23 ms·
Basically, unless you are writing a browser with decent marketshare, you defacto have no voice in making the standards. Basically, the only voices that matter a
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
Basically, unless you are writing a browser with decent marketshare, you defacto have no voice in making the standards. Basically, the only voices that matter are Mozilla (Firefox), Apple (Safari), Google(Chrome), and Microsoft (Edge/Explorer). Despite what any standard says, web developers are going to go by the behavior of the browsers do. The only company on the list of browser makers that really has any desire to try to exclude DRM is Mozilla, and unfortunately, if they do that, the users will switch to the browser that makes watching Netflix easiest.
- featherverse 9y agoI would suggest not underestimating Mozilla's market influence. It would be possible to create a browser that displays DRM content and ignores DRM. The only thing that content publishers could do is ban that browser. And then it would adapt to disguise itself as other browsers. DRM on the web can only happen if all of the major players (that is, browser publishers) agree to play along. I am very excited about this news, this is probably the most important news in weeks, and could impact the Internet for years to come.
- jandrese 9y agoWouldn't publishers just refuse to distribute keys to said browser?
- wyager 9y agoYou build a plugin framework that lets users pirate keys without exposing the author to excessive DMCA risk.
- jandrese 9y agoI think the author of such a plugin would be at considerable legal risk.
- QAPereo 9y agoThat sounds like a strong case for anonymous authorship.
- noir_lord 9y agoIf they where in the US.
- DCKing 9y agoLots of this stuff is so US focused. Any European nation for one will let you reverse engineer stuff you buy or download to your own heart's content in the safety of your own home. I expect many countries in the world are civilized like that.
- dannyobrien 9y agoAlmost every country, with the exception of Israel, has implemented the anti-DRM provisions of the WIPO Copyright Treaty using similar language to the United States, or worse. In the European countries, it's embodied in the European Copyright Directive: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Directive#Technological_protection_measures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Directive#Technologi... That's one of the reason why we argued so strongly that the W3C should include a covenant. Even if EFF continues to successfully obtain temporary exemptions from the DMCA in the tri-annual review, we can't do that for security researchers or lobby for similar fair use exemptions in every country.
- DCKing 9y agoYou're right. I've done some digging, and some similar language has been implemented at least in the Netherlands (for the Dutch, this is article 29a of our Auteurswet). Although it's somewhat vague, it does bum me out. It seems the Dutch implementation has not been enforced all that often (mostly to combat game console mod chips), but it has been used to fight security researchers publishing stuff on security weaknesses in our public transport RFID cards... Thought we were better than that.
- idbehold 9y agoSo hopefully Firefox will simply display DRM content and ignore any restriction DRM imposes.
- Crespyl 9y agoEME plugins will use whatever user-hostile platform-specific opaque techniques necessary to communicate with the host OS in their attempt to ensure compliance. If the browser interferes with them, or the OS can't promise a "secure" chain from plugin-output > display, they can just refuse to stream the content. You can bet EME plugins will be highly platform specific, and poorly supported, if at all, on platforms that respect their users.
- icebraining 9y agoFirefox will heavily sandbox their EME plugins. They get no direct access to the host OS.
- Crespyl 9y agoAnyone taking bets on how long it will be before CDMs start requiring extensions that allow access to platform Output Protection/HDCP mechanisms? If nothing else, the standard already allows for the CDM to access the network (albeit managed by the user-agent) which means, for example, it could ping Microsoft to ask about this particular Win10 computer (as identified by user agent, IP address, and/or user account data from the content provider). Netflix/Microsoft/Hollywood/etc. aren't going to stop until they can close the loop as much as possible, with MS and hardware manufacturers already working to tighten things from the other end (see HDCP and the various frameworks for "protected content" that MS has been working towards). Either providers will push to integrate those platform-level frameworks, or they'll just stop offering content to web browsers entirely.
- pjmlp 9y agoApple and Google also have platform-level frameworks on their OSes.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- AnssiH 9y agoI don't believe this formal standardization will affect end-user web browser features. All major browsers (Firefox, Chrome, IE, Edge, Safari) have already included HTML EME DRM support for years, so it is a de-facto standard already.
- objclxt 9y ago> I would suggest not underestimating Mozilla's market influence. They have no market influence. They have maybe ~10% of the market globally (I've seen figures between 5-15%), and that's primarily desktop - which is decreasing daily. On mobile it's even worse (probably less than 1%). Any influence they have solely extends to the desktop, and that's not the primary way people are interacting with the internet nowadays.
