a way to get money out of China, but slowed recently due to bitcoin being a better option. Would be interesting to see if that activity picks back up.
- wingerlang 9y agoHow does this work?
- joelrunyon 9y agoThere's a limited quantity of some types of domains (2 & 3 letter domains). They typically have a "trading floor" where they can switch hands between investors for a minimum amount - so they're referred to as "Liquid." Not always the case, and sometimes the floor drops - but it was a good market for quite a while - especially for chinese investors that wanted to diversify their holdings.
- puranjay 9y agoWhat's the going prize on 3L.com's right now? Say, a bad combination (Q, X, Y, V, etc.)? Last time I exited this market (2008), lowest tier 3L.coms were selling for $3k
- jameskegel 9y agoI have a 4 letter domain that sounds like a common word. What should I sell for?
- joelrunyon 9y agoYou're gonna have to share way more info than that...
- puranjay 9y agoemail me at my username @ growthpub dot com
- xaldir 9y agoSo... Are we going to see a surge of cheap second hand GPUs?
- 6nf 9y agoThe Chinese miners use custom ASIC hardware, no GPUs.
- jameskegel 9y agoThey mine with ASIC chips they themselves manufacture in China. If anything this hurts our ability to buy mining hardware from china, the main supplier.
- gtrubetskoy 9y agoOne would be naive to think that a government like PBOC would just let it be. But this is long-term positive news for Bitcoin. It is good that China is taking steps to regulate the cryptocurrency world (starting with an outright ban, I guess) Especially the ICO's, which are mostly scams, and even those that aren't should probably be treated as securities. Bitcoin (and other crypto-currency) exchanges also could use some regulatory oversight - if you watch the order books even on US-based ones like GDAX there's non-stop spoofing and other trading illegalities that would normally get you banned from any exchange and perhaps land you in jail in a jiffy. It will be interesting to see what happens if we lose the China hashing capacity. If that happens (and it looks like it already is), we will have slow blocks until the next difficulty adjustment. In general the more of this sort of thing happens, the better it validates the Bitcoin model. What doesn't kill it makes it stronger.
- dx034 9y agoTo be fair, in the past exchanges weren't the one advancing rules against spoofing. Only when regulators forced them to act they actually started stepping in. Exchanges have an incentive to maximise trading volume, high volatility is good for them.
- korzun 9y agoThis is good news for Bitcoin. They are holding the executives so they can apologize and issue them licenses. /s
- chatmasta 9y agoIf miners shut down, mining rate slows, supply goes down, so price should go up. Right?
- hartator 9y agoMiners are purely demand not supply. The number of new bitcoins is already set, competition is not.
- moufestaphio 9y agoNo. Bitcoin algorithm automatically adjusts every 2016 blocks, to make the average block time 10 minutes. If the number of miners drops, the algorithm will adjust the difficulty of finding a 'good' hash. Meaning as an individual miner you have a better chance of finding the correct hash, but the overall network has the same rate.
- qznc 9y agoIf all the chinese miners drop out suddenly, how long does it take to mine those 2016 blocks? More precisely, how much longer than 20160 minutes (2 weeks)? If Bitcoin transaction rate would be significantly reduced for weeks or months, would that kill it in the sense that Litecoin or Ethereum would take over?
- moufestaphio 9y agoIt should happen right away I believe. As soon as the next block after the 2016th is accepted, the difficulty updates. The transaction rate would only be affected for a max of two weeks as I understand it. As for how the 'market' would react if all Chinese miners dropped out, I have no idea :)
- pc86 9y agoBTC noob here, please forgive me. My understanding is that you can send from any wallet to any other wallet, right? So what's to stop me from having wallets on both Huobi and LakeBTC, buying a BTC on Huobi for $3524 then transferring it to my LakeBTC wallet and selling it for $4282? I understand arbitrage so I'm sure there's a step I'm missing, and I know there's often a delay between the order and fulfillment, fees etc, but a 21.5% spread between Huobi and LakeBTC seems like a lot.
- argo_ 9y agoDeposits are blocked. You can't deposit money in the exchange to start the arbitrage.
- Laforet 9y agoIt's still an option now, however it looks like they too will lose banking access in China soon. >The impact of the Chinese ruling on LakeBTC is limited. The only major change is that our services to all Chinese citizens will be suspended. LakeBTC is a legitimate business which follows applicable laws and regulations. Source: https://www.lakebtc.com/p/9352 https://www.lakebtc.com/p/9352 The type of arbitrage you described has been going on for years, especially for ETH where 20% price differential isn't uncommon at all. The difficult part, however, is getting money in and out of China without raising suspicion. By the time you have paid off all middleman the margin isn't that great anymore.
- yellowapple 9y ago"China’s decision to shut down exchanges took many by surprise" Really? It's a "communist" country. If anything, what's surprising is that it took China this long to start cracking down on Bitcoin.
- banku_brougham 9y agoI'm most interesting in how the unfolding events affect the miners. Over 50% of mining compute is happening in China, would the state step in and try to control this aspect as well? My understanding is this would give them to power to make arbitrary changes to the blockchain. As the article mentions, miners have expenses to pay which are likely funded by bitcoin conversion to local currency, if they can't operate in China (especially favorable because of inexpensive power) the controlling nodes will be moving or shifting to other mining firms.