- civilian 9y agoMarket share isn't immutable! Market share changes based on capabilities. I dropped IE for FF when I got a basic understanding of computers, I dropped FF when it became clear it was a memory hog, and now I kind of toggle between Chrome and FF. I think that, with killer features like breaking out of DRM, the market share could change.
- objclxt 9y ago> I think that, with killer features like breaking out of DRM, the market share could change. That's not a killer feature to the market: I bet 99/100 people don't know what DRM is or what it stands for. They just care that they can watch videos or not. For better or the worse the overwhelming majority of browser users don't know, care, or have any idea about how the internet is standardized, how DRM works, and why it matters to them.
- xvilka 9y agoOf course for the worse. As usual worst things in the world come with a silent agreement of majority.
- hyperdunc 9y agoIgnorance != agreement
- baddox 9y agoI actually don't see how using the browser would provide any practical value. If you pay for a streaming service you might as well just watch the legit DRM'd version. If you're watching a pirate stream you might as well stream from a pirate who cracked the DRM on their side.
- btown 9y ago> displays DRM content and ignores DRM Nothing says "attempting to survive as a legitimate corporate entity" like "let's flagrantly violate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WIPO_Copyright_and_Performances_and_Phonograms_Treaties_Implementation_Act#Section_103 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WIPO_Copyright_and_Performance... ..."
- mirimir 9y agoWho needs to "survive as a legitimate corporate entity"? All you need is to publish a browser. And basic browsers aren't that hard. Just be anonymous. Edit: If oligarchs create unworkable rules, why not create a new game?
- admax88q 9y ago> It would be possible to create a browser that displays DRM content and ignores DRM. The DMCA makes this illegal. No browser vendor is going to take that risk. Maybe some anonymous developers will release a firefox fork or similar, but that's a big risk. Not to mention, most groups who pirate content tend to keep their methods secret and only release the content.
- rplnt 9y agoDMCA has no reach outside of USA.
- featherverse 9y agoThe only people who give a @!#$ about the DMCA are lawyers. It's going to be repealed eventually.
- jandrese 9y agoThis is really the issue. If we could convince media rightsholders that DRM is harmful and unnecessary then all of this heartache wouldn't be necessary. I don't expect this to happen in my lifetime. Any slight glimmer of hope from Apple ditching DRM on iTunes has died as nobody else shows the slightest interest in following their lead.
- tptacek 9y agoIt seems self-evidently unharmful, in that we appear to be in a golden era of delivering content online so extraordinary that it threatens traditional television networks. I understand that this is an extremely unpopular sentiment on HN, but here goes: at least with respect to video content, the industry seems to have largely proven DRM concerns unfounded. Update: modulo the Hickson concerns below. Continuing: DRM certainly has kept some (power) user-friendly features off the market. You can take this as a serious harm inflicted by DRM. But I don't think it's reasonable to take that harm in isolation; the alternative isn't simply a world with no such limitations, but also a world with less content made available online. But I don't see a lot of evidence that those limitations, if genuinely important to users, can't be competed away. The restrictions might be dealbreakers for Paramount, but in 2017, Netflix can route around Paramount.
- saganus 9y agoMaybe the harm will be realized in the long run, when you want to watch something that is no longer available? For example, the Netflix library changes every now and then (at least that I've been able to detect), and there's more than one show that I can no longer watch anymore that I wish I could. That to me is harmful because I don't really know when this happens until I search for it and it's no longer there. So I end up buying DVDs of shows/movies I really would like to re-watch in the future just so I can avoid Netflix's listing changes. I guess the argument is that if there were no DRM I could download those shows I like the most and watch them at anytime, regardless of whether Netflix wants me to or not. Not sure about the reasons for others to consider DRM harmful (or not), but this one to me is really important and would love to have a DRM-free alternative besides pirating (due to inconvenience mainly, and due to general concern for downloading stuff that might not be what it supposedly should be). However this looks like wishful thinking at best, as time goes by and DRM is pushed further.
- coldtea 9y ago>The only company on the list of browser makers that really has any desire to try to exclude DRM is Mozilla Didn't Spotify just abandon Safari (OS X) because unlike Mozilla it doesn't support the DRM they need?
- mccr8 9y agoSafari supports DRM, it just uses FairPlay instead of Widevine. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairPlay https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairPlay
- krupan 9y agoWho watches Netflix with their browser?
- grzm 9y agoIf I'm on my computer as opposed to a mobile or TV device, I use the browser. It's not as often, but I definitely have done so, even within the past week.
- flukus 9y agoDue to DRM it's the only (legal) way I can watch it on my computer.
- jedberg 9y agoI'm guessing you don't have young kids? I say that because if I want to watch any R rated content (like Bojack Horseman for example, which I did last week), the only place I can safely do that is in my office with headphones on, since the toddler tends to creepily sneak up on us in the middle of the night after climbing out of bed.
- driverdan 9y agoWho doesn't?
- paulddraper 9y agoMe. I'm on my computer 50% of my day. I have it handy the most often.
- app4soft 9y agoPale Moon will be the last outpost in the world of suitable open-source browsers? https://github.com/MoonchildProductions/Pale-Moon/issues/1354 https://github.com/MoonchildProductions/Pale-Moon/issues/135...
- cyphar 9y agoGNU IceCat would be a better choice of "last outpost".
- e40 9y agoI 100% agree, and I wouldn't have agreed to it had I not been on a standardization committee in a before/after situation. The before was mainly implementers. At least they had a super majority. After was 5% implementers and it was a complete disaster. That 95% was like a kid in a candy store: no regard for implementation difficulty or what it would do to language consistency. Thankfully, the effort died quite quickly, so I never had to make much of the issue.
- Iv 9y agoIt took me a while to understand how politics are very different than the binary world of logic and strictly enforced rule of my CS universe. In politics, very often, there are no strictly enforced rules, there are groups of pressures pushing in opposing directions. W3C has no way to prevent proprietary browsers for doing what they want, they just put some pressure on them. They know that going through W3C is the easiest way to agree on a standard and to provide interoperability for their users. This is a small amount of pushing power. EFF withdrawing is normal: that's the main item they were interested in. The question now is to see whether Mozilla will stay.
- schoen 9y agoAs several people have pointed out elsewhere in these comments, Mozilla has already implemented EME. That makes it seem unlikely that it would quit over the adoption of this recommendation, even though Mozilla also stated that DRM is bad.
- forapurpose 9y ago> In politics, very often, there are no strictly enforced rules, there are groups of pressures pushing in opposing directions. All power is ultimately politics, not rules. People can use politics to change the rules, which happens often through lobbyists, influence, or even force. Powerful actors operate on the level of politics; they write the rules. The plebeians operate at the level of rules. If I'm unhappy with something a major corporation does, I can operate within the rules and complain to a regulator or take the company to court. If the corporation is unhappy then they get the rules changed, for example by having laws passed that prohibit my lawsuit, eliminate their liability, or hamstring the regulator. It also happens in smaller domains, such as among employees of a business: those skilled in politics get the internal decisions and rules made in their favor. The exception is, broadly speaking, more common than the process described above: The issues most people deal with in their everyday lives aren't important enough to motivate political action.
- wiz21c 9y ago>>> The issues most people deal with in their everyday lives aren't important enough to motivate political action. Save for the fact that their life is completely shaped by politics. I like your analysis a lot, but I don't like your conclusion. Because ultimately, humans make politics, so one can influence them. In french there's a saying : if you don't care about politics, then politics will take care of you...
- shawnee_ 9y ago> The only company on the list of browser makers that really has any desire to try to exclude DRM is Mozilla, and unfortunately, if they do that, the users will switch to the browser that makes watching Netflix easiest. This is simply not true. Netflix's entire business model is based around one thing: video content delivery. It started with DVDs in red envelopes, and has evolved to be app-based streaming now. Neither of these two things has any relevance to web browsers. Netflix's wish to be able to provide its content on as many platforms as possible for the lowest cost? Yes, that would make a lot more sense for why they are pushing this. Not an enticing enough argument for destroying web browser-based DRMs imo.
- bridge_ro 9y agoI agree. I'm curious as to what percentage of Netflix users primarily stream through a web browser rather than an app. I know my personal experience amounts to basically nothing but I can't even remember the last time I watched something on Netflix through a browser. I just have a hard time imagining that a lack of Netflix would kill Firefox.
- tanilama 9y agoSadly that is the ugly Truth about politics. Not really about rules it is all about power, hard power.
- tinus_hn 9y agoThey could definitely hurt Netflix by making it a shitty, barely workable experience.
- feelin_googley 9y ago"... web developers are going to go by the behavior of [what] the browsers do." I have pointed this out before. It is an important point that I think perhaps is overlooked when users ponder how to change the web. Want to change how the web is presented, fix annoyances, scratch an itch? Try to achieve through web development? Good luck. Try to achieve through browser development? Far more interesting. Alternative, open source, non-commercial browser. For example, implements limited set of features. Web development follows browser development. For example, a browser that does not automatically follow URLs so that ads and other crud can be loaded into pages. Giving users access to a browser like this may be a far more effective means of influencing web development away from annoying "user experiences". If such annoyances rely on a certain modern web browser feature, then use a browser that lacks the feature. Non-commercial means developers do not care about "market share". They are not trying to "compete" with the major browsers on features. They care about creating a superior alternative to major browsers that shifts the focus from advertisers and media companies to users. If the annoyances users have while using major browsers are bad enough, then they will try alternatives and the "market share" may shift. Or maybe not. But who cares? Because with an alternative browser "market share" is not the goal. In another thread, a Chrome developer perhaps a former Firefox developer tells of how they dropped some feature because it was too "power-user" and that is not "what [they] were going for". Maybe you are within the market they "are going for". And maybe you are not. If you are not, then waiting for developers at a large corporation, whose customers are advertisers, to cater to your needs is futile.
- antoinevg 9y agoThe original vision for hypertext absolutely had multiple "browsers/clients" and feature parity between them was not even remotely an issue. The idea was that you tell the server what capabilities you have, it then tells you what it wants to offer you and a negotiation ensues. I have no idea where this concept of a "standardized hypertext client" came from! ;-)
- near 9y agoThe web has been engineered to a complexity level so grossly obscene that it is all but impossible for independent developers to produce fully independent web browsers anymore. You would need hundreds of millions of dollars in capital and strong leadership to produce a browser that would be successful in today's world. I could dedicate the rest of my life working 100 hours a week on a browser, and I would die before I had something that could compete with browsers of 2017, let alone of the browsers far into the future at my demise. The standards grow in complexity faster than a small team of developers could possibly keep up with. The best we have are attempts at forks of major browser engines, which will never gain any serious traction to have any power over the direction of web standards. If people want to do something about it, they need to fork the web itself. HTTP, TLS, HTML, CSS, JS ... the entire stack needs to be scrapped and replaced with something sensible with a focus on simplicity. If a single highly talented developer working full-time can't implement a reasonable browser within a year, then the standard is too complex. This will of course never happen. And so, on the subject of DRM, we've officially lost the war today. And combined with the impending loss of net neutrality, brace yourselves everyone: it's only going to get worse from here on out.
- tudorw 9y agoIf we want to win that war, we should focus on content not technology, Mosaic got a lead in the game because, despite the 'techies' seeing no use for images, image support was added, with images came the transition of media, users were au fait with articles containing text and images and could now experience similar on line, this alone was not enough, content creators starting creating content that people wanted to consume, that's what drove people to 'get online', they were missing out. Don't get me wrong, it's still a long shot, but if an organisation could build a raft of talent, get that talent to make content that was only available on an open and progressive platform, then you might get some traction. So what might that look like, well, say I had the funds to secure 100 of the worlds best financial journalists and only delivered that content on a novel protocol, do you think I might be able to persuade some people to run a novel application to access that content, oh hang on, did I just describe Bloomberg...
- 9y ago
- pornel 9y agoIt has always been like this (see browser wars, WHATWG). In this case W3C is involved just as a tool. Microsoft/Netflix didn't need W3C for anything other than the brand name lending legitimacy to the spec they've designed and implemented before presenting it to the W3C, and didn't materially change it after.
- scriptkiddy 9y ago> The only company on the list of browser makers that really has any desire to try to exclude DRM is Mozilla, and unfortunately, if they do that, the users will switch to the browser that makes watching Netflix easiest. This is the world we live in. People are willing to sacrifice privacy and security in favor of convenience. Sounds a hell of a lot like a book I read in high school. People are so willing to make these sacrifices because they don't even understand what they're sacrificing. They don't understand what they're sacrificing because they couldn't be bothered. Apathy is the disease that will bring down the world. I'm calling it now.
- skummetmaelk 9y agoIt is truly a tragedy of the commons. It makes sense for the individual to consume their content, they're not giving up much by themselves. The problem arises when everyone does it.